Characterization of eutectic Sn-Bi solder joints

This report presents experimental results on 58Bi-42Sn solder joints, optical and SEM microstructures of their matrix and of their interface with copper, solidification behavior studied by differential scanning calorimetry, wettability to copper, creep, and low cycle fatigue. These results are discussed in comparison with 60Sn-40Pb solder, and with three low temperature solders, 52In-48Sn, 43Sn-43Pb-14Bi, and 40In-40Sn-20Pb. The 58Bi-42Sn solder paste with RMA flux wets Cu matrix with a wetting angle of 35° and had a 15° C undercooling during solidification. The constitutive equation of the steady state shear strain rate, and the Coffin-Manson relation constants for the low cycle shear fatigue life at 65° C have been determined. The test results show that this solder has the best creep resistance but the poorest fatigue strength compared with the other four solders.     

Characterization of 63Sn37Pb and 80Au2OSn solder sealed opticalfiber feedthroughs subjected to repetitive thermal cycling

A highly accurate prediction of hermeticity lifetime is made for eutectic 63Sn37Pb and 80Au20Sn alloy solder sealed optical fiber-Kovar ^TM nosetube feedthroughs subjected to repetitive thermal cycling. Thermal fatigue fracture of the Sn-Pb solder/Kovar^TM interface develops when cracks, initially generated from creep deformation of the solder, propagate gradually through the junction in the axial direction. A nonlinear axisymmetric finite element analysis of the 63Sn37Pb fiber feedthrough seal is performed using a thermo-elastic creep constitutive equation, and solder joint fatigue based on accumulated strain energy associated with solder creep imposed by temperature cycling is analyzed. Additionally, thermal effective stress and plastic strain is studied for alternative 80Au20Sn solder by the finite element method with results indicating significant increase in useful life as compared to 63Sn37Pb. SEM/EDX metallurgical analysis of the solder/Ni-Au plated Kovar^TM nosetube interface indicates that AuSn₄ intermetallic formed during soldering with 63Sn37Pb also contributes to joint weakening, whereas no brittle intermetallic is observed for 80Au20Sn. Hermetic carbon coated optical fibers metallized with Ni,P-Ni underplate and electrolytic Au overplating exhibit correspondingly similar metallurgy at the solder/fiber interface. Combined hermeticity testing and metallurgical analysis carried out on 63Sn37Pb and 80Au20Sn alloy solder sealed optical fiber feedthroughs after repetitive temperature cycling between -65 and +150°C, and -40 and +125°C validated the analytical approach     

Superplastic creep of low melting point solder joints

In prior work, we showed that eutectic Sn-Pb solder joints exhibit superplastic behavior after rapid solidification. Further examples of superplasticity in nominally air-cooled solder joints are reported in this study of three low-melting point alloys: 40In-40Sn-20Pb (wt. %), eutectic 52In-48Sn, and 43Sn-43Pb-14Bi, which were creep-tested in shear at 20°, 65°, and 90° C. The test results indicate that above 65° C, the indium-containing solders have stress exponents between 2.4 to 2.9, a possible overall shear strains of 500%, and an absence of primary creep; at 90° C, 43Sn-43Pb-14Bi solder has a stress exponent close to 2.3. Optical microstructures of the three solders are presented; they help to explain the superplastic behavior.     

The creep and strain rate sensitivity of a high Pb content solder with comparisons to 60Sn/40Pb solder

Creep plays an important role in the mechanical behavior of solder alloys. This paper presents creep and strain rate sensitivity data for a Pb rich solder (92.5Pb, 2.5Ag, 5Sn-Indalloy 151) and compares it to the behavior of near eutectic 60Sn/40Pb solder. The high Pb alloy is used for exposures to higher temperatures than can be withstood by eutectic Sn/Pb solders. The Pb rich solder tested here is less strain rate sensitive than 60Sn/40Pb. There are also differences in the creep behavior.     

