In-Plane Seismic Response of URM Walls Upgraded with FRP

Recent earthquakes have shown the vulnerability of unreinforced masonry (URM) buildings, which have led to an increasing demand for techniques to upgrade URM buildings. Fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) can provide an upgrading alternative for URM buildings. This paper presents results of dynamic tests investigating the in-plane behavior of URM walls upgraded with FRP (URM-FRP). These tests represent pioneer work in this area (dynamic and in-plane). Five half-scale walls were built, using half-scale brick clay units, and upgraded on one face only. Two moment/shear ratios (1.4 and 0.7), two mortar types (M2.5 and M9), three composite materials (carbon, aramid, and glass), three fiber structures (plates, loose fabric, and grids), and two upgrading configurations (diagonal “X” and full surface shapes) were investigated. The test specimens were subjected to a series of synthetic earthquake motions with increasing intensities on a uniaxial earthquake simulator. The tests validate the effectiveness of the one side upgrading: the upgrading technique improved the lateral resistance of the URM walls by a factor ranging from 1.3 to 2.9; however, the improvement in the lateral drift was less significant. Moreover, no uneven response was observed during the test due to the single side upgrading. Regarding the upgrading configurations, the bidirectional surface type materials (fabrics and grids) applied on the entire surface of the wall (and correctly anchored) can help postpone the three classic failure modes of masonry walls: rocking (“flexural failure”), step cracking, and sliding (“shear failures”). Additionally, in some situations, they will postpone collapse by “keeping the bricks together” under large seismic deformations. On the other hand, the diagonal “X” shape was less successful and premature failure was developed during the test.     

Flexural Capacity of Glass FRP Strengthened Concrete Masonry Walls

Fiber-reinforced polymers (FRP) can provide a strengthening alternative for unreinforced and underreinforced masonry. The ease with which FRP can be installed on the exterior of a masonry wall makes this form of strengthening attractive to the owner, considering both reduced installation cost and down time of the occupied structure. Six unreinforced concrete masonry walls (four at 1.8 m tall and two at 4.7 m tall) were tested in out-of-plane flexure up to capacity. The walls were strengthened with glass FRP composite composed of unidirectional E-glass fabric with an epoxy matrix. The composite was adhered to the surface of the masonry using the same epoxy with the fibers oriented perpendicular to the bed joints. General flexural strength design equations are presented and compared with the results of the testing. It was found that the equations overpredicted the actual capacity of the test specimens by no more than 20%.     

Load-Displacement of Masonry Panels with Unbonded and Intermittently Bonded FRP. I: Analytical Model

An experimental study was carried out to develop and test innovative fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) rehabilitation techniques that meet the stringent requirements of restoration of historical buildings and are cost-effective alternatives applicable to existing masonry structures. In these techniques, FRP reinforcement was either unbonded or intermittently bonded to the masonry wall. In order to analyze performance, extend the range of the investigated parameters, and define limitations, a simplified analytical model was developed to predict the postcracking lateral load-displacement response under biaxial bending. The response of the retrofitted walls cannot be modeled by conventional approaches. The proposed model is based on balancing internal and external work and rigid body mechanics. It is assumed that all postcracking deformations take place at cracks between wall subpanels. Postcracking displacements are calculated from rotation rather than curvature. The adequacy of the model was verified by comparisons with the experimental results and a good agreement was found. The model could be used as the basis for a design method.     

FRP-Retrofitted URM Walls under In-Plane Shear: Review and Assessment of Available Models

In the last two decades, several seismic retrofitting techniques for masonry structures have been developed and practiced and fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) material has been increasingly used owing to its high strength/stiffness to mass ratio and easy application. Although much research has been carried out on FRP strengthening of unreinforced masonry (URM) structures, most of it has been experimental studies to investigate the effectiveness of retrofitting techniques rather than the development of a rational design model. In addition, more research has been conducted on FRP-retrofitted URM walls under out-of-plane loads where flexural behavior dominates, the research on the shear strength of FRP-retrofitted URM walls has been limited. This paper presents a review of research in this area. Existing retrofitting techniques are overviewed, followed by a detailed discussion of experimental results of failure modes as they are directly related to the design model. The available design models are then assessed based on a test database collected from the available literature. Limitations of each model are addressed.     

