Decay heat in fast reactors with transuranic fuels

In this work, we performed an evaluation of decay heat power of advanced, fast spectrum, lead and molten salt-cooled reactors, with flexible conversion ratio. The decay heat power was calculated using the BGCore computer code, which explicitly tracks over 1700 isotopes in the fuel throughout its burnup and subsequent decay. In the first stage, the capability of the BGCore code to accurately predict the decay heat power was verified by performing a benchmark calculation for a typical UO₂ fuel in a Pressurized Water Reactor environment against the (ANSI/ANS-5.1-2005, “Decay Heat Power in Light Water Reactors,” American National Standard) standard. Very good agreement (within 5%) between the two methods was obtained. Once BGCore calculation capabilities were verified, we calculated decay power for fast reactors with different coolants and conversion ratios, for which no standard procedure is currently available. Notable differences were observed for the decay power of the advanced reactor as compared with the conventional UO₂ LWR. The importance of the observed differences was demonstrated by performing a simulation of a Station Blackout transient with the RELAP5 computer code for a lead-cooled fast reactor. The simulation was performed twice: using the code-default ANS-79 decay heat curve and using the curve calculated specifically for the studied core by BGCore code. The differences in the decay heat power resulted in failure to meet maximum cladding temperature limit criteria by ∼100 °C in the latter case, while in the transient simulation with the ANS-79 decay heat curve, all safety limits were satisfied. The results of this study show that the design of new reactor safety systems must be based on decay power curves specific to each individual case in order to assure the desired performance of these systems.     

Safety approach of DFBR design study in Japan

The goal of the safety design for the demonstration fast breeder reactor is to ensure that the safety level is equivalent to or higher than that of the light water reactors of the same period. The design of the safety features such as reactor shutdown, decay heat removal and confinement systems is of importance to reach the goal. The reactor core is equipped with two independent fast shutdown systems, the primary system and the backup system. In addition, it is planned to strengthen the passive shutdown capability by using self- actuated systems such as a Curie point device for the backup system. The decay heat is removed from the core to the atmosphere through the safety lines of the direct reactor auxiliary cooling system which is composed of four independent lines. Furthermore, under the severe conditions that no active function of the decay heat removal system is available, the heat can be removed by natural convection through the safety lines by taking advantage of the high boiling temperature of sodium. For the confinement function, the reactor vessel is surrounded by a containment vessel and a confinement area.

The design concept of these safety features is described in this paper.     

European lead fast reactor—ELSY

The conceptual design of the European Lead Fast Reactor is being developed starting from September 2006, in the frame of the EU-FP6-ELSY project. The ELSY (European Lead-cooled System) reference design is a 600 MWe pool-type reactor cooled by pure lead. The ELSY project demonstrates the possibility of designing a competitive and safe fast critical reactor using simple engineered technical features, while fully complying with the Generation IV goal of sustainability and minor actinide (MA) burning capability. Sustainability was a leading criterion for option selection for core design, focusing on the demonstration of the potential to be self sustaining in plutonium and to burn its own generated MAs. To this end, different core configurations have been studied. Economics was a leading criterion for primary system design and plant layout. The use of a compact and simple primary circuit with the additional objective that all internal components be removable, are among the reactor features intended to assure competitive electric energy generation and long-term investment protection. Low capital cost and construction time are pursued through simplicity and compactness of the reactor building (reduced footprint and height). The reduced plant footprint is one of the benefits coming from the elimination of the Intermediate Cooling System, the low reactor building height is the result of the design approach which foresees the adoption of short-height components and two innovative Decay Heat Removal (DHR) systems. Among the critical issues, the impact of the large mass of lead has been carefully analyzed; it has been demonstrated that the high density of lead can be mitigated by compact solutions and adoption of seismic isolators. Safety has been one of the major focuses all over the ELSY development. In addition to the inherent safety advantages of lead coolant (high boiling point and no exothermic reactions with air or water) a high safety grade of the overall system has been reached. In fact the overall primary system has been conceived in order to minimize pressure drops and, as a consequence, to allow decay heat removal by natural circulation. Moreover two redundant, diverse and passive operated DHR systems have been developed and adopted. The paper presents the overall work performed so far.     