Metallurgical reactions in composite 90Pb10Sn/lead-free solder joints and their effect on reliability of LTCC/PWB assembly

Use of 90Pb10Sn solder as a noncollapsible sphere material with 95.5Sn 4Ag0.5Cu and SnInAgCu lead-free solders is investigated. Practical reflow conditions led to strong Pb dissolution into liquid solder, resulting in >20 at.% Pb content in the original lead-free solders. The failure mechanism of the test joints is solder cracking due to thermal fatigue, but the characteristic lifetime of 90Pb10Sn/SnInAgCu joints is almost double that of 90Pb10Sn/95.5Sn4Ag0.5Cu in a thermal cycling test (TCT) over the temperature range from −40°C to 125°C. It is predicted that this is mainly a consequence of the better fatigue resistance of the SnPbInAgCu alloy compared with the SnPbAgCu alloy. Indium accelerates the growth of the intermetallic compound (IMC) layer at the low temperature co-fired ceramic (LTCC) metallization/solder interface and causes coarsening of IMC particles during the TCT, but these phenomena do not have a major effect on the creep/fatigue endurance of the test joints.     

Microstructure evolution of gold-tin eutectic solder on Cu and Ni substrates

The microstructures of the eutectic Au20Sn (wt.%) solder that developed on the Cu and Ni substrates were studied. The Sn/Au/Ni sandwich structure (2.5/3.75/2 μm) and the Sn/Au/Ni sandwich structure (1.83/2.74/5.8 μm) were deposited on Si wafers first. The overall composition of the Au and the Sn layers in these sandwich structures corresponded to the Au20Sn binary eutectic. The microstructures of the Au20Sn solder on the Cu and Ni substrates could be controlled by using different bonding conditions. When the bonding condition was 290°C for 2 min, the microstructure of Au20Sn/Cu and Au20Sn/Ni was a two-phase (Au₅Sn and AuSn) eutectic microstructure. When the bonding condition was 240°C for 2 min, the AuSn/Au₅Sn/Cu and AuSn/Au₅Sn/Ni diffusion couples were subjected to aging at 240°C. The thermal stability of Au20Sn/Ni was better than that of Au20Sn/Cu. Moreover, less Ni was consumed compared to that of Cu. This indicates that Ni is a more effective diffusion barrier material for the Au20Sn solder.     

Isothermal aging effects on the microstructure and solder bump shear strength of eutectic Sn37Pb and Sn3.5Ag solders

The reliability of the eutectic Sn37Pb (63%Sn37%Pb) and Sn3.5Ag (96.5%Sn3.5%Ag) solder bumps with an under bump metallization (UBM) consisting of an electroless Ni(P) plus a thin layer of Au was evaluated following isothermal aging at 150 °C. All the solder bumps remained intact after 1500 h aging at 150 °C. Solder bump microstructure evolution and interface structure change during isothermal aging were observed and correlated with the solder bump shear strength and failure modes. Cohesive solder failure was the only failure mode for the eutectic Sn37Pb solder bump, while partial cohesive solder failure and partial Ni(P) UBM/Al metallization interfacial delamination was the main failure mode for eutectic Sn3.5Ag solder bump.     

Interfacial reaction between multicomponent lead-free solders and Ag,Cu, Ni,and Pd substrates

The interfacial reaction between two prototype multicomponent lead-free solders, Sn-3.4Ag-1Bi-0.7Cu-4In and Sn-3.4Ag-3Bi-0.7Cu-4In (mass%), and Ag, Cu, Ni, and Pd substrates are studied at 250°C and 150°C. The microstructural characterization of the solder bumps is carried out by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) coupled with energy dispersive x-ray analysis. Ambient temperature, isotropic elastic properties (bulk, shear, and Young’s moduli and Poisson’s ratio) of these solders along with eutectic Sn-Ag, Sn-Bi, and Sn-Zn solders are measured. The isotropic elastic moduli of multicomponent solders are very similar to the eutectic Sn-Ag solder. The measured solubility of the base metal in liquid solders at 250°C agrees very well with the solubility limits reported in assessed Sn-X (X=Ag, Cu, Ni, Pd) phase diagrams. The measured contact angles were generally less than 15° on Cu and Pd substrates, while they were between 25° and 30° on Ag and Ni substrates. The observed intermediate phases in Ag/solder couples were Ag₃Sn after reflow at 250°C and Ag₃Sn and ζ (Ag-Sn) after solid-state aging at 150°C. In Cu/solder and Ni/solder couples, the interfacial phases were Cu₆Sn₅ and (Cu,Ni)₆Sn₅, respectively. In Pd/solder couples, only PdSn₄ after 60-sec reflow, while both PdSn₄ and PdSn₃ after 300-sec reflow, were observed.     

