Behavior of Bond-Critical Regions Wrapped with Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Sheets in Normal and High-Strength Concrete

This paper reports on the third phase of a multiphase study undertaken at the American University of Beirut (AUB) to examine the effect of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) sheets in confining tension lap splice regions in reinforced concrete beams. Results of the first two phases showed that glass and carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (GFRP and CFRP) sheets were effective in increasing the bond strength and improving the ductility of the mode of failure of tension lap splices in high-strength concrete (HSC) beams with nominal concrete strength of 70 MPa. The experimental results of the two phases were used to propose a new FRP confinement parameter, Ktr,f, that accounts for the bond strength contribution of FRP sheets wrapping tension lap splice regions in HSC beams. In this third phase of the AUB study, the trend of the results of phases 1 and 2 and the validity of the analytical model proposed were verified if normal-strength concrete (NSC) is used instead of HSC. Seven beams with nominal concrete strength of 27.58 MPa (4 ksi) were tested in positive bending. Each beam was designed with a tension lap splice in a constant moment region in the midspan of the beam. The main test variables were the configuration (1 strip, 2 strips, or a continuous strip) and the number of layers (1 layer or 2 layers) of the CFRP sheets wrapping the splice region. The test results demonstrated that CFRP sheets were effective in enhancing the bond strength and ductility of failure mode of tension lap splices in NSC in a very similar way to HSC. In addition, the FRP confinement index proposed earlier for HSC was proven to be valid in the case of NSC.     

Seismic Behavior of High-Strength Concrete Columns Confined by Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Tubes

The use of high-strength concrete (HSC) in seismically active regions poses a major concern because of the brittle nature of material. The confinement requirements for HSC columns may be prohibitively stringent when ordinary grade transverse steel reinforcement is used. An alternative to conventional confinement reinforcement is the use of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) tubes in the form of stay-in-place formwork which can fulfill multiple functions of: (1) formwork; (2) confinement reinforcement; and (3) protective shell against corrosion, weathering and chemical attacks. The use of stay-in-place FRP formwork is investigated as concrete confinement reinforcement for HSC and normal strength concrete (NSC) columns with circular cross sections. Large-scale specimens with 270?mm circular cross-sections and different concrete strengths were tested under constant axial compression and incrementally increasing lateral deformation reversals. FRP tubes were manufactured from carbon fiber sheets and epoxy resin. The results indicate that inelastic deformability of HSC and NSC columns can be improved significantly by using FRP tubes, beyond the performance level usually expected of comparable columns confined with conventional steel reinforcement.     

Effect of Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Confinement on Bond Strength of Reinforcement in Beam Anchorage Specimens

This paper reports on the fourth phase of a multiphase study undertaken at the American University of Beirut (AUB) to examine the effect of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) sheets in confining bond-critical regions in reinforced concrete beams. Results of the first three phases showed that glass- and carbon-fiber-reinforced polymer (GFRP and CFRP) sheets were effective in increasing the bond strength and improving the ductility of the mode of failure of tension lap splices in high-strength concrete (HSC) and normal-strength concrete (NSC) beams. The main objective of the fourth phase of the AUB study was to assess the effect of CFRP sheets in improving the serviceability and ultimate response of beam anchorage specimens. The added experimental data and the improved knowledge of the bond behavior of FRP confined concrete members will encourage the use of FRP technology to strengthen and retrofit bond anchorage zones. Ten beam anchorage specimens were tested in positive bending in two series. The variables were bar size, anchorage length, and concrete strength. For each bar size, anchorage length, and concrete strength, two companion specimens—identical except for whether the anchorage zone was wrapped with FRP sheets or not wrapped—were tested. The test results demonstrated that CFRP sheets were effective in enhancing the bond strength and ductility of anchorage zones in beam anchorage specimens where splitting failures were imminent.     

Bond Strength of Tension Lap Splices in High-Strength Concrete Beams Strengthened with Glass Fiber Reinforced Polymer Wraps

This paper presents the experimental results of the first phase of a study undertaken at the American University of Beirut to examine the effectiveness of fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) wraps to confine steel reinforcement in a tension lap splice region anchored in high-strength reinforced-concrete beams. Seven beam specimens were constructed. The specimens were reinforced on the tension side with three deformed bars spliced at midspan. The splice region was devoid of any transverse reinforcement to allow a full examination of the FRP wrap contribution. Glass fiber reinforced polymer (GFRP) sheets were used. The main test variables were the GFRP configuration in the splice region (one strip, two strips, or a continuous strip), and the number of layers of the GFRP wraps placed around the splice region (one layer or two layers). All GFRP wraps were U-shaped. Except for the epoxy adhesive, no other anchorage mechanism or bonding procedure was applied for the GFRP wraps on the concrete beam. Following the application of the GFRP wraps, the beams were tested in positive bending. The test results demonstrated that GFRP wraps were effective in enhancing the bond strength and ductility of failure mode of the tension lap splices, especially when continuous strips were applied over the splice region.     