CEFR改进型独立热交换器热工水力分析研究

事故余热排出系统是池式钠冷快堆最重要的专设安全设施之一,是实现反应堆相关事故工况下余热排出安全功能的主要手段,如全厂断电工况,而独立热交换器是快堆事故余热排出系统的关键设备之一。本文以ANSYS FLUENT为工具,对中国实验快堆现有的独立热交换器和一种改进的新型独立热交换器布置在快堆热池中的情况进行了瞬态数值模拟,并分析比较其结果,证明了改进型独立热交换器在热工水力上的可行性。本文工作对大型快堆的独立热交换器的设计具有一定的借鉴意义。     

Evaluation of decay heating in shutdown reactors

Heating from the decay of radioactive nuclides in shutdown reactors plays an important role in the safety evaluation of nuclear power plants. It also must be known in order to design spent fuel storage systems, shutdown reactor cooling systems and heat sink, reprocessing and nuclear waste disposal systems. Of these applications, the analysis of reactor accident scenarios has been the main impetus to develop more accurate methods of decay heat evaluation. It was recognized early in the 1970s that the knowledge was inadequate for safety requirements and that this placed an economic burden on nuclear power plants.Intensive research has been undertaken in the past few years and this has led to a much more precise knowledge of decay heat power in Light Water Reactors (LWR). With additional work this improvement can soon be extended to other reactors types. This paper reviews the background, recent research developments and the evolution of a major revision of the American Nuclear Society Standard for decay heat power in LWR.     

Renewed interest in lead cooled fast reactors

In the last few years a number of compact designs of lead-alloy cooled systems have been promoted. Moreover, in Russia a design effort was started earlier on the pure lead-cooled BREST reactor but this effort does not appear to be strongly funded any more. But now the lead cooled and compact STAR-LM reactor is promoted in the US and in the European Union there is some interest in a mediumsized lead-cooled fast reactor (LFR). It has brought some nuclear industries, a large utility, several research centers and universities together to ask the European Commission for a partial funding of design and safety efforts. A 600 MWe LFR design is proposed which would be useful for base load operation but as a fast system it could also be used for load following. Because of the possible plant simplifications and the use of pure lead, the economics of such a system should be good. Moreover, efficient fuel utilization, the burning of higher actinides and a closed fuel cycle make it a sustainable system. Whether, this larger system has the same inherent / passive safety characteristics as smaller LFRs needs to be examined. In this paper the passive emergency decay heat removal by reactor vessel aircooling of such a larger system is investigated. Moreover an inlet blockage in a subassembly of a low power density LMR is analyzed. Furthermore, the pros and cons of lead vs. lead/bismuth coolants are discussed.     

SADHANA facility for simulation of natural convection in the SGDHR system of PFBR

The Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor (PFBR) is a 500 MWe sodium cooled pool type fast reactor being constructed at Kalpakkam, India. PFBR has all the reactor components immersed in the pool of sodium and the fission heat generated in the core, is removed by the sodium circulating in the pool. During normal operation this fission heat is transferred by primary sodium to secondary sodium, which in turn transfers the heat to water in the steam generator for producing steam. The removal of the decay heat generated in the reactor core after the reactor shutdown is also very important to maintain the structural integrity of reactor core components. PFBR employs two independent systems namely, Operational Grade Decay Heat Removal system (OGDHRS) and Safety Grade Decay Heat Removal System (SGDHRS) for decay heat removal. SGDHR system is a passive system working on natural convection to ensure the core coolability even under station blackout condition. It is very important to study the thermal hydraulic behavior of Safety Grade Decay Heat Removal system of PFBR to ensure its reliable operation. A scaled down model of the circuit, named SADHANA has been modeled, designed, constructed and commissioned for demonstration and evaluation of these systems. The facility has completed around 2000 h of high temperature operation. The performance of the experimental system is satisfactory and it meets all the design requirements. At 550 °C sodium pool temperature in test vessel the secondary sodium loop generated a sodium flow of 6.7 m³/h. These experiments have revealed the adequacy and capability of SGDHR system to remove the decay heat from the fast breeder reactor core after its shutdown.     

