The prediction of cutting forces in the ball-end milling process—II. Cut geometry analysis and model verification

This paper presents a model for the prediction of cutting forces in the ball-end milling process. The steps used in developing the force model are based on the mechanistic principles of metal cutting. The cutting forces are calculated on the basis of the engaged cut geometry, the underformed chip thickness distribution along the cutting edges, and the empirical relationships that relate the cutting forces to the undeformed chip geometry. A simplified cutter runout model, which characterizes the effect of cutter axis offset and tilt on the undeformed chip geometry, has been formulated. A model building procedure based on experimentally measured average forces and the associated runout data is developed to identify the numerical values of the empirical model parameters for the particular workpiece/cutter combination.     

Compensation of progressive radial run-out in face-milling by spindle speed variation

This paper investigates the use of spindle speed variation to compensate for progressive radial run-out in the face-milling process. Machine setup errors like spindle axis tilt, cutter axis tilt and cutter center offset result in radial and axial run-out on the inserts. Cutter center offset, in particular, results in progressive radial run-out on the inserts which can be compensated by continuously varying the spindle speed in a sinusoidal pattern. The amplitude and phase of the sinusoidal trajectory significantly influence the capability of this technique for run-out compensation. A method is proposed for selection of optimal values of the speed variation amplitude and phase based on the idea of matching the chip load pattern under variable speed machining conditions in the presence of progressive radial run-out with that of constant speed machining in the absence of any run-out. Experiments performed with optimal values of the speed variation parameters show a significant reduction in the cutting force component at the spindle frequency and a shift in the frequency content of cutting force from the harmonics of the spindle frequency to those of the tooth passing frequency. An industrial implementation strategy of the proposed scheme is also presented that integrates run-out estimation with its subsequent compensation.     

Time domain model of plunge milling operation

Plunge milling operations are used to remove excess material rapidly in roughing operations. The cutter is fed in the direction of spindle axis which has the highest structural rigidity. This paper presents time domain modeling of mechanics and dynamics of plunge milling process. The cutter is assumed to be flexible in lateral, axial, and torsional directions. The rigid body feed motion of the cutter and structural vibrations of the tool are combined to evaluate time varying dynamic chip load distribution along the cutting edge. The cutting forces in lateral and axial directions and torque are predicted by considering the feed, radial engagement, tool geometry, spindle speed, and the regeneration of the chip load due to vibrations. The mathematical model is experimentally validated by comparing simulated forces and vibrations against measurements collected from plunge milling tests. The study shows that the lateral forces and vibrations exist only if the inserts are not symmetric, and the primary source of chatter is the torsional–axial vibrations of the plunge mill. The chatter vibrations can be reduced by increasing the torsional stiffness with strengthened flute cavities.     

Milling force convolution modeling for identification of cutter axis offset

This paper discusses the application of a convolution integral force model to the identification of the geometry of cutter axis offset in milling operations. This analysis builds upon the basis of linear decomposition of elemental local cutting forces into a nominal component and an offset-induced component. The convolution of each elemental local cutting force component with the chip width density in the context of cutter angular position provides an integral expression for the total cutting forces. By virtue of the convolution integration property, the total cutting forces in the frequency domain can be derived as closed-form functions of the cutting pressure constants, various cutting conditions, as well as the cutter offset geometry. Subsequently, the magnitude and phase angle of cutter axis offset are shown to be algebraic and explicit functions of the Fourier series coefficients of cutting forces at the spindle frequency. Following the theoretical analysis, experimental study is discussed to illustrate the implementation procedure for offset identification, and frequency domain data are presented to verify the analytical results. Potential industrial applications of this work include the real-time monitoring of dynamic cutter runout and the in-process compensation for the loss of tolerance or finish using automatic controls based on the feedback information of offset magnitude and phase angle.     

The prediction of dimensional error for sculptured surface productions using the ball-end milling process. Part 1: Chip geometry analysis and cutting force prediction

The study of machining errors caused by tool deflection in the balkend milling process involves four issues, namely the chip geometry, the cutting force, the tool deflection and the deflection sensitivity of the surface geometry. In this paper, chip geometry and cutting force are investigated. The study on chip geometry includes the undeformed radial chip thickness, the chip engagement surface and the relationship between feed boundary and feed angle. For cutting force prediction, a rigid force model and a flexible force model are developed. Instantaneous cutting forces of a machining experiment for two 2D sculptured surfaces produced by the ball-end milling process are simulated using these force models and are verified by force measurements. This information is used in Part 2 of this paper, together with a tool deflection model and the deflection sensitivity of the surface geometry, to predict the machining errors of the machined sculptured surfaces.     

