A single amino acid substitution can restore the solubility of aggregated colicin A mutants in Escherichia coli

Mutants of colicin A have been prepared in which the three tryptophanresidues (Trp86, Trpl30 and Trpl40), localized in the C-terminaldomain of the soluble wild-type protein, have been substitutedby phenylalanine. The Trpl40Phe single mutation had the effectof decreasing the percentage of protein that is expressed asinsoluble aggregates. The created hydrophobic cavity decreasedthe stability of the protein during its folding, resulting inpartial aggregation in the cytoplasm of the Escherichia coli-producingcells. Aggregation was increased when Trpl40 was substitutedby Lys, Leu or Cys, or if the Trpl40 mutation was combined withthe Trp86Phe and/ or Trpl30Phe mutations. A single mutation,Lysll3Phe, however, was able to restore the solubility of theaggregated mutants in vivo. Detailed analysis of the 3-D structureof the C-terminal domain of colicin A suggests that fillingof the hydrophobic cavity is responsible for this effect.     

Enhanced dead-end elimination in the search for the global minimum energy conformation of a collection of protein side chains

Although the conformational states of protein side chains canbe described using a library of rotamers, the determinationof the global minimum energy conformation (GMEC) of a largecollection of side chains, given fixed backbone coordinates,represents a challenging combinatorial problem with importantapplications in the field of homology modelling. Recently, wehave developed a theoretical framework, called the dead-endelimination method, which allows us to identify efficientlyrotamers that cannot be members of the GMEC. Such dead-endingrotamers can be iteratively removed from the system under studythereby tracking down the size of the combinatorial problem.Here we present new developments to the dead-end eliminationmethod that allow us to handle larger proteins and more extensiverotamer libraries. These developments encompass (i) a procedureto determine weight factors in the generalized dead-end eliminationtheorem thereby enhancing the elimination of dead-ending rotamersand (ii) a novel strategy, mainly based on logical argumentsderived from the logic pairs theorem, to use dead-ending rotamerpairs in the efficient elimination of single rotamers. Thesedevelopments are illustrated for proteins of various sizes andthe flow of the current method is discussed in detail. The effectivenessof dead-end elimination is increased by two orders of magnitudeas compared with previous work. In addition, it now becomesfeasible to use extremely detailed libraries. We also providean appendix in which the validity of the generalized dead-endcriterion is shown. Finally, perspectives for further applicationswhich may now become within reach are discussed.     

Redesigning a sweet protein: increased stability and renaturability

Monellin is one of two natural proteins from African berrieswith potent sweet taste. Monellin is the smaller of the two,and consists of two peptides. The protein loses sweetness whenheated above 50°C under acidic pH. Based on the crystalstructure of monellin we have fused the two chains into a singlechain using several different linkers copied and ‘transplanted’from the same molecule. One of the newly designed proteins isas potently sweet as the natural one, is more stable upon temperatureor pH changes, and renatures easily even after heating to 100°Cat low pH.     

Coordinated amino acid changes in homologous protein families

In the tobamovirus coat protein family, amino acid residuesat some spatially close positions are found to be substitutedin a coordinated manner [Altschuh et al. (1987) J. Mol. Biol.,193,693]. Therefore, these positions show an identical patternof amino acid substitutions when amino acid sequences of thesehomologous proteins are aligned. Based on this principle, coordinatedsubstitutions have been searched for in three additional proteinfamilies: serine proteases, cysteine proteases and the haemoglobins.Coordinated changes have been found in all three protein familiesmostly within structurally constrained regions. This methodworks with a varying degree of success depending on the functionof the proteins, the range of sequence similarities and thenumber of sequences considered. By relaxing the criteria forresidue selection, the method was adapted to cover a broaderrange of protein families and to study regions of the proteinshaving weaker structural constraints. The information derivedby these methods provides a general guide for engineering ofa large variety of proteins to analyse structure–functionrelationships.     