Microstructure, creep properties, and failure mechanism of SnAgCu solder joints

The effect of microstructure on the creep properties and the failure mechanism of SnAgCu solder joints was studied. Single overlap shear specimens made of FR-4 printed circuit boards (PCBs) with organic solderability preservative (OSP), NiAu, and immersion Sn surface finish were reflow-soldered with hypoeutectic, eutectic, and hypereutectic SnAgCu solder paste. Creep tests of the solder joints were performed at 85°C and 105°C under constant load. The effect of microstructure on the creep behavior of the joints was studied by examining the fracture surfaces and cross-sectional samples of the tested joints. Results show that the intermetallic compound at the interface between the PCB and solder affects the fracture behavior of SnAgCu solder joints, thus creating a significant difference in the creep properties of solder joints on different surface finishes. Composition of SnAgCu solder was also found to affect the creep properties of the joints.     

Residual-mechanical behavior of thermomechanically fatigued Sn-Ag based solder joints

Thermomechanical fatigue (TMF) due to the mismatch in coefficients of thermal expansion between solder and substrate gradually degrades the mechanical properties of electronic solder joints during service. This study investigated the role of TMF on the residual-mechanical behavior of solder joints made with eutectic Sn-Ag solder and Sn-Ag solder with Cu or Ni additions. The TMF tests were carried out between −15°C and +150°C with a ramp rate of 25°C/min for the heating segment and 7°C/min for the cooling segment. The hold times were 20 min at the high extreme and 300 min at the low extreme. Residual shear strength was found to drop significantly during the first 250 TMF cycles, although it did remain relatively constant between 250 and 1000 cycles. Alloying elements were found to affect the residual creep strength of solder joints after TMF.     

Influence of microstructure size on the plastic deformation kinetics, fatigue crack growth rate, and low-cycle fatigue of solder joints

The influence of microstructure size on the plastic deformation kinetics, fatigue crack growth rate and low-cycle fatigue of eutectic Sn-Pb solder joints is reviewed. The principal microstructure feature considered is the average eutectic phase size d=(d_Pb+d_Sn)/2. The effect of an increase in reflow cooling rate (which gave a decrease in d) on the flow stress and on fatigue life was irregular at 300K, depending on the stress or strain level and cooling rate. In contrast, a consistent increase in fatigue life with decrease in d occurred for thermomechanical cycling between −30° and 130°C. Constitutive equations for plastic deformation and fatigue crack growth rate are presented which include the microstructure size. It appears that the rate-controlling deformation mechanism is the intersection of forest dislocations in the Sn phase. The mechanism for both static and dynamic phase coarsening appears to be grain boundary diffusion with a t^1/4 time law. Some success has been achieved in predicting the cyclic stress-strain hysteresis loops and fatigue life, including the influence of the as-reflowed microstructure size and its coarsening. Additional definitive studies are however needed before we can accurately predict the fatigue life of solder joints over the wide temperature range and conditions experienced by electronic packages.     

Study of electromigration in eutectic SnPb solder stripes using the edge displacement method

Electromigration (EM) parameters in the eutectic SnPb solder were measured using the edge displacement method (EDM) and an atomic force microscope (AFM) in the temperature range of 60° to 140°C. The measured drift velocity was found to be 0.3 Å/sec when the solder stripe was stressed under 4.9×10⁴ A/cm² at 80°C, and it increased as the current density or the temperature increased. The products of DZ* at 60°C, 80°C, 100°C, 120°C, and 140°C were also obtained. In addition, the EM activation energy was determined to be 0.45 eV at the temperature range 60–100°C and 0.55 eV at the temperature range 100–140°C. These two activation energies may correspond to the Sn and Pb diffusion at the two temperature ranges. These values are very fundamental to current-carrying capability and mean-time-to-failure measurement for solder joints.     

Effects of cooling rate on creep behavior of a Sn-3.5Ag alloy

The effect of cooling rate on microstructure and creep behavior of bulk, eutectic Sn-3.5Ag solders was studied. The cooling rate is an important processing variable that significantly affects the microstructure of the solder and therefore determines its mechanical behavior. Controlled cooling rates were obtained by cooling specimens in different media: water, air, and furnace, which resulted in cooling rates of 24°C/s, 0.5°C/s, and 0.08°C/s, respectively. The cooling rate decreased the secondary dendrite arm size and the spacing of the Sn-rich phase, as well as the morphology of Ag₃Sn. The Sn-dendrite arm size and spacing were smaller at fast cooling rates, while slower cooling rates yielded a nearly eutectic microstructure. The morphology of Ag₃Sn also changed from relatively spherical, at faster cooling rates, to needlelike for slower cooling. The effect of cooling rate on creep behavior was studied at 25°C, 60°C, 95°C, and 120°C. Faster cooling rates were found to increase the creep strength of the solder due to the refinement of the solder microstructure. Stress exponents, n, indicated that dislocation climb was the controlling mechanism. Activation energies, for all cooling rates, indicated that the dominant diffusional mechanism corresponded to dislocation pipe diffusion of Sn. Grain boundary sliding (GBS) measurements were conducted, using both scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM). It was observed that GBS had a very small contribution to the total creep strain.     

