Adjusting selectivity in liquid chromatography by use of the thermally tuned tandem column concept

In this study, we propose the novel "thermally tuned tandem column (T3C)" concept for the optimization of selectivity in LC by continuous adjustment of the stationary phase. Two columns with distinctly different chromatographic selectivities (e.g., polybutadiene- and carbon-coated zirconia) are serially coupled and independently temperature-controlled. Selectivity is "tuned" by adjusting the individual temperatures of the two columns. The effect of changing column temperature is quite analogous to changing the relative column lengths, thereby altering the relative and absolute contribution each column makes to the overall retention time in T3C. The distinct selectivity differences between polybutadiene- and carbon-coated zirconia as well as the extraordinary thermal stability of zirconia-based phases (thermally stable to 200 degrees C) allow us to tune the overall chromatographic selectivity over a very substantial range. We have developed a simplified useful model, which characterizes retention and selectivity for the T3C system as a function of the two column temperatures. The model is in good agreement with the experimental results. We also describe a simple computer-assisted optimization strategy based on the window diagram method, which facilitates the optimization of the T3C system with only four or five initial runs.     

Silica xerogel as a continuous column support for high-performance liquid chromatography

A preliminary study of the chromatographic performance and permeability of a continuous silica xerogel column under reversed-phase HPLC conditions was performed. A porous chromatographic support was synthesized inside a 0.32 mm i.d. × 13 cm fused silica tube from potassium silicate solution and derivatized with dimethyloctadecylchlorosilane. The plate height at 0.01 cm/s (0.5 μL/min), near the apparent optimum linear velocity, was about 65 μm. The column efficiencies in terms of numbers of plates per meter were 5000 and 13?000 for ethyl benzoate (k = 0.8) and naphthalene (k = 2.0), respectively, at 0.5 μL/min. The major parameter affecting column efficiency was the heterogeneous morphology of the xerogel, modifications to which are expected to improve chromatographic performance. The column provided efficiencies comparable to those reported for continuous polymeric columns but less than that previously reported for a continuous silica column. Gradient elution mode was demonstrated with a mixture of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. The column was highly permeable, exhibiting a linear dependence of pressure to flow rate and a back pressure of only 632 psi at 10 μL/min when a 95% aqueous mobile phase was used.     

Combination of column temperature gradient and mobile phase flow gradient in microcolumn and capillary column high-performance liquid chromatography

The combination of several gradient modes (solvent, temperature, and flow programming) is rarely used in HPLC analysis. In this work, the separations obtained utilizing simultaneous flow and temperature gradient in capillary column and microcolumn HPLC were compared with the separations performed under isocratic, isothermal, and isorheic (constant flow) conditions. When the mobile phase flow rate and the column temperature were changed simultaneously during the separation run, the analysis time was shortened up to 50%, while the separation efficiency was preserved. The separations obtained with combined temperature and flow gradients show high reproducibility (relative standard deviation <2.0%), comparable to the reproducibility normally seen with a mobile phase gradient. For capillary HPLC, simultaneous temperature and flow programming is the method of choice because of the great technical difficulties involved in performing solvent gradient elution.     

Surface-enhanced resonance Raman spectroscopy as an identification tool in column liquid chromatography

The compatibility of ion-pair reversed-phase column liquid chromatography and surface-enhanced resonance Raman spectroscopy (SERRS) for separation and identification of anionic dyes has been investigated, with emphasis on the at-line coupling via a thin-layer chromatography (TLC) plate. SERR spectra using silver sols were recorded both for aqueous solutions and for samples deposited on aluminum oxide and silica TLC plates at 514.5- and 457.9-nm laser excitation. For some dyes, the shorter wavelength was needed to diminish the fluorescence background. For aqueous solutions and for samples deposited on aluminum oxide, clear SERR spectra were obtained upon addition of poly(L-lysine); for the silica plates, the addition of nitric acid was required. Upon drying the plates, the SERRS signals decreased in intensity; simply adding a drop of water could largely restore them. At-line coupling of LC and SERRS was successfully achieved when using silica, but not aluminum oxide, plates. The application of a gradient, a high water content, and the presence of ion-pair reagents needed for the separation did not adversely affect the deposition and the recording of SERR spectra. The identification limits were 10-20 ng of deposited material, depending on the dye selected, which corresponded to injected concentrations of 5-10 microg mL(-1).     

Shape selectivity for constrained solutes in reversed-phase liquid chromatography

In reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC), the separation of compound mixtures of similar polarity can present a significant challenge for the analyst. Examples of such compounds include geometric isomers present in environmental samples (e.g., polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, polycyclic aromatic sulfur heterocycles, and polychlorinated biphenyl congeners) and compounds of biological significance (e.g., carotenoids and steroids). In general, compounds with rigid, well-defined molecular shape are best separated using a column with enhanced shape selectivity characteristics. This perspective presents an overview of column properties that influence shape selectivity for constrained solutes. Approaches to the characterization of stationary-phase structure are described, and the findings are correlated with chromatographic performance. Finally, retention models of shape discrimination are presented that are consistent with observed retention behavior. An appreciation for shape recognition effects in RPLC will facilitate method development for certain classes of difficult to resolve compounds.     

