Mechanical and histological fixation of hydroxylapatite-coated pyrolytic carbon and titanium alloy implants: a report of short-term results

Historically, pyrolytic carbon has been a material for cardiovascular applications, but it has several properties suited for orthopedic uses as well. Pyrolytic carbon has an elastic modulus similar to bone and is highly fatigue resistant, but has not been used in orthopedics because of poor fixation to bone. Plasma sprayed hydroxylapatite (HA) has significantly improved the bonding of bone to titanium alloy implants. The effect of plasma-sprayed HA on pyrolytic carbon implants was investigated in this study. Cylindrical samples were implanted through a single cortex in Beagle femurs. The animals were sacrificed after 8 weeks, and a mechanical push-out test was performed on the implants immediately after explantation. Samples were microradiographed, stained for histology, and examined histomorphometrically. Interface strength for each type of implant was calculated. Pyrolytic carbon showed almost no attachment strength with an average strength value of 1.59 MPa. HA-coated pyrolytic carbon (8.71 MPa) yielded the same interfacial strength as HA-coated titanium (8.71 MPa). Histology revealed that bone was in direct apposition to all implants, both HA coated and noncoated. Failures occurred between the core material and the coating, or within the coating, but not at the bone/HA interface. Histomorphometry results confirmed that the two types of HA-coated implants had more bone apposition than the uncoated pyrolytic carbon implants. It was concluded that a plasma sprayed HA coating significantly improves the bone fixation of pyrolytic carbon.     

Differential effects of aromatic and charged residue substitutions in the RNA binding domains of the yeast poly(A)-binding protein

A new modified thermal decomposition method is described for preparing a double layered coating on titanium plates which includes an initial perovskite (CaTiO3) layer followed by a hydroxyapatite (HA) layer on top. The characterization of the coating was studied by X-ray diffractometry and infrared spectroscopy and indicated that the double layer consisted of carbonate HA and CaTiO3 and the thickness of the layer was 4 microns. The coating was performed on the inner surfaces of 50-200 microns sized pores and was also consistent in the smallest of the pores even those of 50 microns. Bone formation was examined in canines at 2-32 week intervals and was dominant on coated plates and in large-sized pores before 16 weeks. However, after 16 weeks bone ingrowth was similar in non-coated and coated plates and in all pore sizes. The results indicated that HA could only influence early bone ingrowth, though good bone ingrowth into small pores indicated that HA exhibited enhanced osteocompatibility. Our methodology ensured the stability of the HA layer consequently minimizing the problems associated with HA loss.     

Maintenance of proximal cortical bone with use of a less stiff femoral component in hemiarthroplasty of the hip without cement. An investigation in a canine model at six months and two years

A canine model of hemiarthroplasty of the hip was used to determine if the use of a less stiff femoral stem can reduce the amount of bone loss induced by stress-shielding. Two types of stem were used: the stiffer stems were made of a titanium alloy, and the less stiff stems were composed of a cobalt-chromium-alloy core with an outer polymer layer. The stems were identical in shape, and both types were circumferentially coated along their entire length (except for the distal five millimeters) with commercially pure titanium fiber metal. Ten dogs with each type of stem were followed for six months, and twelve dogs with each type of stem were followed for two years. Loss of cortical bone from the proximal part of the femur was associated with both types of stem, but typically 50 per cent less bone was lost with the less stiff implants. Most of the cortical loss occurred at the subperiosteal surface. The amount of medullary bone adjacent to the proximal and distal aspects of both types of stem increased; the less stiff stems were associated with a greater increase in the proximal region, and the stiffer stems were associated with a greater increase in the distal region. Similarly, there were peaks in the amount of bone growth into the proximal and distal portions of both types of stem, with a greater peak in proximal bone growth into the less stiff stems and a greater peak in distal bone growth into the stiffer stems.     

