Shoulder muscle fatigue development in young and older female adults during a repetitive manual task

Age may modify the association between occupational physical demand and muscle loading, and ultimately increase the risk of musculoskeletal disorders. The goal of this study was to investigate age-related differences in shoulder muscle fatigue development during a repetitive manual task. Twenty participants in two age groups completed an 80-minute simulated low-intensity assembly task. Electromyographic (EMG) manifestation of muscle fatigue was observed in the upper trapezius, deltoid and infraspinatus muscles in both age groups, and coincided with an increase in the subjective ratings of perceived exertions. Compared with the younger group, older group showed a more monotonic decrease in EMG power frequency in the upper trapezius and deltoid muscles. However, the age-related difference in EMG amplitude was less consistent. Relative rest time of the upper trapezius muscle in the older group was less than the young group throughout the task. The observed patterns of EMG measures suggest that older participants may have disadvantages in fatigue resistance in the upper trapezius and posterior deltoid muscles during the simulated repetitive manual task.     

Work load and fatigue in repetitive arm elevations

Six females performed continuous series of concentric and eccentric flexions in the shoulder between 0 and 90 degrees with 0 to 3.1 kg weights held in a powergrip. Heart rate (H R), perceived exertion (RPE) and myoelectric activity (EMG) from the descending part of the trapezius muscle, the anterior part of the deltoid muscle, and the biceps brachii were measured during the tasks. The increase of RPE was faster than the increase of HR with work load indicating an increased importance of local factors (i.e. strain on muscles and tendons) with load in the perceived exertion. The local muscular load determined by EMG on the trapezius muscle was closely correlated with the external torque produced in the glenohumeral joint. The time constants of EMG amplitude increase were correlated with work load, endurance time and with slope coefficients of RPE-HR linear regression. Symptoms and complaints 24 hours after the task were often localized to the descending part of the trapezius muscle. It is suggested that exertion of the descending part of the trapezius muscle in tasks involving repetitive shoulder flexion may promote discomfort and complaints referred to the neck.     

Subjective and objective evaluation of shoulder muscle fatigue

In order to relate EMG signs of localized muscle fatigue to subjectively perceived muscle fatigue, a study was undertaken on 20 healthy volunteers exposing their right trapezius muscle by raising the arm to 90° of abduction. Every person performed two contractions: 0 kg hand load during 5 min and 2 kg hand load during 2.5 min. Surface EMG was recorded and analysed with respect to RMS amplitude and mean power frequency (MPF). Subjective muscle fatigue was estimated with a psychophysical rating scale (Borg's CR-10 Scale). At high load level we found a significant correlation between MPF and the CR-scores (r = ? 0.46), but at low load level there was no correlation. At high load level there was a linear decrease of MPF with increasing load dose, but at low load level the MPF did not change, despite significant subjective fatigue. There was a linear rise of the CR-score with increasing load dose, more pronounced at high load level. It was concluded, that at low load levels common in working life, MPF and subjective scores seem to provide different fatigue information. Moreover, the MPF did not seem to work as a valid estimator of muscle fatigue at this low load level. Caution is recommended if it is to be used in static low-load situations.     

Temporal strategy and performance during a fatiguing short-cycle repetitive task

This study investigated temporal changes in movement strategy and performance during fatiguing short-cycle work. Eighteen participants performed six 7-min work blocks with repetitive reaching movements at 0.5 Hz, each followed by a 5.5-min rest break for a total duration of 1 h. Electromyography (EMG) was collected continuously from the upper trapezius muscle, the temporal movement strategy and timing errors were obtained on a cycle-to-cycle basis, and perceived fatigue was rated before and after each work block. Clear signs of fatigue according to subjective ratings and EMG manifestations developed within each work block, as well as during the entire hour. For most participants, timing errors gradually increased, as did the waiting time at the near target. Changes in temporal movement strategy were negatively correlated with changes in the level and variability of EMG, suggesting that an adaptive temporal strategy offset the development of unstable motor solutions in this fatiguing, short-cycle work. PRACTITIONER SUMMARY: Sustained performance of operators is essential to maintain competitiveness. In this study of repetitive work, participants gradually changed their temporal movement strategy, for possibly alleviating the effects of fatigue. This suggests that in order to effectively counteract fatigue and sustain performance, industrial production should allow extensive spatial and temporal flexibility.     

