A review of daylight illuminance determinations and energy implications

Daylighting is recognized as an important element in architecture and a useful strategy in energy-efficient building designs. Daylight gives a sense of cheeriness and brightness that can have a significant positive impact on the people. There is a scope for integrating daylight with electric light to reduce building energy use. The amount of daylight entering a building is mainly through window openings, which create in the indoor environment a more attractive and pleasing atmosphere, in addition to maximise visual access to the pleasant views of the outside world. Determinations of the exterior and interior daylight and lighting energy savings are key issues to demonstrate the benefits based on daylighting designs. This paper provides a review of daylight illuminance determinations and the lighting energy reductions due to daylighting schemes. The study includes daylight measurements, prediction of daylight illuminance under various sky conditions and potential electric lighting energy savings from daylight-linked lighting controls. The article aims at providing building professionals, practitioners and researchers more information and a better understanding of daylight for promoting effective daylighting designs and evaluations.     

Daylighting and energy analysis for air-conditioned office buildings

We propose a simple method for estimating the likely energy savings in electric lighting due to daylighting and the possible cooling penalty. Fractions of the working year and cooling season when daylighting alone is adequate to provide the indoor design illuminance are presented for on-off and top-up controls. Based on the simple average daylight factor method, energy savings in electric lighting have been estimated for a generic office building using measured outdoor illuminance data in Hong Kong. The daylight-induced cooling penalty is estimated using average solar heat gain factors. Our case study suggests that daylighting schemes can result in substantial energy savings in air-conditioned office buildings in Hong Kong.     

An analysis of light-pipe system via full-scale measurements

Daylighting is an effective sustainable development strategy to alleviating the problems in energy and the environment, and improving the qualities for visual comfort and health. In Hong Kong, many buildings are high-rise blocks constructed close to each other resulting in severe sky obstructions. Recently, a great deal of attention has been paid to the development of natural daylight exploitation products. One invention is the light-pipe system that transports natural light efficiently from outdoor into rear part of a room. However, this innovative daylighting device is not popular in subtropical Hong Kong. The main reason for such unenthusiastic responses is the lack of local data to indicate the visual performance, energy savings and design implications. A research project was initiated to evaluate these issues. The study includes field measurements of daylight illuminance in a corridor installed a number of light pipes. The results demonstrate that the light-pipe system can provide sufficient illuminance, improve the daylight uniformity and have a high potential to reduce the electric lighting energy consumption.     

Daylighting performance evaluation of a bottom-up motorized roller shade

This paper presents an experimental and simulation study for quantifying the daylighting performance of bottom-up roller shades installed in office spaces. The bottom-up shade is a motorized roller shade that opens from top to bottom operating in the opposite direction of a conventional roller shade, so as to cover the bottom part of the window, while allowing daylight to enter from the top part of the window, reaching deeper into the room. A daylighting simulation model, validated with full-scale experiments, was developed in order to establish correlations between the shade position, outdoor illuminance and work plane illuminance for different outdoor conditions. Then, a shading control algorithm was developed for application in any location and orientation. The validated model was employed for a sensitivity analysis of the impact of shade optical properties and control on the potential energy savings due to the use of daylighting. The results showed that Daylight Autonomy for the bottom-up shade is 8–58% higher compared to a conventional roller shade, with a difference of 46% further away from the façade, where the use of electric lighting is needed most of the time. The potential reduction in energy consumption for lighting is 21–41%.     

Measurements of solar radiation and illuminance on vertical surfaces and daylighting implications

There is a growing concern about the rapid development of infrastructure and building projects and their likely impacts on the environment. Particular concerns have been raised about office building developments and energy consumption issues. In recent years, there has been increasing interest in using daylight to save energy in buildings. Lighting control integrated with daylighting is recognised as an important and useful strategy in terms of energy-efficient building design. It is believed that proper daylighting schemes can help reduce the electrical demand and contribute to achieving environmentally sustainable building developments. This paper presents a simple method for estimating the likely energy savings in electric lighting due to daylighting and the possible cooling penalty. Vertical solar radiation and illuminance data measurements are described. Cumulative frequency distributions of daylight availability are reported. The likely energy savings in office buildings are determined based on on–off and top-up controls, and the energy and environmental implications are discussed.     

