Influence on cheese proteolysis and sensory characteristics of non-starter lactobacilli strains with probiotic potential

The contribution to cheese proteolysis and sensory profile of four potentially probiotic non-starter lactobacilli strains was assessed in two different models: soft and semi-hard cheeses. All the strains were able to grow in both types of cheese, where they maintained high levels during ripening. Overall, adjunct cultures of Lactobacillus rhamnosus showed the strongest influence in peptidolysis, which was verified by changes in peptide profiles and increase of free amino acids concentration. Nevertheless, some cheeses treated with L. rhamnosus also showed post-acidification during ripening and decreased sensory characteristics compared to controls. Cheeses with adjunct cultures of Lactobacillus casei I90 and Lactobacillus plantarum I91 exhibited, in general, an intermediate level of peptidolysis between control and L. rhamnosus-added cheeses; their sensory characteristics were preserved or improved, and they did not show any defects. Adjunct cultures showed similar trends in both models, confirming L. casei I90 and L. plantarum I91 as the most performing adjunct cultures for cheese-making among the strains.     

Application of infrared microspectroscopy and multivariate analysis for monitoring the effect of adjunct cultures during Swiss cheese ripening

Improved cheese flavor has been attributed to the addition of adjunct cultures, which provide certain key enzymes for proteolysis and affect the dynamics of starter and nonstarter cultures. Infrared microspectroscopy provides unique fingerprint-like spectra for cheese samples and allows for rapid monitoring of cheese composition during ripening. The objective was to use infrared microspectroscopy and multivariate analysis to evaluate the effect of adjunct cultures on Swiss cheeses during ripening. Swiss cheeses, manufactured using a commercial starter culture combination and 1 of 3 adjunct Lactobacillus spp., were evaluated at d 1, 6, 30, 60, and 90 of ripening. Cheese samples (approximately 20 g) were powdered with liquid nitrogen and homogenized using water and organic solvents, and the water-soluble components were separated. A 3-μL aliquot of the extract was applied onto a reflective microscope slide, vacuum-dried, and analyzed by infrared microspectroscopy. The infrared spectra (900 to 1,800 cm⁻¹) produced specific absorption profiles that allowed for discrimination among different cheese samples. Cheeses manufactured with adjunct cultures showed more uniform and consistent spectral profiles, leading to the formation of tight clusters by pattern-recognition analysis (soft independent modeling of class analogy) as compared with cheeses with no adjuncts, which exhibited more spectral variability among replicated samples. In addition, the soft independent modeling of class analogy discriminating power indicated that cheeses were differentiated predominantly based on the band at 1,122 cm⁻¹, which was associated with S-O vibrations. The greatest changes in the chemical profile of each cheese occurred between d 6 and 30 of warm-room ripening. The band at 1,412 cm⁻¹, which was associated with acidic AA, had the greatest contribution to differentiation, indicating substantial changes in levels of proteolysis during warm-room ripening in addition to propionic acid, acetic acid, and eye formation. A high-throughput infrared microspectroscopy technique was developed that can further the understanding of biochemical changes occurring during the ripening process and provide insight into the role of adjunct nonstarter lactic acid bacteria on the complex process of flavor development in cheeses.     

Influence of bacteria used as adjunct culture and sunflower oil addition on conjugated linoleic acid content in buffalo cheese

The influence of bacteria and sunflower oil addition on conjugated linoleic acid content (CLA) in buffalo cheese was determined. Fresh and short-ripened cheeses were manufactured using the same starter culture and four different adjunct strains previously selected by their CLA production rate. Lactobacillus casei, Lactobacillus rhamnosus, Bifidobacterium bifidum and Streptococcus thermophilus were individually used as adjunct culture. Sunflower oil (SO) was added to obtain a final concentration of 200 μg/ml of linoleic acid. CLA levels in cheese were higher than raw milk, especially after ripening time. SO supplementation increase CLA concentrations in fresh cheeses, except in those manufactured with S. thermophilus as adjunct culture. Both, ripening and SO supplementation showed a positive influence on CLA concentration. Similar texture, acidity and colour were determined in cheeses with or without SO supplementation. Buffalo cheeses manufactured with appropriate adjunct cultures may be a natural source of CLA for human consumption.     

