Effect of Agronomical Practices on the Nutritional Quality of Virgin Olive Oil at Different Ripening Stages

There is a need to verify the quality of organically produced olive oils and to compare them to conventional ones. The objective of this study was to assess possible differences in nutritional quality between agronomic practices in Picual and Hojiblanca olive oil varieties at different stages of olive ripeness. The results showed that organic versus conventional cultivation did not consistently affect acidity, peroxide index or spectrophotometric constants of the virgin olive oils considered in this study. On the contrary, phenol content, oxidative stability, tocopherol content and fatty acid composition were affected by the agronomical practices. Principal component analysis indicated that linolenic acid and β‐tocopherol were mainly responsible for discriminating Hojiblanca organic oils, whereas total phenols, palmitoleic acid and α‐tocopherol were the major contributors to differentiating Picual conventional oils. Lignoceric and stearic acids were related to oils from unripe and ripe olive fruits, respectively. Long‐term experiments are required to confirm these results.     

On the importance of total polar phenols to monitor the stability of Greek virgin olive oil

A large number of virgin olive oil samples obtained from different areas in Greece were analyzed for various quality parameters. The work focuses on the colorimetric determination of total phenols with the Folin‐Ciocalteu reagent and its importance in predicting shelf life of virgin olive oil. The results indicate a good correlation of total polar phenol content with the stability of the oil. Colorimetric determination of ortho‐diphenol content does not seem to be a better means for predicting virgin olive oil stability. RP‐HPLC quantification of hydroxytyrosol and tyrosol in their free form gives poor results in the case of freshly extracted oils. It is concluded that until an easy‐to‐manage HPLC method will be available, which will quantify accurately both free and bound forms of hydroxytyrosol and other phenolics, the colorimetric method for the determination of total polar phenols remains a good practical means to evaluate the stability of virgin olive oil.     

Characterization of virgin olive oil from Southern Tunisia

Fruits from three Tunisian cultivars of Olea europea L. grown in the southeast of Tunisia were harvested at the maturity stage of ripeness and immediately processed with a laboratory mill. There are as yet no data on the chemical composition of virgin olive oils from the southeast of Tunisia, an area characterized by an arid condition of growth for olive trees. Our results showed significant differences in the analytical parameters examined for the three cultivars such as fatty acid composition, total phenols and o‐diphenols, and the content of chlorophylls and carotenoids, confirming the importance of genetic factors in the chemical characteristics of the oil. Headspace solid‐phase microextraction (HS‐SPME) was applied to the analysis of volatile compounds of virgin olive oils. Forty‐eight compounds were isolated and characterized by GC‐RI and GC‐MS, representing 94.1–98.1% of the total amount. (E)‐Hex‐2‐enal, the main compound extracted by SPME, characterized the olive oil headspace for all samples. So, it was clearly shown that there were qualitative and quantitative differences in the proportion of volatile constituents from oils of the various cultivars.     

A high-field1H nuclear magnetic resonance study of the minor components in virgin olive oils

High-field (600 MHz) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy was applied to the direct analysis of virgin olive oil. Minor components were studied to assess oil quality and genuineness. Unsaturated and saturated aldehyde resonances, as well as those related to other volatile compounds, were identified in the low-field region of the spectrum by two-dimensional techniques. Unsaturated aldehydes can be related to the sensory quality of oils. Other unidentified peaks are due to volatile components, because they disappear after nitrogen fluxing. The statistical analysis performed on the intensity of these peaks in several oil samples, obtained from different olive varieties, allows clustering and identification of oils arising from the same olive variety. Diacylglycerols, linolenic acid, other volatile components, water, acetic acid, phenols, and sterols can be detected simulteneously, suggesting a useful application of high-field NMR in the authentication and quality assessment of virgin olive oil.     

Natural antioxidants and volatile compounds of virgin olive oils obtained by two or three‐phases centrifugal decanters

Research has been carried out to ascertain the influence of different centrifugal decanters employed in olive process on oil yields and qualitative characteristics and composition of volatile compounds of virgin olive oil. Tests were performed in an olive oil mill equipped with centrifugal decanters at two or three‐phases. Results show that oil yields were similar and oils extracted from good‐quality olives do not differ in free fatty acids, peroxide value, UV absorptions and organoleptic assessment. Total phenols and o‐diphenols content as well as induction time values are higher in oils obtained by the centrifugal decanter at two‐phases, because it requires less quantity of water added to olive paste in comparison to the three‐phases centrifugal decanter. The amount of water added determines the dilution of the aqueous phase and lowers the concentration of the phenolic substances more soluble in vegetable waste water. Due to the partition equilibrium law the concentration of the same substances consequently diminishes in the oil. In this research, the coefficient of the partition equilibrium of total phenols between oil and vegetable water has been calculated and discussed. No significant difference occurred, due to the different decanters employed, in the average values of the volatile components of the head‐space of oils.     

