Comparative analysis on sorption enhanced steam reforming and conventional steam reforming of hydroxyacetone for hydrogen production: Thermodynamic modeling

The chemical thermodynamics of sorption enhanced steam reforming (SESR) of hydroxyacetone for hydrogen production were investigated and contrasted with hydroxyacetone steam reforming (SR) by means of Gibbs free energy minimization principle and response reactions (RERs) method. Hydrogen is mainly derived methane steam reforming reaction from and water gas shift reaction. The former reaction contributes more than the latter one to hydrogen production below 550 °C and at higher temperature the latter one tends to dominate. The maximum hydrogen concentration is 70% in SR, which is far below hydrogen purities required by fuel cells. In SESR, hydrogen purities are over 99% in 525–550 °C with a WHMR greater than 8 and a CHMR of 6. The optimum temperature for SESR is approximately 125 °C lower than that for SR. In comparison with SR, SESR has the advantage of almost complete inhibition of coke formation in 200–1200 °C for WHMR ≥ 3.     

Hydrogen production via sorption enhanced steam reforming of butanol: Thermodynamic analysis

Thermodynamic equilibrium for sorption enhanced steam reforming of butanol (SESRB) to hydrogen was investigated using Gibbs free energy minimization method. The optimal operation conditions for SESRB are at 800 K, the steam-to-butanol molar ratio of 10, the calcium oxide-to-butanol molar ratio of 8 and atmospheric pressure. Under the optimal conditions, complete conversion of butanol, 97.07% concentration of H₂ and 0.05% concentration of CO₂, and efficiency of 86.60% could be achieved and at which no coke tends to form. Under the same conditions in SRB, 58.18% concentration of H₂, 21.62% concentration of CO₂, and energy efficiency of 81.51% could be achieved. Butanol steam reforming with CO₂ adsorption has the higher H₂ content and efficiency, and lower CO₂ content than that without adsorption under the same reaction conditions. In addition, reaction conditions for coke-free and coke-formed regions are also discussed in butanol steam reforming with or without CO₂ separation.     

Thermodynamic analysis of propane dry and steam reforming for synthesis gas or hydrogen production

Thermodynamics was applied to investigate propane dry reforming (DR) and steam reforming (SR). Equilibrium calculations employing the Gibbs free energy minimization were performed upon a wide range of pressure (1–5 atm), temperature (700–1100 K), carbon dioxide to propane ratio (CPR, 1–12) and water to propane ratio (WPR, 1–18). From a thermodynamic perspective, it is demonstrated that DR is promising for production of synthesis gas with low hydrogen content, as opposite to SR which favours generation of synthesis gas with high hydrogen content. Complete conversion of propane was obtained for the range of pressure, temperature, CPR and WPR considered in this study. Atmospheric pressure is shown to be preferable for both DR and SR. Approximately 10 mol of synthesis gas can be produced per mole of propane at a temperature greater than 1000 K from DR when CPR is higher than 6. The optimum conditions for synthesis gas production from DR are found to be 975 K (CPR = 3) for a H₂/CO ratio of 1 and 1100 K (CPR = 1) for a H₂/CO ratio of 2. The greatest CO₂ conversion (95%) can be obtained also at 1100 K and CPR = 1. Preferential conditions for hydrogen production from SR are achieved with the temperatures between 925 and 975 K and WPRs of 12–18. The maximum number of moles of hydrogen produced is 9.1 (925 K and WPR = 18). Under conditions that favour hydrogen production, methane and carbon formation can be eliminated to negligible level.     

Thermodynamic analysis of steam reforming and oxidative steam reforming of propane and butane for hydrogen production

Thermodynamic analyses of cracking, partial oxidation (POX), steam reforming (SR) and oxidative steam reforming (OSR) of butane and propane (for comparison) were performed using the Gibbs free energy minimization method under the reaction conditions of T = 250–1000 °C, steam-to-carbon ratio (S/C) of 0.5–5 and O₂/HC (hydrocarbon) ratio of 0–2.4. The simulations for the cracking and POX processes showed that olefins and acetylene can be easily generated through the cracking reactions and can be removed by adding an appropriate amount of oxygen. For SR and OSR of propane and butane, predicted carbon formation only occurred at low S/C ratios (<2) with the maximum level of carbon formation at 550–650 °C. For the thermal-neutral conditions, the TN temperatures decrease with the increase of the S/C ratio (except for O/C = 0.6) and the decrease of the O/C ratio. The simulated results for SR or OSR of propane and butane are very close under the investigated conditions.     

