Laser ablation behaviors of vacuum plasma sprayed ZrC-based coatings

ZrC, ZrC-30 vol% SiC, and ZrC-30 vol% TiC coatings were fabricated by vacuum plasma spray and the laser ablation behaviors were evaluated by a CO₂ laser beam under two heat fluxes (15.9 and 25.5 MW/m²). The phase compositions and microstructures of the coatings after ablation were investigated and the effect of SiC and TiC additives was analyzed. The results showed that the ZrC–SiC coating displayed better ablation resistance compared with the ZrC and ZrC–TiC coatings under 15.9 MW/m² heat flux. While the ZrC–TiC coating exhibited the improved ablation resistance under 25.5 MW/m² heat flux. The continuous and integral ZrO₂–SiO₂ scale provided protective effect for the ZrC–SiC coating. A liquid ZrO₂–TiO₂ layer which owned self-healing ability was formed for the ZrC–TiC coating in both heat fluxes. However, the state of the formed liquid, like amount, viscosity, evaporation, and decomposition, was influenced by the environment and was vital for the ablation resistance. This work might give a clue for designing ultrahigh-temperature ceramics as potential laser ablation–resistant coating materials.     

Volatility diagram of ZrB2‐SiC‐ZrC system and experimental validation

A volatility diagram of zirconium carbide (ZrC) at 1600, 1930, and 2200°C was calculated in this work. Combining it with the existing volatility diagrams of ZrB₂ and SiC, the volatility diagram of a ternary ZrB₂‐SiC‐ZrC (ZSZ) system was constructed in order to interpret the oxidation behavior of ZSZ ceramics. Applying this diagram, the formation of ZrC‐corroded and SiC‐depleted layers and the oxidation sequence of each component in ZSZ during oxidation and ablation could be well understood. Most of the predictions from the diagrams are consistent with the experimental observations on the oxidation scale of dense ZrB₂‐SiC‐ZrC ceramics/coatings after oxidation at 1600°C or ablation at 1930 and 2200°C. The reasons for the discrepancy are also briefly discussed.     

Microstructure and ablation property of gradient ZrCSiC modified C/C composites prepared by chemical liquid vapor deposition

Chemical liquid vapor deposition was adopted to fabricate gradient ZrCSiC modified C/C composites, and the microstructure and ablation resistance were studied. Results displayed the content of SiC decreased from the composites edge to the center but that of ZrC increased, indicating SiC and ZrC ceramics have the gradient distribution in the composites. The gradient composites possessed a low CTE and high thermal conductivity. The low CTE restricted the formation and expansion of defects, which could slow the oxygen diffusion in the composites. The high thermal conductivity could transfer the heat quickly in ablation process, which reduced the heat accumulation on the ablation surface and weakened the thermal erosion. Therefore, the gradient composites possessed an outstanding anti-ablation property at two heat fluxes. Compared with the uniformed distribution composites, the linear and mass ablation rates of the gradient composites decreased by 60.9% and 66.7% at heat flux of 2.38 MW/m² and decreased by 55.9% and 67.2% at heat flux of 4.18 MW/m². Because of the gradient distribution, porous ZrO₂ coating, ZrO₂SiO₂ coating and SiO₂ coating with SiO₂ nanowires were generated on the ablation center, ablation transition zone and ablation edge, respectively. These coatings isolated the sample surface from the flame and inhibited the transport of oxygen into the sample inner.     

Ablation resistant ZrC coating modified by polymer-derived SiC/TiC nanocomposites for ultra-high temperature application

To improve the ablation resistance of ZrC coating on SiC-coated carbon/carbon composites above 2000 °C, SiC/TiC nanocomposites (SiC/TiC-NCs) powders derived from single-source precursor were incorporated into ZrC coating, denoted as ZrC-SiC/TiC-NCs, via supersonic atmospheric plasma spraying (SAPS). After SAPS, the incorporated SiC/TiC-NCs evolved into TiC/(SiC and Zr_xTi_yC) embedded in amorphous SiC. The ablation resistance of the ZrC-SiC/TiC-NCs coating was evaluated by oxyacetylene flames with a heat flux of 4.18 MW/m². For comparison, the ZrC-SiC-NCs coating without Ti modification was seriously damaged due to rapid gas denudation. The good ablation resistance of ZrC-SiC/TiC-NCs coating is mainly attributed to the distinctive “capsule-like” multi-crystalline microstructure of SiC/TiC-NCs. During ablation, TiO₂ and Zr_xTi_yO₂, due to the oxidation of TiC and Zr_xTi_yC, contributed to the formation of Zr-Ti-Si-O glass with high viscosity and low evaporation pressure, improving the ablation resistance.     

