Characterization of a Holliday junction-resolving enzyme from Schizosaccharomyces pombe

The rearrangement and repair of DNA by homologous recombination involves the creation of Holliday junctions, which are cleaved by a class of junction-specific endonucleases to generate recombinant duplex DNA products. Only two cellular junction-resolving enzymes have been identified to date: RuvC in eubacteria and CCE1 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondria. We have identified a protein from Schizosaccharomyces pombe which has 28% sequence identity to CCE1. The YDC2 protein has been cloned and overexpressed in Escherichia coli, and the purified recombinant protein has been shown to be a Holliday junction-resolving enzyme. YDC2 has a high degree of specificity for the structure of the four-way junction, to which it binds as a dimer. The enzyme exhibits a sequence specificity for junction cleavage that differs from both CCE1 and RuvC, and it cleaves fixed junctions at the point of strand exchange. The conservation of the mechanism of Holliday junction cleavage between two organisms as diverse as S. cerevisiae and S. pombe suggests that there may be a common pathway for mitochondrial homologous recombination in fungi, plants, protists, and possibly higher eukaryotes.     

Substrate specificity of the Escherichia coli RuvC protein. Resolution of three- and four-stranded recombination intermediates

The specificity of the Escherichia coli RuvC Holliday junction resolvase has been investigated in vitro. RuvC protein cleaves synthetic DNA substrates that model three- or four-stranded recombination intermediates but fails to act upon Y junctions, G/A mismatches, heterologous loop structures, or two-stranded branched junctions. RuvC therefore differs from endonuclease VII of bacteriophage T4 which exhibits broad range specificity. Using related three- and four-stranded synthetic DNA junctions, we show that RuvC cleaves both junctions at the same DNA sequence and requires a region of homology at the junction point. The action of RuvC on three- and four-stranded recombination intermediates made by RecA was also investigated. We found that RuvC fails to resolve three-stranded intermediates in the presence of RecA, although four-stranded intermediates are resolved under the same conditions. However, both three- and four-stranded intermediates are substrates for the nuclease after removal of RecA. We interpret these differences in terms of the contiguity of the RecA nucleoprotein filament which may, under certain conditions, limit access to the Holliday junction resolvase.     

Formation of RuvABC-Holliday junction complexes in vitro

In Escherichia coli, the RuvA, RuvB and RuvC proteins are required for the late stages of homologous recombination and DNA repair. RuvA and RuvB form a complex that interacts with Holliday junctions--crossed DNA structures that are recombination intermediates--and promotes branch migration; RuvC is a junction-specific endonuclease that resolves Holliday junctions and completes the recombination process. Because genetic and biochemical experiments suggest that the processes of branch migration and resolution are linked, coimmunoprecipitation experiments were carried out to determine whether the three Ruv proteins interact to form a functional complex (RuvABC). Using a synthetic Holliday junction, a multisubunit complex containing the junction and RuvA, RuvB and RuvC was detected. In the absence of RuvB, RuvAC-junction complexes were observed. Complex formation was not facilitated by duplex DNA. The identification of a RuvABC-junction complex provides direct evidence that the RuvABC proteins interact at the Holliday junction.     

Resolution of Holliday junctions by RuvC resolvase: cleavage specificity and DNA distortion

E. coli RuvC protein resolves Holliday junctions during genetic recombination and postreplication repair. Using small synthetic junctions, we show that junction recognition is structure-specific and occurs in the absence of metal cofactors. In the presence of Mg2+, Holliday junctions are resolved by the introduction of symmetrically related nicks at the 3' side of thymine residues. The nicked duplex products are repaired by the action of DNA ligase. Within the RuvC-Holliday junction complex, the DNA is distorted such that 2 of the 4 strands become hypersensitive to hydroxyl radical attack. The ionic requirements of binding, hydroxyl radical sensitivity, and strand cleavage indicate three distinct steps in the mechanism of RuvC-mediated Holliday junction resolution: structure-specific recognition, DNA distortion, and sequence-dependent cleavage.     

