Pullout Strength Models for FRP Anchors in Uncracked Concrete

Mechanical anchorage can delay or even prevent premature debonding failure in externally bonded fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite strengthening systems. A promising type of anchor made from FRP, which is known as a FRP spike anchor or FRP anchor among other names, is noncorrosive and can be applied to a wide range of structural elements and externally bonded FRP strengthening schemes. Experimental investigations have shown FRP anchors to be effective under tension (pullout) and shear loading, however, few analytical models exist to date. This paper in turn presents analytical models to quantify the pullout strength of FRP anchors. As existing research on the pullout behavior of metallic anchors is partially relevant to FRP anchors, this paper first presents a review of current pullout strength models for metallic anchors. These models are then assessed with experimental data of FRP anchors and modified and recalibrated where appropriate. As a result, simple and rational pullout strength models for FRP anchors are proposed which can also be used in design. Finally, parametric studies are undertaken and the influence of key variables is identified.     

Numerical Simulation of Vertical Pullout of Plate Anchors in Clay

The behavior of strip and circular plate anchors during vertical pullout in uniform and normally consolidated clays was studied in this paper by means of small strain and large deformation finite-element analyses. Both fully bonded (attached), and “vented” (no suction on rear face), anchors were considered. The current numerical results were compared with existing laboratory test data, finite-element results, and analytical solutions. This study showed that, in small strain analysis, the scatter of existing data was mainly due to the effect of soil stiffness. In large deformation analysis, when soil and anchor base were attached with suction, the pullout capacity factor formed a unique curve independent of the soil strength (su), soil effective unit weight (γ′) and anchor size (B=width of strip anchor and D=diameter of circular anchor). The transitional embedment depth ratio, HSD/B or HSD/D, (where HSD=transition depth between shallow and deep embedment) was 1.4 for a strip anchor and 0.75 for a circular anchor. The ultimate pullout capacity factors (Nc) for deep embedment were 11.6 and 11.7 for smooth and rough strip anchors and 13.1 and 13.7 for smooth and rough circular anchors, respectively. However, when the anchor base was vented, the soil stayed attached to the anchor base for deep embedment, and the pullout capacity was therefore the same as for the attached anchor. The separation depth ratio, Hs/B or Hs/D, (where Hs=embedment depth at which the soil and anchor base separated) was found to increase linearly with the normalized strength ratio, su/γ′B or su/γ′D.     

Linear Elastic Fracture Mechanics Pullout Analyses of Headed Anchors in Stressed Concrete

The results of research initiated in the early 1980s led to the replacement of plasticity-based design guidelines for the load-carrying capacity of headed anchors embedded in concrete with those developed using fracture mechanics. While provisions are available in the design codes that account for the presence of tensile fields causing concrete cracking, no provisions are available for anchors embedded in prestressed concrete. This paper presents the results of linear elastic fracture mechanics (LEFM) analyses and of a preliminary experimental investigation of the progressive failure of headed anchors embedded in a concrete matrix under compressive or tensile prestress. The model predicts an increase (decrease) in load-carrying capacity and ductility with increasing compressive (tensile) prestress. It is shown that despite neglecting the dependence on size of concrete fracture toughness, LEFM predicts with remarkable accuracy the functional dependence of the ultimate capacity on prestress.     

Uplift Behavior of Blade-Underreamed Anchors in Silty Sand

To evaluate the uplift behavior of anchors installed by the blade underreaming system, a numerical model for anchors in silty sand has been developed in this study and the calculated results are compared to the results of full scale anchor pullout tests. Although the blade-underreamed anchor tends to be irregular in shape due to possible collapse of the borehole, the excavated anchor showed an underreamed body of approximately multiple-stepped shape. Despite the difference in shape, the numerical results indicate that the difference between the load–displacement curve of the multiple-stepped anchor and that of the conical shaped anchor is small. In addition, the anchorage behavior of conical shaped anchors calculated from this numerical model was in good agreement with those of full scale anchor tests. No sign of progressive soil yielding along the underreamed body was found from the numerical analysis. So, the pull-out capacity of this underreamed anchor increases more than linearly with the length of the underream. Since only a small underream angle is needed to generate a substantial increase in anchor pull-out resistance, the ultimate pull-out capacity of the blade-underreamed anchor is found to be higher than that of straight shaft anchor in silty sand.     

Ultimate Uplift Capacity of Multiplate Helical Type Anchors in Clay

In recent years, the use of helical anchors has expanded beyond their traditional use in the electrical power industry. The advantages of rapid installation and immediate loading capability have resulted in their being used in more traditional civil engineering infrastructure applications. Unfortunately, our current understanding of these anchors is unsatisfactory, and the underlying theoretical framework adopted by engineers has proven to be largely inappropriate and inadequate. A better understanding of helical anchor behavior will lead to increased confidence in design, a wider acceptance as a foundation alternative, and more economic and safer designs. The primary aim of this research is to use numerical modeling techniques to better understand multiplate circular anchor foundation behavior in clay soils. A practical design framework for multiplate anchor foundations will be established to replace existing semiempirical design methods that are inadequate and have been found to be excessively under- or overconservative. This framework can then be used by design engineers to confidently estimate the pullout capacity of multiplate anchors under tension loading.     

