Farm typologies,soil fertility variability and nutrient management in smallholder farming in Sub-Saharan Africa

Farm typologies are a useful tool to assist in unpacking and understanding the wide diversity among smallholder farms to improve targeting of crop production intensification strategies. Sustainable crop production intensification will require the development of an array of nutrient management strategies tailored to farm-specific conditions, rather than blanket recommendations across diverse farms. This study reviewed key literature on smallholder farm typologies focusing on three countries (Kenya, Malawi and Zimbabwe), to gain insights on opportunities for crop production intensification, and the importance of developing farm-specific nutrient management practices. Investigations on farm typologies have done well in highlighting the fundamental differences between farm categories, with 3–5 typologies often adequate to represent the wide differences in resource endowment. Resource-endowed farmers have ready access to large quantities of manure and mineral fertilizers, which contribute to higher soil fertility and crop productivity on their farms. Resource-constrained households use little or no manure and mineral fertilizers, and have limited capacity to invest in labour-demanding soil fertility management technologies. These farmers often have to rely on off-farm opportunities for income that are largely limited to selling unskilled labour to their resource-endowed neighbors. The variability in management practices by farmers has resulted in three main soil fertility classes that can be used for targeting soil fertility management technologies, characterized by potential response to fertilizer application as: (1) low-responsive fertile fields that receive large additions of manure and fertilizer; (2) high-responsive infertile fields that receive moderate nutrient applications; (3) poorly responsive degraded soils cultivated for many years with little or no nutrient additions. The main conclusions drawn from the review are: (1) resource constrained farmers constitute the widest band across the three countries, with many of the farmers far below the threshold for sustainable maize production intensification and lacking capacity to invest in improved seed and fertilizer, (2) farm sizes and livestock ownership were key determinants for both farmer wealth status and farm productivity, and (3) soil organic carbon and available P were good indicators for predicting previous land management, that is also invariably linked to farmer resource endowment.     

Available technologies to replenish soil fertility in East Africa

Low inherent soil fertility in the highly weathered and leached soils largely accounts for low and unsustained crop yields in most African countries. But in particular, the major nutrients, nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P), are commonly deficient in these soils. This scenario of nutrient depletion is reflected in food deficits and hence the food aid received continuously, specifically in sub-Saharan Africa. Undoubtedly, substantial efforts have been made in the continent to replenish the fertility of degraded soils in attempts to raise crop yields, towards self-sufficiency and export. Such efforts consist of applications of both organic and inorganic resources to improve the nutrient status of soils and enhanced nutrient uptake by crops, provided that soil moisture is adequate. Overall, positive crop responses to these materials have been obtained. Thus in the East African region, maize (staple) yields have been raised in one growing season from below 0.5 t/ha without nutrient inputs, to 3–5 t/ha from various nutrient amendments at the smallhold farm level. However, in spite of the positive crop responses to nutrient inputs, farmers are generally slow to adopt the soil fertility management technologies. In this paper we review the impact of some technologies, focussing the use of nutrient resources of different characteristics (qualities) in relation to improved crop yields, with an overall goal to enhance technology adoption. Thus, inorganic resources or fertilizers often give immediate crop responses, but their use or adoption is rather restricted to large-scale farmers who can afford to buy these materials. Organic resources, which include crop residues, water hyacinth and agroforestry shrubs and trees, are widely distributed, but they are generally of low quality, reflecting the need to apply large quantities to meet crop nutrient demands. Moreover, most organics will add N mainly to soils. On the other hand, phosphate rocks of varying reactivity are found widely in Africa and are refined elsewhere to supply soluble P sources. The recently developed soil fertility management options in East Africa have targeted the efficient use of N and P by crops and the integrated nutrient management approach. Some people have also felt that the repackaging of inputs in small, affordable quantities, such as the PREP-PAC described in this paper, may be an avenue to attract smallhold farmers to use nutrient inputs. Nonetheless, crop responses to nutrient inputs vary widely within and across agroecozones (AEZs), suggesting specificity in recommendations. We highlight this observation in a case study whereby eight soil fertility management options, developed independently, are being tested side-by-side at on-farm level. Farmers will be empowered to identify technologies from their own choices that are agronomically effective and economically friendly. This approach of technology testing and subsequent adoption is recommended for technology development in future.     