Static Cyclic Response of Masonry Walls Retrofitted with Fiber-Reinforced Polymers

The behavior of seven one-half scale masonry specimens before and after retrofitting using fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) is investigated. Four walls were built using one-half scale hollow clay masonry units and weak mortar to simulate walls built in central Europe in the mid-20th century. Three walls were first tested as unreinforced masonry walls; then, the seismically damaged specimens were retrofitted using FRPs. The fourth wall was directly upgraded after construction using FRP. Each specimen was retrofitted on the entire surface of a single side. All the specimens were tested under constant gravity load and incrementally increasing in-plane loading cycles. The tested specimens had two effective moment/shear ratio, namely, 0.5 and 0.7. The key parameter was the amount of FRP axial rigidity, which is defined as the amount of FRP reinforcement ratio times its E modulus. The single-side retrofitting/upgrading significantly improved the lateral strength, stiffness, and energy dissipation of the test specimens. The increase in the lateral strength was proportional to the amount of FRP axial rigidity. However, using high amount of FRP axial rigidity led to very brittle failure. Finally, simple existing analytical models estimated the ultimate lateral strengths of the test specimens reasonably well.     

Assessment of Design Formulas for In-Plane FRP Strengthening of Masonry Walls

Masonry structures have demonstrated their seismic vulnerability during recent world seismic events. This paper investigates in-plane seismic performance of unreinforced masonry (URM) walls before and after they are retrofit using fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) materials. An assessment of available design formulas for evaluating both the in-plane performance of URM walls and the contribution of FRP strengthening systems was performed. Walls with two configurations of the FRP reinforcement have been analyzed: one based on FRP strips installed parallel to the mortar joints, the other characterized by FRP strips arranged along the diagonals of the wall. Based on shear–compression tests carried out on FRP-strengthened masonry walls available in the literature, a comparison between theoretical and experimental data is performed. A discussion about the FRP strains at failure of the walls is provided and values of effective FRP strains to be used for design purposes are proposed.     

Ductile Anchorage for Connecting FRP Strengthening of Under-Reinforced Masonry Buildings

Fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites have been examined as a convenient and cost-effective means of strengthening unreinforced masonry structures. Seismic design in the United States is almost entirely based on the assumption that the structural system provides a ductile failure mode. FRP strengthened masonry walls inherently have brittle failure modes due to the nature of the strengthening system. The concept explored in this article is the introduction of ductility using a hybrid strengthening system. This involves the placement of structural steel or reinforcing steel at critical locations in the lateral force resisting system. This article presents the testing and analysis of a ductile structural steel connection that can be used to strengthen the connection of FRP strengthened shear walls to the foundation. The connection also increases energy dissipation. Results indicate that a ductile failure mode can be attained when the connection is designed to yield prior to the failure of the FRP strengthening.     

Strengthening of Unreinforced Masonry Walls Using FRPs

An experimental program conducted at the University of Alberta showed that externally applied fiber reinforced polymers (FRPs) are effective in increasing the load-carrying capacity of unreinforced masonry walls that are subjected to out-of-plane flexural loads. Ten walls with a height of 4 m were used to conduct 13 tests in two series. Both undamaged and slightly damaged walls were tested. The following experimental parameters were investigated: (1) type of fiber reinforcement; (2) amount of fiber reinforcement; (3) layout of fiber reinforcement; (4) effects of moderate compressive axial load; and (5) cyclic behavior. This paper briefly reviews the existing rehabilitation methods available and explains why the use of FRPs as external reinforcement is a possible alternative. The test setup and instrumentation of the specimens are described followed by a discussion of the results. The general behavior of the specimens is discussed with emphasis on the load deflection and strain characteristics. The modes of failure are identified and categorized. Finally, a simple analytical model is proposed and compared with the test results followed by a summary of the major results.     