Penetration Resistance of Offshore Skirted Foundations and Anchors in Dense Sand

Penetration of skirts is an essential design issue for offshore skirted foundations and anchors in sand. Skirts may not penetrate far enough into dense sand by the available submerged weight alone. It may therefore be necessary to apply underpressure inside the skirt compartment to produce an increased driving force and to reduce the penetration resistance. This paper recommends procedures to calculate penetration resistance and required underpressure for skirts penetrated in dense sand with and without interbedded clay layers. The recommendations are based on interpretation of skirt penetration data from prototypes, field model tests, and laboratory model tests in dense sand. The paper first presents a model to calculate the penetration resistance of skirts penetrated by weight, or other external vertical load that does not cause flow of water in the sand. Two models are considered; one based on bearing capacity equations with friction angles from laboratory tests, and the other one based on empirical correlations with CPT tip resistance. The bearing capacity model gives more consistent correlations with the empirical data than the CPT model. Thereafter, a model to account for the effect of underpressure applied inside the skirt compartment is proposed. This model is developed based on interpretation of available prototype and model test data from skirts penetrated by underpressure. The results show that underpressure facilitates skirt penetration in sand considerably by providing both an additional penetration force and a reduced penetration resistance. It is also shown that interbedded clay layers can prevent flow of water through the sand and eliminate the beneficial reduction in penetration resistance.     

Performance of Tension and Compression Anchors in Weathered Soil

Anchor pull-out tests were performed on seven instrumented full-scale low-pressure grouted anchors installed in weathered soil at the Geotechnical Experimentation Site at Sungkyunkwan University. Anchors were 165 mm in diameter and embedded 9 to 12 m in weathered soil. Four were compression type and three were tension anchors. Performance tests, creep tests, and long term relaxation tests were performed and the results are presented. The characteristics of grout-soil and grout-strand interface were investigated and presented. From the measurements, a load transfer mechanism for tension and compression ground anchors was investigated and evaluated by a simple beam-spring numerical model.     

Effects of Electrode Configuration on Electrokinetic Stabilization for Caisson Anchors in Calcareous Sand

The study is on the electrokinetic strengthening of caisson anchors embedded in offshore calcareous sand. The effects of electrode configuration on the effectiveness of electrokinetic treatment are investigated based on electric field analysis and are verified by results from a series of large scale laboratory tests on caisson models of 200?mm diam and 400?mm height, embedded in calcareous sand submerged under seawater. The electrokinetic treatment generates cementation of soil solids as well as bonding between soil and caisson shafts, which leads to increases in the side resistance and overall pullout resistance. The effectiveness of electrokinetic treatment is directly related to the electric field intensity. A linear relationship is observed between the increase in the side resistance and energy consumption. The study shows that the effectiveness of electrokinetic treatments can be maximized by the optimization of the electric field distribution through the electrode configuration.     

关塘铁矿斜井井筒施工中流沙及涌水的防治

关塘铁矿提升斜井原预计涌水量小于34m^3／h，斜井要穿越较厚的第四系冲积层和流沙层。在井筒掘进过程中，关塘铁矿遭遇了几次特大涌水和流沙等危害，通过采用注浆堵涌及挤压注浆固沙相结合的方案，解决了上部井筒渗水、淋水现象，井筒最终出水量小于10m^3／h，保证了井筒安全穿越软土含水层和流沙层的掘进施工．     

Field Pullout Testing and Performance Evaluation of GFRP Soil Nails

Glass fiber–reinforced polymer (GFRP) materials provide practical solutions to corrosion and site-maneuvering problems for civil infrastructures using conventional steel bars as reinforcements. In this study, the feasibility of using GFRP soil nails for slope stabilization is evaluated. The GFRP soil nail system consists of a GFRP pipe installed by the double-grouting technique. Two field-scale pullout tests were performed at a slope site. Fiber Bragg grating (FBG) sensors, strain gauges, linear variable displacement transformers (LVDTs), and a load cell were used to measure axial strain distributions and pullout force-displacement relationships during testing. The pullout test results of steel soil nails at another slope site are also presented for comparison. It is proven that the load transfer mechanisms of GFRP and steel soil nails have certain difference. Based on these test results, a simplified model using a hyperbolic shear stress-strain relationship was developed to describe the pullout performance of the GFRP soil nail. A parametric study was conducted using this model to study some factors affecting the pullout behavior of GFRP soil nails, including nail diameter, shear resistance of soil-grout interface, and ratio of interface shear coefficient to the Young’s modulus of the nail. The results indicate that the GFRP soil nail may exhibit excessive pullout displacement and thus a lower allowable pullout resistance than with the steel soil nail.     