Profitability of agro-forestry based soil fertility management technologies: the case of small holder food production in Western Kenya

Persistent food insecurity accompanied by low and declining farm household incomes are a common feature of many small holder maize and bean producers in western Kenya. This has been largely attributed to soil nutrient depletion, among other factors. One way of addressing soil fertility problems in many maize-based cropping systems is the use of agro-forestry based technologies. We carried out a survey in western Kenya (Vihiga and Siaya districts) aimed at analyzing the financial and social profitability of use of agroforestry based (improved tree fallows) and other soil fertility management technologies among smallholder farmers. The Policy Analysis Matrix (PAM) was used to determine the financial and social profitability of different production systems, which were categorized on the basis of the technology used to address soil fertility. Farm budgets were first prepared and in turn used to construct the PAMs for six production systems namely: maize–bean intercrop without any soil fertility management inputs; maize–bean intercrop with chemical fertilizers only; maize–bean intercrop with a combination of chemical fertilizers and improved fallows; maize–bean intercrop with improved fallows only; maize–bean intercrop with a combination of improved fallows and rock phosphate; and maize–bean intercrop with Farm Yard Manure (FYM) only. Results revealed that use of chemical fertilizers with improved fallows was the most profitable technology and thus the study recommended that farmers be encouraged to intensify the use of chemical fertilizers. To make chemical fertilizers more accessible to farmers, the study also recommended that good linkages be made between farmers and micro credit institutions so that small scale farmers are not actually biased against due to lack of collateral when credit is being advanced to clients.     

Organic Matter Management as an Underlying Cause for Soil Fertility Gradients on Smallholder Farms in Zimbabwe

Management of spatial and temporal variability of soil fertility within fields and farms is one major challenge for increasing farm-level crop productivity in smallholder agriculture. A study was conducted across 120 on-farm field sites in three agro-ecological regions of Zimbabwe to identify management factors influencing the formation of within-field/farm soil fertility gradients. Using farmer participatory research approaches, host farmers were put into three classes according to resource endowment, namely, Resource-endowed, Intermediate and Resource-constrained farmers. Each host farmer identified the most (rich) and least (poor) productive field or field section, which were then studied over two years. Farmer criteria for defining soil fertility ranged from colour through elements of soil structure to crop response following external nutrient inputs. The fertility ranking of fields consistently matched with laboratory indices, with rich fields containing significantly more soil organic carbon (SOC) and nutrients than the corresponding poor fields. Fertility gradients were evident within and across farms belonging to different farmer classes. The mean SOC content for rich fields were >6.0 g kg⁻¹ compared with <4.6 g kg⁻¹ for the designated poor fields. Rich fields belonging to Resource-endowed farmers had 16–28% more SOC than those belonging to their resource-constrained counterparts, suggesting differences in organic matter management. Differences in SOC and fertility status between rich and poor fields were wider in two of the study areas which had more than 70 years of cultivation in contrast to the third site which had been under smallholder farming for only 20 years, suggesting that the observed fertility gradients are a cumulative effect of years of differential management practices by different farmer classes. Analysis of potential benefits from in situ organic biomass inputs suggested that the processes of organic matter capture and utilization discriminated against Resource-constrained farmers. About 50% of in situ biomass, preferentially maize stover, was lost in three dry season months, and up to 72% of potentially recyclable N is lost from poor fields managed by Resource-constrained farmers. In contrast, Resource-endowed farmers incorporated more than 1.5 t C, 25 kg N and 5 kg P ha⁻¹ season⁻¹ because of their access to draught power during the early dry season. Such inputs could make a difference on these nutrient-depleted soils. Intermediate farmers represented a diverse transitional group whose size and variability could be indicative of the dynamism of technology usage. It was concluded that management of soil fertility gradients to increase crop productivity on smallholder farms hinges on increasing the capacity and efficiency with which organic matter is generated and utilized by different farmer weaclth groups across temporal scales.     

