Evaluation of the performance of warm mix asphalt in Washington state

Warm mix asphalt (WMA) is a relatively new and emerging technology for the asphalt industry. It offers potential construction and environmental advantages over traditional hot mix asphalt (HMA). However, WMA must perform at least as well as HMA before it can be used extensively. This study evaluates the performance of WMA mixtures and their corresponding HMA control mixtures obtained from various field sites in the state of Washington. Four WMA technologies are examined, including Sasobit^® and three water-foaming technologies, Gencor^®, Aquablack? and ALmix Water Injection. Performance tests are conducted on the field cores to evaluate and compare the rutting, moisture susceptibility, fatigue and thermal resistance of WMA and HMA, respectively. Also, the extracted binders from the field cores are evaluated. In addition, the early-age field performance of WMA and HMA control pavements are compared.     

Comparison between the fatigue response of hot and warm mix asphalts based on the dissipated energy approach

This study focused on the fatigue behaviour of warm mix asphalt (WMA) based on the dissipated energy (DE) approach. Two conventional binders consisting of 60/70 and 85/100 penetration-grade bitumens were used to prepare the control mix. WMA was prepared by incorporating 2% Sasobit by weight of bitumen. First, the basic properties of WMA containing optimum bitumen content were compared with those of control hot mix asphalt (HMA). The main laboratory programme included four-point flexural fatigue test that was accomplished at different strain levels of 250, 500, 750 and 1000 microstrain. The studied WMA had comparable Marshall stability and indirect tensile strength to those of control HMA. Furthermore, based on the resilient modulus test results, the temperature susceptibility of WMA was slightly more than that of the control mix. Fatigue lives of studied mixes were evaluated using the conventional fatigue curves that were developed based on the initial strain level. Comparison between these curves revealed the predominant fatigue behaviour of WMAs at different examined strain levels. The initial DE and the cumulative DE of WMAs were lower than those of HMAs. The latter issue justifies the predominant fatigue response of WMA. By considering the DE curve, the ratio of dissipated energy change (RDEC) was calculated. Afterward, the plateau value (PV) was determined using the moving average of fatigue data in the plateau stage of the RDEC curve. Finally, PV-based fatigue models were developed which could precisely estimate the fatigue life regardless of the mix type and testing condition.     

Field performance of top-down fatigue cracking for warm mix asphalt pavements

As a result of repeated rehabilitation efforts over the past few decades, often asphalt pavements have become deep-strength pavements. Consequently, top-down cracking has become a primary distress type. In particular, the top-down cracking performance of warm mix asphalt (WMA) pavements, i.e. how does it compare with similar hot mix asphalt (HMA) pavements is largely unclear mainly due to the lack of field performance data. This paper presents an effort of monitoring the top-down cracking performance of 28 pavement projects including WMA pavements and their corresponding HMA control pavements with service lives ranging between 4 and 10 years. These pavements cover different climate zones, WMA technologies, service years, pavement structures and traffic volume levels. Two rounds of distress surveys were conducted at a two-year interval, and the material (asphalt binder and mixture) properties of the pavements were determined using field cores. The top-down cracking performance of the HMA and WMA pavements was compared based on the first and second round distress surveys. It was found that the HMA and WMA pavement in general exhibited comparable performance. The significant determinants (material properties) for top-down cracking were determined, which were vertical failure deformation of mixes measured at 20 °C from indirect tension test.     

Dynamic mechanical characterization of asphalt concrete mixes with modified asphalt binders

The primary objective of this work is to characterize and compare the dynamic mechanical behavior of asphalt concrete mixes with styrene butadiene styrene (SBS) polymer and crumb rubber modified asphalt binders with the behavior of mixes with unmodified viscosity grade asphalt binders. Asphalt binders are characterized for their physical and rheological properties. Simple performance tests like dynamic modulus, dynamic and static creep tests are carried out at varying temperatures and time. Dynamic modulus master curves constructed using numerical optimization technique is used to explain the time and temperature dependency of modified and unmodified asphalt binder mixes. Creep parameters estimated through regression analysis explained the permanent deformation characteristics of asphalt concrete mixes. From the dynamic mechanical characterization studies, it is found that asphalt concrete mixes with SBS polymer modified asphalt binder showed significantly higher values of dynamic modulus and reduced rate of deformation at higher temperatures when compared to asphalt concrete mixes with crumb rubber and unmodified asphalt binders. From the concept of energy dissipation, it is found that SBS polymer modification substantially reduces the energy loss at higher temperatures. Multi-factorial analysis of variance carried out using generalized liner model showed that temperature, frequency and asphalt binder type significant influences the mechanical response of asphalt concrete mixes. The mechanical response of SBS polymer modified asphalt binders are significantly correlated with the rutting resistance of asphalt concrete mixes.     

