Single-Atom Catalysts and Dual-Atom Catalysts for CO2 Electroreduction: Competition or Cooperation?

Developing highly active and selective electrocatalysts for electrochemical reduction of CO₂ can reduce environmental pollution and mitigation of greenhouse gas emission. Owing to maximal atomic utilization, the atomically dispersed catalysts are broadly adopted in CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR). Dual-atom catalysts (DACs), with more flexible active sites, distinct electronic structures, and synergetic interatomic interactions compared to single-atom catalysts (SACs), may have great potential to enhance catalytic performance. Nevertheless, most of the existing electrocatalysts have low activity and selectivity due to their high energy barrier. Herein, 15 electrocatalysts are explored with noble metallic (Cu, Ag, and Au) active sites embedded in metal–organic hybrids (MOHs) for high-performance CO₂RR and studied the relationship between SACs and DACs by first-principles calculation. The results indicated that the DACs have excellent electrocatalytic performance, and the moderate interaction between the single- and dual-atomic center can improve catalytic activity in CO₂RR. Four among the 15 catalysts, including (CuAu), (CuCu), Cu(CuCu), and Cu(CuAu) MOHs inherited a capability of suppressing the competitive hydrogen evolution reaction with favorable CO overpotential. This work not only reveals outstanding candidates for MOHs-based dual-atom CO₂RR electrocatalysts but also provides new theoretical insights into rationally designing 2D metallic electrocatalysts.     

A Highly Active Star Decahedron Cu Nanocatalyst for Hydrocarbon Production at Low Overpotentials

The electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO₂RR) presents a viable approach to recycle CO₂ gas into low carbon fuels. Thus, the development of highly active catalysts at low overpotential is desired for this reaction. Herein, a high‐yield synthesis of unique star decahedron Cu nanoparticles (SD‐Cu NPs) electrocatalysts, displaying twin boundaries (TBs) and multiple stacking faults, which lead to low overpotentials for methane (CH₄) and high efficiency for ethylene (C₂H₄) production, is reported. Particularly, SD‐Cu NPs show an onset potential for CH₄ production lower by 0.149 V than commercial Cu NPs. More impressively, SD‐Cu NPs demonstrate a faradaic efficiency of 52.43% ± 2.72% for C₂H₄ production at ?0.993 ± 0.0129 V. The results demonstrate that the surface stacking faults and twin defects increase CO binding energy, leading to the enhanced CO₂RR performance on SD‐Cu NPs.     

Alloy Nanocatalysts for the Electrochemical Oxygen Reduction (ORR) and the Direct Electrochemical Carbon Dioxide Reduction Reaction (CO2RR)

In the face of the global energy challenge and progressing global climate change, renewable energy systems and components, such as fuel cells and electrolyzers, which close the energetic oxygen and carbon cycles, have become a technology development priority. The electrochemical oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) and the direct electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO₂RR) are important electrocatalytic processes that proceed at gas diffusion electrodes of hydrogen fuel cells and CO₂ electrolyzers, respectively. However, their low catalytic activity (voltage efficiency), limited long‐term stability, and moderate product selectivity (related to their Faradaic efficiency) have remained challenges. To address these, suitable catalysts are required. This review addresses the current state of research on Pt‐based and Cu‐based nanoalloy electrocatalysts for ORR and CO₂RR, respectively, and critically compares and contrasts key performance parameters such as activity, selectivity, and durability. In particular, Pt nanoparticles alloyed with transition metals, post‐transition metals and lanthanides, are discussed, as well as the material characterization and their performance for the ORR. Then, bimetallic Cu nanoalloy catalysts are reviewed and organized according to their main reaction product generated by the second metal. This review concludes with a perspective on nanoalloy catalysts for the ORR and the CO₂RR, and proposes future research directions.     