On the assessment of muscle fatigue rate via various EMG frequency spectral parameters

A research study was undertaken to investigate the fatigue process of quadriceps muscle during sustained isometric contraction at several work load levels using root-mean-squared (RMS) voltage and frequency parameters of EMG frequency spectral distribution. Its objective was to evaluate the possibility of using those parameters to indicate muscle fatigue rate. Twelve male subjects participated in an experiment which required them to exert and maintain isometric knee extension forces at 25%, 40%, 55%, and 70% of their maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) force levels. The results showed that both initial mean power frequency (MPF) and median power frequency (MF) (as determined from MPF and MF versus time curves) were not significantly influenced by muscle contraction level (p > 0.1). RMS voltage, MPF, and MF linear slopes, on the other hand, were significantly correlated to muscle contraction level (p < 0.001) which suggested that they could be used to represent muscle fatigue rate. The exponential relationship found in this study showed that quadriceps fatigued at an increasing rate as the work load increased. Further, an improvement in the coefficient of correlation between their linear slopes and muscle work load was found when expressing muscle work load in terms of the ratio of force to body weight. This finding indicated the possibility of using body weight as a basis of determining work load level which could help to improve the quality of quantitative assessment of muscle fatigue.     

Ergonomic evaluation of the effects of forearm conditions and body postures on trapezius muscle activity during smartphone texting

Neck-shoulder and upper back musculoskeletal symptoms in smartphone users have gained increasing attention. We evaluated trapezius muscle activity and fatigue using an objective method (surface electromyography, sEMG), and discomfort using a subjective method (questionnaire), in smartphone users during the performance of different text-entry tasks. Fifteen participants were recruited to perform six text-entry tasks under different forearm conditions (floating and supported) and body postures (sitting, standing, lying, and walking). We collected upper trapezius (UT) and lower trapezius (LT) sEMG data, and recorded muscle discomfort scores after each task. We found that static postures (especially sitting) during smartphone use predisposed to lower muscle activity with higher fatigue level and discomfort scores than dynamic posture; there was a significant main effect of body posture on average sEMG amplitude (aEMG) and discomfort scores of both muscles (all p < 0.05). Moreover, using a smartphone with the forearm supported can reduce muscle activity, fatigue level, and discomfort scores; there was a significant main effect of the forearm condition on aEMG and discomfort scores of both muscles (all p < 0.05). Our study indicates that smartphone use with the forearm floating for a long time in a static posture should be avoided (especially while sitting).     

Low mean level sustained and intermittent grip exertions: Influence of age on fatigue and recovery

The goal of this study was to quantify localised muscle fatigue resulting from low mean levels of exertion in younger (< 40 years) and older (>50 years) adults. Fatigue, elicited in the finger flexor muscles by intermittent (10% mean maximum voluntary contraction (MVC)) and sustained (8% MVC) handgrip exercises, was quantified by a muscle twitch force response before, immediately after and during 3 h following exercise. Despite greater mean loads, recovery time was shorter following intermittent than sustained contractions, which suggests that recovery from fatigue is more sensitive to rest within the work cycle than mean work. The more pronounced effects for younger than older individuals following the sustained exertion indicate that changes in muscle fibre type composition might predispose older individuals to be more resistant to fatigue resulting from sustained contractions of low level. Performing hand exertion tasks requiring low mean force levels contributes to similar long-lasting fatigue effects regardless of gender and age. Intermittent periods of complete rest reduce muscle fatigue. Since fatigue was not perceived during recovery from the tested sustained and intermittent contractions, subjective evaluations may not be a reliable indicator of localised muscle fatigue.     

Muscular loading and subjective ratings of muscular tension by novices when typing with standard and split‐design computer keyboards

The objective of this research project was to compare two different computer keyboard designs with respect to their effect on the extent of muscular loading in the right and left trapezius and extensor muscles during typing. The two computer keyboards used in this study were (1) a classic or standard keyboard, and (2) a split‐design keyboard. Evaluation of muscular loading was done using the electromyography (EMG) technique and subjective ratings of muscular tension. Sixteen women, between 18 and 26 years of age, with similar secretarial experience and limited typing abilities, took voluntary part in the experiment. Each subject used both keyboards for 15 min. The EMG signals recorded during typing sessions were those of the left and right sides of trapezius (m. trapezius pars descendeus) and extensor (m. extensor carpi radialis brevis et longus) muscles. Upon completion of each task, subjects were asked to evaluate perceived levels of muscular tension in the shoulder‐neck area and forearms. The results showed that the split‐design computer keyboard significantly reduces muscular loading of the trapezius muscle and subjective feelings of muscular tension in the shoulder‐neck area.     

