Effect of particle size and freezing conditions on freeze-casted scaffold

Freeze casting is one of the emerging and novel manufacturing routes to fabricate porous scaffolds for various applications including orthopedic implants, drug delivery, energy storing devices etc. Thus, it becomes important to understand this process in a deeper sense. Present work was focused to study the effect/influence of basic parameters, particle sizes, and freezing conditions on the mechanical properties and microstructures of porous scaffold fabricated by freeze casting. β-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP) and hydroxyapatite (HAp) powder with particle sizes of 10?μm and 20?nm were used. Prepared slurries were freeze casted at constant freezing temperature (5?°C) and constant freezing rate (1.86?°C/min) to study the effect of freezing conditions on mechanical and microstructural properties of the porous scaffold. It was observed that porous scaffold fabricated by nanoparticles has given better porosity (63.22–76.16%), than scaffold fabricated by microparticles (13–43.05%) at given solid loading of both freezing conditions. Although, the range of pore size of the scaffold fabricated by nanoparticles (CFR: 2.60–0.84?μm; CFT: 1.66–0.46?μm) was lower than that of scaffold fabricated by microparticles (CFR: 9.45–4.83?μm; CFT: 4.72–2.84?μm). The compressive strength of scaffolds prepared by nanoparticles was in the range of trabecular bone. Moreover, the results of present work will pave the way for the fabrication of porous scaffold with desired pore size and porosity for various implants, energy, and drug delivery applications.     

Fabrication and characterization of porous β-tricalcium phosphate scaffolds coated with alginate

All porous materials have a common limitation which is lack of strength due to the porosity. In this study, two different methods have been used to produce porous β-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP) scaffolds: liquid-nitrogen freeze casting and a combination of the direct-foaming and sacrificial-template methods. Among these two methods, porous β-TCP scaffolds with acceptable pore size and compressive strength and defined pore-channel interconnectivity were successfully fabricated by the combined direct-foaming and sacrificial-template method. The average pore size of the scaffolds was in the range of 100–150 µm and the porosity was around 70%. Coating with 4 wt% alginate on porous β-TCP scaffolds led to higher compressive strength and low porosity. In order to make a chemical link between the β-TCP scaffolds and the alginate coating, silane coupling agent was used. Treated β-TCP scaffold showed improvements in compressive strength of up to 38% compared to the pure β-TCP scaffold and 11% compared to coated β-TCP scaffold.     

Novel Layered Hydroxyapatite/Tri‐Calcium Phosphate–Zirconia Scaffold Composite with High Bending Strength for Load‐Bearing Bone Implant Application

The integration of biological and mechanical requirements remains a challenge in developing porous hydroxyapatite (HA) and tri‐calcium phosphate (TCP) scaffolds for load‐bearing bone implant application. With the newly developed slip‐deposition and coating‐substrate co‐sintering technique, a strong layered HA/TCP‐zirconia scaffold composite structure was successfully fabricated. The bending strength (321 MPa) of this composite can match upper strength limit of the natural compact bone. The HA‐based scaffold coating has multiple scale porous structures with pore size ranging 1–10 and 20–50 μm. The zirconia‐based substrate is also porous with submicropores. Focus ion beam micrographs show most of the micropores in the coating are interconnected. Microindentation and primarily adhesive strength tests demonstrate that the scaffold coating strongly bonds with the zirconia based substrate. In vitro cell culture study indicates that the coatings have no cytotoxicity. It is evident that the strong layered HA–zirconia scaffold composite offers new implant options for bone repairs requiring immediate load bearing capacity.     