The role of inorganic fertilizers and their management practices

Nutrient management is the key issue in sustainable soil fertility. N, P, K fertilization aims not only for a high economic return of the investment through optimized yield and quality, but also for minimum environmental hazards. The basic concept underlying integrated plant nutrition systems, is the maintenance and possible increase of soil fertility for sustaining enhanced crop productivity through optimal use of all sources of plant nutrients, particularly inorganic fertilizer, in an integrated manner and as appropriate to each specific ecological, social and economic situation. Much research has established the importance of fertilizers in increasing the fertility of soil and in influencing its productivity. It has been observed that applying fertilizers causes many changes in the soil, including chemical changes, that can positively or negatively influence its productiveness. Only a fraction of the fertilizer applied to the soil is taken up by the crop, the rest either remains in the soil or is lost through leaching, physical wash-off, fixation by the soil, or release to the atmosphere through chemical and microbiological processes. The critical information on the relative merits of different fertilization practices such as method of fertilizer placement, time and rate of application and type of fertilizers, is essential. Results from different field and laboratory experiments which helped to achieve maximum efficiency, in the most economical and sustainable way of fertilizer use to reduce the nutrient losses and production costs to the farmers and prevent environmental pollution are presented in the paper.     

Recycling of nutrients in Japanese mint - assessment of soil fertility and crop yield

The efficiency of mint-residue, composted alone and amended with starter nutrients, microbial culture and soil suspension (hereafter termed amended compost) was compared with farm yard manure and inorganic fertilizer on the yield of Japanese mint (Mentha arvensis L.) and improvement of soil fertility. Herbage, essential oil yield, nutrient uptake of Japanese mint and soil available nutrients were significantly enhanced due to application of amended compost as compared to nonamended compost, farm yard manure and inorganic fertilizer. Organic fertilized soils maintained significantly higher available nutrients throughout the crop growth period as compared to inorganic fertilized soils. No additional improvement in yields and soil fertility was recorded with combined application of compost and inorganic fertilizer in 1:1 ratio as against addition of compost alone. Advantage of such combinations was recorded in case of farm yard manure. Results of the study suggested possibilities for nutrient recycling through composted mint-residue for supplementing the fertilizers requirement of Japanese mint.     

Fertiliser use and definition of farmer domains for impact-oriented research in the northern Guinea savanna of Nigeria

One of the options to alleviate soil fertility constraints for sustainable agriculture in the savannas of West Africa is to develop soil nutrient management technologies from an adequate supply and feasible share of organic and mineral inputs. This paper makes a diagnosis of farm-level use of organic and inorganic inputs, as a basis for the development of technologies.The results from the diagnosis are then used to develop a framework for characterizing farmers for impact-oriented research on soil nutrient management systems. The survey was carried out with 200 farmers carefully selected in two villages in the northern Guinea savanna of Nigeria. The results showed that more than 90% of farmers in both villages used chemical fertilizers. This is contrary to a general belief that they are not widely applied to food crops by small holders in African agriculture. However, up to 81% of the fields received less than half of the recommended 120 because of high costs due, probably to removal of subsidies and inefficient marketing systems. Organic inputs such as animal manure were applied in very small quantities (about 8% of the requirements). However there is evidence of integrated use of inorganic fertilizers and organic manure on some(24%) of the fields. The problem to be addressed is that of the production (and efficient utilisation) of organic inputs in the northern Guinea savanna. Nitrogen deficiency is the most limiting soil nutrient in the cereal-dominated systems of study area. On this basis, farmers were classified into two a-priori groups using a threshold of 30, and multiple quantitative variables were fitted in a discriminant analysis tovalidate the typology. Results indicated that more than 75% of farmers were well classified into two groups that had the characteristics of thea-priori groups. Two others were a typical and included the remaining 25% of farmers. Thus, there are a total of four groups of farmers referred to as farmer domains in this paper. The two domains with 75% of well-classified individuals are suitable for the selection of farmers with whom to conduct applied research or for development activities because they represent the general patterns in the supply and use of soil nutrients in the study area.Although basic research can be done in the four domains, the two atypical groups are most suited for process-level studies to improve the understanding of factors that make the systems either more efficient or less efficient than the two other farmer domains. In either case, representative farmers were easily identified by their highest probability of belonging to a specific domain from the model results. Multivariate models constitute a good framework to make a typology of, and to select farmers for, participatory research and extrapolation of results in the northern Guinea savanna. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

