Residual carbon dioxide as an index of feed efficiency in lactating dairy cows

High feed costs make feed conversion efficiency a desirable target for genetic improvement. Residual feed intake (RFI), calculated as the difference between observed and predicted intake, is a commonly used estimate of feed efficiency. However, determination of feed efficiency in dairy herds is challenging due to difficulties in measuring feed intake of individual animals reliably. Using residual CO₂ (RCO₂) production as an estimate of feed efficiency would allow ranking the cows according to feed efficiency, provided that CO₂ production is closely related to heat production and feed intake. The objective of this study was to evaluate the potential of RCO₂ as an index of feed efficiency using data from respiration calorimetry studies (289 cow per period observations). Heat production was precisely predicted from CO₂ production [root mean square error (RMSE)] adjusted for random effects was 1.5% of observed mean]. Dry matter intake (DMI) was better predicted from energy-corrected milk (ECM) yield and CO₂ production than from ECM yield and body weight in the model (adjusted RSME = 0.92 vs. 1.39 kg/d). Residual CO₂ production estimated as the difference between actual CO₂ production and that predicted from ECM yield, metabolic body weight was closely related to RFI (adjusted RMSE = 0.42) that was calculated as the difference between actual DMI and that predicted from ECM, metabolic body weight, and energy balance (EB). When the cows were categorized in 3 groups of equal sizes on the basis of RCO₂ (low, medium, and high), low RCO₂ cows had lower DMI, RFI, methane production and intensity (g/kg ECM), and heat production, but higher efficiency of metabolizable energy utilization for lactation than high RCO₂ cows. When RFI was predicted from RCO₂, the residuals (observed – predicted) were negatively related to EB and digestibility. Predicting RFI with a 2-variable model based on RCO₂ and digestibility, adjusted RMSE decreased to 0.23 kg/d, and residuals were not significantly related to EB. The cows in low RCO₂ group had a higher energy digestibility than the cows in the high RCO₂ group, and differences in EB were observed between the groups. Error of the model predicting residual ECM production from RCO₂ was 1.41 kg/d. The residuals were positively related to ECM yield and energy digestibility. Predicting residual ECM from RCO₂ and ECM yield decreased adjusted RMSE to 1.07 kg/d, and further to 0.78 kg/d when digestibility was included in the 2-variable model. It is concluded that RCO₂ has a potential for ranking individual cows based on feed efficiency.