The effects of cool and variable temperatures on the hatch date,growth and overwinter mortality of a warmwater fish in small coastal embayments of Lake Ontario

Little is known about the ecology of warmwater fish in small coastal embayments (< 32 ha) where temperatures are lowered by exchange with the adjacent lake. Using pumpkinseed (Lepomis gibbous) as a model warmwater fish, we compare hatch dates and overwinter survival in two embayments with higher and lower amounts of cold-water input from Lake Ontario, in a warmer and cooler year. In 2007, the embayments differed by approximately 2–5 °C until late-July. In that year, temperatures in the cooler embayment delayed hatching times until July 18–August 20, approximately eight weeks later (May 24–August 20) than in the warmer embayment. Almost all offspring in the cooler embayment were likely too small to survive the winter. In 2008 both embayments had similar temperatures. In that year, pumpkinseed started hatching in early-June, and most were likely large enough to survive the winter. The findings from the two intensively sampled embayments were confirmed with a 21-year fish monitoring dataset; adult pumpkinseed were captured in the littoral zone of warm embayments 6–8 weeks earlier than in cooler embayments. Relative to pumpkinseed in the small inland lakes of eastern and central Ontario, spawning is delayed by at least two weeks in coastal embayments. Using water temperatures as a surrogate for growth, we calculated that only 5 of the 17 embayments for which we have temperature records were able to consistently produce successfully overwintering age-0 fish. Nevertheless, we found pumpkinseed age ≥ 1 in embayments too cold to produce age-0 pumpkinseed, suggesting immigration from warmer embayments.