Natural circulation characteristics of lead-based reactor under long-term decay heat removal

The natural circulation of primary coolant plays an important role in removing the decay heat in Station-Black-out (SBO) accident from reactor core to decay heat removal systems, such as RVACS and PHXS cooling, for lead-based reactor. In order to study the natural circulation characteristics of primary coolant under Reactor Vessel Air Cooling System (RVACS) and primary heat exchangers (PHXs) cooling, which are crucial to the safety of lead-based reactors. A three-dimensional CFD model for the China Lead-based Research Reactor (CLEAR-I) has been built to analyze the thermal-hydraulics characteristics of primary coolant system and the cooling capability of the two systems. The abilities of the two cooling systems with different decay heat powers were discussed as well. The results demonstrated that the decay heat could be removed effectively only relying on either of the two systems. However, RVACS appeared the obvious thermal stratification phenomenon in the cold pool. Besides, with the increase in decay heat power, the natural circulation capacity of primary coolant between the two systems had a significant difference. The PHXs cooling system was stronger than the RVACS, with respect to the mass flow of primary coolant and the average temperature difference between cold pool and hot pool.     

CAST3M/ARCTURUS: A coupled heat transfer CFD code for thermal–hydraulic analyzes of gas cooled reactors

The safety of gas cooled reactors (High Temperature Reactors (HTR), Very High Temperature Reactors (VHTR) or Gas Cooled Fast Reactors (GFR)) must be ensured by systems (active or passive) which maintain loads on component (fuel) and structures (vessel, containment) within acceptable limits under accidental conditions. To achieve this objective, thermal–hydraulics computer codes are necessary tools to design, enhance the performance and ensure a high safety level of the different reactors. Some key safety questions are related to the evaluation of decay heat removal and containment pressure and thermal loads. This requires accurate simulations of conduction, convection, thermal radiation transfers and energy storage. Coupling with neutronics is also an important modeling aspect for the determination of representative parameters such as neutronics coefficient (Doppler coefficient, Moderator coeffcient, …), critical position of control rods, reactivity insertion aspects, …. For GFR, the high power density of the core and its necessary reduced dimension cannot rely only on passive systems for decay heat removal. Therefore, forced convection using active safety systems (gas blowers, heat exchangers, …) are highly recommended. Nevertheless, in case of station black-out, the safety demonstration of the concept should be guaranteed by natural circulation heat removal. This could be performed by keeping a relatively high back-up pressure for pure helium convection and also by heavy gas injection. So, it is also necessary to model mixing of different gases, the on-set of natural convection and the pressure and thermal loads onto the proximate or guard containment. In this paper, we report on the developments of the CAST3M/ARCTURUS thermal–hydraulics (Lumped Parameter and CFD) code developed at CEA, including its coupling to the neutronics code CRONOS2 and the system code CATHARE. Elementary validation cases are detailed, as well as application of the code to benchmark problems such as the HTR-10 thermal–hydraulic exercise. Examples of containment thermal–hydraulics calculations for fast reactor design (GFR) are also detailed.     

The design features of the HTR-10

The 10 MW High Temperature Gas-cooled Test Reactor (HTR-10) is a modular pebble bed type reactor. This paper briefly introduces the main design features and safety concept of the HTR-10. The design features of the pebble bed reactor core, the pressure boundary of the primary circuit, the decay heat removal system and the two independent reactor shutdown systems and the barrier of confinement are described in this paper.     

Core power limits for a lead-bismuth natural circulation actinide burner reactor

The Idaho National Engineering and Environmental Laboratory and Massachusetts Institute of Technology are investigating the suitability of lead-bismuth cooled fast reactors for producing low-cost electricity as well as for actinide burning. The design being considered here is a pool type reactor that burns actinides and utilizes natural circulation of the primary coolant, a conventional steam power conversion cycle, and a passive decay heat removal system. Thermal-hydraulic evaluations of the actinide burner reactor were performed to determine allowable core power ratings that maintain cladding temperatures below corrosion-established temperature limits during normal operation and following a loss-of-feedwater transient. An economic evaluation was performed to optimize various design parameters by minimizing capital cost. The transient power limit was initially much more restrictive than the steady-state limit. However, enhancements to the reactor vessel auxiliary cooling system for transient decay heat removal resulted in an increased power limit of 1040 MWt, which was close to the steady-state limit. An economic evaluation was performed to estimate the capital cost of the reactor and its sensitivity to the transient power limit. For the 1040 MWt power level, the capital cost estimate was 49 mills per kWhe based on 1999 dollars.     