Metal‐Free Carbon Materials for CO2 Electrochemical Reduction

The rapid increase of the CO₂ concentration in the Earth's atmosphere has resulted in numerous environmental issues, such as global warming, ocean acidification, melting of the polar ice, rising sea level, and extinction of species. To search for suitable and capable catalytic systems for CO₂ conversion, electrochemical reduction of CO₂ (CO₂RR) holds great promise. Emerging heterogeneous carbon materials have been considered as promising metal‐free electrocatalysts for the CO₂RR, owing to their abundant natural resources, tailorable porous structures, resistance to acids and bases, high‐temperature stability, and environmental friendliness. They exhibit remarkable CO₂RR properties, including catalytic activity, long durability, and high selectivity. Here, various carbon materials (e.g., carbon fibers, carbon nanotubes, graphene, diamond, nanoporous carbon, and graphene dots) with heteroatom doping (e.g., N, S, and B) that can be used as metal‐free catalysts for the CO₂RR are highlighted. Recent advances regarding the identification of active sites for the CO₂RR and the pathway of reduction of CO₂ to the final product are comprehensively reviewed. Additionally, the emerging challenges and some perspectives on the development of heteroatom‐doped carbon materials as metal‐free electrocatalysts for the CO₂RR are included.     

Single-Site Metal–Organic Framework and Copper Foil Tandem Catalyst for Highly Selective CO2 Electroreduction to C2H4

Tandem catalysis is a promising way to break the limitation of linear scaling relationship for enhancing efficiency, and the desired tandem catalysts for electrochemical CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR) are urgent to be developed. Here, a tandem electrocatalyst created by combining Cu foil (CF) with a single-site Cu(II) metal–organic framework (MOF), named as Cu–MOF–CF, to realize improved electrochemical CO₂RR performance, is reported. The Cu–MOF–CF shows suppression of CH₄, great increase in C₂H₄ selectivity (48.6%), and partial current density of C₂H₄ at −1.11 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode. The outstanding performance of Cu–MOF–CF for CO₂RR results from the improved microenvironment of the Cu active sites that inhibits CH₄ production, more CO intermediate produced by single-site Cu–MOF in situ for CF, and the enlarged active surface area by porous Cu–MOF. This work provides a strategy to combine MOFs with copper-based electrocatalysts to establish high-efficiency electrocatalytic CO₂RR.     

Promoting Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction to CH4 by Copper Porphyrin with Donor–Acceptor Structures

Molecular catalysts have been receiving increasingly attention in the electrochemical CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR) with attractive features such as precise catalytic sites and tunable ligands. However, the insufficient activity and low selectivity of deep reduction products restrain the utilization of molecular catalysts in CO₂RR. Herein, a donor–acceptor modified Cu porphyrin (CuTAPP) is developed, in which amino groups are linked to donate electrons toward the central CuN₄ site to enhance the CO₂RR activity. The CuTAPP catalyst exhibited an excellent CO₂-to-CH₄ electroreduction performance, including a high CH₄ partial current density of 290.5 mA cm⁻² and a corresponding Faradaic efficiency of 54.8% at –1.63 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode in flow cells. Density functional theory calculations indicated that CuTAPP presented a much lower energy gap in the pathway of producing *CHO than Cu porphyrin without amino group modification. This work suggests a useful strategy of introducing designed donor–acceptor structures into molecular catalysts for enhancing electrochemical CO₂ conversion toward deep reduction products.     

Engineering Under-Coordinated Active Sites with Tailored Chemical Microenvironments over Mosaic Bismuth Nanosheets for Selective CO2 Electroreduction to Formate

Selective electrochemical reduction of CO₂ into fuels or chemical feedstocks is a promising avenue to achieve carbon-neutral goal, but its development is severely limited by the lack of highly efficient electrocatalysts. Herein, cation-exchange strategy is combined with electrochemical self-reconstruction strategy to successfully develop diethylenetriamine-functionalized mosaic Bi nanosheets (mBi-DETA NSs) for selective electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction to formate, delivering a superior formate Faradaic efficiency of 96.87% at a low potential of −0.8 V_RHE. Mosaic nanosheet morphology of Bi can sufficiently expose the under-coordinated Bi active sites and promote the activation of CO₂ molecules to form the OCHO⁻* intermediate. Moreover, in situ attenuated total reflectance infrared spectra further corroborate that surface chemical microenvironment modulation of mosaic Bi nanosheets via DETA functionalization can improve CO₂ adsorption on the catalyst surface and stabilize the key intermediate (OCHO⁻*) due to the presence of amine groups, thus facilitate the CO₂-to-HCOO⁻ reaction kinetics and promote formate formation.     

