Thermostatic valve control using a non-azeotropic refrigerant, isobutane/propane mixtureRégulation d'un détendeur thermostatique utilisant un mélange d'isobutane et de propane comme frigorigène non azéotropique

This article describes the evaluation and comparison of a conventional R12 cross-charged thermostatic valve and an electronic expansion valve using a non-azeotropic refrigerant mixture (NARM); isobutane/propane mixture (CARE30). The superheat temperature setting on an expansion valve needs to compensate for the temperature glide associated with a non-azeotropic refrigerant as these can be of similar magnitude. It is also advisable to increase the superheat setting to make allowance for change in refrigerant composition as a result of preferential refrigerant/oil solubility. The majority of refrigeration systems operate at fixed evaporating temperatures, hence, once superheat setting is trimmed during commissioning, then there should be no further problems associated with evaporation of a non-azeotropic refrigerant provided the system is leak-tight. An R12 expansion valve with a factory superheat setting of 5°C tested over a wide range of evaporating temperatures proved satisfactory in operation with CARE30 after increasing the superheat temperature screw setting equivalent to 5°C.     

The use of propane in domestic refrigerators

The implications of using propane in domestic refrigerators are examined in relation to energy consumption, compressor lubrication, costs, availability, environmental factors and safety. It is concluded that propane is an attractive and environmentally friendly alternative to CFCs used currently.     

Mixing and separation characteristics of isobutane with refrigeration oil

This paper discusses the transient mixing and separation characteristics of isobutane with/from refrigeration oil. The mixing/separation processes are observed and investigated experimentally in a glass cylindrical vessel. Since liquid isobutane is less dense than refrigeration oil, the mixing process proceeds one dimensionally by diffusion from the interface between isobutane gas and refrigeration oil. The progress of mixing, therefore, is very slow compared with a combination of halocarbon refrigerant and refrigeration oil having convection flow during the mixing process. The diffusion process can be analyzed using a one-dimensional diffusion model with an appropriate diffusion coefficient, which increases linearly with temperature. The separation of isobutane from the oil–refrigerant mixture occurs at the interface and the denser oil from which isobutane is separated causes a convective flow. Bubble generation under the depressurized conditions is unstable, but in the most cases, it tends to start when a high super saturation degree is reached. The temperature change during the separation process is estimated using latent heat as the separation heat of refrigerant.     

A study on the performance of multi-stage condensation heat pumpsEtude sur la performance des pompes à chaleur à condensation en plusieurs étages

In this study, computer simulation programs were developed for multi-stage condensation heat pumps and their performance was examined for CFC11, HCFC123, HCFC141b under the same condition. The results showed that the coefficient of performance (COP) of an optimized ‘non-split type’ three-stage condensation heat pump was 25–42% higher than that of a conventional single-stage heat pump. The increase in COP differed among the fluids examined. The improvement in COP was due largely to the decrease in average temperature difference between the refrigerant and water in the condensers, which resulted in a decrease in thermodynamic irreversibility. For the three-stage heat pump, the highest COP was achieved when the total condenser area was evenly distributed to the three condensers. For the two-stage heat pump, however, the optimum distribution of total condenser area varied with working fluids. For the three-stage system, splitting the condenser cooling water for the use of intermediate and high pressure subcoolers helped increase the COP further. When the individual cooling water for the intermediate and high pressure subcoolers was roughly 10% of the total condenser cooling water, the optimum COP was achieved showing an additional 11% increase in COP as compared to that of the ‘non-split type’ for the three-stage heat pump system.     

Simulation d'une machine frigorifique à absorption fonctionnant avec des mélanges d'alcanes

We propose in this article an absorption chiller operating with binary alkane mixtures as an alternative to compression machines. It is an installation using low-level energy at a temperature below 150 °C (waste heat or solar energy) and operating with environmentally friendly fluids. Ten mixtures are considered and compared with two cooling mediums of the condenser and the absorber: the ambient air at 35 °C and the water at 25 °C. For an air-cooled chiller, the COP reaches 0.37 for the n-butane/octane system. This value remains 27% lower than that of an ammonia/water installation operating under the same conditions. For a water-cooling chiller, the n-butane/octane and propane/octane systems give a COP of about 0.63, which is comparable to that of the ammonia/water system. When n-butane is used as refrigerant, the machine works at a pressure under 5 bars, which is an advantage compared with machines working with ammonia/water mixtures.     

