An Empirical Study of Two Approaches to Sequence Learning for Anomaly Detection

This paper introduces the computer security domain of anomaly detection and formulates it as a machine learning task on temporal sequence data. In this domain, the goal is to develop a model or profile of the normal working state of a system user and to detect anomalous conditions as long-term deviations from the expected behavior patterns. We introduce two approaches to this problem: one employing instance-based learning (IBL) and the other using hidden Markov models (HMMs). Though not suitable for a comprehensive security solution, both approaches achieve anomaly identification performance sufficient for a low-level focus of attention detector in a multitier security system. Further, we evaluate model scaling techniques for the two approaches: two clustering techniques for the IBL approach and variation of the number of hidden states for the HMM approach. We find that over both model classes and a wide range of model scales, there is no significant difference in performance at recognizing the profiled user. We take this invariance as evidence that, in this security domain, limited memory models (e.g., fixed-length instances or low-order Markov models) can learn only part of the user identity information in which we're interested and that substantially different models will be necessary if dramatic improvements in user-based anomaly detection are to be achieved.