Textile-Reinforced Mortar versus FRP Jacketing in Seismic Retrofitting of RC Columns with Continuous or Lap-Spliced Deformed Bars

The effectiveness of a new structural material, namely, textile-reinforced mortar (TRM), was investigated experimentally in this study as a means of confining oldtype reinforced concrete (RC) columns with limited capacity due to bar buckling or due to bond failure at lap splice regions. Comparisons with equal stiffness and strength fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) jackets allow for the evaluation of the effectiveness of TRM versus FRP. Tests were carried out on nearly full scale nonseismically detailed RC columns subjected to cyclic uniaxial flexure under constant axial load. Ten cantilevertype specimens with either continuous or lap-spliced deformed longitudinal reinforcement at the floor level were constructed and tested. Experimental results indicated that TRM jacketing is quite effective as a means of increasing the cyclic deformation capacity of oldtype RC columns with poor detailing, by delaying bar buckling and by preventing splitting bond failures in columns with lap-spliced bars. Compared with their FRP counterparts, the TRM jackets used in this study were found to be equally effective in terms of increasing both the strength and deformation capacity of the retrofitted columns. From the response of specimens tested in this study, it can be concluded that TRM jacketing is an extremely promising solution for the confinement of reinforced concrete columns, including poorly detailed ones with or without lap splices in seismic regions.     

Experimental Performance of RC Hollow Columns Confined with CFRP

Column jacketing with fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite materials has been extensively investigated in the last decade to address the issue of seismic upgrade and retrofit of existing reinforced concrete (RC) columns. Researchers have mainly focused their attention on solid columns, while very little research has been done on hollow columns strengthened with FRP. To study the behavior of noncircular hollow cross sections subjected to combined axial load and bending and to contribute to the comprehension of the resistant mechanisms present in FRP confinement, a total of seven specimens have been tested. The present work is the first step in a broader endeavor aimed at evaluating the benefits generated by a FRP wrapping, computing (P-M) interaction diagrams for hollow columns confined with FRP, and defining design criteria for the strengthening of these elements using composite jackets. The theoretical analyses will also assess under which conditions the standard approaches for columns with solid cross sections could be extended to the case of hollow columns.     

Bond Strength of Lap-Spliced Bars in Concrete Confined with Composite Jackets

The effectiveness of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) and textile-reinforced mortar (TRM) jackets was investigated experimentally and analytically in this study to confine old-type reinforced concrete (RC) columns with limited capacity because of bond failure at lap-splice regions. The local bond strength between lap-spliced bars and concrete was measured experimentally along the lap-splice region of six full-scale RC columns subjected to cyclic uniaxial flexure under constant axial load. The bond strength of the two column specimens tested without retrofitting was found to be in good agreement with the predictions given by two existing bond models. These models were modified to account for the contribution of composite material jacketing to the bond resistance between lap-spliced bars and concrete. The effectiveness of FRP and TRM jackets against splitting at lap splices was quantified as a function of jacket properties and geometry as well as in terms of the jacket effective strain, which was found to depend on the ratio of lap-splice length to bar diameter. Consequently, simple equations for calculating the bond strength of lap splices in members confined with composite materials (FRP or TRM) are proposed.     

Posttensioned FRP Composite Shells for Concrete Confinement

Experiments have shown that externally bonded fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) jackets for square and rectangular columns are not as effective as they are for circular columns. The results of experiments on shape-modified concrete columns using posttensioned FRP shells are presented. Posttensioning was achieved by radially straining the precured FRP shell outwards to a substantial strain level, using expansive cement concrete, over a period of 60?days. The prefabricated FRP shell was also used as a stay-in-place formwork. The effectiveness of shape modification using posttensioned FRP shells is compared to FRP-confined original square and rectangular columns, as well as shape-modified columns with nonshrink grout and externally bonded FRP jackets. It is shown that shape modification with posttensioning of FRP shells, using expansive cement concrete, can change the confinement from passive to active and improve significantly the axial strength and ultimate compressive axial strain capacity of square and rectangular columns.     