Hydrogen production through sorption enhanced steam reforming of natural gas: Thermodynamic plant assessment

A detailed and comprehensive simulation model of a H₂ production plant based on the Sorption Enhanced Reforming (SER) process of natural gas has been developed in this work. Besides thermodynamic advantages related to the shift of reforming equilibrium, SER technology features an intrinsic CO₂ capture that can be of interest in environmentally constrained economies. The model comprises natural gas treatment, H₂ and CO₂ compression, as well as H₂ purification with an adsorption unit that has been integrated within the SER process by using the off-gas for sorbent regeneration. A complete thermal integration has been also performed between the available hot gas streams in the plant, so that high pressure steam is generated and used to generate power in a steam cycle.     

Improvement of steam methane reforming via in-situ CO2 sorption over a nickel-calcium composite catalyst

Optimization of steam methane reforming (SMR) reaction by CO₂ sorption enhancement was investigated. In this study, the sorption-enhanced steam methane reforming reaction (SESMR) was conducted to maximize hydrogen production via suitable adjustments in the operating conditions of the reaction, which include the molar ratio of steam to CH₄, space velocity, and temperature. The reforming catalysts were prepared by a physical mixture of 20 wt% Ni/Al₂O₃ and CaO. The results reveal that there are significant differences in CH₄ conversion between the SMR and the SESMR from 18% to 108%; this conversion strongly depended on the reaction conditions. High-purity H₂ products (98.9%) with <0.1 ppmv CO were obtained by SESMR under the suitable conditions of 2600 cm³/g/h, steam/CH₄ molar ratio of 4 and 823 K. This implies that the high-quality H₂ produced through the SESMR process could be directly used for the proton-exchange membrane fuel cell.     

Hydrogen production by sorption enhanced steam reforming of oxygenated hydrocarbons (ethanol, glycerol, n-butanol and methanol): Thermodynamic modelling

Thermodynamic analysis of steam reforming of different oxygenated hydrocarbons (ethanol, glycerol, n-butanol and methanol) with and without CaO as CO₂ sorbent is carried out to determine favorable operating conditions to produce high-quality H₂ gas. The results indicate that the sorption enhanced steam reforming (SESR) is a fuel flexible and effective process to produce high-purity H₂ with low contents of CO, CO₂ and CH₄ in the temperature range of 723-873 K. In addition, the separation of CO₂ from the gas phase greatly inhibits carbon deposition at low and moderate temperatures. For all the oxygenated hydrocarbons investigated in this work, thermodynamic predictions indicate that high-purity hydrogen with CO content within 20 ppm required for proton exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) applications can be directly produced by a single-step SESR process in the temperature range of 723-773 K at pressures of 3-5 atm. Thus, further processes involving water-gas shift (WGS) and preferential CO oxidation (COPROX) reactors are not necessary. In the case of ethanol and methanol, the theoretical findings of the present analysis are corroborated by experimental results from literature. In the other cases, the results could provide an indication of the starting point for experimental research. At P = 5 atm and T = 773 K, it is possible to obtain H₂ at concentrations over 97 mol% along with CO content around 10 ppm and a thermal efficiency greater than 76%. In order to achieve such a reformate composition, the optimized steam-to-fuel molar ratios are 6:1, 9:1, 12:1 and 4:1 for ethanol, glycerol, n-butanol and methanol, respectively, with CaO in the stoichiometric ratio to carbon atom.     

