Long-term oxidation and ablation behavior of Cf/ZrB2–SiC composites at 1500, 2000, and 2200°C

Although C_f/ZrB₂–SiC composites prepared via direct ink writing combined with low-temperature hot-pressing were shown to exhibit high relative density, high preparation efficiency, and excellent flexural strength and fracture toughness in our previous work, their oxidation and ablation resistance at high and ultrahigh temperatures had not been investigated. In this work, the oxidation and ablation resistance of C_f/ZrB₂–SiC composites were evaluated via static oxidation at high temperature (1500°C) and oxyacetylene ablation at ultrahigh temperatures (2080 and 2270°C), respectively. The thickness of the oxide layer of the C_f/ZrB₂–SiC composites is <40 μm after oxidizing at 1500°C for 1 h. The C_f/ZrB₂–SiC composites exhibit non-ablative properties after oxyacetylene ablation at 2080 and 2270°C for >600 s, with mass ablation rates of 3.77 × 10⁻³ and 5.53 × 10⁻³ mg/(cm² s), and linear ablation rates of −4.5 × 10⁻⁴ and −5.8 × 10⁻⁴ mm/s, respectively. Upon an increase in the ablation temperature from 2080 to 2270°C, the thickness of the total oxide layer increases from 360 to 570 μm, and the carbon fibers remain intact in the unaffected region. Moreover, the oxidation and ablation process of C_f/ZrB₂–SiC at various temperatures was analyzed and discussed.     

Advances in oxidation and ablation resistance of high and ultra-high temperature ceramics modified or coated carbon/carbon composites

Carbon/carbon (C/C) composites are considered as one of the most promising materials in structural applications owing to their excellent mechanical properties at high temperature. However, C/C composites are susceptible to high-temperature oxidation. Matrix modification and coating technology with ultra-high temperature ceramics (UHTCs) have proved to be highly effective to improve the oxidation and ablation resistance of C/C composites. In this paper, recent advances in oxidation and ablation resistance of C/C composites were firstly reviewed, with attention to oxidation and ablation properties of C/C composites coated or modified with UHTCs. Then, several new methods in improving oxidation and ablation resistance were discussed, such as by using nanostructures to toughen UHTCs coatings or carbon matrix and the combination of matrix modification and coating technology. In addition, relevant ablation tests with scaled models were also briefly introduced. Finally, some open problems and future challenges were highlighted in the development and application of these materials.     

First principles investigation on mechanical and thermal properties of α‐ and β‐YAlB4 ultra‐high temperature ceramics

Ultra‐high temperature ceramics (UHTCs) exhibit a unique combination of excellent properties that makes them promising candidates for applications in extreme environments. Various UHTCs are needed due to diverse harsh conditions that UHTCs are faced with in different applications. Due to structural similarity to ZrB₂, possible high melting point and possible protective oxide scale formed in oxygen rich and water vapor environments, REAlB₄ (RE: rare‐earth) is suggested a good candidate for UHTCs. In the present work, temperature‐dependent mechanical and thermal properties of both α‐YAlB₄ (YCrB₄ type, space group Pbam) and β‐YAlB₄ (ThMoB₄ type, space group Cmmm) were investigated by first principles calculations in combination with quasi‐harmonic approach. Due to the structural similarity between α‐YAlB₄ and β‐YAlB₄, their properties are very similar to each other, which are approximately transverse isotropic with properties in (001) plane being almost the same and differing from properties out of (001) plane. The results reveal that resistance to normal strain in (001) plane (~460 GPa) is higher than that along [001] direction (~320 GPa) and thermal expansion in (001) plane (~10 × 10^?6 K^?1) is lower than that along [001] direction (~17 × 10^?6 K^?1), which is because the stiff boron networks are parallel to (001) plane. The average thermal expansion coefficient is around 12 × 10^?6 K^?1, which is fairly high among UHTCs and compatible with metallic frameworks. The combination of high thermal expansion coefficient and protective oxidation scale forming ability suggest that REAlB₄ is promising for practical applications not only as high‐temperature structural ceramic but also as oxidation resistant coating for alloys.     