Enhanced CO Affinity on Cu Facilitates CO2 Electroreduction toward Multi-Carbon Products

Electrochemical CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR) is a promising strategy for waste CO₂ utilization and intermittent electricity storage. Herein, it is reported that bimetallic Cu/Pd catalysts with enhanced *CO affinity show a promoted CO₂RR performance for multi-carbon (C2+) production under industry-relevant high current density. Especially, bimetallic Cu/Pd-1% catalyst shows an outstanding CO₂-to-C2+ conversion with 66.2% in Faradaic efficiency (FE) and 463.2 mA cm⁻² in partial current density. An increment in the FE ratios of C2+ products to CO  for Cu/Pd-1% catalyst further illuminates a preferable C2+ production. In situ Raman spectra reveal that the atop-bounded CO is dominated by low-frequency band CO on Cu/Pd-1% that leads to C2+ products on bimetallic catalysts, in contrast to the majority of high-frequency band CO on Cu that favors the formation of CO. Density function theory calculation confirms that bimetallic Cu/Pd catalyst enhances the *CO adsorption and reduces the Gibbs free energy of the C C coupling process, thereby favoring the formation of C2+ products.     

Oxalate-Assisted Synthesis of Hollow Carbon Nanocage With Fe Single Atoms for Electrochemical CO2 Reduction

Metal single-atom catalysts are promising in electrochemical CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR). The pores and cavities of the supports can promote the exposure of active sites and mass transfer of reactants, hence improve their performance. Here, iron oxalate is added to ZIF-8 and subsequently form hollow carbon nanocages during calcination. The formation mechanism of the hollow structure is studied in depth by controlling variables during synthesis. Kirkendall effect is the main reason for the formation of hollow porous carbon nanocages. The hollow porous carbon nanocages with Fe single atoms exhibit better CO₂RR activity and CO selectivity. The diffusion of CO₂ facilitated by the mesoporous structure of carbon nanocage results in their superior activity and selectivity. This work has raised an effective strategy for the synthesis of hollow carbon nanomaterials, and provides a feasible pathway for the rational design of electrocatalysts for small molecule activation.     

Recent Advances in Inorganic Heterogeneous Electrocatalysts for Reduction of Carbon Dioxide

In view of the climate changes caused by the continuously rising levels of atmospheric CO₂, advanced technologies associated with CO₂ conversion are highly desirable. In recent decades, electrochemical reduction of CO₂ has been extensively studied since it can reduce CO₂ to value‐added chemicals and fuels. Considering the sluggish reaction kinetics of the CO₂ molecule, efficient and robust electrocatalysts are required to promote this conversion reaction. Here, recent progress and opportunities in inorganic heterogeneous electrocatalysts for CO₂ reduction are discussed, from the viewpoint of both experimental and computational aspects. Based on elemental composition, the inorganic catalysts presented here are classified into four groups: metals, transition‐metal oxides, transition‐metal chalcogenides, and carbon‐based materials. However, despite encouraging accomplishments made in this area, substantial advances in CO₂ electrolysis are still needed to meet the criteria for practical applications. Therefore, in the last part, several promising strategies, including surface engineering, chemical modification, nanostructured catalysts, and composite materials, are proposed to facilitate the future development of CO₂ electroreduction.     

