Ferritic stainless steel tubular members strengthened with high modulus CFRP plate subjected to web crippling

Web crippling failure of ferritic stainless steel tubular structural members could be found due to localised concentrated loads or reactions. This paper reports experimental and numerical investigation on strengthening of ferritic stainless steel tubular members using externally bonded high modulus carbon fibre-reinforced polymer (CFRP) plate. The CFRP plate strengthening is only applied to a small localise area subjected to concentrated load. A series of tests on CFRP strengthened ferritic stainless steel square and rectangular hollow sections subjected to web crippling was conducted. The web crippling tests were conducted under four loading conditions of end-two-flange (ETF), interior-two-flange (ITF), end-one-flange (EOF) and interior-one-flange (IOF). A total of 37 web crippling tests was conducted in this study. The investigation was mainly focused on the effects of web slenderness of ferritic stainless steel tubular sections on CFRP strengthening against web crippling. The tests were performed on five different sizes of square and rectangular hollow sections. The ferritic stainless steel type EN 1.4003 test specimens were used in this study. Tensile coupon tests were conducted to determine the material properties of the ferritic stainless steel specimens. Most of the strengthened specimens were failed by debonding of CFRP plate from the ferritic stainless steel tubes. Two different failure modes were observed in the tests of the strengthened specimens, namely the adhesion failure as well as the combination of adhesion and cohesion failure. Finite element models have been developed and verified against the test results. The failure loads, failure modes and the load-web deformation behaviour of the ferritic stainless steel sections are also presented.     

FRP strengthened aluminium tubular sections subjected to web crippling

This paper presents a test programme on aluminium tubular structural members that have experienced web crippling failure due to localized concentrated loads or reactions. A series of tests was performed on fibre-reinforced polymer (FRP) strengthening of aluminium tubular structural members subjected to End-Two-Flange and Interior-Two-Flange loading conditions. A total of 58 web crippling tests was conducted. The investigation was mainly focused on the effects of different adhesive and FRP for strengthening of aluminium tubular sections against web crippling. The influence of different widths of FRP plate strengthening against web crippling has been also investigated in this study. The test specimens consisted of 6061-T6 heat-treated aluminium alloy square and rectangular hollow sections. Six different adhesives and six different FRPs were considered in this study. The properties of adhesive and FRP have significant influence on the effectiveness of the strengthening. Most of the strengthened specimens were failed by debonding of FRP plates from the aluminium tubes. There are mainly four different failure modes observed in the tests, namely the adhesion, cohesion, combination of adhesion and cohesion, and interlaminar failure of FRP plate. The failure loads, failure modes, and the load-web deformation behaviour of the aluminium sections are presented in this study. It was found that the web crippling capacity of aluminium tubular sections is significantly increased due to FRP strengthening, especially for those sections with large value of web slenderness ratio.     

FRP strengthening of lean duplex stainless steel hollow sections subjected to web crippling

This paper presents the experimental and numerical investigations of lean duplex stainless steel hollow sections subjected to web crippling. The test specimens were strengthened with different fibre-reinforced polymer (FRP). The web crippling tests were conducted under end-two-flange, interior-two-flange, end-one-flange and interior-one-flange loading conditions. A series of web crippling tests was conducted. The investigation was focused on the effects of surface treatment, web slenderness, different adhesives and FRPs for the strengthening of lean duplex stainless steel hollow sections against web crippling. The lean duplex stainless steel type EN 1.4162 was used in the investigation. Two different surface treatments, three different adhesives and six different FRPs were investigated in this study. The tests were performed on five different sizes of square and rectangular hollow sections that covered a wide range of web slenderness ratio from 8.1 to 57.3. Three different failure modes were observed in the tests of the strengthened specimens, namely the adhesion, interlaminar failure of FRP plate and combination of adhesion and interlaminar failure of FRP plate. Finite element models have been developed and verified against the test results of the specimens subjected to two-flange loading conditions.     

Design rules for web crippling of CFRP strengthened aluminium rectangular hollow sections

Web crippling failure (web buckling and web yielding) is critical for thin-walled members when subjected to concentrated load. Carbon fibre reinforced polymer (CFRP) is attracting increasing research interest as a strengthening material for metallic structural members. Improved web crippling capacity of aluminium rectangular hollow sections has been achieved with CFRP being attached to the exterior and/or interior of the webs from a series of tests conducted by the authors. This paper focuses on developing design rules for predicting the nominal crippling strength of CFRP strengthened sharp-corner aluminium tubular sections: rectangular hollow section (RHS) and square hollow section (SHS), under end bearing load. The existing design rules for bare sections without CFRP strengthening are firstly reviewed and assessed, including design rules for both cold-formed steel structural members (Australian/New Zealand standard (AS 4100-1998) and North American Specification) and aluminium structures (Australian/New Zealand standard (AS 1664-1997) and American aluminium design manual). They are modified to take account of the improved capacity due to CFRP strengthening. The proposed design rules are calibrated against test results.     

