Aluminum foam integral armor: a new dimension in armor design

Closed-cell aluminum foam offers a unique combination of properties such as low density, high stiffness, strength and energy absorption that can be tailored through design of the microstructure. During ballistic impact, the foam exhibits significant non-linear deformation and stress wave attenuation. Composite structural armor panels containing closed-cell aluminum foam are impacted with 20-mm fragment-simulating projectiles (FSP). One-dimensional plane strain finite element analysis (FEA) of stress wave propagation is performed to understand the dynamic response and deformation mechanisms. The FEA results correlate well with the experimental observation that aluminum foam can delay and attenuate stress waves. It is identified that the aluminum foam transmits an insignificant amount of stress pulse before complete densification. The ballistic performance of aluminum foam-based composite integral armor (CIA) is compared with the baseline integral armor of equivalent areal-density by impacting panels with 20-mm FSP. A comparative damage study reveals that the aluminum foam armor has finer ceramic fracture and less volumetric delamination of the composite backing plate as compared to the baseline. The aluminum foam armors also showed less dynamic deflection of the backing plate than the baseline. These attributes of the aluminum foam in integral armor system add a new dimension in the design of lightweight armor for the future armored vehicles.     

Degradation of yarns recovered from soft-armor targets subjected to multiple ballistic impacts

Post ballistic impact residual yarn mechanical properties were analyzed from two different as-received shoot packs composed solely of AuTx yarn possessing the 2/2 twill weave structure, one being impacted by 9-mm projectiles and the other by 2-grain projectiles. It was found that yarn mechanical properties from both shoot packs yielded similar results, regardless of yarn orientation, ply location, or penetrator size, which indicates that ballistic damage in the packets is very localized, producing little damage to the neighboring yarns. Mechanical properties of these woven, ballistically impacted, and then extracted yarns were compared to as-received native spooled AuTx yarn yielding a slight reduction in tensile strength, an increase in failure strain, and a reduction in elastic modulus, thereby yielding little variation in yarn toughness.     

A unit cell approach of finite element calculation of ballistic impact damage of 3-D orthogonal woven composite

This paper presents ballistic impact damages of 3-D orthogonal woven composite in finite element analysis (FEA) and experimental. A unit-cell model of the 3-D woven composite was developed to define the material behavior and failure evolution. A user-defined subroutine VUAMT was compiled and connected with commercial available FEA code ABAQUS/Explicit to calculate the ballistic penetration. Ballistic impact tests were conducted to investigate impact damage of 3-D kevlar/glass hybrid woven composite. Residual velocities of conically-cylindrical steel projectiles (Type 56 in China Military Standard) and impact damage of the composite targets after ballistic perforation were compared both in theoretical and experimental. The reasonable agreements between FEA results and experimental results prove the validity of the unit-cell model in ballistic limit prediction of the 3-D woven composite. We believe such an effort could be extended to bulletproof armor design with the 3-D woven composite.     

Effect of interlayer on stress wave propagation in CMC/RHA multi-layered structure

Due to the significance of the propagation of stress wave in composite armor during projectile–target interaction, the characteristics of stress wave propagation in multi-layered composite structure under impact load were investigated by traditional Split Hopkinson Pressure Bar system in this study. The effect of interlayer characteristic on the stress wave propagation was discussed. The results show that the interlayer properties between CMC and RHA steel play an important role in the propagation of wave. Compared to “CMC/RHA” structure without interlayer, the tungsten carbide interlayer can increase stress level in CMC layer remarkably, while silica gel layer has an opposite effect, and epoxy resin adhesive layer has no distinct effect on the propagation of stress wave. The increased compressive stress level in CMC layer is very useful when the CMC layer served as the face plate of a composite armor. During the impact process of the projectile to the armor, the anti-penetration capability of the face plate of the composite armor can be improved when in the compression stress state. In the comparison ballistic testing conducted with 7.62 mm armor piercing projectiles, the protection efficiency of the “CMC/WC/RHA” composite armor is about 36% higher than that of the “CMC/RHA” structure, which is in good correlation with the stress wave measurement results.     