Achieving Tunable Selectivity and Activity of CO2 Electroreduction to CO via Bimetallic Silver–Copper Electronic Engineering

Limited comprehension of the reaction mechanism has hindered the development of catalysts for CO₂ reduction reactions (CO₂RR). Here, the bimetallic AgCu nanocatalyst platform is employed to understand the effect of the electronic structure of catalysts on the selectivity and activity for CO₂ electroreduction to CO. The atomic arrangement and electronic state structure vary with the atomic ratio of Ag and Cu, enabling tunable d-band centers to optimize the binding strength of key intermediates. Density functional theory calculations confirm that the variation of Cu content greatly affects the free energy of *COOH, *CO (intermediate of CO), and *H (intermediates of H₂), which leads to the change of the rate-determining step. Specifically, Ag₉₆Cu₄ reduces the free energy of the formation of *COOH while maintaining a relatively high theoretical overpotential for hydrogen evolution reaction(HER), thus achieving the best CO selectivity. While Ag₇₀Cu₃₀ shows relatively low formation energy of both *COOH and *H, the compromised thermodynamic barrier and product selectivity allows Ag₇₀Cu₃₀ the best CO partial current density. This study realizes the regulation of the selectivity and activity of electrocatalytic CO₂ to CO, which provides a promising way to improve the intrinsic performance of CO₂RR on bimetallic AgCu.     

Cu?C(O) Interfaces Deliver Remarkable Selectivity and Stability for CO2 Reduction to C2+ Products at Industrial Current Density of 500 mA cm−2

The electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR) is an attractive technology for CO₂ valorization and high-density electrical energy storage. Achieving a high selectivity to C₂₊ products, especially ethylene, during CO₂RR at high current densities (>500 mA cm⁻²) is a prized goal of current research, though remains technically very challenging. Herein, it is demonstrated that the surface and interfacial structures of Cu catalysts, and the solid–gas–liquid interfaces on gas-diffusion electrode (GDE) in CO₂ reduction flow cells can be modulated to allow efficient CO₂RR to C₂₊ products. This approach uses the in situ electrochemical reduction of a CuO nanosheet/graphene oxide dots (CuO C(O)) hybrid. Owing to abundant Cu O C interfaces in the CuO C(O) hybrid, the CuO nanosheets are topologically and selectively transformed into metallic Cu nanosheets exposing Cu(100) facets, Cu(110) facets, Cu[n(100) × (110)] step sites, and Cu⁺/Cu⁰ interfaces during the electroreduction step,  the faradaic efficiencie (FE) to C₂₊ hydrocarbons was reached as high as 77.4% (FE_ethylene ≈ 60%) at 500 mA cm⁻² . In situ infrared spectroscopy and DFT simulations demonstrate that abundant Cu⁺ species and Cu⁰/Cu⁺ interfaces in the reduced CuO C(O) catalyst improve the adsorption and surface coverage of *CO on the Cu catalyst, thus facilitating C C coupling reactions.     

AuCu Alloy Nanoparticle Embedded Cu Submicrocone Arrays for Selective Conversion of CO2 to Ethanol

The CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR) driven by renewable electricity represents a promising strategy toward alleviating the energy shortage and environmental crisis facing humankind. Cu species, as one type of versatile electrocatalyst for the CO₂RR, attract tremendous research interest. However, for C₂ products, ethanol formation is commonly less favored over Cu electrocatalysts. Herein, AuCu alloy nanoparticle embedded Cu submicrocone arrays (AuCu/Cu‐SCA) are constructed as an active, selective, and robust electrocatalyst for the CO₂RR. Enhanced selectivity for EtOH is gained, whose Faradaic efficiency (FE) reaches 29 ± 4%, while ethylene formation is relatively inhibited (16 ± 4%) in KHCO₃ aqueous solution. The ratio between partial current densities of EtOH and C₂H₄ (j_EtOH/j_C2H4) can be tuned in the range from 0.15 ± 0.27 to 1.81 ± 0.55 by varying the Au content of the electrocatalysts. The combined experimental and theoretical calculation results identify the importance of Au in modifying binding energies of key intermediates, such as CH₂CHO*, CH₃CHO*, and CH₃CH₂O*, which consequently modify the activity and selectivity (j_EtOH/j_C2H4) for the CO₂RR. Moreover, AuCu/Cu‐SCA also shows high durability with both the current density and FE_EtOH being largely maintained for 24 h electrocatalysis.     