Potential of selected Portuguese cultivars for the production of high quality monovarietal virgin olive oil

The effect of cultivar and ripeness stage on the potential nutritional value of monovarietal extra virgin olive oils (MEVOOs) obtained from Cordovil, Carrasquinha, Verdeal, and Negrinha do Freixo cultivars was investigated. MEVOOs produced were characterized by high oleic acid (72–83%), tocopherol (182–530 mg/kg), and phenolic compounds (326–1110 mg/kg) content and by a similar polyphenolic profile. 1‐Penten‐3‐one was found to be the compound with the highest contribution for the aroma of the four MEVOO, related to bitter, pungent, and leaf attributes. MEVOO from Verdeal cultivar showed the best performance in terms of the composition: the highest yield of oil, the highest content of oleic acid, high tocopherol, polyphenol and sterol content, and the lowest content of linoleic acid. These characteristics give to these MEVOO not only a great oxidative stability but also interesting properties from the health point of view. MEVOO obtained with fruits at the maturity index of around 4 were in general richer in beneficial minor compounds. MEVOO produced were discriminated by variety and ripeness stage, using a stepwise linear discriminant analysis. This discrimination will in the future enable the prevention of adulteration of these monovarietal olive oils with specific nutritional composition with other olive oils. Practical implications: High‐quality MEVOOs have recently been introduced in the market, which for growers is a practical way to differentiate and increase the commercial value of extra virgin olive oil. The quantification of major and minor olive oil compounds in monovarietal olive oils represents an objective way of predicting the sensory characteristics, stability, and potential health benefits of the oils, as well as preventing their adulteration with other olive oils. This study will help in the selection of olive varieties during the maintenance or development of new olive orchards and also to select optimum harvest period for these varieties, in order to obtain MEVOOs with the maximum quality and health benefits for consumers.     

Comparability and reliability of different techniques for the determination of phenolic compounds in virgin olive oil

Phenolic compounds represent a unique and functional part of the polar fraction of virgin olive oils. Many different approaches for the analysis of these compounds have been published, which has led to ambiguous results that are difficult to compare. In order to explain the controversial data reported in the literature, extraction techniques (solid‐phase extraction, SPE, and liquid‐liquid extraction, LLE), methods of analysis (HPLC and colorimetric assay) and quantification methods have been re‐investigated with genuine olive oil phenols. The optimized LLE system led to high recovery of the nine major olive oil phenolics (93%) and, in addition, was at least as good as the SPE technique in view of costs, solvent and sample consumption, and analysis time. SPE was shown to be problematic because of the selectivity towards the individual phenolics, particularly the aglycone‐type ones. The proposed LLE/HPLC method was compared with the traditional colorimetric assay (Folin‐Ciocalteu method) by analyzing 23 samples of virgin olive oils. A strong correlation between both methods has been found, suggesting that the colorimetric assay is reasonably valid for a rough prediction of the total phenolic content. In the literature, the level of phenolics is expressed in several different units (reference compound equivalents in case of colorimetric measurements and ppm in HPLC measurements). As these units can differ in orders of magnitude, it is necessary to convert the data to a common base before comparing or combining them.     