Experimental investigation of the role of frictional yarn pull-out and windowing on the probabilistic impact response of kevlar fabrics

The probabilistic impact responses of single layer greige and scoured plain-weave Kevlar KM2 fabrics are experimentally studied. Single-layer, 101 cm × 101 cm fabric targets are mounted in a novel equilateral octagon (EO) fixture that leaves the principal yarns unclamped. A probabilistic velocity response (PVR) curve, which describes the probability of fabric penetration as a function of projectile impact velocity, is generated through a series of thirty impact tests using a spherical steel projectile impacted at velocities between 69 and 113 m/s. Additional experiments are conducted by impacting targets repeatedly at identical velocities, and comparing the resulting residual velocities of the penetrating projectiles. Fabric penetration in all cases is entirely accommodated by yarn pull-out and windowing, without any principal yarn failure at the impact site. The results indicate that frictional yarn sliding and pull-out are the primary energy dissipating mechanisms during these impact conditions. Controlled yarn pull-out experiments are conducted on the same greige and scoured fabrics to statistically characterize the yarn pull-out loads. Variability in pull-out forces in the greige fabrics are measurably higher than the variability in pull-out forces for the scoured fabrics, which correlates well with variability trends in the PVR and residual velocity ballistic experiments. Additional factors, such as yarn-projectile friction and differences in filament packing efficiency, are hypothesized to also contribute to the observed differences in the greige and scoured fabric impact responses.     

半球形头弹不同角度冲击下编织复合材料板的侵彻特性

利用一级气炮发射半球形头弹冲击2 mm厚的编织复合材料层合板,冲击角度为0°、30°和45°,通过高速相机记录弹靶撞击过程并得到弹体速度数据。利用拟合公式处理试验数据,得到不同冲击角度时的弹道极限值,并和理论模型结果进行对比。分析了冲击角度对靶板弹道极限、能量吸收率和失效模式的影响。结果表明：45°斜冲击时的靶板弹道极限最高,正冲击次之,30°斜冲击最低。相同冲击能量时,45°斜冲击的能量吸收率最高,低能量（<80 J）冲击时,30°斜冲击比正冲击能量吸收率高,高能量（>80 J）时,正冲击更高。正冲击时,靶板正面因剪切失效而形成圆形凹坑,背面因纤维拉伸失效形成菱形鼓包,斜冲击形成椭圆形扩孔,且其面积随冲击角度增加而增加。     

On the comparison of the ballistic performance of 10% zirconia toughened alumina and 95% alumina ceramic target

Ballistic performance of different type of ceramic materials subjected to high velocity impact was investigated in many theoretical, experimental and numerical studies. In this study, a comparison of ballistic performance of 95% alumina ceramic and 10% zirconia toughened alumina (ZTA) ceramic tiles was analyzed theoretically and experimentally. Spherical cavity model based on the concepts of mechanics of compressible porous media of Galanov was used to analyze the relation of target resistance and static mechanical properties. Experimental studies were carried out on the ballistic performance of above two types of ceramic tiles based on the depth of penetration (DOP) method, when subjected to normal impact of tungsten long rod projectiles. Typical damaged targets were presented. The residual depth of penetration on after-effect target was measured in all experiments, and the ballistic efficiency factor of above two types ceramic plates were determined. Both theoretical and experimental results show that the improvement on ballistic resistance was clearly observed by increasing fracture toughness in ZTA ceramics.     

Multi-scale ballistic material modeling of cross-plied compliant composites

The open-literature material properties for fiber and polymeric matrix, unit-cell microstructural characteristics, atomic-level simulations and unit-cell based finite-element analyses are all used to construct a new continuum-type ballistic material model for 0°/90° cross-plied highly-oriented polyethylene fiber-based armor-grade composite laminates. The material model is formulated in such a way that it can be readily implemented into commercial finite-element programs like ANSYS/Autodyn [ANSYS/Autodyn version 11.0, User Documentation, Century Dynamics Inc. a subsidiary of ANSYS Inc. (2007)] and ABAQUS/Explicit [ABAQUS version 6.7, User Documentation, Dessault Systems, 2007] as a User Material Subroutine. Model validation included a series of transient non-linear dynamics simulations of the transverse impact of armor-grade composite laminates with two types of projectiles, which are next compared with their experimental counterparts. This comparison revealed that a reasonably good agreement is obtained between the experimental and the computational analyses with respect to: (a) the composite laminates’ capability, at different areal densities, to defeat the bullets with different impact velocities; (b) post-mortem spatial distribution of damage within the laminates; (c) the temporal evolution of composite armor laminate back-face bulging and delamination; and (d) the existence of three distinct penetration stages (i.e. an initial filament shearing/cutting dominated stage, an intermediate stage characterized by pronounced filament/matrix de-bonding/decohesion and the final stage associated with the extensive back-face delamination and bulging of the armor panel).     