Ablation behavior and mechanism of C/C–ZrC–SiC composites under an oxyacetylene torch at 3000 °C

C/C–ZrC–SiC composites with continuous ZrC–SiC ceramic matrix were prepared by a multistep technique of precursor infiltration and pyrolysis process. Ablation properties of the composites were tested under an oxyacetylene flame at 3000 °C for 120 s. The results show that the linear ablation rate of the composites was about an order lower than that of pure C/C and C/C–SiC composites as comparisons, and the mass of the C/C–ZrC–SiC composites increased after ablation. Three concentric ring regions with different coatings appeared on the surface of the ablated C/C–ZrC–SiC composites: (i) brim ablation region covered by a coating with layered structure including SiO₂ outer layer and ZrO₂–SiO₂ inner layer; (ii) transition ablation region, and (iii) center ablation region with molten ZrO₂ coating. Presence of these coatings which acted as an effective oxygen and heat barrier is the reason for the great ablation resistance of the composites.     

Ablation behavior of a C/C-ZrC-SiC composite based on high-solid-loading slurry impregnation under oxyacetylene torch

A C/C-ZrC-SiC composite was successfully prepared by high-solid-loading slurry impregnation combined with polymer infiltration and pyrolysis. The microstructure and ablation behavior of the C/C–ZrC–SiC composite were investigated. ZrC particles were uniformly distributed in the matrix, and the obtained C/C–ZrC–SiC composite had a high density of 2.74 g/cm³. After exposure to oxyacetylene flame with a heat flux of 3.86 MW/m² for 120 s, the mass and linear ablation rates of the composite were 0.72 ± 0.11 mg/s and 0.52 ± 0.09 µm/s, respectively. The excellent ablation properties of the composite were attributed to the protection of the matrix by a three-layered oxide scale consisting of ZrO₂/SiO₂-rich/ZrO₂-SiO₂.     

Ablation behavior and thermal protection performance of TaSi2 coating for SiC coated carbon/carbon composites

For extending application of TaSi₂ in complex coating system, the ablation behavior and thermal protection performance of TaSi₂ coating is studied to evaluate its potential applications for anti-ablation protection of C/C composites. TaSi₂ coating is prepared by supersonic atmospheric plasma spraying (SAPS) on the surface of SiC coated carbon/carbon (C/C) composites. Phase variation and microstructure are characterized by XRD and SEM, respectively. During the ablation process, the coating is quickly oxidized to SiO₂ and Ta₂O₅ accompanied by a lot of heat consumption. The linear and mass ablation rates are 0.9?µm?s^?1 and ??0.4?mg?s^?1 after ablation for 80?s, respectively Results show that the prepared coating possesses optimal ablation performance under the heat flux of 2.4?MW/m². Moreover, the TaSi₂ coating and SiC inner coating have good chemical and physical compatibility during the ablation process. Therefore, the excellent performance of TaSi₂ coating during the ablation process makes it a candidate for anti-ablation protection for C/C composites.     

Effect of MoSi2 addition on ablation behavior of ZrC coating fabricated by vacuum plasma spray

To improve the ablation resistance of ZrC coating, MoSi₂ incorporated ZrC composite coatings were fabricated by vacuum plasma spray. The ablation resistance of the composite coatings was evaluated using a plasma jet with a heat flux of 1.94?MW/m². The phase compositions and microstructures of the coatings before and after ablation were investigated, and the ablation mechanisms and effect of MoSi₂ were analyzed based on thermal dynamics and microstructure changes. Results showed that MoSi₂ addition could improve the ablation resistance of ZrC coating by means of decreasing the surface temperature and changing the microstructure of the oxidation layer. Si derived from the decomposition of MoSi₂, which occurred within coating, was beneficial to maintain the thickness and integrity of the SiO₂ layer and reduce the oxygen pressure beneath. The thickness of the SiO₂ layer was related to the formation rate (V_f) and the consumption rate (V_c) of SiO₂. The diffusion of Si was in favor of increasing the value of V_f. MoSi₂ could be one choice to improve the ablation resistance of the ZrC coating.     

