Label-free detection of single protein molecules and protein-protein interactions using synthetic nanopores

Nanofabricated pores in 20 nm-thick silicon nitride membranes were used to probe various protein analytes as well as to perform an antigen-antibody binding assay. A two-compartment electrochemical cell was separated by a single nanopore, 28 nm in diameter. Adding proteins to one compartment caused current perturbations in the ion current flowing through the pore. These perturbations correlated with both the charge and the size of the protein or of a protein-protein complex. The potential of this nanotechnology for studying protein-protein interactions is highlighted with the sensitive detection of beta-human chorionic gonadotropin, a hormone and clinical biomarker of pregnancy, by monitoring in real time and at a molecular level the formation of a complex between hormones and antibodies in solution. In this form, the assay compared advantageously to immunoassays, with the important difference that labels, immobilization, or amplification steps were no longer needed. In conclusion, we present proof-of-principle that properties of proteins and their interactions can be investigated in solution using synthetic nanopores and that these interactions can be exploited to measure protein concentrations accurately.     

Controlling protein translocation through nanopores with bio-inspired fluid walls

Synthetic nanopores have been used to study individual biomolecules in high throughput, but their performance as sensors does not match that of biological ion channels. Challenges include control of nanopore diameters and surface chemistry, modification of the translocation times of single-molecule analytes through nanopores, and prevention of non-specific interactions with pore walls. Here, inspired by the olfactory sensilla of insect antennae, we show that coating nanopores with a fluid lipid bilayer tailors their surface chemistry and allows fine-tuning and dynamic variation of pore diameters in subnanometre increments. Incorporation of mobile ligands in the lipid bilayer conferred specificity and slowed the translocation of targeted proteins sufficiently to time-resolve translocation events of individual proteins. Lipid coatings also prevented pores from clogging, eliminated non-specific binding and enabled the translocation of amyloid-beta (Aβ) oligomers and fibrils. Through combined analysis of their translocation time, volume, charge, shape and ligand affinity, different proteins were identified.     

Nanometer-thin solid-state nanopores by cold ion beam sculpting

Recent work on protein nanopores indicates that single molecule characterization (including DNA sequencing) is possible when the length of the nanopore constriction is about a nanometer. Solid-state nanopores offer advantages in stability and tunability, but a scalable method for creating nanometer-thin solid-state pores has yet to be demonstrated. Here we demonstrate that solid-state nanopores with nanometer-thin constrictions can be produced by "cold ion beam sculpting," an original method that is broadly applicable to many materials, is easily scalable, and requires only modest instrumentation.     

Controlled translocation of individual DNA molecules through protein nanopores with engineered molecular brakes

Protein nanopores may provide a cheap and fast technology to sequence individual DNA molecules. However, the electrophoretic translocation of ssDNA molecules through protein nanopores has been too rapid for base identification. Here, we show that the translocation of DNA molecules through the α-hemolysin protein nanopore can be slowed controllably by introducing positive charges into the lumen of the pore by site directed mutagenesis. Although the residual ionic current during DNA translocation is insufficient for direct base identification, we propose that the engineered pores might be used to slow down DNA in hybrid systems, for example, in combination with solid-state nanopores.     

Aptamer-derived nucleic acid oligos: applications to develop nucleic acid chips to analyze proteins and small ligands

The specificity and affinity of aptamers for their cognate ligands are comparable to those of antibodies for antigens. To use aptamers effectively in high-throughput assays in a microarray format, to analyze various analytes, we developed a strategy in which the aptamer was split into two nonfunctional units and allowed to reassemble into the functional aptamer by the cognate ligand. We have named this method "analyte-dependent oligonucleotide modulation assay" (ADONMA). As proof-of-principle, we used oligonucleotides derived from the aptamer RNA against HIV-1 Tat and demonstrated, with both titer plates and plastic slide chips, that specifically in the presence of Tat or its peptide, the two oligos reconstituted the core binding regions of Tat. Thus, these results suggest that ADNOMA has the potential for use in nucleic acid microarrays for detecting various ligands.     

Biomolecule‐Functionalized Solid‐State Ion Nanochannels/Nanopores: Features and Techniques

Solid‐state ion nanochannels/nanopores, the biomimetic products of biological ion channels, are promising materials in real‐world applications due to their robust mechanical and controllable chemical properties. Functionalizations of solid‐state ion nanochannels/nanopores by biomolecules pave a wide way for the introduction of varied properties from biomolecules to solid‐state ion nanochannels/nanopores, making them smart in response to analytes or external stimuli and regulating the transport of ions/molecules. In this review, two features for nanochannels/nanopores functionalized by biomolecules are abstracted, i.e., specificity and signal amplification. Both of the two features are demonstrated from three kinds of nanochannels/nanopores: nucleic acid–functionalized nanochannels/nanopores, protein‐functionalized nanochannels/nanopores, and small biomolecule‐functionalized nanochannels/nanopores, respectively. Meanwhile, the fundamental mechanisms of these combinations between biomolecules and nanochannels/nanopores are explored, providing reasonable constructs for applications in sensing, transport, and energy conversion. And then, the techniques of functionalizations and the basic principle about biomolecules onto the solid‐state ion nanochannels/nanopores are summarized. Finally, some views about the future developments of the biomolecule‐functionalized nanochannels/nanopores are proposed.     