Effect of sucralfate and basic fibroblast growth factor on fibrovascular ingrowth into hydroxyapatite and porous polyethylene alloplastic implants using a novel rabbit model

This study investigated the effects of sucralfate and basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) on fibrovascular ingrowth into porous implant materials. Seven white female New Zealand rabbits underwent bilateral abdominal incisions through which porous orbital spherical or and disc-shaped implants were inserted between their abdominal muscles. Eighty hydroxyapatite (HA) and porous polyethylene (PP) implants, each material of different pore sizes, were implanted. These implants were either uncoated or coated with suspensions of polyhydroxymethylmethacrylate (hydron); hydron and sucralfate; or hydron, sucralfate, and bFGF. Implants were harvested after 1, 3, or 6 weeks. Observers classified the extent of fibrovascular ingrowth in a blind manner using light microscopy. All discs and spheres showed fibrovascular ingrowth; at 6 weeks, almost all implants were fully vascularized. Although demonstrating different degrees of fibrovascular maturity, all 3- and 6-week discs showed complete cellular ingrowth. Overall, the most extensive and mature fibrovascularization was found in HA implants, regardless of shape, duration of implantation, or angiogenic enhancing agent used. Thus, this study indicates that fibrovascular ingrowth into porous implants is more greatly affected by implant porosity and composition than by addition of angiogenic enhancing agents. Further in vivo study, using other potential angiogenesis-promoting agents as well as implants with different pore characteristics, is warranted using this reliable and predictable animal model.     

Mechanical and histological evaluation of amorphous calcium phosphate and poorly crystallized hydroxyapatite coatings on titanium implants

The effect of amorphous calcium phosphate (Ca/P) and poorly crystallized (60% crystalline) hydroxyapatite (HA) coatings on bone fixation to "smooth" and "rough" (Ti-6A1-4V powder sprayed) titanium-6Al-4V (Ti) implants was investigated. Implants were evaluated histologically, mechanically, and by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) after 4 and 12 weeks of implantation in a rabbit transcortical femoral model. Histological evaluation of amorphous vs. poorly crystallized HA coatings showed significant differences in bone apposition (for rough-coated implants only) and coating resorption (for smooth- and rough-coated implants) that were increased within cortical compared to cancellous bone. The poorly crystallized HA coatings showed most degradation and least bone apposition. Mechanical evaluation, however, showed no significant differences in push-out shear strengths between the two types of coatings evaluated. Differences between 4 and 12 weeks were significant for coating resorption and push-out shear strength but not for bone apposition. Significant enhancement in interfacial shear strengths for bioceramic coated as compared to uncoated implants were seen for smooth-surfaced implants (3.5-5 times greater) but not for rough-surfaced implants at 4 and 12 weeks. Rough implants showed greater mean interfacial strengths than uncoated smooth implants at 4 and 12 weeks (seven times greater) and to coated smooth implants at 12 weeks only (two times greater). Mechanical failure of the bone/coating/implant interface consistently occurred within the bone, even in the case of the poorly crystallized HA coatings, which had almost completely resorbed on rough implants. These results suggest that once early osteointegration is achieved biodegradation of a bioactive coating should not be detrimental to the bone/coating/implant fixation.     

Surface-dimpled commercially pure titanium implant and bone ingrowth

The purpose of this investigation was to examine the effect of the surface macrostructure of a dimpled commercially pure titanium (cp Ti) implant on bone ingrowth in vivo by means of histological examination and a push-out test. Cylindrical implants were inserted in one femur of each experimental rabbit and the animals were killed at 1.5, 3 and 13 months after implantation. The femur with the implant of each animal was then examined in a push-out test. The fracture surfaces of the bone-implant interface after the push-out test were examined under light and electron microscopy. It seems that the dimpled cp Ti surface results in the increased retention of the cp Ti implant in bone due to interlocking between vital bone and the dimples.     

Rapid bone resorption adjacent to hydroxyapatite-coated implants

This paper describes rapid bone resorption in the peri-implantitis of HA implants based on both our clinical observations of and histological research on extracted dense hydroxyapatite (HA) implants. The surfaces of extracted HA implants were rough, although they were smooth at fixture placement. Plaque formed on the necks of the implants, whereas little plaque was seen on the bottoms. The plaque consisted of cocci and rods, including filamentous bacteria. Few spirochetes were observed. Although surrounding bone was formed rapidly around the HA implant, bone thickness gradually decreased compared with the titanium implant. These facts suggest that the rigid biointegration of HA with the thin surrounding bone--that is, the overstressing of the bone--causes rapid bone resorption rather than plaque accumulation on HA.     

