Capital cost and economic viability of thermosyphonic solar water heaters manufactured from alternate materials in India

Many companies in India manufacture solar water heaters but these are not becoming popular in the domestic sector because of their high cost. The Ministry of Non-Conventional Energy Sources (MNES), New Delhi is recommending flat-plate collectors with copper (Cu) risers, headers and plate. Therefore, their cost is high. Long term studies have been carried out at the Central Arid Zone Research Institute, Jodhpur, to reduce the cost by replacing copper tubes with galvanised steel (G.S.) tube and copper plate with aluminium (Al) plate. The aluminium plate is wrapped over the G.S. tube by a special wire wound technique so that good contact of plate with risers and headers has been maintained. In this paper performance and testing of solar water heaters having G.S.–Al fin, Cu–Al fin and Cu–Cu fin in flat-plate collectors have been compared. It has been found that performance of all the three heaters is almost similar. The heater can provide 100 litres of hot water at an average temperature 62.0°C at 4 pm that can be retained to 50.4°C when average tap water temperature was 23.9°C. The efficiency of the heater is 51.9%. The cost of the heater with G.S.–Al collector is only Rs. 8,000.00 while it is Rs. 10,250.00 for solar water heaters with Cu–Cu collectors. The payback period of a solar water heater with G.S.–Al collector has been worked out by considering 10% compound annual interest, 5% maintenance cost, 5%, inflation in fuel prices and maintenance cost. The payback period varies between 2.92 years to 4.53 years depending upon which fuel it replaces. The payback periods are in increasing order with respect to fuels: electricity, firewood, LPG, charcoal, and kerosene.     

Performance and testing of large-size solar water heater cum solar cooker

The performance of a novel device has been tested. The device can be used as a collector cum storage type solar water heater during the winter, and, with minor adjustments, it can be used as a hot-box solar cooker. The device can provide hot water at 50–60°C in the evening, which can be maintained at 40–45°C until the following morning. It can also be used for cooking food for about 40 people. The efficiencies of the device as a solar water heater and as a solar cooker have been found to be 67.7% and 29.8%, respectively. The payback period varies between 1.64 to 5.90 years depending on the fuel it replaces. The payback periods are of increasing length with respect to the fuels firewood, coal, electricity, LPG and kerosene.     

Life cycle cost analysis of single slope hybrid (PV/T) active solar still

This paper presents the life cycle cost analysis of the single slope passive and hybrid photovoltaic (PV/T) active solar stills, based on the annual performance at 0.05 m water depth. Effects of various parameters, namely interest rate, life of the system and the maintenance cost have been taken into account. The comparative cost of distilled water produced from passive solar still (Rs. 0.70/kg) is found to be less than hybrid (PV/T) active solar still (Rs. 1.93/kg) for 30 years life time of the systems. The payback periods of the passive and hybrid (PV/T) active solar still are estimated to be in the range of 1.1–6.2 years and 3.3–23.9 years, respectively, based on selling price of distilled water in the range of Rs. 10/kg to Rs. 2/kg. The energy payback time (EPBT) has been estimated as 2.9 and 4.7 years, respectively.     

A low cost collector-cum-storage type solar water heater

A low cost collector-cum-storage type solar water heater has been developed. The cost of the heater is reduced by replacing window glass cover with 0.2 mm thick PVC film to avoid glass breakage in transportation and maintenance. In this paper the performances of solar water heaters having double glazing of PVC and glass have been compared. It was found that their performances are similar. Moreover, by providing an insulating cover in the night, the water remains warm till next morning for taking a bath etc. in the early hours when there is no sunshine.     

Experimental observations on a continuous flow type domestic solar water heater

The operation of a continuous flow type domestic solar water heater is explained with the help of a schematic diagram. Steady state thermal analysis of such a water heater is carried out. A water heater of this type with a collector area of 1 m² is subjected to tests. The experimental results are compared with predicted results. The experimental results have also been compared with those obtained from a water heater operating on thermosiphon flow. The performance of the continuous flow type water heater is shown to be comparable to that of the thermosiphon flow type. It is concluded that, in the Indian context, the continuous flow type water heater has more advantages than the thermosiphon flow type water heater in view of its low capital cost and the ease of operation and maintenance.     