球床式高温气冷堆的余热不确定性分析

反应堆在停堆后相当长时间内仍具有较高的剩余发热是核电站的重要特性,也是核电站安全分析的关键。因此,对反应堆余热及其不确定性进行分析,对于合理设计余热排出系统、研究论证燃料元件在事故后的安全特性等均具有重要意义。本工作结合德国针对球床式高温气冷堆制定的余热计算标准,介绍了球床式高温气冷堆剩余发热及其不确定性的计算方法,并结合200 MWe球床模块式高温气冷堆示范工程（HTR-PM）的初步物理设计,对长期运行在满功率平衡堆芯状态下的反应堆停堆后的余热及其不确定性进行了计算分析,为进一步的事故分析提供依据。     

Development of natural circulation analysis methods for a sodium cooled fast reactor

A natural circulation evaluation methodology has been developed to insure safety of a sodium cooled fast reactor (SFR) of 1500 MWe adopting a natural circulation decay heat removal system (NC-DHRS). The methodology consists of a one-dimensional safety analysis which can be applied to safety evaluation for SFR licensing taking into account the temperature flattening effect due to buoyancy force in the core, and a three-dimensional fluid flow analysis which can evaluate thermal-hydraulics for local convection and thermal stratification in the primary system and DHRSs. The one-dimensional safety analysis method and the three-dimensional fluid flow analysis method have been validated using the test results of a water test apparatus and a sodium test loop for some typical transient events selected from the design basis events of the SFR. Finally, it has been confirmed that a good agreement between the test results and analysis results has been obtained, and reliability of each method has been demonstrated.     

CFD modeling and thermal-hydraulic analysis for the passive decay heat removal of a sodium-cooled fast reactor

In this study, a pool-typed design similar to sodium-cooled fast reactor (SFR) of the fourth generation reactors has been modeled using CFD simulations to investigate the characteristics of a passive mechanism of Shutdown Heat Removal System (SHRS). The main aim is to refine the reactor pool design in terms of temperature safety margin of the sodium pool. Thus, an appropriate protection mechanism is maintained in order to ensure the safety and integrity of the reactor system during a shutdown mode without using any active heat removal system. The impacts on the pool temperature are evaluated based on the following considerations: (1) the aspect ratio of pool diameter to depth, (2) the values of thermal emissivity of the surface materials of reactor and guard vessels, and (3) innerpool liner and core periphery structures. The computational results show that an optimal pool design in geometry can reduce the maximum pool temperature down to ∼551 °C which is substantially lower than ∼627 °C as calculated for the reference case. It is also concluded that the passive Reactor Air Cooling System (RACS) is effective in removing decay heat after shutdown. Furthermore, thermal radiation from the surface of the reactor vessel is found to be important; and thus, the selection of the vessel surface materials with a high emissivity would be a crucial factor for consideration in safety design. This study provides future researchers with a guideline on designing safety measures for the fourth generation of the fast reactors with no particular reference to any specific manufacturer.     

池式钠冷快堆事故余热排出系统一回路仿真研究

池式钠冷快堆事故余热排出系统采用了非能动工作原理,依靠液态钠及空气的自然对流排出堆芯余热。为研究事故工况下余热排出系统一回路的换热能力,基于FORTRAN语言,建立堆芯单通道及盒间流模型,采用全隐二阶迎风差分格式及改进的欧拉法离散求解,对事故余热排出系统一回路系统进行数值模拟,并对全厂断电事故进行仿真计算验证。结果表明:该程序能较好地反映事故余热排出系统瞬态变化过程,并可达到超实时仿真。     

Incorporating reliability analysis into the design of passive cooling systems with an application to a gas-cooled reactor

A time-dependent reliability evaluation of a two-loop passive decay heat removal (DHR) system was performed as part of the iterative design process for a helium-cooled fast reactor. The system was modeled using RELAP5-3D. The uncertainties in input parameters were assessed and were propagated through the model using Latin hypercube sampling. An important finding was the discovery that the smaller pressure loss through the DHR heat exchanger than through the core would make the flow to bypass the core through one DHR loop, if two loops operated in parallel. This finding is a warning against modeling only one lumped DHR loop and assuming that n of them will remove n times the decay power. Sensitivity analyses revealed that there are values of some input parameters for which failures are very unlikely. The calculated conditional (i.e., given the LOCA) failure probability was deemed to be too high leading to the identification of several design changes to improve system reliability. This study is an example of the kinds of insights that can be obtained by including a reliability assessment in the design process. It is different from the usual use of PSA in design, which compares different system configurations, because it focuses on the thermal–hydraulic performance of a safety function.     