Effects of electromyographic and mechanomyographic biofeedback on upper trapezius muscle activity during standardized computer work

The purpose of this laboratory study was to investigate the effects of surface electromyography (EMG)- and mechanomyography (MMG)-based audio and visual biofeedback during computer work. Standardized computer work was performed for 3 min with/without time constraint and biofeedback in a randomized order. Biofeedback was given on the basis of an individual preset threshold value for the right trapezius EMG and MMG signal and a time factor (repetition of events above the threshold). The duration of muscle activity above the preset threshold, the right trapezius EMG and MMG root mean square (RMS) values as well as the work performance in terms of number of completed graph/mouse clicks/errors, the rating of perceived exertion (RPE) and the usefulness of the biofeedback were assessed. The duration of muscle activity above the threshold was significantly lower with MMG compared with EMG as source of biofeedback (p < 0.05). Biofeedback led to a significant decrease in the right trapezius EMG RMS, lower RPE and decreased number of errors and mouse clicks, but also decreased number of completed graphs (p < 0.05). Audio and visual biofeedbacks were as effective. MMG-based biofeedback is a potential reliable alternative to EMG in ergonomics. A lowering of the trapezius muscle activity may contribute to diminish the risk of work related musculoskeletal disorders development.     

Effects of electromyographic and mechanomyographic biofeedback on upper trapezius muscle activity during standardized computer work

The purpose of this laboratory study was to investigate the effects of surface electromyography (EMG)- and mechanomyography (MMG)-based audio and visual biofeedback during computer work. Standardized computer work was performed for 3 min with/without time constraint and biofeedback in a randomized order. Biofeedback was given on the basis of an individual preset threshold value for the right trapezius EMG and MMG signal and a time factor (repetition of events above the threshold). The duration of muscle activity above the preset threshold, the right trapezius EMG and MMG root mean square (RMS) values as well as the work performance in terms of number of completed graph/mouse clicks/errors, the rating of perceived exertion (RPE) and the usefulness of the biofeedback were assessed. The duration of muscle activity above the threshold was significantly lower with MMG compared with EMG as source of biofeedback (p < 0.05). Biofeedback led to a significant decrease in the right trapezius EMG RMS, lower RPE and decreased number of errors and mouse clicks, but also decreased number of completed graphs (p < 0.05). Audio and visual biofeedbacks were as effective. MMG-based biofeedback is a potential reliable alternative to EMG in ergonomics. A lowering of the trapezius muscle activity may contribute to diminish the risk of work related musculoskeletal disorders development.     

Muscle fatigue associated with repetitive arm lifts: effects of height,weight and reach

A simulated assembly-line task was constructed to investigate the metabolic cost and the pattern of muscular fatigue associated with selected arm lifts. Five healthy males lifted lead-filled cylinders five limes per minute in eight 1 hour sessions. In each session, the effect of varying the weight of the cylinders and the horizontal and vertical location or the point to which they were lifted was studied. Muscle fatigue was assessed from a frequency shift and rectified amplitude analysts of surface electromyographic records (EMG) of the deltoid, biceps, brachioradialis and upper trapezius muscles. Metabolic costs of the work were estimated from an analysis of heart rate and oxygen uptake. Additional measures included tests of strength decrement and ratings of perceived fatigue.

The results indicated that the most fatiguing task variable was weight. At the heavier of the two levels, weight significantly increased the EMG amplitude of the deltoid, biceps and brachioradialis muscles. Significant increases in the EMG amplitude of the biceps were also found when the variable of height was adjusted to the higher of two levels. There was a similar effect on the EMG level of the deltoid muscle when reach was at a maximum. Although not as dramatic as the increases in EMG activity, both heart rate and oxygen uptake were significantly increased when the variables of height and weight were at their maximum levels, i.e. eye level and 80% maximum voluntary contraction ( MVC) The results provided a physiological basis for evaluating the effects of three task variables in lifting tasks involving upper extremity muscles     

Reliability of myoelectric trapezius muscle activity in repetitive light work

The aim of this study was to evaluate the reliability of selected electromyographic (EMG) parameters describing the muscle activity in repetitive light work. EMG from the trapezius muscle of twelve female workers were recorded during a 20-min work session, morning and afternoon; Monday, Wednesday, Friday and the following Monday. The estimated reliability coefficient was 0·59 for static muscle activity and 0·85 for short interruptions in muscle activity (EMG gaps) during work. The reliability coefficient was 0·94 for the EMG signal's average median frequency of test contractions associated with the work session. The median frequency declined significantly during the work session. No time trend was found during the day or the week for these parameters. Consequently, it is possible to get representative measurements of the mentioned EMG parameters during repetitive light work by a recording taken at any time of the day or week.     

