Fair distributed congestion control in multirate multicast networks

We study fairness of resource allocation in multirate, multicast networks. In multirate networks, different receivers of the same multicast session can receive service at different rates. We develop a mathematical framework to model the maxmin fair allocation of bandwidth with minimum and maximum rate constraints. We present a necessary and sufficient condition for a rate allocation to be maxmin fair in a multirate, multicast network. We propose a distributed algorithm for computing the maxmin fair rates allocated to various source-destination pairs. This algorithm has a low message exchange overhead, and is guaranteed to converge to the maxmin fair rates in finite time.     

Intra-Session Fairness in Multicast Communications

Multicast communication achieves scalability by sending data to multiple receivers at the same time. Receivers in a multicast session usually share the fate with each other, even though their processing speed and the capacity of the path they use can be quite different. A conventional multicast session usually consists of a single multicast group and the problem is how to set the group rate so that it is fair to both fast and slow receivers, to some extent. In a replicated multicast service, receivers are divided into groups based on their capacities and a multicast session can consist of multiple multicast groups. The question is how to divide receivers into groups exactly and set appropriate group rates so that it is fair to all the receivers. Most of current work focuses on optimizing the social welfare represented as a sum of some performance measures of receivers [Kar et al., 2002; Stoenescu et al., 2003]. In this paper, we define a new concept called intra-session fairness and give an optimal solution that can achieve fairness among receivers in the same session. The goal is to maximize the minimum fairness value of the receivers. The novelty of the framework is that it is independent of the specific definition of the fairness function on individual receivers. We illustrate a layering method to implement the max-min intra-session fair allocation and demonstrate the significant difference in fairness achieved by the maximal social welfare algorithm and the max-min intra-session fairness algorithm.     

Cross-Layer Design for End-to-End Throughput and Fairness Enhancement in Multi-Channel Wireless Mesh Networks

In this paper, we study joint rate control, routing and scheduling in multi-channel wireless mesh networks (WMNs), which are traditionally known as transport layer, network layer and MAC layer issues respectively. Our objective is to find a rate allocation along with a flow allocation and a transmission schedule for a set of end-to-end communication sessions such that the network throughput is maximized, which is formally defined as the maximum throughput rate allocation (MRA) problem. As simple throughput maximization may result in a severe bias on rate allocation, we take account of fairness based on a simplified max-min fairness model and the proportional fairness models. We define the max-min guaranteed maximum throughput rate allocation (MMRA) problem and proportional fair rate allocation (PRA) problem. We present efficient linear programming (LP) and convex programming (CP) based schemes to solve these problems. Numerical results show that proportional fair rate allocation schemes achieves a good tradeoff between throughput and fairness.     

Layered media multicast control (LMMC): rate allocation and partitioning

The objective of layering techniques of distributing multimedia traffic over multicast IP networks is to effectively cope with the challenges in continuous media applications. The challenges include heterogeneity, fairness, real-time constraints, and quality of service. We study the problem of rate allocation and receiver partitioning in layered and replicated media systems. We formulate an optimization problem aimed at maximizing a close approximation of the so-called max-min fairness metric subject to loss and bandwidth constraints. Our optimal layered media multicast control (LMMC) solution to the problem analytically determines the layer rates and the corresponding partitioning of the receivers. Our simulation results show the effectiveness of our proposed solution in realistic scenarios.     

Airtime Fairness for IEEE 802.11 Multirate Networks

Under a multirate network scenario, the IEEE 802.11 DCF MAC fails to provide airtime fairness for all competing stations since the protocol is designed for ensuring max-min throughput fairness. As such, the maximum achievable throughput by any station gets bounded by the slowest transmitting peer. In this paper, we present an analytical model to study the delay and throughput characteristics of such networks so that the rate anomaly problem of IEEE DCF multirate networks could be mitigated. We call our proposal time fair CSMA (TFCSMA) which utilizes an interesting baseline property for estimating a target throughput for each competing station so that its minimum contention window could be adjusted in a distributed manner. As opposed to the previous work in this area, TFCSMA is ideally suited for practical scenarios where stations frequently adapt their data rates to changing channel conditions. In addition, TFCSMA also accounts for packet errors due to the time varying properties of the wireless channel. We thoroughly compare the performance of our proposed protocol with IEEE 802.11 and other existing protocols under different network scenarios and traffic conditions. Our comprehensive simulations validate the efficacy of our method toward providing high throughput and time fair channel allocation.     