Effect of FRP Confinement on Bond Strength of Hooked Bars: Normal-Strength Concrete Structures

To assess the viability of the external confinement of normal-strength concrete beam–column joints with carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets in increasing the bond strength of hooked bars anchored in the joints, 12 hooked bar specimens were tested. The variables were beam tensile bar size, anchorage length, mode of confinement of the beam hooked bars in the beam–column joint (whether the hooked bars were anchored within or outside the column reinforcement cage, denoted as “confined specimens” or “unconfined specimens”), and presence or absence of FRP wraps. The specimen simulated the rigid connection of a cantilever beam to a column. The tensile beam reinforcement consisted of two bars anchored in the base column using hooked-bar anchorages. Test results indicated that FRP sheets were effective in increasing the anchorage capacity and the ductility of the load–deflection history for both unconfined and confined specimens. However, FRP sheets had a more significant influence on unconfined specimens than companion confined specimens. As compared with unconfined specimens without FRP wrapping, unconfined FRP specimens had an average of a 23% increase in bond strength, confined non-FRP specimens had an average 30% increase in bond strength, and confined FRP specimens had an increase of 54%.     

Behavior of Gravity Load-Designed Rectangular Concrete Columns Confined with Fiber Reinforced Polymer Sheets

This study concentrates on analytical evaluation of the effect of external confinement using fiber reinforced polymers (FRP) sheets on the response of concrete rectangular columns designed for gravity load only and having spliced longitudinal reinforcement at the column base. A general analytical scheme for evaluating the strength capacity and ductility of the columns under combined flexural–axial loads was developed. The analysis takes into account the bond strength degradation of the spliced reinforcement with increase in lateral load by incorporating a generalized bond stress–slip law, and considers the effect of FRP confinement on the stress–strain response of concrete material. Particular emphasis is placed in the analysis on the slip response of the spliced bars and the consequent fixed end rotation that develops at the column base. Results predicted by the analysis showed very good agreement with limited experimental data. A parametric evaluation was carried out to evaluate the effect of different design and strength parameters on the column response under lateral load. Without confinement, the columns suffered premature bond failure and, consequently, low flexural strength capacity. Confining the concrete in the columns end zone at the splice location with FRP sheets enhanced the bond strength capacity of the spliced reinforcement, increased the steel stress that can be mobilized before bond failure occurs, and consequently improved the flexural strength capacity and ductility of the columns. A general design equation, expressed as a function of the main parameters that influence the bond strength capacity between spliced steel bars and FRP confined concrete, is proposed to calculate the area of FRP sheets needed for strengthening of the subject columns.     

Normal- and High-Strength Concrete Circular Elements Wrapped with FRP Composites

Reinforced concrete columns usually have a minimum amount of transverse steel reinforcement this transverse reinforcement can have non negligible effects on the response of columns retrofitted with fiber-reinforced polymers (FRP). This paper presents a test program that was designed to study the behavior of small- and large-scale normal- and high-strength concrete circular columns confined with transverse steel reinforcement, FRP, and both transverse steel reinforcement and FRP under concentric loading. The effect of the main variables—such as the unconfined concrete strength, the volumetric ratio, the type and the yield strength of the transverse steel reinforcement, the concrete cover, and the number of FRP layers—are studied in this research program. The test results show that the enhancement of the confined concrete strength and strain is more pronounced in specimens with normal-strength concrete. It is also shown that the rupture of the FRP in the specimens with higher volumetric transverse steel reinforcement ratios corresponds to larger axial compressive strength and strain and that the postpeak behavior of these specimens is more ductile.     