A critical analysis of challenges and opportunities for soil fertility restoration in Sudano-Sahelian West Africa

Since the 1970s, research throughout West Africa showed that low soil organic matter and limited availability of plant nutrients, in particular phosphorus and nitrogen, are major bottlenecks to agricultural productivity, which is further hampered by substantial topsoil losses through wind and water erosion. A few widely recognized publications pointing to massive nutrient mining of the existing crop–livestock production systems triggered numerous studies on a wide array of management strategies and policies suited to improve soil fertility. Throughout Sudano-Sahelian West Africa, the application of crop residue mulch, animal manure, rockphosphates and soluble mineral fertilizers have been shown to enhance crop yields, whereby yield increases varied with the agro-ecological setting and the rates of amendments applied. In more humid areas of Western Africa, the intercropping of cereals with herbaceous or ligneous leguminous species, the installation of fodder banks for increased livestock and manure production, and composting of organic material also proved beneficial to crop production. However, there is evidence that the low adoption of improved management strategies and the lack of long-term investments in soil fertility can be ascribed to low product prices for agricultural commodities, immediate cash needs, risk aversion and labour shortage of small-scale farmers across the region. The wealth of knowledge gathered during several decades of on-station and on-farm experimentation calls for an integration of these data into a database to serve as input variables for models geared towards ex-ante assessment of the suitability of technologies and policies at the scale of farms, communities and regions. Several modelling approaches exist that can be exploited in this sense. Yet, they have to be improved in their ability to account for agro-ecological and socio-economic differences at various geographical scales and for residual effects of management options, thereby allowing scenario analysis and guiding further fundamental and participatory research, extension and political counselling.     

The prospects for integrated nutrient management for sustainable rainfed lowland rice production in Sukumaland, Tanzania

The possibilities of integrated nutrient management for sustainable ricecultivation are investigated for rainfed, lowland rice in Sukumaland,northwestern Tanzania. Typical, hardpan rice soils in Sukumaland have ratherlowlevels of organic matter, total nitrogen and available phosphorus, and a low tomedium amount of exchangeable potassium. Consumption of mineral fertilizers inrice is, however, very low due to availability problems and sharply increasedprices of fertilizers. Use of locally available resources for soil fertilityimprovement is hampered by the additional inputs of farm household labourinvolved. High labour inputs per hectare without increases in capital inputslead to lower marginal and average products per hour of labour. Furthermore, insemi-arid Sukumaland biomass production of green manures is seriouslyrestrictedby climate. The amount of kraal cattle manure is insufficient and half thehouseholds have no easy access to it. Using rice straw as cattle feed andthatching material has priority over soil fertility improvement. Some farmersindicate that at present there is not yet an urgent need for improvedintegratednutrient management in Sukumaland rice cultivation. Adoption of integratednutrient management based technologies depends on conducive socio-economic,agro-ecological and public policy circumstances. Farmer investment in learningand a favourable policy environment are thus no guarantee for worldwideadoptionof these technologies by farm households.     

Factors affecting the use of fertilizers and manure by smallholders: the case of Vihiga,western Kenya

Sub-Saharan Africa faces huge food supply challenges due to increasing human population, limited opportunities to increase arable land, and declining yields associated with continuously declining soil fertility. To cater for their food requirements, smallholders use only modest levels of inorganic fertilizers and rely to a large extent on manure, which is generally of low quality. To explore factors influencing fertilizer and manure use at the farm level, 253 farm households in Vihiga district of western Kenya were sampled. A pair of Tobit models was used to relate amounts of manure and fertilizer used to household variables. The results indicate that the use of both manure and fertilizer reciprocally influence each other and are strongly influenced by household factors, and also imply that manure and fertilizer uses are endogenous. Policy changes are required to (1) reduce the burden on farming alone in rural areas; (2) promote the use of higher-cost, higher-value inputs such as fertilizers; (3) improve access to input and output markets; and (4) encourage farmer education so as to promote sustainable soil fertility management. Improved understanding of the biophysical and socioeconomic environment of smallholder systems can help target sustainable soil fertility interventions more appropriately.

