Sandwiches and milk with varying fat and sodium contents: What is the best combination?

Saltiness and fattiness were systematically varied in combinations of wheat bread (unsalted vs regular-salt), spread (none vs regular-salt and regular-fat), cheese (low-salt and low-fat vs low-fat). All possible combinations, amounting to sixteen samples of sandwich and milk, were presented to 43 subjects for ratings of pleasantness. The subjects also rated the pleasantness of individual components. The unsalted bread without spread but with low-salt, low-fat cheese and any of the milk types received the lowest hedonic ratings, whereas the regular-salt bread with spread and with any of the cheese and milk options received the highest. The pleasantness of individual components predicted the pleasantness of a combination by only 10–40% (multiple regression analysis). Thus the pleasantness of an entity depended on the pleasantness of components only to a very limited extent. The absence of major elements, such as spread on bread or the salty taste in bread, had major effects on acceptance.