Hydrogen production from bio-oil: A thermodynamic analysis of sorption-enhanced chemical looping steam reforming

The steam reforming of pyrolysis bio-oil is one proposed route to low carbon hydrogen production, which may be enhanced by combination with advanced steam reforming techniques. The advanced reforming of bio-oil is investigated via a thermodynamic analysis based on the minimisation of Gibbs Energy. Conventional steam reforming (C-SR) is assessed alongside sorption-enhanced steam reforming (SE-SR), chemical looping steam reforming (CLSR) and sorption-enhanced chemical looping steam reforming (SE-CLSR). The selected CO₂ sorbent is CaO(s) and oxygen transfer material (OTM) is Ni/NiO. PEFB bio-oil is modelled as a surrogate mixture and two common model compounds, acetic acid and furfural, are also considered. A process comparison highlights the advantages of sorption-enhancement and chemical looping, including improved purity and yield, and reductions in carbon deposition and process net energy balance.The operating regime of SE-CLSR is evaluated in order to assess the impact of S/C ratio, NiO/C ratio, CaO/C ratio and temperature. Autothermal operation can be achieved for S/C ratios between 1 and 3. In autothermal operation at 30 bar, S/C ratio of 2 gives a yield of 11.8 wt%, and hydrogen purity of 96.9 mol%. Alternatively, if autothermal operation is not a priority, the yield can be improved by reducing the quantity of OTM. The thermodynamic analysis highlights the role of advanced reforming techniques in enhancing the potential of bio-oil as a source of hydrogen.     

Comparative exergy analysis of sorption enhanced and conventional methane steam reforming

Exergy efficiency analysis tool is used to evaluate sorption enhanced steam reforming in comparison with the industrial hydrogen production route, steam reforming. The study focuses on hydrogen production for use in high pressure processes. Thermodynamic sensitivity analysis (effect of reforming temperature on hydrogen yield and reforming enthalpy) was performed to indicate the optimum temperature (650 °C) for the sorption enhanced reforming. The pressure was selected to be, for both cases, 25 bar, a typical pressure used in the industrial (conventional) process. Atmospheric pressure, 1000 °C and CO₂ as inert gas were specified as the optimum operating parameters for the regeneration of the sorbent after performing exergy efficiency analysis of three realistic case scenarios. Aspen Plus simulation process schemes were built for conventional and sorption enhanced steam reforming processes to attain the mass and energy balances required to assess comparatively exergy analysis. Simulation results showed that sorption enhanced reforming can lead to a hydrogen purity increase by 17.3%, along with the recovery of pure and sequestration-ready carbon dioxide. The exergy benefit of sorption enhanced reforming was calculated equal to 3.2%. Analysis was extended by adding a CO₂ separation stage in conventional reforming to reach the hydrogen purity of sorption enhanced reforming and enable a more effective exergy efficiency comparison. Following that analysis, sorption enhanced reforming gained 10.8% in exergy efficiency.     

Continuous high-purity hydrogen production by sorption enhanced steam reforming of ethanol over modified lithium silicate