Effect of waste plastic bottles on the stiffness and fatigue properties of modified asphalt mixes

Nowadays, the use of recycled waste materials as modifier additives in asphalt mixes could have several economic and environmental benefits. The main purpose of this research was to investigate the effect of waste plastic bottles (Polyethylene Terephthalate (PET)) on the stiffness and specially fatigue properties of asphalt mixes at two different temperatures of 5 and 20 °C. Likewise, the effect of PET was compared to styrene butadiene styrene (SBS) which is a conventional polymer additive which has been vastly used to modify asphalt mixes. Different PET contents (2–10% by weight of bitumen) were added directly to mixture as the method of dry process. Then the resilient modulus and fatigue tests were performed on cylindrical specimens with indirect tensile loading procedure. Overall, the mix stiffness reduced by increasing the PET content. Although stiffness of asphalt mix initially increased by adding lower amount of PET. Based on the results of resilient modulus test, the stiffness of PET modified mix was acceptable and warranted the proper deformation characteristics of these mixes at heavy loading conditions. At both temperatures, PET improved the fatigue behavior of studied mixes. PET modified mixes revealed comparable stiffness and fatigue behavior to SBS at 20 °C. However, at 5 °C the fatigue life of SBS modified mixes was to some extent higher than that of PET modified ones especially at higher strain levels of 200 microstrain.     

Effect of warm mix additives on the interfacial bonding characteristics of asphalt binders

The quality of the interfacial bonding between asphalt binder and aggregates plays a significant role in determining the durability of asphalt mixtures. Warm mix asphalt (WMA) modifiers have been used extensively in the last decade primarily to reduce production and compaction temperatures as well as to improve workability of asphalt mixtures. This study aimed to provide better understanding of the effects of these WMA modifiers on the interfacial bonding between asphalt binders and aggregates. The evaluation focused on measuring surface energy of binders in unaged and aged states and aggregates and then calculating energy parameters that describe the potential of a given asphalt-aggregate combination to resist fatigue cracking and moisture damage. Results show that the combination of asphalt-WMA additive, as well as the content applied of WMA additive has a significant impact on the fatigue cracking and moisture damage resistance. The results suggest that it is poor practice to use a given type and percentage of WMA modifier without regard for binder type. Instead, test methods are recommended to evaluate the compatibility of asphalt binder, WMA additive type/content, and aggregates for improved performance at different conditions.     

Effects of high friction aggregate and PG Plus binder on rutting resistance of hot mix asphalt mixtures

The rutting resistance of hot mix asphalt (HMA) Superpave? mixes in surface course materials was investigated using asphalt material characterisation tests and a digital imaging processing (DIP) technique. The effects of the type of aggregate, the type of binder and the binder content on rutting resistance were quantified. Two types of aggregate were examined: Superpave? SP12.5 and high friction SP12.5 FC2. Both a modified (PG Plus) and an unmodified binders were considered at the optimum binder content and the optimum content plus an additional 0.5%. To accurately identify the effect of each variable, the shear upheave of these mixes was also quantified. The DIP technique involved estimating the number of aggregate contacts, the total contact length and internal structure index of two-dimensional images of the experimentally tested samples. The results showed that both the rutting resistance and stiffness of HMA surface mixes were sensitive to aggregate type, binder type and binder content. A high friction aggregate provided a better internal structure characteristic, as well as superior rutting resistance and stiffness for HMA mixes. The use of PG Plus and the addition of 0.5% to the optimum binder content negatively affected HMA stiffness and rutting resistance. However, the levels of rutting resistance for all mixes were acceptable (rut depth < 12.5 mm), even when the shear upheave was considered. Internal structure indices measured by DIP were effective for capturing changes in the internal HMA structure with respect to aggregate type and asphalt cement content.     