Developing new test procedures for domestic refrigerators: harmonisation issues and future R&D needs—a review

This paper highlights the salient differences among various test standards for household refrigerators/freezers and identifies the main parameters that play important role in the overall energy consumption of a refrigerating appliance. Further the paper examines the merits and demerits of current test standards for refrigerator-freezers and proposes new guidelines that should be considered to improve them. There is a need to develop a new test procedure that harmonises the basic features of various standards and is simple, repeatable and reproducible. Such a procedure should also represent realistic “real” world energy use, encourage product innovation, capture both the software and hardware developments and facilitate ‘free trade’ among various economies. In order to achieve this, the paper highlights areas where concerted efforts are required for carrying out the requisite research and development work.     

Evaluation of supplementary/retrofit refrigerants for automobile air-conditioners charged with CFC12Evaluation des frigorigènes supplémentaires / de remplacement pour des systèmes de conditionnement d'air automobiles utilisant du CFC12

In this study, thermodynamic performance of supplementary/retrofit refrigerant mixtures for CFC12 used in existing automobile air-conditioners was examined. A thermodynamic computer analysis of an automobile air-conditioner was carried out for the initial screening of possible mixture candidates, and refrigerant mixtures composed of HCFC22, HFC134a, HCFC142b, RE170 (dimethylether), HC290 (propane), and HC600a (iso-butane) were proposed to supplement CFC12. Also a breadboard type refrigeration test facility was manufactured to verify the performance of the alternative refrigerant mixtures proposed through the computer analysis. Test results showed that HFC134a/RE170 mixture with zero ozone depletion potential is the best long term candidate to supplement CFC12. On the other hand, HCFC22/HFC134a/RE170 and HCFC22/HFC134a/HCFC142b mixtures are good only as short term supplementary/retrofit alternatives since they contain HCFC22. A hydrocarbon mixture of HC290/HC600a showed a good performance but its use in existing automobile air-conditioners should be carefully considered due to its flammability.     

An experimental investigation and modelling of the viscosity refrigerant/oil solutions

This paper presents experimental data for the viscosity of solutions of refrigerant R600a (isobutane) with mineral compressor oils Azmol, Reniso WF 15A, and R245fa (1,1,1,3,3-pentafluoropropane) with polyolester compressor oil Planetelf ACD 100 FY on the saturation line. The experimental data were obtained for solution of R600a with mineral compressor oil Azmol in the temperature range from 294.7 to 338.1 K and the concentration range 0.04399 ≤ w_R ≤ 0.3651, the solution of R600a with mineral compressor oil Reniso WF 15A at the temperatures from 285.8 to 348.4 K and the concentration range 0.03364 ≤ w_R ≤ 0.2911, the solution of R245fa with polyolester compressor oil Planetelf ACD 100 FY at the temperatures from 309 to 348.2 and the concentration range 0.06390 ≤ w_R ≤ 0.3845. The viscosity was measured using a rolling ball method. The method for prediction of the dynamic viscosity for refrigerant/oil solutions is reported.     

Performance characteristics of a small-capacity directly cooled refrigerator using R290/R600a (55/45)

In this study, the performance of a small-capacity directly cooled refrigerator was evaluated by using the mixture of R290 and R600a with mass fraction of 55:45 as an alternative to R134a. The compressor displacement volume of the alternative system with R290/R600a (55/45) was modified from that of the original system with R134a to match the refrigeration capacity. Both systems with R290/R600a (55/45) and R134a were tested, and then optimized by varying the refrigerant charge and capillary tube length under experimental conditions for both the pull-down test and the power consumption test. The refrigerant charge of the optimized R290/R600a system was approximately 50% of that of the optimized R134a system. The capillary tube lengths for each evaporator in the optimized R290/R600a system were 500 mm longer than those in the optimized R134a system. The power consumption of the optimized R134a system was 12.3% higher than that of the optimized R290/R600a system. The cooling speed of the optimized R290/R600a (55/45) system at the in-case setting temperature of −15 °C was improved by 28.8% over that of the optimized R134a system.     

