Trading With a Stock Chart Heuristic

The efficient market hypothesis (EMH) is a cornerstone of financial economics. The EMH asserts that security prices fully reflect all available information and that the stock market prices securities at their fair values. Therefore, investors cannot consistently ldquobeat the marketrdquo because stocks reside in perpetual equilibrium, making research efforts futile. This flies in the face of the conventional nonacademic wisdom that astute analysts can beat the market using technical or fundamental stock analysis. The purpose of this research is to partially assess whether technical analysts, who predict future stock prices by analyzing past stock prices, can consistently achieve a trading return that outperforms the stock market average return. This is tested using knowlege engineering experimentation with one price history pattern - the ldquobull flag stock chartrdquo - which signals technical analysts of a future stock market price increase. A recognizer for the stock chart pattern is built using a template-matching technique from pattern recognition. The recognizer and associated trading rules are then tested by simulating trading on over 35 years of daily closing price data for the New York stock exchange composite index. The experiment is then replicated using the horizontal rotation or mirror image pattern of the ldquobull flagrdquo (or ldquobear flagrdquo stock chart) that signals a future stock market decrease. Results are systematic, statistically significant, and fail to confirm the null hypothesis based on a corollary to the EMH: that profit realized from trading determined by this heuristic method is no better than what would be realized from trading decisions based on random choice.     

Trend following deep Q-Learning strategy for stock trading

Computers and algorithms are widely used to help in stock market decision making. A few questions with regards to the profitability of algorithms for stock trading are can computers be trained to beat the markets? Can an algorithm take decisions for optimal profits? And so forth. In this research work, our objective is to answer some of these questions. We propose an algorithm using deep Q-Reinforcement Learning techniques to make trading decisions. Trading in stock markets involves potential risk because the price is affected by various uncertain events ranging from political influences to economic constraints. Models that trade using predictions may not always be profitable mainly due to the influence of various unknown factors in predicting the future stock price. Trend Following is a trading idea in which, trading decisions, like buying and selling, are taken purely according to the observed market trend. A stock trend can be up, down, or sideways. Trend Following does not predict the stock price but follows the reversals in the trend direction. A trend reversal can be used to trigger a buy or a sell of a certain stock. In this research paper, we describe a deep Q-Reinforcement Learning agent able to learn the Trend Following trading by getting rewarded for its trading decisions. Our results are based on experiments performed on the actual stock market data of the American and the Indian stock markets. The results indicate that the proposed model outperforms forecasting-based methods in terms of profitability. We also limit risk by confirming trading actions with the trend before actual trading.     

A hybrid stock trading system for intelligent technical analysis-based equivolume charting

This paper presents the use of an intelligent hybrid stock trading system that integrates neural networks, fuzzy logic, and genetic algorithms techniques to increase the efficiency of stock trading when using a volume adjusted moving average (VAMA), a technical indicator developed from equivolume charting. For this research, a neuro–fuzzy-based genetic algorithm (NF-GA) system utilizing a VAMA membership function is introduced. The results show that the intelligent hybrid system takes advantage of the synergy among these different techniques to intelligently generate more optimal trading decisions for the VAMA, allowing investors to make better stock trading decisions.     

多源异构数据融合驱动的股票指数预测研究

现代信息技术的广泛应用使得资本市场投资者能够获得更及时、更有价值的信息,也更容易受到金融论坛、专业投资网站的影响。融合资本市场的多源异构数据对股票指数进行预测成为该领域的研究热点。提出了一种基于多源异构数据的长短期神经网络（Long Short-Term Memory,LSTM）模型,通过对融合资本市场交易数据、技术指标数据、投资者情绪三种源数据的量化来预测股票指数的走势。提出了一种可以提取深度情感特征的卷积神经网络（Convolutional Neural Networks,CNN）情感分析模型,构建了投资者情绪特征模型。利用“上证50指数”数据进行实验,结果显示：LSTM模型的预测准确率比传统模型更为优秀,数据源的增加也对模型准确率的提升有较大贡献,验证了该方法的可行性和有效性。     