Textile-Reinforced Mortar versus FRP Jacketing in Seismic Retrofitting of RC Columns with Continuous or Lap-Spliced Deformed Bars

The effectiveness of a new structural material, namely, textile-reinforced mortar (TRM), was investigated experimentally in this study as a means of confining oldtype reinforced concrete (RC) columns with limited capacity due to bar buckling or due to bond failure at lap splice regions. Comparisons with equal stiffness and strength fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) jackets allow for the evaluation of the effectiveness of TRM versus FRP. Tests were carried out on nearly full scale nonseismically detailed RC columns subjected to cyclic uniaxial flexure under constant axial load. Ten cantilevertype specimens with either continuous or lap-spliced deformed longitudinal reinforcement at the floor level were constructed and tested. Experimental results indicated that TRM jacketing is quite effective as a means of increasing the cyclic deformation capacity of oldtype RC columns with poor detailing, by delaying bar buckling and by preventing splitting bond failures in columns with lap-spliced bars. Compared with their FRP counterparts, the TRM jackets used in this study were found to be equally effective in terms of increasing both the strength and deformation capacity of the retrofitted columns. From the response of specimens tested in this study, it can be concluded that TRM jacketing is an extremely promising solution for the confinement of reinforced concrete columns, including poorly detailed ones with or without lap splices in seismic regions.     

Analytical Model for FRP-Confined Circular Reinforced Concrete Columns

One disadvantage of most available stress–strain models for concrete confined with fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites is that they do not take into consideration the interaction between the internal lateral steel reinforcement and the external FRP sheets. According to most structural concrete design codes, concrete columns must contain minimum amounts of longitudinal and transverse reinforcement. Therefore, concrete columns that have to be retrofitted (and therefore confined) with FRP sheets usually contain lateral steel. Hence, the retrofitted concrete column is under two actions of confinement: the action due to the FRP and that due to the steel ties. This paper presents a new designed-oriented confinement model for the axial and lateral behavior of circular concrete columns confined with steel ties, FRP composites, and both steel ties and FRP composites. Comparison with experimental results of confined concrete stress–strain curves shows good agreement between the test and predicted results.     

Bond Strength of Lap-Spliced Bars in Concrete Confined with Composite Jackets

The effectiveness of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) and textile-reinforced mortar (TRM) jackets was investigated experimentally and analytically in this study to confine old-type reinforced concrete (RC) columns with limited capacity because of bond failure at lap-splice regions. The local bond strength between lap-spliced bars and concrete was measured experimentally along the lap-splice region of six full-scale RC columns subjected to cyclic uniaxial flexure under constant axial load. The bond strength of the two column specimens tested without retrofitting was found to be in good agreement with the predictions given by two existing bond models. These models were modified to account for the contribution of composite material jacketing to the bond resistance between lap-spliced bars and concrete. The effectiveness of FRP and TRM jackets against splitting at lap splices was quantified as a function of jacket properties and geometry as well as in terms of the jacket effective strain, which was found to depend on the ratio of lap-splice length to bar diameter. Consequently, simple equations for calculating the bond strength of lap splices in members confined with composite materials (FRP or TRM) are proposed.     

Bond Performance of GFRP Bars in Tension: Experimental Evaluation and Assessment of ACI 440 Guidelines

The development/splice strength and the pullout local bond stress-slip response of glass fiber-reinforced polymer (GFRP) bars in tension were experimentally investigated using beam specimens and pullout specimens, respectively. Two types of 12-mm (0.47-in.)-diameter GFRP bars were evaluated, namely, thread wrapped and ribbed. The test parameters included the concrete cover, the splice length, and the area of steel confinement for the beam specimens, and the concrete compressive strength for the pullout specimens. Companion steel reinforced beams were also tested for comparison. All beam specimens reinforced with thread-wrapped GFRP bars experienced pullout mode of bond failure, while all specimens reinforced with ribbed GFRP bars or steel bars experienced splitting mode of bond failure. It was found that the bond strength of FRP bars is largely dependent on the surface conditions of the bars. The pullout local bond stress-slip response of ribbed GFRP bars is intrinsically similar to that of steel bars reported in the literature. The bond strength of both types of GFRP bars investigated was about two to three times lower than that of steel bars. Predictions of the development/splice strength of GFRP bars in accordance with the ACI Committee 440 guidelines were unconservative in comparison with the test data. Also, in contradiction with the current ACI 440 report, the use of transverse confining reinforcement increased the bond strength by a sizable 15–30%.     