Effect of cutter runout on process geometry and forces in peripheral milling of curved surfaces with variable curvature

This paper presents a novel method for cutting force modeling related to peripheral milling of curved surfaces including the effect of cutter runout, which often changes the rotation radii of cutting points. Emphasis is put on how to efficiently incorporate the continuously changing workpiece geometry along the tool path into the calculation procedure of tool position, feed direction, instantaneous uncut chip thickness (IUCT) and entry/exit angles, which are required in the calculation of cutting force. Mathematical models are derived in detail to calculate these process parameters in occurrence of cutter runout. On the basis of developed models, some key techniques related to the prediction of the instantaneous cutting forces in peripheral milling of curved surfaces are suggested together with a whole simulation procedure. Experiments are performed to verify the predicted cutting forces; meanwhile, the efficiency of the proposed method is highlighted by a comparative study of the existing method taken from the literature.     

Effect of tool setting error on the topography of surfaces machined by peripheral milling

In peripheral milling operations, errors in the tool setting on the spindle create roughness heterogeneity bands on the milled surfaces. This represents a defect in the appearance of the surfaces that cannot be ignored when surfaces have to meet high aesthetic requirements. Although the existence of these bands has been reported long ago, a quantitative evaluation has not been made so far.This paper presents a new model that allows the prediction of bands generated on surfaces machined by peripheral milling. This model accounts for tool setting errors: cutter parallel axis offset and cutter axis tilt. Through the proposed model, the effects of tool setting error, cutter geometry and feed, on band position, width and roughness are evaluated. Cutting tests were carried out to validate the model predictions and it was found that model predictions on band position and width agreed reasonably well with experimental results.     

Use of radial forces for fault detection in tapping

A model-based method for fault detection in tapping based on torque and radial forces is proposed. The method allows the identification of faults typical of a tapping operation including axial misalignment, tap runout, tooth breakage both singly and together. The validation experiments have been run on aluminum 356 workpieces for different combinations of process faults. Results have shown that the model predictions are in good agreement with the experimental radial force and torque signals under various fault conditions.     

Numerical simulation and prediction of cutting forces in five-axis milling processes with cutter run-out

Radial cutter runout is a common issue in milling processes and has a direct effect on milling stability due to variations of resulting chip load and forces. This paper presents a new method to effectively model and predict the instantaneous cutting forces in 5-axis milling processes with radial cutter runout based on tool motion analysis. First, the undeformed chip thickness model taking runout effect into account is established under continuous change of cutter axis orientation by means of the sweep traces of cutter edges. Second, the engaged cutting edge is determined and cutting coefficients are subsequently calibrated. Finally, the method of identifying runout parameters from the measured cutting forces is proposed, and mechanistic method is then applied to predict the cutting force. Since this method is completely based on the relative motion analysis of tool-part, it can reduce the prediction errors of cutting forces effectively and is suitable for generic rotation cutters. Several validation examples are given under different cutting conditions to prove its effectiveness and accuracy. The results reveal that the developed method can predict the cutter forces with a high accuracy and has the ability to be used in simulations and optimizations of five-axis machining.     

Cutting force model for multi-toothed cutting processes and force measuring equipment for face milling

This article presents a mechanical cutting force model for multi-tooth cutting processes, where initial position errors in radial and axial direction, eccentricity and edge wear are taken into account. The cutting forces are presented for each individual cutting edge, and in a system of coordinates where one axis is parallel to the cutting speed vector at any instant. The process parameter cutting resistance, C_r is derived from the measured main cutting force F_M. C_r should be regarded as a parameter since it is always increasing with decreasing values of theoretical chip thickness h₁. A new way of measuring cutting forces in multi-tooth cutting processes is also presented. Eight cutting force components are measured on the tool close to each of the four cutting edges. The aroused signals are filtered, amplified, A/D-converted and put together in a serial stream for transmission through a hollow spindle via a fibre optic cable. The signals are sent from the rotating spindle to the frame of the machine over an air gap with Light Emitting Diodes. They are then demultiplexed, D/A-converted, and stored in a PC-based eight channel oscilloscope. With this measurement equipment it is possible to directly measure the cutting forces acting on each individual cutting edge.     

