Approximations for Strategies and Termination

The theorem of Huet and Lévy stating that for orthogonal rewrite systems (i) every reducible term contains a needed redex and (ii) repeated contraction of needed redexes results in a normal form if the term under consideration has a normal form, forms the basis of all results on optimal normalizing strategies for orthogonal rewrite systems. However, needed redexes are not computable in general.

In the paper we illustrate, based on the framework introduced in [6], how the use of approximations and their associated tree automata results allows one to obtain decidable conditions in a simple and elegant way.

We further show how the very same ideas can be used to improve [18] the dependency pair method of Arts and Giesl [1] for proving termination of rewrite systems automatically. More precisely, we show how approximations and tree automata techniques provide a better estimation of the dependency graph. This graph determines the ordering constraints that have to be solved in order to conclude termination. Furthermore, we present a new estimation of the dependency graph that does not rely on computationally expensive tree automata techniques.     

Comparing Curried and Uncurried Rewriting

Currying is a transformation of term rewrite systems which may contain symbols of arbitrary arity into systems which contain only nullary symbols, together with a single binary symbol called application. We show that for all term rewrite systems (whether orthogonal or not) the following properties are preserved by this transformation: strong normalization, weak normalization, weak Church-Rosser, completeness, semi-completeness, and the non-convertibility of distinct normal forms. Under the condition of left-linearity we show preservation of the properties NF (if a term is reducible to a normal form,then its reducts are all reducible to the same normal form) and UN→ (a term is reducible to at most one normal form).We exhibit counterexamples to the preservation of NF and UN→ for non-left-linear systems.The results extend to partial currying(where some subset of the symbols are curried),and imply some modularity properties for unions of applicative systems.     

Non-Linear Rewrite Closure and Weak Normalization

A rewrite closure is an extension of a term rewrite system with new rules, usually deduced by transitivity. Rewrite closures have the nice property that all rewrite derivations can be transformed into derivations of a simple form. This property has been useful for proving decidability results in term rewriting. Unfortunately, when the term rewrite system is not linear, the construction of a rewrite closure is quite challenging. In this paper, we construct a rewrite closure for term rewrite systems that satisfy two properties: the right-hand side term in each rewrite rule contains no repeated variable (right-linear) and contains no variable occurring at depth greater than one (right-shallow). The left-hand side term is unrestricted, and in particular, it may be non-linear. As a consequence of the rewrite closure construction, we are able to prove decidability of the weak normalization problem for right-linear right-shallow term rewrite systems. Proving this result also requires tree automata theory. We use the fact that right-shallow right-linear term rewrite systems are regularity preserving. Moreover, their set of normal forms can be represented with a tree automaton with disequality constraints, and emptiness of this kind of automata, as well as its generalization to reduction automata, is decidable. A preliminary version of this work was presented at LICS 2009 (Creus 2009).     

Lazy Context Cloning for Non-Deterministic Graph Rewriting

We define a rewrite strategy for a class of non-confluent constructor-based term graph rewriting systems and prove its correctness. Our strategy and its extension to narrowing are intended for the implementation of non-strict non-deterministic functional logic programming languages. Our strategy is based on a graph transformation, called bubbling, that avoids the construction of large contexts of redexes with distinct replacements, an expensive and frequently wasteful operation executed by competitive complete techniques.     

Type introduction for equational rewriting

Abstract. Type introduction is a useful technique for simplifying the task of proving properties of rewrite systems by restricting the set of terms that have to be considered to the well-typed terms according to any many-sorted type discipline which is compatible with the rewrite system under consideration. A property of rewrite systems for which type introduction is correct is called persistent. Zantema showed that termination is a persistent property of non-collapsing rewrite systems and non-duplicating rewrite systems. We extend his result to the more complicated case of equational rewriting. As a simple application we prove the undecidability of AC-termination for terminating rewrite systems. We also present sufficient conditions for the persistence of acyclicity and non-loopingness, two properties which guarantee the absence of certain kinds of infinite rewrite sequences. In the final part of the paper we show how our results on persistence give rise to new modularity results. Received 30 June 1998 / 12 January 2000     

重写系统的模块分解

Ｍｉｄｄｅｌｄｏｒｐ和Ｔｏｙａｍａ证明，强加构造原则到项重写系统可获得完备概念的模块性，并且系统分解成的各部分间可共亨函数符号和重量写规则。本文推广他们的结论，当构造性的项重写系统引用定义在其它系统中的函数符号时，完备概念的模块性仍保持。该结论对代数规范和基于项重写的编程语言等方面是很有意义的。     

Decidability for Left-Linear Growing Term Rewriting Systems

A term rewriting system is called growing if each variable occurring on both the left-hand side and the right-hand side of a rewrite rule occurs at depth zero or one in the left-hand side. Jacquemard showed that the reachability and the sequentiality of linear (i.e., left-right-linear) growing term rewriting systems are decidable. In this paper we show that Jacquemard's result can be extended to left-linear growing rewriting systems that may have right-nonlinear rewrite rules. This implies that the reachability and the joinability of some class of right-linear term rewriting systems are decidable, which improves the results for right-ground term rewriting systems by Oyamaguchi. Our result extends the class of left-linear term rewriting systems having a decidable call-by-need normalizing strategy. Moreover, we prove that the termination property is decidable for almost orthogonal growing term rewriting systems.     