Recognition and manipulation of branched DNA by the RusA Holliday junction resolvase of Escherichia coli

Homologous recombination is a fundamental cellular process that shapes and reshapes the genomes of all organisms and promotes repair of damaged DNA. A key step in this process is the resolution of Holliday junctions formed by homologous DNA pairing and strand exchange. In Escherichia coli , a Holliday junction is processed into recombinant products by the concerted activities of the RuvA and RuvB proteins, which together drive branch migration, and RuvC endonuclease, which resolves the structure. In the absence of RuvABC, recombination can be promoted by increasing the expression of the RusA endonuclease, a Holliday junction resolvase encoded by a cryptic prophage gene. Here, we describe the DNA binding properties of RusA. We found that RusA was highly selective for branched molecules and formed complexes with these structures even in the presence of a large excess of linear duplex DNA. However, it does bind weakly to linear duplex DNA. Under conditions where there was no detectable binding to duplex DNA, RusA formed a highly structured complex with a synthetic Holliday junction that was remarkably stable and insensitive to divalent metal ions. The duplex arms were found to adopt a specific alignment within this complex that approximated to a tetrahedral conformation of the junction.     

Formation of a single base mismatch impedes spontaneous DNA branch migration

DNA branch migration, a process whereby two homologous DNA duplexes exchange strands, is an essential component of genetic recombination. Models for homologous recombination have invoked spontaneous branch migration as one mechanism for the generation of large regions of heteroduplex DNA. During recombination, two homologous parental duplexes that contain similar, but not identical, sequences are paired and undergo strand exchange. An important issue is whether spontaneous branch migration is capable of traversing sequence heterology such as mismatches, insertions and deletions. We use a model four-strand system to examine the effect of mispaired or unpaired bases on branch migration. The assay consists of annealing two short duplexes having defined sequence heterologies. Following annealing, a Holliday junction is formed that is free to branch migrate. Our results demonstrate that a single base mismatch, insertion or deletion is sufficient to pose a substantial barrier to spontaneous branch migration. In the presence of magnesium, branch migration through such sequence heterologies is almost completely blocked. Others have shown that non-mobile four-way junctions undergo a dramatic shift in conformation in the presence of magnesium. Our data suggest that a similar transition occurs for the mobile Holliday junction. We also discuss how proteins may facilitate branch migration through sequence heterologies in vivo.     

Interaction of the resolving enzyme YDC2 with the four-way DNA junction

Holliday junctions (four-way DNA junctions), formed during homologous recombination, are bound and resolved by junction-specific endonucleases to yield recombinant duplex DNA products. The junction-resolving enzymes are a structurally diverse class of proteins that nevertheless have many properties in common; in particular a high structure specificity for binding and metal-dependent, (frequently) sequence-specific cleavage activity. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the enzyme CCE1 is necessary for the resolution of recombining mitochondrial genomes, and in Schizosaccharomyces pombe the homologous protein YDC2 is thought to have a similar function. We have generated an inactive mutant of YDC2, D226N, that retains structure-specific junction binding and have analysed the interaction of this protein with the four-way DNA junction. YDC2 binds the four-way junction in two specific complexes (I and II), unfolding the stacked X-structure into a conformation where the arms extend to the four corners of a square. This structure is reminiscent of that of the free junction in the absence of metal ions and of the structures imposed on the Holliday junction by CCE1 and RuvA. DNase I probing reveals footprints specific for complexes I and II which extend from the junction centre on all four arms. No protection is observed with the small, hydrophobic probe DMS.     

Dissection of the sequence specificity of the Holliday junction endonuclease CCE1

CCE1 is a Holliday (four-way DNA) junction-specific endonuclease which resolves mitochondrial DNA recombination intermediates in Saccharomycescerevisiae. The junction-resolving enzymes are a diverse class, widely distributed in nature from viruses to higher eukaryotes. In common with most other junction-resolving enzymes, the cleavage activity of CCE1 is nucleotide sequence-dependent. We have undertaken a systematic study of the sequence specificity of CCE1, using a single-turnover kinetic assay and a panel of synthetic four-way DNA junction substrates. A tetranucleotide consensus cleavage sequence 5'-ACT downward arrowA has been identified, with specificity residing mainly at the central CT dinucleotide. Equilibrium constants for CCE1 binding to four-way junctions are unaffected by sequence variations, suggesting that substrate discrimination occurs predominantly in the transition state complex. CCE1 cuts most efficiently at the junction center, but can also cleave the DNA backbone at positions one nucleotide 3' or 5' of the point of strand exchange, suggesting a significant degree of conformational flexibility in the CCE1:junction complex. Introduction of base analogues at single sites in four-way junctions has allowed investigation of the sequence specificity of CCE1 in finer detail. In particular, the N7 moiety of the guanine base-pairing with the cytosine of the consensus sequence appears to be crucial for catalysis. The functional significance of sequence specificity in junction-resolving enzymes is discussed.     

