地质科学数据的同行评议实践与思考

科学数据出版逐渐成为数据密集型科学发现的重要学术传播方式。数据出版质量的控制主要通过同行评议方法来确保,然而各个学科领域对于数据质量控制还没形成统一的标准,同行评议模式也没有达成共识。为了建立更加完善的地质科学数据同行评议过程,促进数据出版在国内的发展,本文总结国内外数据论文出版所采用的同行评议模式,结合地质科学数据出版所积累的实践经验,以此为未来数据出版同行评议工作提出思考。

Practice and thinking of peer review of geoscientific data

Scientific data publishing has gradually become an important academic communication method for data-intensive scientific discoveries. The control of data publication quality is mainly ensured by peer review methods. However, there is no unified standard for data quality control in various subject areas, and there is no consensus on the peer review model. In order to further improve the peer review process of geoscientific data and promote the development of data publication in China, this paper summarizes the peer review model used in the publication of data papers worldwide, combined with the practical experience accumulated in the geoscientific data publishing, as the thoughts on the peer review work of the future data publishing.