Infinitary Combinatory Reduction Systems

We define infinitary Combinatory Reduction Systems (iCRSs), thus providing the first notion of infinitary higher-order rewriting. The systems defined are sufficiently general that ordinary infinitary term rewriting and infinitary λ-calculus are special cases.Furthermore, we generalise a number of known results from first-order infinitary rewriting and infinitary λ-calculus to iCRSs. In particular, for fully-extended, left-linear iCRSs we prove the well-known compression property, and for orthogonal iCRSs we prove that (1) if a set of redexes U has a complete development, then all complete developments of U end in the same term and that (2) any tiling diagram involving strongly convergent reductions S and T can be completed iff at least one of S/T and T/S is strongly convergent.We also prove an ancillary result of independent interest: a set of redexes in an orthogonal iCRS has a complete development iff the set has the so-called finite jumps property.     

Perfect Bases for Equational Theories

Perfect bases for equational theories are closely related to confluent and finitely terminating term rewrite systems. The two classes have a large overlap, but neither contains the other. The class of perfect bases is recursive. We also investigate a common generalization of both concepts; we call these more general bases normal, and touch the question of their uniqueness. We also give numerous examples.     

Match-bounds revisited

The use of automata techniques to prove the termination of string rewrite systems and left-linear term rewrite systems is advocated by Geser et al. in a recent sequence of papers. We extend their work to non-left-linear rewrite systems. The key to this extension is the introduction of so-called raise rules and the use of tree automata that are not quite deterministic. Furthermore, to increase the applicability of the method we show how it can be incorporated into the dependency pair framework. To achieve this we introduce two new enrichments which take the special properties of dependency pair problems into account.     

An initial algebra approach to term rewriting systems with variable binders

We present an extension of first-order term rewriting systems. It involves variable binding in the term language. We develop systems called binding term rewriting systems (BTRSs) in a stepwise manner. First we present the term language, then formulate equational logic. Finally, we define rewriting systems. This development is novel because we follow the initial algebra approach in an extended notion of Σ-algebras in various functor categories. These are based on Fiore-Plotkin-Turi’s presheaf semantics of variable binding and Lüth-Ghani’s monadic semantics of term rewriting systems. We characterise the terms, equational logic and rewrite systems for BTRSs as initial algebras in suitable categories. Then, we show an important rewriting property of BTRSs: orthogonal BTRSs are confluent. Moreover, by using the initial algebra semantics, we give a complete characterisation of termination of BTRSs. Finally, we discuss our design choice of BTRSs from a semantic perspective. An erlier version appeared in Proc. Fifth ACM-SIGPLAN International Conference on Principles and Practice of Declarative Programming (PPDP2003).     

Evaluation strategies for functional logic programming

Recent advances in the foundations and the implementations of functional logic programming languages originate from far-reaching results on narrowing evaluation strategies. Narrowing is a computation similar to rewriting which yields substitutions in addition to normal forms. In functional logic programming, the classes of rewrite systems to which narrowing is applied are, for the most part, subclasses of the constructor-based, possibly conditional, rewrite systems. Many interesting narrowing strategies, particularly for the smallest subclasses of the constructor-based rewrite systems, are generalizations of well-known rewrite strategies. However, some strategies for larger non-confluent subclasses have been developed just for functional logic computations. This paper discusses the elements that play a relevant role in evaluation strategies for functional logic computations, describes some important classes of rewrite systems that model functional logic programs, shows examples of the differences in expressiveness provided by these classes, and reviews the characteristics of narrowing strategies proposed for each class of rewrite systems.     

Rigid tree automata and applications

We introduce the class of rigid tree automata (RTA), an extension of standard bottom-up automata on ranked trees with distinguished states called rigid. Rigid states define a restriction on the computation of RTA on trees: RTA can test for equality in subtrees reaching the same rigid state. RTA are able to perform local and global tests of equality between subtrees, non-linear tree pattern matching, and some inequality and disequality tests as well. Properties like determinism, pumping lemma, Boolean closure, and several decision problems are studied in detail. In particular, the emptiness problem is shown decidable in linear time for RTA whereas membership of a given tree to the language of a given RTA is NP-complete. Our main result is the decidability of whether a given tree belongs to the rewrite closure of an RTA language under a restricted family of term rewriting systems, whereas this closure is not an RTA language. This result, one of the first on rewrite closure of languages of tree automata with constraints, is enabling the extension of model checking procedures based on finite tree automata techniques, in particular for the verification of communicating processes with several local non-rewritable memories, like security protocols. Finally, a comparison of RTA with several classes of tree automata with local and global equality tests, with dag automata and Horn clause formalisms is also provided.     