Tensile creep and microstructural characterization of bulk Sn3.9Ag0.6Cu lead-free solder

The microstructural and creep behavior of bulk 63SnPb37 and the Pb-free solder alloy Sn3.9Ag0.6Cu are reported and compared. The Sn3.9Ag0.6Cu alloy showed much lower absolute creep rates than 63SnPb37. The size and distribution of the intermetallic compound (IMC) coarsened with increasing creep temperature. A number of coarsened precipitates of Cu₆Sn₅ segregate around β-Sn grain boundaries. After creep at 80°C and 115°C. the β-Sn particles in the Sn3.9Ag0.6Cu alloy are strongly aligned at approximately 45° to the uniaxial tension, parallel to the maximum shear-stress planes. The powerlaw-defined stress exponent significantly increases with increasing stress in both the 63Sn37Pb and Sn3.9Ag0.6Cu alloys; therefore, the Dorn model is unsuitable for these materials over large stress and temperature ranges. Both sets of experimental data were successfully fit with the present power-law stress-dependent energy-barrier model and the Garofalo model. However, the application of the present power-law stress-dependent energy model resulted in a significantly lower estimated variance as compared to the Garofalo model.     

Creep behavior of the ternary 95.5Sn-3.9Ag-0.6Cu solder: Part II—Aged condition

Compression creep tests were performed on the 95.5Sn-3.9Ag-0.6Cu (wt.%) solder. The specimens were aged prior to testing at 125°C, 24 h or 150°C, 24 h. Applied stresses were 2–40 MPa. Test temperatures were −25°C to 160°C. The 125°C, 24-h aging treatment caused the formation of coarsened Ag₃Sn particle boundaries within the larger ternary-eutectic regions. The 150°C, 24-h aging treatment resulted in contiguous Ag₃Sn boundaries in the ternary-eutectic regions as well as a general coarsening of Ag₃Sn particles. The 125°C, 24-h aging treatment had only a small effect on the strain-time curves vis-à-vis the as-cast condition. Negative creep was observed at 75°C for time periods >10⁵ sec and stresses of 3–10 MPa. The creep kinetics exhibited a sinh term (stress) exponent, p, of 5.3±0.6 and an apparent-activation energy, ΔH, of 49±5 kJ/mol when data from all test temperatures were included. A good data correlation was observed over the [−25–125°C] temperature regime. Steady-state creep kinetics exhibited a greater variability in the [125–160°C] regime because of the simultaneous coarsening of Ag₃Sn particles. The aging treatment of 150°C for 24 h resulted in a more consistent stress dependence and better reproducibility of the creep curves. Negative creep was observed in samples aged at 150°C for 24 h when tested at −25°C, 25°C, and 75°C. The values of p and ΔH were 4.9±0.3 kJ/mol and 6±5 kJ/mol, respectively. Only a slight improvement in the data correlation was observed when the analysis examined separated [−25−75°C] and [75–166°C] temperature regimes. Creep testing did not cause observable deformation in any of the sample microstructures.     

Microstructure and shear strength evolution of SnAg/Cu surface mount solder joint during aging

The effect of aging at 150°C on the microstructure and shear strength of SnAg/Cu surface mount solder joint has been investigated with comparison to 62Sn36Pb2Ag/Cu. It is found that the diffusion coefficient of intermetallic compounds at SnAg/Cu interface is smaller than that of intermetallic compounds at SnPbAg/Cu interface at 150°. The shear strength of SnAg solder joint is higher and decreases at a smaller rate during aging compared to that of SnPbAg solder joint. The fracture surface analysis shows that as the aging time increases, the fracture takes place along the solder/Cu₆Sn₅ interface with an extension toward the Sn−Cu intermetallic layer.     