Ultra-high temperature ceramic coating for carbon/carbon composites against ablation above 2000 K

To improve the ablation resistance of carbon/carbon composites at the temperature above 2000 K, a ZrB₂-SiC-ZrC ultra-high temperature ceramic coating was prepared by combination of supersonic atmosphere plasma spray (SAPS) and reaction melt infiltration. The micro-holes in ZrB₂-Si-ZrC coating prepared by SAPS were effectively filled and the compactness and interface compatibility between the coating and C/C composites was improved through the reaction melt infiltration process. The ultra-high temperature ceramic coating exhibited good ablation resistance under oxyacetylene torch ablation above 2000 K. After ablation for 120 s, the mass and linear ablation rates of the ZrB₂-SiC-ZrC coated C/C samples were only ?0.016 × 10^?3 g/s and 1.30 µm/s, respectively. Good ablation resistance of the ultra-high temperature ceramic coating is mainly attributed to the dense coating structure and the improvement of interface compatibility between the coating and C/C composites.     

Effects of porous C/C density on the densification behavior and ablation property of C/C–ZrC–SiC composites

C/C–ZrC–SiC composites were prepared by precursor infiltration and pyrolysis process using a mixture solution of organic zirconium-containing polymer and polycarbosilane as precursors. Porous carbon/carbon (C/C) composites with density of 0.92, 1.21 and 1.40 g/cm³ were used as preforms, and the effects of porous C/C density on the densification behavior and ablation resistance of C/C–ZrC–SiC composites were investigated. The results show that the C/C preforms with a lower density have a faster weight gain, and the obtained C/C–ZrC–SiC composites own higher bulk density and open porosity. The composites fabricated from the C/C preforms with a density of 1.21 g/cm³ exhibit better ablation resistance with a surface temperature of over 2400 °C during ablation. After ablation for 120 s, the linear and mass ablation rates of the composites are as low as 1.02 × 10⁻³ mm/s and −4.01 × 10⁻⁴ g/s, respectively, and the formation of a dense and continuous coating of molten ZrO₂ solid solution is the reason for their great ablation resistance.     

Ultra-high temperature ceramics: Aspiration to overcome challenges in thermal protection systems

Ultra-high temperature ceramics (UHTCs) have played a significant role in fulfilling demands for the thermal protection system (TPS) in the aerospace sector, however, a promising candidate has not emerged yet. This critical review provides typical inconsistencies and new perspectives related to UHTCs in terms of: (i) material and processing: i.e., sinterability, reinforcements, microstructural evolution, (ii) properties and performance correlation with the processing conditions and resulting microstructure, and (iii) outlook on the most promising ZrB₂-HfB₂-SiC-based composites as potential candidates for hypersonic leading edge and re-entry structures. An optimal selection of the content, size and reinforcing phase (such as silicides, refractory carbides, and carbon-based, etc.) is mandated in upgrading the thermo-mechanical performance of UHTCs to sustain elevated temperature (1700 °C), exhibiting flexural/fracture strength of >300 MPa, high thermal conductivity >14.5 Wm^?1K^?1, and high oxidation resistance (<80 gm^?2 over 2 h at 1400 °C). From emphasis on the powder purity, and sintering additives on affecting the densification, mechanical properties and high temperature oxidation, improvements in the functional performance of UHTCs are carried forward with emphasis mainly on borides and carbides. Emergence of SiC as most promising sintering additive with optimal content of ～20 vol%, and with supplemented HfB₂ addition in ZrB₂-HfB₂-SiC based UHTCs have exhibited higher oxidation resistance and may serve as conceivable entrants for hypersonic vehicles. Further, the review leads the reader to developing new materials (including silicides, MAX phases, and high entropy UHTCs), incorporating novel strategies like designing layered structures or functionally graded materials (FGM), and effective joining to allow the integration of smaller components into scaled up structures. On one hand, where plasma arc-jet exposure mimics high heat-flux exposures, the utilization of multi-length-scale computational modeling (such as finite element methods, density functional theory, ab initio etc.) allows assessing the material performance under dynamic changes (of variable partial pressure, temperatures, gradation, etc.) towards perceiving new insights into the structural stability and thermo-mechanical properties of UHTCs. This review critically underlines the present state of the art and guides the reader towards the futuristic development of new class of high-temperature materials for TPSs.     