钠冷快堆系统分析程序FR-Sdaso衰变热计算模型开发与验证

反应堆停堆后的余热导出是反应堆的重要安全功能之一,停堆初期余热由裂变功率和衰变热构成,停堆后期余热主要取决于衰变热。本文开发了应用于钠冷快堆系统分析程序FR-Sdaso的衰变热计算模型,该模型可考虑裂变功率和功率历史的影响。通过与ANSI/ANS-5.1-2005标准和SAS4A/SASYS-1程序对比进行了模型验证。FR-Sdaso程序的计算结果与ANSI/ANS-5.1-2005标准的最大相对偏差约为0.1%,与SAS4A/SASYS-1的最大相对偏差在10-8量级,初步证明了所开发模型的正确性。最后,基于中国实验快堆的设计数据,分析了紧急停堆过程中裂变功率对衰变热的影响,结果表明,忽略裂变功率的影响导致衰变热的最大相对偏差约-7%,出现在停堆初期。因此,计算停堆初期衰变热时应考虑裂变功率的影响。     

Decay heat

Many aspects of the nuclear fuel cycle require accurate and detailed knowledge of the energy release rate from the decay of radioactive nuclides produced in an operating reactor. In addition to the safety assessment of nuclear power plant, decay heat estimates are needed for the evaluation of shielding requirements on fuel discharge and transport routes and for the safe management of radioactive waste products extracted from spent fuel during reprocessing. The decay heat estimates may be derived by either summation calculations or Standard equations.This paper reviews the development of these evaluation methods and traces their evolution since the first studies of the 1940s. In contrast to many of the previous reviews of this subject, both actinide and fission product evaluation methods are reviewed in parallel. Data requirements for summation calculations are examined and a summary given of available codes and their data libraries. The capabilities of present-day summation methods are illustrated through comparisons with available experimental results. Uncertainties in summation results are examined in terms of those in the basic nuclear data, irradiation details and method of calculation. The evolution of decay heat Standards is described and a brief examination made of their reliability and ability to provide suitably conservative decay heat estimates. Finally, to illustrate the use of present summation methods, comparisons are given of both the actinide and fission product decay heat levels from typical fuel samples in a variety of reactor systems.     

Decay heat production in a TRU burner

The design of new reactors such as ADS has been investigated in many countries during the last years for burning transuranic nuclides (TRUs) contained in spent reactor fuel. To increase the TRU incineration rate, fertile-free dedicated fuels, which may contain a large fraction of minor actinides (MAs), are currently considered. Based on past experience, R&D activities for dedicated fuels in Europe concentrate on fuel forms, in which the oxide actinide phase is mixed with oxide or metal inert matrices. Decay heat in a system with inert matrix fuel (IMF) containing MAs may differ from that in a conventional fast reactor. In this paper, several fast reactor designs with different TRU content are considered and related decay heat values, calculated on the basis JEFF 3.0 and JEFF 3.1 nuclear data libraries, are compared. It is shown that some decay heat components for fuels with MAs may be lower than those for MA-free fuels, but the total decay heat may be significantly higher for cooling times exceeding about 1 min.     

Development of the FHR advanced natural circulation analysis code and application to FHR safety analysis

The University of California, Berkeley (UCB) is performing thermal hydraulics safety analysis to develop the technical basis for design and licensing of fluoride-salt-cooled, high-temperature reactors (FHRs). FHR designs investigated by UCB use natural circulation for emergency, passive decay heat removal when normal decay heat removal systems fail. The FHR advanced natural circulation analysis (FANCY) code has been developed for assessment of passive decay heat removal capability and safety analysis of these innovative system designs. The FANCY code uses a one-dimensional, semi-implicit scheme to solve for pressure-linked mass, momentum and energy conservation equations. Graph theory is used to automatically generate a staggered mesh for complicated pipe network systems. Heat structure models have been implemented for three types of boundary conditions (Dirichlet, Neumann and Robin boundary conditions). Heat structures can be composed of several layers of different materials, and are used for simulation of heat structure temperature distribution and heat transfer rate. Control models are used to simulate sequences of events or trips of safety systems. A proportional-integral controller is also used to automatically make thermal hydraulic systems reach desired steady state conditions. A point kinetics model is used to model reactor kinetics behavior with temperature reactivity feedback. The underlying large sparse linear systems in these models are efficiently solved by using direct and iterative solvers provided by the SuperLU code on high performance machines. Input interfaces are designed to increase the flexibility of simulation for complicated thermal hydraulic systems. This paper mainly focuses on the methodology used to develop the FANCY code, and safety analysis of the Mark 1 pebble-bed FHR under development at UCB is performed.