Experimental Evaluation of Axial Behavior of Strengthened Circular Reinforced-Concrete Columns

Insufficient or deteriorating reinforced-concrete piers in many existing bridges are required to be strengthened using economical, fast, and efficient methods. Currently, only a few methods can be used to strengthen circular columns. Steel jackets and fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites are the two commonly used methods. In this study, along with these two strengthening methods, concrete jackets reinforced with spiral rebar, welded wire fabric (WWF), and a new steel reinforcement called PCS are investigated under different axial-load applications. Fifteen identical specimens were constructed, strengthened, and tested: one column with no strengthening; three columns strengthened with FRP; two with steel jacketing; and nine with concrete jacketing (two with WWF, three with spiral rebar, and four with the new reinforcement). The bare or unretrofitted specimens had a 152?mm (6?in.) diameter, while the outside diameter of concrete-jacketed specimens was 254?mm (10?in.). Effectiveness of each strengthening method in increasing the stiffness, axial capacity, and displacement ductility was investigated using the experimental data.     

Variable Strain Ductility Ratio for Fiber-Reinforced Polymer-Confined Concrete

The encasement of concrete in fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite jackets can significantly increase the compressive strength and strain ductility of concrete columns and the structural system of which the columns are a part, be it a building or a bridge. Due to the approximate bilinear compressive behavior of FRP-confined concrete, analysis and design of FRP-confined concrete members requires an accurate estimate of the performance enhancement due to the confinement provided by FRP composite jackets. An analytical model is presented for predicting the bilinear compressive behavior of concrete confined with either bonded or nonbonded FRP composite jackets. This article describes the basis of the model, which is a variable plastic strain ductility ratio. The variable plastic strain ductility ratio defines the increase in plastic compressive strain relative to the increase in the plastic compressive strength of the FRP-confined concrete, which is a function of the hoop stiffness of the confining FRP composite jacket, the plastic dilation rate, and the type of bond between the FRP composite and concrete.     

Seismic Behavior of RC Columns with Bond-Critical Regions: Criteria for Bond Strengthening Using External FRP Jackets

In 2003, an experimental research program was initiated at the American University of Beirut with the objectives of (1) evaluating the effectiveness of external fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) confinement in improving the bond strength of spliced reinforcement in reinforced-concrete (RC) columns and its implications on the lateral load capacity and ductility of the columns under seismic loading; and (2) establishing rational design criteria for bond strengthening of spliced reinforcement using external FRP jackets. This paper presents a discussion of recent experimental results dealing with rectangular columns and the results of a pilot study conducted on circular columns with particular emphasis on aspects related to the bond strength of the spliced column reinforcement. A nonlinear analysis model is developed for predicting the envelope load–drift response, taking into account the effect of FRP confinement on the stress–strain behavior of concrete in compression. Results predicted by the model showed excellent agreement with the test results. Design expressions of the bond strength of spliced bars in FRP-confined concrete were assessed against the current experimental data, and a criterion for seismic FRP strengthening of bond-critical regions in RC members is proposed.     

Structural Upgrading of Masonry Columns by Using Composite Reinforcements

Emerging techniques that use fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites for strengthening and conservation of historic masonry are becoming increasingly accepted. In the last decades steel plates or wood frames were used for external confinement in containing the lateral dilation of masonry columns subjected to axial loads. In the last years FRP epoxy bonded strips or jackets were also employed to increase strength and ductility with encouraging results in terms of mechanical behavior and cost effectiveness. The behavior of masonry columns confined with FRP and subjected to axial compression is studied in this paper. An extended experimental investigation is presented in order to show the mechanical behavior of circular masonry columns built with calcareous blocks that may be commonly found in Italy and all over Europe in historical buildings. Different stacking schemes were used to build the columns, aiming to simulate the most common situations in existing masonry structures. Carbon FRP sheets were applied as external reinforcement; different amounts and different schemes of confining reinforcement were studied. The experiments include a new reinforcement technique made by using injected FRP bars through the columns cross section. Such a solution can be considered in place of a more traditional confinement, when external reinforcement must be avoided, or in addition to external reinforcement when an improved confinement effect is required. The structural behavior of masonry columns damaged under different levels of load and strengthened by using FRP reinforcements, was also investigated. Experimental results revealed the effectiveness of the FRP confinement for masonry columns, also for columns that were strongly predamaged before strengthening. A computation of the ultimate load was conducted using the Italian National Research Council recommendations to show an application of the design approach recently proposed in Italy. An existing analytical model, previously developed by the writers, was applied for computation of expected experimental values.     

