Spectral methods to estimate local multiaxial fatigue failure for structures undergoing random vibrations

This paper proposes computationally efficient frequency domain formulations for two well-known multiaxial fatigue failure criteria, namely Matake's critical plane criterion and Crossland's criterion. For that purpose, it is shown how fatigue-related variables involved in both criteria can be estimated from the power spectral density matrix of the local stress vector. The finite element model of an example structure is then used to illustrate the application of the proposed frequency domain approaches. It is observed that both frequency domain formulations produce consistent results when compared with those obtained in the time domain from Monte-Carlo simulations of local stress vectors while offering tremendous computer savings. A frequency domain tool indicating whether the principal stress directions do rotate with time or not during the loading at a given location in the structure is also presented.     

A multiaxial fatigue criterion for random loading

ABSTRACT A multiaxial fatigue criterion for random loading is proposed. Firstly, the orientation of the critical plane, where fatigue life estimation is carried out, is determined from the weighted mean position of the principal stress directions. Then, the scalar value of the normal stress vector N (t) perpendicular to the critical plane is taken as the cycle counting variable since the direction of such a vector is fixed with respect to time (conversely to the time‐varying direction of the shear stress vector C (t)), and a nonlinear combination of normal and shear stress components acting on the critical plane is used to define an equivalent stress amplitude. Finally, a damage accumulation model is employed to process such an equivalent stress amplitude and to determine fatigue endurance. This criterion is herein applied to some relevant random fatigue tests (proportional bending and torsion).     

A non-local theory applied to high cycle multiaxial fatigue

ABSTRACT The stress gradient effect on the fatigue limit is an important factor which has to be taken into account for an efficient transfer of fatigue data from laboratory tests to design of industrial components. A short review of some multiaxial high cycle fatigue criteria considering this effect is presented. On the basis of the two local mesoscopic approaches of Papadopoulos, two new non‐local high cycle multiaxial fatigue criteria are developed. These proposals are based on the concept of volume influencing fatigue crack initiation. Their predictions are compared with experimental multiaxial fatigue data on four materials (a mild steel, two high strength steels and a spheroidal graphite cast iron). The accuracy of the two local Papadopoulos criteria and of the non‐local proposals are compared and discussed, together with the physical interpretation of the threshold defining the volume influencing fatigue crack initiation.     

A notch critical plane approach of multiaxial fatigue life prediction for metallic notched specimens

An approach based on the local stress response is proposed to locate the fatigue critical point for metallic blunt notched specimens under multiaxial fatigue loading. According to the stress analysis, both stress gradient and gradient of loading nonproportionality exist at notch root. The plane in the vicinity of the notch that passes through the fatigue critical point and experiences the maximum shear stress amplitude is defined as the critical plane for notch specimens (CPN). Furthermore, the Susmel's fatigue damage parameter is modified to assess fatigue life of notched components by combining CPN and the theory of critical distance (TCD). The multiaxial fatigue test of the thin‐walled round tube specimens made of Ni‐base alloy GH4169 is carried out to verify the above approaches. In addition, test data of two kinds of materials are collected. The results show that the maximum absolute error of the fatigue critical point is 9.6° and the majority of the predicted life falls within the three‐time scatter band.     

Strain-based multiaxial fatigue damage modelling

A new multiaxial fatigue damage model named characteristic plane approach is proposed in this paper, in which the strain components are used to correlate with the fatigue damage. The characteristic plane is defined as a material plane on which the complex three‐dimensional (3D) fatigue problem can be approximated using the plane strain components. Compared with most available critical plane‐based models for multiaxial fatigue problem, the physical basis of the characteristic plane does not rely on the observations of the fatigue crack in the proposed model. The cracking information is not required for multiaxial fatigue analysis, and the proposed model can automatically adapt for different failure modes, such as shear or tensile‐dominated failure. Mean stress effect is also included in the proposed model by a correction factor. The life predictions of the proposed fatigue damage model under constant amplitude loading are compared with a wide range of metal fatigue results in the literature.     

The use of multiaxial fatigue models to predict fretting fatigue life of components subjected to different contact stress fields

This work describes the application of multiaxial fatigue criteria based on critical plane and mesoscopic (Dang Van, 1973, Sciences et Techniques de lÁrmement, 47 , 647—722) approaches to predict the fatigue initiation life of fretted components. To validate the analysis, several tests under closely controlled laboratory conditions are carried out in a Ti‐6Al‐4V alloy. These classical Hertzian tests reveal a size effect where fretting fatigue lives vary with contact size. Experimentally available data for fretting fatigue of an Al‐4Cu alloy are also used to assess the models. Neither the critical plane models nor the mesoscopic criterion considered can account for the effects of different contact stress fields on the initiation life, if the calculation is based only on highly stressed points on the surface. It is shown, however, that satisfactory results can be achieved if high values of the fatigue parameters are sustained over a critical volume.     