Physical and mechanical properties of a poly-3-hydroxybutyrate-coated nanocrystalline hydroxyapatite scaffold for bone tissue engineering

A major challenge for tissue engineers is the design of scaffolds with appropriate physical and mechanical properties. The present research discusses the formation of ceramic scaffolding in tissue engineering. Hydroxyapatite (HAp) powder was made from bovine bone by thermal treatment at 900?°C; 40, 50 and 60%wt porous HAp was then produced using the polyurethane sponge replication method. Scaffolds were coated with poly-3-hydroxybutyrate (P3HB) for 30?s and 1?min in order to increase the scaffold??s mechanical properties. XRD, SEM and FT-IR were used to study phase structure, morphology and agent groups, respectively. In XRD and FT-IR data, established hydrogen bands between polymer and ceramic matrix confirm that the scaffold is formed as a composite. The scaffold obtained with 50%wt HAp and a 30?s coating was 90% porous, with an average diameter of 100?C400???m, and demonstrated a compressive strength and modulus of 1.46 and 21.27?MPa, respectively. Based on these results, this scaffold is optimised for the aforementioned properties and can be utilised in bone tissue engineering.     

Gelatin-layered and multi-sized porous β-tricalcium phosphate for tissue engineering scaffold

The multi-sized porous β-tricalcium phosphate scaffolds were fabricated by freeze drying followed by slurry coating using a multi-sized porous sponge as a template. Then, gelatin was dip coated on the multi-sized porous β-tricalcium phosphate scaffolds under vacuum. The mechanical and biological properties of the fabricated scaffolds were evaluated and compared to the uniformly sized porous scaffolds and scaffolds that were not coated by gelatin. The compressive strength was tested by a universal testing machine, and the cell viability and differentiation behavior were measured using a cell counting kit and alkaline phosphatase activity using the MC3T3-E1 cells. In comparison, the gelatin-coated multi-sized porous β-tricalcium phosphate scaffold showed enhanced compressive strength. After 14 days, the multi-sized pores were shown to affect cell differentiation, and gelatin coatings were shown to affect the cell viability and differentiation. The results of this study demonstrated that the multi-sized porous β-tricalcium phosphate scaffold coated by gelatin enhanced the mechanical and biological strengths.     

A porous hydroxyapatite scaffold for bone tissue engineering: Physico-mechanical and biological evaluations

Polymer sponge replication method was used in this study to prepare the macroporous hydroxyapatite scaffolds with interconnected oval shaped pores of 100-300 μm with pore wall thickness of ∼50 μm. The compression strength of 60 wt.% HA loaded scaffold was 1.3 MPa. The biological response of the scaffold was investigated using human osteoblast like SaOS2 cells. The results showed that SaOS2 cells were able to adhere, proliferate and migrate into pores of scaffold. Furthermore, the cell viability was found to increase on porous scaffold compared to dense HA. The expression of alkaline phosphate, a differentiation marker for SaOS2 cells was enhanced as compared to nonporous HA disc with respect to number of days of culture. The enhanced cellular functionality and the ability to support osteoblast differentiation for porous scaffolds in comparison to dense HA has been explained in terms of higher protein absorption on porous scaffold.     

Mechanical and Biological Performance of Calcium Phosphate Coatings on Porous Bone Scaffold

Composite coatings, consisting of calcium phosphate (CaP) ceramics and phosphate-based glass (P-glass), were obtained on a strong ZrO₂ porous scaffold to improve biocompatibility by combining mechanical properties and biological activity. Powder mixtures of hydroxyapatite (HA) and P-glass in varying composition and content were dip-coated on a ZrO₂ porous scaffold and heat-treated above 800°C for 2 h in air. During thermal treatment, substantial reaction and crystallization occurred, resulting in coating phases of HA, tricalcium phosphate (TCP), dicalcium phosphate (DCP), and surrounding glass. The CaP-glass coating layer was highly dense and uniform and adhered firmly to the ZrO₂ scaffold. The adhesion strength of the coating layer as tested on a nonporous disk increased with increasing glass addition and decreasing CaO content in glass. The highest strength was about 40 MPa, an improvement of twice as high as that of pure HA coating. The osteoblastic cells grew and spread actively through the coated scaffolds. The differentiation of cells on the CaP coatings was much higher than that on ZrO₂ substrate and comparable to or slightly higher than that on pure HA coating.     

