Solar seasonal thermal energy storage for space heating in residential buildings: Optimization and comparison with an air-source heat pump

ABSTRACT

This study evaluates the techno-economics of replacing an air-source heat pump (ASHP) system with a solar seasonal thermal energy storage (STES) system for space heating in Hangzhou, China. Three heating systems, solar STES, ASHP, and ASHP with short-term storage of solar energy, are developed using TRNSYS for a house with 240 m² of floor area. The ratio of tank volume to collector area (RVA) of the STES is optimized for the lowest equivalent annual cost over a lifespan of 20 y. The determined optimal RVA is 0.33 m³/m², although it depends on the system and electricity prices. The optimized STES reduces the electricity demand to 1,269 kWh (74% reduction). Despite the superior energy performance, the economic benefit is only possible with large STES systems, which enjoy low tank prices due to scale effects. The results suggest that policy support is needed for STES, where district scaling is not an option.     

A thermo-economical optimization of a domestic solar heating plant with seasonal storage

In this study, the thermo-economic optimization analysis to determinate economically optimal dimensions of collector area and storage volume in domestic solar heating systems with seasonal storage is presented. For this purpose, a formulation based on the simplified P₁ and P₂ method is developed and solved by using MATLAB optimization Toolbox for five climatically different locations of Turkey. The results showed that the required optimum collector area in Adana (37 °N) for reaching maximum savings is 36 m²/house and 65 m²/house in Erzurum (39 °N) for same storage volume (1000 m³). The effects of collector efficiency on solar fraction and savings are investigated. The simulation results showed that the solar fraction and savings of the selective flat plate collector systems are higher than the other black paint flat plate collector systems.     

Performance optimization of evacuated tube collector for solar cooling of a house in hot climate

Evacuating the space connecting cover and absorber significantly improves evacuated tube collector (ETC) performance. So, ETCs are progressively utilised all over the world. The main goal of current study is to explore ETC thermal efficiency in hot and severe climate like Kuwait weather conditions. A collector test facility was installed to record ETC thermal performance for one-year period. An extensively developed model for ETCs is presented, employing complete optical and thermal assessment. This study analyses separately optics and heat transfer in the evacuated tubes, allowing the analysis to be extended to different configurations. The predictions obtained are in agreement with experimental. The optimum collector parameters (collector tube length and diameter, mass flow rate and collector tilt angle) are determined. The present results indicate that the optimum tube length is 1.5 m, as at this length a significant improvement is achieved in efficiency for different tube diameters studied. Finally, the heat generated from ETCs is used for solar cooling of a house. Results of the simulation of cooling system indicate that an ETC of area 54 m², tilt angle of 25° and storage tank volume of 2.1 m³ provides 80% of air-conditioning demand in a house located in Kuwait.     

Central solar heating plants with seasonal duct storage and short-term water storage: design guidelines obtained by dynamic system simulations

A central solar heating plant with seasonal ground storage is analysed by dynamic system simulations. A reference system, involving a collector area, water buffer storage and ground duct storage, is defined for typical Swiss conditions and simulated for several types of heat load. A methodology is established for the optimisation of the main system parameters. The thermal behaviour of such a system is highlighted. The short-term heat requirements are covered by the buffer unit, whereas the seasonal heat requirements are covered by the ground duct storage. As a consequence, a system such as this is intended to supply a large solar fraction (>50%). Optimal ratios between the main system parameters are sought for an annual solar fraction of 70%. An optimal buffer volume of 110 to 130 l per m² of collector area is obtained. The optimal duct storage volume and collector area vary respectively from 4 to 13 m³ per m² of collector area and from 2 to 4 m² per MWh (3.6 GJ) of annual heat demand. They depend mainly on the specific heat losses from the duct storage unit. A large annual heat demand (>3600 GJ or 1000 MWh) and/or low temperatures in the heat distribution are essential for satisfactory system thermal performance. The spacing of the boreholes which form the ground heat exchanger of the duct store is fairly constant and is found to be about 2.5 m for a ground thermal conductivity of 2.5 Wm⁻¹ K⁻¹. Some improvements of the system control are also investigated to assess the influence on the overall thermal performances of the system. They indicate that the system thermal performances are only slightly improved in contrast to the improvement brought by a simple but optimised system control.     