A portfolio optimization model using Genetic Network Programming with control nodes

Many evolutionary computation methods applied to the financial field have been reported. A new evolutionary method named “Genetic Network Programming” (GNP) has been developed and applied to the stock market recently. The efficient trading rules created by GNP has been confirmed in our previous research. In this paper a multi-brands portfolio optimization model based on Genetic Network Programming with control nodes is presented. This method makes use of the information from technical indices and candlestick chart. The proposed optimization model, consisting of technical analysis rules, are trained to generate trading advice. The experimental results on the Japanese stock market show that the proposed optimization system using GNP with control nodes method outperforms other traditional models in terms of both accuracy and efficiency. We also compared the experimental results of the proposed model with the conventional GNP based methods, GA and Buy&Hold method to confirm its effectiveness, and it is clarified that the proposed trading model can obtain much higher profits than these methods.     

Cascading logistic regression onto gradient boosted decision trees for forecasting and trading stock indices

Forecasting the direction of the daily changes of stock indices is an important yet difficult task for market participants. Advances on data mining and machine learning make it possible to develop more accurate predictions to assist investment decision making. This paper attempts to develop a learning architecture LR2GBDT for forecasting and trading stock indices, mainly by cascading the logistic regression (LR) model onto the gradient boosted decision trees (GBDT) model. Without any assumption on the underlying data generating process, raw price data and twelve technical indicators are employed for extracting the information contained in the stock indices. The proposed architecture is evaluated by comparing the experimental results with the LR, GBDT, SVM (support vector machine), NN (neural network) and TPOT (tree-based pipeline optimization tool) models on three stock indices data of two different stock markets, which are an emerging market (Shanghai Stock Exchange Composite Index) and a mature stock market (Nasdaq Composite Index and S&P 500 Composite Stock Price Index). Given the same test conditions, the cascaded model not only outperforms the other models, but also shows statistically and economically significant improvements for exploiting simple trading strategies, even when transaction cost is taken into account.     

Application of wrapper approach and composite classifier to the stock trend prediction

The research on the stock market prediction has been more popular in recent years. Numerous researchers tried to predict the immediate future stock prices or indices based on technical indices with various mathematical models and machine learning techniques such as artificial neural networks (ANN), support vector machines (SVM) and ARIMA models. Although some researches in the literature exhibit satisfactory prediction achievement when the average percentage error and root mean square error are used as the performance metrics, the prediction accuracy of whether stock market goes or down is seldom analyzed. This paper employs wrapper approach to select the optimal feature subset from original feature set composed of 23 technical indices and then uses voting scheme that combines different classification algorithms to predict the trend in Korea and Taiwan stock markets. Experimental result shows that wrapper approach can achieve better performance than the commonly used feature filters, such as χ²-Statistic, Information gain, ReliefF, Symmetrical uncertainty and CFS. Moreover, the proposed voting scheme outperforms single classifier such as SVM, kth nearest neighbor, back-propagation neural network, decision tree, and logistic regression.     

基于遗传编程的中国股票市场有效性检验

现代资本市场理论与金融投资实践之间存在着有效市场假说与技术分析之间的矛盾,使用流行的技术交易规则检验股票市场有效性可能导致两种结论偏差。遗传编程使用树形结构表示问题的候选解,可以很好地描述技术交易规则。利用遗传编程算法生成一种技术交易策略,并用其检验上证综合指数和5个沪深股市个股。回测结果表明,提出的方法相对于“买入-持有”策略能够获得超额收益,并且优于常用的流行技术指标,也说明我国股票市场并未达到弱式有效。     

A multiple fuzzy inference systems framework for daily stock trading with application to NASDAQ stock exchange