The role of heat-shock and chaperone proteins in protein folding: possible molecular mechanisms

Recently some heat-shock proteins have been linked to functionsof ‘chaperoning’ protein folding in vivo. Here currentexperimental evidence is reviewed and possible requirementsfor such an activity are discussed. It is proposed that onemode of chaperone action is to actively unfold misfolded orbadly aggregated proteins to a conformation from whkh they couldrefold spontaneously; that improperly folded proteins are recognizedby excessive stretches of solvent-exposed backbone, rather thanby exposed hydrophobic patches; and that the molecular mechanismfor unfolding is either repeated binding and dissociation (‘plucking’)or translocation of the protein backbone through a binding cleft(‘threading’), allowing the threaded chain to refoldspontaneously. The observed hydrolysis of ATP would providethe energy for active unfolding. These hypotheses can be appliedto both monomeric folding and oligomeric assembly and are sufficientlydetailed to be open to directed experimental verification.     

Complex additivity of the effects of suppressor mutations in differing protein environments

In the -complementation of -galactosidase, a defective ß-galactosidaseprotein interacts with an autologous peptide fragment (-peptide)to restore enzymatic activity. Within a specific site of a defective-peptide we have previously isolated a large number of mutations,many of which suppress the functional defect. The -peptide wasoriginally defective due to both insertional and substitutionalsequence alteration near its N-terminus, which provided an increasein the sensitivity of detection of (suppressor) secondary mutationswhich conferred improved function. We have now studied the effectsof the suppressor mutations when the primary deleterious mutationsare sequentially reversed. This was done in intact ß-galactosidase,as we have shown that mutations in the -peptide have relatedfunctional effects in the whole protein. Evidence was obtainedshowing that the effects of at least some suppressor mutationswere not simply additive when the mutations are placed intothe original wild-type protein environment. One suppressor appearedto function less effectively in the normal environment, whileanother when tested in the same manner functioned at a relativelyincreased level. This failure to show simple additivity maybe attributable to the physical proximity of the original defectivemutations and the introduced suppressors. Nevertheless, evenin such cases it may be feasible to use a defective proteinas a sensitive starting point for the identification of mutationswhich improve the wild-type protein.     

Homogenization and crystallization of histidine ammonia-lyase by exchange of a surface cysteine residue

Histidase (histidine ammonia-lyase, EC 4.3.1.3) from Pseudomonasputida was expressed in Escherichia coli and purified. In theabsence of thiols the tetrameric enzyme gave rise to undefinedaggregates and suitable crystals could not be obtained. Thesolvent accessibility along the chain was predicted from theamino acid sequence. Among the seven cysteines, only one waslabeled as `solvent-exposed'. The exchange of this cysteineto alanine abolished all undefined aggregations and yieldedreadily crystals diffracting to 1.8 Å resolution.     

The creation of a novel fluorescent protein by guided consensus engineering

Consensus engineering has been used to increase the stability of a number of different proteins, either by creating consensus proteins from scratch or by modifying existing proteins so that their sequences more closely match a consensus sequence. In this paper we describe the first application of consensus engineering to the ab initio creation of a novel fluorescent protein. This was based on the alignment of 31 fluorescent proteins with >62% homology to monomeric Azami green (mAG) protein, and used the sequence of mAG to guide amino acid selection at positions of ambiguity. This consensus green protein is extremely well expressed, monomeric and fluorescent with red shifted absorption and emission characteristics compared to mAG. Although slightly less stable than mAG, it is better expressed and brighter under the excitation conditions typically used in single molecule fluorescence spectroscopy or confocal microscopy. This study illustrates the power of consensus engineering to create stable proteins using the subtle information embedded in the alignment of similar proteins and shows that the benefits of this approach may extend beyond stability.     