Lighting and energy performance of solar film coating in air-conditioned cellular offices

In subtropical Hong Kong, the principal objectives of fenestration design include eliminating direct sunlight and decreasing cooling loads. To avoid the problems of glare, excessive brightness and thermal discomfort, occupants may block the windows with internal shading devices, resulting in poor daylighting performance and very small amount of electric lighting energy savings. Recently, the advances in thin film coatings for window glass products provide a means of substantially reducing heat gain without proportionally reducing daylight transmittance. It has been suggested that film coatings together with photoelectric lighting control systems could minimise the electric lighting and cooling requirements without causing undue visual and thermal discomfort to the occupants. This paper presents field measurements on solar control film coatings in fully air-conditioned offices in Hong Kong. Solar heat gains, indoor illuminance levels and the electricity consumption by the fluorescent luminaires were systematically recorded and analysed. Measurements were made for two cellular offices, one with solar control film coating on the window glass and the other without. The findings showed that the solar film coating could cut down energy expenditures for air-conditioned buildings, especially for spaces with large glazing areas subject to substantial amount of direct sunlight. Results are presented and the design implications discussed.     

Workplane illuminance prediction method for daylighting control systems

A new prediction method with an interior light sensor for the workplane illuminance in daylighting control systems is introduced. Based on radiosity theory, the spatial distributions of daylight and electric light in the space are discussed and the prediction method is developed. An experimental verification of the technique is performed in an outdoor test-room for a double-glazed window system with a motorized venetian blind integrated between the two glazings. Electric light and daylight predictions were performed in accordance with the proposed method. The results showed that the electric light workplane illuminance can be predicted with high accuracy (±5 lux error with a linear correlation) and that the daylight workplane illuminance can be predicted within ±20 lux (with a linear correlation) for any sky conditions (overcast, clear sky, or variable) with the window system controlled to prevent direct daylight transmission. This method is useful for integrated control of motorized daylighting devices and dimmable electric lights.     

DAYLIGHTING TECHNOLOGIES IN NON-DOMESTIC BUILDINGS

Natural daylight is an inexpensive and very efficient light source provided that the amount of daylight entering a building is controlled according to demand. In commercial buildings electricity for lighting can be cut by 50-75% using daylighting design techniques in combination with efficient artificial lighting. New lighting control technologies and advanced computer simulation tools lo optimize large buildings makes it possible to exploit these energy savings.

Daylight is a very efficient light source, providing more light for less input of thermal energy than any other artificial light source. Efficient shading systems are now emerging systems that can control the admission of daylight to the room according to requirement, and avoid overheating. Some of these systems, such as reflective light shelves, will also contribute to a better distribution of the daylight available by redistributing some daylight to the back of the room. However, more work is needed to develop and test such combined daylight and shading systems.

The use of daylight to reduce electric lighting must be seen as an integrated part of the overall energy optimization of the building. An efficient control of the use of daylight and artificial lighting will not only reduce electricity use for lighting. Additionally, the use of electricity for ventilation and cooling can be reduced also, because the internal heat gains provocating these electricity uses are reduced. This calls for an integrated design approach to the overall energy design of the building, involving the architect and the engineer from the very beginning of the design phase.

Visual comfort of office buildings receives increasing attention, partially because of the VDU's (Visual Display Units) of the computers, that are now almost standard equipment of every work place. The performance requirements for both daylighting systems and artificial lighting systems have been sharpened, and the attention to this fact is crucial in future development of lighting systems.     