Influence of olive crushing methods on the yields and oil characteristics

In the last years, metallic crushers substituted granite stone mill with some variations in the organoleptic oil characteristics. To control the influence of the crushing method on the yield and oil quality, the olive pastes were obtained using three different ways: (i) new metallic crusher at mobile knives; (ii) granite stone mill; (iii) double olive crushing by the metallic crusher and the granite stone mill. With the aim to ascertain the useful use of a new metallic crusher (at mobile knives), experimental tests were carried out in an industrial oil mill. This oil mill is equipped by a centrifugal decanter generating two oil flows: first and second extraction (recovery) oils. The results showed that the yields obtained by different methods were satisfactory. No statistically significant differences have been observed in terms of oil yield and quality when different crushing devices were used. All first extracted oils are extra virgin with similar organoleptic characteristics, especially for the fruity intensity and for the bitter and pungent taste, as confirmed by the composition of volatile substances and the content of phenolic oil compounds. The recovery oils (second extraction oils) showed, in contrast to first extraction oils, a more intense green colour and a higher content of total phenols. Practical applications: Processing of sound olives with the right ripening grade and good quality allows to easily obtain an extra virgin olive oil, with commercial qualitative parameters according to the European Union requirements. However, different olive crushing systems affect the concentrations of some compounds responsible of aroma and taste (phenolic compounds). The use of the more violent metallic crushers facilitates obtaining oils with total phenol content higher than when using a stone mill. Here we used a particular metallic crusher (at knives) that, however, is suitable to replace the granite stone mill when a less pungent and bitter oil is required.     

Antioxidant activity of tocopherols and phenolic compounds of virgin olive oil

The antioxidant effects of hydrophilic phenols and tocopherols on the oxidative stability in virgin olive oils and in purified olive oil have been evaluated. Total hydrophilic phenols and the oleosidic forms of 3,4-dihydroxyphenolethanol (3,4-DHPEA) were correlated (r=0.97) with the oxidative stability of virgin olive oil. On the contrary, tocopherols showed low correlation (r=0.05). Purified olive oil with the dialdehydic form of elenolic acid linked to 3,4-DHPEA, an isomer of oleuropeine aglycon, and 3,4-DHPEA had good oxidative stability. A synergistic effect was observed in the mixture of 3,4-DHPEA and its oleosidic forms with α-tocopherol in purified olive oil by the Rancimat method at 120°C.     

Stability to oxidation of virgin olive oils as related to olive conditions: Study of polar compounds by chemometric methods

Polar compounds of virgin olive oils were analyzed. They influence oil flavor and aroma and improve the shelf-life of the oil. The orthodiphenolic fraction is particularly significant for oil stability because of its antioxidative activity. A relationship between the composition of the whole fraction of polar compounds and the state of health of the olives was established. For this purpose, oil samples were obtained from olives that had reached different degrees of ripeness and that had been affected by Dacus oleae infestation differently. The polar compounds were then analyzed by high-performance liquid chromatography. The data set was studied by means of chemometric methods. Partial least squares regression was used to obtain models that show a significant correlation between composition of the oil’s polar compounds and conditions of the olives sampled. In particular, compounds with antioxidative activity were directly linked with the state of health of the olives. The models obtained allow tracing of the state of health of the olives sampled through analysis of the polar fraction of virgin olive oil with a high degree of accuracy, and thus prediction of the oil’s expected shelf life.     

Color-pigment correlation in virgin olive oil

The chlorophyll and carotenoid content of virgin olive oils from five varieties harvested at varying degrees of ripeness were determined. Colors were evaluated from the chromatic ordinates L*, a*, b* of the absorption spectrum. Oil color changes for different varieties or stages of ripeness are directly related to pigment content and a* and b* values. The statistical study made on both series of parameters proves that there is a good correlation between them. The carotenoid content and b* have one of the best correlation coefficients (r) and is easily measured. This methodology evaluates chlorophyll and carotenoid content, an additional attribute for evaluation of virgin olive oil quality.     

Evaluation of MALDI-TOF/MS Technology in Olive Oil Adulteration

Adulteration of extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) by addition of other vegetable oils or lower-grade olive oils is a common problem of the oil market worldwide. Therefore, we developed a fast protocol for detection of EVOO adulteration by mass spectrometry fingerprinting of triacylglycerol (TAG) profiles based on MALDI-TOF/MS. For that purpose, EVOO TAG profiles were compared with those of edible sunflower oil and olive oil composed of refined olive oil and virgin olive oils. Adulteration of EVOO was simulated by addition of sunflower and mixture of refined olive oil and virgin olive oils at 1, 10 and 20% w/w. Results of mass spectrometry TAG profiling were compared with routinely assessed K values for identification of adulteration. MALDI-TOF/MS technology coupled with statistical analysis was proven as useful for detection of adulteration in EVOO at a rate down to 1%. In contrast, standard spectrophotometric methods failed to identify minor adulterations. In addition, the ability of MALDI-TOF/MS in detection of adulteration was tested on EVOO samples from different geographical regions. Results demonstrated that MALDI-TOF/MS technology coupled with statistical analysis is able to distinguish adulterated oils from other EVOO.     