Biologic attachment of an allograft bone and tendon transplant to a titanium prosthesis

An Achilles tendon allograft with its bony insertion was used to bridge a Titanium implant, containing an endoprosthetic tendon anchor, and the sheep biceps muscle. Twelve sheep were operated on unilaterally and followed up clinically and histologically for 2, 4 (n = 2), 8, and 12 months (n = 4). Full function of the front limb was regained after 8 to 12 weeks. There were no signs of mechanical loosening at all times. The morphologic changes at the bone block and implant fixation site were an initial revascularization of the allograft bone, which was observed at 2 months and enhanced at 4 months but occurred without any evidence of bone remodeling. This was changed in all specimens taken at 8 and 12 months where intensive new bone development, remodeling, and bone ingrowth in the titanium implant was found. Bone mass was shifted significantly to the tendon insertion half of the bone block because of a creeping substitution of the cancellous allograft bone and bone ingrowth to the implant. Overall bone mass slightly decreased with time but resorption of allograft bone outweighed new bone development only at lesser loaded areas. Transplantation of a bone and tendon allograft to an implant resulted in a revitalized, mechanically stable, and biologically anchored compound.     

Present status and future of blood management in Japan]

The ability of shear strains to inhibit bony ingrowth was investigated by use of a transcortical porous-coated cylindrical plug implant in a functionally isolated turkey ulna model in which the mechanical loading environment could be accurately controlled and rigorously defined. The distribution of ingrowth at the bone-implant interface was quantified following 8 weeks of in vivo loading consisting of 100 seconds per day of a 20 Hz sinusoidal stimulus sufficient to cause a local peak strain of approximately 100 microstrain in the cortex at the bone-implant interface in four turkeys. A nonuniform but repeatable pattern of bony ingrowth, from 33 +/- 6 to 72 +/- 6% (mean +/- SE), was observed. The mechanical environment in the vicinity of the bone-implant interface was calculated using a three-dimensional elastic orthotropic finite element model. The general stress-strain state of the bone as predicted by the finite element model was validated in two additional turkeys using four three-element rosette strain gauges, while high resolution moiré interferometry was used to determine the mechanical state of the region immediately adjacent to the implant itself. Shear strains and stresses were evaluated at the interface and correlated to the pattern of bony ingrowth circumscribing the implant interface. Linear regressions between ingrowth and both shear strain and shear stress were negative, with the values of R = -0.75 and R = -0.78 (p < 0.001), respectively, indicating significant inhibition of ingrowth where shear components were maximal. These results suggest that the minimization of shear stress and strain components is a major determinant in achieving successful ingrowth of bone into a prosthesis.     

Persistent papillomavirus infection in a cat

The purpose of this study was to further define the cellular response to titanium and polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) particles in aseptic loosening, and to determine if the use of pamidronate may be effective in inhibiting bone resorption associated with this response. Macrophages and osteoblasts were cocultured to simulate the environment around an aseptically loose prosthesis. Macrophages were plated on the bottom of six well plates and osteoblasts were plated on culture dish inserts, and placed into the wells with the macrophages. Incubation of macrophages with PMMA in this system led to release of prostaglandin E (PGE2), granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF), and interleukin-6 (IL-6). Incubation with titanium led to release of tumor necrosis factor (TNF) and IL-6. Exposure of calvaria to media from cells exposed to either PMMA or titanium led to release of calcium 45. Incubation of calvaria with pamidronate was able to inhibit release of calcium 45 associated with exposure to the macrophage/osteoblast/particle conditioned medium. Bone resorption at the interface between implant and bone is a consistent feature leading to loosening of orthopedic implants. By inhibiting bone resorption associated with the inflammatory response to implant particulates, pamidronate or other bisphosphonates may have clinical utility in the treatment or prevention or aseptic loosening.     

Effect of chronic bile duct obstruction and LPS upon targeting of naproxen to the liver using naproxen-albumin conjugate