A study on the performance of multi-stage heat pumps using mixturesEtude sur la performance de pompes à chaleur multi-étagées utilisant des mélanges

Multi-stage heat pumps composed of a condenser, evaporator, compressor, suction line heat exchanger, and low and/or high stage economizers are studied by computer simulation. Their thermodynamic performance and design options are examined for various working fluids. In the simulation, HCFC22/HCFC142b and HFC134a are studied as an interim and long term alternatives for CFC12 while HFC32/HFC134a and HFC125/HFC134a are studied as long term alternatives for HCFC22. The results indicate that the three-stage super heat pump with appropriate mixtures is up to 27.3% more energy efficient than the conventional single-stage system with pure fluids. While many factors contribute to the performance increase of a super heat pump, the most important factor is found to be the temperature matching between the secondary heat transfer fluid and refrigerant mixture, which is followed by the use of a low stage economizer and suction line heat exchanger. The contribution resulting from the use of a high stage economizer, however, is not significant. With the suction line heat exchanger, the system efficiency increases more with the fluids of larger molar liquid specific heats. From the view point of volumetric capacity and energy efficiency, a 40%HCFC22/60%HCFC142b mixture is proposed as an interim alternative for CFC12 while a 25%HFC32/75%HFC134a mixture is proposed as a long term alternative for HCFC22.     

HFC134a/HC600a/HC290 mixture a retrofit for CFC12 systems

The environmental concerns with the impact of refrigerant emissions lead to the importance in identifying a long-term alternative to meet all requirements in respect of system performance and service. Even though HFC134a and HC blend (containing 55.2% HC600a and 44.8% HC290 by weight) have been reported to be substitutes for CFC12, they have their own drawbacks in respect of energy efficiency/flammability/serviceability aspects of the system. In this present work, experimental investigation has been carried out on the performance of an ozone friendly refrigerant mixture (containing HFC134a/HC blend) in two low temperature systems (a 165 l domestic refrigerator and a 400 l deep freezer) and two medium temperature systems [a 165 l vending machine (visi cooler) and a 3.5 kW walk-in cooler]. The oil miscibility of the new mixture with mineral oil was also studied and found to be good. The HFC134a/HC blend mixture that contains 9% HC blend (by weight) has better performance resulting in 10–30% and 5–15% less energy consumption (than CFC12) in medium and low temperature system, respectively.     

Natural refrigerant-based subcritical and transcritical cycles for high temperature heating

Theoretical analyses of subcritical/transcritical heat pumps using four natural refrigerants, carbon dioxide, ammonia, propane and isobutane have been carried out for high temperature heating applications at different heating outlet temperatures and heat sources using computer models. The compressor discharge pressures have been optimized for transcritical and subcritical (with near critical operation of condenser) cycles. Results show that for subcritical heat pumps, use of subcooling is efficient for heating applications with a gliding temperature. Results also show that although propane yields better coefficient of performance (COP) in low temperature heating applications, ammonia performs the best in high temperature heating applications. Finally, design aspects of major components of all the four heat pumps for high temperature heating have been discussed, particularly with reference to suitability of available lubricants to the newly evolved operating conditions.     

