Linking denotational semantics with operational semantics for web services

Web Services have become more and more important in these years, and BPEL4WS (BPEL) is a de facto standard for the web service composition and orchestration. It contains several distinct features, including the scope-based compensation and fault handling mechanism. The denotational semantics and operational semantics have been explored for BPEL. The two semantic models should be consistent. This paper considers the linking of these two semantics. Our approach is to derive the denotational semantics from operational semantics for BPEL, which aims for the consistency of the two models. Moreover, the derivation can be applied in exploring the program equivalence easily, especially for parallel programs.     

From algebraic semantics to denotational semantics for Verilog

This paper considers how the algebraic semantics for Verilog relates with its denotational semantics. Our approach is to derive the denotational semantics from the algebraic semantics. We first present the algebraic laws for Verilog. Every program can be expressed as a guarded choice that can model the execution of a program. In order to investigate the parallel expansion laws, a sequence is introduced, indicating which instantaneous action is due to which exact parallel component. A head normal form is defined for each program by using a locality sequence. We provide a strategy for deriving the denotational semantics based on head normal form. Using this strategy, the denotational semantics for every program can be calculated. Program equivalence can also be explored by using the derived denotational semantics. A short version of this paper appeared in Proc. ICECCS 2006: 11th IEEE International Conference on Engineering of Complex Computer Systems [48]. This work is partially supported by the National Basic Research Program of China (No. 2005CB321904), the National High Technology Research and Development Program of China (No. 2007AA010302) and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 90718004). Jonathan Bowen is a visiting professor at King’s College London and an emeritus professor at London South Bank University.     

Linking operational semantics and algebraic semantics for a probabilistic timed shared-variable language

Complex software systems typically involve features like time, concurrency and probability, with probabilistic computations playing an increasing role. However, it is currently challenging to formalize languages incorporating all those features. Recently, the language PTSC has been proposed to integrate probability and time with shared-variable concurrency (Zhu et al. (2006, 2009) [51] and [53]), where the operational semantics has been explored and a set of algebraic laws has been investigated via bisimulation. This paper investigates the link between the operational and algebraic semantics of PTSC, highlighting both its theoretical and practical aspects.The link is obtained by deriving the operational semantics from the algebraic semantics, an approach that may be understood as establishing soundness of the operational semantics with respect to the algebraic semantics. Algebraic laws are provided that suffice to convert any PTSC program into a form consisting of a guarded choice or an internal choice between programs, which are initially deterministic. That form corresponds to a simple execution of the program, so it is used as a basis for an operational semantics. In that way, the operational semantics is derived from the algebraic semantics, with transition rules resulting from the derivation strategy. In fact the derived transition rules and the derivation strategy are shown to be equivalent, which may be understood as establishing completeness of the operational semantics with respect to the algebraic semantics.That theoretical approach to the link is complemented by a practical one, which animates the link using Prolog. The link between the two semantics proceeds via head normal form. Firstly, the generation of head normal form is explored, in particular animating the expansion laws for probabilistic interleaving. Then the derivation of the operational semantics is animated using a strategy that exploits head normal form. The operational semantics is also animated. These animations, which again supports to claim soundness and completeness of the operational semantics with respect to the algebraic, are interesting because they provide a practical demonstration of the theoretical results.     

Trace Semantics and Algebraic Laws for Total Store Order Memory Model

Modern multiprocessors deploy a variety of weak memory models(WMMs).Total Store Order(TSO) is a widely-used weak memory model in SPARC implementations and x86 architecture.It omits the store-load constraint by allowing each core to employ a write buffer.In this paper,we apply Unifying Theories of Programming(abbreviated as UTP) in investigating the trace semantics for TSO,acting in the denotational semantics style.A trace is expressed as a sequence of snapshots,which records the changes in registers,write buffers and the shared memory.All the valid execution results containing reorderings can be described after kicking out those that do not satisfy program order and modification order.This paper also presents a set of algebraic laws for TSO.We study the concept of head normal form,and every program can be expressed in the head normal form of the guarded choice which is able to model the execution of a program with reorderings.Then the linearizability of the TSO model is supported.Furthermore,we consider the linking between trace semantics and algebraic semantics.The linking is achieved through deriving trace semantics from algebraic semantics,and the derivation strategy under the TSO model is provided.     

Semantic theories of programs with nested interrupts

In the design of dependable software for embedded and real-time operating systems, time analysis is a crucial but extremely difficult issue, the challenge of which is exacerbated due to the randomness and nondeterminism of interrupt handling behaviors. Thus research into a theory that integrates interrupt behaviors and time analysis seems to be important and challenging. In this paper, we present a programming language to describe programs with interrupts that is comprised of two essential parts: main program and interrupt handling programs. We also explore a timed operational semantics and a denotational semantics to specify the meanings of our language. Furthermore, a strategy of deriving denotational semantics from the timed operational semantics is provided to demonstrate the soundness of our operational semantics by showing the consistency between the derived denotational semantics and the original denotational semantics.     