Twin-twin transfusion syndrome: the challenge of etiology-based management decisions

Here we present the crystal structure of the Escherichia coli protein RuvA bound to a key DNA intermediate in recombination, the Holliday junction. The structure, solved by isomorphous replacement and density modification at 6 A resolution, reveals the molecular architecture at the heart of the branch migration and resolution reactions required to process Holliday intermediates into recombinant DNA molecules. It also reveals directly for the first time the structure of the Holliday junction. A single RuvA tetramer is bound to one face of a junction whose four DNA duplex arms are arranged in an open and essentially four-fold symmetric conformation. Protein-DNA contacts are mediated by two copies of a helix-hairpin-helix motif per RuvA subunit that contact the phosphate backbone in a very similar manner. The open structure of the junction stabilized by RuvA binding exposes a DNA surface that could be bound by the RuvC endonuclease to promote resolution.     

Characterization of the low magnification performance of a Philips CM300-FEG

BACKGROUND: All the ruvA, ruvB and ruvC mutants of Escherichia coli are sensitive to treatments that damage DNA, and are mildly defective in homologous recombination. It has been reported that the ruv mutants form nonseptate, multinuclear filaments after low doses of UV irradiation, dependent on the sfiA gene product. In vitro, the RuvAB complex promotes the branch migration of Holliday junctions, and RuvC resolves the junctions endonucleolytically. RESULTS: After a low UV dose (5 J/m2), both delta ruvAB and delta ruvC mutant cells became filamentous, with their chromosomes aggregated in the central region. This corresponded to an increase in nonmigrating DNA on pulsed field gel electrophoresis of the XbaI digested chromosome. Upon further incubation, they produced a large number of anucleoid cells of normal size. A recA mutation, but not a recB mutation, suppressed these phenotypes of the ruv mutants. The ruv polA12(Ts) double mutants were inviable at the nonpermissive temperature and mimicked the morphological phenotypes of the UV irradiated ruv mutants. CONCLUSION: ruvA, B and C mutations block chromosome partitioning in UV irradiated cells because the abortive homologous recombination covalently links chromosomes together. There is a recBCD independent pathway for the recA dependent formation of recombination intermediates. An Ruv-mediated resolution of recombination intermediates is required for the repair of strand breaks produced in UV irradiated cells and in the polA mutant cells.     

Identification of three aspartic acid residues essential for catalysis by the RusA holliday junction resolvase

RusA is a Holliday junction resolvase encoded by the cryptic prophage DLP12 of Escherichia coli K-12 that can be activated to promote homologous recombination and DNA repair in resolution-deficient mutants lacking the RuvABC proteins. Database searches with the 120 amino acid residue RusA sequence identified 11 homologues from diverse species, including one from the extreme thermophile Aquifex aeolicus, which suggests that RusA may be of ancient bacterial ancestry. A multiple alignment of these sequences revealed seven conserved or invariant acidic residues in the C-terminal half of the E. coli protein. By making site-directed mutations at these positions and analysing the ability of the mutant proteins to promote DNA repair in vivo and to resolve junctions in vitro, we identified three aspartic acid residues (D70, D72 and D91) that are essential for catalysis and that provide the first insight into the active-site mechanism of junction resolution by RusA. Substitution of any one of these three residues with asparagine reduces resolution activity >80-fold. The mutant proteins retain the ability to bind junction DNA regardless of the DNA sequence or of the mobility of the crossover. They interfere with the function of the RuvABC proteins in vivo, when expressed from a multicopy plasmid, an effect that is reproducible in vitro and that reflects the fact that the RusA proteins have a higher affinity for junction DNA in the presence of Mg2+ than do the RuvA and RuvC proteins. The D70N protein has a greater affinity for junctions in Mg2+ than does the wild-type, which indicates that the negatively charged carboxyl group of the aspartate residue plays a critical role at the active site of RusA. Electrostatic repulsions between D70, D72 and D91 may help to form a classical Mg2+-binding pocket.     