Pigment parameters determining spanish virgin olive oil authenticity: Stability during storage

The chlorophyll and carotenoid pigment composition in 12 mono-variety virgin olive oils was examined every 30 d during 1 yr of storage at 15°C in darkness. The oil authenticity parameters, as defined by the ratio of chlorophylls/carotenoids and the ratio of minor carotenoids/lutein, remained stable throughout storage, irrespective of the variety and degree of ripeness of the source fruit. The percent of violaxanthin, percent of lutein, and total pigment content, the classifying variables chosen as the best possible discriminators among olive varieties, also remained stable during storage. The prediction model for olive variety, which was based on a discriminant multivariate analysis of the observed values of these variables, gave a correct classification in 99.6% of the oils analyzed. The discriminant criterion established remained valid after 1 yr of oil storage. The detection of chlorophyll derivatives other than those associated with the physical extraction process was seen as a quality index, as small, analytically detectable transformations in the structure of pigments were indicative of oil storage.     

Use of high-resolution 13C nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy for the screening of virgin olive oils

¹³C Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra of 104 oil samples were obtained and analyzed in order to study the use of this technique for routine screening of virgin olive oils. The oils studied included the following: virgin olive oils from different cultivars and regions of Europe and north Africa, and refined olive, “lampante” olive, refined olive pomace, high-oleic sunflower, hazelnut, sunflower, corn, soybean, rapeseed, grapeseed, and peanut oils, as well as mixtures of virgin olive oils from different geographical origins and mixtures of 5–50% hazelnut oil in virgin olive oil. The analysis of the spectra allowed us to distinguish among virgin olive oils, oils with a high content of oleic acid, and oils with a high content of linoleic acid, by using stepwise discriminant analysis. This parametric method gave 97.1% correct validated classifications for the oils. In addition, it classified correctly all the hazelnut oil samples and the mixtures of hazelnut oil in virgin olive oil assayed. All of these results suggested that ¹³C NMR may be used satisfactorily for discriminating some specific groups of oils, but to obtain 100% correct classifications for the different oils and mixtures, more information than that obtained from the direct spectra of the oils is needed.     

Influence of ecological cultivation on virgin olive oil quality

The quality of oil extracted from ecologically cultivated olives of the Picual variety was compared with oil extracted from Picual olives cultivated using conventional methods. Olive trees were grown in a two-section plot. Fruits from each plot were harvested at various stages of ripeness, and acidity value, peroxide index, ultraviolet absorption at 232 and 270 nm, stability to oxidation, sensory analysis, fatty composition, and contents of tocopherols, phenolic compounds, and sterols were determined on oil extracted from each treatment. The results showed that the organic virgin olive oil was of a superior quality to the conventional virgin olive oil in all the quality parameters analyzed.     

Stability of a phenol‐enriched olive oil during storage

The use of an emulsifier to stabilize the phenolic compounds added in the preparation of an enriched olive oil was evaluated. Two emulsifiers, lecithin and monoglyceride, were studied. The results showed lecithin to be the most convenient, due to the increase in the value of the oxidative stability of the phenol‐enriched oils in relation to the enrichments prepared with monoglycerides. After that, the shelf life of the prepared oils was evaluated during a period of 256 days of storage at 25°C in the dark. Oil quality parameters, total phenolic content, bitterness index and oxidative stability were studied during the storage period. Additionally, the phenolic composition and antioxidant capacity (by using the ORAC assay) were evaluated at the end of the storage. The phenolic enrichment of the oils allowed the shelf life of the oils to be extended compared with the control (virgin olive oil without phenol addition), delaying the appearance of peroxides and improving their oxidative stability. In addition, the higher content of phenolic compounds in the oils at all stages of storage is desirable in order to increase the intake of these beneficial compounds. Practical applications : The preparation of phenol‐enriched olive oils with a higher phenolic content than the commercial virgin olive oils is of special interest to increase the ingestion of these healthy compounds the daily intake of which is limited due to the high caloric value of olive oil. There are two key points in the development of this product: (i) the dispersion and stabilization of the phenol extract in the oil matrix and (ii) the stability of the phenols in the prepared oils to guarantee the phenol concentration during their shelf life. It is important to study the use of emulsifiers to determine if they allow an improvement in the dispersion of the phenolic extract, and their stabilization in the final product. In addition, the emulsifiers could mask the bitter taste of the enriched oils, which is desirable to increase consumer acceptance of the enriched oil.     