The aim of this study is to develop an expert system for predicting daily trading decisions in a typical financial market environment. The developed system thus employs a Multiple FISs framework consisting of three dedicated FISs for stock trading decisions, Buy, Hold and Sell respectively. As input to the Multiple FISs framework, the system takes the fundamental information of the respective companies and the historical prices of the stocks which are processed to give the technical information. The framework suggests the investor to Buy, Sell or Hold on a daily basis for a portfolio of stock taken into consideration. Experimenting the framework on selected stocks of NASDAQ stock exchange shows that including the fundamental data of the stocks as input along with the technical data significantly improves the profit return than that of the system taking only technical information as input data. Characterised as a stock market indicator, the framework performs better than some of the most popularly used technical indicators such as Moving Average Convergence/Divergence (MACD), Relative Strength Index (RSI), Stochastic Oscillator (SO) and Chaikin Oscillator (CO). The developed framework also gives better profit return compared to an existing model with similar objective.     

Forecasting stock returns based on information transmission across global markets using support vector machines

This paper provides evidence that forecasts based on global stock returns transmission yield better returns in day trading, for both developed and emerging stock markets. The study investigates the performance of global stock market price transmission information in forecasting stock prices using support vector regression for six global markets—USA (Dow Jones, S&P500), UK (FTSE-100), India (NSE), Singapore (SGX), Hong Kong (Hang Seng) and China (Shanghai Stock Exchange) over the period 1999–2011. The empirical analysis shows that models with other global market price information outperform forecast models based merely on auto-regressive past lags and technical indicators. Shanghai stock index movement was predicted best by Hang Seng Index opening price (57.69), Hang Seng Index by previous day’s S&P500 closing price (54.34), FTSE by previous day’s S&P500 closing price (57.94), Straits Times Index by previous day’s Dow Jones closing price (54.44), Nifty by HSI opening price (60), S&P500 by STI closing price (55.31) and DJIA by HSI opening price (55.22), and Nifty was found to be the most predictable stock index. Trading using global cues-based forecast model generates greater returns than other models in all the markets. The study provides evidence that stock markets across the globe are integrated and the information on price transmission across markets, including emerging markets, can induce better returns in day trading.     

A feature weighted support vector machine and K-nearest neighbor algorithm for stock market indices prediction

This study investigates stock market indices prediction that is an interesting and important research in the areas of investment and applications, as it can get more profits and returns at lower risk rate with effective exchange strategies. To realize accurate prediction, various methods have been tried, among which the machine learning methods have drawn attention and been developed. In this paper, we propose a basic hybridized framework of the feature weighted support vector machine as well as feature weighted K-nearest neighbor to effectively predict stock market indices. We first establish a detailed theory of feature weighted SVM for the data classification assigning different weights for different features with respect to the classification importance. Then, to get the weights, we estimate the importance of each feature by computing the information gain. Lastly, we use feature weighted K-nearest neighbor to predict future stock market indices by computing k weighted nearest neighbors from the historical dataset. Experiment results on two well known Chinese stock market indices like Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchange indices are finally presented to test the performance of our established model. With our proposed model, it can achieve a better prediction capability to Shanghai Stock Exchange Composite Index and Shenzhen Stock Exchange Component Index in the short, medium and long term respectively. The proposed algorithm can also be adapted to other stock market indices prediction.     

A hybrid ANFIS based on n-period moving average model to forecast TAIEX stock

Linear model is a general forecasting model and moving average technical index (MATI) is one of useful forecasting methods to predict the future stock prices in stock markets. Therefore, individual investors, stock fund managers, and financial analysts attempt to predict price fluctuation in stock markets by either linear model or MATI. From literatures, three major drawbacks are found in many existing forecasting models. First, forecasting rules mined from some AI algorithms, such as neural networks, could be very difficult to understand. Second, statistic assumptions about variables are required for time series to generate forecasting models, which are not easily understandable by stock investors. Third, stock market investors usually make short-term decisions based on recent price fluctuations, i.e., the last one or two periods, but most time series models use only the last period of stock price. In order to overcome these drawbacks, this study proposes a hybrid forecasting model using linear model and MATI to predict stock price trends with the following four steps: (1) test the lag period of Taiwan Stock Exchange Capitalization Weighted Stock Index (TAIEX) and calculate the last n-period moving average; (2) use subtractive clustering to partition technical indicator values into linguistic values based on data discretization method objectively; (3) employ fuzzy inference system (FIS) to build linguistic rules from the linguistic technical indicator dataset, and optimize the FIS parameters by adaptive network; and (4) refine the proposed model by adaptive expectation models. The proposed model is then verified by root mean squared error (RMSE), and a ten-year period of TAIEX is selected as experiment datasets. The results show that the proposed model is superior to the other forecasting models, namely Chen's model and Yu's model in terms of RMSE.     