Efficient venetian blind control strategies considering daylight utilization and glare protection

This paper presents the development of new venetian blind control strategies considering daylight provision, lighting energy use and visual comfort. A hybrid ray-tracing and radiosity method is used to calculate transmission through the window-blind system and interior illuminance distributions taking into account specular and diffuse material properties. Work plane illuminances are used to extract daylighting metrics, while directional light distribution and respective luminance values are used to calculate glare potential. Four types of control strategies were evaluated – a cut-off angle control, a daylight-redirecting control, and two glare protection control modes. Using the common “cut-off” angle may result in a strong second reflection that might significantly affect visual discomfort depending on view direction and profile angle. Proper rotation of the tilt angle and consideration of specular characteristics can minimize this effect and redistribute daylight deeper into the space, although glare problems cannot be eliminated in some cases. Moreover, two additional control strategies were developed based on glare probability and sky conditions: the first is a model-based control derived from real time glare simulation results. The second is a “simplified” control that uses pre-calculated correlations between glare probability and transmitted illuminance to establish binary set points that can be used in model-predictive control algorithms.A detailed daylighting analysis was performed in order to evaluate set points for blind control actions, annual daylighting metrics, lighting energy use and daylight glare probability and duration. Different room sizes, glazing properties, blind material characteristics and orientations were studied. The results showed that diffuse blinds do not reduce the risk of glare when light redirection is desired; double-sided slats with a diffuse top and a specular bottom surface are better in this regard. Fixed angles at 60° or higher provide satisfactory results for most cases, although there is a penalty in daylighting efficiency. The two glare protection control algorithms proved to be efficient in providing high daylight autonomy values without the risk of glare for all studied cases.     

Energy and cost analysis of semi-transparent photovoltaic in office buildings

Solar energy conversion systems and daylighting schemes are important building energy strategies to produce clean energy, reduce the peak electrical and cooling demands and save the building electricity expenditures. A semi-transparent photovoltaic (PV) is a building component generating electricity via PV modules and allowing daylight entering into the interior spaces to facilitate daylighting designs. This paper studies the thermal and visual properties, energy performance and financial issue of such solar facades. Data measurements including solar irradiance, daylight illuminance and output power for a semi-transparent PV panel were undertaken. Using the recorded results, essential parameters pertaining to the power generation, thermal and optical characteristics of the PV system were determined. Case studies based on a generic reference office building were conducted to elaborate the energy and cooling requirements, and the cost implications when the PV facades together with the daylight-linked lighting controls were being used. The findings showed that such an integrated system could produce electricity and cut down electric lighting and cooling energy requirements to benefit the environmental, energy and economic aspects.     

Performance prediction and design optimisation of an integrated light pipe and artificial lighting system

This paper describes recent research on the prediction of the performance of light pipes and the ways to optimise their design, in order to house artificial lighting, able to supplement daylight in a space. The research has resulted in an algorithm, for the easy and quick calculation of the interior illuminance provided by light pipes, and in a procedure for the calculation of the power of the necessary artificial lighting (light emitting diodes [LEDs]) and the energy savings for lighting, due to the daylight provided by the light pipes and the daylight linked controls of the LEDs.     

An analysis of energy-efficient light fittings and lighting controls

Electric lighting is one of the major energy consuming items in many non-domestic buildings. Using appropriate energy-efficient light fittings with dimming controls and proper daylighting schemes can help reduce the electrical demand and contribute to visual comfort and green building development. This paper presents a study on the energy and lighting performances for energy-efficient fluorescent lamps associated with electronic ballasts and high frequency photoelectric dimming controls installed in a school building. Electricity expenditures and indoor illuminance levels for a workshop and a classroom employing high frequency dimming controls were analyzed. Simple prediction methods were used to illustrate the lighting savings. The findings provide the operational and performance information, which would be applicable to other spaces with similar building layouts and lighting schemes.     