Escherichia coli RuvBL268S: a mutant RuvB protein that exhibits wild-type activities in vitro but confers a UV-sensitive ruv phenotype in vivo

The RuvABC proteins of Escherichia coli process recombination intermediates during genetic recombination and DNA repair. RuvA and RuvB promote branch migration of Holliday junctions, a process that extends heteroduplex DNA. Together with RuvC, they form a RuvABC complex capable of Holliday junction resolution. Branch migration by RuvAB is mediated by RuvB, a hexameric ring protein that acts as an ATP-driven molecular pump. To gain insight into the mechanism of branch migration, random mutations were introduced into the ruvB gene by PCR and a collection of mutant alleles were obtained. Mutation of leucine 268 to serine resulted in a severe UV-sensitive phenotype, characteristic of a ruv defect. Here, we report a biochemical analysis of the mutant protein RuvBL268S. Unexpectedly, the purified protein is fully active in vitro with regard to its ATPase, DNA binding and DNA unwinding activities. It also promotes efficient branch migration in combination with RuvA, and forms functional RuvABC-Holliday junction resolvase complexes. These results indicate that RuvB may perform some additional, and as yet undefined, function that is necessary for cell survival after UV-irradiation.     

Sequence specificity and biochemical characterization of the RusA Holliday junction resolvase of Escherichia coli

The RusA protein of Escherichia coli is an endonuclease that resolves Holliday intermediates in recombination and DNA repair. Analysis of its subunit structure revealed that the native protein is a dimer. Its resolution activity was investigated using synthetic X-junctions with homologous cores. Resolution occurs by dual strand incision predominantly 5' of CC dinucleotides located symmetrically. A junction lacking homology is not resolved. The efficiency of resolution is related inversely to the number of base pairs in the homologous core, which suggests that branch migration is rate-limiting. Inhibition of resolution at high ratios of protein to DNA suggests that binding of RusA may immobilize the junction point at non-cleavable sites. Resolution is stimulated by alkaline pH and by Mn2+. The protein is unstable in the absence of substrate DNA and loses approximately 80% of its activity within 1 min under standard reaction conditions. DNA binding stabilizes the activity. Junction resolution is inhibited in the presence of RuvA. This observation probably explains why RusA is unable to promote efficient recombination and DNA repair in ruvA+ strains unless it is expressed at a high level.     

Role of partner homology in DNA recombination. Complementary base pairing orients the 5'-hydroxyl for strand joining during Flp site-specific recombination

Absolute homology between partner substrates within the strand exchange region is an essential requirement for recombination mediated by the yeast site-specific recombinase Flp. Using combinations of specially designed half- and full-site Flp substrates, we demonstrate that the strand joining step of recombination is exquisitely sensitive to spacer homology. At each exchange point, 2-3 spacer nucleotides adjacent to the nick within the cleaved strand of one substrate must base pair with the corresponding segment of the un-nicked strand from the second substrate for efficient strand joining in the recombinant mode. In accordance with the "cis-activation/trans-nucleophilic attack" model for each of the two transesterification steps of Flp recombination (strand cleavage and strand joining), we propose that the limited strand pairing orients the DNA-nucleophile (5'-hydroxyl) for attack on its target diester (3'-phosphotyrosyl-Flp). During one round of recombination, 4-6 terminal base pairs of the spacer (2-3 base pairs at each spacer end) must unpair, following strand cleavage, within a DNA substrate and pair with the partner substrate prior to strand union. In this model, the extent of branch migration of the covalently closed Holliday intermediate is limited to the central core of the spacer. The templated positioning of reactive nucleic acid groups (which is central to the model) may be utilized by other recombination systems and by RNA splicing reactions.     

Stochastic model for a wavelike exothermal reaction in condensed heterogeneous systems

The labile protons of two 32-base-pair, four-arm models of immobile Holliday junctions have been studied by two-dimensional 1H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. Overlap of resonances in the imino-imino region of two-dimensional nuclear Overhauser enhancement (NOE) spectra necessitates the use of a multi-pathway approach for obtaining sequence-specific assignments wherein all possible NOE connectivities to the labile protons are utilized, including those from the 2H of adenine, 5CH3 of thymine, and 5H of cytosine. Resonance assignments are obtained for all slowly exchanging imino and cytosine amino protons. Base-pairing up to and including the junction point is found in all four arms of both Holliday junctions. Several cross-arm NOE connectivities are identified and can be used to infer the geometry of the helical stacking domains. The two Holliday junctions studied, which differ only by the exchange of two base pairs at the branch point, appear to have opposite arm stacking geometries. These assignments form an important part of the critical background for detailed NMR analysis of Holliday junction structure and dynamics.     