Assessing the proteolytic and lipolytic activities of single strains of mesophilic lactobacilli as adjunct cultures using a Caciotta cheese model system

Seventeen strains of mesophilic lactic acid bacteria, isolated from cheese (non-starter lactic acid bacteria, NSLAB) or sourdough, were used individually as adjunct cultures in a Caciotta cheese model system. Adjunct cultures were monitored by randomly amplified polymorphic DNA analysis and their cell counts mainly varied from ca. 9.0 to 8.0 log cfu g⁻¹ throughout 36 days of ripening. Adjunct cultures influenced differently cheese proteolysis. Both NSLAB and sourdough strains caused an extensive secondary proteolysis; however, some NSLAB strains produced the highest concentration of free amino acids. Principal component analysis (PCA) differentiated cheeses manufactured with NSLAB strains Lactobacillus parabuckneri B₉F_ST, Lb. paracasei B₆₁F₅, Lb. curvatus 2768 and Lb. rhamnosus ATCC 7469 based on the accumulation of Lys, Glu, Phe, Hist, Asp and Met. Assessment of cheese lipolysis showed that: (i) highest concentrations of free fatty acids (FFA) were found with NSLAB strains Lb. rhamnosus ATCC 7469 and Lb. casei subsp. pseudoplantarum 2742 (ca. 10 500 mg kg⁻¹); (ii) PCA differentiated cheeses manufactured with NSLAB strains Lb. rhamnosus ATCC 7469 and Lb. casei subsp. pseudoplantarum 2742 based on the accumulation of palmitic (C16:0) and linoleic (C18:2) acids, and those with Lb. curvatus 2768 and Lb. parabuckneri B₉F_ST based on the high concentration of short chain FFA; (iii) the cheese made with sourdough strain Lb. sanfranciscensis CB1 had the highest levels of unsaturated FFA.     

Probiotic cheese production using Lactobacillus casei cells immobilized on fruit pieces

Lactobacillus casei cells were immobilized on fruit (apple and pear) pieces and the immobilized biocatalysts were used separately as adjuncts in probiotic cheese making. In parallel, cheese with free L. casei cells and cheese only from renneted milk were prepared. The produced cheeses were ripened at 4 to 6°C and the effect of salting and ripening time on lactose, lactic acid, ethanol concentration, pH, and lactic acid bacteria viable counts were investigated. Fat, protein, and moisture contents were in the range of usual levels of commercial cheeses. Reactivation in whey of L. casei cells immobilized on fruit pieces after 7 mo of ripening showed a higher rate of pH decrease and lower final pH value compared with reactivation of samples withdrawn from the remaining mass of the cheese without fruit pieces, from cheese with free L. casei, and rennet cheese. Preliminary sensory evaluation revealed the fruity taste of the cheeses containing immobilized L. casei cells on fruit pieces. Commercial Feta cheese was characterized by a more sour taste, whereas no significant differences concerning cheese flavor were reported by the panel between cheese containing free L. casei and rennet cheese. Salted cheeses scored similar values to commercial Feta cheese, whereas unsalted cheese scores were significantly lower, but still acceptable to the sensory panelists.     

Nonstarter Lactobacillus strains as adjunct cultures for cheese making: in vitro characterization and performance in two model cheeses