The ablation behavior and mechanical property of C/C-SiC-ZrB2 composites fabricated by reactive melt infiltration

In order to improve the ablation resistance of carbon/carbon (C/C) composites, SiC-ZrB₂ di-phase ceramic were introduced by reactive melt infiltration. The ablation properties of these composites were evaluated by oxyacetylene torch with a heat flux of 2.38 MW/m² for 60 s. Compared with the pure C/C composites, the C/C-SiC-ZrB₂ composites show a significant improvement in the ablation resistance, and the linear and mass ablation rates decreased from 10.28×10⁻³ mm/s to 6.72×10⁻³ mm/s and from 3.08×10⁻³ g/s to 0.61×10⁻³ g/s, respectively. After ablation test, the flexural strength retentions of the C/C and C/C-SiC-ZrB₂ composites near the ablated center region are 39.7% and 81.6%, respectively. The higher strength retention rate of C/C-SiC-ZrB₂ composites was attributed to the introduction of SiC-ZrB₂ ceramic phases, which have excellent ablation resistant property. During ablation test, an ‘embedding structure’ of Zr-O-Si glass layer was formed, which could act as an effective barrier for oxygen and heat. The oxide ceramic coating could protect the C/C-SiC-ZrB₂ composites from further ablation, and thus contribute to retaining the mechanical property of C/C-SiC-ZrB₂ composites after ablation.     

Ultra‐High‐Temperature Ceramic HfB2‐SiC Coating for Oxidation Protection of SiC‐Coated Carbon/Carbon Composites

To protect the carbon/carbon (C/C) composites from oxidation, an outer ultra‐high‐temperature ceramics (UHTCs) HfB₂‐SiC coating was prepared on SiC‐coated C/C composites by in situ reaction method. The outer HfB₂‐SiC coating consists of HfB₂ and SiC, which are synchronously obtained. During the heat treatment process, the formed fluid silicon melt is responsible for the preparation of the outer HfB₂‐SiC coating. The HfB₂‐SiC/SiC coating could protect the C/C from oxidation for 265 h with only 0.41 × 10^?2 g/cm² weight loss at 1773 K in air. During the oxidation process, SiO₂ glass and HfO₂ are generated. SiO₂ glass has a self‐sealing ability, which can cover the defects in the coating, thus blocking the penetration of oxygen and providing an effective protection for the C/C substrate. In addition, SiO₂ glass can react with the formed HfO₂, thus forming the HfSiO₄ phase. Owing to the “pinning effect” of HfSiO₄ phase, crack deflecting and crack termination are occurred, which will prevent the spread of cracks and effectively improve the oxidation resistance of the coating.     

Ablation behaviour of a TaC coating on SiC coated C/C composites at different temperatures

To improve the ablation resistance of carbon/carbon (C/C) composites, a TaC coating was prepared by supersonic plasma spraying on SiC coated C/C composites. The microstructure and morphology of the coatings were characterised by Scanning Electron Microscopy and X-ray diffraction. The ablation properties were studied at different temperatures under oxyacetylene torch. At 2100 °C, the oxides were blown away and resulted in high ablation rates: 1.2×10^?2 mm/s and 3.9×10^?3 g/s. However, most oxides can remain in ablation centre and serve as a coating at low temperature (1900 and 1800 °C). Therefore, the TaC/SiC coated samples exhibited zero linear ablation rate and lower mass ablation rate.     

