Impact of required storage space on storage policy performance in a unit-load warehouse

The performance of a storage policy in a warehouse is usually evaluated on the basis of the average one-way travel distance/time needed to store/retrieve a load. Dividing the storage space into zones based on item turnover frequency can reduce the travel distance. However, for a given number of stored items, a larger number of storage zones also requires more storage space, because of reduced space sharing between the items, which increases travel time. This study considers the required space consumption by storage zoning in comparing the performance of random, full turnover-based and class-based storage policies for a unit-load warehouse operated by a forklift in single-command mode. A generalised travel distance model that considers the required space consumption is developed to compare the performance of these policies. Results show that the one-way travel distance of a random policy decreases with the increase in skewness of the demand curve. By considering the required space consumption, a class-based storage policy performs generally better than a full turnover-based policy. In addition, the optimal warehouse shape factor (ratio of warehouse width to depth) appears to decrease with the skewness of the demand curve. Warehouse managers are advised to adopt a wide-shallow warehouse layout when the item demands are approximately equal, whereas a narrow-deep layout is preferred when the demand curves are steep.     

Designing an optimal turnover-based storage rack for a 3D compact automated storage and retrieval system

Compact, multi-deep (3D) automated storage and retrieval systems (AS/RS) are becoming increasingly popular for storing products. We study such a system where a storage and retrieval (S/R) machine takes care of movements in the horizontal and vertical directions of the rack, and an orthogonal conveying mechanism takes care of the depth movement. An important question is how to layout such systems under different storage policies to minimize the expected cycle time. We derive the expected single-command cycle time under the full-turnover-based storage policy and propose a model to determine the optimal rack dimensions by minimizing this cycle time. We simplify the model, and analytically determine optimal rack dimensions for any given rack capacity and ABC curve skewness. A significant cycle time reduction can be obtained compared with the random storage policy. We illustrate the findings of the study by applying them in a practical example.     

Design and storage cycle time analysis for the automated storage system with a conveyor and a rotary rack

In this paper, we analyse the performance of an automated Work-In-Process (WIP) storage system consisting of a conveyor and a rotary rack. The stability condition and the expected storage cycle time are derived to analyse the performance of the WIP storage system. As part of the storage cycle time analysis, the derived expected waiting times at the conveyor and the rotary rack are important performance measures that can be used for buffer-sizing purpose in such systems. Given the fixed storage space of the rotary rack, we also develop a heuristic approach to determine the near optimum ‘shape’ of the rotary rack so that the expected storage cycle time is minimized. Numerical results are presented to examine the storage cycle time model and the proposed shape design. The analytical model introduces a simple approach over simulation with acceptable accuracy; it is useful when designing such WIP storage systems. Moreover, it can be expanded to model more complex systems. The derived model also provides insightful information on the design parameters that a typical simulation tool can hardly provide.     

Travel time models for double-deep automated storage and retrieval systems

In this paper new analytical travel time models for the computation of cycle times for unit-load double-deep automated storage and retrieval systems (in continuation double-deep AS/RS) are presented. The proposed models consider the real operating characteristics of the storage and retrieval machine and the condition of rearranging blocking loads to the nearest free storage location during the retrieval process. With the assumption of the uniform distributed storage rack positions and the probability theory, the expressions of the single and modified dual command cycle have been determined. The proposed models enable the calculation of the mean cycle time for single and dual command cycles, from which the performance of the double-deep AS/RS can be evaluated. A simulation model of the selected double-deep AS/RS has been developed to compare the performances of the proposed analytical travel time models. The numerical analyses show that with regard to the examined type of double-deep AS/RS with a different fill-grade factor, the results of the proposed analytical travel time models correlate with the results of simulation models of double-deep AS/RS.     