Is there a need for a rock bed store? Simulation and optimization of solar air heating systems for offices with large thermal capacity walls

A solar air heating system is designed for a floor of 120 m² offices, with large thermal capacity walls, in Israel. A constant air volume system is chosen for its operational simplicity. Representative winter hourly weather data are used to calculate the heating load. The building behavior is modeled in detail with dynamic wall and room temperatures which are linked to the heat input. The heat losses are found to be primarily (70–75%) due to storage in the walls for two different values of wall heat capacity and for two design temperatures (19° and 20°C). The paper deals with the operational details, seasonal performance and economics of the system. Multivariate optimization is carried out using the Simplex method. Optimum collector area, store volume and air flow rate of 30 m², 2–3 m³ and 0.5 kg s⁻¹, respectively, are not affected by economic predictions. A comparison of this system with one which omits the rock bed store and uses only the building material as storage is also made. Results show that for the higher design temperaturre of 20°C, the rock bed store improves system performance, but the same solar fraction can be achieved by increasing the collector area from 30 to 50 m² in the system without active storage. For the lower design temperature of 19°C the improvement in performance made by the addition of the rock bed store is small, and can be obtained by increasing the collector area from 30 to 40 m², obviating the need for the store system. In buildings with a high heat capacity, operated during daytime only, the no-active-store system is recommended for its ease of operation and suitability for retrofitting.     

Performance analysis and cost optimization of a solar-assisted heat pump system

A solar-assisted heat pump system with a conventional backup unit was simulated for a 93 m² (1000 ft²) house in Rhode Island using quasi-dynamic computer models. The performance of the system as a function of collector area and thermal storage volume was evaluated to determine the fraction of the space heating and domestic hot water load that was supplied by the solar-assisted system. This information was used to compute the payback time, based on cumulative costs, for each variation of the system's parameters when compared to a conventional system. The optimal combination of system components which had a payback time less than the mortgage life was determined. For the given initial costs of solar panels and storage reservoir, this optimal combination was found to be insensitive to the variations in mortgage and fuel cost growth rates presented in this report.     

Dimensioning of the solar heating system in the zero energy house in Denmark

The paper describes the project for a Zero Energy House constructed at the Technical University of Denmark. The house is designed and constructed in such a way that it can be heated all winter without any “artificial” energy supply, the main source being solar energy. With energy conservation arrangements, such as high-insulated constructions (30–40 cm mineral wool insulation), movable insulation of the windows and heat recovery in the ventilating system, the total heat requirement for space heating is calculated to 2300 kWh per year. For a typical, well insulated, one-storied, one-family house built in Denmark, the corresponding heat requirement is 20,000 kWh. The solar heating system is dimensioned to cover the heat requirements and the hot water supply for the Zero Energy House during the whole year on the basis of the weather data in the “Reference Year”. The solar heating system consists of a 42 m² flat-plate solar collector, a 30 m³ water storage tank (insulated with 60 cm of mineral wool), and a heat distribution system. A total heat balance is set up for the system and solved for each day of the “Reference Year”. Collected and accumulated solar energy in the system is about 7300 kWh per yr; 30 per cent of the collected energy is used for space heating, 30 per cent for hot water supply, and 40 per cent is heat loss from the accumulator tank. For the operation of the solar heating system, the pumps and valves need a conventional electric energy supply of 230 kWh per year (corresponding to 5 per cent of the useful solar energy).     