Discrimination of Protein Amino Acid or Its Protonated State at Single‐Residue Resolution by Graphene Nanopores

The function of a protein is determined by the composition of amino acids and is essential to proteomics. However, protein sequencing remains challenging due to the protein's irregular charge state and its high‐order structure. Here, a proof of principle study on the capability of protein sequencing by graphene nanopores integrated with atomic force microscopy is performed using molecular dynamics simulations. It is found that nanopores can discriminate a protein sequence and even its protonation state at single‐residue resolution. Both the pulling forces and current blockades induced by the permeation of protein residues are found to be highly correlated with the type of amino acids, which makes the residues identifiable. It is also found that aside from the dimension, both the conformation and charge state of the residue can significantly influence the force and current signal during its permeation through the nanopore. In particular, due to the electro‐osmotic flow effect, the blockade current for the double‐protonated histidine is slightly smaller than that for single‐protonated histidine, which makes it possible for discrimination of different protonation states of amino acids. The results reported here present a novel protein sequencing scheme using graphene nanopores combined with nanomanipulation technology.     

Electromechanical unzipping of individual DNA molecules using synthetic sub-2 nm pores

Nanopores have recently emerged as high-throughput tools for probing and manipulating nucleic acid secondary structure at the single-molecule level. While most studies to date have utilized protein pores embedded in lipid bilayers, solid-state nanopores offer many practical advantages which greatly expand the range of applications in life sciences and biotechnology. Using sub-2 nm solid-state nanopores, we show for the first time that the unzipping kinetics of individual DNA duplexes can be probed by analyzing the dwell-time distributions. We performed high-bandwidth electrical measurements of DNA duplex unzipping as a function of their length, sequence, and temperature. We find that our longer duplexes (>10 bp) follow Arrhenius dependence on temperature, suggesting that unzipping can be approximated as a single-barrier crossing, but the unzipping kinetics of shorter duplexes do not involve a barrier, due to the strong biasing electrical force. Finally, we show that mismatches in the duplex affect unzipping times in a position-sensitive manner. Our results are a crucial step toward sequence variability detection and our single-molecule nanopore sequencing technology, which rely on parallel detection from nanopore arrays.     

Assessing graphene nanopores for sequencing DNA

Using all-atom molecular dynamics and atomic-resolution Brownian dynamics, we simulate the translocation of single-stranded DNA through graphene nanopores and characterize the ionic current blockades produced by DNA nucleotides. We find that transport of single DNA strands through graphene nanopores may occur in single nucleotide steps. For certain pore geometries, hydrophobic interactions with the graphene membrane lead to a dramatic reduction in the conformational fluctuations of the nucleotides in the nanopores. Furthermore, we show that ionic current blockades produced by different DNA nucleotides are, in general, indicative of the nucleotide type, but very sensitive to the orientation of the nucleotides in the nanopore. Taken together, our simulations suggest that strand sequencing of DNA by measuring the ionic current blockades in graphene nanopores may be possible, given that the conformation of DNA nucleotides in the nanopore can be controlled through precise engineering of the nanopore surface.     

Large apparent electric size of solid-state nanopores due to spatially extended surface conduction

Ion transport through nanopores drilled in thin membranes is central to numerous applications, including biosensing and ion selective membranes. This paper reports experiments, numerical calculations, and theoretical predictions demonstrating an unexpectedly large ionic conduction in solid-state nanopores, taking its origin in anomalous entrance effects. In contrast to naive expectations based on analogies with electric circuits, the surface conductance inside the nanopore is shown to perturb the three-dimensional electric current streamlines far outside the nanopore in order to meet charge conservation at the pore entrance. This unexpected contribution to the ionic conductance can be interpreted in terms of an apparent electric size of the solid-state nanopore, which is much larger than its geometric counterpart whenever the number of charges carried by the nanopore surface exceeds its bulk counterpart. This apparent electric size, which can reach hundreds of nanometers, can have a major impact on the electrical detection of translocation events through nanopores, as well as for ionic transport in biological nanopores.     