Predicting daylight illuminance on inclined surfaces using sky luminance data

Daylight illuminance, particularly on vertical surfaces, plays a major role in determining and evaluating the daylighting performance of a building. In many parts of the world, however, the basic daylight illuminance data for various vertical planes are not always readily available. The usual method to obtain diffuse illuminance on tilted planes would be based on inclined surfaces models using data from the horizontal measurements. Alternatively, the diffuse illuminance on a sloping plane can be computed by integrating the luminance distribution of the sky ‘seen’ by the plane. This paper presents an approach to estimate the vertical outdoor illuminance from sky luminance data and solar geometry. Sky luminance data recorded from January 1999 to December 2001 in Hong Kong and generated by two well-known sky luminance models (Kittler and Perez) were used to compute the outdoor illuminance for the four principal vertical planes (N, E, S and W). The performance of this approach was evaluated against data measured in the same period. Statistical analysis indicated that using sky luminance distributions to predict outdoor illuminance can give reasonably good agreement with measured data for all vertical surfaces. The findings provide an accurate alternative to determine the amount of daylight on vertical as well as other inclined surfaces when sky luminance data are available.     

Application of automated blind for daylighting in tropical region

This paper reports an experimental and simulation study on application of automated Venetian blind for daylighting in tropical climate. A horizontal blind system operating automatically under programmed control was constructed and integrated onto the glazed windows to form a window system with an automated blind in a room of a laboratory building. A dimming controller was also integrated to the lighting system of the room. Different operation schemes of the window system were devised and tested in the attempt to maximize energy savings while maintaining the quality of the visual environment in the room. Intensive measurement of illuminance of the interior space was undertaken during the experiments. A methodology for calculation of interior daylight illuminance and associated glare corresponding to the configurations of the experiments was adopted. The method was coded into a computer program. Results of calculation from the program agree well with those from experiments for all the schemes of operation conducted. The program was used to simulate the situation when each scheme of operation was implemented for a whole year. It was found that such window system with automated blind enabled energy savings of 80%, but a more sophisticated scheme also helped maintain the interior visual quality at high level.     

Estimation of exterior vertical daylight for the humid tropic of Kota Kinabalu city in East Malaysia

In tropical regions natural daylight has been a fundamental factor in building design. It is the most efficient way of lighting a building in the daytime and has a great potential for energy conservation in buildings. In Malaysia there are a limited available data of measured illuminance which is the case of several regions in the tropics. Using established models it is possible to predict the luminous efficacy and then estimate the monthly mean hourly exterior illuminance. In this study two different models were chosen. The Perez and Du Mortier–Perraudeau–Page–Littlefair models were selected for the prediction of hourly exterior horizontal illuminance for the city of Kota Kinabalu in East Malaysia. Comparison between the two models were made. The vertical hourly illuminance was predicted also using Perez approach. The potentiality of daylight in four orientations was discussed. This study highlights the importance of Sunpath diagram on daylight illuminance during the conceptual design stage. The results in this study is hoped to contribute further insight into the potentiality of daylighting of tropical sky.     

Lighting controls: Their current use and possible improvement

The use of automatic lighting controls to modify artificial lighting consumption, either to implement the concepts of Permanent Supplementary Artificial Lighting or to save energy, has been previously proposed by several authors. However, since little quantitative evidence of likely benefits exists, implementation of the proposals has been rare. the increased cost of energy has renewed interest and recent studies at the Building Research Station have attempted to: (a) decide if the use of photoelectric controls would save energy; and (b) define the situations where this might be done cost effectively. A [broad brush] picture of likely waste was obtained by a survey of about 200 offices, visited on at least five occasions each, over the course of several months. the illuminance at desk positions and the prevailing switching conditions were noted, and an estimate of waste was calculated by comparing the data with the known design illuminance. More detailed information of lighting use and apparent waste was obtained by [time-lapse photography] in seven installations; three offices and four teaching areas of different depths and occupancy patterns. Here, waste associated with excessive use during daylight hours and use during unoccupied periods could be isolated and savings predicted for the use of automatic photoelectric controls and time switches. The available hardware for such control has been surveyed and its cost effectiveness investigated in general terms for several types of installation. Predicted savings have been calculated using a simple model of available daylight and it is expected that analysis of more recent meteorological data will provide more precise estimates. the validity of using [daylight factors] as an effective control parameter in these calculations is also being investigated. The results of the studies outlined above are being assessed by installing control equipment in several real working interiors, including three of those originally monitored by [time-lapse] cameras. Energy consumption and user acceptability are being monitored and preliminary results on both counts are promising.     