Virtual Design and Optimization of Machine Tool Spindles

An integrated digital model of spindle, tool holder, tool and cutting process is presented. The spindle is modeled using an in-house developed Finite Element system. The preload on the bearings and the influence of gyroscopic and centrifugal forces from all rotating parts due to speed are considered. The bearing stiffness, mode shapes, Frequency Response Function at any point on the spindle can be predicted. The static and dynamic deflections along the spindle shaft as well as contact forces on the bearings can be predicted with simulated cutting forces before physically building and testing the spindles. The spacing of the bearings are optimized to achieve either maximum dynamics stiffness or maximum chatter free depth of cut at the desired speed region for a given cutter geometry and work-piece material. It is possible to add constraints to model mounting of the spindle on the machine tool, as well as defining local springs and damping elements at any nodal point on the spindle. The model is verified experimentally.     

Direct adaptive control of end milling process

A direct adaptive control algorithm, which is spindle speed and drive dynamics independent, has been developed for machining operations. The combined dynamics of feed motion and cutting process are modelled as a third order system whose parameters may vary with spindle speed and part geometry changes during machining. The algorithm does not use any specific time interval, thus sampling time dependent discrete transfer functions and pole assignments are avoided. The adaptive controller is designed to have a closed loop characteristic function which behaves like an open loop regular and stable machining operation. The proposed direct adaptive controller is practical, can be used in any multi-axes machining, and can be combined with chatter suppression techniques which require spindle speed regulation. The algorithm is applied to the adaptive control of milling. Satisfactory results are obtained in constraining the maximum cutting forces and dimensional surface errors in milling experiments.     

Dynamic analysis of runout correction in milling

Tool runout and its effects is an important area of research within modelling, simulation, and control of milling forces. Tool runout causes tool cutting edges to experience uneven forces during milling. This fact also affects tool life and deteriorates workpiece surface quality. In this article a procedure, in order to diminish the effects of tool runout, is presented. The procedure is based on chip thickness modification by means of the fast correction of the tool feed rate. Dynamic feed rate modification is provided by superposing our own design of a fast feed system driven by a piezoelectric actuator to the conventional feed drive of the CNC machine tool. Previously, a model of the dynamic behaviour of the system was developed to analyze the influence of fast feed rate modification on cutting forces. The model incorporates the piezoelectric actuator response as well as the structural dynamics of the tool and the designed Fast Feed Drive System (FFDS). Simulated and experimental results presented in this paper show the effectiveness and benefits of this new tool runout correction procedure.     

Virtual High Performance Milling

The goal of future manufacturing is to design, test and manufacture parts in a virtual environment before they are manufactured on the shop floor. This paper presents a generalized process simulation and optimization strategy for 2 1/2 axis milling operations to increase Material Removal Rate (MRR) while avoiding machining errors. The process is optimized at two stages. Optimal spindle speed, radial and axial depth of cut are recommended to process planner by considering the chatter, and spindle's torque/power limits. The cutter-part engagement conditions are extracted from CAD system by geometrically processing the NC program and part geometry. Long tool path segments are broken into smaller segments whenever the geometry varies. The spindle speed and feed fields of the NC program are automatically optimized by constraining maximum torque, power, tool deflection and chip load set by the user. The acceleration and speed limits of the machine tool feed drives are considered to prevent frequent variations of the feed unnecessarily. The optimization is experimentally verified by milling a helicopter gear box cover on a high speed, horizontal machining centre.     

Process geometry modeling with cutter runout for milling of curved surfaces

Prediction of cutting forces and machined surface error in peripheral milling of curved geometries is non-trivial due to varying workpiece curvature along tool path. The complexity in this case, arises due to continuously changing process geometry as workpiece curvature varies along tool path. In the presence of cutter runout, the situation is further complicated owing to changing radii of cutting points. The present work attempts to model process geometry in machining of curved geometries and in the presence of cutter runout. A mathematical model computing process geometry parameters which include cutter/workpiece engagements and instantaneous uncut chip thickness in the presence of cutter runout is presented. The developed model is more realistic as it accounts for interaction of cutting tooth trajectory with that of preceding teeth trajectories in computing process geometry. Computer simulation studies carried for this purpose has shown that it is essential to account for teeth trajectory interactions for accurate prediction of process geometry parameters. This aspect is further confirmed with machining experiments, which were conducted to validate this aspect. From the outcomes of present work, it is clearly seen that the computation of process geometry during machining of curved geometries and in presence of cutter runout is not straightforward and requires a systematic approach as presented in this paper.     