Hybrid pore formation by directed insertion of α-haemolysin into solid-state nanopores

Most experiments on nanopores have concentrated on the pore-forming protein α-haemolysin (αHL) and on artificial pores in solid-state membranes. While biological pores offer an atomically precise structure and the potential for genetic engineering, solid-state nanopores offer durability, size and shape control, and are also better suited for integration into wafer-scale devices. However, each system has significant limitations: αHL is difficult to integrate because it relies on delicate lipid bilayers for mechanical support, and the fabrication of solid-state nanopores with precise dimensions remains challenging. Here we show that these limitations may be overcome by inserting a single αHL pore into a solid-state nanopore. A double-stranded DNA attached to the protein pore is threaded into a solid-state nanopore by electrophoretic translocation. Protein insertion is observed in 30-40% of our attempts, and translocation of single-stranded DNA demonstrates that the hybrid nanopore remains functional. The hybrid structure offers a platform to create wafer-scale device arrays for genomic analysis, including sequencing.     

Electrical characterization of protein molecules by a solid-state nanopore

The authors measured ionic current blockages caused by protein translocation through voltage-biased silicon nitride nanopores in ionic solution. By calculating the mean amplitude, time duration, and the integral of current blockages, they estimated the relative charge and size of protein molecules at a single molecule level. The authors measured the change in protein charge of bovine serum albumin (BSA) protein induced by pH variation. They also confirmed that BSA molecules indeed traverse nanopores using an improved chemiluminescent analysis. They demonstrated that a larger protein fibrinogen could be distinguished from BSA by a solid-state nanopore measurement.     

An aptamer-based protein biochip

The establishment of an aptamer-based biochip for protein detection is described. Using a model system comprising human IgE as the analyte and single-stranded DNA aptamers specific for IgE or anti-IgE antibodies as immobilized ligands on chips, we could demonstrate that aptamers were equivalent or superior to antibodies in terms of specificity and sensitivity, respectively. Aptamer-based analyte detection on glass slides could clearly be demonstrated at minimum concentrations of 10 ng/mL IgE. In addition, we successfully showed specific analyte recognition in complex protein samples by the aptamer-based biochip system. Using DNA aptamers specific for human thrombin as an additional model receptor/ligand system, dual protein detection on a single slide could be proven. In conclusion, we could show the suitability of nucleic acid aptamers as low molecular weight receptors on biochips for sensitive and specific protein detection, representing an innovative tool for future proteomics.     

Selection of smart aptamers by methods of kinetic capillary electrophoresis

We coin the term "smart aptamers" -- aptamers with predefined binding parameters (k(on), k(off), Kd) of aptamer-target interaction. Aptamers, in general, are oligonucleotides, which are capable of binding target molecules with high affinity and selectivity. They are considered as potential therapeutic targets and also thought to rival antibodies in immunoassay-like analyses. Aptamers are selected from combinatorial libraries of oligonucleotides by affinity methods. Until now, technological limitations have precluded the development of smart aptamers. Here, we report on two kinetic capillary electrophoresis techniques applicable to the selection of smart aptamers. Equilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures was used to develop aptamers with predefined equilibrium dissociation constants (Kd), while nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures facilitated selection of aptamers with different dissociation rate constants (k(off)). Selections were made for MutS protein, for which aptamers have never been previously developed. Both theoretical and practical aspects of smart aptamer development are presented, and the advantages of this new type of affinity probes are described.     

Voltage-gated ion transport through semiconducting conical nanopores formed by metal nanoparticle-assisted plasma etching

Nanopores with conical geometries have been found to rectify ionic current in electrolytes. While nanopores in semiconducting membranes are known to modulate ionic transport through gated modification of pore surface charge, the fabrication of conical nanopores in silicon (Si) has proven challenging. Here, we report the discovery that gold (Au) nanoparticle (NP)-assisted plasma etching results in the formation of conical etch profiles in Si. These conical profiles result due to enhanced Si etch rates in the vicinity of the Au NPs. We show that this process provides a convenient and versatile means to fabricate conical nanopores in Si membranes and crystals with variable pore-diameters and cone-angles. We investigated ionic transport through these pores and observed that rectification ratios could be enhanced by a factor of over 100 by voltage gating alone, and that these pores could function as ionic switches with high on-off ratios of approximately 260. Further, we demonstrate voltage gated control over protein transport, which is of importance in lab-on-a-chip devices and biomolecular separations.     

Molecular discrimination inside polymer nanotubules

Recognition of small organic molecules and large biomolecules such as proteins is of great importance in pharmaceutical as well as biological applications. Recognition inside a nanoporous membrane is particularly attractive, because of the advantages associated with ligand-receptor interactions in confined spaces. Classical nanoporous membrane-based separations simply use the difference in size of the analytes relative to pore size in the membrane. In order to bring about selectivity beyond size, it is necessary that methods for functionalizing the membrane pores are readily available. Here, we describe a simple approach to functionalize the nanopores within these membranes using self-assembling and non-self-assembling polymers. We show that these modified membranes separate small molecules based on size, charge and hydrophobicity. We also demonstrate here that proteins can be differentially transported through the nanopores based on their size and/or electrostatics.     