Trapezius muscle activity as a risk indicator for shoulder and neck pain in female service workers with low biomechanical exposure

Electromyographic activity of the upper trapezius muscles was recorded over the workday for two groups of service workers, shopping centre (n = 22) and healthcare workers (n = 44), both with low observed biomechanical exposure. Static and median EMG activity level, number of EMG gaps and gap time were determined. The variability of these variables over the workday was examined by calculating the coefficient of variation (CV) and the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) of 1-h consecutive recording periods. All variables except gap time showed acceptable reliability (ICC = 0.69-0.78), i.e. the largest fraction of variance in the data set was due to intersubject variance, despite relatively large hour-to-hour variation (CV = 0.21 0.62). The EMG activity level in the trapezius muscles was low (static activity level < 1% EMGmax), despite the high prevalence of shoulder and neck pain for both groups of workers. In addition to the work recordings, tests were performed to determine intersubject variation in muscle activity when adopting a standardized resting posture, and in a dynamic muscle activity pattern during paced arm movement. Neither the EMG variables from the work recordings nor the tests with EMG recording indicated higher trapezius EMG activity levels for workers with pain in the shoulders and neck in this study. The low EMG levels are interpreted to indicate a low risk of developing shoulder and neck complaints due to biomechanical exposure for both groups of workers. The possibility of pain-initiating mechanisms, associated with stress and not mediated through muscle activity, is considered in the discussion.     

Trapezius muscle activity as a risk indicator for shoulder and neck pain in female service workers with low biomechanical exposure

Electromyographic activity of the upper trapezius muscles was recorded over the workday for two groups of service workers, shopping centre (n = 22) and healthcare workers (n = 44), both with low observed biomechanical exposure. Static and median EMG activity level, number of EMG gaps and gap time were determined. The variability of these variables over the workday was examined by calculating the coefficient of variation (CV) and the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) of 1-h consecutive recording periods. All variables except gap time showed acceptable reliability (ICC = 0.69-0.78), i.e. the largest fraction of variance in the data set was due to intersubject variance, despite relatively large hour-to-hour variation (CV = 0.21-0.62). The EMG activity level in the trapezius muscles was low (static activity level < 1% EMG_max), despite the high prevalence of shoulder and neck pain for both groups of workers. In addition to the work recordings, tests were performed to determine intersubject variation in muscle activity when adopting a standardized resting posture, and in a dynamic muscle activity pattern during paced arm movement. Neither the EMG variables from the work recordings nor the tests with EMG recording indicated higher trapezius EMG activity levels for workers with pain in the shoulders and neck in this study. The low EMG levels are interpreted to indicate a low risk of developing shoulder and neck complaints due to biomechanical exposure for both groups of workers. The possibility of pain-initiating mechanisms, associated with stress and not mediated through muscle activity, is considered in the discussion.     

An evaluation of backpack harness systems in non-neutral torso postures

Much of the research on backpack design has been focused on spinal loading/biomechanics while the wearer is in a neutral/upright trunk posture, such as those employed by outdoor enthusiasts and schoolchildren. This research has led to some important harness design improvements that reduce trunk muscle exertions, fatigue and improve overall comfort. There are number of occupations, however, wherein workers wear back-mounted packs/devices (e.g. air tanks) while working in non-neutral trunk postures. The objective of the current study was to evaluate the effects of these non-neutral postures on biomechanical loading and then reconsider the backpack system design recommendations. Fifteen participants were asked to support a 18.2 kg load on their back while assuming static forward flexed postures of the torso (15 degrees , 30 degrees , 45 degrees , and 60 degrees of sagittal bend). The mass on the back was attached to the participant through two different harness mechanisms: a basic harness design (as seen on college student backpacks) and a more advanced design containing lateral stiffness rods and a weight-bearing hip belt (as seen on backpacks for hikers). While performing these static, posture maintenance tasks, the activation levels of the bilateral trapezius, erector spinae, and rectus abdominis were collected. Participants also provided subjective ratings of comfort. The results showed that there was a significant interaction between harness type and forward flexion angle for the trapezius and the erector spinae muscles. The normalized EMG for the trapezius muscles showed a 14% and 11% reduction in muscle activity at 15 degrees and 30 degrees , respectively, with the advanced design but these positive effects of the advanced design were not found at the greater flexion angles. Likewise the erector spinae muscles showed a 24% and 14% reduction in muscle activity at 15 degrees and 30 degrees , respectively, with the advanced design harness but these effects of the advanced design were not found at the greater forward flexion angles. The level of forward flexion angle affected the rectus abdominis muscle activity, but neither the harness type main effect nor the interaction of harness type and forward flexion angle was significant. The subjective survey results agreed with the EMG results and showed the advanced design harness was generally more comfortable with respect to the shoulder and low back areas. Collectively, the subjective and objective results show a significant improvement with the advanced harness system but also note an interesting interaction with degree of sagittal flexion, indicating a diminished effectiveness of the design improvements at forward flexed postures. Design criteria for harness systems in these forward flexed postures are discussed.     