Behavior of FRP Strengthened Infill Walls under In-Plane Seismic Loading

The present paper investigates the suitability and effectiveness of fiber-reinforced polymers (FRP) in strengthening and/or repairing unreinforced masonry infill walls in reinforced concrete frames which are subjected to in-plane seismic/cyclic loading. For this purpose, a detailed experimental program was conducted. Specimen geometry, test setup, instrumentation, and a loading procedure that simulates earthquake loading are presented in a detailed fashion. Results of experimental observations are discussed in the form of load-displacement hysteretic loops and envelopes; column profiles; strain diagrams, and wall shear distortion. The test results, in general, indicate that the use of glass FRP (GFRP) sheets as strengthening materials provides a degree of enhancement to the infill wall, upgrades its deformation capacity, and makes the wall work as one unit. These results thus show great potential for externally bonded GFRP sheets in upgrading and strengthening the infill walls under in-plane seismic loads.     

Out-of-Plane Strengthening of Masonry Walls with Reinforced Composites

This paper presents an investigation into the effectiveness of using fiber-reinforced composite overlays to strengthen existing unreinforced masonry walls to resist out-of-plane static loads. A total of fifteen wall panels [1,200 × 1,800 × 200 mm (4 ft × 6 ft × 8 in.)] were tested. Twelve panels were assembled with fiber-reinforcing systems attached to the tension side, and the remaining three control walls were left without any external reinforcement. Two configurations of external reinforcement were evaluated. The first reinforcement configuration consisted of two layers of fiber-reinforced plastic webbing and the second consisted of vertical and horizontal bands of undirectional fiber composites. The three wall specimens without external reinforcement were tested to evaluate the change in the system strength and behavior with application of the external reinforcing systems. In addition to the two fiber configurations, the testing program also evaluated two methods of surface preparation of the walls, sand blasting, and wire brush. All specimens were thoroughly washed by water jet, 48 hours prior to application of the fiber-reinforcing systems. Three specimens were tested for each variable. A uniformly distributed lateral load was applied to each panel using the procedures described in the ASTM Standard E-72 Test Method (airbag). Failure loads, strains in the external reinforcement (FRP), out-of-plane deformations, and failure modes were recorded. Recommendations on the usefulness of the proposed technique as a means of strengthening masonry walls for out-of-plane loads are presented. In general, flexural strength of masonry walls can be increased if the shear failure is controlled.     

Strengthening of Infill Masonry Walls with FRP Materials

This paper evaluates the effectiveness of different externally bonded glass fiber–reinforced polymer (GFRP) systems for increasing the out-of-plane resistance of infill masonry walls to loading. The research included a comprehensive experimental program comprising 14 full-scale specimens, including four unstrengthened (control) specimens and 10 strengthened specimens. To simulate the boundary conditions of infill walls, all specimens consisted of a reinforced concrete (RC) frame, simulating the supporting RC elements of a building superstructure, which was infilled with solid concrete brick masonry. The specimens were loaded out-of-plane using uniformly distributed pressure to simulate the differential (suction) pressure induced by a tornado. Parameters investigated in the experimental program included aspect ratio, FRP coverage ratio, number of masonry wythes, and type of FRP anchorage. Test results indicated that the type of FRP anchorage had a significant effect on the failure mode. Research findings concluded that GFRP strengthening of infill masonry walls is effective in increasing the out-of-plane load-carrying capacity when proper anchorage of the FRP laminate is provided.     

Masonry Wall Crack Control with Carbon Fiber Reinforced Polymer

Restrained shrinkage is a major source of damage to buildings. By the combination of different construction materials, or through different conditions of exposure of different structural elements, differential dimensional change occurs. Thereby, stresses arise, which can cause cracking. In recent combined experimental and numerical research projects, this source of damage to masonry walls has been confirmed. The ability has been developed to predict the level of damage computationally. This paper addresses a method to reduce the width of cracks in masonry walls subjected to restrained shrinkage, to acceptable levels. Crack control by externally applied carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP) reinforcement is studied. Although structural strengthening by CFRP reinforcement is actively researched, its application here to preserve structural serviceability is novel. An experiment was designed and performed to study the response of an unreinforced masonry wall to restrained shrinkage. Subsequently, the wall was repaired and reinforced on one face with CFRP strips. The required CFRP reinforcement was designed by finite element analysis, which also served as prediction of the response of the reinforced wall to restrained shrinkage.     