Sorption-enhanced steam reforming of ethanol (SE-SRE) with in-situ CO₂ removal is an environmentally friendly and sustainable approach for hydrogen production. Researches on continuous production of high-purity H₂ by SE-SRE over the modified Li₄SiO₄ sorbent were conducted using two parallel reactor in this work. The low cost Li₄SiO₄ derived from rice husk ash (RHA) is a promising high-temperature CO₂ sorbent. However, the poor adsorption kinetics of RHA-Li₄SiO₄ sorbent at low CO₂ concentration is the major challenge. The metallic elements (K, Ca, Al, Mg) were employed to modify the RHA-Li₄SiO₄ for efficient CO₂ capture. The developed sorbents were characterized and tested to study the role of dopants on the crystal, textural, microstructure and CO₂ adsorption kinetics and cyclic stability. Results indicated that K doping effectively inhibited the growth of crystal aggregation and resulted in a fluffy morphology with abundant pores and higher specific surface area, while the addition of Ca, Al and Mg formed a nubby structure with larger particle size. K-doped RHA-Li₄SiO₄ exhibited the best CO₂ uptake properties and the optimal K doping molar content was 0.02 with the maximum capture capacity of 34.16 wt%, which is higher than 27.1 wt% of pure RHA-Li₄SiO₄. Then, the effect of operating conditions on the enhancement behaviors was considered in the SE-SRE system. High-purity H₂ (above 96%) was achieved by coupling K(0.02)/RHA-Li₄SiO₄ sorbent with Ni-based catalyst under the optimum condition (T: 525 °C, liquid hourly space velocity: 0.9 mL/(g·h), sorbent/catalyst: 4 and steam/carbon: 8.0). The adsorption activity of K(0.02)/RHA-Li₄SiO₄ maintained at a high level in ten SE-SRE/regeneration cycles. Finally, a scheme including two parallel fixed-bed reactors was designed and operated periodically for continuous production of high-purity H₂. The reaction switching time was shown to depend strongly on the pre-breakthrough time and operating conditions. As the reaction switching time was 40 min, the products were always only H₂ and CH₄ (no CO and CO₂ appear) and the H₂ purity remained above 90% during 400 min, confirming high purity hydrogen stream can be obtained continuously.     

Thermodynamic analysis of steam reforming of ethanol and glycerine for hydrogen production

In the past few years there has been a growing interest in environmentally clean renewable sources for hydrogen production. In this context new technologies have been developed for ethanol and glycerine reforming. Hydrogen production varies significantly according to the operating conditions such as pressure, temperature and feed reactants ratio. The thermodynamic analysis provides important knowledge about the effects of those variables on the process of ethanol and glycerine reforming. The present work was aimed at analyzing the thermodynamic steam reforming of ethanol and glycerine, using Gibbs free energy minimization using actual temperature and pressure data found in the literature. The nonlinear programming model was implemented in GAMS^® and the CONOPT2 solver was used to solve the equations. The ideality in gaseous phase and the formation of solid carbon was considered. The methodology used reproduced the most relevant papers involving experimental studies and thermodynamic analysis.     

Hydrogen production by sorption enhanced steam reforming of propane: A thermodynamic investigation

Thermodynamic features of hydrogen production by sorption enhanced steam reforming (SESR) of propane have been studied with the method of Gibbs free energy minimization and contrasted with propane steam reforming (SR). The effects of pressure (1-5 atm), temperature (700-1100 K) and water to propane ratio (WPR, 1-18) on equilibrium compositions and carbon formation are investigated. The results suggest that atmospheric pressure and a WPR of 12 are suitable for hydrogen production from both SR and SESR of propane. High WPR is favourable to inhibit carbon formation. The minimum WPR required to eliminate carbon production is 6 in both SR and SESR. The most favourable temperature for propane SR is approximately 950 K at which 1 mol of propane has the capacity to produce 9.1 mol of hydrogen. The optimum temperature for SESR is approximately 825 K, which is over 100 K lower than that for SR. Other key benefits include enhanced hydrogen production of nearly 10 mol (stoichiometric value) of hydrogen per mole of propane at 700 K, increased hydrogen purity (99% compared with 74% in SR) and no CO₂ or CO production with the only impurity being CH₄, all indicating a great potential of SESR of propane for hydrogen production.     

Dry and steam reforming of biomass pyrolysis gas for rich hydrogen gas

Biomass pyrolysis gas (including H₂, CO, CH₄, CO₂, C₂H₄, C₂H₆ and etc.) reforming for hydrogen production over Ni/Fe/Ce/Al₂O₃ catalysts was presented in this study. This study investigated how the operating conditions, such as the calcinations temperature of catalysts, the reaction temperature, the gas hourly space velocity (GHSV) and the ratio of H₂O/C, affect the conversion of CH₄ and CO₂ and the selectivity of hydrogen from dry and steam reforming of pyrolysis gas. The experimental results indicated that, under the conditions: the reaction temperature of 600 °C, the GHSV of 900 h⁻¹ and H₂O/C of 0.92, the reaction efficiency is the optimal. Especially, the concentration of H₂, CO, CH₄, CO₂, and C₂H_n (C₂H₄ and C₂H₆) were 36.80%, 10.48%, 9.61%, 42.62%, 0.49% respectively. The conversion of CH₄ and CO₂ reached 45.9% and 51.09%, respectively. There were all kinds of reactions during the processing of reforming of pyrolysis gas. And the main reactions changed with the operation condition. It was due to the promoting or inhibiting interaction among different constituents in the pyrolysis gas and the different activity of catalysts in the different operation condition.     