Expected travel time and optimal boundary formulas for a two-class-based automated storage/retrieval system

Our paper studies a two-class-based rectangular-in-time automated storage/ retrieval system (AS/RS). We present explicit formulas for the optima! boundary of the two storage areas as well as for the expected single command cycle time for an optimally designed rack. In the basic model each crane handles a single aisle. These formulas provide the designer with a full picture of the quantitative effects of the various factors (i.e., access frequencies of the two storage areas, and dimensions of the rack) on the optimal boundary of the two storage areas and the achievable cycle lime in the warehouse. We also develop expected travel time formulas for the dual command AS/RS with two-class-based storage policies and obtain the optimal boundary with a one-dimensional search procedure. Similar developments (i.e., expected travel time formulas and optimal boundary search procedures) are discussed for AS/RS with a single command policy but with each crane handling multiple aisles.     

Interleaving models for the analysis of twin shuttle automated storage and retrieval systems

A system of state equations is formulated for describing the dynamic behaviour of the queue of storage and retrieval transactions in a storage aisle served by twin shuttle storage and retrieval (S/R) machines. Using estimates of order picking cycle times in conjunction with storage and retrieval transaction demand levels, an estimate of the probability distribution of storage queue states is derived for a given storage aisle. System performance measures under an opportunistic interleaving discipline including S/R machine utilization, transaction queue lengths, average cycle times and expected transaction waiting times are approximated using the state probability distribution. The modelling tools are demonstrated using sample problems where the performance of twin versus single shuttle systems is contrasted for alternative combinations of storage and retrieval machine travel speeds, storage rack configurations, and transactions demand scenarios.     

Optimal storage rack design for a multi-deep compact AS/RS considering the acceleration/deceleration of the storage and retrieval machine

This paper explores the optimal storage rack design for a multi-deep compact Automated Storage and Retrieval System (AS/RS) considering the acceleration and deceleration of storage and retrieval (S/R) machine. The expected travel time under the single-command cycle and dual-command cycle for a random storage strategy is derived. Based on the travel time, the general models we propose calculate the optimal ratio between three dimensions that minimises the travel time under different speed profile scenarios. From the result, it is proven that the optimal storage rack design model in the constant speed situation can be treated as a special case of the model considering the acceleration and deceleration of S/R machine. Finally, this study investigates the effect of speed profile of S/R machine and fixing dimensions by various numerical experiments.     

Optimal routing in an automated storage/retrieval system with dedicated storage

We address the sequencing of requests in an automated storage/retrieval system with dedicated storage. We consider the block sequencing approach, where a set of storage and retrieval requests is given beforehand and no new requests come in during operation. The objective for this static problem is to find a route of minimal total travel time in which all storage and retrieval requests may be performed. The problem of sequencing a list of retrievals is equivalent to the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP), and thus NP-hard in general. We show that the special case of sequencing under the dedicated storage policy can be solved in polynomial time. The results apply to systems with arbitrary positions of the input and output stations. Tlus generalizes the models in the literature, where only combined input/output stations are considered. Furthermore we identify a single command area in the rack. At the end we evaluate the model against heuristic procedures.     

A bi-directional flow-rack automated storage and retrieval system for unit-load warehouses

Flow-rack is a multi-deep rack containing multi-row and multi-column slope bins. Traditionally, bins slope in the same direction in a flow-rack to make unit-loads slide from the storage face to the retrieval face driven by gravity, which cause unit-loads are stored to the storage face and retrieved from the retrieval face. In this paper, a bi-directional flow-rack (BFR) is designed, in which bins in adjacent columns slope to opposite directions. In each side of a BFR, unit-loads are stored in half of the bins and retrieved from the other half. Therefore, dual-command (DC) operations could be simultaneously performed on both faces and blocking unit-loads are re-stored to available bins on the same face directly. We develop a travel time model for BFR systems, which provides the throughput baseline for different configurations of BFR. A DC operation generation method is introduced for BFR systems. Simulation experiments are conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of the BFR travel time model, to compare the throughput performance between BFR and SFR systems and to evaluate the performance of the proposed DC operation generation method.     