Novel substrate specificity engineered in the arabinose binding protein

The L-arabinose binding protein (ABP) of Escherichia coli naturallybinds L-arabinose and D-galactose with very high affinity and,with reduced affinity, a variety of other sugars that differonly at the C5 position of the pyranose ring.However, thereare stringent specificity requirements at the 1, 2, 3 and 4positions. Based on the high resolution crystallographic structureof the Ugand-protein complex, remodelling of the binding pocketwas attempted to shift the specificity towards Cl-substitutedgalactosides. To create space in the vicinity of the reducingend of bound galactose, four residues, LyslO, Asp90, Thrl47and Leul45, have been mutated for residues with smaller sidechains. Forty-seven mutants containing different combinationsof these mutations were tested by fluorometry for their abilityto bind methylß-D-galactoside (met-ß-Gal)or iso-propyl-ß-D-thio-galactoside (IPTG). Two double-residuemutants carrying Ser at position 147 and Ala or Gly at position90 appeared of particular interest for being able to bind met-ß-Galor IPTG, respectively, and no longer galactose. Fluorescenceexperiments and molecular modelling indicate that the mode ofbinding of the new substrates to the mutant proteins might besimilar to that of the natural ligands to wild-type ABP.     

Analysis of protein conformational characteristics related to thermostability

The thermal stability of proteins was studied, 195 single aminoacid residue replacements reported elsewhere being analysedfor several protein conformational characteristics: type ofresidue replacement; conservative versus nonconservative substitution;replacement being in a homologous stretch of amino acid residues;change in hydrogen bond, van der Waals and secondary structurepropensities; solvent-accessible versus inaccessible replacement;type of secondary structure involved in the substitution; thephysico-chemical characteristics to which the thermostabilityenhancement can be attributed; and the relationship of the replacementsite to the folding intermediates of the protein, when known.From the above analyses, some general rules arise which suggestwhere amino acid substitutions can be made to enhance proteinthermostability: substitutions are conservative according tothe Dayhoff matrix; mainly occur on conserved stretches of residues;preferentially occur on solvent-accessible residues; maintainor enhance the secondary structure propensity upon substitution;contribute to neutralize the dipole moment of the caps of helicesand strands; and tend to increase the number of potential hydrogenbonding or van der Waals contacts or improve hydrophobic packing.     

Ribosome display of mammalian receptor domains

Many mammalian receptor domains, among them a large number of potential therapeutic target proteins, are highly aggregation-prone upon heterologous expression in bacteria. This severely limits functional studies of such receptor domains and also their engineering towards improved properties. One of these proteins is the Nogoreceptor, which plays a central role in mediating the inhibition of axon growth and functional recovery after injury of the adult mammalian central nervous system. We show here that the ligand binding domain of the Nogoreceptor folds to an active conformation in ternary ribosomal complexes, as formed in ribosome display. In these complexes the receptor is still connected, via a C-terminal tether, to the peptidyl tRNA in the ribosome and the mRNA also stays connected. The ribosome prevents aggregation of the protein, which aggregates as soon as the release from the ribosome is triggered. In contrast, no active receptor was observed in phage display, where aggregation appears to prevent incorporation of the protein into the phage coat. This strategy sets the stage for rapidly studying defined mutations of such aggregation-prone receptors in vitro and to improve their properties by in vitro evolution using the ribosome display technology.     

Graphical representation of the salient conformational features of protein residues

A composite plot for depicting in two dimensions the conformationand the secondary structural features of protein residues hasbeen developed. Instead of presenting the exact values of themain- and side-chain torsion angles (, and ₁), it indicatesthe region in the three-dimensional conformational space towhich a residue belongs. Other structural aspects, like thepresence of a cis peptide bond and disulfide linkages, are alsodisplayed. The plot may be used to recognize patterns in thebackbone and side-chain conformation along a polypeptide chainand to compare protein structures derived from X-ray crystallography,NMR spectroscopy or molecular modelling studies and also tohighlight the effect of mutation on structure.     