Carbon‐Based Metal‐Free Catalysts for Electrocatalytic Reduction of Nitrogen for Synthesis of Ammonia at Ambient Conditions

The electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) is a promising catalytic system for N₂ fixation in ambient conditions. Currently, metal‐based catalysts are the most widely studied catalysts for electrocatalytic NRR. Unfortunately, the low selectivity and poor resistance to acids and bases, and the low Faradaic efficiency, production rate, and stability of metal‐based catalysts for NRR make them uncompetitive for the synthesis of ammonia in comparison to the industrial Haber–Bosch process. Inspired by applications of carbon‐based metal‐free catalysts (CMFCs) for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) and CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR), the studies of these CMFCs in electrocatalytic NRR have attracted great attention in the past year. However, due to the differences in electrocatalytic NRR, there are several critical issues that need to be addressed in order to achieve rational design of advanced carbon‐based metal‐free electrocatalysts to improve activity, selectivity, and stability for NRR. Herein, the recent developments in the field of carbon‐based metal‐free NRR catalysts are presented, along with critical issues, challenges, and perspectives concerning metal‐free catalysts for electrocatalytic reduction of nitrogen for synthesis of ammonia at ambient conditions.     

One-Step Phase Separation for Core-Shell Carbon@Indium Oxide@Bismuth Microspheres with Enhanced Activity for CO2 Electroreduction to Formate

It is a substantial challenge to construct electrocatalysts with high activity, good selectivity, and long-term stability for electrocatalytic reduction of carbon dioxide to formic acid. Herein, bismuth and indium species are innovatively integrated into a uniform heterogeneous spherical structure by a neoteric quasi-microemulsion method, and a novel C@In₂O₃@Bi₅₀ core-shell structure is constructed through a subsequent one-step phase separation strategy due to melting point difference and Kirkendall effect with the nano-limiting effect of the carbon structure. This core-shell C@In₂O₃@Bi₅₀ catalyst can selectively reduce CO₂ to formate with high selectivity (≈90% faradaic efficiency), large partial current density (24.53 mA cm⁻² at −1.36 V), and long-term stability (up to 14.5 h), superior to most of the Bi-based catalysts. The hybrid Bi/In₂O₃ interfaces of core-shell C@In₂O₃@Bi will stabilize the key intermediate HCOO* and suppress CO poisoning, benefiting the CO₂RR selectivity and stability, while the internal cavity of core-shell structure will improve the reaction kinetics because of the large specific surface area and the enhancement of ion shuttle and electron transfer. Furthermore, the nano-limited domain effect of outmost carbon prevent active components from oxidation and agglomeration, helpful for stabilizing the catalyst. This work offers valuable insights into core-shell structure engineering to promote practical CO₂ conversion technology.     

Hybrid Cu0 and Cux+ as Atomic Interfaces Promote High‐Selectivity Conversion of CO2 to C2H5OH at Low Potential

The mixing of charge states of metal copper catalysts may lead to a much improved reactivity and selectivity toward multicarbon products for CO₂ reduction. Here, an electrocatalyst model composed of copper clusters supported on graphitic carbon nitride (g‐C₃N₄) is proposed; the connecting Cu atoms with g‐C₃N₄ can be oxidized to Cu^{x +} due to substantial charge transfer from Cu to N atoms, while others stay as Cu⁰. It is revealed that CO₂ can be captured and reduced into *CO on the Cu_t⁰ site, owing to its zero oxidation state. More importantly, C–C coupling reaction of two *CHO species on the Cu_t⁰–Cu_b^{x +} atomic interface can occur with a rather low kinetic barrier of 0.57 eV, leading to the formation of the final C₂ product, namely, C₂H₅OH. During the whole process, the limiting potential is just 0.68 V. These findings may open a new avenue for CO₂ reduction into high‐value fuels and chemicals.     

