The effect of a graph‐oriented computer‐assisted project‐based learning environment on argumentation skills |
| |
| Authors: | P‐S Hsu M Van Dyke Y Chen TJ Smith |
| |
| Affiliation: | 1. Department of Educational Technology, Research and Assessment, Northern Illinois University, DeKalb, Illinois, USA;2. O'Neill Middle School, Downers Grove, Illinois, USA |
| |
| Abstract: | The purpose of this quasi‐experimental study was to explore how seventh graders in a suburban school in the United States developed argumentation skills and science knowledge in a project‐based learning environment that incorporated a graph‐oriented, computer‐assisted application. A total of 54 students (three classes) comprised this treatment condition and were engaged in a project‐based learning environment that incorporated a graph‐oriented, computer‐assisted application, whereas a total of 57 students (three classes) comprised the control condition and were engaged in a project‐based learning environment without this graph‐oriented, computer‐assisted application. Verbal collaborative argumentation was recorded and the students' post essays were collected. A random effects analysis of variance (ANOVA) was conducted and a significant difference in science knowledge about alternative energies between conditions was observed. A multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) was conducted and there was a significant difference in counterargument and rebuttal skills between conditions. A qualitative analysis was conducted to examine how the graph‐oriented, computer‐assisted application supported students' development of argumentation skills and affected the quality of collaborative argumentation. The difference in argumentation structure and quality of argumentation between conditions might explain a difference in science knowledge as well counterargument and rebuttal skills (argumentation) between both conditions. This study concluded that a project‐based learning environment incorporating a graph‐oriented, computer‐assisted application was effective in improving students' science knowledge and developing their scientific argumentation skills. |
| |
| Keywords: | collaborative argumentation computer‐assisted application graph‐oriented application middle school students project‐based learning |
|
|