Chlorophyll and β-carotene pigments in moroccan virgin olive oils measured by high-performance liquid chromatography

Chlorophyll and β-carotene concentrations were determined by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) in virgin olive oils, which were press-extracted from green and semi-black olives. Pheophytin A was found to be the major chlorophyll isomer in all oil samples. The occurrence of this pigment at higher concentrations in oil extracted from green olives is a possible indication of its time-related destruction during olive ripening. Some evidence for thein vivo existence of pheophytin A is also presented. Beta-carotene concentration in oils was found to decrease during olive ripening.     

Detection of pressed hazelnut oil in admixtures with virgin olive oil by analysis of polar components

Analysis of the polar fraction from virgin olive oil and pressed hazelnut oil by high-performance liquid chromatography showed marked differences in the chromatograms of the polar components in the two oils. Six commercial samples of pressed hazelnut oil and 12 samples of virgin olive oil (or blended olive oil including virgin olive oil) were analyzed. The phenolic content of the pressed hazelnut oil samples was 161±6 mg·kg⁻¹. Inspection of the chromatograms showed that the pressed hazelnut oil extracts contained a component that eluted in a region of the chromatogram that was clear in the olive oil samples, and consequently this component could be used to detect adulteration of virgin olive oil by pressed hazelnut oil. The component had a relative retention time of 0.9 relative to 4-hydroxybenzoic acid added to the oil as an internal standard. The ultraviolet spectrum of the component showed a maximum at 293.8 nm, but the component could not be identified. Analysis of blends of oils showed that adulteration of virgin olive oil by commercial pressed hazelnut oil could be detected at a level of about 2.5%.     

The olive oil oxygen radical absorbance capacity (DPPH assay) as a quality indicator

The antioxidant properties of some single components and the total antioxidant activity of extra‐virgin olive oil have been evaluated by the oxygen radical absorbance capacity (ORAC) method. The total ORAC of the extra‐virgin olive oil was found to be positively correlated with the concentration of total polyphenols, which are important to the shelf life of the product. Among the single phenolic compounds studied, gallic acid showed a higher ORAC than caffeic acid and oleuropein, while among the derivates of oleuropein, hydroxytyrosol was found to be the most active compound among all the phenols studied. The total ORAC of commercial olive oils differed according to the concentration of total polyphenols. The total ORAC of extra‐virgin olive oil was constant during 1 year of storage in rational conditions, whereas it worsened dramatically in olive oil damaged by the lipase‐producing yeast Williopsis californica or by lipase from Pseudomonas spp. The study accomplished on the oily fraction of the fruits before harvesting demonstrated that the total ORAC of the oil of under‐ripe green olives is higher compared to that shown by mature fruits; therefore, through the choice of the harvesting time, it is possible to define also the future content of polyphenols of the oil. The total ORAC test, together with other analyses, can be considered as a qualitative parameter that can contribute to the expression of technological and health virtues of extra‐virgin olive oil.     

Chemical Composition and Sensory Quality of Tunisian ‘Sayali’ Virgin Olive Oils as Affected by Fruit Ripening: Toward an Appropriate Harvesting Time

Herein, the influence of the ripeness of Tunisian Sayali olives on the chemical composition and sensory quality of virgin olive oils have been investigated, with a particular focus on minor metabolites. Towards this end, five samples (S1–S5) were produced from fruits at increasing stages of maturity and then analyzed. Quality indices (free acidity, peroxide value, specific extinction in UV, sensory characteristics) and composition in major (fatty acids) and minor compounds (squalene, pigments, tocopherols, phenolic compounds, volatile compounds), as well as oxidative stability, were evaluated. Significant variations for the most analytical parameters of Sayali samples were demonstrated, highlighting the impact of stage of ripening. In particular, at later stages of ripening a decreased tendency was seen in minor compounds that are able to inhibit lipid oxidation (tocopherols, carotenoids, squalene and polar phenolic compounds) and, as a consequence, in the oxidative stability value. Moreover, a higher intensity of positive sensory notes (fruity, bitter and pungent) characteristic of extra virgin olive oil were found for samples produced with less ripe olives. Finally, a deeper knowledge of the influence of this factor would be helpful to correctly manage the optimal fruit harvesting time for producers for this variety and to improve the marketing of extra virgin olive oils by using a promising secondary variety (with a high oxidative stability and an interesting fatty acid composition).