3D gel-printing of hierarchically porous BCP scaffolds for bone tissue engineering

In this study, a conventional technique of porous preparation was used to improve the constructive capability of direct ink writing on microstructures, and the hierarchically porous scaffolds were successfully prepared by 3D gel printing (3DGP). Micron-sized hydroxyapatite (HA) was coated with tricalcium phosphate (TCP) nanopowders synthesized by chemical co-precipitation to form biphasic calcium phosphate (BCP). The random structure of concave micropores was achieved by filling the BCP slurry with PMMA microspheres while successfully controlling the internal porosity of printed filaments. The results showed that the three-stage porous structure was successfully constructed, i.e., macroscopic pores of 1.50–2.00 mm, spherical micropores of 100–200 µm, and inter-powder interstices of 1.00–10.00 µm. Nano-TCP coated micron-HA powders improved the sintering activity of BCP particles. The compressive strength and porosity of the scaffolds sintered at 1400 °C were 2.78 MPa and 84.98%. The hierarchically porous BCP scaffolds had bright applications in bone tissue engineering.     

Fabrication and performance of calcium phosphate cement/small intestinal submucosa composite bionic bone scaffolds with different microstructures

The microstructure of the tissue has a very important determining effect on its performance. Herein, two calcium phosphate cement (CPC)/small intestinal submucosa(SIS) composites bionic bone scaffolds with different microstructures were fabricated by rolling or/ and assembling method. The microstructure, 3D morphology, the crystal phase and mechanical properties of the scaffolds were investigated by micro CT, XRD, FIIR, SEM and electronic universal testing machines respectively. The results showed that the pore size of all scaffolds are in the range of 100–400?µm, which are beneficial to cells growth, migration, and tissue vascularization. Their porosity and the specific surface area were 14.53?±?0.76%, 8.74?±?1.38?m²/m³ and 32?±?0.58%, 26.75?±?2.69?m²/m³ separately. The high porosity and the large specific surface area can provide a larger space and contact area for cells adhesion and proliferation. Meanwhile, compressive strength of the scaffolds soaked were 10?MPa and 27?MPa, about 1.2 folds and 3.2 folds of the original scaffolds, respectively. The results are derived from different microstructures of the scaffolds and chemical bonds between SIS and new phases (hydroxyapatite), and the scaffolds performance steadily increased at near the physiological conditions. Finally, biocompatibility of the scaffolds was evaluated by CCK8, bionic microstructure scaffolds are no cytotoxicity and their biocompatibility is favorable. Based on the microstructure, compressive strength and cytotoxicity of the scaffolds, bionic Harvarsin microstructure CPC/SIS composite scaffold is expected to turn into a scaffold with the excellent properties of real bone.     

Synthesis of silicate glass/poly(l-lactide) composite scaffolds by freeze-extraction technique: Characterization and in vitro bioactivity evaluation

The main objectives of the present study were to fabricate the silicate glass/poly(l-lactide) composite scaffolds for bone engineering applications, by using the freeze-extraction technique, and to evaluate the possibility for optimizing their degradation rate by changing their glass content. The scaffolds characterized by SEM-EDXA, FT-IR, TGA and XRD. Examination of the SEM microphotographs revealed that the pore size of the scaffolds decreased as the glass content increased. The neat polymer scaffold (PLA) had a highly interconnected porous structure with a maximum pore size of 200 μm. For the composite scaffold containing glass content up to 25 wt% (SP25) and up to 50 wt% (SP50), the maximum pore size was 40 μm and 20 μm respectively. The apparent porosity was 56.56%, 52.49% and 48.74% for PLA, SP25 and SP50, respectively. The results of the degradation study showed that the water absorption of the scaffolds decreased by increasing their glass content, It reached finally to 48.71%and 30.93% for SP25 and SP50, respectively. It revealed that also the weight loss of the scaffolds increased by increasing the glass content. The final weight loss was around 5.44%, 9.31% and 26.17% for the PLA, SP25 and SP50, respectively, indicating that it was possible to modulate the degradation rate of the scaffolds by varying their glass content. In addition, the pH measurement of incubation medium indicated that the glass could compensate the acidic degradation products of the polymer. In vitro bioactivity evaluation showed that the composite scaffolds were able to induce the formation of hydroxyapaptite layer on their surfaces, demonstrating their potential application in bone engineering.     