Social, economic and policy dimensions of soil organic matter management in sub-Sahara Africa: challenges and opportunities

In recent years and in some situations the status of soil organic matter (SOM) has deteriorated considerably due to long periods of continuous cultivation and limited external inputs in the form of mineral fertilizers. Deterioration of SOM varies by agro-ecological zones, by soil types and by cropping patterns. It is more intense in East Africa, followed by coastal West Africa and Southern Africa and least intensive in the Sahel and Central Africa. It is also more serious in areas under low-input agriculture irrespective of the prevailing cropping system. The major consequence of the decrease in SOM in the tropics is lower agricultural productivity with a direct negative effect on food security. While biophysical dynamics of SOM have been extensively covered in the literature, social considerations have not received similar attention. This paper examines the social, economic and policy factors associated with the management of tropical soil organic matter. Empirical data from a range of environments in Africa show that SOM improvement options yield a positive return to land as well as labour. However, there are a number of constraints. Social constraints are related to the large quantities of organic matter that are required (case of farmyard manure), the competitive uses for the material (case of crop residues), land and labour requirements, and gender-related issues. From a policy stand point, unsecured tenure rights together with price distortions and other market failures may be important constraints. Challenges for sustainable management of SOM are identified. These include management conflicts, land tenure arrangements, the divergence in goals between individuals and society, land and labour requirements, inadequate support systems for land users, profitability issues, the role of subsidies, and the absence of national action plans. A number of opportunities are identified that could enhance the improvement or maintenance of SOM. These include: exploring the need and potential role of community-based SOM management practices; development of an integrated plant nutrient management strategy involving both organic and inorganic inputs; and development of concrete national action plans. It is argued that because externalities of SOM improvement or maintenance extend beyond the farmer's fields, SOM investment may require cost sharing between individuals and the society. Policies on subsidies need to be reconsidered. Research priorities are identified that require closer collaboration between scientists from a variety of disciplines. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Soil fertility status and nutrient input–output flows of specialised organic cropping systems: a review

The management of specialised organic crops for vegetable and fruit production require the use of imported fertilizers. A wide range of fertilizers is currently available to organic farmers. These include bulky organic materials with a relatively low nutrient concentration commonly used as base dressing (e.g. composts, solid animal manures) and complementary commercial organic fertilizers with relatively high nutrient concentrations to adjust nutrient supply to crop requirements (e.g. feather meal, hoof and horn meal, vinasse, meat and bone meal, etc.). Nutrient imbalances are a major threat affecting the long term sustainability of horticultural and fruit cultivation systems. Major reasons for these imbalances are the biased element composition of base as well as complementary fertilizers in relation to the nutrient offtakes via harvested products. Gaseous nitrogen losses during manure management and gaseous as well as leaching nitrogen losses after application are major reasons for such nutrient imbalances, as they lead to a relative increase in the concentration of other elements. Conceptual weaknesses in the fertilizer approach in organic farming exist, namely the preferred application of slow release nitrogen fertilizers often rich in phosphorus. This review suggests that the current soil fertility approaches based on application of solid fertilizers and simultaneously a low rate of N inputs via N₂ fixation do not foster balanced nutrient levels. The key challenge is to design cropping systems with a higher share of N inputs via biological N₂ fixation, and to find fertilizers with a nutrient stoichiometry better suited to match the overall specific offtakes of fertilized crops.     