Ballistic impact response of laminated hybrid materials made of 5086-H32 aluminum alloy,epoxy and Kevlar® fabrics impregnated with shear thickening fluid

The ballistic impact behavior of hybrid composite laminates synthesized for armor protection was investigated. The hybrid materials, which consist of layers of aluminum 5086-H32 alloy, Kevlar® 49 fibers impregnated with shear thickening fluid (STF) and epoxy resin were produced in different configurations using hand lay-up technique. The hybrid materials were impacted by projectiles (ammunitions of 150 g power-point) fired from a rifle Remington 7600 caliber 270 Winchester to strike the target at an average impact velocity and impact energy of 871 m/s and 3687 J, respectively. The roles of the various components of the hybrid materials in resisting projectile penetration were evaluated in order to determine their effects on the overall ballistic performance of the hybrid laminates. The effects of hybrid material configuration on energy dissipation during ballistic impacts were investigated in order to determine a configuration with high performance for application as protective armor. The energy dissipation capability of the hybrid composite targets was compared with the initial impact energy of low caliber weapons (according to NATO standards) in order to determinate the protection level achieved by the developed hybrid laminates. Deformation analysis and penetration behavior of the targets were studied in different stages; the initial (on target front faces), intermediate (cross-section), and final stages (target rear layers). The influence of target thickness on the ballistic impact response of the laminates were analyzed. Differences in ballistic behavior were observed for samples containing Kevlar® impregnated with STF and those containing no STF. Finally, mechanisms of failure were investigated using scanning electron microscopic examination of the perforations.     

Ballistic Limit of Single and Layered Aluminium Plates

Abstract: This paper presents an experimental and finite‐element investigation of ballistic limit of thin single and layered aluminium target plates. Blunt‐, ogive‐ and hemispherical‐nosed steel projectiles of 19 mm diameter were impacted on single and layered aluminium target plates of thicknesses 0.5, 0.71, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 2.5 and 3 mm with the help of a pressure gun to obtain the ballistic limit in each case. The ballistic limit of target plate was found to be considerably affected by the projectile nose shape. Thin monolithic target plates as well as layered in‐contact plates offered lowest ballistic resistance against the impact of ogive‐nosed projectiles. Thicker monolithic plates on the other hand, offered lowest resistance against the impact of blunt‐nosed projectiles. The ballistic resistance of the layered targets decreased with increase in the number of layers for constant overall target thickness. Axi‐symmetric numerical simulations were performed with ABAQUS/Explicit to compare the numerical predictions with experiments. 3D numerical simulations were also performed for single plate of 1.0 mm thickness and two layered plate of 0.5 mm thickness impacted by blunt‐, ogive‐ and hemispherical‐nosed projectiles. Good agreement was found between the numerical simulations and experiments. 3D numerical simulations accurately predicted the failure mode of target plates.     

间隙对A3钢薄板抗卵形头弹侵彻性能影响的实验研究

为了分析板间间隙大小对双层板失效模式以及抗侵彻性能的影响,本文利用轻气炮进行了卵形杆弹正撞击单层板和等厚双层板的实验研究,得到了各种结构靶体的初始-剩余速度曲线和弹道极限速度。实验表明,对于卵形弹,单层板的弹道极限高于双层板的弹道极限,包括接触式和间隙式。当总厚度一定时,多层板的弹道极限随分层数目的增加而减小。此外,间隙大小对间隙式双层板的抗侵彻性能影响小,并且随着弹体初始速度的增加而减小。     

Ballistic-performance optimization of a hybrid carbon-nanotube/E-glass reinforced poly-vinyl-ester-epoxy-matrix composite armor