Ultra‐High‐Temperature Ceramic HfB2‐SiC Coating for Oxidation Protection of SiC‐Coated Carbon/Carbon Composites

To protect the carbon/carbon (C/C) composites from oxidation, an outer ultra‐high‐temperature ceramics (UHTCs) HfB₂‐SiC coating was prepared on SiC‐coated C/C composites by in situ reaction method. The outer HfB₂‐SiC coating consists of HfB₂ and SiC, which are synchronously obtained. During the heat treatment process, the formed fluid silicon melt is responsible for the preparation of the outer HfB₂‐SiC coating. The HfB₂‐SiC/SiC coating could protect the C/C from oxidation for 265 h with only 0.41 × 10^?2 g/cm² weight loss at 1773 K in air. During the oxidation process, SiO₂ glass and HfO₂ are generated. SiO₂ glass has a self‐sealing ability, which can cover the defects in the coating, thus blocking the penetration of oxygen and providing an effective protection for the C/C substrate. In addition, SiO₂ glass can react with the formed HfO₂, thus forming the HfSiO₄ phase. Owing to the “pinning effect” of HfSiO₄ phase, crack deflecting and crack termination are occurred, which will prevent the spread of cracks and effectively improve the oxidation resistance of the coating.     

Fabrication and properties of Cf/ZrC‐SiC‐based composites by an improved reactive melt infiltration

C_f/ZrC‐SiC composites with a density of 2.52 g/cm³ and a porosity of 1.68% were fabricated via reactive melt infiltration (RMI) of Si into nano‐porous C_f/ZrC‐C preforms. The nano‐porous C_f/ZrC‐C preforms were prepared through a colloid process, with a ZrC “protective coating” formed surrounding the carbon fibers. Consequently, highly dense C_f/ZrC‐SiC composites without evident fiber/interphase degradation were obtained. Moreover, abundant needle‐shaped ZrSi₂ grains were formed in the composites. Benefiting from this unique microstructure, flexural strength, and elastic modulus of the composites are as high as 380 MPa and 61 GPa, respectively, which are much higher than C_f/ZrC‐SiC composites prepared by conventional RMI.     

Experimental investigation of mechanical,thermal, and ablation performance of ZrO2/SiC modified C-Ph composites

In this study, an effort has been made to improve the mechanical, thermal, and ablation performance of carbon-phenolic (C-Ph) composites. The ZrO₂, SiC, and ZrO₂/SiC hybrid fillers were synthesized using sol-gel method followed by individual incorporation into C-Ph composites. The thermal stability and flexural strength of these C-Ph composites were analyzed using thermogravimetry analysis and three-point bending test, respectively. A significant improvement in the flexural strength and modulus of the reinforced C-Ph composites was observed and also exhibited the higher thermal stability. The oxyacetylene flame test was conducted to measure the ablation behavior of these filler reinforced C-Ph composites under a heat flux of 4.0 MW/m² for 60 seconds. ZrO₂/SiC0.5 reinforcement in the C-Ph composite decreased the linear and mass ablation rates by 46% and 22%, respectively when compared with pure C-Ph composite. The surface morphology analysis revealed that the burnt composite covered with the ZrC ceramic phase and SiO₂ bubble-like structure, which could have improved the ablation resistance of composites. These results were found well within the acceptable range when using the surface energy dispersive spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction analysis.     

Microstructure and ablation behavior of SiC coated C/C–SiC–ZrC composites prepared by a hybrid infiltration process

In this study, C/C–SiC–ZrC composites coated with SiC were prepared by precursor infiltration pyrolysis combined with reactive melt infiltration. The pyrolysis behavior of the hybrid precursor was investigated using thermal gravimetric analysis-differential scanning calorimetry, X-ray diffraction, and scanning electron microscopy techniques. The microstructure and ablation behavior of the composites were also investigated. The results indicate that the composites exhibit an interesting structure, wherein a ceramic coating composed of SiC and a small quantity of ZrC covers the exterior of the composites, and the SiC–ZrC hybrid ceramics are partially embedded in the matrix pores and distributed around the carbon fibers as well. The composites exhibit good ablation resistance with a surface temperature of over 2300 °C during ablation. After ablation for 120 s, the mass and linear ablation rates of the composites are 0.0026 g/s and 0.0037 mm/s, respectively. The great ablation resistance of the composites is attributed to the formation of a continuous phase of molten SiO₂ containing SiC and ZrO₂, which seals the pores of the composites during ablation.     