Tests on Seismically Damaged Reinforced Concrete Walls Repaired and Strengthened Using Fiber-Reinforced Polymers

The behavior of six 1:2.5-scale reinforced concrete cantilever wall specimens having an aspect ratio of 1.5, tested to failure and subsequently repaired and strengthened using fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) sheets is investigated. Specimens were first repaired by removing heavily cracked concrete, lap splicing the fractured steel bars by welding new short bars, placing new hoops and horizontal web reinforcement, and finally casting nonshrink high-strength repair mortar. The specimens were then strengthened using FRP sheets and strips, with a view to increasing flexural as well as shear strength and ductility. In addition to different arrangements of steel and FRP reinforcement in the walls, a key parameter was the way carbon-FRP strips added for flexural strengthening were anchored; steel plates and steel angles were used to this effect. Steel plates were anchored using U-shaped glass-FRP (GFRP) strips or bonded metal anchors. Test results have shown that by using FRP reinforcement, the flexural and shear strength of the specimens can be increased. From the anchorage systems tested, metal plates combined with FRP strips appear to be quite efficient. The effectiveness of the bonded metal anchors used was generally less than that of the combination of plates and GFRP strips. In all cases, final failure of the FRP anchorage is brittle, but only occurs after the peak strength is attained and typically follows the fracture of steel reinforcement in critical areas, hence the overall behavior of the strengthened walls is moderately ductile.     

Investigation into the Effect of Bonding on FRP-Wrapped Cylindrical Concrete Columns

In this paper the failure of a three layer system comprising a concrete column, an intermediate epoxy layer, and fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) confinement is investigated. We perform a series of numerical experiments to investigate how the failure loads and ultimate strains of axially loaded plain cement concrete (PCC) and reinforced cement concrete (RCC) columns change with the type of the bond between concrete and epoxy and between epoxy and FRP. Three types of interfacial behavior are considered: rigid, cohesive compliant, and unbonded contact. An idealized spring model for the resultant confinement stiffness is used to explain the effect the nature of the bond has on the results. It is found that the type of bond has a significant effect on the ultimate strength of PCC columns. The results also indicate that the presence of longitudinal and hoop steel reinforcement allows use of comparatively less stiff FRP sheets as confinement material for RCC columns.     

FRP-Reinforced Concrete Beams: Unified Approach Based on IC Theory

In general, steel-reinforced concrete involves a ductile steel material and a very strong and ductile bond between the steel reinforcement and concrete, so that debonding rarely governs the design. In contrast, fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) reinforcement is a brittle material with a weak and brittle bond, making debonding a major issue. Consequently, there has been an extensive amount of research on FRP debonding and in particular intermediate crack (IC) debonding. This paper shows that the very good research by the FRP research community on the mechanics of IC debonding can be applied to a wide range of apparently disparate reinforced concrete behaviors to produce a unified approach. Hence, a single mechanism, or unified approach, based on IC debonding is proposed in this paper for dealing with moment rotation, tension stiffening and deflections, member ductility and moment redistribution, shear capacity, confinement, and fiber concrete for FRP RC beams.     

Combined Shear and Flexural Behavior of Hybrid FRP-Concrete Beams Previously Subjected to Cyclic Loading

Concrete-filled fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) tubes (CFFTs) were initially proposed for bridge substructures in corrosive environments in the early 1990s. Systematic studies have since demonstrated the feasibility and merits of CFFTs with or without internal mild steel reinforcement. However, the experimental database in this field is still quite limited. This paper enhances the test database through a series of monotonic bending tests on one control RC specimen and five CFFT specimens previously subjected to reverse cyclic loading. Although the control RC specimen suffered shear-flexural cracks, specimens with carbon fibers experienced flexural failure by longitudinal splitting of the FRP tube in tension and its crumpling in compression. Specimens with glass or hybrid (glass/carbon) fibers, on the other hand, all failed by local buckling of FRP with either burst crushing or crumpling cracks. The specimen with hybrid fibers had higher normalized initial stiffness primarily because of its higher FRP/concrete stiffness ratio. The tests showed that the ductility of CFFT increases with FRP rupture strain. Further synthesis of flexural strength with FRP and mild steel reinforcement indexes reveals the existence of an optimized overall reinforcement index to achieve a design moment without overconfining concrete. Finally, the study confirms that shear failure is not critical for CFFT specimens at short shear span-to-depth ratios, even with internal mild steel reinforcement, as long as the FRP architecture is designed properly.     

