Performance comparison of state-of-the-art heterojunction bipolar devices (HBT) based on AlGaAs/GaAs, Si/SiGe and InGaAs/InP

This paper presents a comprehensive comparison of three state-of-the-art heterojunction bipolar transistors (HBTs); the AlGaAs/GaAs HBT, the Si/SiGe HBT and the InGaAs/InP HBT. Our aim in this paper is to find the potentials and limitations of these devices and analyze them under common Figure of Merit (FOM) definitions as well as to make a meaningful comparison which is necessary for a technology choice especially in RF-circuit and system level applications such as power amplifier, low noise amplifier circuits and transceiver/receiver systems. Simulation of an HBT device with an HBT model instead of traditional BJT models is also presented for the AlGaAs/GaAs HBT. To the best of our knowledge, this work covers the most extensive FOM analysis for these devices such as I-V behavior, stability, power gain analysis, characteristic frequencies and minimum noise figure. DC and bias point simulations of the devices are performed using Agilent's ADS design tool and a comparison is given for a wide range of FOM specifications. Based on our literature survey and simulation results, we have concluded that GaAs based HBTs are suitable for high-power applications due to their high-breakdown voltages, SiGe based HBTs are promising for low noise applications due to their low noise figures and InP will be the choice if very high-data rates is of primary importance since InP based HBT transistors have superior material properties leading to Terahertz frequency operation.