Ablation behaviors of ZrC-TiC coatings prepared by vacuum plasma spray: Above 2000 °C

ZrC-TiC coatings were fabricated by vacuum plasma spray and their ablation resistance were evaluated and compared with ZrC-SiC coating by a plasma flame with a heat flux of 4.02 MW/m². The microstructure and phase compositions of the as-sprayed and ablated coatings were characterized and the function of TiC addition on the ablation resistance was investigated. The results showed that the ablation resistance of the ZrC-TiC coating was much better than that of the ZrC-SiC coating under the present ablation conditions. The decrease of surface temperatures with the increasing of TiC content were observed. (Zr, Ti)O₂ eutectic phase in liquid state was observed. The low vapor and decomposition pressures of TiO₂, combined with the formation of (Zr, Ti)O₂ liquid contributed to the excellent ablation resistance of the ZrC-TiC coating. This work affirmed that TiC could be an ideal addition to improve the ablation resistance of the ZrC coating in harsh environment above 2000 °C.     

Synthesis of ZrC–SiC Powders from Hybrid Liquid Precursors with Improved Oxidation Resistance

ZrC–SiC powders are synthesized by high‐temperature pyrolysis of hybrid liquid precursors, which are prepared from organic Zr‐containing precursor (PZC) and liquid polycarbosilane (LPCS). Due to the excellent miscibility between PZC and LPCS, the hybrid liquid precursors are formed by dissolving PZC into LPCS without adding organic solvent. The viscosity and elemental content of Zr and Si of the hybrid precursors are readily adjustable by controlling the LPCS/PZC mass ratio. SEM and TEM observations reveal that the ZrC–SiC powders pyrolyzed at 1550°C exhibit spherical morphology with characteristic dimension of less than 60 nm, and the two phases are uniformly distributed in composite powders. The advantage of the ZrC–SiC powders synthesized by this novel method is demonstrated by investigating the oxidation behavior of powders with different amount of SiC and ZrC. Below 700°C, ZrC quickly oxidizes to generate an almost nonprotective ZrO₂ scale, whereas at ~ 1000°C, dense and protective SiO₂ forms that improves the oxidation resistance of the ZrC–SiC composite powders.     

Effects of porous C/C density on the densification behavior and ablation property of C/C–ZrC–SiC composites

C/C–ZrC–SiC composites were prepared by precursor infiltration and pyrolysis process using a mixture solution of organic zirconium-containing polymer and polycarbosilane as precursors. Porous carbon/carbon (C/C) composites with density of 0.92, 1.21 and 1.40 g/cm³ were used as preforms, and the effects of porous C/C density on the densification behavior and ablation resistance of C/C–ZrC–SiC composites were investigated. The results show that the C/C preforms with a lower density have a faster weight gain, and the obtained C/C–ZrC–SiC composites own higher bulk density and open porosity. The composites fabricated from the C/C preforms with a density of 1.21 g/cm³ exhibit better ablation resistance with a surface temperature of over 2400 °C during ablation. After ablation for 120 s, the linear and mass ablation rates of the composites are as low as 1.02 × 10⁻³ mm/s and −4.01 × 10⁻⁴ g/s, respectively, and the formation of a dense and continuous coating of molten ZrO₂ solid solution is the reason for their great ablation resistance.     

Ablation resistance of HfB2-SiC coating prepared by in-situ reaction method for SiC coated C/C composites

To improve the ablation resistance of SiC coating, HfB₂-SiC coating was prepared on SiC-coated carbon/carbon (C/C) composites by in-situ reaction method. Owing to the penetration of coating powders, there is no clear boundary between SiC coating and HfB₂-SiC coating. After oxyacetylene ablation for 60 s at heat flux of 2400 kW/m², the mass ablation rate and linear ablation rate of the coated C/C composites were only 0.147 mg/s and 0.267 µm/s, reduced by 21.8% and 60.0%, respectively, compared with SiC coated C/C composites. The good ablation resistance was attributed to the formation of multiple Hf-Si-O glassy layer including SiO₂, HfO₂ and HfSiO₄.     