Laboratory characterisation of asphalt mixes containing RAP and RAS

Due to its economic and environmental benefits, using reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP) and reclaimed asphalt shingles (RAS) in new hot-mix asphalt (HMA) has become an integral part of today's asphalt industry. The advantages of using RAP and RAS in HMA are not limited to economic and environmental benefits, and may result in improving a number of mix performance characteristics including rutting and resistance to moisture-induced damage. Despite aforementioned benefits, concerns over premature pavement distresses resulting from using RAP and RAS limit their usage in HMA. Furthermore, because of the lack of mechanistic performance data, use of new mixes containing RAP and RAS remains limited. Therefore, the present study was undertaken to investigate the effects of using different amounts of RAP and RAS on laboratory performance of HMA, and to generate valuable input design parameters for implementation of the mechanistic-empirical pavement design guide (M-EPDG), using local materials. Four types of base course mixes containing 0% RAP, 25% RAP, 40% RAP and 20% RAP+5% RAS, and three types of surface course mixes containing 0% RAP, 25% RAP and 20% RAP+5% RAS were tested. Laboratory tests were conducted to evaluate stiffness, low-temperature cracking, fatigue life, rut and moisture-induced damage potential of the mixes. It was found that dynamic modulus and creep compliance of the asphalt mixes increase and decrease, respectively, with an increase in the amount of RAP and/or RAS used in the mix. Fatigue life was found to increase with increasing RAP content up to 25%, and to decrease when the RAP and/or RAS content exceeded 25%, or when RAS was used in the mix. It should be noted that this conclusion was drawn based on a 15% increment in RAP content. Hamburg wheel tracking (HWT) test results showed increased resistance to rutting and moisture-induced damage, with an increase in the amount of RAP and/or RAS. However, the tensile strength ratio test results were not confirmed by HWT. The findings of this study are expected to be helpful in understanding the effects of using different amounts of RAP and RAS on the performance of asphalt mixes produced using local materials. Furthermore, valuable design input parameters, developed in this study for new mixes containing RAP and RAS, may be used for calibration of the M-EPDG input parameters, with local materials.     

Fatigue life and endurance limit prediction of asphalt mixtures using energy-based failure criterion

Fatigue cracking is one of the major types of distress in asphalt mixtures and is caused by the accumulation of damage in pavement sections under repeated load applications. The fatigue endurance limit (EL) concept assumes a specific strain level, below which the damage in hot mix asphalt (HMA) is not cumulative. In other words, if the asphalt layer depth is controlled in a way that keeps the critical HMA flexural strain level below the EL, the fatigue life of the mixture can be extended significantly. This paper uses two common failure criteria, the traditional beam fatigue criterion and the simplified viscoelastic continuum damage model energy-based failure criterion (the so-called G^R method), to evaluate the effect of different parameters, such as reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP) content, binder content, binder modification and warm mix asphalt (WMA) additives, on the EL value. In addition, both failure criteria are employed to investigate the impacts of these parameters in terms of the fatigue life of the study mixtures. According to the findings, unlike an increase in RAP content, which has a negative effect on the mixtures’ fatigue resistance, a higher binder content and/or binder modification can significantly increase the EL value and extend the fatigue life as was proved before by other researchers, whereas WMA additives do not significantly affect the mixtures’ fatigue behaviour. A comparison of the model simulation results with the field observations indicates that the G^R method predicts the field performance more accurately than the traditional method.     

Rheological characterization of wax-modified asphalt binders at high service temperatures

The research reported herein focuses on the rheological characterization of wax-modified asphalt binders used in warm mix asphalt (WMA) technology. Wax-modified asphalt binders were produced by adding controlled quantities of different types of wax to a 50/70 unmodified bitumen. Five different kinds of wax were used, including synthetic hydrocarbons Fischer–Tropsch wax, Montan waxes and amidic-modified waxes. All the blends were subjected to different rheometric tests to assess their mechanical response at high service temperatures. The viscous deformation mechanism was analyzed with reference to static and repetitive creep loading; it was found that the viscous deformation is strongly affected by the presence of both hydrocarbons and amidic-modified waxes. Wax-modified binders exhibited an effective improvement in intrinsic resistance to non-reversible deformation, even in high applied stress and cyclic loading conditions. It was observed that the chemical composition and the consequent physical characteristics of the wax are the most important factors regulating the final behavior of wax-modified asphalt binders at high service temperatures. The final contribution of the experience performed is related to the technical evaluation of wax-modified asphalt binders and to the general development of WMA technologies for pavement applications.     