Nonstarter lactic acid bacteria are the main uncontrolled factor in today's industrial cheese making and may be the cause of quality inconsistencies and defects in cheeses. In this context, adjunct cultures of selected lactobacilli from nonstarter lactic acid bacteria origin appear as the best alternative to indirectly control cheese biota. The objective of the present work was to study the technological properties of Lactobacillus strains isolated from cheese by in vitro and in situ assays. Milk acidification kinetics and proteolytic and acidifying activities were assessed, and peptide mapping of trichloroacetic acid 8% soluble fraction of milk cultures was performed by liquid chromatography. In addition, the tolerance to salts (NaCl and KCl) and the phage-resistance were investigated. Four strains were selected for testing as adjunct cultures in cheese making experiments at pilot plant scale. In in vitro assays, most strains acidified milk slowly and showed weak to moderate proteolytic activity. Fast strains decreased milk pH to 4.5 in 8 h, and continued acidification to 3.5 in 12 h or more. This group consisted mostly of Lactobacillus plantarum and Lactobacillus rhamnosus strains. Approximately one-third of the slow strains, which comprised mainly Lactobacillus casei, Lactobacillus fermentum, and Lactobacillus curvatus, were capable to grow when milk was supplemented with glucose and casein hydrolysate. Peptide maps were similar to those of lactic acid bacteria considered to have a moderate proteolytic activity. Most strains showed salt tolerance and resistance to specific phages. The Lactobacillus strains selected as adjunct cultures for cheese making experiments reached 10⁸ cfu/g in soft cheeses at 7 d of ripening, whereas they reached 10⁹ cfu/g in semihard cheeses after 15 d of ripening. In both cheese varieties, the adjunct culture population remained at high counts during all ripening, in some cases overcoming or equaling primary starter. Overall, proximate composition of cheeses with and without added lactobacilli did not differ; however, some of the tested strains continued acidifying during ripening, which was mainly noticed in soft cheeses and affected overall quality of the products. The lactobacilli strains with low acidifying activity showed appropriate technological characteristics for their use as adjunct cultures in soft and semihard cheeses.     

Enhanced nutty flavor formation in cheddar cheese made with a malty Lactococcus lactis adjunct culture

Nutty flavor in Cheddar cheese is desirable, and recent research demonstrated that 2- and 3-methyl butanal and 2-methyl propanal were primary sources of nutty flavors in Cheddar. Because malty strains of Lac-tococcus lactis (formerly Streptococcus lactis var. malti-genes) are characterized by the efficient production of these and other Strecker aldehydes during growth, this study investigated the influence of a malty L. lactis adjunct culture on nutty flavor development in Cheddar cheese. Cheeses made with different adjunct levels (0, 10⁴ cfu/mL, and 10⁵ cfu/mL) were ripened at 5 or 13°C and analyzed after 1 wk, 4 mo, and 8 mo by a combination of instrumental and sensory methods to characterize nutty flavor development. Cheeses ripened at 13°C developed aged flavors (brothy, sulfur, and nutty fla-vors) more rapidly than cheeses held at 5°C. Additionally, cheeses made with the adjunct culture showed more rapid and more intense nutty flavor development than control cheeses. Cheeses that had higher intensities of nutty flavors also had a higher concentration of 2/3-methyl butanal and 2-methyl propanal compared with control cheeses, which again confirmed that these compounds are a source of nutty flavor in Cheddar cheese. Results from this study provide a simple methodology for cheese manufacturers to obtain consistent nutty flavor in Cheddar cheese.     

Multivariate analysis of proteolysis patterns differentiated the impact of six strains of probiotic bacteria on a semi-hard cheese

The individual contribution of 6 strains of probiotic bacteria (3 of Lactobacillus acidophilus and 3 of the Lactobacillus casei group) to proteolysis patterns in a semi-hard cheese was assessed. Control cheeses (without probiotics) and 2 types of experimental cheeses (with the addition of probiotics either directly to milk or by a 2-step fermentation method) were manufactured. Cheeses containing Lb. acidophilus showed the most extensive peptidolysis, which was evidenced by changes in the peptide profiles and a noticeable increase of free amino acids compared with control cheeses. The strains of the Lb. casei group showed a lower contribution to cheese peptidolysis, which consisted mainly of free amino acid increase. Two-step fermentation improved peptidolytic activity for only one of the cultures of Lb. acidophilus tested. The addition of Lb. acidophilus strains into cheese may be suitable not only for their beneficial health effect but also for their influence on secondary proteolysis, consistent with acceleration of ripening and improved flavor formation.     