Grafting of discontinuous sites: a protein modeling strategy

A strategy for modeling continuous as well as discontinuoussites in protein structures has been developed. Central to thismodeling strategy is the search algorithm of FITSITE, a programto search a given target structure for suitable combinationsof backbone positions mirroring as closely as possible the geometricrelationships of a source structural motif of interest. Alltarget sites detected by FITSITE are further refined to mimicthe source geometry. The side-chain rotamer library conceptfails to precisely describe side chains involved in coordinativebonding (e.g. metal binding sites). Therefore an algorithm usingdetailed database bonding parameter information was appliedfor the side-chain construction. The FITSITE program and thesubsequent processing of the program output are presented ina test case. The Rop protein, a four-helix bundle structure,served as the target protein. It was searched for candidatesites to model a variety of metal binding sites, with structuresextracted from Brookhaven Protein Database entries. The preliminaryprotein models were investigated for structural overlaps withneighboring residues by interactive computer graphics; if required,additional changes were performed. A set of parameters for energyminimization with AMBER (including metal ions) was developed,and the completed Rop variants were energy minimized. Finally,12 potentially metal binding Rop variants were selected forproduction via genetic engineering.     

Enhancement of protein stability by the combination of point mutations in T4 lysozyme is additive

A number of mutations have been shown previously to stabilizeT4 lysozyme. By combining up to seven such mutations in thesame protein, the melting temperature was incrementally increasedby up to 83°C at pH 5.4 (G = 3.6 kcal/mol). This shows thatit is possible to engineer a protein of enhanced thermostabilityby combining a series of rationally designed point mutations.It is also shown that this stabilization is achieved with onlyminor, localized changes in the structure of the protein. Thisis consistent with the observation that the change in stabilityof each of the multiple mutants is, in each case, additive,i.e. equal to the sum of the stability changes associated withthe constituent single mutants. One of the seven substitutions,Asn116 Asp, changes a residue that participates in substratebinding; not surprisingly, it causes a significant loss in activity.Ignoring this mutation, there is a gradual reduction in activityas successively more mutations are combined.     

Optimal protein library design using recombination or point mutations based on sequence-based scoring functions

In this paper, we introduce and test two new sequence-based protein scoring systems (i.e. S1, S2) for assessing the likelihood that a given protein hybrid will be functional. By binning together amino acids with similar properties (i.e. volume, hydrophobicity and charge) the scoring systems S1 and S2 allow for the quantification of the severity of mismatched interactions in the hybrids. The S2 scoring system is found to be able to significantly functionally enrich a cytochrome P450 library over other scoring methods. Given this scoring base, we subsequently constructed two separate optimization formulations (i.e. OPTCOMB and OPTOLIGO) for optimally designing protein combinatorial libraries involving recombination or mutations, respectively. Notably, two separate versions of OPTCOMB are generated (i.e. model M1, M2) with the latter allowing for position-dependent parental fragment skipping. Computational benchmarking results demonstrate the efficacy of models OPTCOMB and OPTOLIGO to generate high scoring libraries of a prespecified size.     

High level expression of a synthetic gene coding for IgG-binding domain B of Staphylococcal protein A

A gene coding for one of the IgG-binding domains of Staphylococcalprotein A, designated domain B, was chemically synthesized.This gene was tandemly repeated to give dimeric and tetramericdomain B genes by the use of two restriction enzymes which gaveblunt ends. The genes were highly expressed in Escherichia colito afford a large amount of dimeric and tetrameric domain Bproteins. The single domain B protein was efficiently producedas a fusion protein with a salmon growth hormone fragment. Thefusion protein was converted to monomeric domain B by cyanogenbromide cleavage. The CD spectra of the monomeric, dimeric andtetrameric domain B proteins were essentially the same as thatof native form protein A, showing that their secondary structureswere very similar. The dimeric and tetrameric domain B proteinsformed precipitates with IgG as protein A. This system permitsthe efficient production of mutated single and multiple IgG-bindingdomains which can be used to study structural changes and proteinA–immunoglobulin interactions.     