Influence of precursor characteristics on properties of porous calcium phosphate-titanium dioxide composite bioceramics

Highly porous (macroporosity 76–90%) bioceramics containing interconnected pores (>100 μm) with compressive strength between 0.54 and 0.32 MPa were prepared by polyurethane foam replica method. Effect of following variables, i.e., calcium phosphate/anatase ratio (30/70, 50/50, 70/30 wt%) in the ceramic slurry, anatase particle size (15 nm, 180 nm), Ca/P molar ratio of calcium phosphate (1.67 and 1.50 for hydroxyapatite and apatitic-tricalcium phosphate (ap-TCP), respectively), on the bioceramics properties was investigated. Bioceramics prepared using anatase and hydroxyapatite consisted of three high-temperature crystalline phases - β-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP), rutile and CaTiO₃. In case of anatase and ap-TCP, two phases (β-TCP and rutile) were obtained. Interaction of anatase and hydroxyapatite during sintering caused formation of CaTiO₃ at β-TCP and rutile grain boundaries thus contributing to a denser grain packing. Combination of ap-TCP and nanosized anatase facilitated decrease of grain sizes. Correlation was found between compressive strength and calcium phosphate precursor in the ceramic slurry.     

Control of the structure and mechanical property of porous WS<Subscript>2</Subscript> scaffold during freeze casting

Porous WS₂ scaffolds with aligned lamellar pore were fabricated by freeze casting, and the pore morphology and size can be well controlled by adjusting the processing parameters during freeze casting process. The results indicated that the porosity and the compressive strength of porous WS₂ were greatly affected by the concentration of gelatin. As the gelatin addition increased from 1 to 5 wt%, the porosity of porous WS₂ scaffolds with initial solid content of 3 vol% decreased from 95.12 to 90.23%, and their compressive strength increased from 0.22 to 1.16 MPa. Moreover, the lamellar spacing and wall thickness could be tailored from 90 to 320 and 5 to 30 μm respectively by changing the cooling temperature. And the compressive strength of scaffolds has a slight increase with the decreases of cooling temperature. The porous WS₂ scaffold with fine aligned lamellar structure and proper compressive strength are expected to be used for scaffold materials.     

Formation of porous PLGA scaffolds by a combining method of thermally induced phase separation and porogen leaching

A novel method for the fabrication of porous poly(L -lactide-co-glycolide) (PLGA) scaffolds by combining thermally induced phase separation and porogen leaching is presented in this article. Big pores with about 75–400 μm diameters in the obtained scaffolds were generated by the porogen, sucrose particles, while small pores with diameters less than 20 μm induced via phase separation. Extraction of the solvent, chloroform by ethanol at cool temperatures could reduce the scaffold toxicity. Effects of PLGA concentration, freezing temperature, volume fraction of porogen, and introduction of β-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP) on morphology, porosity, and compressive properties of the scaffolds were systematically discussed. Results showed that the size of small pores decreased by decreasing the polymer concentration and reducing the freezing temperature, whereas the interconnectivity of the scaffolds was improved by increasing the porogen fraction. The compressive modulus and strength were significantly lowered by increasing the scaffold porosity, that is, by increasing porogen fraction, or decreasing the polymer concentration, or reducing the freezing temperature. Addition of β-TCP into the scaffolds did not influence the compressive modulus significantly but tended to decrease the compressive strength. The obtained scaffolds with diverse pore sizes would be potentially used in bone tissue engineering. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Appl Polym Sci, 2008     

In vitro assessment of degradation and bioactivity of robocast bioactive glass scaffolds in simulated body fluid