Electrochemical CO2 Reduction into Chemical Feedstocks: From Mechanistic Electrocatalysis Models to System Design

The electrochemical reduction of CO₂ is a promising route to convert intermittent renewable energy to storable fuels and valuable chemical feedstocks. To scale this technology for industrial implementation, a deepened understanding of how the CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR) proceeds will help converge on optimal operating parameters. Here, a techno‐economic analysis is presented with the goal of identifying maximally profitable products and the performance targets that must be met to ensure economic viability—metrics that include current density, Faradaic efficiency, energy efficiency, and stability. The latest computational understanding of the CO₂RR is discussed along with how this can contribute to the rational design of efficient, selective, and stable electrocatalysts. Catalyst materials are classified according to their selectivity for products of interest and their potential to achieve performance targets is assessed. The recent progress and opportunities in system design for CO₂ electroreduction are described. To conclude, the remaining technological challenges are highlighted, suggesting full‐cell energy efficiency as a guiding performance metric for industrial impact.     

Selective and Stable CO2 Electroreduction to CH4 via Electronic Metal–Support Interaction upon Decomposition/Redeposition of MOF

The CO₂ electroreduction to fuels is a feasible approach to provide renewable energy sources. Therefore, it is necessary to conduct experimental and theoretical investigations on various catalyst design strategies, such as electronic metal–support interaction, to improve the catalytic selectivity. Here a solvent-free synthesis method is reported to prepare a copper (Cu)-based metal–organic framework (MOF) as the precursor. Upon electrochemical CO₂ reduction in aqueous electrolyte, it undergoes in situ decomposition/redeposition processes to form abundant interfaces between Cu nanoparticles and amorphous carbon supports. This Cu/C catalyst favors the selective and stable production of CH₄ with a Faradaic efficiency of ≈55% at −1.4 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE) for 12.5 h. The density functional theory calculation reveals the crucial role of interfacial sites between Cu and amorphous carbon support in stabilizing the key intermediates for CO₂ reduction to CH₄. The adsorption of COOH* and CHO* at the Cu/C interface is up to 0.86 eV stronger than that on Cu(111), thus promoting the formation of CH₄. Therefore, it is envisioned that the strategy of regulating electronic metal–support interaction can improve the selectivity and stability of catalyst toward a specific product upon electrochemical CO₂ reduction.     

Less-Coordinated Atomic Copper-Dimer Boosted Carbon–Carbon Coupling During Electrochemical CO2 Reduction

This work reports a metal–organic framework (MOF) with less-coordinated copper dimers, which displays excellent electrochemical CO₂ reduction (eCO₂RR) performance with an advantageous current density of 0.9 A cm⁻² and a high Faradaic efficiency of 71% to C₂ products. In comparison with MOF with Cu monomers that are present as Cu₁ O₄ with a coordination number of 3.8 ± 0.2, Cu dimers exist as O₃Cu₁···Cu₂O₂ with a coordination number of 2.8 ± 0.1. In situ characterizations together with theoretical calculations reveal that two *CO intermediates are stably adsorbed on each site of less-coordinated Cu dimers, which favors later dimerization via a key intermediate of *CH₂CHO. The highly unsaturated dual-atomic Cu provides large-quantity and high-quality actives sites for carbon–carbon coupling, achieving the optimal trade-off between activity and selectivity of eCO₂RR to C₂ products.     

Heterogeneous Single-Atom Catalysts for Electrochemical CO2 Reduction Reaction

The electrochemical CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR) is of great importance to tackle the rising CO₂ concentration in the atmosphere. The CO₂RR can be driven by renewable energy sources, producing precious chemicals and fuels, with the implementation of this process largely relying on the development of low-cost and efficient electrocatalysts. Recently, a range of heterogeneous and potentially low-cost single-atom catalysts (SACs) containing non-precious metals coordinated to earth-abundant elements have emerged as promising candidates for the CO₂RR. Unfortunately, the real catalytically active centers and the key factors that govern the catalytic performance of these SACs remain ambiguous. Here, this ambiguity is addressed by developing a fundamental understanding of the CO₂RR-to-CO process on SACs, as CO accounts for the major product from CO₂RR on SACs. The reaction mechanism, the rate-determining steps, and the key factors that control the activity and selectivity are analyzed from both experimental and theoretical studies. Then, the synthesis, characterization, and the CO₂RR performance of SACs are discussed. Finally, the challenges and future pathways are highlighted in the hope of guiding the design of the SACs to promote and understand the CO₂RR on SACs.