The effect of small additions of copper on the aging kinetics of the intermetallic layer and intermetallic particles of eutectic tin-silver solder joints

The effects of small additions of copper to the aging kinetics of eutectic tin-silver solder joints were studied. Aging of joints made with tin-silver solder containing 0.5% and 0.7% copper was carried out at various temperatures ranging to 180°C, at various times ranging to 4000 h. The small differences in the compositions of the two types of solder alloys studied did not produce any significant differences in the aging kinetics of the intermetallic layer, although a noticeable difference in the aging kinetics of the Ag₃Sn particles present in the solder was observed. The growth rates of all intermetallics present in the solder joint were insignificant below 120°C. The results obtained were compared to earlier aging experiments involving eutectic tin-silver solder without any copper. It was found that the activation energy of the Cu₆Sn₅ intermetallic layer growth was about 10% less in the tin-silver solder joints with the small additions of copper added to the composition. Copper from the substrate tended to diffuse through the Cu-Sn intermetallic layer faster than tin from the solder.     

Accelerated thermal fatigue of lead-free solder joints as a function of reflow cooling rate

Leadless chip resistor (LCR) assemblies were manufactured using both traditional tin-lead (Sn37Pb) and lead-free (Sn3.8Ag0.7Cu) solders. The leadfree test vehicles were assembled using three different cooling rates: 1.6°C/sec, 3.8°C/sec, and 6.8°C/sec. They were then exposed to accelerated thermalcycling (ATC) tests between 0°C and 100°C with a 10–14°C/min ramp rate and a 5-min dwell time. The test results indicated that these lead-free solder joints had better creep-fatigue performance than the tin-lead solder joints. The LCR built with the medium cooling rate showed the longest fatigue life compared with the resistors built with the normal cooling rate of 1.6°C/sec and the higher cooling rate 6.8°C/sec. The number of cycles to failure was significantly correlated to the void defect rate. Failure analyses were done using cross-sectioning methods and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Finite-element models were built to analyze the inelastic, equivalent strain range in solder joints subjected to thermal-cycling conditions with different degrees of solder wetting. The results indicated that poor wetting increases strains throughout the joint significantly, which is in accordance with the ATC results.     

Finite element modeling of thermal fatigue and damage of solder joints in a ceramic ball grid array package

A nonlinear finite element model is presented for analyzing the cyclic and thermal fatigue loading and for viscoplastic damage characterization of the lead-tin (Pb-Sn) solder joints in a ceramic ball grid array (CBGA) surface mount package. An approach using a Δ ∈ _eq ⁱⁿ -modified Coffin-Manson equation is proposed to estimate the fatigue life of the solder joints. The Δ ∈ _eq ⁱⁿ represents a saturated equivalent inelastic strain range as determined by the finite element model. The present study shows that the predictied fatigue life and the associated damage mechanism of the solder joint agree reasonably well with the test data for the 18,25, and 32 mm CBGA packages run at a cyclic temperature load of 0°C/100°C with a frequency of 1.5 cycles per hour. Analysis also shows that a preferred failure site is expected to occur in and around the Pb37-Sn63 solder attachment of the solder joint. A time-dependent (creep induced) damage mechanism is found to be more pronounced than the time-independent (plastic deformation) mechanism.     

Microstructure and shear strength of Sn37Pb/Cu solder joints subjected to isothermal aging

The effects of isothermal aging on the microstructure and shear strength of Sn37Pb/Cu solder joints were investigated. Single-lap shear solder joints of eutectic Sn37Pb solder were aged for 1–10 days at 120 °C and 170 °C, respectively, and then loaded to failure in shear with a constant loading speed of 5 × 10⁻³ mm/s. The growth of the interfacial Cu–Sn intermetallic compounds (IMC) layer (Cu₆Sn₅ + Cu₃Sn) of Sn37Pb/Cu solder joints subjected to isothermal aging exhibited a linear function of the square root of aging time, indicating that the formation of Cu–Sn IMC was mainly controlled by the diffusion mechanism. And the diffusion coefficient (D) values of IMC layer were 1.07 × 10⁻¹⁷ and 3.72 × 10⁻¹⁷ m²/s for aged solder joints at 120 °C and 170 °C, respectively. Shear tests results revealed that as-reflowed solder joint had better shear strength than the aged solder joints and the shear strength of all aged solder joints decreased with increasing aging time. The presence of elongated dimple-like structures on the fracture surfaces of these as-reflowed or aged for short time solder joints were indicative of a ductile failure mode. As aging time further increased, the solder joints fractured in the mixed solder/IMC mode at the solder/IMC interface.