A minichannel aluminium tube heat exchanger – Part II: Evaporator performance with propane

This paper presents heat transfer data for a multiport minichannel heat exchanger vertically mounted as an evaporator in a test-rig simulating a small water-to-water heat pump. The multiport minichannel heat exchanger was designed similar to a shell-and-tube type heat exchanger, with a six-channel tube of 1.42 mm hydraulic diameter, a tube-side heat transfer area of 0.777 m² and a shell-side heat transfer area of 0.815 m². Refrigerant propane with a desired vapour quality flowed upward through the tubes and exited with a desired superheat of 1–4 K. A temperature-controlled glycol solution that flowed downward on the shell-side supplied the heat for the evaporation of the propane. The heat transfer rate between the glycol solution and propane was controlled by varying the evaporation temperature and propane mass flow rate while the glycol flow rate was fixed (18.50 l min⁻¹). Tests were conducted for a range of evaporation temperatures from −15 to +10 °C, heat flux from 2000 to 9000 W m⁻² and mass flux from 13 to 66 kg m⁻² s⁻¹. The heat transfer coefficients were compared with 14 correlations found in the literature. The experimental heat transfer coefficients were higher than those predicted by many of the correlations. A correlation which was previously developed for a very large and long tube (21 mm diameter and 10 m long) was in good agreement with the experimental data (97% of the data within ±30%). Several other correlations were able to predict the data within a reasonable deviation (within ±30%) after some adjustments to the correlations.     

An experimental investigation and modelling of the thermodynamic properties of isobutane–compressor oil solutions: Some aspects of experimental methodology

This paper presents experimental data for the solubility, density and capillary constant for solutions of natural refrigerant isobutane with commercial mineral compressor oil Azmol over a wide range of temperatures and concentrations. Based on information for the capillary constant, the surface tension of the solutions isobutane/Azmol is determined. The experimental data were obtained in the temperature range from 303 K to 363 K and at pressures up to 1.7 MPa using static methods. The experimental data obtained for the solutions of the natural refrigerant isobutane with the commercial mineral compressor oil Azmol are sufficiently described with the help of correlations based on the theory of thermodynamic similarity. The paper reports variation of the vapor pressure, density, capillary constant and surface tension as a function of concentration for the isobutane/Azmol solutions. The enthalpy of liquid phase of the isobutane/Azmol solutions is calculated. The analysis of the behaviour of the excess thermodynamic functions is carried out. The paper examines experimental and methodical uncertainties in the investigation of thermodynamic properties of the refrigerant/oil solutions (ROS). The influence of the time taken to establish thermodynamic equilibrium in the experimental cell on the uncertainty of the experimental data for gas-saturated mixtures such as ROS is discussed. Information about the changing concentration of refrigerant in the liquid phase of the ROS and in the surface layer of the liquid phase of the ROS at increasing temperature is presented. In addition, the experimental data for the density, surface tension and refractive index of the mineral compressor oil Azmol are reported.     

Performance of compression/absorption hybrid refrigeration cycle with propane/mineral oil combination

This paper discusses the feasibility of a vapor compression/absorption hybrid refrigeration cycle for energy saving and utilization of waste heat. The cycle employs propane as a natural refrigerant and a refrigeration oil as an absorbent. A prototype of the cycle is constructed, in which a compressor and an absorption unit are combined in series. The performance of the cycle is examined both theoretically and experimentally. Although the solubility of the propane with the oil is not enough as a working pair in the absorption unit, the theoretical calculation shows that the hybrid cycle has a potential to achieve a higher performance in comparison with a simple vapor compression cycle by using the waste heat. In the experiment, the prototype cycle is operated successfully and it is found that an improvement of an absorber is necessary to achieve the good performance close to the theoretical one. The application of an AHE (absorber heat exchanger) can reduce the heat input to a generator. Further examinations on some other combinations of refrigerant/refrigeration oil and additives are desirable.     

Performance analysis of a series of hermetic reciprocating compressors working with R290 (propane) and R407C

In this paper, a series of compressors with different capacities and geometries working with propane as refrigerant are analyzed in terms of the compressor model developed by [E. Navarro, E. Granryd, J.F. Urchueguía, J.M. Corberán, A phenomenological model for analyzing reciprocating compressors, International Journal of Refrigeration, in this issue, doi:10.1016/j.irefrig.2007.02.006]. The relative influence of the diverse compressor losses is estimated as a function of the operating conditions.In addition, a comparison study between propane and R407C was carried out for one compressor and the observed differences were analyzed in terms of the compressor model. This study was also useful to verify the model's goodness with the aim of predicting the compressor performance with an untested refrigerant.     