融合社交情感分析的股市预测探究

针对现有股市预测研究中所存在的大众情感度量不够全面的问题,提出了一种基于社交情感分析的股市预测模型. 该模型首先基于异构图模型的证券情感量化方法对社交媒介的数据进行情感分析,得到量化的情感时间序列;然后,基于自组织神经网络模型对情感序列及行情指数序列进行建模,从而对股票指数进行预测. 在国内社交媒介及股市行情数据集上的实验结果表明,本文所建立的模型在预测误差和精度上较BP（Back Propagation）神经网络分别提升了15%和12%,能更好地预测股票指数.     

Bridging the divide in financial market forecasting: machine learners vs. financial economists

Financial time series forecasting is a popular application of machine learning methods. Previous studies report that advanced forecasting methods predict price changes in financial markets with high accuracy and that profit can be made trading on these predictions. However, financial economists point to the informational efficiency of financial markets, which questions price predictability and opportunities for profitable trading. The objective of the paper is to resolve this contradiction. To this end, we undertake an extensive forecasting simulation, based on data from thirty-four financial indices over six years. These simulations confirm that the best machine learning methods produce more accurate forecasts than the best econometric methods. We also examine the methodological factors that impact the predictive accuracy of machine learning forecasting experiments. The results suggest that the predictability of a financial market and the feasibility of profitable model-based trading are significantly influenced by the maturity of the market, the forecasting method employed, the horizon for which it generates predictions and the methodology used to assess the model and simulate model-based trading. We also find evidence against the informational value of indicators from the field of technical analysis. Overall, we confirm that advanced forecasting methods can be used to predict price changes in some financial markets and we discuss whether these results question the prevailing view in the financial economics literature that financial markets are efficient.     

基于Agent的投资者情绪对于股市演化行为仿真研究

基于双向拍卖机制作为价格生成机制,应用遗传算法来进化预测规则,建立了中国股市的人工金融市场模型,并在此基础上研究了投资者情绪对于市场演化行为的影响。研究结果表明人工市场能够产生真实市场演化过程中的混沌动力学行为,并且市场演化行为随着投资者情绪的变化而变动。这一研究对挖掘中国股票市场的演化规律具有重要意义。     

A Naïve SVM-KNN based stock market trend reversal analysis for Indian benchmark indices

This paper proposes a hybridized framework of Support Vector Machine (SVM) with K-Nearest Neighbor approach for Indian stock market indices prediction. The objective of this paper is to get in-depth knowledge in the stock market in Indian Scenario with the two indices such as, Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE Sensex) and CNX Nifty using technical analysis methods and tools such as predicting closing price, volatility and momentum of the stock market for the available data. This hybrid model uses SVM with different kernel functions to predict profit or loss, and the output of SVM helps to compute best nearest neighbor from the training set to predict future of stock value in the horizon of 1 day, 1 week and 1 month. The proposed SVM and KNN based prediction model is experienced with the above mentioned distinguished stock market indices and the performance of proposed model has been computed using Mean Squared Error and also been compared with recent developed models such as FLIT2NS and CEFLANN respectively. The limitation of both of those existing models undergoes complex weight updating procedures, whereas, proposed SVM-KNN hybridized model scales relatively well to high dimensional data and the trade-off between classifier complexity and error can be controlled explicitly and have better prediction capability.     