Major nutrient balances in small-scale vegetable farming systems in peri-urban areas in China

Balances of major nutrients such as nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K) in small-scale farming systems are of critical importance to nutrient management and sustainable agricultural development. Mass balances of N, P, and K and some of their influencing factors were studied for two years from July 2003 to July 2005 on small-scale vegetable-farming systems in two contrasting peri-urban areas (Nanjing and Wuxi) of the Yangtze river delta region of China. This balance approach considered organic fertilizer inputs (cow manure, pig manure, and human biosolids), inorganic fertilizer inputs (urea, composite fertilizer, and phosphates), irrigation water, and atmospheric deposition; and considered outputs by vegetables. Input via organic fertilizers was significant for all element balances in the Nanjing area. Inorganic and organic fertilizer, particularly inorganic fertilizer, contributed major nutrient inputs to the system in the Wuxi area. Compared with nutrient output by vegetables, there were significant surpluses of N and P on two vegetable farm systems. Furthermore, N surplus in the Nanjing area was higher than that in the Wuxi area with an inverse relationship to P surplus. In contrast, the general trend of K balances was negative on both sites; hence, the nutrient use efficiency was significantly lower for N and P than K. The nutrient imbalance may be attributed to the differences between fertilizer types and management modes driven by social economic status differences among farmer households. The large N and P net excess creates an environmental threat because of potential losses to ground or surface waters, whereas negative K balance creates soil fertility risks. The results highlight researchers’ and farmers’ need to develop rational fertilization technology to optimize nutrient management on vegetable farmlands to promote sustainable agricultural development in peri-urban areas.     

Effect of farmer management strategies on spatial variability of soil fertility and crop nutrient uptake in contrasting agro-ecological zones in Zimbabwe

Variability of soil fertility within, and across farms, poses a major challenge for increasing crop productivity in smallholder systems of sub-Saharan Africa. This study assessed the effect of farmers’ resource endowment and nutrient management strategies on variability in soil fertility and plant nutrient uptake between different fields in Gokwe South (ave. rainfall ~650 mm year⁻¹; 16.3 persons km⁻²) and Murewa (ave. rainfall ~850 mm year⁻¹; 44.1 persons km⁻²) districts, Zimbabwe. In Murewa, resource-endowed farmers applied manure (>3.5 t ha⁻¹ year⁻¹) on fields closest to their homesteads (homefields) and none to fields further away (outfields). In Gokwe the manure was not targeted to any particular field, and farmers quickly abandoned outfields and opened up new fields further way from the homestead once fertility had declined, but homefields were continually cultivated. Soil available P was higher in homefields (8–13 mg kg⁻¹) of resource-endowed farmers than on outfields and all fields on resource constrained farms (2–6 mg kg⁻¹) in Murewa. Soil fertility decreased with increasing distance from the homestead in Murewa while the reverse trend occurred in Gokwe South, indicating the impact of different soil fertility management strategies on spatial soil fertility gradients. In both districts, maize showed deficiency of N and P, implying that these were the most limiting nutrients. It was concluded that besides farmers’ access to resources, the direction of soil fertility gradients also depends on agro-ecological conditions which influence resource management strategies.     

Influence of plant density on variability of soil fertility and nutrient budgets in low input East African highland banana (Musa spp. AAA-EA) cropping systems

The productivity of East African highland (EAH) banana cropping systems is declining, particularly in areas with low inherent soil fertility. Soil fertility management requires knowledge of nutrient flows at the interface between the soil surface and the soil system. The magnitude of soil fertility dynamics and nutrient depletion was studied for a short-term banana plant density trial in three contrasting agro-ecological sites of Rwanda (Kibungo low rainfall with medium soil fertility, Rubona high rainfall with low soil fertility and Ruhengeri high rainfall with high soil fertility) using nutrient stock and partial nutrient balance calculations. Plant density did not influence significantly nutrient mass fractions in plant parts (fruit, leaves and pseudostems) but nutrients contained through shredded leaves and pseudostems and those removed through bunch dry matter increased with plant density. Plant density responses to variation in soil fertility and partial nutrient balances seemed to depend on diversity in climate and soil type. Partial N and K balances (kg ha^?1 year^?1) were estimated to be strongly negative at Rubona and Ruhengeri while Ca and Mg were positive at Kibungo and Ruhengeri but negative at Rubona. This study showed that partial nutrient balances associated with soil nutrient stocks can provide the first order of magnitude of nutrient depletion in low input EAH banana cropping systems. This brings attention from agricultural researchers and farmers to develop options that can improve the productivity of these systems, where resource availability for improved nutrient management is scarce.     