Cooling performance of several CO2/propane mixtures and glide matching with secondary heat transfer fluid

This paper presents the cooling performance of several CO₂/propane mixtures measured in air-conditioning test rig at several conditions. The discharge pressure of CO₂/propane mixtures is reduced with increasing mole fraction of propane and their reduced values coincide approximately with the circulation concentrations of propane. Since propane is the refrigerant having a higher refrigerating effect and a much lower vapor density than CO₂, adding propane to CO₂ improves the system efficiency and reduces the cooling capacity. The temperature glide effect of CO₂/propane mixtures on the cooling performance was analyzed based on the experimental data. To utilize the temperature glide effect successfully, a sufficient heat exchange area is required, and the temperature gradient of refrigerant must be similar to that of secondary heat transfer fluid. It is better the temperature change of refrigerant can prevent pinching with that of the secondary heat transfer fluid.     

Circulation concentration of CO2/propane mixtures and the effect of their charge on the cooling performance in an air-conditioning system

CO₂ and propane mixtures are considered as alternative refrigerants due to their negligible direct global warming potentials and favorable thermodynamic properties. To properly evaluate the system performance using zeotropic mixtures, the circulation concentration was measured and the cause for its shift from the charged concentration was discussed. The circulation concentration of CO₂/propane mixtures has increased CO₂ fraction than its charged concentration. In addition, the effect of refrigerant charge on the cooling performance was tested for the transcritical cycle of CO₂ and the subcritical cycle of CO₂/propane mixtures of 75/25 and 60/40 by the charged mass percentage. It is shown that CO₂ refrigeration system could operate without a significant impact on its COP over a relatively wider range from the optimum charge.     

Condensation heat transfer coefficients of flammable refrigerants

In this study, external condensation heat transfer coefficients (HTCs) of six flammable refrigerants of propylene (R1270), propane (R290), isobutane (R600a), butane (R600), dimethylether (RE170), and HFC32 were measured at the vapor temperature of 39 °C on a plain tube of 19.0 mm outside diameter with a wall subcooling of 3–8 °C under a heat flux of 7–23 kW m⁻². Test results showed a typical trend that external condensation HTCs decrease with the wall subcooling. No unusual behavior or phenomenon was observed for these flammable refrigerants during experiments. HFC32 and DME showed 28–44% higher HTCs than those of HCFC22 due to their excellent thermophysical properties. Propylene and butane showed the similar HTCs as those of HCFC22 while propane and isobutane showed 9% lower HTCs than those of HCFC22. Finally, a general correlation was made by modifying Nusselt's equation based upon the measured data of eleven fluids of various vapor pressures including halogenated refrigerants. The general equation showed an excellent agreement with all data exhibiting a deviation of less than 3%.     

Nucleate boiling heat transfer coefficients of flammable refrigerants on various enhanced tubes

In this study, nucleate boiling heat transfer coefficients (HTCs) of five flammable refrigerants of propylene (R1270), propane (R290), isobutane (R600a), butane (R600), and dimethylether (RE170) were measured at the liquid temperature of 7 °C on a low fin tube of 1023 fins per meter, Turbo-B, and Thermoexcel-E tubes. All data were taken from 80 to 10 kW m⁻² with an interval of 10 kW m⁻² in the decreasing order of heat flux. Flammable refrigerants' data showed a typical trend that nucleate boiling HTCs obtained on enhanced tubes also increase with the vapor pressure. Fluids with lower reduced pressure such as DME, isobutene, and butane took more advantage of the heat transfer enhancement mechanism of enhanced tubes than those with higher reduced pressure such as propylene and propane. Finally, Thermoexcel-E showed the highest heat transfer enhancement ratios of 2.3–9.4 among the tubes tested due to its sub-channels and re-entrant cavities.