Behavior of Composite Unreinforced Masonry–Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Wall Assemblages Under In-Plane Loading

An experimental investigation was conducted to study the in-plane behavior of face shell mortar bedded unreinforced masonry (URM) wall assemblages retrofitted with fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) laminates. Forty-two URM assemblages were tested under different stress conditions present in masonry shear and infill walls. Tests included prisms loaded in compression with different bed joint orientation (on/off-axis compression), diagonal tension specimens, and specimens loaded under joint shear. The behavior of each specimen type is discussed with emphasis on modes of failure, strength and deformation characteristics. Results showed that the application of FRP laminates on URM has a great influence on strength, postpeak behavior, as well as altering failure modes and maintaining the specimen integrity. The retrofitted specimens reached compressive strength of 1.62–5.64 times that of their unretrofitted counterparts, depending on the bed joint orientation, and joint shear strength increased by eightfold.     

Structural Upgrading of Masonry Columns by Using Composite Reinforcements

Emerging techniques that use fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites for strengthening and conservation of historic masonry are becoming increasingly accepted. In the last decades steel plates or wood frames were used for external confinement in containing the lateral dilation of masonry columns subjected to axial loads. In the last years FRP epoxy bonded strips or jackets were also employed to increase strength and ductility with encouraging results in terms of mechanical behavior and cost effectiveness. The behavior of masonry columns confined with FRP and subjected to axial compression is studied in this paper. An extended experimental investigation is presented in order to show the mechanical behavior of circular masonry columns built with calcareous blocks that may be commonly found in Italy and all over Europe in historical buildings. Different stacking schemes were used to build the columns, aiming to simulate the most common situations in existing masonry structures. Carbon FRP sheets were applied as external reinforcement; different amounts and different schemes of confining reinforcement were studied. The experiments include a new reinforcement technique made by using injected FRP bars through the columns cross section. Such a solution can be considered in place of a more traditional confinement, when external reinforcement must be avoided, or in addition to external reinforcement when an improved confinement effect is required. The structural behavior of masonry columns damaged under different levels of load and strengthened by using FRP reinforcements, was also investigated. Experimental results revealed the effectiveness of the FRP confinement for masonry columns, also for columns that were strongly predamaged before strengthening. A computation of the ultimate load was conducted using the Italian National Research Council recommendations to show an application of the design approach recently proposed in Italy. An existing analytical model, previously developed by the writers, was applied for computation of expected experimental values.     

Blast Resistance of FRP-Strengthened Masonry Walls. I: Approximate Analysis and Field Explosion Tests

An approximate analysis method is proposed to determine the blast resistance of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP)-strengthened masonry walls. The method relates the static to dynamic response by incorporating the strain rate effect on the material strength and a dynamic load factor for the applied peak load. Based on the method, 18 full-scale masonry walls reinforced with three different FRP systems were designed and subjected to field explosions, using charges of 27-ton TNT in one test and 5-ton TNT in the other. For each test, the walls were placed at three different standoff distances and orientations to the blast source. The response of the strengthened walls under blast was monitored by high-speed data acquisition systems. Post-test observations indicated no visible damage, crack, or debonding in any of the walls, thus confirming the effectiveness of the FRP retrofit technique in blast protection. The data presented are valuable for validation of analytical or numerical models.     

Experimental Response of Externally Retrofitted Masonry Walls Subjected to Shear Loading

Recent earthquakes have produced extensive damage in a large number of existing masonry buildings, demonstrating the need for retrofitting masonry structures. Externally bonded carbon fiber is a retrofitting technique that has been used to increase the strength of reinforced concrete elements. Sixteen full-scale shear dominant clay brick masonry walls, six with wire-steel shear reinforcement, were retrofitted with two configurations of externally bonded carbon fiber strips and subjected to shear loading. The results of the experimental program showed that the strength of the walls could be increased 13–84%, whereas, their displacement capacity increased 51–146%. This paper presents an analysis of the experimental results and simple equations to estimate the cracking load and the maximum shear strength of clay brick masonry walls, retrofitted with carbon fiber.     