An overview of the emerging warm mix asphalt technology

The asphalt industry is constantly attempting to reduce its emissions as concerns are growing on global warming. This is done by decreasing the mixing and compaction temperatures of asphalt mixtures without affecting the properties of the mix which is possible through numerous available technologies in the industry. The production of asphalt mix is done by warm mix asphalt (WMA) technology at considerably lower temperatures (120°C or lower). Less energy consumption, lower mixing and compaction temperatures, early site opening, reduced ageing, fewer emissions, cool weather paving, better workability and, finally, an extended paving window could be mentioned as some of the benefits obtained by using the WMA. This paper presents the WMA techniques and technologies such as foaming techniques, wax and chemical additives techniques. Additionally, the performance of WMA popular technologies such as Sasobit^®, WAM^®-Foam, Evotherm^®, Low energy asphalt, Rediset^® WMX and REVIX? are fully described.     

Application of nano-silica and styrene-butadiene-styrene to improve asphalt mixture self healing

Nanoparticles, due to their physical and chemical characteristics, present an inherent potential to improve the performance of bituminous materials. Presently, the technology of producing nanosized particles is evolving, and their application in various aspects of pavement engineering is becoming more cost-effective. Nanosilica, due to its spherical shape, high specific area, very tiny size and higher density compared to bitumen, presents an inherent potential to accelerate molecular randomisation movements, promote bitumen binder flow into microcracks and evolve healing index (HI) of hot mix asphalt (HMA). Moreover, it has been proved that Styrene–Butadiene–Styrene polymer (SBS) promotes fatigue life of HMA and decreases its temperature sensitivity. It would be interesting to know if the addition of nanosilica to modified binder with SBS will promote the total HI and lead to an enhanced HMA life cycle. In this study, the effects of four parameters, most importantly, the effect of the combination of nanosilica particles and SBS polymer to improve the self-healing of asphalt mixture was investigated using the Taguchi design of experiment (DOE) method. Experiments performed with the Superpave indirect tensile test included repeated loadings (fracture) and healing phases. These experiments showed that the combination of nanosilica and SBS promoted the self-healing of HMA, significantly. Moreover, the optimum condition to attain maximum HI and effect factor of each parameter, based on Taguchi DOE method, was obtained. Furthermore, scanning electron microscope images of fatigued, under healing and healed HMA samples were captured to investigate HMA self-healing mechanism.     

基于表面能理论的老化温拌SBS改性沥青结合料的粘附性

在SBS改性沥青中添加Sasobit与Evotherm温拌剂制备得到温拌沥青,对3种SBS改性沥青进行旋转薄膜烘箱老化(RTFOT)与压力老化(PAV),采用接触角法检测了老化前后温拌SBS改性沥青与蒸馏水、甘油和甲酰胺等3种液体的接触角,探讨了短期老化与长期老化对温拌SBS改性沥青接触角的影响。基于表面自由能理论,得到了温拌SBS改性沥青的表面能及其色散分量和极性分量,研究了老化对温拌SBS改性沥青表面能的影响。结果表明:随着老化程度的加强,温拌SBS改性沥青与水的接触角逐渐增大,疏水性变化明显;原样与Evotherm温拌SBS改性沥青的总表面自由能及其分量均随着老化程度的加强呈降低趋势,其在短期老化阶段的表面自由能下降较为严重;经长期老化,Sasobit温拌SBS改性沥青的极性分量有增大趋势。     

基于数字散斑相关法的紫外老化沥青混合料界面开裂特性

利用数字图像相关技术(DSCM)针对紫外光老化的沥青混合料(HMA)半圆试件弯拉试验中裂纹产生及扩展规律从细观角度进行表征,运用Vic-3D分析软件对沥青混合料半圆试件进行全场位移、应变计算,得到试件破坏过程的位移场、应变场。结果表明:通过对紫外光照的沥青胶浆、集料及界面水平方向应变场的对比分析,发现界面为沥青混合料最薄弱处,最易产生裂纹;进一步通过水平方向应变随载荷变化曲线的变化对HMA开裂时间进行分析,可以更好地将HMA微裂缝开裂时间与宏观裂缝开裂时间加以区分,且紫外老化后的HMA试样界面开裂时间明显缩短。同时,将相同的紫外老化前后的橡胶粉(CR)改性HMA试样与苯乙烯-丁二烯-苯乙烯(SBS)改性HMA试样的位移随载荷变化规律进行对比发现,经紫外老化后的CR改性HMA比紫外老化后SBS改性HMA具有更强的抗开裂能力及持荷能力。      