Thermal capacity of liquid diheptyl ether as a function of temperature and pressure

We have studied the iosbaric thermal capacity of liquid diheptyl ether in the temperature range 313&#x2013;473 K and pressure range 0.101&#x2013;49.05 MPa.Translated from Izmeritel'naya Tekhnika, No. 2, pp. 42&#x2013;43, February, 1995.     

Simulation and optimization of retention in ion chromatography using virtual column 2 software

A new software package, Virtual Column 2, is described for the simulation and optimization of the separation of inorganic anions by ion chromatography (IC). The software uses a limited amount of experimental retention data acquired according to a correct experimental design to predict retention times for analytes over a designated search area of eluent compositions. The experimental retention data are used to solve a new retention model, called the linear solvent strength model, empirical approach (LSSM-EA), which then enables prediction of retention times for all eluent compositions in the search area. The theoretical development of LSSM-EA and the processes used for solving the equations are discussed. Virtual Column 2 can be used for eluents containing one or two competing ions, and the software contains retention databases for up to 33 analytes on the Dionex AS9A-HC, AS4A-SC, and AS14A analytical columns with carbonate-bicarbonate eluents and the Dionex AS10, AS15, and AS16 analytical columns with hydroxide eluents (results for the AS10 and AS15 columns are not discussed in the present study). Virtual Column 2 has been evaluated extensively and is shown to give predicted retention times that in most cases agree with experimentally determined data to within 5%. The software has uses in practical IC method development, education and training in IC, and refinement of existing IC methodology. A free version of this program is available by download at www.virtualcolumn.com.     

Induced free liquid surface oscillations in a visco-elastic liquid column due to angular temperature fluctuations

The response due to time-fluctuating temperature distribution applied at the free surface of a viscoelastic cylindrical liquid column with no axial dependency has been determined analytically. The amplitude of the radial- and angular velocity as well as the free liquid surface elevation has been presented as a function of the “reduced” forcing frequency of the oscillatory temperature and has numerically been evaluated for an angular temperature field proportional to sin 2φ. It was found, that visco-elasticity as described by the Maxwell model has quite some influence upon the liquid behavior. It shows for larger relaxation times besides the enlarged resonance peak additional peaks below and above resonance. This is particularly evident inside the liquid column, indicating a more pronounced elastic behavior of the liquid.     

Effect of a variety of organic additives on retention and efficiency in micellar liquid chromatography

The effect of 21 organic additives (alkanols, alkane diols, dipolar aprotic solvents, alkanes) on the chromatographic behavior (retention, elution strength, efficiency) of probe solutes of widely differing hydrophobicity, such as benzene and 2-ethylanthraquinone, have been examined using a C18 stationary phase and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micellar mobile phases. The mobile-phase elution strength parallels the octanol-water partition coefficients of the additives or their ability to bind to the SDS micellar system, due to the increased solubility in the mobile phase and reduced affinity for the additive-modified surfactant-coated stationary phase. The comparison of the elution strength of micellar mobile phases with that of a reference acetonitrile-water system indicates that the elution strength is lower for micellar systems and depends on the nature of the eluted solute. The displacement of the solute-micelle and solute-stationary phase binding equilibria is quantified for several probe solutes eluted with micellar mobile phases in the presence of 1-propanol, 1-butanol, 1-pentanol, and acetonitrile. A correlation was also observed between the number of theoretical plates and the hydrophobicity of the alcohol additives: the efficiency initially increased steeply and reached a plateau. Compared to benzene, a more hydrophobic additive was needed to attain the maximum efficiency for the more hydrophobic 2-ethylanthraquinone analyte. Dipolar aprotic solvents appear to be somewhat more effective in enhancing the efficiency than alcohols. The results are rationalized in terms of the ability of the organic additives to alter the composition, structure, dynamics, and properties of the micelles and the surfactant-coated stationary phase.     

Liquid surface oscillations in a viscous liquid column induced by temperature fluctuations

It was found that timewise fluctuating temperature gradients induce, due to the variation of the surface tension, oscillations of the free surface of a liquid column, which may in or close to resonance lead to large amplitudes, able to disingtegrate the liquid system. An analytical solution leading to the magnification functions and their phases is presented for an arbitrary angular temperature field.     