Thermal optimisation of a built-in storage solar water heater

A simple transient analysis of a built-in storage solar water heater is presented; the results obtained by the present theory are in close agreement with experimental observations as well as with predictions obtained by a more rigorous theory. The water heater consits of an insulated rectangular tank whose top surface is suitably blackened by blackboard paint and then glazed. The unit is exposed to solar radiation during sunshine hours and is covered by adequate insulation at night. The effect of insulation thicknesses (top and bottom insulation) and water mass in the tank is discussed. The importance of using a reflecting sheet instead of insulation is emphasised.     

Year round performance of a cylindrical solar water heater

A cylindrical collector-cum-storage type solar water heater has been designed, developed and tested. Its year round performance has been carried out and reported in this paper. The heater can provide 50 litres of hot water at 50–60°C in the afternoon and a temperature of 35°C can be retained till the next day for early morning use. The heater receives approximately 30% more radiation as compared to a flat surface. The economics of the heater has been worked out and it has been found that the cost can be recovered within one year.     

Performance studies of a large size nontracking solar cooker

A large size nontracking solar cooker has been designed, fabricated and tested. The cooker is based on the hot box principle. The cooker has been tested extensively and its performance has been compared with a solar oven, a hot box solar cooker and a solar cooker (tilted absorber). The stagnation temperatures are in increasing order for the hot box solar cooker, the solar cooker (tilted absorber), the large size nontracking solar cooker and the solar oven. The performance of this solar cooker is comparable with that of a solar oven. The former is not tracked towards sun while the latter is tracked every 30 min. The efficiency of a large size nontracking solar cooker is 24.9%. The energy saved by this new solar cooker has also been calculated and its payback period has been computed by considering interest, maintenance and inflation in fuel prices and maintenance cost. The payback periods are 1.10–3.63 years depending on which fuel it replaces. Relatively short payback periods show that the use of the cooker is economical, and it is easy to operate since no tracking is required.     

Effective solar radiation based benefit and cost analyses for solar water heater development in Taiwan

To reduce greenhouse gases emissions, promoting solar water heaters (SWHs) has become an essential national policy in Taiwan. To implement this policy effectively, the applicability of SWHs in different regions must be analyzed. Previous studies generally performed SWH benefit-cost analyses based on total annual solar radiation; however, this method may overestimate energy production benefits because, for an SWH, the solar energy captured today cannot be preserved. Therefore, this study proposes the concept of effective solar radiation (ESR), which is based on potential heat output estimated using tap water temperature and solar radiation in each region. The benefits of SWHs are then assessed based on the number of effective days and ESR, instead of using total annual solar radiation. A procedure is established to evaluate the applicability of SWHs in each region based on proposed benefit-cost analyses. Possible outcomes of a national SWH program are estimated. The sensitivities of essential factors, including collector efficiency, installation cost, and discount rate, are also analyzed. Analytical results show that the ratios of ESR to total annual solar radiation for regions in Taiwan are about 82-89%. The payback periods vary at 6-15 years for different regions and heater types being replaced. The national program is expected to reduce greenhouse gases emissions by approximately 150,000 tons eCO₂ annually.     

Techno-economic feasibility analysis of solar thermal systems

This communication introduces the basic concepts for techno-economic feasibility assessment of various solar thermal systems in a dynamic and market oriented economic environment. An analytical expression for calculating the payback period is derived by assuming a non-linear increase in maintenance cost and incorporating subsidy and salvage values. Further, a method is evolved to ascertain the lifetime of the system for an optimal return on investment mode, incorporating capital inflation during the lifetime and a non-linear increase in maintenance cost. The results for the payback period have been used, along with the lifetime, to optimize the cost of the system.     

Study of a solar water heater using stationary V-trough collector

There are various types of solar water heater system available in the commercial market to fulfill different customers’ demand, such as flat plate collector, concentrating collector, evacuated tube collector and integrated collector storage. A cost effective cum easy fabricated V-trough solar water heater system using forced circulation system is proposed. Integrating the solar absorber with the easily fabricated V-trough reflector can improve the performance of solar water heater system. In this paper, optical analysis, experimental study and cost analysis of the stationary V-trough solar water heater system are presented in details. The experimental result has shown very promising results in both optical efficiency of V-trough reflector and the overall thermal performance of the solar water heater.     