Concrete-Filled Square and Rectangular FRP Tubes under Axial Compression

This paper presents results of an experimental study on the behavior of square and rectangular concrete-filled fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) tubes (CFFTs) under concentric compression. FRP tubes were designed as column confinement reinforcement and were manufactured using unidirectional carbon fiber sheets with fibers oriented in the hoop direction. The effects of the thickness and corner radius of the tube, sectional aspect ratio, and concrete strength on the axial behavior of CFFTs were investigated experimentally. Test results indicate that FRP confinement leads to substantial improvement in the ductility of both square and rectangular columns. Confinement provided by the FRP tube may also improve the axial load-carrying capacity of the square and rectangular columns if the confinement effectiveness of the FRP tube is sufficiently high. The results also indicate that the confinement effectiveness of FRP tubes is higher in square columns than in rectangular columns, and in both sections the effectiveness of confinement increases with the corner radius. Furthermore, for a given confinement level, improvement observed on the axial behavior of concrete due to confinement decreases with increasing concrete strength.     

Limitations of FRP Jacketing in Confining Old-Type Reinforced Concrete Members in Axial Compression

The efficacy of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) confinement as a means of repairing/strengthening reinforced concrete members with nonductile details is explored in this paper with particular emphasis on the interaction between jacket and the embedded longitudinal compression reinforcement at the onset of bar buckling. To this end, a total of 27 short prismatic specimens were tested to failure under concentric compression subsequent to application of FRP jackets; four additional specimens were tested as controls. Specimens had a square cross section and most were detailed according to former practices with the exception of few specimens that contained the minimum transverse reinforcement as specified by modern provisions. Parameters of the experimental study were the extent of initial damage prior to jacketing, the jacket material, and the number of layers. Response variables included ductility at failure, deformation capacity, strength increase, and mode of failure of the repaired/strengthened member. Confinement effectiveness was quantified using the degree of lateral dilation as the primary performance index. Deformation capacity as limited by embedded longitudinal bar buckling and jacket rupture/debonding strains was evaluated from the experimental results and analytical considerations.     

Stress-Strain Model for Fiber-Reinforced Polymer-Confined Concrete

The design of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP)-confined concrete members requires accurate evaluation of the performance enhancement due to the confinement provided by FRP composite jackets. A strain ductility-based model is developed for predicting the compressive behavior of normal strength concrete confined with FRP composite jackets. The model is applicable to both bonded and nonbonded FRP-confined concrete and can be separated into two components: a strain-softening component, which accounts for unrestrained internal crack propagation in the concrete core, and a strain-hardening component, which accounts for strength increase due to confinement provided by the FRP composite jacket. A variable strain ductility ratio described in a companion paper is used to develop the proposed stress-strain model. Equilibrium and strain compatibility are used to obtain the ultimate compressive strength and strain of FRP-confined concrete as a function of the confining stiffness and ultimate strain of the FRP jacket.     

Size Effect of Concrete Short Columns Confined with Aramid FRP Jackets

Most previous studies on concrete short columns confined with fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites were based on small-scale testing, and size effect of the columns still has not been studied thoroughly. In this study, 99 confined concrete short columns wrapped with aramid FRP (AFRP) jackets and 36 unconfined concrete short columns with circular and square cross sections were tested under axial compressive loading. The circular specimens were divided into six groups, and the square specimens were divided into five groups, with each group containing different levels of the AFRP’s confinement. In each group, the specimens were geometrically similar to one another and had three different scaling dimensions. Statistical analyses were used to evaluate the size and interaction effects between the specimen size and the AFRP’s confinement, and a size-dependent model for predicting the strength of the columns was developed by modifying Baz?nt’s size-effect law. The experimental results showed that the size of a specimen had a significant effect on the strength of AFRP-confined concrete short columns, lesser effect on the axial stress-strain curves, and slight effect on the failure modes. The modified Baz?nt model was in good agreement with the experimental data.     