Local electrical potential detection of DNA by nanowire-nanopore sensors

Nanopores could potentially be used to perform single-molecule DNA sequencing at low cost and with high throughput. Although single base resolution and differentiation have been demonstrated with nanopores using ionic current measurements, direct sequencing has not been achieved because of the difficulties in recording very small (～pA) ionic currents at a bandwidth consistent with fast translocation speeds. Here, we show that solid-state nanopores can be combined with silicon nanowire field-effect transistors to create sensors in which detection is localized and self-aligned at the nanopore. Well-defined field-effect transistor signals associated with DNA translocation are recorded when an ionic strength gradient is imposed across the nanopores. Measurements and modelling show that field-effect transistor signals are generated by highly localized changes in the electrical potential during DNA translocation, and that nanowire-nanopore sensors could enable large-scale integration with a high intrinsic bandwidth.     

Shape-controlled nanopores in single crystals

Nanometer length-scale holes (nanopores) are often formed in amorphous materials for fundamental studies of molecular mass transport. In the current study, electron beam irradiation in the transmission electron microscope was used to form nanopores in a crystalline material (Si). Analysis of the nanopores showed that they are formed by knock-on of atoms by the high energy incident electron beam, and surface diffusion is partially responsible for the hour-glass shapes that are found for some nanopores. Energetically favorable three-dimensional shapes of nanopores were simulated, and the nanopores simulated in the model crystalline material were found to be more stable than the nanopores simulated in the amorphous material. The nanopore shape was also found to depend on the nanopore diameter-to-length ratio. Based on the above, we demonstrate the advantage in using a crystalline material for nanopore formation and show that control of the three-dimensional shape of nanopores formed by electron beam irradiation is possible.     

Sensitive discrimination and detection of prion disease-associated isoform with a dual-aptamer strategy by developing a sandwich structure of magnetic microparticles and quantum dots

The major challenge of prion disease diagnosis at the presymptomatic stage is how to sensitively or selectively discriminate and detect the minute quantity of disease-associated prion protein isoform (PrP(Res)) in complex biological systems such as serum and brain homogenate. In this contribution, we developed a dual-aptamer strategy by taking the advantages of aptamers, the excellent separation ability of magnetic microparticles (MMPs), and the high fluorescence emission features of quantum dots (QDs). Two aptamers (Apt1 and Apt2), which can recognize their two corresponding distinct epitopes of prion proteins (PrP), were coupled to the surfaces of MMPs and QDs, respectively, to make MMPs-Apt1 and QDs-Apt2 ready at first, which then could be coassociated together through the specific recognitions of the two aptamers with their two corresponding distinct epitopes of PrP, forming a sandwich structure of MMPs-Apt1-PrP-Apt2-QDs and displaying the strong fluorescence of QDs. Owing to the different binding affinities of the two aptamers with PrP(Res) and cellular prion protein (PrP(C)), both of which have distinct denaturing detergent resistance, our dual-aptamer strategy could be applied to discriminate PrP(Res) and PrP(C) successfully in serum. Further identifications showed that the present dual-aptamer assay could be successfully applied to the detection of PrP in 0.01% brain homogenate, about 1000-fold lower than that of commonly applied antibody-mediated assays, which can detect PrP just in 10% brain homogenate, indicating that the present designed dual-aptamer assay is highly sensitive and adequate for clinical diagnosis without isolation of target protein prior to assay.     

Surface immobilization of structure-switching DNA aptamers on macroporous sol-gel-derived films for solid-phase biosensing applications

Structure-switching signaling aptamers (ss-aptamers) are single-stranded DNA molecules that are generated through in vitro selection and have the ability to switch between a duplex composed of a quencher-labeled DNA strand (QDNA) hybridized adjacent to a fluorophore label on the aptamer, and an aptamer-target complex wherein the QDNA strand is released, generating a fluorescence signal. While such species have recently emerged as promising biological recognition and signaling elements, very little has been done to evaluate their potential for solid-phase assays. In this study, we demonstrate that high surface area, sol-gel-derived macroporous silica films are suitable platforms for high-density affinity-based immobilization of functional ss-aptamer molecules, allowing for binding of both large and small target analytes with robust signal development. These films are formed using a poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)-doped sodium silicate material, and we show that it is possible to control the pore size distribution and surface area of the silica film by varying the amount of PEG. Materials with the highest surface area are shown to be able to immobilize up to 6-fold more ss-aptamer than planar glass surfaces, providing greater detection sensitivity and somewhat improved detection limits as compared to immobilization on conventional glass. The solid-phase assay is performed using two different structure-switching signaling aptamers with high selectivity for adenosine 5'-triphosphate and platelet-derived growth factor, respectively, demonstrating that this immobilization scheme should be suitable for a variety of target ligands.