A comparison of solar absorption system configurations

Solar thermal driven cooling systems for residential applications are a promising alternative to electric compression chillers, although its market introduction still represents a challenge, mainly due to the higher investment costs. The most common system configuration is an absorption chiller driven by a solar thermal system, backed up by a secondary heating source, normally a gas boiler. Heat storage in the primary (solar) circuit is mandatory to stabilize and extend the operation of the chiller, whereas a cold storage tank is not so common.This paper deals with the selection of the most suitable configuration for residential cooling systems with solar energy. In Spain, where cooling needs are usually higher than heating needs, the interest of a reversible heat pump as auxiliary system and a secondary cooling storage are analyzed.A complete TRNSYS model has been developed to compare a configuration with just hot storage (of typical capacity 40 L/m² of solar collector surface) and a configuration with both, hot and cool storages. The most suitable configuration is very sensible to the solar collector area. As the collector area increases, the advantages of a cool storage vanish. Increasing the collector area tends to increase the temperature of the hot storage, leading to higher thermal losses in both the collector and the tank. When the storage volume is concentrated in one tank, these effects are mitigated. The effect of other variables on the optimal configuration are also analyzed: collector efficiency curve, COP of the absorption chiller, storage size, and temperature set-points of the chillers.     

Study on a direct‐expansion solar‐assisted heat pump water heating system

Analytical and experimental studies were performed on a direct‐expansion solar‐assisted heat pump (DX‐SAHP) water heating system, in which a 2 m² bare flat collector acts as a source as well as an evaporator for the refrigerant. A simulation model was developed to predict the long‐term thermal performance of the system approximately. The monthly averaged COP was found to vary between 4 and 6, while the collector efficiency ranged from 40 to 60%. The simulated results were used to obtain an optimum design of the system and to determinate a proper strategy for system operating control. The effect of various parameters, including solar insolation, ambient temperature, collector area, storage volume and speed of compressor, had been investigated on the thermal performance of the DX‐SAHP system, and the results had indicated that the system performance is governed strongly by the change of solar insolation, collector area and speed of compressor. The experimental results obtained under winter climate conditions were shown to agree reasonably with the computer simulation. Copyright © 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Energy analysis and modeling of a solar assisted house heating system with a heat pump and an underground energy storage tank

An analytical model is presented and analyzed to predict the long term performance of a solar assisted house heating system with a heat pump and an underground spherical thermal energy storage tank. The system under investigation consists of a house, a heat pump, solar collectors and a storage tank. The present analytical model is based on a proper coupling of the individual energy models for the house, the heat pump, useful solar energy gain, and the transient heat transfer problem for the thermal energy storage tank. The transient heat transfer problem outside the energy storage tank is solved using a similarity transformation and Duhamel’s superposition principle. A computer code based on the present model is used to compute the performance parameters for the system under investigation. Results from the present study indicate that an operational time span of 5–7 years will be necessary before the system under investigation can attain an annually periodic operating condition. Results also indicate a decrease in the annually minimum value of the storage tank temperature with a decrease in the energy storage tank size and/or solar collector area.     

Heat gain reduction by means of thermoelectric roof solar collector

This paper presents a numerical investigation on attic heat gain reduction by using thermoelectric modules integrated in a conventional roof solar collector (RSC). This system, called thermoelectric roof solar collector (TE-RSC), is composed of a transparent glass, air gap, a copper plate, thermoelectric modules (TE) and rectangular fin heat sink. Due to the incident solar radiation, a temperature difference is created between the hot and cold sides of TE modules that generates a direct current. This current is used to drive a ventilating fan for cooling the TE-RSC and enhancing attic ventilation that reduces ceiling heat gain. The system performance was simulated using TRNSYS program with new TE and DC fan components developed by our team and compared to a common house.Simulation results using real house configuration showed that a TE-RSC unit of 0.0525 m² surface area can generate about 9 W under 972 W/m² global solar radiation and 35 °C ambient temperature. The induced air change varied between 20 and 40 and the corresponding ceiling heat transfer rate reduction is about 3–5 W/m². The annual electrical energy saving was about 362 kWh. Finally, economical calculations indicated that the payback period of the TE-RSC is 4.36 years and the internal rate of return is 22.05%.     

A Comparative Study of Community Solar Heating Systems for Northern High Latitudes

A computational performance study of community solar heating systems with seasonal storage in southern Finland (60^°N) has been accomplished. Computer simulations are carried out on an hour-by-hour basis and for four types of system configurations. The effect of collector type, storage volume, heat pump and collector area are investigated. The results of the study show that district solar heating systems may provide considerable solar fractions even in strict climatic conditions.     