A novel combination of precursor pyrolysis assisted sintering and rapid sintering for construction of multi-composition coatings to improve ablation resistance of SiOC ceramic modified carbon fiber needled felt preform composites

A double-layer coating composed of MoSi₂–SiO₂–SiC/ZrB₂–MoSi₂–SiC was designed and successfully constructed by a novel combination of precursor pyrolysis assisted sintering and rapid sintering to improve the ablation resistance of SiOC ceramic modified carbon fiber needled felt preform composites (CSs). The ZrB₂–MoSi₂–SiC inner layer coating was in relatively uniform distribution in the zone of 0–3 mm from the surface of CSs through the slurry/precursor infiltration in vacuum and SiOC precursor pyrolysis assisted sintering, which played a predominant role in improving oxidation and ablation resistance and maintaining the morphology of CSs. The MoSi₂–SiO₂–SiC outer layer coating was prepared by the spray and rapid sintering to further protect CSs from high-temperature oxidation. The ablation resistance of CSs coated with double-layer coating was evaluated by an oxygen-acetylene ablation test under the temperature of 1600–1800 °C with different ablation time of 1000 and 1500 s. The results revealed that the mass recession rates increased with the rise of ablation temperature and extension of ablation time, ranging from 0.47 g/(m²·s) to 0.98 g/(m²·s) at 1600–1800 °C for 1000 s and from 0.72 g/(m²·s) to 0.86 g/(m²·s) for 1000–1500 s at 1700 °C, while the linear recession rates showed negative values at 1700 °C due to the formation of oxides, such as SiO₂ and ZrO₂. The ablation mechanism of the double-layer coating was analyzed and found that a SiO₂–ZrO₂–Mo_4.8Si₃C_0.6 oxidation protection barrier would be formed during the ablation process to prevent the oxygen diffusion into the interior CSs, and this study provided a novel and effective way to fabricate high-temperature oxidation protective and ablation resistant coating.     

Self‐Generating High‐Temperature Oxidation‐Resistant Glass‐Ceramic Coatings for C–C Composites Using UHTCs

Carbon–carbon (C–C) composites are ideal for use as aerospace vehicle structural materials; however, they lack high‐temperature oxidation resistance requiring environmental barrier coatings for application. Ultra high‐temperature ceramics (UHTCs) form oxides that inhibit oxygen diffusion at high temperature are candidate thermal protection system materials at temperatures >1600°C. Oxidation protection for C–C composites can be achieved by duplicating the self‐generating oxide chemistry of bulk UHTCs formed by a “composite effect” upon oxidation of ZrB₂–SiC composite fillers. Dynamic Nonequilibrium Thermogravimetric Analysis (DNE‐TGA) is used to evaluate oxidation in situ mass changes, isothermally at 1600°C. Pure SiC‐based fillers are ineffective at protecting C–C from oxidation, whereas ZrB₂–SiC filled C–C composites retain up to 90% initial mass. B₂O₃ in SiO₂ scale reduces initial viscosity of self‐generating coating, allowing oxide layer to spread across C–C surface, forming a protective oxide layer. Formation of a ZrO₂–SiO₂ glass‐ceramic coating on C–C composite is believed to be responsible for enhanced oxidation protection. The glass‐ceramic coating compares to bulk monolithic ZrB₂–SiC ceramic oxide scale formed during DNE‐TGA where a comparable glass‐ceramic chemistry and surface layer forms, limiting oxygen diffusion.     

TaB2–SiC–Si multiphase oxidation protective coating for SiC-coated carbon/carbon composites

To improve the oxidation resistance of the carbon/carbon (C/C) composites, a TaB₂–SiC–Si multiphase oxidation protective ceramic coating was prepared on the surface of SiC coated C/C composites by pack cementation. Results showed that the outer multiphase coating was mainly composed of TaB₂, SiC and Si. The multilayer coating is about 200 μm in thickness, which has no penetration crack or big hole. The coating could protect C/C from oxidation for 300 h with only 0.26 × 10^?2 g²/cm² mass loss at 1773 K in air. The formed silicate glass layer containing SiO₂ and tantalum oxides can not only seal the defects in the coating, but also reduce oxygen diffusion rates, thus improving the oxidation resistance.     