On the estimation of the material fatigue properties required to perform the multiaxial fatigue assessment

To accurately perform the fatigue assessment of engineering components subjected to in‐service multiaxial fatigue loading, the adopted design criterion must properly be calibrated, the used information usually being the fatigue strength under both pure uniaxial and pure torsional fatigue loading. Because of the complex fatigue response of metallic materials to multiaxial loading paths, the only reliable way to generate the necessary pieces of calibration information is by running appropriate experiments. Unfortunately, because of a lack of both time and resources, very often, structural engineers are requested to perform the multiaxial fatigue assessment by guessing the necessary fatigue properties. In this complex scenario, initially, the available empirical rules suitable for estimating fatigue strength under both pure axial and pure torsional fatigue loading are reviewed in detail. Subsequently, several experimental results taken from the literature and generated by testing metallic materials under a variety of proportional and non‐proportional multiaxial loading paths are used to investigate the way such empirical rules affect the accuracy in estimating fatigue strength, the damage extent being evaluated according to the modified Wöhler curve method. Such a systematic validation exercise allowed us to prove that under proportional loading (with both zero and non‐zero mean stresses), an adequate margin of safety can be reached even when the necessary calibration information is directly estimated from the material ultimate tensile strength. On the contrary, in the presence of non‐proportional loading, the use of the empirical rules reviewed in the present paper can result, under particular circumstances, in a non‐conservative fatigue design.     

Prediction of rubber fatigue life under multiaxial loading

The process of fatigue failure of materials is generally described by two phases: crack initiation and crack propagation. This study concerns the crack initiation in rubbers submitted to a cyclic loading. A parameter based on the strain energy density (SED) and predicting the onset of primary crack and its probable orientation has been identified for such materials according to the investigations of Mars and Fatemi. More precisely, this criterion has been analytically developed in the cases of simple tension, biaxial tension and simple shear loadings by assuming large strains. The results denote the possibility to predict the orientation plane in which the primary crack would be expected to occur in a material. Then, it was implemented in a finite‐elements (FE) program in order to be applied to structures under any kind of the strain states. A good agreement was obtained between FE and analytical results for the usual strain states. Finally, to evaluate lifetime up to crack nucleation, we have achieved a set of experimental fatigue tests using uniaxial tension (UT) and pure shear (PS) test specimens containing a hole in order to localize the crack initiation. The obtained results proved the efficiency of the criterion to describe the fatigue life of rubbers under multiaxial loading.     

A stress-based method to predict lifetime under multiaxial fatigue loadings

This paper extends to low/medium‐cycle fatigue a stress‐based method recently proposed by the same authors for high‐cycle multiaxial fatigue assessments. By considering the plane of maximum shear stress amplitude coincident with the microcrack initiation plane, the method requires the calculation both of the maximum shear stress amplitude and the maximum normal stress relative to the same plane. Multiaxial fatigue life estimates are made by means of bi‐parametric modified Wöhler curves, which take into account the mean stress effect, the influence of the out‐of‐phase angle and the presence of notches by using a generalization to multiaxial fatigue of the fatigue strength reduction factor K_f. Approximately 700 experimental data taken from the literature are used to demonstrate that the method is a useful tool to summarize fatigue strength data of both smooth and notched components, subjected to either in‐phase or out‐of‐phase loads. Finally, a simple practical rule for the calculation of the multiaxial fatigue strength reduction factor is proposed.     

Interaction equations for multiaxial fatigue assessment of welded structures

Multiaxial fatigue data from 233 welded test specimens taken from eight different studies have been evaluated based on three published interaction equations for normal and shear stress. The interaction equations were obtained from SFS 2378, Eurocode 3 and International Institute of Welding (IIW) recommendations. Fatigue classes for normal and shear stress were obtained directly from the design guidance documents. Additionally, mean fatigue strengths were determined by regression analysis of bending only and torsion only data for different specimen types. In some cases, the S–N slopes assumed by the different standards were not appropriate for the test data. Specimens that showed significantly different cracking locations or cracking mode between bending and torsion were not easily correlated by the interaction equations. Interaction equations work best in cases where both the normal stress and the shear stress tend to produce crack initiation and growth in the same location and in the same direction. The use of a damage summation of 0.5 for non‐proportional loading as recommended by IIW was consistent with experimental observations for tube‐to‐plate specimens. Other codes used a damage sum of unity.     

Two methods for predicting the multiaxial fatigue limits of sharp notches

In this paper the problem of the multiaxial fatigue limit estimation of sharply notched components has been addressed using two different methods: a critical distance method and a method involving modified Wöhler curves. These two methods had been previously developed by the authors, but required modification for use in conjunction with finite element stress analysis of sharply notched specimens subjected to multiaxial loadings. Initially, it was demonstrated mathematically that these methods are equivalent in terms of multiaxial stresses near the notch tip. Subsequently, by employing some well‐known uniaxial notch fatigue concepts, some assumptions have been made in order to extend the use of these methods to in‐phase multiaxial notch fatigue situations. Experimental data were obtained from tests conducted on V‐notched specimens subjected to in‐phase mixed Mode I and Mode II loadings. Both methods were successful in giving fatigue limit predictions with an error usually less than 15%. This is interesting because the two methods make quite different assumptions about the nature of fatigue crack growth in the vicinity of the notch.     