Use of Microwaves for Damage Detection of Fiber Reinforced Polymer-Wrapped Concrete Structures

Jacketing technology using fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) composites is being applied for seismic retrofit and rehabilitation of reinforced concrete (RC) columns designed and constructed under older specifications. In this study, the authors develop an electromagnetic (EM) imaging technology for detecting such damage as voids and debonding between the jacket and the column, which may significantly weaken the structural performance of the column otherwise attainable by jacketing. This technology is based on the reflection analysis of a continuous EM wave sent toward and reflected from layered FRP–adhesive-concrete medium: Voids and debonding areas will generate air gaps which produce additional reflections of the EM wave. In this study, dielectric properties of various materials involved in the FRP-jacketed RC column were first measured using a plane-wave reflectometer. The measured properties were then used for a computer simulation of the proposed EM imaging technology. The simulation demonstrated the difficulty in detecting damage by using plane waves, as the reflection contribution from the voids and debonding is very small compared to that from the jacketed column. In order to alleviate this difficulty, dielectric lenses were designed and fabricated, focusing the EM wave on the bonding interface. Finally, three concrete columns were constructed and wrapped with glass–FRP jackets with various voids and debonding conditions artificially introduced in the bonding interface. Using the proposed EM imaging technology involving the especially designed and properly installed lenses, these voids and debonding areas were successfully detected. This technology can be used to assess the jacket bonding quality during the initial jacket installation stage and to detect debonding between the column and the jacket caused by earthquake and other destructive loads.     

Debonding in RC Beams Shear Strengthened with Complete FRP Wraps

Substantial research has been conducted on the shear strengthening of reinforced concrete (RC) beams with bonded fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) strips. The beams may be strengthened in various ways: complete FRP wraps covering the whole cross section (i.e., complete wrapping), FRP U jackets covering the two sides and the tension face (i.e., U jacketing), and FRP strips bonded to the sides only (i.e., side bonding). Shear failure of such strengthened beams is generally in one of two modes: FRP rupture and debonding. The former mode governs in almost all beams with complete FRP wraps and some beams with U jackets, while the latter mode governs in all beams with side strips and U jackets. In RC beams strengthened with complete wraps, referred to as FRP wrapped beams, the shear failure process usually starts with the debonding of FRP from the sides of the beam near the critical shear crack, but ultimate failure is by rupture of the FRP. Most previous research has been concerned with the ultimate failure of FRP wrapped beams when FRP ruptures. However, debonding of FRP from the sides is at least a serviceability limit state and may also be taken as the ultimate limit state. This paper presents an experimental study on this debonding failure state in which a total of 18 beams were tested. The paper focuses on the distribution of strains in the FRP strips intersected by the critical shear crack, and the shear capacity at debonding. A simple model is proposed to predict the contribution of FRP to the shear capacity of the beam at the complete debonding of the critical FRP strip.     

Experimental Study of Normal- and High-Strength Concrete Confined with Fiber-Reinforced Polymers

The experimental program reported here was conducted to gain insight into the behavior of concrete confined with fiber-reinforced polymers (FRPs). A total of 112 cylindrical concrete specimens, each 150 mm in diameter, 300 mm in height, and concrete strength up to 112 MPa, were tested under monotonic uniaxial compression. Test variables included amount of FRP, strength and stiffness of FRP, concrete strength, and the health of concrete at the time of strengthening. Results showed that, with an increase of the unconfined concrete strength, the strength enhancement, energy absorption capacity, ductility factor, and work (energy) index at rupture of FRP jackets all decreased remarkably. A positive correlation was found between concrete ductility and FRP rupture strain. A gradual post-peak failure of the specimens, observed previously from FRP-confined concrete columns tested at the University of Toronto, was also observed in some of the current tests. This ductile failure, attributed to the gradual unzipping failure of FRP jacket, is related to specimen size and is explained in terms of various confinement parameters.     