Daylight performance of lightpipes

Increasing the use of natural daylight for lighting purposes in buildings can offer large savings in electricity usage, up to 20–30% of total building energy consumption. One solution is the use of lightpipes that can not only bring light into otherwise inaccessible or dimly lit places, but also improve the internal environment without generating excessive heat. The performance of six light pipes has been monitored in three different areas, a workshop, a residential landing, and a small office. The highest illuminance was 1538 lux, obtained underneath the straight lightpipe on the landing, with an aspect ratio of 2.1. The lowest was 41 lux in the darkest corner of the workshop. The average illuminance for the whole landing was 366 lux and a mean internal to external ratio of 0.48%. The results show that lightpipes are proficient devices for introducing daylight into buildings, the most effective lightpipes being straight, short ones with low aspect ratios; consequently, larger diameter lightpipes would probably be more effective. However, the benefits of lightpipes also include energy savings, user satisfaction and a healthier and improved indoor environment.     

Evaluation of a large dish‐type concentrator solar lighting system for underground car park

To utilize solar energy more efficiently and reduce lighting power consumption in underground public spaces such as car park, a large dish‐type concentrator solar lighting system is put forward along with its evaluation, which is a unique design to apply a laminated layer of beam split thin‐film coating and thin‐film solar cells onto the dish reflector. The collected sunlight is split into 2 parts, one being reflected into a fiber optical bundle and transmitted for daylighting, while the rest being absorbed by solar cells for electricity generation as the other way to replenish daylighting. A set of 4 solar lighting systems using 3.28‐m diameter dish are designed to meet the lighting requirement in a 1771‐m² underground car park. A mathematical model is adopted to calculate the output power and conversion efficiency of solar cells distributed on the parabolic dish surface. The indoor illuminance distribution is given by lighting simulation. The results indicate that the average daylight illuminance in the car park can vary between 62.7 and 284 lx on February 25, 2016 and between 62.7 and 353 lx on August 17, 2016 for 2 chosen days, respectively. For the presented design, the electricity produced by solar cells is just enough to power light‐emitting diodes for lighting meeting a criterion at night. Considering about 19% conversion efficiency of solar cells and the efficacy of 129.5 lm/W of light‐emitting diodes, the hybrid solar lighting system can have about 40% utilization ratio of solar energy, so it can be concluded that a sufficient lighting provision can be provided by the proposed large dish‐type concentrator solar lighting system for applications in underground car park.     

The availability of daylight from tropical skies—a case study of Malaysia

In Malaysia, no long-term daylight data are measured. It was only recently that the need to measure the availability of daylight became urgent when the importance of daylighting in buildings was rediscovered. The hourly daylight availability has been simulated for the Malaysian sky using daylight modelling techniques based on empirical and measured solar irradiation and cloud cover data. This paper presents the techniques involved in producing exterior illuminance data. These data were then compared with measured illuminance at Shah Alam and Bangi, Malaysia. The global illuminance levels are generally high, with values exceeding 80,000 lux at noon during the months when solar irradiation is highest. Even during the months when the ground receives less solar irradiation, the peak illuminance can reach 60,000 lux. Applications and uses of such data are in daylighting design, both for visual and thermal comfort, task illuminance and energy-conscious design of buildings. Recommendations are made at the end of the paper on the various climatic data that are required to be measured for overall daylighting design applications.