Is evidence-based practice diverse enough? Philosophy of science considerations.

In its policy rationale for evidence-based practice in psychology (EBPP), the APA Presidential Task Force on Evidence-Based Practice (see record 2006-05893-001) claims to have constituted itself with "scientists and practitioners from a wide range of perspectives and traditions, reflecting the diverse perspectives within the field" (p. 273). We applaud this attention to diversity but contend that an entire perspective of the debate was omitted in the Task Force's newly approved policy and its underlying report. The failure to consider a philosophy of science perspective led the Task Force to make a number of epistemological assumptions that are not based on evidence or rationale and that thus violate the very spirit of evidence-based decision making. In this comment, we reveal a few of these assumptions and discuss their detrimental consequences. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

High resolution STEM/EDX spectral imaging to resolve metal distributions within ∼100 nm combustion generated ash particles

Ultrafine ash particles play an important role in establishing a sticky inner deposit layer on heat transfer surface for power plants, but it is still unclear whether a thin surface alkali coating on these ultrafine particles might control this deposition behavior. In this research, we used a high resolution FE-TEM/STEM equipped with twin SDD EDX detectors for high X-ray detection efficiency, to determine the presence and absence of surface enrichment of alkali metals on ultrafine solid fuel ash samples that had low bulk alkali compositions but high deposition rates. Results from two types of combustion generated nano-sized ash particles are presented. One was from the oxy-combustion of pulverized bituminous coal, the other from oxy-combustion of pulverized rice husks, both being burned in a 100?kW rated down-flow laboratory combustor. Elemental mapping results from STEM/EDX uncovered some surface enrichment of alkali metals in ultrafine ash particles, where it existed, as it did for combustion of rice husks. However, it was not able to discern similar alkali metal surface enrichment for the bituminous coal ultrafines that had resulted in even higher deposition rates. Since deposition rates from both of these cases lie on the same correlation with PM₁, one can conclude that although surface enrichment of alkali metals is present for some ～100?nm particles, it is not a prerequisite to achieve high inner surface deposition rates. This is in contrast to prevailing theories that point to alkali metals as “bad actors” as far as the sticky inner deposition rate is concerned.

Copyright © 2019 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Constraints on the disposal of detergent manufacturing waste

The needs of the detergent industry in the 1980s will require the management of many new regulatory and environmental concerns. The rules and regulations on waste disposal are changing rapidly and are likely to have an ever increasing impact on manufacturing processes. An understanding of the current constraints in disposal of waste will minimize the cost and future problems in this aspect of detergent manufacture. In a broader sense, the detergent industry needs to be continually aware of the concerns within governmental agencies, to be informed on proposed regulations that address these concerns and to provide input into the regulatory process. The detergent industry needs to help regulatory agencies resolve their concerns in such a way that restrictions and costs are minimized.     

Erosion of sintered TiB2-cathodes during cathodic aluminium deposition from LiCl/AlCl3 melts

Using an aluminium dissolution/deposition electrolysis cell, TiB₂, TiB₂/TiC and TiC sintered specimens of different porosity were tested for erosion resistance on exposure to liquid electrodeposited aluminium at 700°C to determine whether cathodes coated with such materials can be applied in aluminium chloride electrolysis cells. Although not wetted by liquid aluminium, the TiC and the TiB₂/TiC composites were extensively eroded. The densest TiB₂ specimens showed the highest resistance against liquid aluminium. The erosion rate of TiB₂ specimens of different density after exposure to the test environment for over 200 h was almost identical and reached a value of 0.16 cm y^–1. The observed wear rates exceed the values predicted on the basis of published solubility data by a factor of approximately 10.     

Carbon fiber structure and stability studies

A study has been made of the thermal-oxidative stability of several commercially available carbon fibers. Significant differences in the weight loss behavior were observed in air aging studies run on the bare fibers at 600°F (589 K). The stability of high temperature laminates, such as those based on NR-150 polyimide precursor solutions, was found to be directly affected by the stability of the reinforcing carbon fibers. In studies carried out to determine the reasons for carbon fiber instability, residual sodium sulfate was found to be the principle destabilizing factor. A mechanism whereby the sodium sulfate promotes the oxidation of carbon in the presence of air is proposed.     

Optimal operation of distillation processes under uncertain inflows accumulated in a feed tank

A new method of optimizing the operation of distillation processes with uncertain inflow streams from upstream plants is discussed. The case considered is the streams that will be first accumulated in a tank before feeding to the column. To minimize the total amount of operating energy while keeping a stable column operation under these inflows, a novel decomposed optimization strategy consisting of two steps was used. For an optimal planning of the dynamic operation, a smooth feed flow policy to the column is developed in the first step by stochastic optimization under chance constraints by ensuring a predefined probability of holding the tank level inside the desired range. An easy-to-use method developed computes the maximum reachable probability of holding the constraints so that a feasible solution of the chance constrained problem can be guaranteed. Since the uncertainty in the inflow stream variability is absorbed in the stochastic optimization over the tank, the operation of the dowstream distillation column is deterministic. Therefore, in the second step, the reflux and reboiler duty policies of the column are developed by deterministic dynamic optimization. The optimal overall strategy is obtained by the maximized smoothness of the feed flow to the distillation column. The approach is applied to a pilot column, and the developed operating policies are implemented on the real plant by experiment.     

Kinetics of Thermal Dehydroxylation and Carbonation of Magnesium Hydroxide

The kinetics of simultaneous dehydroxylation and carbonation of precipitated Mg(OH)₂ were studied using isothermal and nonisothermal thermogravimetric analyses. Specimens were analyzed using X-ray diffraction, transmission electron microscopy, and through measurements of the volume of carbon dioxide evolved in a subsequent reaction with hydrochloric acid. From 275° to 475°C, the kinetics of isothermal dehydroxylation in helium were best fit to a contracting-sphere model, yielding an activation energy of 146 kJ/mol, which was greater than values reported in the literature for isothermal dehydroxylation under vacuum (53–126 kJ/mol). The carbonation kinetics were complicated by the fact that dehydroxylation occurred simultaneously. The overall kinetics also could be fit to a contracting-sphere model, yielding a net activation energy of 304 kJ/mol. The most rapid carbonation kinetics occurred near 375°C. At this temperature, Mg(OH)₂ underwent rapid dehydroxylation and subsequent phase transformation, whereas thermodynamics favored the formation of carbonate. During carbonation, MgCO₃ precipitated on the surface of disrupted Mg(OH)₂ crystals acting as a kinetic barrier to both the outward diffusion of H₂O and the inward diffusion of CO₂.