The semantics of the combination of atomized statements and parallel choice

In this paper we define a uniform language that is an extension of the language underlying the process algebraPA. One of the main extensions of this language overPA is given by so-called atomizing brackets. If we place these brackets around a statement then we treat this statement as an atomic action. Put differently, these brackets remove all interleaving points. We present a transition system for the language and derive its operational semantics. We show that there are several options for defining a transition system such that the resulting operational semantics is a conservative extension of the semantics forPA. We define a semantic domain and a denotational model for the language. Next we define a closure operator on the semantic domain and show how to use this closure operator to derive a fully abstract denotational semantics. Then the algebraic theory of the language is considered. We define a collection of axioms and a term rewrite system based on these axioms. Using this term rewrite system we are able to identify normal forms for the language. It is shown that these axioms capture the denotational equality. It follows that if two terms are provably equal then they have the same operational semantics. Finally, we show how to extend the axiomatization in order to axiomatize its operational equivalence.     

进程创建的语义及等价性

针对一个基于共享变量的带有进程创建的命令式语言,用变迁系统描述了它的结构操作语义,并用扩展的状态变迁迹模型定义了它的指称语义,在该模型下,状态变迁被区分为两种不同形式,分别表示发生在原进程和被创建进程中的状态变迁,这样便可以定义适当的语义复合运算,在对命令的指称进行复合时根据变迁类型的不同对变迁迹进行串行或交错连接,恰当地反映了进程的并发运行受创建命令在程序中的相对位置的限制,最后证明了这两个语义     

Operational and goal-independent denotational semantics for Prolog with cut

In this paper we propose an operational and a denotational semantics for Prolog. We deal with the control rules of Prolog and the cut operator. Our denotational semantics provides a goal-independent semantics. This means that the behaviour of a goal in a program is defined as the evaluation of the goal in the denotation (semantics) of the program. We show how our denotational semantics can be specialised into a computed answer semantics and into a call pattern semantics. Our work provides a basis for a precise abstract interpretation of Prolog programs.     

Non-Standard Semantics for Program Slicing

In this paper we generalize the notion of compositional semantics to cope with transfinite reductions of a transition system. Standard denotational and predicate transformer semantics, even though compositional, provide inadequate models for some known program manipulation techniques. We are interested in the systematic design of extended compositional semantics, observing possible transfinite computations, i.e. computations that may occur after a given number of infinite loops. This generalization is necessary to deal with program manipulation techniques modifying the termination status of programs, such as program slicing. We include the transfinite generalization of semantics in the hierarchy developed in 1997 by P. Cousot, where semantics at different levels of abstraction are related with each other by abstract interpretation. We prove that a specular hierarchy of non-standard semantics modeling transfinite computations of programs can be specifiedin such a way that the standard hierarchy can be derived by abstract interpretation. We prove that non-standard transfinite denotational and predicate transformer semantics can be both systematically derived as solutions of simple abstract domain equations involving the basic operation of reduced power of abstract domains. This allows us to prove the optimality of these semantics, i.e. they are the most abstract semantics in the hierarchy which are compositional and observe respectively the terminating and initial states of transfinite computations, providing an adequate mathematical model for program manipulation.     

使用延时演算的时间化RSL的指称语义

使用扩展的持续时间演算(EDC)模型,给出了时间化的RAISE描述语言(RSL)的一个子集的指称语义.在扩展的持续时间演算模型中加入了一些新的特征,并探究了它们的代数定律.这些定律在形式化实时程序和验证实时性质中起着重要作用.最后还给出了时间化RSL的一些代数定律.这些定律可以从其指称语义证明,并用于程序的转化和优化.     

LCF considered as a programming language

The paper studies connections between denotational and operational semantics for a simple programming language based on LCF. It begins with the connection between the behaviour of a program and its denotation. It turns out that a program denotes ⊥ in any of several possible semantics if it does not terminate. From this it follows that if two terms have the same denotation in one of these semantics, they have the same behaviour in all contexts. The converse fails for all the semantics. If, however, the language is extended to allow certain parallel facilities behavioural equivalence does coincide with denotational equivalence in one of the semantics considered, which may therefore be called “fully abstract”. Next a connection is given which actually determines the semantics up to isomorphism from the behaviour alone. Conversely, by allowing further parallel facilities, every r.e. element of the fully abstract semantics becomes definable, thus characterising the programming language, up to interdefinability, from the set of r.e. elements of the domains of the semantics.     