Gene synthesis and functional expression of a protein exhibiting monodomain IgG Fc binding

A gene encoding a bacterial IgG Fc binding domain was designedand synthesized. The synthetic DNA fragment was cloned 3' toan inducible trpE promoter such that expression of the genein Escherichia coli produced abundant Fc binding protein fusedto the first seven amino acids of the trpE protein. The recombinantprotein contained a single Fc binding domain and demonstratedefficient binding to'human IgG in Western blot analysis. Thisprotein degraded rapidly following cell lysis in the absenceof protease inhibitors, but could be effectively protected bythe addition of protease inhibitor. After purification of theprotein by IgG affinity chromatography, IgG Fc binding abilitywas retained for at least 24 h at either 23 or 37°C andon heating for 15 min at temperatures up to 65°C. No immunoprecipitationwas observed in interactions between the monodomain Fc bindingprotein and IgG molecules. Unlike staphylococcal protein A,no detectable binding of the monodomain IgG Fc binding proteinwas observed to either IgM or IgA. Truncated proteins, expressedfrom a series of 3' deletions of the synthetic gene, were usedto estimate the minimum portion of a monodomain Fc binding proteinthat retained Fc binding ability.     

Breakdown in the relationship between thermal and thermodynamic stability in an interleukin-1{beta} point mutant modified in a surface loop

Sequence variants of the ß-barrel protein interleukin-1ßhave been analyzed for their stabilities toward irreversiblethermal inactivation by monitoring the generation of light scatteringaggregates on heating. The derived temperatures for the onsetof aggregation (T_agg values) correlate well with the free energiesof unfolding of these proteins with the exception of one variant,Lys97—Val (K97V), which undergoes aggregation at a temperature7°C lower than expected based on its thermodynamic stability.This lower than expected thermal stability may be due to generationof an aggregation-prone unfolding intermediate at a temperaturelower than the T_m of the global transition. This hypothesisis supported by the location of residue 97 in the long 86–99loop which has structural features suggesting it may comprisea small, independent folding unit or microdomain. The excellentcorrelation of thermal and thermodynamic stabilities of sevenof the eight variants tested is consistent with accepted modelsfor thermal inactivation of proteins. At the same time the poorfit of the K97V variant underscores the risk in using thermalstability data in quantitative analysis of mutational studiesof the folding stability of proteins.     

Engineering the aggregation properties of dodecameric glutamine synthetase: a single amino acid substitution controls 'salting out'

Escherichia coli glutamine synthetase (GS) is a dodecamer ofidentical subunits which are arranged as two face-to-face hexamericrings. In the presence of 10% ammonium sulfate, wild type GSexhibits a pH-dependent ‘salting out’ with a pK_aof 4.51. Electron micrographs indicate that the pH-dependentaggregation corresponds to a highly specific self-assembly ofGS tubules, which result from stacking of individual dodecamers.This stacking of dodecamers is similar to the metal ion-inducedGS tubule formation previously described. Site-directed mutagenesisexperimentsindicate that the N-terminal helix of each subunit is involvedin the salting out reaction, as it is in the metal-induced stacking.A single substitution of alanine for His4 completely abolishesthe (NH₄₂SO₄-induced aggregation. However, the H4C mutant proteindoes nearly completely precipitate under the same salting outconditions. Mutations at other residues within the helix haveno effect on the stacking reaction. Differential catalyticactivityof unadenylylated GS versus adenylylated GS has been used todetermine whether wild type dodecamers ‘complement’the H4A mutant in the stacking reaction. The complementationexperiments indicate that His4 residues on bothsides of thedodecamer-dodecamer interfaces are not absolutely required forsalting out, although the wild type dodecamers clearly stackpreferentially with other wild type dodecamers. Approximately20% of the protein precipitated fromthe mixtures containingthe wild type GS and the H4A mutant is the mutant. The implicationsof these results for protein engineering are discussed.