Variable grain legume yields,responses to phosphorus and rotational effects on maize across soil fertility gradients on African smallholder farms

Promiscuous soyabean varieties have potential to contribute significantly to income generation, food security and soil N budgets on smallholder farms. One of the major factors limiting this potential is farmers’ preference to allocate nutrient resources to food security cereal crops on the most fertile fields, leaving grain legumes to grow on residual fertility on infertile fields. Two experiments were conducted to: (i) compare the current farmer practice with targeting manure and single super phosphate (SSP) to soyabean in a three-year rotation cycle on two fields with different soil fertility: an infertile sandy soil and a more fertile clay soil; and (ii) assess the effects of variability of soil fertility within and across farms on productivity of soyabean and groundnut. In the first experiment, soyabean (<0.2 t ha⁻¹) and maize yields (<0.7 t ha⁻¹) without fertilizer were poor on a degraded sandy soil. Both crops responded poorly to SSP due to deficiency of other nutrients. Manure application significantly increased soyabean and maize yields, led to yield stabilization over three seasons and also significantly increased the proportion of N₂ fixed by soyabean (measured using ¹⁵N natural abundance) from 60% to 83%. On the sandy soil, P was used more efficiently and gross margins were greater when SSP and manure were applied to maize in a maize–soyabean rotation. Soyabean and maize yields without fertilizer inputs were larger on clay soil with moderate fertility (0.4–0.7 t ha⁻¹ and 2.0–2.3 t ha⁻¹ respectively) and were significantly increased by application of SSP and manure. Within rotations, P recovery was higher when manure and SSP were applied to maize (43 and 25%) than when applied to soyabean (20 and 19%). However, application of manure to soyabean on the clay was more profitable than application to maize for individual crops and within rotations. In the second experiment, soyabean and groundnut yields were largest (∼1 and ∼0.8 t ha⁻¹ respectively) on plots closest to homesteads on wealthy farms, which were more fertile due to good past management. Yields were poor (< 0.5 t ha⁻¹) on other fields which previously had received little nutrient inputs. Soyabean and groundnut yields correlated well with available P (R ² = 0.5–0.7) and soil organic C (SOC) contents (R ² = 0.4–0.6). For smallholder farmers to maximise benefits from legume production they need to focus attention on the more fertile plots, although production should be optimized in relation to maize. Targeting nutrients to maize as currently practiced by farmers was more efficient and economic under poor soil fertility conditions, whilst potential exists to increase income by targeting manure to soyabean on the more fertile soils.     

Farm‐scale assessment of maize–pigeonpea productivity in Northern Tanzania

Little is known about productivity of smallholder maize–pigeonpea intercropping systems in sub-Saharan Africa. We conducted a survey of 277 farm households in Northern Tanzania to assess socio-economic factors, field management characteristics, and their association with productivity of maize–pigeonpea intercrops. On each farm, crop assessments were focused on a field that the farmer identified as most important for food supply. Variables associated with yields were evaluated using linear regression and regression classification. Biomass production ranged between 1.0 and 16.6 for maize, and between 0.2 and 11.9 t ha^?1 for pigeonpea (at maize harvest). The corresponding grain yields ranged between 0.1 and 9.5 for maize, and between 0.1 and 2.1 t ha^?1 for pigeonpea. Plant density at harvest, number of years the field had been cultivated, slope, weeding, soil fertility class, fertiliser and manure use were significantly associated with variation in maize grain yield, with interactions among the factors. Fields on flat and gentle slopes with plant density above 24,000 ha^?1 had 28% extra yields when fertiliser was applied, while less than 24,000 plants ha^?1 yielded 16% extra yield when manure was applied. Plant density at harvest was the key factor associated with pigeonpea yield; fields with densities above 24,000 plants ha^?1 yielded an average of 1.4 t ha^?1, while less than 24,000 plants ha^?1 yielded 0.5 t ha^?1. We conclude that performance of intercrops can be enhanced through application of organic and inorganic nutrient sources, and agronomic interventions including weeding, implementing soil conservation measures on steep slopes and optimising plant density.