The impact on rack configuration on the speed profile of the storage and retrieval machine

The travel-time models of automated storage/retrieval machines, proposed by Chang, Wen and Lin (IIE Transactions, 27 (1), 108-111(1995)), which consider the speed profiles in real world applications, have been extended in this paper to investigate the impact on the rack configuration. The results demonstrate that the optimal rack configuration of the single-command cycle is square-in-time whereas the dual-command cycle may not be. Furthermore, the travel times for both single- and dual-command cycles are quite insensitive to the deviation in the length of the rack configuration.     

Back-of-the-envelope miniload throughput bounds and approximations

We derive simple formulas bounding and approximating the throughput of an end-of-aisle miniload system with exponentially distributed pick times and either uniform or turnover-based storage. For typical configurations, the worst-case relative error for the bounds is less than 4%. We use our bounds to show that, for all practical purposes, regardless of the configuration, the picker utilization determines the storage/retrieval machine utilization, and vice versa. Thus, a system designer cannot hope to independently achieve separate goals for the utilization rates.     

Travel-time models and fill-grade factor analysis for double-deep multi-aisle AS/RSs

Double-deep multi-aisle automated storage/retrieval systems are increasingly applied for storing and retrieving unit loads, with advantages of increased space utilisation, reduced number of aisles and improved efficiency of storage rack (S/R) machines. In such systems, the retrieval process may consist of the rearrangement of blocking loads, based on the assumptions of uniformly distributed storage locations and random storage policy. We formulate analytical travel-time models of both single- and dual-command cycles under three rearrangement rules. We validate the analytical travel-time models by simulation and conduct numerical experiments to analyse the effect of the number of aisles an S/R machine serves, the fill-grade factor and the command cycles on the expected travel time of the S/R machine. The results show that the expected travel time of the S/R machine is increasing with the increase in the number of aisles an S/R machine serves and the increase in the fill-grade factor, and dual command cycle outperforms single-command cycle in terms of cycle time. To deal with the trade-off between the storage space cost and the operational cost of the S/R machine, we develop a decision model for finding an optimal fill-grade factor to minimise the total cost. We find the condition when an optimal fill-grade factor exists and show how to calculate it. Based on the decision model, we compare the performance of double-deep multi-aisle automated storage/retrieval system (AS/RSs) and single-deep single-aisle AS/RSs. The results show that double-deep multi-aisle AS/RSs outperform single-deep single-aisle AS/RSs in terms of total cost, although double-deep multi-aisle AS/RSs need more storage locations.     

Rack shape and energy efficient operations in automated storage and retrieval systems

Energy efficiency has become a primary goal to be pursued for sustainable logistics. In automated storage and retrieval systems this leads to revise the traditional control policies aimed at picking time minimisation and to pay more attention to rack configuration, which has been not a research concern from the time-based perspective. Proper models for energy calculation should be developed by introducing new factors neglected in time analysis, such as the weight of unit loads and the differentiation of shifts along the horizontal and vertical axis as regard energy requirements, due to different contribution of gravity, inertia and friction. In this study, a classification of racks based on system height is proposed in order to select the proper crane specifications needed to compute the torque to be overcome by motors to serve a given location within a rack. An overall optimisation model based on Constraint Programming hybridised with Large Neighborhood Search is developed, allowing the joint application of the best control policies for storage assignment and sequencing both for time and energy-based optimisation, as well as the introduction of multiple weight unit loads and energy recovery. Simulations analysis is performed in order to assess the impact of the rack shape on energy saving. Results show how, regardless the demand curve and the optimisation objective, the best performances in terms of energy efficiency are reached by the intermediate height rack shapes, while the lower ones outperform when considering travel time performance.     

A heuristic travel time model for random storage systems using closest open location load dispatching

A heuristic method is proposed for estimating travel times in unit load random storage systems where incoming loads are dispatched to the closest available storage positions. A queuing model representation is used where servers correspond to storage positions and the service rate is based on the turnover distribution of stored loads. The resultant state distribution is applied to approximate storage position occupancy probabilities useful for generating storage and retrieval travel time estimates. Computational results suggest that the heuristic procedure yields smaller errors in random storage travel time estimates than alternative models.     