A review of multiaxial fatigue criteria for random variable amplitude loads

Nowadays, the estimation of fatigue life under multiaxial random loading is still an extremely complex task. In this paper, a comprehensive review of the multiaxial random fatigue criteria available in the literature is presented. Such a review is mainly devoted to stress‐based criteria for the evaluation of fatigue life in high‐cycle regime. Time and frequency domain approaches are examined. The focus of this paper is related to uniform stress/strain distribution, but also the effect of stress/strain gradient is tangentially addressed. More than 200 references are cited.     

A fatigue criterion for general multiaxial loading

An incremental fatigue damage model is proposed. The model incorporates the critical plane concept in multiaxial fatigue, plastic strain energy and material memory in cyclic plasticity. With an incremental form the model does not require a cycle counting method for variable amplitude loading. The model is designed to consider mean stress and loading sequence effects. Features of the new model are discussed and the determination of material constants is detailed. Verification of the model is achieved by comparing the predictions obtained by using the new model and experimental data of four materials under different loading conditions.     

A frequency domain approach for estimating multiaxial random fatigue life

This paper presents a probabilistic method for fatigue life estimation within the frequency domain for structural elements subjected to multiaxial random loadings. Multivariate Monte Carlo Simulation is used to account for the correlation between the stress components and their different probability of occurrence and, moreover, enables stochastics during damage analysis to be allowed for and, at the same time, uses any suitable, material dependent multiaxial fatigue criterion known from the time domain. Comparison of the evaluated fatigue damage with experimental results from vibration tests on a demonstrator, chosen from common application fields in the automobile industry, shows good correlation.     

A curvilinear integral method for multiaxial fatigue life computing under non-proportional, arbitrary or random stressing

Some popular concepts for reducing three variable stress components σ_x(t), σ_y(t), τ_xy(t) to one equivalent amplitude spectrum, and the use of the linear damage accumulation hypothesis, have been evaluated as not fully correct when these components vary non-proportionally and arbitrarily. A different approach is suggested: computing damage accumulation by means of an integral directly on the non-radial arbitrary path, called the ‘trajectory’, described in the σ_x−σ_y plane when τ_xy(t) = 0, in the σ_x−τ_xy plane when σ_y(t) = 0, or in a special coordinate space where this trajectory is invariant of stress directions x, y. If the trajectory is random, it may be replaced by a statistical two-dimensional density of distribution. The integrand, called the R-function, is derived from various S−N fatigue curves under different determined loadings. Thus the traditional S−N function is replaced by the R-function for direct damage summation with differential analysis, which allows the loading to be arbitrary (non-cyclic, multiaxial and non-proportional). The method works by means of computer programs and is applicable to real structures.     

A computerized procedure for long-life fatigue assessment under complex multiaxial loading

A computerized procedure is presented and evaluated for application examples of long-life fatigue analyses of metallic materials under complex multiaxial loading. The method is based on the stress invariants and uses the minimum circumscribed ellipse approach for evaluating the effective shear stress amplitude under complex multiaxial loading. The applicability of the procedure for handling non-proportional loading is examined through typical examples such as combined normal/shear stresses and combined bi-axial normal stresses with complex stress time histories. The effects of phase shift angles, frequency ratios and waveforms on fatigue endurance were re-analysed and compared with available experimental results from the literature. The comparison shows that the presented procedure based on stress invariants is a potential conservative engineering approach, very suitable for fast fatigue evaluation in the integrated computer aided fatigue design.     

A method for low-cycle fatigue life assessment of metallic materials under multiaxial loading

A new method of fatigue life assessment under multiaxial low-cycle regular and irregular loading is proposed, which is based on the modified Pisarenko-Lebedev criterion, the linear damage accumulation hypothesis, and the nonlinear Manson approach. The results of low-cycle fatigue tests of titanium alloy VT9 under irregular proportional and non-proportional biaxial loading are given. The tests were carried out at three Mises strain levels (0.6, 0.8, and 1.0%) with various combinations of proportional and non-proportional strain paths. All the tests were carried out at room temperature. The proposed method turned out to be effective and to allow for such factors as strain state type, strain path type and loading irregularity. __________ Translated from Problemy Prochnosti, No. 1, pp. 56–59, January–February, 2008.     

A multiaxial fretting fatigue test for spline coupling contact

A novel fretting fatigue experimental methodology is presented for mimicking the salient fretting variables for arbitrary axial locations within a complex spline coupling geometry, under combined torque, axial loading and rotating bending moment. The approach permits the simulation, in a simplified test arrangement, of the superimposed multiaxial fretting conditions between the spline teeth. This is achieved via the combination of a low frequency in-plane cyclic normal clamping load and a higher frequency out-of-plane cyclic fatigue stress. The latter is known from spline fatigue tests to play a critical role, along with torque and axial loads, in fretting fatigue cracking of splines.