Congestion control for fair resource allocation in networks with multicast flows

We consider the problem of congestion control in networks which support both multirate multicast sessions and unicast sessions. We present a decentralized algorithm which enables the different rate-adaptive receivers in different multicast sessions to adjust their rates to satisfy some fairness criterion. A one-bit ECN marking strategy to be used at the nodes is also proposed. The congestion-control mechanism does not require any per-flow state information for unicast flows at the nodes. At junctions nodes of each multicast tree, some state information about the rates along the branches at the node may be required. The congestion-control mechanism takes into account the diverse user requirements when different receivers within a multicast session have different utility functions, but does not require the network to have any knowledge about the receiver utility functions.     

FLID-DL: congestion control for layered multicast

We describe fair layered increase/decrease with dynamic layering (FLID-DL): a new multirate congestion control algorithm for layered multicast sessions. FLID-DL generalizes the receiver-driven layered congestion control protocol (RLC) introduced by Vicisano et al. (Proc. IEEE INFOCOM, San Francisco, CA, , p.996-1003, Mar. 1998)ameliorating the problems associated with large Internet group management protocol (IGMP) leave latencies and abrupt rate increases. Like RLC, FLID-DL, is a scalable, receiver-driven congestion control mechanism in which receivers add layers at sender-initiated synchronization points and leave layers when they experience congestion. FLID-DL congestion control coexists with transmission control protocol (TCP) flows as well as other FLID-DL sessions and supports general rates on the different multicast layers. We demonstrate via simulations that our congestion control scheme exhibits better fairness properties and provides better throughput than previous methods. A key contribution that enables FLID-DL and may be useful elsewhere is dynamic layering (DL), which mitigates the negative impact of long IGMP leave latencies and eliminates the need for probe intervals present in RLC. We use DL to respond to congestion much faster than IGMP leave operations, which have proven to be a bottleneck in practice for prior work.     

Existence and uniqueness of fair rate allocations in lossy wireless networks

To extend established concepts of fair resource allocation in wired networks to wireless networks, wired model assumptions must be adapted to be relevant for wireless networks as for example, in wireless networks losses due to environmental conditions may occur even in the absence of queueing congestion. Thus fundamental questions of the existence and uniqueness of fair rate allocations must be reconsidered. We treat wireless networks characterized by lossy channels, spatial channel reuse, multiple routes and multiple frequencies. We establish the existence and uniqueness of utility fair and max-min fair solutions and that, as loss rates decrease, fair allocations converge to the loss-less ones.     

Fairness and Dynamic Flow Control in Both Unicast and Multicast Architecture Networks

With the development of multicast service in the Internet, much attention has been drawn to multicast congestion control and analysis. Multicast traffic poses new challenges to the design of Internet congestion control protocols and system stability analysis. The rate control problem of feedback-based sessions on the coexistence of both unicast and multirate multicast traffic architecture networks is focused upon in this paper. First, a fairness problem is discussed in detail, and a reasonable consumption strategy is proposed. In the reasonable consumption strategy, scaling functions are adaptively adjusted based on a relationship between the session rates. Second, contraposing the case that available link capacities are changing with time for these feedback-based unicast and multicast sessions, stability analysis of a closed-loop rate control system under the modified rate mechanism is made based on Lyapunov stable theory. Finally, the simulations illustrate the effectiveness and goodness of the reasonable consumption strategy     

Fair Bandwidth Allocation in Optical Burst Switching Networks

Optical burst switching (OBS) is a promising switching technology for next-generation Internet backbone networks. One of the design challenges is how to provide fair bandwidth allocation in OBS networks; the schemes proposed for general store-and-forward IP switching networks can not be used because of the non-buffering and un-fully utilized bandwidth characteristics of OBS networks. We propose a rate fairness preemption (RFP) scheme to achieve approximately weighted max-min fair bandwidth allocation in OBS networks. We present an analysis of the burst loss probability in RFP-based OBS networks. The analysis and simulation results show that the RFP scheme provides fair bandwidth allocation in OBS networks.      