Meeting the electricity demand for the heating of greenhouses with hydrogen: Solar photovoltaic-hydrogen-heat pump system application in Turkey

Providing the heating system with coal in greenhouses causes harmful results in terms of carbon emissions. In this study, analyzes were performed to meet the electrical energy required for the heating system with a heat pump from a solar photovoltaic-hydrogen system. For floor area 25000 m² where greenhouses the required energy is obtained directly from hydrogen without using a heat pump 3000 m² solar panel area required. The use of a heat pump reduces energy needs but it is also not feasible for large greenhouses. For convenience, a solar photovoltaic-hydrogen-heat pump system analysis was also made for 1000 m² floor area greenhouses and it is found that the 24 m² solar panel area is adequate in terms of meeting energy demand. Using a solar-hydrogen-heat pump system reduces carbon emissions by 86.5 tons per 1000 m² floor area greenhouse. Considering the hydrogen storage system becomes unfeasible. We normalized the greenhouse floor area to 1 m² and proposed reference values for hydrogen to be produced in 1 h, storage, and PV area. In addition, an analysis was made for the use of hydrogen energy for greenhouses that do not require a heating system and only work with a water pump.     

Optimization of a community solar heating system with a heat pump and seasonal storage

The optimization of a district solar heating system with an electric-driven heat pump and seasonal heat storage is discussed. The optimization process comprises thermal, economic and system control analyses. Thermal and economic optima have been derived for collector area and storage volume simultaneously. The effects of different collector types and building loads are also investigated. Summertime charging of the storage by off-peak electricity has been applied to avoid severe peaking of auxiliary in the winter and to reduce the yearly energy cost. The thermal co-storage of electric energy is emphasized with systems which fail to supply heat for the heat pump during the winter heating season.‡ It has been found that system cost-effectiveness is only slightly affected as storage volume is increased beyond the optimum size. Large variations in the optima for different system configurations were found. The minimum cost of heat supplied in an optimal 500-unit community with 90% solar fraction was estimated at 8.9 ¢ kWh⁻¹.     

Feasibility of solar pond heating for northern cold climates

A computational performance and feasibility study of the salt-gradient solar pond for residential heating in high-latitude and cold climates has been made using computer simulations with meteorological data characteristic to southern Finland (60°N). Freezing, snow coverage and surface insulation for wintertime are also considered in the computations. For an individual house with 100 m² living area, a solar pond of 3.5 m depth and 400 m² area would provide a solar fraction of 50 per cent without surface insulation and 75 per cent with surface insulation. A large pond for district heating would require about one third of the pond area per house as compared with an individual house. A heat pump would still reduce the pond size requirement.     

Simulation of an unglazed collector system for domestic hot water and space heating and cooling

This paper details modeling assumptions and simulation results for an unglazed collector system supplying domestic hot water, space heating, and space cooling loads. Collectors are modeled using unglazed collector test results. Variation of savings with collector area, storage volume, heat exchanger size, and wind for the Albuquerque, NM climate are shown. Over the storage-to-collector ratio range of 40–640 l/m² collector, annual savings varies only ±15%. Cooling is sensitive to heat exchanger size, and heating is sensitive to wind velocity. At a collector area of 23 m², the unglazed system meets about 56% of the annual total energy demand, saving 25.9 $/m² yr for an all-electric home. For the 23 m² area, savings for a cold/damp (Madison) and a hot/humid (Miami) climate are 64% and 56%, respectively, of the savings in Albuquerque.     