Perpetuality and Uniform Normalization in Orthogonal Rewrite Systems

We study perpetuality of reduction steps, as well as perpetuality of redexes, in orthogonal rewrite systems. A perpetual step is a reduction step which retains the possibility of infinite reductions. A perpetual redex is a redex which, when put into an arbitrary context, yields a perpetual step. We generalize and refine existing criteria for the perpetuality of reduction steps and redexes in orthogonal term rewriting systems and the λ-calculus due to Bergstra and Klop and others. We first introduce context-sensitive conditional expression reduction systems (CCERSs) and define a concept of orthogonality (which implies confluence) for them. In particular, several important λ-calculi and their extensions and restrictions can naturally be embedded into orthogonal CCERSs. We then define a perpetual reduction strategy which enables one to construct minimal (w.r.t. Lévy's permutation ordering on reductions) infinite reductions in orthogonal fully-extended CCERSs. Using the properties of the minimal perpetual strategy, we prove   1. perpetuality of any reduction step that does not erase potentially infinite arguments, which are arguments that may become, via substitution, infinite after a number of outside steps, and   2. perpetuality (in every context) of any safe redex, which is a redex whose substitution instances may discard infinite arguments only when the corresponding contracta remain infinite.  We prove both these perpetuality criteria for orthogonal fully-extended CCERSs and then specialize and apply them to restricted λ-calculi, demonstrating their usefulness. In particular, we prove the equivalence of weak and strong normalization (whose equivalence is here called uniform normalization) for various restricted λ-calculi, most of which cannot be derived from previously known perpetuality criteria.     

Decidability of the confluence of finite ground term rewrite systems and of other related term rewrite systems

The aim of this paper is to propose an algorithm to decide the confluence of finite ground term rewrite systems. Actually a more general class of possibly infinite ground term rewrite systems is studied. It is well known that the confluence is not decidable for general term rewrite systems, but this paper proves it is for ground term rewrite systems following a conjecture made by Huet and Oppen in their survey. The result is also applied to the confluence of left-linear and right-ground term rewrite systems. We also sketch an algorithm for checking this property. This algorithm is based on tree automata and tree transducers. Here, we regard them as rewrite systems and specialists in automata theory would translate that easily in their language.     

Interaction Nets with McCarthy's amb

Interaction nets are graphical rewrite systems which have been successfully used to implement various efficient evaluation strategies in the λ-calculus (including optimal reduction). However, they are intrinsically deterministic and this prevents from applying these techniques to concurrent languages where non-determinism plays a key rôle. In this paper we show that a minimal extension —the addition of one agent in the spirit of McCarthy's amb operator —allows us to define non-deterministic processes such as angelic and infinity merge, and more generally, to encode process calculi and wide classes of term rewriting systems (including systems defining parallel functions). We also show that Alexiev's INMPP (interaction nets with multiple principal ports) can be encoded, for which we give a textual calculus and a type system that ensures the absence of deadlock.     

Modular Properties of Composable Term Rewriting Systems

In this paper we prove several new modularity results for unconditional and conditional term rewriting systems. Most of the known modularity results for the former systems hold for disjoint or constructor-sharing combinations. Here we focus on a more general kind of combination: so-called composable systems. As far as conditional term rewriting systems are concerned, all known modularity result but one apply only to disjoint systems. Here we investigate conditional systems which may share constructors. Furthermore, we refute a conjecture of Middeldorp (1990, 1993).     

Rewrite rule systems for modal propositional logic

This paper explains new results relating modal propositional logic and rewrite rule systems. More precisely, we give complete term rewriting systems for the modal propositional systems known as K, Q, T, and S5. These systems are presented as extensions of Hsiang's system for classical propositional calculus. We have checked local confluence with the rewrite rule system K.B. (cf. the Knuth-Bendix algorithm) developed by the Formel project at INRIA. We prove that these systems are noetherian, and then infer their confluence from Newman's lemma. Therefore each term rewriting system provides a new automated decision procedure and defines a canonical form for the corresponding logic. We also show how to characterize the canonical forms thus obtained.     

Rewrite Systems with Constraints

We extend a widely used concept of rewrite systems with a unit holding a kind of global information which can influence and can be influenced by rewriting. The unit is similar to the store used in concurrent constraint programming, and can be also seen as a special (weak) state unit. We present how this extension changes the expressive power of rewrite systems classes which are included in Mayr's PRS hierarchy [8]. The new classes (fcBPA, fcBPP, fcPA, fcPAD, fcPAN, fcPRS) are described and inserted into the hierarchy.     

Uncurrying for Termination and Complexity

First-order applicative rewrite systems provide a natural framework for modeling higher-order aspects. In this article we present a transformation from untyped applicative term rewrite systems to functional term rewrite systems that preserves and reflects termination. Our transformation is less restrictive than other approaches. In particular, head variables in right-hand sides of rewrite rules can be handled. To further increase the applicability of our transformation, we study the method for innermost rewriting and derivational complexity, and present a version for dependency pairs.