In order to avoid the potential risks of disease transmission in allograft surgery, numerous substitute materials have been described. As the biological response to implant materials is different, we undertook the following study to assess type and amount of bone ingrowth in CaP-ceramics. 105 cylindrical bone defects with a diameter of 5.4 mm were created surgically in the femoral condyles of 53 skeletal mature NZW rabbits. The defects were filled with crushed coralline hydroxyapatite (HA) implants (n = 21), synthetically produced hydroxyapatite (n = 21) and surface-modified alpha-Tricalciumphosphate (TCP) grains (n = 21). 21 defects were left empty and other drill holes were filled with rabbit cancellous bone cylinders (n = 21) after 3 months of cryopreservation at -78 degrees C without sterilization. Following observation periods of 2, 4, 6, 8, 12, 26 and 52 weeks the femoral condyles were harvested for histological evaluation and quantitative analysis of bone ingrowth. Woven bone formation at implant periphery can be observed in all substances as early as 2 weeks postoperatively. At 4-week-intervals cryopreserved allografts show new bone apposition on surfaces of necrotic trabeculae and graft-host junctions by a predominantly osteoblastic reaction at the periphery of all cylinders, while in HA- and TCP-grains early bone formation in the center of drill holes is detectable as well. There is a direct contact between HA-/TCP-particles and newly formed bone without fibrous tissue formation at the implant surfaces. Central new bone formation in rabbit allografts can be observed after 6 to 8 weeks together with a secondary osteoclastic resorption of necrotic transplant trabeculae. The result of this remodeling process is a complete degradation of transplant cylinders with reorganization of vital trabeculae oriented in a mature pattern after 12 to 26 weeks. In contrast the HA- and TCP-implants did not show any signs of resorption.     

Preclinical testing of total hip stems. The effects of coating placement

The long-term fixation endurance of noncemented hip stems in total hip arthroplasty is subject to incompatible design goals. To reduce stress shielding and periprosthetic bone loss, proximal fixation and load transfer are indicated. However, to prevent interface motion and promote interface-bonding security, fixation preferably should be maximized over the entire stem surface. In this study, the authors questioned whether hydroxyapatite coatings could be applied in patterns that reduce bone resorption, while maintaining safe interface stress levels. For that purpose, strain-adaptive bone-remodeling theory was applied in 3-dimensional finite element models, to simulate the long-term postoperative bone resorption process. During the process, the adaptation of interface stresses was monitored, and its effects on interface failure probability evaluated. This analysis was done for a fully coated stem, a 1/3 proximally coated stem, a smooth uncoated, press-fitted stem, and a stem with 5 proximal patches of circumferential stripes. The uncoated stem reduced bone loss dramatically, but promoted interface motions and distal pedestal formation. In all cases, the gradual bone-remodeling process increased the interface security of the coated stems. Bone loss and interface failure probability were not very different for the fully and 1/3-coated stems. Stripe coating reduced bone resorption considerably, while increasing long-term interface failure probability only slightly. The investigators concluded that the initial stability and the ingrowth potential of such a stem design are likely to be inadequate.     

Functional adaptation and ingrowth of bone vary as a function of hip implant stiffness

The purpose of the present study was to test the hypothesis that cortical bone loss, trabecular bone density and the amount of bone ingrowth vary as a function of stem stiffness in a canine cementless hip replacement model. The study was motivated by the problem of cortical bone atrophy in the proximal femur following cementless total hip replacement. Two stem stiffnesses were used and both designs were identical in external geometry and porous coating placement. The high stiffness stem caused approximately 26% cortical bone stress-shielding and the low stiffness stem caused approximately 7.5% stress-shielding, as assessed by beam theory. Each group included nine adult, male canines who received unilateral arthroplasties for a period of six months. The animals with the low stiffness stems tended to lose less proximal cortical bone than the animals with high stiffness stems (4% +/- 9 as opposed to 11% +/- 14), but the difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.251). However, the patterns of bone ingrowth into the implant and change in medullary bone density adjacent to the implant were fundamentally different as a function of stem stiffness (p < 0.01). Most importantly, while the high stiffness group had peaks in these variables at the distal end of the stem, the low stiffness group had peak values proximally. These different patterns of functional adaptation are consistent with the idea that reduced stem stiffness enhances proximal load transfer.     

Effect of flexibility of the femoral stem on bone-remodeling and fixation of the stem in a canine total hip arthroplasty model without cement

The purpose of this study was to compare, with regard to fixation of the implant and femoral bone resorption, two fully porous-coated stems of different stiffnesses in a canine total hip arthroplasty model. A bilateral arthroplasty was carried out with insertion of a titanium-alloy stem (which had stiffness properties comparable with those of the canine femur) on one side and with insertion of a composite stem (which was three to fivefold more flexible than the canine femur) on the contralateral side. Eight femora were evaluated at six months and eight, at eighteen months after the operation, to determine the extent of bone ingrowth, periprosthetic cortical area, intracortical porosity, and bone-remodeling. Despite the markedly greater flexibility of the composite stems, no significant difference could be detected (with the numbers available), with regard to the overall degree of femoral stress-shielding, cortical area, or cortical porosity, between these stems and the stiffer, titanium-alloy stems at either time-period. However, the composite stems had less bone ingrowth and more formation of radiopaque lines than did the titanium-alloy stems. At eighteen months, the values for bone ingrowth were 9.7 +/- 5.38 percent (mean and standard deviation) for the composite stems compared with 28.1 +/- 5.31 percent for the titanium-alloy stems (p = 0.003). Furthermore, the histological sections from the femora containing a composite stem showed radiopaque lines indicative of fibrous ingrowth approximately threefold more often than did those from the femora containing a titanium-alloy stem (p = 0.02).     