Ablation behavior of a network interlacing ZrC-VC ceramic coating prepared by a pioneering spillover permeation

A novel network interlacing ZrC-VC ceramic coating was prepared by a pioneering spillover permeation. With the increase of Zr content in the blind vias, the content of ZrC in the coating and the density of the coating all decrease. The density of the coating on C/C–ZrC–SiC substrate is obviously higher than that on C/C substrate. The linear ablation rate of the novel ceramic coated C/C–ZrC–SiC composites was ?0.06 μm/s with about 20 and 1.56 times reduction than C/C composites and C/C–ZrC–SiC composites respectively. The improved ablation resistance was attributed to a dense honeycomb ZrO₂ layer filled with liquid vanadium oxide in the ablation center and the improved thermal radiation.     

New anti-ablation candidate for carbon/carbon composites: Preparation,composition and ablation behavior of Y2Hf2O7 coating under an oxyacetylene torch

Y₂Hf₂O₇ possesses low thermal conductivity and high melting point, which make it promising for a new anti-ablation material. For evaluating the thermal stability and the potential applications of Y₂Hf₂O₇ on anti-ablation protection of C/C composites, Y₂Hf₂O₇ ceramic powder was synthesized by solution combustion method and Y₂Hf₂O₇ coating was prepared on the surface of SiC coated C/C composites using SAPS. Results shown that the coating exhibits good ablation resistance under the heat flux of 2.4?MW/m² with the linear and mass ablation rates are 0.16?μm?s^?1 and ?0.028?mg?s^?1, respectively, after ablation for 40?s. With the prolonging of the ablation time, the increasing thermal stress causes the increase of cracks. Moreover, the chemical erosion from SiO₂ and the physical volatilization of low temperature molten products aggravate failure of the Y₂Hf₂O₇ coating.     

Ablation behavior of single and alternate multilayered ZrC-SiC coatings under oxyacetylene torch

Based on the investigation of ablation behavior and thermal stress of the monolayered ZrC-SiC coatings with different SiC amounts, an alternate coating consisting of 4 sublayers with 10 and 70 vol.% SiC was prepared on SiC-coated carbon/carbon (C/C) composites through plasma spraying technique. Ablation tests were carried out under oxyacetylene torch with a heat flux of 2.38 MW/m². The alternate coating could offer 90 s ablation shield for C/C composites, providing superior ablation properties than all monolayered coatings. The improved ablation resistance is mostly induced by the fact that the outmost scale with abundant ZrO₂ particles was able to better endure the mechanical denudation from the torch. Moreover, due to the indirect contact with torch, the innermost sublayers were placed into relatively mild environment, thereby most of Si-based oxides could be retained and further hinder oxygen transport inward during ablation.     

A novel combination of precursor pyrolysis assisted sintering and rapid sintering for construction of multi-composition coatings to improve ablation resistance of SiOC ceramic modified carbon fiber needled felt preform composites

A double-layer coating composed of MoSi₂–SiO₂–SiC/ZrB₂–MoSi₂–SiC was designed and successfully constructed by a novel combination of precursor pyrolysis assisted sintering and rapid sintering to improve the ablation resistance of SiOC ceramic modified carbon fiber needled felt preform composites (CSs). The ZrB₂–MoSi₂–SiC inner layer coating was in relatively uniform distribution in the zone of 0–3 mm from the surface of CSs through the slurry/precursor infiltration in vacuum and SiOC precursor pyrolysis assisted sintering, which played a predominant role in improving oxidation and ablation resistance and maintaining the morphology of CSs. The MoSi₂–SiO₂–SiC outer layer coating was prepared by the spray and rapid sintering to further protect CSs from high-temperature oxidation. The ablation resistance of CSs coated with double-layer coating was evaluated by an oxygen-acetylene ablation test under the temperature of 1600–1800 °C with different ablation time of 1000 and 1500 s. The results revealed that the mass recession rates increased with the rise of ablation temperature and extension of ablation time, ranging from 0.47 g/(m²·s) to 0.98 g/(m²·s) at 1600–1800 °C for 1000 s and from 0.72 g/(m²·s) to 0.86 g/(m²·s) for 1000–1500 s at 1700 °C, while the linear recession rates showed negative values at 1700 °C due to the formation of oxides, such as SiO₂ and ZrO₂. The ablation mechanism of the double-layer coating was analyzed and found that a SiO₂–ZrO₂–Mo_4.8Si₃C_0.6 oxidation protection barrier would be formed during the ablation process to prevent the oxygen diffusion into the interior CSs, and this study provided a novel and effective way to fabricate high-temperature oxidation protective and ablation resistant coating.