Price-based max-min fair rate allocation in wireless multi-hop networks

The interaction between links in wireless multihop networks introduces extra constraints on the combinations of achievable flow rates. Algorithms have been proposed to achieve max-min fairness under these additional constraints. This letter provides a simple price-based max-min fair rate allocation scheme, building on a utility maximization scheme recently proposed for such networks.     

Achieving inter-session fairness for layered video multicast

The Internet is increasingly used to deliver multimedia services. Since there are heterogeneous receivers and changing network conditions, it has been proposed to use adaptive rate control techniques such as layered video multicast to adjust the video traffic according to the available Internet resources. A problem of layered video multicast is that it is unable to provide fair bandwidth sharing between competing video sessions. We propose two schemes, layered video multicast with congestion sensitivity and adaptive join-timer (LVMCA) and layered video multicast with priority dropping (LVMPD), to achieve inter-session fairness for layered video multicast. Receiver-driven layered multicast (RLM), layer-based congestion sensitivity, LVMCA, and LVMPD are simulated and compared. Results show both proposed schemes, especially LVMPD, are fairer and have shorter convergence time than the other two schemes.     

Application-Oriented Flow Control: Fundamentals, Algorithms and Fairness

This paper is concerned with flow control and resource allocation problems in computer networks in which real-time applications may have hard quality of service (QoS) requirements. Recent optimal flow control approaches are unable to deal with these problems since QoS utility functions generally do not satisfy the strict concavity condition in real-time applications. For elastic traffic, we show that bandwidth allocations using the existing optimal flow control strategy can be quite unfair. If we consider different QoS requirements among network users, it may be undesirable to allocate bandwidth simply according to the traditional max-min fairness or proportional fairness. Instead, a network should have the ability to allocate bandwidth resources to various users, addressing their real utility requirements. For these reasons, this paper proposes a new distributed flow control algorithm for multiservice networks, where the application's utility is only assumed to be continuously increasing over the available bandwidth. In this, we show that the algorithm converges, and that at convergence, the utility achieved by each application is well balanced in a proportionally (or max-min) fair manner     

Computing Optimal Max-Min Fair Resource Allocation for Elastic Flows

In this paper, we consider the max-min fair resource allocation problem as applied to elastic flows. We are interested in computing the optimal max-min fair rate allocation. The proposed approach is a linear programming based one and allows the computation of optimal routing paths with regard to max-min fairness, in stable and known traffic conditions. We consider non-bounded access rates, but we show how the proposed approach can handle the case of upper-bounded access rates. A proof of optimality and some computational results are also presented     

Adaptive Fair Subcarrier/Rate Allocation in Multirate OFDMA Networks: Radio Link Level Queuing Performance Analysis

This paper presents a semi-analytical methodology for radio link level performance analysis in a multirate "orthogonal frequency-division multiple-access" (OFDMA) network with adaptive fair rate allocation. Multirate transmission is assumed to be achieved through adaptive modulation, and fair rate allocation is based on the principle of generalized processor sharing to allocate the subcarriers adaptively among the users. The fair rate allocation problem is formulated as an optimization problem with the objective of maximizing system throughput while maintaining fairness (in terms of transmission rate) among the users. The "optimal" fair rate allocation is obtained by using the "Hungarian method." A heuristic-based approach, namely the "iterative approach," that is more implementation friendly is also presented. The throughput performance of the iterative fair rate allocation is observed to be as good as that of optimal fair rate allocation and is better than that of the static subcarrier allocation scheme. Also, the iterative fair allocation provides better fairness compared to that for each of the optimal and the static subcarrier allocation schemes. To this end, a queuing model is formulated to analyze radio link level performance measures such as packet dropping probability and packet transmission delay under the above rate allocation schemes. In this formulation, packet arrivals are modeled by the discrete Markov modulated Poisson process, which is flexible to model different types of traffic arrival patterns. The proposed framework for radio link level performance analysis of multirate OFDMA networks is validated by extensive simulations. Also, examples on the application of the proposed model for connection admission control and quality-of-service provisioning are illustrated     

Is max-min fairness achievable in the presence of insubordinateusers?