The material model for a multi-walled carbon nanotube (MWCNT) reinforced poly-vinyl-ester-epoxy matrix composite material (carbon nanotube reinforced composite mats, in the following) developed in our recent work (M. Grujicic et al. submitted), has been used in the present work within a transient non-linear dynamics analysis to carry out design optimization of a hybrid polymer-matrix composite armor for the ballistic performance with respect to the impact by a fragment simulating projectile (FSP). The armor is constructed from E-glass continuous-fiber poly-vinyl-ester-epoxy matrix composite laminas interlaced with the carbon nanotube reinforced composite mats. Different designs of the hybrid armor are obtained by varying the location and the thickness of the carbon nanotube reinforced composite mats. The results obtained indicate that at a fixed thickness of the armor, both the position and the thickness of the carbon nanotube reinforced composite mats affect the ballistic performance of the armor. Specifically, it is found that the best performance of the armor is obtained when thicker carbon nanotube reinforced composite mats are placed near the front armor face, the face which is struck by the projectile. The results obtained are rationalized using an analysis of the elastic wave reflection and transmission behavior at the lamina/met and laminate/air interfaces.     

Ballistic resistance of double-layered armor plates

In this paper, the ballistic resistance of double-layered steel shields against projectile impact at the sub-ordnance velocity is evaluated using finite element simulations. Four types of projectiles of different weight and nose shapes are considered, while armor shields consist of two layers of different materials. In a previous study of the same authors, it was shown that a double-layered shield of the same metal was able to improve the ballistic limit by 7.0–25.0% under impact by a flat-nose projectile, compared to a monolithic plate of the same weight. Under impact by a conical-nose projectile, a double-layered shield is almost as capable as a monolithic plate. The present paper extends the analysis to double-layered shields with various metallic material combinations. The study reveals that the best configuration is the upper layer of high ductility and low strength material and the lower layer of low ductility and high strength material. This configuration results in some 25% gain in the ballistic limit under moderate detrimental impact. This research helps clarify the long standing issue of the ballistic resistance of the multi-layered armor configuration.     

A numerical investigation into the influence of fabric construction on ballistic performance

The use of high-performance fibres has made it possible to produce lightweight and strong personal body armour. Parallel to the creation and use of new fibres, fabric construction also plays an essential role for performance improvement. In this research, finite element (FE) models were built up and used to predict the response of woven fabrics with different structural parameters, including fabric structure, thread density of the fabric and yarn linear density. The research confirmed that the plain woven fabric exhibits superior energy absorption over other structures in a ballistic event by absorbing 34% more impact energy than the fabric made from 7-end satin weave. This could be explained that the maximum interlacing points in this fabric which help transmit stress to a larger fabric area, enabling more secondary yarns to be involved for energy dissipation. It was found that fabric energy absorption decreases as fabric is made denser, and this phenomenon becomes more pronounced in a multi-ply ballistic system than in a single-ply system. The research results also indicated that the level of yarn crimp in a woven fabric is an effective parameter in influencing the ballistic performance of the fabrics. A low level of yarn crimp would lead to the increase of the fabric tensile modulus and consequently influencing the propagation of the transverse wave. In addition, it was found that for fabrics with the same level of yarn crimp, low yarn linear density and high fabric tightness were desirable for ballistic performance improvement.     

The influence of projectile hardness on ballistic performance

The ballistic performance of 17 penetrator materials, representing 5 distinct steel alloys treated to various hardnesses along with one tungsten alloy, has been investigated. Residual lengths and velocities, as well as the ballistic limit velocities, were determined experimentally for each of the alloy types for length-to-diameter (L/D) ratio 10 projectiles against finite-thick armor steel targets. The target thickness normalized by the projectile diameter (T/D) was 3.55. For some of the projectile types, a harder target, with the same thickness, was also used. It was found that the ballistic limit velocity decreases significantly when the projectile hardness exceeds that of the target. Numerical simulations are used to investigate some of the observed trends. It is shown that the residual projectile length is sensitive to projectile hardness; the numerical simulations reproduce this experimental observation. However, the observed trend in residual velocity as a function of projectile hardness is not reproduced in the numerical simulations unless a material model is invoked. It is assumed that the plastic work per unit volume is approximately a constant, that is, there is a trade off between strength and ductility. Using this model, the numerical simulations reproduce the experimentally observed trend.     