A cutting force model for finishing processes using helical end mills with significant runout

Analytical cutting force models play an important role in a wide array of simulation approaches of milling processes. The accuracy of the simulated processes directly depends on the predictive power of the applied cutting force model, which may vary under specific circumstances. End milling processes with small radial cutting depths, e.g. finishing processes, are particularly problematic. In this case, the tool runout, which is usually neglected in established cutting force models, can become quite significant. Within this article, well-known cutting force models are implemented for runout-prone finishing processes and modified by integrating additional parameters. A method is presented for how these additional runout parameters can be efficiently determined alongside commonly used cutting coefficients. For this purpose, a large number of milling experiments have been performed where the cutting forces were directly measured using a stationary dynamometer. The measured cutting forces were compared with the simulated cutting forces to verify and assess the modified model. By using the presented model and calibration method, cutting forces can be accurately predicted even for small radial cutting depths and significant tool runout.     

Identification of cutter offset in end milling without a prior knowledge of cutting coefficients

This paper presents a method for the identification of cutter offset through milling force without requiring the specific cutting coefficients to be known as priori. The total milling force in the presence of cutter offset is first obtained on the basis of dual cutting mechanisms, where the local force is comprised of a constant plowing force and a linear shearing force proportional to the chip load under the cutter offset. The total milling force is synthesized through convolution and is shown to be the sum of three force components: the nominal chip shearing force component, the plowing force components and the offset related shearing force component. Fourier analysis of these force components reveals the effects of offset geometry and yields formulas for the identification of offset geometry. The identification process requires only two cutting tests and the evaluation of two algebraic expressions; the shearing constants are found from the average forces of cutting tests and the offset geometry is identified from the force component at the spindle frequency. Through numerical simulation and experimental results, the efficacy of the identification method is demonstrated; the effects of feed per tooth and cutting depths on the accuracy of the model are investigated and criteria for the appropriate selection of these parameters are suggested.     

端铣加工面尺寸误差预测

为了精确预测端铣加工面尺寸误差,利用铣削动态力卷积模型,引入表面生成窗概念,并考虑到工件与刀具的变形误差、机床空间误差与刀具偏摆的影响,建立了加工面尺寸误差预测模型。通过在铣床上进行实验,验证了该模型能够正确预测工件尺寸误差及其分布范围,且在铣刀轴向切深、主轴转速和进给速度一定的情况下,增加径向切深不会对工件尺寸误差产生显著影响。     

Generalized modeling of drilling vibrations. Part II: Chatter stability in frequency domain

A time domain model of the drilling process and hole formation mechanism is presented in Part I, and the general solution of drilling chatter stability in frequency domain is presented in this paper. The drill's flexibility in torsional, axial and lateral directions are considered in determining the regenerative chip thickness. Stability is modelled as a fourth order eigenvalue problem with a regenerative delay term. The critical radial depth of cut and spindle speed are analytically determined from the eigenvalues of the characteristics equation of the dynamic drilling process in frequency domain. The method is compared against the extensive numerical solutions in time domain which were presented in Part I, cutting experiments and previously published partial stability laws. The time domain model presented in Part I of the paper considers tool geometry dependent mechanics, all vibration directions and the true kinematics of drilling, while allowing for nonlinearities such as tool jumping out of cut and nonlinear cutting force models. It is shown that accurate prediction of drilling stability requires modeling of drill/hole surface contact stiffness and damping which is still a research challenge.     

Generalized modeling of drilling vibrations. Part I: Time domain model of drilling kinematics, dynamics and hole formation

This two part paper presents a comprehensive exercise in modeling dynamics, kinematics and stability in drilling operations. While Part II focuses on the chatter stability of drilling in frequency domain, Part I presents a three-dimensional (3D) dynamic model of drilling which considers rigid body motion, and torsional–axial and lateral vibrations in drilling, and resulting hole formation. The model is used to investigate: (a) the mechanism of whirling vibrations, which occur due to lateral drill deflections; (b) lateral chatter vibrations; and (c) combined lateral and torsional–axial vibrations. Mechanistic cutting force models are used to accurately predict lateral forces, torque and thrust as functions of feedrate, radial depth of cut, drill geometry and vibrations. Grinding errors reflected on the drill geometry are considered in the model. A 3D workpiece, consisting of a cylindrical hole wall and a hole bottom surface, is fed to the rotating drill while the structural vibrations are excited by the cutting forces. The mechanism of whirling vibrations is explained, and the hole wall formation during whirling vibrations is investigated by imposing commonly observed whirling motion on the drill. The time domain model is used to predict the cutting forces and frequency content as well as the shape of the hole wall, and how it depends on the amplitude and frequency of the whirling vibration. The model is also used to predict regenerative, lateral chatter vibrations. The influence of pilot hole size, spindle speed and torsional–axial chatter on lateral vibrations is observed from experimental cutting forces, frequency spectra and shows good similarity with simulation results. The effect of the drill–hole surface contact during drilling is discussed by observing the discrepancies between the numerical model of the drilling process and experimental measurements.