Ablation resistance of HfB2-SiC coating prepared by in-situ reaction method for SiC coated C/C composites

To improve the ablation resistance of SiC coating, HfB₂-SiC coating was prepared on SiC-coated carbon/carbon (C/C) composites by in-situ reaction method. Owing to the penetration of coating powders, there is no clear boundary between SiC coating and HfB₂-SiC coating. After oxyacetylene ablation for 60 s at heat flux of 2400 kW/m², the mass ablation rate and linear ablation rate of the coated C/C composites were only 0.147 mg/s and 0.267 µm/s, reduced by 21.8% and 60.0%, respectively, compared with SiC coated C/C composites. The good ablation resistance was attributed to the formation of multiple Hf-Si-O glassy layer including SiO₂, HfO₂ and HfSiO₄.     

Ablation behaviors and mechanism of ultra-thick anti-oxidation layer coating on carbon-bonded carbon fiber composites

To enhance the oxidation resistance capability of the carbon-bonded carbon fiber composites (CBCFs), a silicide ultra-thick coating as high as 1.6 mm with gradient structure is designed and fabricated via a multi-step rapid sintering method. Compared with other ceramic layers on carbon fiber-based composites, ultra-thick anti-oxidation layer coated-CBCFs have the lowest thermal conductivity. Additionally, ablation behaviors of the ultra-thick ceramics layer coated-CBCFs under the oxyacetylene torch are also investigated. After being exposed to oxyacetylene torch, the ultra-thick ceramics layer coated-CBCFs possess a linear rate range from 0.6 to 1.2 μm/s, while a mass ablation rate ranges from 4.95 × 10⁻⁵ g/m² s to 1.45 × 10⁻³ g/m² s.     

A low-temperature prepared composite coating to protect SiC-coated C/C composites against oxidation in a wide temperature range for long-life service

To improve the oxidation resistance of carbon/carbon (C/C) composites in a wide temperature range (1173–1773 K), a composite coating containing rich B₂O₃ glass was prepared on SiC-coated C/C composites by slurry dipping-densifying at low temperature. Borosilicate and SiO₂ glasses acted as oxygen barriers at low and medium-high temperatures, respectively. Besides, Hf-oxides (HfO₂, HfSiO₄) ceramic particles improved the thermal stability of the glass and enhanced the crack resistance of glass layer. Therefore, the composite coating can effectively protect C/C composites against oxidation for 403 h at 1173 K, 723 h at 1473 K and 403 h at 1773 K with the mass gain of 3.77 g·m⁻², 21.41 g·m⁻² and 0.42 g·m⁻², respectively. After 50 times thermal cycles between room temperature and 1773 K, the mass gain of the coated sample was 3.95 g·m⁻² and the mass retention rate was up to 98.19 % during the thermos-gravimetric test from room temperature to 1773 K.     

Structural characteristics and ablative behavior of C/C–ZrC–SiC composites reinforced with “Z-pins like” Zr–Si–B–C multiphase ceramic rods

In order to improve the ablation and oxidation resistance of C/C–ZrC–SiC composites in wide temperature domain, “Z-pins like” Zr–Si–B–C multiphase ceramic rods are prepared in the matrix. The influence of different sintering temperatures on the microstructure of ceramic rods and the ablative behavior of heterogeneous composites are studied. The results showed that the ZrB₂ and SiC phases are formed in the sintered matrix, and the increase of sintering temperature is beneficial to improve the density of the ceramic rods. The ablation properties of samples have been greatly improved. The mass and linear ablation rate are 0.8 mg/s and 3.85 μm/s, respectively, at an ablation temperature of 3000 °C and an ablation time of 60 s. After ablation, the matrix surface is covered with SiO₂ and ZrO₂ mixed oxide films. This is due to the preferential oxidation of “Z-pins like” Zr–Si–B–C multiphase ceramic rods in the ablation process, and B₂O₃ melt, SiO₂ melt, borosilicate glass, ZrSiO₄ melt and ZrO₂ oxide film can be generated successively from the low-temperature segment to the ultra-high temperature segment. These oxidation products can be used as compensation oxide melts for the healing of cracks and holes on the matrix surface in different temperature ranges and effectively prevent the external heat from spreading into the matrix. Therefore, C/C–ZrC–SiC composites with “Z-pins like” Zr–Si–B–C multiphase ceramic rods achieve ablation resistance in wide temperature domain.     