Influence of probiotic strains added to cottage cheese on generation of potentially antioxidant peptides,anti-listerial activity,and survival of probiotic microorganisms in simulated gastrointestinal conditions

Our objective was to evaluate the viability of probiotic microorganisms added to cottage cheese under simulated gastrointestinal conditions, the release of potentially-antioxidant peptides, and their antimicrobial effect on Listeria monocytogenes. Cottage cheeses were prepared in triplicate, incorporating Lactobacillus casei, Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG, the commercial mix YO-MIX™ 205, or a control without probiotic addition. The probiotic population remained at >10⁶ cfu g⁻¹ during 28 days of storage at 8 °C. Cheeses made with added probiotics showed an increased metabolic activity with higher levels of lactic and acetic acids. Higher numbers of potentially bioactive peptides were observed in cheeses added with probiotics. L. monocytogenes population was reduced by about one log cycle after 20 days of storage, in cheeses with probiotics added. Our results indicate that cottage cheese is a good vehicle for probiotic bacteria.     

Characterisation of the microflora during ripening of a Norwegian semi-hard cheese with adjunct culture of propionic acid bacteria

The microflora of a semi-hard, washed curd, Norwegian cheese with an added adjunct culture of propionic acid bacteria (PAB) was investigated throughout ripening by phenotypic and physiological tests, API test and 16S rRNA sequencing. Cheeses were made at two commercial Norwegian dairies using different milk treatments (pasteurisation versus microfiltration plus pasteurisation) and the same type of starter cultures. Microflora in the cheese varied according to different plant site, milk treatment, and ripening time. PAB dominated the microflora throughout the ripening process. Leuconostoc spp., most probably from the starter, dominated among the isolates from the cheese using microfiltered and pasteurised milk; however, after 40 weeks of ripening non-starter lactic acid bacteria specie Lactobacillus casei/paracasei and Leuconostoc spp. dominated at the dairy using pasteurised milk. Cheese made at the two plants on two subsequent days showed almost identical microflora throughout ripening.     

Two strains of nonstarter lactobacilli increased the production of flavor compounds in soft cheeses

The contribution to flavor generation and secondary proteolysis of 2 strains of mesophilic lactobacilli isolated from cheese was studied. Miniature soft cheeses (200 g) were produced with or without the inclusion of a culture of Lactobacillus plantarum I91 or Lactobacillus casei I90 in the starter composed of Streptococcus thermophilus. During ripening, cheeses containing the added lactobacilli showed an increased content of total free amino acids, but this increase was only significant in cheeses with Lb. plantarum I91. In addition, free amino acid profiles were modified by selective increases of some amino acids, such as Asp, Ser, Arg, Leu, and Phe. Cheeses inoculated with Lb. plantarum I91 or Lb. casei I90 were also characterized by a significantly higher concentration of diacetyl, a key flavor compound, and an increased content of acetoin. Results suggest an increase in the catabolism of either citrate or aspartate, with the production of the derived aroma compounds. Overall, aspartate content increased in both lactobacilli-added cheeses, whereas citrate was more or less constant, suggesting that aspartate could be the source of increased diacetyl and acetoin. A triangle aroma test showed that the addition of the lactobacilli strains significantly changed the sensory attributes of cheeses. At least 11 of 12 panelists commented that the aroma of cheeses with adjuncts was more buttery than that of control cheeses, which is desirable in most soft cheeses. Both Lb. plantarum I91 and Lb. casei I90 performed well as adjunct cultures by influencing cheese aroma development and cheese proteolysis.     

Influence of probiotic bacteria on the proteolysis profile of a semi-hard cheese

Two probiotic strains, Lactobacillus acidophilus and Lactobacillus paracasei subsp. paracasei, were used as adjunct cultures in semi-hard cheesemaking experiments, in order to study their influence on proteolysis during ripening. Cheeses with and without probiotic bacteria were manufactured. The population of probiotics remained above 10⁷ cfu g⁻¹ during all ripening, and they did not influence primary proteolysis. However, L. acidophilus produced a significant increase in the level of low molecular weight nitrogen compounds and individual free amino acids; the amino acid profiles were also different. Multivariate analysis of peptide profiles showed that samples were grouped mainly by ripening time, although the impact of probiotics was also noticeable. L. acidophilus showed a clear influence on secondary proteolysis, while a minor effect of L. paracasei was evidenced at the end of the ripening. These results showed that the tested strains influenced distinctly proteolysis of cheeses, probably as a consequence of their different proteolytic systems and their activity via the alimentary matrix (cheese).     