Review on solar water heater collector and thermal energy performance of circulating pipe

The effect of thermal conductivity of the absorber plate of a solar collector on the performance of a thermo-siphon solar water heater is found by using the alternative simulation system. The system is assumed to be supplied of hot water at 50 °C and 80 °C whereas both are used in domestic and industrial purposes, respectively. According to the Rand distribution profile 50, 125 and 250 l of hot water are consumed daily. The condition shows that the annual solar fraction of the planning functions and the collector's configuration factors are strongly dependent on the thermal conductivity for its lower values. The less dependence is observed beyond a thermal conductivity of 50 W/m °C for the solar improper fraction and above 100 W/m °C for the configuration factors. In addition, the number of air ducts and total mass flow rate are taken to show that higher collector efficiency is obtained under the suitable designing and operating parameters. Different heat transfer mechanisms, adding natural convection, vapor boiling, cell nucleus boiling and film wise condensation is observed in the thermo-siphon solar water heater with various solar radiations. From this study, it is found that the solar water heater with a siphon system achieves system characteristic efficiency of 18% higher than that of the conventional system by reducing heat loss for the thermo-siphon solar water heater.     

Economic analysis of power generation from parabolic trough solar thermal plants for the Mediterranean region—A case study for the island of Cyprus

In this work a feasibility study is carried out in order to investigate whether the installation of a parabolic trough solar thermal technology for power generation in the Mediterranean region is economically feasible. The case study takes into account the available solar potential for Cyprus, as well as all available data concerning current renewable energy sources policy of the Cyprus Government, including the relevant feed-in tariff. In order to identify the least cost feasible option for the installation of the parabolic trough solar thermal plant a parametric cost–benefit analysis is carried out by varying parameters, such as, parabolic trough solar thermal plant capacity, parabolic trough solar thermal capital investment, operating hours, carbon dioxide emission trading system price, etc. For all above cases the electricity unit cost or benefit before tax, as well as after tax cash flow, net present value, internal rate of return and payback period are calculated. The results indicate that under certain conditions such projects can be profitable.     

Year-round performance of an improved collector-cum-storage type solar water heater

Systematic studies have been carried out on collector-cum-storage type solar water heaters, and efforts were made to minimise heat losses so that this type of water heater can be used for getting hot water at 40°–45°C for taking baths in the early morning hours of the next day. This paper reports year round performace, the performance equation and economics of this new improved solar water heater. This heater can supply 100 litres of hot water at 60°–70°C in the afternoon, and 40°–45°C temperature can be retained till next day morning. Its efficiency is 70.1%.     

Technoeconomic optimization of solar natural convection hybrid hot water systems

In this paper a techno-economic model for a hybrid domestic hot water system operating under natural convection mode is presented. Three modes of auxiliary energy supply viz.

• A electric heater fitted in the solar hot water tank.
• B electric heater fitted in a small water tank in series with the solar hot water tank, and
• C an instant electric heater fitted in the tap

have been considered. Taking into account the life and the capital and maintenance costs of the solar and electrical equipments, the cost of useful energy (Rs/kWh) has been calculated for different values of the collector area and the tank capacity, and thereby the optimum collector area and tank capacity (for a given demand), corresponding to minimum cost of useful energy, has been determined. From numerical calculations made for the climate of Delhi, India (a representative composite climate) corresponding to the two cases of monthly hot water demand viz. (i) constant monthly demand, and (ii) variable monthly demand, it is seen that case (C) is the most economic design of the hybrid hot water system; numerical calculations have also been made for this case corresponding to the climates of Srinagar and Madras (representing cold and hot climates). The effect of government subsidy on the optimized values of collector area, tank capacity and cost of useful energy has also been investigated for the climate of Delhi.     