In this study porous three-dimensional scaffolds of borate (13-93B3) bioactive glass were prepared by robocasting and in vitro degradation and bioactivity was evaluated. Grid like scaffolds with interconnected pores was assembled using robotic deposition technique which is a direct ink writing method. After binder burnout, the constructs were sintered for 1 h at 560 °C to produce scaffolds (porosity≈60%) consisting of dense glass struts (300±20 μm in diameter) and interconnected pores of width 580±20 μm. Hydroxyapatite formation on borate bioactive glass scaffolds was investigated in simulated body fluid (SBF) using three different scaffold/SBF (S/S) ratios (1, 2 and 10 mg/ml) at 37 °C. When immersed in SBF, degradation rate of the scaffolds and conversion to a calcium phosphate material showed a strong dependence to the S/S ratio. At high solid concentration (10 mg/ml) surface of the glass scaffolds converted to the calcium rich amorphous calcium phosphate after 30 days. At lower solid concentrations (2 and 1 mg/ml) an amorphous calcium phosphate layer formation was observed followed by the conversion to hydroxyapatite.     

Fabrication and properties of 3D printed zirconia scaffold coated with calcium silicate/hydroxyapatite

The scaffold of bone repair needs a variety of material combinations to meet its intended performance; a typical single material such as zirconia has excellent mechanical properties, while hydroxyapatite and calcium silicate are bioactive materials with different degradation rates. In this paper, porous zirconia scaffolds were fabricated using 3D printing technology. The surface of the scaffold was coated by dipping with different contents of calcium silicate and hydroxyapatite to improve the biological activity and mechanical properties. Mechanical tests show that the coating material can effectively fill the pores of the porous scaffold, increasing its compressive strength by an average of 55%. The simulated body fluid (SBF) test showed that the higher calcium silicate in the coating increased the degradation rate. Cell experiments showed that the coated scaffolds exhibited good cytocompatibility and were beneficial to the proliferation and differentiation of cells. In conclusion, coated scaffolds have potential applications in the field of bone repair.     

Mechanical properties of porous ceramic scaffolds: Influence of internal dimensions

Highly porous ceramic scaffolds have been fabricated from a 70% SiO₂–30% CaO glass powder using stereolithography and the lost-mould process combined with gel-casting. After sintering at 1200 °C the glass crystallised to a structure of wollastonite and pseudowollastonite grains in a glassy matrix with a bulk porosity of 1.3%. All scaffolds had a simple cubic strut structure with an internal porosity of approximately 42% and internal pore dimensions in the range 300–600 μm. The mean crushing strength of the scaffolds is in the range 10–25 MPa with the largest pore sizes showing the weakest strengths. The variability of scaffold strengths has been characterised using Weibull statistics and each set of scaffolds showed a Weibull modulus of m≈3 independent of pore size. The equivalent strength of the struts within the porous ceramics was estimated to be in the range 40–80 MPa using the models of the Gibson and Ashby. These strengths were found to scale with specimen size consistent with the Weibull modulus obtained from compression tests. Using a Weibull analysis, these strengths are shown to be in accordance with the strength of 3-point bend specimens of the bulk glass material fabricated using identical methods. The strength and Weibull modulus of these scaffolds are comparable to those reported for other porous ceramic scaffold materials of similar porosity made by different fabrication routes.     

Evaluation of in vitro properties of 3D micro-macro porous zirconia scaffolds coated with 58S bioactive glass using MG-63 osteoblast-like cells

A new family of bioceramic scaffolds consisting of zirconia foam-like structures with 58S bioactive glass (BG) coating was developed. Three open-cell structures fabricated by the foam replica method were coated via immersion in a sol-gel solution. The coating technique was optimised controlling the sol viscosity, condensation time, and the number of immersions in order to increase the coating thickness. The scaffolds chemical and structural characteristics were evaluated before in vitro tests, including the Ca/P ratio, crystalline phase composition, pH change, pore diameter and microporosity of the scaffolds struts. In vitro tests were performed by culturing MG-63 human osteoblast-like cells. An increase in cell proliferation of 100% was found with the decrease in pore size from 700 to 120 μm. Also, with the presence of the 58S-BG coating, an increase of cell proliferation was reached, which indicates the positive effect of the BG coating on the otherwise bioinert ceramic scaffold.     