Thermal properties of La2O3-doped ZrB2- and HfB2-based ultra-high temperature ceramics

Thermal properties of La₂O₃-doped ZrB₂- and HfB₂-based ultra high temperature ceramics (UHTCs) have been measured at temperatures from room temperature to 2000 °C and compared with SiC-doped ZrB₂- and HfB₂-based UHTCs and monolithic ZrB₂ and HfB₂. Thermal conductivities of La₂O₃-doped UHTCs remain constant around 55–60 W/mK from 1500 °C to 1900 °C while SiC-doped UHTCs showed a trend to decreasing values over this range.     

Improved ablation resistance of C–C composites using zirconium diboride and boron carbide

Zirconium diboride and boron carbide particles were used to improve the ablation resistance of carbon–carbon (C–C) composites at high temperature (1500 °C). Our approach combines using a precursor to ZrB₂ and processing them with B₄C particles as filler material within the C–C composite. An oxyacetylene torch test facility was used to determine ablation rates for carbon black, B₄C, and ZrB₂–B₄C filled C–C composites from 800 to 1500 °C. Ablation rates decreased by 30% when C–C composites were filled with a combination of ZrB₂–B₄C particles over carbon black and B₄C filled C–C composites. We also investigated using a sol–gel precursor method as an alternative processing route to incorporate ZrB₂ particles within C–C composites. We successfully converted ZrB₂ particles within C–C composites at relatively low temperatures (1200 °C). Our ablation results suggest that a combination of ZrB₂–B₄C particles is effective in inhibiting the oxidation of C–C composites at temperatures greater than 1500 °C.     

Shock wave-material interaction in ZrB2–SiC based ultra high temperature ceramics for hypersonic applications

We investigate the thermochemical stability of ZrB₂–SiC based multiphase ceramics to hypersonic aerothermodynamic conditions in free piston shock tube with an objective to understand quantitatively the role of thermal shock and pressure. The developed ceramics sustained impulsive thermomechanical shock, under reflected shock pressure of 6.5 MPa and reflected shock temperature of 4160 K in dissociated oxygen, without structural failure. The conjugate heat transfer analysis predicts the surface temperature of ZrB₂–SiC to reach a maximum of 693 and 865 K, for ZrB₂–SiC–Ti. The transient shock-material response is characterized by surface oxidation of the investigated ceramics, when exposed to high enthalpy gaseous environment, as a consequence of the interaction with ultrafast-heated (10⁶ K/s) gas for ~5 ms. Spectroscopic and structural characterization reveals that addition of Ti improves thermomechanical shock resistance, which is attributed to the assemblage of refractory phases. Taken together, ZrB₂–SiC–Ti based multiphase ceramics exhibit favorable shock-material response under impulse loading.     

UHTC–carbon fibre composites: Preparation,oxyacetylene torch testing and characterisation

Current generation carbon–carbon (C–C) and carbon–silicon carbide (C–SiC) materials are limited to service temperatures below 1800 °C and materials are sought that can withstand higher temperatures and ablative conditions for aerospace applications. One potential materials solution is carbon fibre-based composites with matrices composed of one or more ultra-high temperature ceramics (UHTCs); the latter are intended to protect the carbon fibres at high temperatures whilst the former provides increased toughness and thermal shock resistance to the system as a whole. Carbon fibre–UHTC powder composites have been prepared via a slurry impregnation and pyrolysis route. Five different UHTC compositions have been used for impregnation, viz. ZrB₂, ZrB₂–20 vol% SiC, ZrB₂–20 vol% SiC–10 vol% LaB₆, HfB₂ and HfC. Their high-temperature oxidation resistance has been studied using a purpose built oxyacetylene torch test facility at temperatures above 2500 °C and the results are compared with that of a C–C benchmark composite.