A general model for site-specific recombination by the integrase family recombinases

We present here a general model for integrase family site-specific recombination using the geometric relationships of the cleavable phosphodiester bonds and the disposition of the recombinase monomers (defined by their binding planes) with respect to them. The 'oscillation model' is based largely on the conformations of the recombinase-bound DNA duplexes and their dynamics within Holliday junctions. The duplex substrate or the Holliday junction intermediate is capable of 'oscillating' between two cleavage-competent asymmetric states with respect to corres-ponding chemically inert 'equilibrium positions'. The model accommodates several features of the Flp system and predicts two modes of DNA cleavage during a normal recombination event. It is equally applicable to other systems that mediate recombination across 6, 7 or 8 bp long strand exchange regions (or spacers). The model is consistent with approximately 0-1, 1-2 and 2-3 bp of branch migration during recombination reactions involving 6, 7 and 8 bp spacers, respectively.     

Genetic stability of gene-targeted immunoglobulin loci. II. Influence of the cell line and the vector linearization site

The site-specific integration of exogenous gene fragments by homologous recombination provides a convenient method for altering the immunoglobulin loci of B cells and specifically designing antibody molecules. To introduce a human isotype into the heavy chain locus of mouse hybridoma cells we compared the recombination frequencies of vectors that could be linearized either as integration or as replacement constructs in different cell lines. Integration as well as replacement recombination was observed, irrespective of the location of the site at which the vector was cleaved. Integration events involving the human IgG1 vectors were lost at high frequency due to secondary vector excision, so that all stable recombinations were found to be replacement events. Replacement recombination of an integration vector involves an illegitimate crossover at least at the 3' side and sometimes gives rise to deletion of the CH1 domain. However, a homologous event at the 3' side is more efficient than an illegitimate one, so that a homology that is distributed on both sides of the heterologous region promotes targeting at higher frequency than a contiguous sequence of the same total length. The position of the linearization site in the vector markedly influenced the targeting efficiency, but surprisingly, whether a double-strand break in the homology or in the heterology region more efficiently promoted integration was dependent on the cell line. In all cells, however, cleavage of the vector outside the homology region favoured stable replacements with a bias against CH1-truncated clones. We further show that the frequency of replacements induced by integration vectors is not correlated to the homology length and cannot be increased by irradiation of the cells. Our findings indicate that for targeting the IgH locus other mechanisms might be involved than at other loci.     

Sensing homology at the strand-swapping step in lambda excisive recombination

lambda Site-specific recombination requires a short stretch of sequence homology that might be sensed during strand swapping, during ligation and/or during isomerization of the obligate Holliday junction intermediate. Here, we use half-att site suicide substrates to study single and double top-strand-transfers, isolated from the subsequent steps of the reaction. The double-strand-transfer is analogous to a top-strand exchange and consists of one normal top-strand and one "contrary" bottom-strand to top-strand ligation between the half-att site substrate and its full-site partner. The resulting covalent three-way DNA junctions are poor substrates for resolution in the forward or reverse direction. We show that both the rate and the efficiency of Y-junction formation are homology dependent. Pairing of three nucleotides (either in the forward or in the contrary alignment) provides maximal stability to strand swapping. Complementary base-pairing next to one top-strand site (with or without ligation) stimulates strand-transfer at the other mismatched site. The data suggest that homology can be sensed at the strand-swapping step before ligation. However, homology also stimulates ligation and stabilizes the products, as is evident from the different rates of closed Y-junction formation in the presence or absence of homology. Furthermore, under recombination conditions, single top-strand-transfers are subject to reversal even in the presence of sequence homology; stability depends on a double-strand-transfer, i.e. dissociation of covalent Int.     

Double-strand break repair in Ku86- and XRCC4-deficient cells

The Ku86 and XRCC4 proteins perform critical but poorly understood functions in the repair of DNA double-strand breaks. Both Ku 86- and XRCC4-deficient cells exhibit profound radiosensitivity and severe defects in V(D)J recombination, including excessive deletions at recombinant junctions. Previous workers have suggested that these phenomena may reflect defects in joining of the broken DNA ends or in protection of the ends from nucleases. However, end joining in XRCC4-deficient cells has not been examined. Here we show that joining of both matched and mismatched DNA ends occurs efficiently in XRCC4-deficient cells. Furthermore, analysis of junctions shows that XRCC4 is not required to protect the ends from degradation. However, nucleotide sequence analysis of junctions derived from joining of mismatched DNA ends in XRCC4-deficient cells revealed a strong preference for a junction containing a 7 nt homology. Similar results were obtained in Ku86-deficient cells. These data suggest that in the absence of XRCC4 or Ku86, joining is assisted by base pairing interactions, supporting the hypothesis that these proteins may participate in aligning or stabilizing intermediates in end joining.