Porous Hydroxyapatite Scaffolds Coated With Bioactive Apatite–Wollastonite Glass–Ceramics

The objective of this study was to fabricate porous hydroxyapatite (HA) scaffolds coated with bioactive A/W glass–ceramics and to examine their mechanical and biological properties. Firstly, the HA scaffolds were prepared by the polymeric sponge replication method, and then A/W glasses were coated on the surface of the struts. All of the scaffolds had a highly porous structure with well-interconnected pores. It was observed that the bioactive glass coating markedly increased the strength of the HA scaffolds. This enhancement was attributed to the formation of a dense and strong coating layer on the weak HA struts. The in vitro bioactivities of the scaffolds were markedly improved by the coatings. When the coated scaffolds were soaked in a simulated body fluid (SBF), the bone-like apatite crystals were well mineralized on their surfaces. Osteoblast-like cells (MC3T3) adhered, spread, and grew well on the porous scaffolds. The cells placed on the glass-coated HA scaffold showed a higher proliferation rate and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity than those on the pure HA scaffold. These results demonstrate that the bioactive glass coating is effective in improving the strength and bioactivity of the porous HA scaffolds.     

Effect of PCL concentration on PCL/CaSiO3 porous composite scaffolds for bone engineering

Porous polycaprolactone (PCL)-coated calcium silicate (CaSiO₃) composite scaffolds were successfully prepared by 3D gel-printing (3DGP) and vacuum impregnation technology in this study. The effect of different PCL concentration on porous CaSiO₃ scaffolds prepared by 3DGP technology was studied. The composition and morphological characteristics of PCL/CaSiO₃ scaffolds were tested by using fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), scanning electron microscope (SEM), and energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS) analysis. PCL coating amount on the scaffolds surface was calculated by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA). Compressive strength was tested by a universal testing machine, and degradability was tested by immersing the scaffolds in a simulated body fluid (SBF). The results show that PCL coating thickness increased from 7.29 μm to 12.2 μm, and the compressive strength of the corresponding composite scaffolds increased from 17.15 MPa to 24.12 MPa following with PCL concentration increasing from 7.5% to 12.5%. When the porous composite scaffolds were immersed in SBF for 28 days, the degradation ratio was 1.06% (CaSiO₃), 1.63% (CaSiO₃-7.5PCL), 1.81% (CaSiO₃-10PCL) and 1.55% (CaSiO₃-12.5PCL), respectively. It is obviously that PCL/CaSiO₃ composite scaffolds, which are suitable for bone growth in bone repair engineering, are beneficial to improve the mechanical properties and biodegradability of pure CaSiO₃ scaffolds.     

Preparation and characterization of aliphatic polyurethane and hydroxyapatite composite scaffold

Novel porous composite scaffolds for tissue engineering were prepared from aliphatic biodegradable polyurethane (PU) elastomer and hydroxyapatite (HA). It was found that the aliphatic PU was possible to load up to 50 wt % HA. The morphology and properties of the scaffolds were characterized by scanning electron microscope, X‐ray diffraction, infrared absorption spectra, mechanical testing, dynamic mechanical analysis, and in vitro degradation measurement. The results indicated that the HA/PU scaffolds had an interconnected porous structure with a pore size mainly ranging from 300 to 900 μm, and 50–200 μm micropores existed on the pores' walls. The average pore size of macropores and micropores are 510 and 100 μm, respectively. The compressive strength of the composite scaffolds showed higher enhancement with increasing HA content. In addition, the polymer matrix was completely composed of aliphatic component and exhibited progressive mass loss in vitro degradation, and the degradation rate depended on the HA content in PU matrix. The porous HA/PU composite may have a good prospect to be used as scaffold for tissue engineering. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Appl Polym Sci, 2009