A model for the silicon-manganese deoxidation of steel weld metals

From an analytical and theoretical study of flat and out-of-position gas metal arc (GMA) C-Mn steel welds containing varying additions of silicon and manganese, we conclude that the buoyancy effect (flotation obeying Stokes’ law) does not play a significant role in the separation of oxide inclusions during weld metal deoxidation. Consequently, the separation rate of the particles is controlled solely by the fluid flow pattern in the weld pool. A proposed two-step model for the weld metal deoxidation reactions suggests that inclusions formed in the hot, turbulent-flow region of the weld pool are rapidly brought to the upper surface behind the arc because of the high-velocity flow fields set up within the liquid metal. In contrast, those formed in the cooler, less-turbulent flow regions of the weld pool are to a large extent trapped in the weld metal as finely dispersed particles as a result of inadequate melt stirring. The boundary between “hot” and “cold” parts for possible inclusion removal is not well defined, but depends on the applied welding parameters, flux, and shielding gas composition. As a result of the intricate mechanism of inclusion separation, the final weld metal oxygen content depends on complex interactions among the following three main factors: (1) the operational conditions applied, (2) the total amount of silicon and manganese present, and (3) the resulting manganeseto-silicon ratio. The combined effect of the latter two contributions has been included in a new deoxidation parameter, ([pct Si][pct Mn])^−0.25. The small, negative exponent in the deoxidation parameter indicates that control of the weld metal oxygen concentrations through additions of silicon and manganese is limited and that choice of operational conditions in many instances is the primary factor in determining the final degree of deoxidation to be achieved.