Thermodynamic and kinetic model of reforming coke-oven gas with steam

The experiments of reforming the methane of coke-oven gas with steam were performed. The effects of the thermodynamic factors, such as the H₂O/CH₄ ratio, the conversion temperature (T) of methane and the reaction time (t), on the methane conversion rate have been investigated. The experimental results show that the H₂O/CH₄ ratio within the range of 1.1–1.3 and the temperature 1223–1273 K are the reasonable thermodynamic conditions for methane conversion. A methane conversion of more than 95% can be achieved when the H₂O/CH₄ ratio is 1.2, the conversion temperature is above 1223 K and the conversion time is up to 15 s respectively. In additional, kinetic data of different reaction conditions were measured, and a dynamic model of methane conversion was proposed and verified. All results demonstrated that the results of the dynamic models agree well with the experiments, of which the deviation is less than 1.5%.     

Thermodynamic analysis of hydrogen production via glycerol steam reforming with CO2 adsorption

Thermodynamic equilibrium for glycerol steam reforming to hydrogen with carbon dioxide capture was investigated using Gibbs free energy minimization method. Potential advantage of using CaO as CO₂ adsorbent is to generate hydrogen-rich gas without a water gas shift (WGS) reactor for proton exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) application. The optimal operation conditions are at 900 K, the water-to-glycerol molar ratio of 4, the CaO-to-glycerol molar ratio of 10 and atmospheric pressure. Under the optimal conditions, complete glycerol conversion and 96.80% H₂ and 0.73% CO concentration could be achieved with no coke. In addition, reaction conditions for coke-free and coke-formed regions are also discussed in glycerol steam reforming with or without CO₂ separation. Glycerol steam reforming with CO₂ adsorption has the higher energy efficiency than that without adsorption under the same reaction conditions.     

Thermodynamic evaluation of hydrogen production for fuel cells by using bio-ethanol steam reforming: Effect of carrier gas addition

Omitting the influence of the addition of carrier gas to the reaction system for hydrogen production by bio-ethanol steam reforming can lead to wrong conclusions, especially when it is going to be made to scale. The effect of carrier gas addition to produce hydrogen using bio-ethanol steam reforming to feed fuel cells was evaluated. Thermodynamic calculations in equilibrium conditions were made, however the analysis derived from them can also be applied to kinetic conditions. These calculations were made by using the Aspen-HYSYS software at atmospheric pressure and different values of temperature, water/ethanol molar ratios, and inert (argon)/(water/ethanol) molar ratios. The addition of inert carrier gas modifies the concentrations of the reaction products in comparison to those obtained without its presence. This behavior occurs because most of the reactions which take place in bio-ethanol steam reforming have a positive difference of moles. This fact enhances the system sensitivity to inert concentration at low and moderated temperatures (<700 °C). At high values of temperature, the inert addition does not influence the composition of the reaction products because of the predominant effect of inverse WGS reaction.     

Assessment of CO2 capture options from various points in steam methane reforming for hydrogen production