Concrete-Filled Square and Rectangular FRP Tubes under Axial Compression

This paper presents results of an experimental study on the behavior of square and rectangular concrete-filled fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) tubes (CFFTs) under concentric compression. FRP tubes were designed as column confinement reinforcement and were manufactured using unidirectional carbon fiber sheets with fibers oriented in the hoop direction. The effects of the thickness and corner radius of the tube, sectional aspect ratio, and concrete strength on the axial behavior of CFFTs were investigated experimentally. Test results indicate that FRP confinement leads to substantial improvement in the ductility of both square and rectangular columns. Confinement provided by the FRP tube may also improve the axial load-carrying capacity of the square and rectangular columns if the confinement effectiveness of the FRP tube is sufficiently high. The results also indicate that the confinement effectiveness of FRP tubes is higher in square columns than in rectangular columns, and in both sections the effectiveness of confinement increases with the corner radius. Furthermore, for a given confinement level, improvement observed on the axial behavior of concrete due to confinement decreases with increasing concrete strength.     

Uniaxial Tension Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Members Strengthened with Carbon Fiber Sheets

A two-dimensional (2D) nonlinear numerical analysis code by using the rigid body spring method (RBSM) was developed by the writers at Hokkaido University to simulate the behavior of reinforced concrete (RC) members strengthened with fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) sheets. The code supports the nonlinear constitutive laws for the different materials and nonlinear bond stress-slip relationships for steel-concrete and FRP sheet-concrete interfaces. This study uses the aforementioned code to examine the uniaxial tension behavior of RC members strengthened with carbon fiber sheets (CFS). Experimental results are compared with relevant numerical outputs to validate the model and confirm its ability to simulate the experimental observations. This study also assesses the influence of the amount of CFS strengthening on the tension-stiffening behavior of strengthened members. Finally, this research also suggests new analytical expressions for the average stress-strain relationships of concrete and steel in tension in the presence of stiffening contributions from internal steel reinforcement bars and externally bonded CFS reinforcement.     

Hysteretic Behavior of Bridge Columns with FRP-Jacketed Lap Splices Designed for Moderate Ductility Enhancement

This paper presents test results of six specimens representing older bridge columns with inadequate reinforcement detailing consisting of short lap splices at the base and widely spaced transverse reinforcement. Four of these specimens were rehabilitated using fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) jackets of two different composite materials (carbon and aramid) to avoid premature failure of the lapped bars after a limited number of postyield cycles. The test results indicate that thin FRP jackets can be used to avoid failure of short lap splices at moderate displacement ductilities. Displacement capacities consistent with expected demands in regions of moderate or low seismicity were achieved after jacket retrofitting. The hysteretic behavior of rehabilitated columns was assessed with emphasizing issues related to variation of stiffness and damping ratio as a function of ductility demand for this class of columns. Equations that account for the effect of axial load level on estimates of effective stiffness and damping as a function of displacement ductility are proposed for this class of columns.     

Analytical Model for FRP Confinement of Concrete Columns with and without Internal Steel Reinforcement

The paper aims to contribute to a better understanding of the behavior of reinforced concrete columns confined with fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) sheets. In particular, some new insights on interaction mechanisms between internal steel reinforcement and external FRP strengthening and their influence on efficiency of FRP confinement technique are given. In this context a procedure to generate the complete stress-strain response including new analytical proposals for (1) effective confinement pressure at failure; (2) peak stress; (3) ultimate stress; (4) ultimate axial strain; and (5) axial strain corresponding to peak stress for FRP confined elements with circular and rectangular cross sections, with and without internal steel reinforcement, is presented. Interaction mechanisms between internal steel reinforcement and external FRP strengthening, shown by some experimental results obtained at the University of Padova with accurate measurements, are taken into account in the analytical model. Four experimental databases regarding FRP confined concrete columns, with circular and rectangular cross section with and without steel reinforcement, are gathered for the assessment of some of the confinement models shown in literature and the new proposed model. The proposed model shows a good performance and analytical stress-strain curves approximate some available test results quite well.     

Effect of Transverse Steel on the Response of RC Beams Strengthened in Shear by FRP: Experimental Study

The present paper shows and discusses some of the results obtained within an experimental investigation carried out on 15 reinforced concrete (RC) beams strengthened in shear by externally bonded fiber-reinforced plastics (FRP) sheets. The aim of the study is to analyze the influence that the geometrical percentage of transverse steel reinforcement could have on the FRP resisting action. In particular, the objectives of the experimental campaign are to explore the possible interaction between FRP and steel transverse reinforcement resisting actions, analyzing the deformation behavior of the shear resisting system (FRP, transverse steel, and concrete) and the modes of failure of the strengthened and not strengthened beams. The results of the tests in terms of shear capacity are compared to the design formulations provided by the American Concrete Institute and the National Research Council of Italy code-format recommendations.