     

Overcoming soil nutrient constraints to crop production in West Africa: Importance of fertilizers and priorities in soil fertility research

The Alfisols, Oxisols, Ultisols and Inceptisols which dominate the soils of West Africa have sustained crop growth for a very long time. As a consequence, their fertility has become perilously low and the task of increasing or even maintaining the productive capacity of these soils has become perhaps the greatest challenge to agricultural scientists in this latter half of the 20th century.Water is useful not only for the growth of plants but also for the efficient use of costly inputs such as fertilizers. On the other hand, fertilizers increase the water-use efficiency. Such interactions must be closely studied so as to maximize the impact of inputs of agricultural production.The nutrients in the soil are always in a state of flux, with additions and subtractions. Monitoring the dynamics of the nutrients would promote their efficient use by crops and prolong the productive life of the soils.Several models currently exist for the study of organic matter dynamics in soils. These models should be applied to the West African situation since it is vital to develop management practices that can promote efficient use of nutrients released during mineralisation of soil organic matter.Judicious fertilizer use in West Africa should be promoted as this practice will enhance agricultural production while protecting the fragile environment.     

Effect of the integrated use of legume residue,poultry manure and inorganic fertilizers on maize yield,nutrient uptake and soil properties

Identification of a sustainable integrated soil fertility management option in the tropics will not only salvage the degraded soils but also enhances the attainment of the goal of food security. This study was conducted in 2004 and 2005 on a degraded tropical Alfisol in south western Nigeria to evaluate the effect of legume residue, poultry manure and inorganic fertilizers on maize yield, nutrient uptake and soil properties. The treatments consisted of two rates of poultry manure (0 and 5 t ha⁻¹), three rates of N fertilizer (0, 50 and 100 kg N ha⁻¹ applied as urea), three rates of P fertilizer (0, 30 and 60 kg P ha⁻¹ applied as single super phosphate) and two soybean treatments (with or without incorporation of legume residue) in various combinations as a factorial experiment in Randomized Complete Block design with three replicates. Results showed that poultry manure alone led to significant increase in maize yield (60%) and soil organic matter (45%). In contrast, legume residue incorporation gave significantly lower increase in yield (7%) and soil organic matter (11%). However, the combined application of poultry manure and legume incorporation led to 72% increase in maize yield as opposed to 63 and 10% increase recorded when manure alone or legume alone were incorporated, respectively. Optimal maize yield was achieved when manure application was integrated with P fertilizer application. The interaction of P fertilizer and legume incorporation indicated that soil phosphorus and maize P concentration were significantly increased with the application of the P fertilizer and legume incorporation. Hence, the application of P fertilizer alone is most likely to be economical compared with its integration with legume incorporation.     

Soil organic carbon (SOC) management for sustainable productivity of cropping and agro-forestry systems in Eastern and Southern Africa

In Eastern and Southern Africa, the shifting from the no-external input agriculture (shifting cultivation through slash and burn) to intensified agricultural systems has resulted in widespread agro-ecosystems with high soil organic carbon and nutrient depletion. This is quite evident in farming systems with reduced fallow period or those that practice continuous cropping without or with little inputs. Long-term experiments indicate that losses of up to 0.69 t carbon ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹ in the soil surface layers are common. Such losses are commonly reported by farmers engaged in participatory community-based research development projects. This calls for judicious strategies for recapitalization or replacement of these depletions. Such strategies include direct SOC replenishment through addition of organic materials, notably manures, wastes, residues and plant litter; biomass transfer; incorporation of improved fallows in the farming systems. Indirect contribution to SOM replenishment or recapitalization may be achieved through inorganic fertilizations and amendments; legume integration in the production system; and combined inorganic and organic inputs. Research is required to identify inputs that help meet both nutrients availability while contributing to SOC build up at the same time. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.