Seismic Behavior of High-Strength Concrete Columns Confined by Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Tubes

The use of high-strength concrete (HSC) in seismically active regions poses a major concern because of the brittle nature of material. The confinement requirements for HSC columns may be prohibitively stringent when ordinary grade transverse steel reinforcement is used. An alternative to conventional confinement reinforcement is the use of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) tubes in the form of stay-in-place formwork which can fulfill multiple functions of: (1) formwork; (2) confinement reinforcement; and (3) protective shell against corrosion, weathering and chemical attacks. The use of stay-in-place FRP formwork is investigated as concrete confinement reinforcement for HSC and normal strength concrete (NSC) columns with circular cross sections. Large-scale specimens with 270?mm circular cross-sections and different concrete strengths were tested under constant axial compression and incrementally increasing lateral deformation reversals. FRP tubes were manufactured from carbon fiber sheets and epoxy resin. The results indicate that inelastic deformability of HSC and NSC columns can be improved significantly by using FRP tubes, beyond the performance level usually expected of comparable columns confined with conventional steel reinforcement.     

Design of FRP Jackets for Upgrade of Circular Bridge Piers

The upgrading of bridges located in seismic areas and built according to obsolete codes is becoming a priority task for highway administrations. Among the possible upgrading strategies, the use of fiber-reinforced plastic (FRP) jackets is gaining widespread acceptance. In this paper, a design equation is proposed to determine the optimal thickness of FRP jackets, to enhance the ductility of existing reinforced-concrete (RC) bridge piers with circular cross sections. The design procedure stems from the definition of an upgrading index, given as the ratio of the target to availability ductility at the pier base section, to be attained through FRP jacketing. The available ductility is that identified through the usual assessment procedures on the RC member set for upgrade, whereas the target ductility is evaluated based on the expected actions on the bridge. The upgrading index is initially defined in general terms and is subsequently extended to the case of piers built in seismic regions. It results in a simple expression in terms of easily computable quantities, such as the ultimate strain and the peak strength of concrete, before and after upgrading. A parametric study on old-code–designed bridge pier sections, upgraded with either glass or carbon fiber jackets, is performed based on a fiber-section model equipped with a newly developed FRP-confined concrete model. This study shows that the index, despite its simplicity, yields excellent predictions of the ductility increase obtained through FRP wrapping, and it is therefore used to develop a design equation. The equation allows the design of the optimal thickness of FRP jackets in terms of the desired upgrading index, mechanical characteristics of the selected composite material, and quantities defining the initial state of the pier section. The design procedure has been applied to available experimental tests of a scaled bridge pier wrapped with FRP and tested to failure, and it has been demonstrated to be very effective.     

Experimental Investigation on Seismic Retrofitting of Square RC Columns by Carbon FRP Sheet Confinement Combined with Transverse Short Glass FRP Bars in Bored Holes

Jacketing is less effective to large square/rectangular RC columns due to the inability of the rectangular-shaped jacket in restraining the dilation of concrete in the middle of a straight side. A new retrofit method is proposed in this work by fiber reinforcing the surface concrete in the middle of a straight side. Fiber reinforcing is achieved by inserting small fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) bars into the concrete in the plastic hinge zone. The inserted FRP bars act as horizontal reinforcement to increase the ductility of the concrete in a similar way as that in normal fiber-reinforced concrete. When this fiber reinforcing technique is combined with the conventional jacketing, the concrete in all parts of a cross section may be effectively confined. In this work, experimental tests were undertaken to investigate the effectiveness of this new retrofit technique. Six half-scaled columns were tested and the test results demonstrated the effectiveness of the method.     

Confinement Effectiveness of FRP in Retrofitting Circular Concrete Columns under Simulated Seismic Load

The results of a research program that evaluated the confinement effectiveness of the type and the amount of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) used to retrofit circular concrete columns are presented. A total of 17 circular concrete columns were tested under combined lateral cyclic displacement excursions and constant axial load. It is demonstrated that a high axial load level has a detrimental effect and that a large aspect ratio has a positive effect on drift capacity. Compared with the performance of columns that are monotonically loaded until failure, three cycles of every displacement excursion significantly affect drift capacity. The energy dissipation capacity is controlled by FRP jacket confinement stiffness, especially under a high axial load level. The fracture strain of FRP material has no significant impact on the drift capacity of retrofitted circular concrete columns as long as the same confining pressure is provided, which differs from the common opinion that a larger FRP fracture strain is advantageous in seismic retrofitting. The amount of confining FRP greatly affects the length of the plastic hinge region and the drift capacity of FRP-retrofitted columns. A further increase in confinement after a critical value causes a reduction in the deformation capacity of the columns.