Experimental study of a compact PCM solar collector

The performance of a compact phase change material (PCM) solar collector based on latent heat storage was investigated. In this collector, the absorber plate–container unit performs the function of both absorbing the solar energy and storing PCM. The solar energy was stored in paraffin wax, which was used as a PCM, and was discharged to cold water flowing in pipes located inside the wax. The collector's effective area was assumed to be 1 m² and its total volume was divided into 5 sectors. The experimental apparatus was designed to simulate one of the collector's sectors, with an apparatus-absorber effective area of 0.2 m². Outdoor experiments were carried out to demonstrate the applicability of using a compact solar collector for water heating. The time-wise temperatures of the PCM were recorded during the processes of charging and discharging. The solar intensity was recorded during the charging process. Experiments were conducted for different water flow rates of 8.3–21.7 kg/h. The effect of the water flow rate on the useful heat gain (Qu) was studied. The heat transfer coefficients were calculated for the charging process. The propagation of the melting and freezing front was also studied during the charging and discharging processes. The experimental results showed that in the charging process, the average heat transfer coefficient increases sharply with increasing the molten layer thickness, as the natural convection grows strong. In the discharge process, the useful heat gain was found to increase as the water mass flow rate increases.     

Experimental evaluation of energy and exergy efficiency of a seasonal latent heat storage system for greenhouse heating

In the following work, a seasonal thermal energy storage using paraffin wax as a PCM with the latent heat storage technique was attempted to heat the greenhouse of 180 m² floor area. The system consists mainly of five units: (1) flat plate solar air collectors (as heat collection unit), (2) latent heat storage (LHS) unit, (3) experimental greenhouse, (4) heat transfer unit and (5) data acquisition unit. The external heat collection unit consisted of 27 m² of south facing solar air heaters mounted at a 55° tilt angle. The diameter and the total volume of the steel tank used as the latent heat storage unit were 1.7 m and 11.6 m³, respectively. The LHS unit was filled with 6000 kg of paraffin, equivalent to 33.33 kg of PCM per square meter of the greenhouse ground surface area. Energy and exergy analyses were applied in order to evaluate the system efficiency. The rate of heat transferred in the LHS unit ranged from 1.22 to 2.63 kW, whereas the rate of heat stored in the LHS unit was in the range of 0.65–2.1 kW. The average daily rate of thermal exergy transferred and stored in the LHS unit were 111.2 W and 79.9 W, respectively. During the experimental period, it was found that the average net energy and exergy efficiencies were 40.4% and 4.2%, respectively. The effect of the temperature difference of the heat transfer fluid at the inlet and outlet of the LHS unit on the computed values of the energy and exergy efficiency is evaluated during the charging period.     

1 MWth INDUSTRIAL SOLAR HOT WATER SYSTEM AND ITS PERFORMANCE

An industrial model solar water heating system is designed and installed, to heat and supply 110 000 liters of hot water at 85°C per day for an egg powder making plant. It consists of a solar collector field (2560 m²), four thermally insulated hot water storage tanks (57.5 m³ capacity each) and the heat distribution system with electrically operated pumps and pneumatic valves for circulation of water. It is equipped with a PC based data acquisition system to monitor the process parameters, a fault detection system to monitor the status of various subsystems and controls for automatic operation of the system. Performance studies conducted on the various subsystems and on the system as a whole revealed that it is delivering the designed thermal output, and the net savings in furnace oil consumption is 78% on an annual basis.     

Feasibility study of a solar-assisted heating/cooling system for an aquatic centre in hot and humid climates

This paper reports on a feasibility study of a solar-powered heating/cooling system for a swimming pool/space combination in a tropical environment. The system utilizes an absorption chiller and a cooling tower to meet the facilities and locker room load. The heating is accomplished by employing hot water generated by heat exchange with the solar collector working fluid. Two thermal storage tanks were employed for the collector and domestic use. The absorption chiller utilizes hot water to regenerate the LiBr solution. The proposed system enables the swimming season to be extended from sixteen weeks to fifty-two weeks. Simulation results indicate that a combination of a double glazed collector area of 600–4800 m² and a storage tank volume of 11·36 m³ results in a 25–37% reduction in the consumption of natural gas. Economic analysis is performed based on the life-cycle-cost method and takes into account the effects of discount rate, fuel price and fuel inflation rate. Different scenarios for which the solar-assisted system is economical are presented and analysed. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.