Histological comparison of early wound healing following dense hydroxyapatite granule grafting and barrier placement in surgically-created bone defects neighboring implants

The purpose of this study was to examine early wound healing following grafting of dense hydroxyapatite granules (HA granules) and barrier placement in surgically-created bone defects surrounding implants. Eight healthy adult dogs with an average weight of 15 kg were used in this study. Thirty-two bone defects measuring 4 mm x 4 mm were removed with a surgical bur to form continuous bucco-lingual bone defects and 32 implants (16 titanium [Ti]) and 16 hydroxyapatite-coated [HA]) were then placed into the defects. Four implant groups were created: 1) grafting HA; 2) covering with an expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) membrane; 3) grafting HA and covering with ePTFE membrane; and 4) control (no treatment). Animals were sacrificed 28 days after surgery. Histological sections revealed large amounts of newly-formed bone in all bone defects surrounding the implants treated with ePTFE membranes alone. Fibrous encapsulation of HA granules was observed in the defects of the HA granules grafting group. In the group with grafting of HA granules and covering with ePTFE membranes, small amounts of bone tissue were observed among HA granules, but most HA granules were surrounded with fibrous tissue. Bone defects were completely filled with connective tissue in the control group. There were no differences in the histological findings between Ti and HA-coated implants in all cases. Histomorphometric data disclosed that the presence of HA granules in the bone defects significantly arrested bone formation. Our study suggests that the grafting of dense HA into bone defects surrounding implants will result in fibrous healing during the early healing stage.     

Stiffness variation of porous titanium developed using space holder method

Abstract

The excellent properties of Ti have resulted in its generalised use for bone implants. However, Ti is very stiff in comparison with human cortical bone, and this creates problems of bone weakening and loosening of the implant. This article discusses the mechanical properties (flexural and compressive strength, and stiffness) of porous Ti–6Al–4V specimens developed using the space holder method. These properties are examined relative to the production process parameters: compacting pressure and sintering time, as well as temperature, and the addition of spacer and its particle size. It is seen that when spacer is added, compressive strength decreases with the application of compacting pressure and that these are the most influential parameters. The developed pieces show a closed and unconnected porosity. Small additions of spacer (25 vol.-%) reduce stiffness to around half of that shown by the solid material, and the resulting pieces are strong enough to be used as bone substitute.     

In vitro crystallisation systems for the study of urinary stone formation

Hydroxyapatite orbital implants undergo early ingrowth of fibrovascular tissue after enucleation. This animal study determined whether control and osteogenin-impregnated hydroxyapatite orbital implants vary in their osteogenic response at 6 and 52 weeks. Rabbits underwent enucleation with implantation of control or osteogenin-impregnated hydroxyapatite spheres. Light microscopy determined fibrovascular ingrowth, and histomorphometry quantitated the amount of bone produced. Osteogenin implants vascularized at a faster rate and contained bony foci by 6 weeks that became confluent at 1 year. Spontaneous osteogenesis was not seen in control animals at 6 weeks. After 1 year they contained bone, although less than in the osteogenin implants. Mixed cell inflammation was observed at the hydroxyapatite-tissue interface in both groups. No inflammation was noted at the interface of hydroxyapatite and bone. These are the first controlled observations that bone-specific differentiation occurs in the pores of spherical hydroxyapatite implants within the soft tissues of the socket. This vascularized process can be enhanced with osteogenin to occur earlier and more uniformly in the implants at one year.     

