A time-predefined local search approach to exam timetabling problems

In recent years the processing speed of computers has increased dramatically. This in turn has allowed search algorithms to execute more iterations in a given amount of real-time. Does this necessarily always lead to an improvement in the quality of final solutions? This paper is devoted to the investigation of that question. We present two variants of local search where the search time can be set as an input parameter. These two approaches are: a time-predefined variant of simulated annealing and an adaptation of the “great deluge” method. We present a comprehensive series of experiments which show that these approaches significantly outperform the previous best results (in terms of solution quality) on a range of benchmark exam timetabling problems. Of course, there is a price to pay for such better results: increased execution time. We discuss the impact of this trade-off between quality and execution time. In particular we discuss issues involving the proper estimation of the algorithm's execution time and the assessment of its importance.