Geometrical model for the retention of fullerenes in high-performance liquid chromatography

In high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) using a poly(octadecylsiloxane) as a stationary phase, methanol as a mobile phase, C(60) and C(70) fullerenes as solutes, and water as a mobile phase modifier, a study on the surface tension effect of water on fullerene retention was carried out by varying the water concentration [W] and the column temperature T. The thermodynamic parameters for fullerene transfer from the mobile to the stationary phase were determined from linear van't Hoff plots. An enthalpy-entropy compensation revealed that the types of interactions between fullerenes and the stationary phase were independent of the fullerene structure and the mobile phase composition. An analysis of the experimental variations of the retention factor and the selectivity values with [W] was performed using a novel geometrical model. It was shown that the increase in fullerene retention accompanying the water concentration was due to the increased effects of surface tension. This brought about an increase in the interactions between fullerene and the stationary phase, explaining the observed thermodynamic parameter trends over the water concentration range. The theoretical model provided an estimation of the radius of fullerene which was found for C(60) to be equal to 3.3 ? and an activation energy during the transfer equal to 9.8 kJ/mol.     

Performance of a liquid thermal-diffusion column with temperature asymmetry over the width

The theory of thermal diffusion [1] employs an idealized model in which the temperature at all points on the hot or cold surface is assumed to be the same. In practice, however, such a model cannot be realized, since even the most careful design of the column will result in asymmetry in the temperature distributions on these surfaces. This asymmetry is more pronounced in liquid columns because of the small width of the annulus, and so the column acquires parasitic convection [1], which results in resolution worse than theory predicts. The origin of this effect, which is extremely undesirable in practical operation is explained in Fig. 1a [1]. The azimuthal temperature gradient in regions I and II causes the mean temperature of the liquid to vary, so the liquid as a whole moves in one direction in region I and in the opposite direction in region II; in each of these regions there are also two flows caused by the radial temperature gradient, which is incorporated in the theory of the column.Translated from Inzhenerno-Fizicheskii Zhurnal, Vol. 19, No. 5, pp. 809–817, November 1970.One prime and two primes refer, respectively, to the column parts shown in Fig. 1 as I and II.     

Generating multiple independent retention index data in dual-secondary column comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography

A method producing simultaneously three retention indexes for compounds has been developed for comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography by using a dual secondary column approach (GC x 2GC). For this purpose, the primary flow of the first dimension column was equally diverted into two secondary microbore columns of identical geometry by means of a three-way flow splitter positioned after the longitudinally modulated cryogenic system. This configuration produced a pair of comprehensive two-dimensional chromatograms and generated retention data on three different stationary phases in a single run. First dimension retention indexes were determined on a polar SolGel-Wax column under linear programmed-temperature conditions according to the van den Dool approach using primary alcohol homologues as the reference scale. Calculation of pseudoisothermal retention indexes in both second dimensions was performed on low-polarity 5% phenyl equivalent polysilphenylene/siloxane (BPX5) and 14% cyanopropylphenyl/86% dimethylpolysiloxane (BP10) columns. To construct a retention correlation map in the second dimension separation space upon which KovAts indexes can be derived, two methods exploiting "isovolatility" relationships of alkanes were developed. The first involved 15 sequential headspace samplings of selected n-alkanes by solid-phase microextraction (SPME), with each sampling followed by their injection into the GC at predetermined times during the chromatographic run. The second method extended the second dimension retention map and consisted of repetitive introduction of SPME-sampled alkane mixtures at various isothermal conditions incremented over the temperature program range. Calculated second dimension retention indexes were compared with experimental values obtained in conventional one-dimensional GC. A case study mixture including 24 suspected allergens (i.e., fragrance ingredients) was used to demonstrate the feasibility and potential of retention index information in comprehensive 2D-GC.     

Complete temperature profiles in ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography columns

The temperature profiles were calculated along and across seven packed columns (lengths 30, 50, 100, and 150 mm, i.d., 1 and 2.1 mm, all packed with Acquity UPLC, BEH-C 18 particles, average d(p) approximately 1.7 microm) and their stainless steel tubes (o.d. 4.53 and 6.35 mm). These columns were kept horizontal and sheltered from forced air convection (i.e., under still air conditions), at room temperature. They were all percolated with pure acetonitrile, either under the maximum pressure drop (1034 bar) or at the maximum flow rate (2 mL/min) permitted by the chromatograph. The heat balance equation of chromatographic columns was discretized and solved numerically with minimum approximation. Both the compressibility and the thermal expansion of the eluent were taken into account. The boundary conditions were determined from the experimental measurements of the column inlet pressure and of the temperature profile along the column wall, which were made with a precision better than +/-0.1 K. These calculation results provide the 3-D temperature profiles along and across the columns. The axial and radial temperature gradients are discussed in relationship with the experimental conditions used. The temperature map obtained permits a prediction of the chromatographic data obtained under a very high pressure gradient.