Effect of Mesoscale and Multiscale Modeling on the Performance of Kevlar Woven Fabric Subjected to Ballistic Impact: A Numerical Study

In this study, an optimal finite element model of Kevlar woven fabric that is more computational efficient compared with existing models was developed to simulate ballistic impact onto fabric. Kevlar woven fabric was modeled to yarn level architecture by using the hybrid elements analysis (HEA), which uses solid elements in modeling the yarns at the impact region and uses shell elements in modeling the yarns away from the impact region. Three HEA configurations were constructed, in which the solid element region was set as about one, two, and three times that of the projectile’s diameter with impact velocities of 30 m/s (non-perforation case) and 200 m/s (perforation case) to determine the optimal ratio between the solid element region and the shell element region. To further reduce computational time and to maintain the necessary accuracy, three multiscale models were presented also. These multiscale models combine the local region with the yarn level architecture by using the HEA approach and the global region with homogenous level architecture. The effect of the varying ratios of the local and global area on the ballistic performance of fabric was discussed. The deformation and damage mechanisms of fabric were analyzed and compared among numerical models. Simulation results indicate that the multiscale model based on HEA accurately reproduces the baseline results and obviously decreases computational time.     

A fracture mechanics approach to the residual strength behavior of ballistically damaged high hardness laminar composite steel

Welded and unwelded specimens of an air-melted laminar composite steel armor were tested for degradation of strength from ballistic impact. Specimens were impacted with cal. 0.30 AP and ball projectiles at various velocities and 0-degree obliquity. During impact, specimens were tensile loaded from 0 psi to the preload that would result in specimen failure at impact. Specimens that did not fail upon impact were pulled to failure to determine residual strength.

Damage due to cal. 0.30 impact maximized at approx. 2.25 in. laterally for ball and 1 in. for AP at a velocity near the ballistic limit. Preload increased the damage slightly. Impacts near the weld produced no detectable degradation of the weld.

Damage near the maximum resulted in residual strengths near 20% of the original σ_M. Fracture mechanics analysis showed that residual strengths could reasonably be predicted by assuming that all damage could be modeled as a center notch through the hard face.     

Behaviour of multiple composite plates subjected to ballistic impact

An experimental and numerical investigation has been carried out to study the behavior of single and multiple laminated panels subjected to ballistic impact. A pressurized air gun is used to shoot the impactor, which can attain sufficient velocity to penetrate all the laminates in a multiple laminated panel. The incidental and residual velocity of the impactor is measured to estimate the energy absorption in the impact process. The commercially available code ABAQUS has been used for the numerical simulation where the impactor has been modeled as a rigid body and the laminates have been modeled with a simple shell element. A user material model based on a continuum damage mechanics concept for failure mechanism of laminated composites has been implemented. Experimental tests showed that the numerical model could satisfactorily predict the energy absorption. Most interestingly, it has clearly demonstrated a feasible phenomenon behind counterintuitive experimental results for the multiple laminated panels.     

Numerical simulation of ceramic composite armor subjected to ballistic impact

Armor systems made of ceramic and composite materials are widely used in ballistic applications to defeat armor piercing (AP) projectiles. Both the designers and users of body armor face interesting choices – how best to balance the competing requirements posed by weight, thickness and cost of the armor package for a particular threat level. A finite element model with a well developed material model is indispensible in understanding the various nuances of projectile–armor interaction and finding effective ways of developing lightweight solutions. In this research we use the explicit finite element analysis and explain how the models are built and the results verified. The Johnson–Holmquist material model in LS-DYNA is used to model the impact phenomenon in ceramic material. A user defined material model is developed to characterize the ductile backing made of ultra high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) material. An ad hoc design optimization is carried out to design a thin, light and cost-effective armor package. Laboratory testing of the prototype package shows that the finite element predictions of damage are excellent though the back face deformations are under predicted.     

Influence of surface coating on ballistic performance of aluminum plates subjected to high velocity impact loads

Ballistic response of single or multi-layered metal armor systems subjected to high velocity impact loads was investigated in many experimental, theoretical and numerical studies. In this study, influences of plasma spray surface coating on high velocity impact resistance of AA 6061 T651 aluminum plates were analyzed experimentally. Two different types of surface coating were applied to plates using plasma spray. Using 9.00 mm Parabellum bullets, ballistic performance of both uncoated and coated plates was tested. After the impact tests, penetration depth including plate bending on the front face and bulging on the rear face of the target plate was measured. The improvement on the ballistic resistance of the coated plates was clearly observed. The increase in non-perforating projectile velocity and the decrease in penetration depth were both experienced.