Dynamics of starter,adjunct non-starter lactic acid bacteria and propionic acid bacteria in low-fat and full-fat Dutch-type cheese

The microbial dynamics of Dutch-type cheeses differing in starter (commercial DL starter or single strain of Lactococcus lactis ssp. cremoris), adjunct (Lactobacillus or Propionibacterium) and fat contents (10% or 28% fat) were investigated by culture-dependent and culture-independent analysis. The cheese microbiota was dominated by the adjunct Lactobacillus after 4 weeks of ripening and the fat content did not influence the microbial diversity. The Leuconostoc sp., presumably from the DL starter, was detected in cheeses made with added Lactobacillus plantarum and Lactobacillus rhamnosus and was not detected in cheese made with added Lactobacillus paracasei after 4 and 7 weeks. No Lactobacillus spp. were detected in cheese with added Propionibacterium, while Leuconostoc was the only species detected. In cheeses made with Lc. lactis ssp. cremoris as starter, the Lactobacillus microbiota was similar to the cheese milk microbiota after 24 h while after 4 weeks different species of Lactobacillus and Leuconostoc were detected.     

Mesophilic lactobacilli in Fiore Sardo cheese: PCR-identification and evolution during cheese ripening

The mesophilic lactobacilli colonizing Fiore Sardo ewe's milk cheese were characterized. They seemed to be the dominant non-starter lactic acid bacteria composing its natural microflora, with a viable cell number varying from 10⁵ CFU g⁻¹ (1-day-old cheese) to 10⁸ CFU g⁻¹ (30-day-old cheese) and then slowly decreasing up to 10⁴ CFU g⁻¹ after 7 months’ ripening. Considering the relevance of mesophilic lactobacilli in affecting the cheese ripening, a PCR-based taxonomic identification of the Lactobacillus species isolated was performed. Cheese samples were collected from 3 farms and 457 isolates from cheeses at different ripening times were analysed with species-specific primers for L. plantarum, L. casei group, L. paracasei, L. casei, L. rhamnosus, L. pentosus, L. paraplantarum, L. curvatus, L. graminis and L. sake. L. plantarum and L. paracasei were the most frequently detected species. Moreover, the development and the evolution during ripening of the facultatively heterofermentative Lactobacillus species (FHL) were different in the three batches of cheese.     

Technological and probiotic role of adjunct cultures of non-starter lactobacilli in soft cheeses

The influence of two cheese-isolated Lactobacillus strains on cheese composition, acceptability and probiotic capacity was assessed. Soft cheeses with and without the addition of Lactobacillus plantarum I91 or Lactobacillus paracasei I90 were prepared. Gross composition was assessed and secondary proteolysis was described by soluble fractions and free amino acids profiles. Acceptability was determined by a panel of 98 non-trained consumers. Cheeses harboring added Lactobacillus strains were also studied in vivo to evaluate their probiotic capacity. Gross composition of the cheeses was similar for control and treated (Lactobacillus-added) cheeses. Peptidolysis increased in cheeses with added lactobacilli, which was evidenced by a higher free amino acid content. Overall, the acceptability of the cheeses was good: 65%–80% of the consumers said that they “liked very much” or “liked” the cheeses. Cheeses with L. plantarum I91 showed the highest changes in composition and proteolysis and were the most accepted ones. On the contrary, composition of cheeses with L. paracasei I90 was similar to that of the controls, but these samples were less accepted than cheeses without lactobacilli. The oral administration of cheese containing L. plantarum I91 or L. paracasei I90 proved to be safe and able to enhance the number of IgA + cells in the small intestine lamina propria of mice. The use of selected strains of NSLAB exerted a technological and probiotic role: it contributed to the standardization of cheese quality and induced benefic health effects at the gut mucosa in vivo.     