Evaluation of physiological work demands and low back neuromuscular fatigue on nurses working in geriatric wards

This study evaluated the physiological demands and low back neuromuscular fatigue patterns following a daytime work shift of 21 female nurses working in geriatric wards. Subjects' heart rate (HR) at work was monitored for 8 h and surface electromyogram (EMG) of their back muscle was recorded during a 1-minute horizontal trunk holding test before and after work. Results showed that the nurses had heart rates exceeding 90 beats/min in 57% and 110 beats/min in 19% of their working hours. The EMG revealed a significant drop in initial median frequency (MF) (p = 0.04) and increase in negative slope of the MF/time plot (p<0.001) of the back muscle after work. These suggest that the muscles were fatigued after work. The nurses rated patient lifting, transfer and turning as most physically demanding, and these corresponded to the highest heart rates recorded. The physiological and neuromuscular strain on the nurses indicated that extreme care should be exercised at work, particularly towards the end of a work shift when the muscles have become fatigued.     

The ironies of vehicle feedback in car design

Optimization of the temporal aspects of task design requires a better understanding of the development of muscle fatigue in the neck and shoulder region over time. The objective of the study was to investigate this in two production companies and to determine the relationship between objective and subjective estimates of fatigue. Indicators of fatigue were obtained through electromyography (EMG) during test contractions and ratings of perceived discomfort. EMG amplitude increased during the day in both case studies while mean power frequency decreased only in one case. In both cases, a more detailed frequency analysis of the EMG signals showed an increase in lower frequency power accompanied by a decrease in higher frequency power. Local perceived discomfort in the neck and shoulder increased over the course of the day in both cases. However, no clear relationship between perceived discomfort and objective indicators of fatigue was found. Obtaining sufficient sensitivity to detect effects of temporal aspects of task design probably requires complementary or more refined methods (e.g. EMG arrays, mechanomyography).     

Development of fatigue and discomfort in the upper trapezius muscle during light manual work

Optimization of the temporal aspects of task design requires a better understanding of the development of muscle fatigue in the neck and shoulder region over time. The objective of the study was to investigate this in two production companies and to determine the relationship between objective and subjective estimates of fatigue. Indicators of fatigue were obtained through electromyography (EMG) during test contractions and ratings of perceived discomfort. EMG amplitude increased during the day in both case studies while mean power frequency decreased only in one case. In both cases, a more detailed frequency analysis of the EMG signals showed an increase in lower frequency power accompanied by a decrease in higher frequency power. Local perceived discomfort in the neck and shoulder increased over the course of the day in both cases. However, no clear relationship between perceived discomfort and objective indicators of fatigue was found. Obtaining sufficient sensitivity to detect effects of temporal aspects of task design probably requires complementary or more refined methods (e.g. EMG arrays, mechanomyography).     

Sustained muscle tension as a risk factor for trapezius myalgia

Thirty female chocolate packers were included in a prospective study to relate trapezius muscle activity during work to the development of myalgia. Electromyographic (EMG) recordings and interviews on risk factors were performed at start of employment and every 10th week. The muscle activity was characterized by the averaged static and median level. Only data obtained before a possible development of severe symptoms of trapezius myalgia (patient) was used in the analysis. Seventeen of the subjects became patients within the first year of employment. Machine-stops occurred accidentally during work. At one task the stops induced a pause where the subjects passively waited for the machine to start. Twenty-one subjects experienced machine-stops of a sufficient duration to be evaluated for a potential “resting tension”. Future patients showed significantly higher “resting tension” compared to healthy controls.