Introducing a new specimen shape to assess the fatigue performance of asphalt mastic by dynamic shear rheometer testing

Early failure of asphalt pavements is a common issue all around the world. Damages are caused by various reasons like insufficient binder or aggregate quality, an inadequate mix design or improper handling in the production/construction process. The effects of binder, aggregates and mix design have been widely studied and state-of-the-art testing methods are available for both, hot-mix asphalt (HMA) and for each component. An important part in HMA belongs to the asphalt mastic, where no standardized method is available to allow a quality control. Asphalt mastic is the mix of bitumen with aggregates smaller than 63 (125) µm and covers the coarse aggregates as the actual binding component in the mix. This research aims at developing a testing method for asphalt mastic based on fatigue tests. The dynamic shear rheometer (DSR) was found as a suitable device for this purpose. The DSR fatigue test consists of the 8 mm parallel-plate geometry widely used for binder performance grading with a sample height of 3 mm. Instead of a cylindrical specimen shape, a hyperboloid of one sheet is applied. This shape predetermines the point of failure and prevents adhesion/interface failures between the mastic specimen and the upper or lower DSR stainless steel plate. The specimens are prepared directly in the DSR employing a silicone mould to ensure an exact specimen shape. This test can be applied to all DSR devices without costly changes or additional equipment as long as sufficient cooling capacity and torque can be provided from the DSR. This fatigue test makes it possible to assess the fatigue performance of binders and mastic samples.     

Effects of recycled asphalt pavements on the fatigue life of asphalt under different strain levels and loading frequencies

Fatigue lives of Hot Mix Asphalt (HMA) and binder have been studied separately for a long time. However, fatigue lives of HMA containing Recycled Asphalt Pavement (RAP) and the binder extracted from the same HMA containing RAP have not been studied yet. This study examines the effects of RAP, loading frequency and strain level on the fatigue lives of asphalt mixtures and binders. In addition, the relationship between the fatigue lives of asphalt mixture and binder is determined. Beam fatigue tests were conducted to determine the fatigue behaviors of two asphalt mixtures: one with 35% RAP and the other without RAP. To evaluate binder’s fatigue behavior, binders were extracted and recovered from these two mixtures. Then, fatigue lives of these two binders were determined using time sweep and Linear Amplitude Sweep (LAS) tests. Results show that presence of RAP in mixture causes a decrease in the mixture’s fatigue life, whereas it causes an increase in the fatigue life of binder. As expected, an increase in loading frequency results in an increase in the fatigue lives of asphalt mixture as well as binder. In addition, increase in strain level causes a decrease in the fatigue lives of both mixtures and binders. Fatigue lives of binders from time sweep and LAS tests show a good correlation with the mixture’s fatigue life by the beam fatigue test.     

Effect of warm mix asphalt chemical additives on the mechanical performance of asphalt binders

Warm mix asphalt (WMA) has become very popular in asphalt pavement construction because it allows reducing both energy consumptions and carbon emissions. WMA can be obtained by using different types of additives and can be produced, applied, and compacted at temperatures 20–40 °C lower than hot mix asphalt. WMA additives allow reducing the working temperatures without compromising the final performance of the asphalt concrete. Many WMA additives are available on the worldwide market and some of them reduce the viscosity of asphalts binder (organic additives or foam) whereas others do not act on this sense (chemical additives). This study focuses on the effect of chemical additives on the performance of asphalt binders for WMA production. To this purpose, a neat bitumen, a polymer modified bitumen (PMB) and two different chemical additives were selected. All the binders were characterized through conventional tests, DSR, MSCR, FTIR and microscopic analysis. The result clearly showed that the influence of the chemical additives on the neat bitumen is negligible or non-existent. On the contrary, significant changes were observed in the modified bitumen properties. Specifically, chemical additives reduce the viscosity temperature susceptibility of PMBs in the temperature range between 80 and 140 °C, increase the rutting resistance potential and the elastic response of PMBs at high temperatures. Moreover, a morphological inspection supported the modifications observed in the rheological properties of PMBs.     