Lesions in the dentate hilum and CA2/CA3 regions of the rat hippocampus produce cognitive deficits that correlate with site-specific glial activation

The aim of the present experimental investigation was to study the morphological and dimensional changes of bone, augmented at titanium implants by a membrane technique, taking place after membrane removal. In 12 rabbits, screw-shaped titanium implants were inserted in the tibial metaphyses in such a way that 5 threads became uncovered with bone. Surgery was performed on 2 occasions in order to retrieve specimens with different follow-up times. An e-PTFE barrier and a titanium device were used to provide space for bone formation. In 1 tibia of each rabbit, the membranes and spacers were removed after 8 weeks of healing, and the implants followed for 16 more weeks. Impressions were taken at day 0 and after 8 and 24 weeks of healing and plaster models were produced. In the contralateral tibiae, implants were inserted either 16 or 8 weeks prior to sacrifice. Measurements were made on the plaster models in 3 dimensions at 35 points around each implant in a coordinate measuring machine. Specimens taken 8, 16 and 24 weeks after insertion were analysed by means of light microscopical morphometry. The coordinate measurements showed that, in mean, 1.92 mm of bone had been formed during the first 8 weeks. A statistically significant loss of the height of the newly formed bone (0.70 mm) and thereby reduction of bone volume was found 24 weeks postoperatively. The volume decrease of the newly formed bone was more pronounced beside the implants than over the implant body. The histology showed that woven bone had been formed at the implants after 8 weeks. Further bone formation and remodelling and a net increase of mineralized bone were seen. The degree of bone-implant contact and bone area in the threads increased with time. The present study showed that coordinate measurements on plaster models, obtained from the experimental areas, in combination with histology, form a useful technique to study long-term changes of augmented bone. It was found that bone formed by a barrier membrane technique, decreased in volume during a 16-week follow-up period after barrier removal. Less dimensional changes were observed for the bone formed over the implant body, indicating that a solid surface may have a stabilizing effect on the augmented bone.     

The radiographic and imaging characteristics of porous tantalum implants within the human cervical spine

STUDY DESIGN: Seven cadaveric cervical spines were implanted with a porous tantalum spacer and a titanium alloy spacer, and their radiographic and imaging characteristics were evaluated. OBJECTIVE: To determine the radiographic characteristics of porous tantalum and titanium implants used as spacers in the cervical spine. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Anterior decompressive surgery of the disc space or the vertebral body creates a defect that frequently is repaired with autologous bone grafts to promote spinal fusion. Donor site morbidity, insufficient donor material, and additional surgical time have spurred the development of biomaterials to replace or supplement existing spinal reconstruction techniques. Although the promotion of a solid bony fusion is critical, the implanted biomaterial should be compatible with modern imaging techniques, should allow visualization of the spinal canal and neural foramina, and should permit radiographic assessment of bony ingrowth. METHODS: Cadaveric spines containing the implants were imaged with plain radiography, computerized tomography, and magnetic resonance imaging. The image distortion produced by the implants was determined qualitatively and quantitatively. RESULTS: The tantalum and titanium spacers were opaque on plain radiographic films. On computed tomographic scans, more streak artifact was associated with the tantalum implants than with the titanium. On magnetic resonance imaging, the porous tantalum implant demonstrated less artifact than did the titanium spacer on T1- and T2-weighted spin echo and on T2*-weighted gradient-echo magnetic resonance images. Overall, the tantalum implant produced less artifact on magnetic resonance imaging than did the titanium spacer and therefore allowed for better visualization of the surrounding bony and neural structures. CONCLUSION: The material properties of titanium and porous tantalum cervical interbody implants contribute to their differential appearance in different imaging methods. The titanium implant appears to image best with computed tomography, whereas the porous tantalum implant produces less artifact than does the titanium implant on several magnetic resonance imaging sequences.     

Cemented femoral component surface finish mechanics

A cemented femoral component's surface finish may influence implant function through variations in cement adhesion and abrasion properties. Morphologic characterization of historic and current femoral hip prosthesis surface finishes show greater than x 20 range in implant roughness. Early implants typically had relatively smooth surfaces, whereas many of the more recent implants have rougher surface finishes. Smoother implant surfaces have lower cement-metal interface fixation strength, whereas rougher surfaces have greater fixation strength. With interface motion, the smoother surfaces are less abrasive of bone cement, whereas rougher implant surfaces are more abrasive. Because of enhanced bone cement attachment, rougher implant surfaces may have a lower probability of interface motion, while at the same time, a higher debris generation consequence if motion occurs. In contrast, smoother implant surfaces may have a higher probability of interface motion with a lower debris generating consequence of that motion. The prolonged use of cemented total hip replacement may be approached by either extending the duration of implant function after cement-metal interface loosening with smooth surfaced implants or, in contrast, by extending the duration of cement-metal interface adhesion with rougher surfaced implants.