Joined Influences of Nonlinearity and Dilation on the Ultimate Pullout Capacity of Horizontal Shallow Plate Anchors by Energy Dissipation Method

The ultimate pullout capacity (UPC) and the shape modification factors of horizontal plate anchors were calculated by using upper-bound limit analysis, in which the assumptions of both a nonlinear failure criterion and the nonassociated flow rule were made upon the soil mass above the anchor plate. Three types of anchor plates, including strip anchors, circle anchors, and rectangle anchors, and the corresponding failure mechanisms are taken into consideration. The anchor breakout factors were obtained according to the principle of virtual power, which was realized numerically by the nonlinear sequential quadratic programming algorithm. The shape modification factors for different kinds of anchors were given through a multiple nonlinear regression method. Numerical experiments demonstrate the validity of the solutions by reducing the solutions (nonlinear criterion and nonassociated flow rule) into their special cases (linear criterion and associated flow rule), which matches well with existing work. The dilation and nonlinearity of soil mass should be considered because it plays a remarkable role in the UPC of anchor plates.     

Mathematical Modeling of Encapsulated Buffer Performance in Sand Columns

A one-dimensional mathematical model was developed to simulate pH control using an encapsulated phosphate buffer during denitrification in a sand column. The parameters required for the model were obtained from direct physical measurement, from a tracer study to characterize the dispersion coefficient in the column, and from batch experiments designed to obtain an empirical expression describing the variation of the first-order rate constant for the encapsulated buffer core release with pH. First-order kinetic constants describing the rates of denitrification and ethanol biodegradation were obtained by fitting the model to column runs without the encapsulated buffer. With these parameters, the model was subsequently used to predict the performance of column runs containing the encapsulated buffer. Since denitrification was essentially complete in the sand columns, an increase in the effluent pH was observed. This pH increase was counteracted by the controlled release of the acidic core of the encapsulated buffers added in the columns. The model reasonably predicted the release of the encapsulated buffer core and the performance of the encapsulated buffer for controlling pH in the column.     

钢筋直螺纹接头变形性能的分析

通过钢筋及相应的滚轧直螺纹接头的对比试验分析表明,过分地追求钢筋接头的等强度连接,忽视钢筋接头的刚性性能,将会对钢筋混凝土构件的质量产生一定的影响.     

Rapid Pullout Test of Soil Nail

This technical paper describes the rapid pullout response of soil nail embedded in dry clean sand. In the rapid pullout test, soil nail is pullout by a tensile impulse load with loading duration that is long enough to eliminate the influence of the stress wave propagation phenomenon. The results of these experiments showed the influence of loading rate on pullout response is highly dependent on the roughness condition of the nail surface. For rough nail, the prepeak rapid pullout response was significantly stiffer in the load-displacement characteristic and higher in peak pullout strength when compared to the corresponding quasi-static pullout response. While for a smooth nail, a negligible difference between rapid and quasi-static pullout response was noticed. In light of these limited experimental results, the radiation damping effect appears to be the dominant contributor to the enhancements in prepeak rapid pullout response of rough nail. “Actual” damping coefficient that quantifies the damping resistance mobilized in a rapid pullout test was found not to be constant but to decrease with the increase in pullout displacement.     

Tensile Behavior of FRP Anchors in Concrete

Strengthening of concrete structures using fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) systems has become a widely accepted technology in the construction industry over the past decade. Externally bonded FRP sheets are proven to be a feasible alternative to traditional methods for strengthening and stiffening deficient reinforced or prestressed concrete members. However, the delamination of FRP sheets from the concrete surface poses major concerns, as it usually leads to a brittle member failure. This paper reports on the development of FRP anchors to overcome delamination problems encountered in surface bonded FRP sheets. An experimental investigation was conducted on the performance of carbon FRP anchors that were embedded in normal- and high-strength concrete test specimens. A total of 81 anchors were tested under monotonic uniaxial loading. Test parameters included the length, diameter, and angle of inclination of the anchors and the compressive strength of the concrete. The experimental results indicate that FRP anchors can be designed to achieve high pullout capacities and hence can be used effectively to prevent or delay the delamination of externally bonded FRP sheets. The results also indicate that the diameter, length, and the angle of inclination of the anchors have a significant influence on the pullout capacity of FRP anchors.     