Application of the consensus method in a multiagent financial decision support system

Financial decisions are supported by different methods, based mainly on statistics, mathematics, behaviorism, artificial intelligence or experts’ opinion sentiment analysis. The main problem is that under conditions of risk and uncertainty predicting financial markets can be very difficult. This paper presents an approach to investment strategy design for a multiagent system which supports investment decisions on the stock market. Individual components and functionalities of the multiagent financial decision support system method have been briefly described. On the basis of decisions generated by agents, the Supervisor Agent uses a consensus method to generate a satisfactory rate of return and reduce the level of risk associated with investing in a financial instrument. Verification of the effectiveness of the strategy has been conducted using investments on the Warsaw Stock Exchange.     

Improving stock index forecasts by using a new weighted fuzzy-trend time series method

We propose using new weighted operators in fuzzy time series to forecast the future performance of stock market indices. Based on the chronological sequence of weights associated with the original fuzzy logical relationships, we define both chronological-order and trend-order weights, and incorporate our proposals for the ex-post forecast into the classical modeling approach of fuzzy time series. These modifications for the assignation of weights affect the forecasting process, because we use jumps as technical indicators to predict stock trends, and additionally, they provide a trapezoidal fuzzy number as a forecast of the future performance of the stock index value. Working with trapezoidal fuzzy numbers allows us to analyze both the expected value and the ambiguity of the future behavior of the stock index, using a possibilistic interval-valued mean approach. Therefore, using fuzzy logic more useful information is provided to the decision analyst, which should be appropriate in a financial context. We analyze the effectiveness of our approach with respect to other weighted fuzzy time series methods using trading data sets from the Taiwan Stock Index (TAIEX), the Japanese NIKKEI Index, the German Stock Index (DAX) and the Spanish Stock Index (IBEX35). The comparative results indicate the better accuracy of our procedure for point-wise one-step ahead forecasts.     

An intelligent hybrid trading system for discovering trading rules for the futures market using rough sets and genetic algorithms

Discovering intelligent technical trading rules from nonlinear and complex stock market data, and then developing decision support trading systems, is an important challenge. The objective of this study is to develop an intelligent hybrid trading system for discovering technical trading rules using rough set analysis and a genetic algorithm (GA). In order to obtain better trading decisions, a novel rule discovery mechanism using a GA approach is proposed for solving optimization problems (i.e., data discretization and reducts) of rough set analysis when discovering technical trading rules for the futures market. Experiments are designed to test the proposed model against comparable approaches (i.e., random, correlation, and GA approaches). In addition, these comprehensive experiments cover most of the current trading system topics, including the use of a sliding window method (with or without validation dataset), the number of trading rules, and the size of training period. To evaluate an intelligent hybrid trading system, experiments were carried out on the historical data of the Korea Composite Stock Price Index 200 (KOSPI 200) futures market. In particular, trading performance is analyzed according to the number of sets of decision rules and the size of the training period for discovering trading rules for the testing period. The results show that the proposed model significantly outperforms the benchmark model in terms of the average return and as a risk-adjusted measure.     

A stock trading expert system based on the rule-base evidential reasoning using Level 2 Quotes

Generally, stock trading expert systems (STES) called also “mechanical trading systems” are based on the technical analysis, i.e., on methods for evaluating securities by analyzing statistics generated by the market activity, such as past prices and volumes (number of transactions during a unit of a timeframe). In other words, such STES are based on the Level 1 information. Nevertheless, currently the Level 2 information is available for the most of traders and can be successfully used to develop trading strategies especially for the day trading when a significant amount of transactions are made during one trading session. The Level 2 tools show in-depth information on a particular stock. Traders can see not only the “best” bid (buying) and ask (selling) orders, but the whole spectrum of buy and sell orders at different volumes and different prices. In this paper, we propose some new technical analysis indices bases on the Level 2 and Level 1 information which are used to develop a stock trading expert system. For this purpose we adapt a new method for the rule-base evidential reasoning which was presented and used in our recent paper for building the stock trading expert system based the Level 1 information. The advantages of the proposed approach are demonstrated using the developed expert system optimized and tested on the real data from the Warsaw Stock Exchange.