PCF的信息系统模型

带类型的λ－演算是一个逻辑系统，它可以作为程序语言的基础．Ｐｌｏｔｋｉｎ所引进的ＰＣＦ就是这样一类程序语言．Ｐｌｏｔｋｉｎ构造了ＰＣＦ的一个模型，然后讨论与这个模型相关的指称语义和操作语义之间的配合问题──简单配合和完全配合．本文利用Ｓｃｏｔｔ引进的信息系统概念构造ＰＣＦ的另一种模型，并证明与这个模型对应的指称语义与操作语义是完全配合的．     

The rewriting logic semantics project

Rewriting logic is a flexible and expressive logical framework that unifies algebraic denotational semantics and structural operational semantics (SOS) in a novel way, avoiding their respective limitations and allowing succinct semantic definitions. The fact that a rewrite logic theory’s axioms include both equations and rewrite rules provides a useful “abstraction dial” to find the right balance between abstraction and computational observability in semantic definitions. Such semantic definitions are directly executable as interpreters in a rewriting logic language such as Maude, whose generic formal tools can be used to endow those interpreters with powerful program analysis capabilities.     

A mathematical semantics for a nondeterministic typed λ-calculus

This paper is concerned with the problems encountered in defining the semantics of nondeterministic algorithms. A nondeterministic control structure is added to a typed λ-calculus and the usual operational semantics for the deterministic language is generalized to take into account the more complex behaviour of nondeterministic algorithms. A mathematical model is then given for the language and the relationship between the denotational and operational semantics is explored.     

Algebraic Correctness Proofs for Compiling Recursive Function Definitions with Strictness Information

Adding appropriate strictness information to recursive function definitions we achieve a uniform treatment of lazy and eager evaluation strategies. By restriction to first-order functions over basic types we develop a pure stack implementation that avoids a heap even for lazy arguments. We present algebraic definitions of denotational, operational, and stack-machine semantics and prove their equivalence by means of structural induction.     

A continuous semantics for unbounded nondeterminism

Nondeterminism is introduced into an ordinary iterative programming language by treating procedure calls as nondeterministic assignment statements. The effect of such assignment statements is assumed to be determined solely by the entry-exit specifications of the corresponding procedures. The nondeterminism which this approach yields is not necessarily bounded. The paper discusses the problem of defining a denotational semantic for programming languages with this kind of, possibly unbounded, nondeterminism. As an additional constraint, the semantics is required to be continuous, in the sense that the underlying semantic algebra is continuous. It is shown how such a continuous semantics for unbounded nondeterminism can be derived from a simple operational semantics based on program execution trees.     

Verilog代数语义研究

给出了Verilog的代数语义.这是一个等式公理体系,它将Verilog语义特征通过代数规则简洁而准确地表达出来;并且这个代数语义相对于已经所作的操作语义模型来讲是可靠的,即所有的这些代数规则左右两边的进程在操作语义的观察模型下都是互模拟的.研究了此代数语义的相对完备性,即参照前面的操作语义模型,相对于扩展Verilog语言的一个子集而言,此代数语义是完备的.即所有符合这样语法的程序,如果它们是互模拟等价的,那么它们同样可以在所提出的代数系统中被推导相等.在完备性证明过程中,采用范式方法,即构造一种语法上特殊的程序,任何属于上述子集中的一个程序通过该代数规则都能够被转化为范式程序,而且范式程序在操作语义模型下是互模拟的当且仅当它们是语法相同的.上述结果具有重要的理论意义,因为现有的进程代数理论主要是针对管道通信并行语言而展开的,而对于像Verilog这种以共享变量通信为基础的复杂并行语言研究还是比较少的,对此类复杂的基于共享变量的并行语言的进程代数理论研究提出了一种通用、有效的方法.     

Semantics of plan revision in intelligent agents

In this paper, we give an operational and denotational semantics for a meta-language of the 3APL agent programming language. With this meta-language, various 3APL interpreters can be programmed. We prove equivalence of the operational and denotational semantics. Furthermore, we give an operational semantics for object-level 3APL. Using this semantics, we relate the 3APL meta-language to object-level 3APL by providing a specific interpreter, the semantics of which will prove to be equivalent to object-level 3APL.     

The formal definition of a real-time language

Summary This paper presents the formal definition of TOMAL (Task-Oriented Microprocessor Applications Language), a programming language intended for real-time systems running on small processors. The formal definition addresses all aspects of the language. Because some modes of semantic definition seem particularly well-suited to certain aspects of a language, and not as suitable for others, the formal definition employs several complementary modes of definition.The primary definition is axiomatic and is employed to define most statements of the language. Simple, denotational (but not lattice-theoretic) semantics complement the axiomatic semantics to define type-related features, such as binding of names to types, data type coercions, and evaluation of expressions. Together, the axiomatic and denotational semantics define all features of the sequential language. An operational definition is used to define real-time execution, and to extend the axiomatic definition to account for all aspects of concurrent execution. Semantic constraints, sufficient to guarantee conformity of a program with the axiomatic definition, can be checked by analysis of a TOMAL program at compilation.