Fatigue and healing performance assessment of asphalt binder from rheological and chemical characteristics

The fatigue and healing performance of asphalt binder affect the durability of asphalt concrete and by extension, asphalt pavements. The objectives of this paper are to (1) estimate the fatigue and healing characteristics of asphalt binder by newly developed linear amplitude sweep (LAS) and LAS-based Healing (LASH) protocols, and (2) investigate the relationship between chemical composition of asphalt and engineering performance. Three neat asphalt binders (Pen-30, Pen-50 and Pen-70) and one SBS modified binder are selected for this study. Experimental results indicate that the SBS binder has advanced fatigue resistance among all tested binders and the softer neat binder with a higher penetration grade generally displays better fatigue performance. The fatigue failure occurrence is a significant threshold for healing potential comparison. The rate of healing (H^R) results suggest that the best healing potential is with Pen-70 binder in pre-failure conditions followed by the SBS binder, Pen-50 and Pen-30 binders. However, the SBS binder presents better healing performance than Pen-70 binder in post-failure condition. Further solvency fractionation, into saturates, aromatics, resins and asphaltenes, indicates that the asphaltene content is negatively proportional to the quantified binder fatigue life whereas the H^R index is found to be well correlated to the weight percents of saturates and ratio of saturates to aromatics (S/Ar). The combined use of LAS and LASH tests is recommended for effectively distinguishing and designing the fatigue-healing performance of neat and modified asphalt binders. Limiting the contents of asphaltenes would be of help to improve the binder fatigue resistance and either saturates percent or S/Ar parameter should be considered to assure the self-healing potential of asphalt binder.     

Black curves and creep behaviour of crumb rubber modified binders containing warm mix asphalt additives

Warm mix asphalt (WMA) is a new research topic in the field of road pavement materials. This technology allows lower energy consumption and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by reducing compaction and placement temperatures of the asphalt mixtures. However, this technology is still under study, and the influence of the WMA additives has yet to be investigated thoroughly and clearly identified, especially in the case of crumb rubber modified (CRM) binders.In order to study the effect that different types and quantities of organic waxes have on the high and intermediate temperature properties of 15 % and 20 % CRM binders, a dynamic shear rheometer (DSR) was used. Using Black diagrams, the rheological behaviour of the binders for the defined range of test temperature and frequency are summarised in a single diagram. In this way, a preliminary evaluation of the rheological behaviour in the extended domain of time and temperature can be attained as well as the effectiveness of the time–temperature superposition principle (TTSP) on the materials under study. Creep tests were also performed in order to evaluate the differences regarding mechanical response due to the addition of rubber and WMA additives, and particularly the ability to recover the strain at high temperatures.The results of this study reveal that these binders do not conform to the Time Temperature Superposition Principle (TTSP) and their rheological behaviour is strongly affected by the interaction of waxes and bituminous matrix and thus generally exhibited a higher elasticity compared to the corresponding control binder. The creep test results carried out proved the enhancement of elasticity and the resistance to permanent deformation produced by the addition of waxes. The WMA additives significantly lower the maximum deformation when compared to the control binders and slightly increased their elastic recovery.     

反应性弹性体三元共聚物改性沥青及其混合料性能与机制

采用黏度试验和动态剪切流变试验研究了反应性弹性体三元共聚物（RET）对基质沥青与苯乙烯-丁二烯-苯乙烯嵌段共聚物（SBS）改性沥青性能的影响,通过原子力显微镜（AFM）分析了SBS改性沥青和RET-SBS改性沥青的表面形貌特征,并采用车辙试验、低温弯曲试验、弯曲疲劳试验及加速加载试验评价了RET改性沥青混合料的各项技术性能,最后通过Weibull分布,分析了不同RET改性沥青混合料在不同失效概率下的疲劳性能。结果表明：RET的掺入提高了沥青的黏度和抗车辙因子,对沥青的高温性能有较大改善;通过掺入RET-SBS,增加了改性沥青中的黏性成分;相较于SBS改性沥青,RET-SBS改性沥青的表面粗糙度显著增大;RET改性剂能够明显改善沥青混合料的高温稳定性;RET与SBS改性剂复配,可有效弥补RET对沥青混合料低温性能的不足,明显改善沥青混合料的疲劳性能和高温长期稳定性。