Steam methane reforming (SMR) is currently the main hydrogen production process in industry, but it has high emissions of CO₂, at almost 7 kg CO₂/kg H₂ on average, and is responsible for about 3% of global industrial sector CO₂ emissions. Here, the results are reported of an investigation of the effect of steam-to-carbon ratio (S/C) on CO₂ capture criteria from various locations in the process, i.e. synthesis gas stream (location 1), pressure swing adsorber (PSA) tail gas (location 2), and furnace flue gases (location 3). The CO₂ capture criteria considered in this study are CO₂ partial pressure, CO₂ concentration, and CO₂ mass ratio compared to the final exhaust stream, which is furnace flue gases. The CO₂ capture number (N_cc) is proposed as measure of capture favourability, defined as the product of the three above capture criteria. A weighting of unity is used for each criterion. The best S/C ratio, in terms of providing better capture option, is determined. CO₂ removal from synthesis gas after the shift unit is found to be the best location for CO₂ capture due to its high partial pressure of CO₂. However, furnace flue gases, containing almost 50% of the CO₂ in produced in the process, are of great significance environmentally. Consequently, the effects of oxygen enrichment of the furnace feed are investigated, and it is found that this measure improves the CO₂ capture conditions for lower S/C ratios. Consequently, for an S/C ratio of 2.5, CO₂ capture from a flue gas stream is competitive with two other locations provided higher weighting factors are considered for the full presence of CO₂ in the flue gases stream. Considering carbon removal from flue gases, the ratio of hydrogen production rate and N_cc increases with rising reformer temperature.     

Thermodynamic equilibrium analysis of combined carbon dioxide reforming with steam reforming of methane to synthesis gas

Thermodynamics equilibrium analysis of carbon dioxide reforming of methane combined with steam reforming to synthesis gas was studied by Gibbs free energy minimization method to understand the effects of process variables such as temperature, pressure and inlet CH₄/H₂O/CO₂ ratios on product distributions. For this purpose, the calculations were carried out at total pressures of 1 and 20 bar, and at ranges of temperature and steam-to-carbon ratios of 200–1200 °C and 0–0.50, respectively. The results revealed that carbon dioxide reforming of methane combined with steam reforming process was controlled by different reactions with regard to the operating temperature, pressure and varying feed compositions. The H₂/CO product ratio could be modified by changing the relative concentration of steam and CO₂ in the feed, temperature and pressure, depending on the downstream application.     

The progress in water gas shift and steam reforming hydrogen production technologies – A review

Hydrogen has been widely considered a clean fuel of the future, with the highest mass based energy density of known fuels. Water gas shift (WGS) and steam reforming (SR) are the major reactions used for hydrogen production, and improved catalysts are essential to the future of the WGS and SR processes. Much progress in the different aspects of these fields has been made recently, which includes approaches to preparation and characterization, doping and promotion, as well as evaluation of catalysts, especially nanocatalysts. Significant improvements have been realized in increasing the stability of the catalysts, the overall conversion of raw materials, and the hydrogen production selectivity. This review aims to introduce these hydrogen production processes, to present developments in these areas, and discusses recent improvements that have made noteworthy impacts.     

Effect of Ni precursor salts on Ni-mayenite catalysts for steam methane reforming and on Ni-CaO-mayenite materials for sorption enhanced steam methane reforming

In view of climate change containment, sorption enhanced steam methane reforming (SESMR) appears as an interesting production route for H₂ with the additional advantage of CO₂ capture application performed by high-temperature solid sorbents. CaO is largely employed as CO₂ sorbent because of its low-cost mineralized forms (limestone and dolomite), of its high sorption capacity in the high temperature range compatible with steam methane reforming (SMR). Many recent studies have proposed purposely synthesized Ni-based reforming catalysts, used with high-temperature CO₂ solid sorbents, or combined sorbent-catalyst materials (CSCM). For this last purpose, we studied the effect of Ni salt precursor (Ni nitrate hexahydrate or Ni acetate tetrahydrate) on properties and reactivity of Ni-mayenite catalysts or Ni-CaO-mayenite CSCM, synthesized by an already validated sequence of wet mixing (for sorbents synthesis) and wet impregnation (for catalysts and CSCM synthesis) methods. Although Ni acetate tetrahydrate was often reported as the best choice to improve textural properties, our study identified Ni nitrate hexahydrate as a definitely more suitable precursor than Ni acetate tetrahydrate in the purpose of developing efficient materials for SESMR. The dissimilar behaviors observed in reforming reactivity are related and explained by the differences in textural properties, Ni species dispersion, and reducibility.