Strengthening of Masonry Walls against Out-of-Plane Loads Using Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Reinforcement

Thirty masonry walls strengthened using three different fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) systems, with three anchorage methods, were fabricated and tested under a concentrated load over a 100 mm square area or a patch load over a 500 mm square area. The test results indicated a significant increase in the out-of-plane wall strength over the unstrengthened wall. While failure occurred in the unstrengthened wall by bending, four different modes of failure, that is, punching shear through the bricks, debonding of FRP reinforcement from the masonry substrate, crushing of brick in compression, and tensile rupture of the FRP reinforcement, were observed in the strengthened walls, depending on the types and configurations of FRP and anchorage systems. With appropriate surface preparation and anchorage systems, premature failure due to FRP debonding is prevented. Based on the principles of strain compatibility and force equilibrium, simple analytical models are presented to predict the ultimate load-carrying capacity of the strengthened walls. The test results compared well with the analytical predictions.     

In-Plane Shear Behavior of Masonry Panels Strengthened with NSM CFRP Strips. I: Experimental Investigation

An experimental investigation was conducted to study the in-plane shear behavior of masonry panels strengthened with near-surface mounted (NSM) carbon fiber-reinforced polymer strips (CFRP). As part of the study four unreinforced masonry panels and seven strengthened panels were tested in diagonal tension/shear. Different reinforcement orientations were used including vertical, horizontal, and a combination of both. The effect of nonsymmetric reinforcement was also studied. The results of these tests are presented in this paper, and include the load-displacement behaviors, crack patterns, failure modes, and FRP strains. The results showed that the vertically aligned reinforcement was the most effective, with significant increases in strength and ductility observed. The dowel strength of the vertical reinforcement did not likely contribute significantly to the shear resistance of the masonry. Instead, it was likely that the vertical reinforcement acted in tension to restrain shear induced dilation and restrain sliding. In some panels cracking adjacent to the FRP strip, through the panel thickness was observed. This type of cracking reduced the bond between one side of the FRP strip and the masonry, and led to premature debonding. A comparison of the test results with the results of other tests from the literature is also presented in this paper.     

Wind Damage to Masonry Buildings

An examination has been made of the methods of construction of masonry‐walled buildings, and their performance in severe windstorms. Particular emphasis was placed on low‐rise buildings using unreinforced concrete block walls and light roofs, which suffer the majority of wind damage. It is shown that traditionally built, nonengineered buildings have become more wind sensitive in recent years as the result of a reduction in the number of internal walls and a lowering of roof weights. Empirical design procedures regarding wall height‐to‐thickness ratios and roof anchorage have not changed to reflect this increased sensitivity, leaving many modern, nonengineered buildings with insufficient wind resistance. Professionally designed structures often have a similar structural form to traditionally built structures, since the same empirical design rules are often used to size walls and roof anchors. The longer roof spans in these buildings render them even more sensitive to wind uplift loads, and subject to progressive collapse. The inadequacies of present building code requirements are discussed and recommendations for improvements are made.     

Modeling Out-of-Plane Behavior of URM Walls Retrofitted with Fiber Composites

Although masonry is one of the oldest construction materials, its behavior has not been investigated as extensively as other construction materials. Out-of-plane failures are common in unreinforced masonry (URM) buildings constructed in seismic regions. Seven half-scale brick masonry walls were constructed, externally strengthened with vertical glass-fabric composite strips, and subjected to static cyclic out-of-plane loading. The flexural behavior of the tested specimens is characterized by three main stages corresponding to the first visible bed-joint crack, the first delamination, and the ultimate load. The main parameters being investigated in this study are the amount of composite, the height-to-thickness ratio h∕t, the tensile strain in composites, and the mode of failure. Based on the trends observed in the experimental phase, it was concluded that the behavior of the walls is best predicted with a linear elastic approach. It was also concluded that the ultimate strength method overestimates the flexural capacity and the ultimate deflection of the wall. Preliminary design recommendations are also proposed for tensile strain in the composite, maximum deflection, and maximum reinforcement ratio.