Experimental investigation of shared storage assignment policies in automated storage/retrieval systems

In this study, two shared storage assignment policies are compared in an Automated Storage/Retrieval System (AS/RS) by using computer simulation. The AS/RS is assumed to operate under a continuous review, order quantity, reorder point inventory policy. The average travel time of the AS/R machine for storing and retrieving products is used as the main performance measure. Sensitivity of the system to product variety, inventory replenishment lead time, and demand rate is investigated, as well as the effects of the inventory policy and the product classification technique used. Our main conclusion is that the turnover-based policy, in general, outperforms the duration of stay-based policy. However, the' difference between the performance of the two policies becomes insignificant under certain conditions.     

Dynamic Operational Policies in an Automated Warehouse

In this paper we consider the optimal relocation of pallets with a high expectancy of retrieval within each storage rack of an automated warehouse to meet the fluctuating, short-term throughput requirements imposed on the automated storage-retrieval machines. The prepositioning of these pallets closer to the input/output point of each rack during off-peak periods will reduce the expected travel time for the storage/retrieval machines during future peak periods of the planning horizon.

As the model has been abstracted from an actual operating environment, we first describe the environment in which the problem has been posed. We then exploit the special structure of the problem to develop conditions that an optimal relocation policy should satisfy. Based on these optimality conditions, we develop a very efficient optimal relocation algorithm. Finally, we present the performance of several relocation policies in the warehouse studied.     

Optimal storage rack design for a 3-dimensional compact AS/RS

In this paper, we consider a newly designed compact three-dimensional automated storage and retrieval system (AS/RS). The system consists of an automated crane taking care of the pallets' movements in the horizontal and vertical direction. A gravity or powered conveying mechanism takes care of the pallets’ depth movement in the rack. Our research objective is to analyze the system performance and optimally dimension the system. For single-command cycles, the crane's expected retrieval travel time is the same for gravity and powered conveyors; we give a closed-form expression. From the expected travel time, we calculate the optimal ratio between three dimensions that minimizes the travel time for a random storage strategy. In addition, we derive an approximate travel time expression for dual command cycles for the system with powered and gravity conveyors, respectively, and use it to optimize the system dimensions. Finally, we illustrate the findings of the study by a practical example.     

Evaluating order throughput time with variable time window batching

Given increased pressure to provide short delivery times, minimising customer order throughput time is a very important objective in warehousing operations. There are many factors that may affect the performance of an order picking system, such as layout of the warehouse, the storage strategy, the routing policy, the zoning method and the batching policy. In this study, we propose a simple travel time model and analyse the effect of order batching on the expected customer order throughput time with variable time window batching. In addition, we discussed the impact of some parameters on the batch size and the expected customer order throughput time. In the practice of Wuhan Dong Hon Logistics co. Ltd, the storage rack in the warehouse has two levels: the low storage level and the high storage level. These two levels are visited by pickers and forklifts, respectively. The classification improves the performance of order picking. In this study, we build the model based on this practice.     

Simulation study of an automated storage/retrieval system

In this paper we present a simulation study of an automated storage/retrieval system and examine a wide variety of control policies. We compare several storage location assignment policies. For the class-based storage policy, we apply a recent algorithm that enables us to evaluate the trade-off between storage space requirements and travel times. We also study a new storage location policy which combines low storage space requirements with short mean travel times. Furthermore, we study the sequencing of storage and retrieval requests whereby we focus on the trade-off between efficient travel of the S/R machines and response time performance.     

The impact of acceleration/deceleration on travel-time models in class-based automated S/R systems

The travel time models of Automated Storage and Retrieval systems (AS/RS) machines under randomized storage proposed by Chang et al. (IIE Transactions, 27(1), 108–111, 1995), which consider the speed profiles in real-world applications, are extended in this paper. In the present study, travel time models are proposed that consider various travel speeds with known acceleration and deceleration rates. Compact forms of expected travel times under the class-based storage assignment and full-turnover-based storage assignment have been determined. The results show that both the proposed exponential travel time model and the adjusted exponential model perform satisfactorily and could be useful tools for designing an AS/RS in real-world applications.