Design Considerations of Carbon Fiber Anchors

Carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets can be used to strengthen existing reinforced concrete members. However, debonding (separation of the CFRP sheet from the concrete surface) may occur at less than 50% of CFRP sheet’s tensile capacity, implying that half of the CFRP material is ineffective in increasing the strength of a concrete member. The use of carbon fiber anchors can increase the amount of tension carried in the CFRP sheets. Forty specimens were tested to develop initial design parameters of carbon fiber anchors. Tests showed that by providing anchors with a total cross-sectional area at least two times greater than that of the longitudinal sheet, it was possible to fracture the CFRP sheets. The best results were obtained using a greater number of smaller anchors. Further, surface preparation is unimportant when the CFRP sheets were well anchored and a 1:4 transition slope can manage any offsets in surface level. The general anchor design was then implemented on a series of long beams and demonstrated that the full CFRP sheet tensile capacity can be realized without incurring limitations due to debonding.     

Uncertainties of Field Pullout Resistance of Soil Nails

A large number of field pullout tests on soil nails have been carried out to provide valuable information for enhancing the understanding of pullout resistance of soil-grout interface and for reliability evaluation of soil-nailed slopes. In this paper, a data set of 167 field pullout tests performed in 23 nailed completely decomposed granite cut slopes is used for a statistical evaluation of four factors influencing the pullout resistance of soil nails, namely overburden pressure, grout length, soil suction, and soil dilatancy. For the tests in which nails were pulled out, the measured pullout resistance is essentially independent of the effective overburden pressure. A bias factor r* is defined as the ratio of the measured pullout resistance and the calculated value using a design equation. The mean value of r* is 4.30 and the coefficient of variation is 47%. When the uncertainties in grout length, soil suctions around nails, and the soil shear dilatancy are considered, the mean value of r* can finally be reduced to 0.99. The quantification of the uncertainties provides a better physical understanding of the working mechanisms of soil nails.     

Seismic Performance of a River Dike Improved by Sand Compaction Piles

Sand compaction piling is one of the commonly used countermeasures for earthquake liquefaction hazard of river dikes. This paper presents a case study of the performance of an instrumented dike in northeast Japan that was improved by sand compaction piles and subjected to the 2003 Northern Miyagi Earthquake, with the aim to better understand the effectiveness of this ground improvement method. Simulation has been carried out by means of a fully coupled numerical procedure which employs a sophisticated cyclic elastoplastic constitutive model and the updated Lagrangian algorithm. Comparisons between the field measurements and the computed responses, including the time histories of accelerations and pore-water pressures at different locations, show reasonably good agreement. Numerical simulation has also been made of the same dike but without ground improvement to identify the effects of sand compaction piles in altering the performance of the dike. The study demonstrates that the comprehensive numerical procedure is a promising tool for development of seismic performance-based design of earth structures.     

Soil–Nail Pullout Interaction in Loose Fill Materials

A laboratory study was conducted to investigate the behavior of soil nails embedded in loosely compacted sandy fills. By varying the overburden pressure, the peak pullout force and the load–displacement behavior were determined by carrying out pullout tests in a displacement-rate controlled manner. The test results were compared to other published ones. The present results show that the pullout resistance can be interpreted with conventional soil parameters. The effect of retrained dilatancy, which is considered to be the reason for high pullout resistance in dense materials, is negligible in loose fill materials except under very low stress level. Furthermore, pullout resistance increases with overburden pressure opposed to some field test results reported in the literature which show no systematic trend in pullout resistance with overburden pressure. A numerical model was developed to simulate the mobilization of pullout force in soil nails. It has been shown that a simple one-dimensional spring model can be used to simulate the pullout load–displacement relationship.     

Tensile Capacity of GFRP Postinstalled Adhesive Anchors in Concrete

This paper presents the results of an experimental study conducted on the pullout capacity of glass fiber reinforced polymer (GFRP) postinstalled adhesive anchors embedded in concrete. A total of 90 adhesive anchors were installed using sand-coated GFRP reinforcing bars and tested under monotonic tension loading in accordance with ASTM E-488-96 in 1996. The test parameters were: (1) the GFRP bar diameter (25.4, 15.9, and 6.4?mm); (2) the embedment depth (5, 10, and 15 db where db=bar diameter); (3) the adhesive type (epoxy-based and cement-based adhesives); and (4) installation conditions (wet or partially submerged and dry holes). The tested GFRP adhesive anchors were installed in concrete slabs measuring 3,750?mm long, 1,750?mm wide, and 400?mm deep. The test specimens were kept outdoors for 7?months to be subjected to real environmental conditions including freeze-thaw cycles, wet and dry cycles, and temperature variations. The experimental results indicated the adequate performance of GFRP adhesive anchors installed in wet or partially submerged condition using epoxy-based adhesive. Similar behavior was observed for those installed with cement-based adhesive in dry conditions as well. The capacity of the GFRP bars installed with both adhesive types was achieved at an embedment depth ranging from 10 to 15 db.