Enforcement of max-min fairness encourages end users to implement adaptive end-to-end flow control. Unfortunately, there can be insubordinate users who ignore congestion and cause performance degradation to others. The commonly used max-min fairness definition that treats insubordinate users fairly causes inefficiency. We demonstrate that a strict priority regime can protect the cooperative users so that they enjoy fair and efficient service. We also demonstrate that this cannot be achieved by weighted class fairness     

A low-state packet marking framework for approximate fair bandwidth allocation

Misbehaving, non-congestion-reactive traffic is on the rise in the Internet. One way to control misbehaving traffic is to enforce local fairness among flows. Locally fair policies, such as fair-queueing and other fair AQM schemes, are inadequate to simultaneously control misbehaving traffic and provide high network utilization. We thus need to enforce globally fair bandwidth allocations. However, such schemes have typically been stateful and complex to implement and deploy. In this letter, we present a low state, lightweight scheme based on stateless fair packet marking at network edges followed by RIO queueing at core nodes, to control misbehaving flows with more efficient utilization of network bandwidth. Additionally, with low-state feedback from bottleneck routers, we show that, in practice, we can approximate global max-min fairness within an island of routers. We show, using simulations, that we can indeed control misbehaving flows and provide more globally fair bandwidth allocation.     

Session-aware popularity-based resource allocation for assureddifferentiated services

Differentiated services networks are fair in the way that different types of traffic can be associated to different network services, and so to different quality levels. However, fairness among flows sharing the same service, may, not be provided. Our goal is to study fairness between scalable multimedia sessions for assured DS services in a multicast network environment. To achieve this goal, we present a fairness mechanism called session-aware popularity-based resource allocation (SAPRA), which allocates resources to scalable. sessions based on their number of receivers. Simulation results in a scalable and multireceiver scenario show that SAPRA maximizes the utilization, of bandwidth and the number of receivers with high-quality reception     

Fairness and Load Balancing in Wireless LANs Using Association Control

The traffic load of wireless LANs is often unevenly distributed among the access points (APs), which results in unfair bandwidth allocation among users. We argue that the load imbalance and consequent unfair bandwidth allocation can be greatly reduced by intelligent association control. In this paper, we present an efficient solution to determine the user-AP associations for max-min fair bandwidth allocation. We show the strong correlation between fairness and load balancing, which enables us to use load balancing techniques for obtaining optimal max-min fair bandwidth allocation. As this problem is NP-hard, we devise algorithms that achieve constant-factor approximation. In our algorithms, we first compute a fractional association solution, in which users can be associated with multiple APs simultaneously. This solution guarantees the fairest bandwidth allocation in terms of max-min fairness. Then, by utilizing a rounding method, we obtain the integral solution from the fractional solution. We also consider time fairness and present a polynomial-time algorithm for optimal integral solution. We further extend our schemes for the on-line case where users may join and leave dynamically. Our simulations demonstrate that the proposed algorithms achieve close to optimal load balancing (i.e., max-min fairness) and they outperform commonly used heuristics.     

基于网络控制的分层多点播送速率控制机制研究

本文在视频分层编码及分层传输协议的基础上，将基于网络控制与接收端控制机制相结合，提出一种新的分层多点播送速率控制机制。文中给出了该机制的拥塞检测、流行度权衡和数据层增加和丢弃算法。实验结果表明，该速率控制机制通史对拥塞做也快速响应，并在较好利用宽带的基础上保证高流行度的会话流具有较好的服务质量。