Incentives for solar water heating systems

Life-cycle costing has been used in an economic analysis of three solar domestic hot water installations. These are in operation in Las Palmas (Canary Islands) and are backed by conventional installations consuming either fuel-oil (GG), butane (BB) or electricity (EE). The cumulative cost flows (CCF), including expenditures for purchase, recovery, maintenance, fuel and operating costs, are calculated over the useful life of the installations for expected annual fuel-increment rates. Twenty-seven comparisons are made between the solar (SAS) and conventional systems (CS). Total savings are found over the lifetime and the repayment periods are obtained as a function of discount rate. The SAS and CS are examined with respect to economic incentives such as subvention, tax deduction, loans and their combinations. Finally, the variations of the payback periods and rates of return on investment (IRR) are plotted against the fuel price, annual fuel increment rate and initial investment in the SAS for a wide range of economic parameters.     

Thermal performance, economic and environmental life cycle analysis of thermosiphon solar water heaters

In this paper, the environmental benefits or renewable energy systems are initially presented followed by a study of the thermal performance, economics and environmental protection offered by thermosiphon solar water heating systems. The system investigated is of the domestic size, suitable to satisfy most of the hot water needs of a family of four persons. The results presented in this paper show that considerable percentage of the hot water needs of the family are covered with solar energy. This is expressed as the solar contribution and its annual value is 79%. Additionally, the system investigated give positive and very promising financial characteristics with payback time of 2.7 years and life cycle savings of 2240 € with electricity backup and payback time of 4.5 years and life cycle savings of 1056 € with diesel backup. From the results it can also be shown that by using solar energy considerable amounts of greenhouse polluting gasses are avoided. The saving, compared to a conventional system, is about 70% for electricity or diesel backup. With respect to life cycle assessment of the systems, the energy spent for the manufacture and installation of the solar systems is recouped in about 13 months, whereas the payback time with respect to emissions produced from the embodied energy required for the manufacture and installation of the systems varies from a few months to 3.2 years according to the fuel and the particular pollutant considered. It can therefore be concluded that thermosiphon solar water hearting systems offer significant protection to the environment and should be employed whenever possible in order to achieve a sustainable future.     

Influence of collector plate temperature gradient on solar heater performance

This communication deals with the effect of a temperature gradient, due to difference in temperatures of sunlit collector surface and the surface in contact with the working fluid (heat exchanger fluid), on the performance of solar water heater. The analysis is not restricted to any particular configuration of solar heater. Experimental study of a spiral solar water heater confirms the theoretical prediction of thermal loss with temperature gradient.     

Optimization of a hybrid solar forced-convection water heating system

In this paper, a techno-economic model has been developed for a hybrid solar forced-convection water heating system. Two options of auxiliary energy use, viz. (A) an instant electric heater and (B) use of diesel as the auxiliary energy fuel, have been considered. Numerical calculations have been made for the climate of Delhi, India, corresponding to the two representative demand patterns, viz. (i) hot-water demand of big residential buildings and (ii) industrial hot-water demand. Taking into account the life, capital cost and the maintenance cost of the solar and auxiliary systems, the cost of useful energy has been calculated for different values of collector area and tank capacity. This exercise, thereby, yields the optimum values of collector area and tank capacity corresponding to the minimum cost of useful energy. The effect of government subsidy on the optimized values of collector area, tank capacity and cost of useful energy has also been investigated.     

Performance evaluation of a passive solar building in Western Himalayas

Under the Passive Solar Building Programme, more than 100 buildings have been constructed in the high altitude region of the Indian State of Himachal Pradesh. A policy decision has been taken by the State that all government/semi-government buildings are to be designed and constructed as per passive solar housing technology. The evaluation studies of some of these buildings have been carried out by our group. In the present study, the thermal performance of a passive solar bank building at Shimla, has been evaluated. This solar building incorporates a heat-collecting wall and a roof-top solar air heater with an electric heating backup, sunspaces and double-glazed windows. The monitoring of the building shows that the solar passive features in the building results in comfortable living conditions. The study shows that the high cost central electric/gas/wood-fired heating systems can be replaced by a low cost solar heating system with backup heaters. This will result not only in reducing higher installation costs of these systems but also the annual running and maintenance costs. It is shown that the solar passive features save electricity required for space heating and reduce the heat losses in the building by about 35%. The strategy to be followed for the propagation of passive solar technology on large scale in this Himalayan State or in any other cold hilly region is also presented.