A preliminary study on the effect of Lactobacillus casei expressing cystathionine lyase1/cystathionine lyase2 on Cheddar cheese and the formation of sulphur-containing compounds

Model Cheddar cheeses were manufactured from pasteurised milk with various Lactobacillus casei adjuncts. The added L. casei FAM18101, L. casei FAM18108, and L. casei FAM18149 possessed genetic variants of a gene cluster that is involved in the conversion of methionine to cysteine. The gene cluster comprises a cystathionine lyase (ctl) previously shown to degrade cysteine, homocysteine, cystathionine and methionine to volatile sulphur compounds such as hydrogen sulphide and methanethiol. A strain that does not possess the gene cluster was used as a control. An inhibitory effect of the adjuncts on starter culture activity was not observed. Expression analysis of the genetic variant ctl1 showed that the gene was expressed in cheese. The development of cysteine, methionine and volatile sulphur compounds was analysed during ripening. The cheeses containing the L. casei adjuncts possessing the gene cluster had markedly higher concentrations of cysteine, hydrogen sulphide and methanethiol at the end of ripening.     

Influence of microfiltration and adjunct culture on quality of Domiati cheese

The effects of microfiltration and pasteurization processes on proteolysis, lipolysis, and flavor development in Domiati cheese during 2 mo of pickling were studied. Cultures of starter lactic acid bacteria isolated from Egyptian dairy products were evaluated in experimental Domiati cheese for flavor development capabilities. In the first trial, raw skim milk was microfiltered and then the protein:fat ratio was standardized using pasteurized cream. Pasteurized milk with same protein:fat ratio was also used in the second trial. The chemical composition of cheeses seemed to be affected by milk treatment—microfiltration or pasteurization—rather than by the culture types. The moisture content was higher and the pH was lower in pasteurized milk cheeses than in microfiltered milk cheeses at d 1 of manufacture. Chemical composition of experimental cheeses was within the legal limits for Domiati cheese in Egypt. Proteolysis and lipolysis during cheese pickling were lower in microfiltered milk cheeses compared with pasteurized milk cheeses. Highly significant variations in free amino acids, free fatty acids, and sensory evaluation were found among the cultures used in Domiati cheesemaking. The cheese made using adjunct culture containing Lactobacillus delbrueckii ssp. lactis, Lactobacillus paracasei ssp. paracasei, Lactobacillus casei, Lactobacillus plantarum, and Enterococcus faecium received high scores in flavor acceptability. Cheeses made from microfiltered milk received a higher score in body and texture compared with cheeses made from pasteurized milk.     

The design of a three strain starter system for Cheddar cheese manufacture exploiting bacteriocin-induced starter lysis

A three strain starter system was developed for increasing the level of starter cell lysis during cheese manufacture and ripening. The composition of this starter combination includes a bacteriocin (lactococcin A, B and M) producer which causes the lysis of a second strain (sensitive to bacteriocin activity) during cheese manufacture, and a third strain resistant to bacteriocin activity. The latter strain plays an essential role in ensuring acid production during cheese manufacture. Cheeses manufactured at pilot-scale (450 L vats), with the three strain starter combination were assessed for levels of the intracellular enzyme, lactate dehydrogenase, released into the cheese matrix during ripening. Experimental cheeses, manufactured with the bacteriocin-producing adjunct, exhibited higher levels of free amino acids and greater release of intracellular LDH than control cheeses manufactured in its absence. Cheese was subject to sensory analysis which revealed that experimental cheese showed a decrease in bitterness over cheeses manufactured without the bacteriocin-producing adjunct. Thus, this three strain system offers manufacturers a reliable starter system exhibiting increased lysis with concomitant improvements in cheese flavour.     

Effect of yeast and bacterial adjuncts on the CLA content and flavour of a washed-curd,dry-salted cheese

Three strains of Propionibacterium freudenreichii ssp. shermanii that converted free linoleic acid to conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) in laboratory media were used as adjunct strains, together with strains of Geotrichum candidum and Yarrowia lipolytica, to make a dry-salted, washed-curd cheese. Lactobacillus fermentum was included to produce ethanol (from lactose), a potential substrate for ethyl ester synthesis, while Lactobacillus rhamnosus was used to control the adventitious non-starter lactic acid bacteria population. The total (esterified plus free) level of CLA was similar in the control and experimental cheeses and remained unchanged over 4 months of ripening. Addition of linoleic acid-rich safflower oil to the cheese curd increased the concentration of free linoleic acid generated in the cheese but the CLA content did not change. Free linoleic acid was released by the yeast lipase(s) but there was no conversion to CLA. High concentrations of ethyl esters were produced in the cheeses made with added yeast, giving a fruity flavour.