第五届钢结构进展国际会议（ICASS2007）2007年12月5～7日，新加坡

主办单位：新加坡国立大学 新加坡钢结构协会 钢结构进展国际会议是举办了多年的盛会，第一次到第三次会议在中国香港召开，第四次会议于2005年在中国上海召开。大会旨在为钢结构的科研工作者和工程师们提供一个平台，使他们能够就钢结构、铝结构和组合结构的分析、性能、设计以及施工等方面的最新进展互相交流探讨。     

考虑单侧翼缘受载腹板屈曲的不锈钢钢管设计

本文给出了冷成型不锈钢方钢管和矩形钢管在腹板屈曲时的设计公式。研究了两种单翼缘加载的情况,一种是端部单翼缘加载,另一种是内部单翼缘加载,此外还研究了内部加载的情况。采用屈服线理论预测了不锈钢管截面的腹板屈曲强度。屈服线理论模型是在试验中观察到的破坏模式的基础上发展起来的。在屈服线模型基础上采用不同的假定,给出了计算冷成型不锈钢方钢管和矩形钢管的腹板屈曲强度的三种设计方法。其中两种腹板屈曲设计方法是完全采用屈服线分析理论推导出来的,另外一种设计方法是综合理论分析和经验分析得到的。将试验得到的腹板屈曲强度和这三种设计方法得到的屈曲强度进行了对比。结果表明采用纯理论推导得到的设计方法计算得到的腹板屈曲设计强度偏于保守,而综合了理论分析和经验分析得到的设计方法其计算的腹板屈曲设计强度值比较合理,可以用于单翼缘受载时冷成型不锈钢管的设计。     

Experimental and numerical investigations of cold-formed stainless steel tubular sections subjected to concentrated bearing load

Experimental and numerical investigations of cold-formed stainless steel square and rectangular hollow sections subjected to concentrated bearing load are presented in this paper. A total of 124 data are presented that include 64 test results and 60 numerical results. The tests were performed on austenitic stainless steel type 304, high strength austenitic and duplex material. The measured web slenderness value of the tubular sections ranged from comparatively stocky webs of 6.2 to relatively more slender webs of 61.4. The tests were carried out under end and interior loading conditions. A non-linear finite element model is developed and verified against experimental results. Geometric and material non-linearities were included in the finite element model. The material nonlinearity of the flat and corner portions of the specimen sections were carefully incorporated in the model. It was shown that the finite element model closely predicted the web crippling strengths and failure modes of the tested specimens. Hence, the model was used for an extensive parametric study of cross-section geometries, and the web slenderness value ranged from 52.0 to 206.7. The test results and the web crippling strengths predicted from the finite element analysis were compared with the design strengths obtained using the American, Australian/New Zealand and European specifications for stainless steel structures. A unified web crippling equation with new coefficients for cold-formed stainless steel square and rectangular hollow sections subjected to concentrated bearing load is proposed. It is demonstrated that the proposed web crippling equation is safe and reliable using reliability analysis.     

不锈钢受弯构件的试验研究

采用国产的304牌号不锈钢,针对冷成型SHS、RHS和焊接工字钢截面,11种不同截面规格,共39根受弯构件,进行受弯构件试验研究。考察两端简支不锈钢梁在不同的加载方式和腹板约束条件下的极限承载力和破坏形式。通过试验发现:两端简支不锈钢冷成型SHS、RHS梁在集中荷载作用下根据加载方式和腹板约束条件的不同,主要有3种破坏形式,即整体弯曲破坏、腹板压屈破坏、两者耦合破坏。两端简支不锈钢焊接工字形梁在集中荷载作用下以发生弯扭失稳为主。在对两端简支不锈钢梁截面的抗弯强度、非线性挠度以及平面外稳定等受力性能分析的基础上,将试验结果与欧洲不锈钢设计规范(EN1993-1-4)和美国不锈钢设计规范(SEI/ASCE 8-02)进行对比分析。对比结果表明:试验得到的构件抗弯强度和平面外稳定承载能力均高于上述规范计算值,规范偏于保守;按上述规范计算得到的挠度小于试验值,规范偏于不安全。     

Study of web crippling in ferritic stainless steel cold formed sections

Cold-formed stainless steel members are widely used due to their high corrosion resistance and high resistance-to-weight ratio but their susceptibility to buckle implies that instability phenomena such as web crippling, where the web locally buckles due to concentrated transverse forces, must be considered. On the other hand, the emergent ferritic stainless steel has very low nickel content and therefore, they are cheaper and relatively price stable compared to austenitics and duplex. Their promising future has aimed to develop efficient design guidance and as a result, a new unified web crippling resistance expression based on numerical simulations and thereafter validated with experimental results has been proposed.     

Analysis and design of cold-formed steel channels subjected to combined bending and web crippling

The channel failures due to combined bending and web crippling may occur at the highly concentrated interior loading when there is no load stiffener in cold-formed thin-walled steel beams. This paper presents accurate finite element models to predict the behavior and ultimate strengths of cold-formed steel channels subjected to pure bending as well as combined bending and web crippling. Both geometric and material nonlinearities are considered in the finite element analysis. The nonlinear finite element models are verified against experimental results of cold-formed steel channels subjected to pure bending as well as combined bending and web crippling. The finite element analytical results show a good agreement with the experimental results in terms of the ultimate loads and moments, failure modes and web load-deformation curves thus validating the accuracy of the finite element models. The verified finite element models are then used for an extensive parametric study of different channel dimensions. The channel strengths predicted from the parametric study are compared with the design strengths calculated from the North American Specification for cold-formed steel structures. It is shown that the design rules in the North American Specification are generally conservative for channel sections with unstiffened flanges having the web slenderness ranged from 7.8 to 108.5 subjected to combined bending and web crippling. It is demonstrated that the nonlinear finite element analysis by using the verified finite element models against test results is an effective way to predict the ultimate strengths of cold-formed thin-walled steel members.     

Experimental investigation on ferritic stainless steel columns in fire

This paper presents the performance of EN 1.4003 ferritic stainless steel hollow section columns when exposed to fire loading. Experimental analysis of the behaviour of ferritic stainless steel structural members in fire represents a novelty. In detail, three column tests were carried out in the framework of the Research Fund of Coal and Steel (RFCS) project named Structural Applications of Ferritic Stainless Steels (SAFSS, RFSR-CT-2010-00026). Tubular thin-walled members were considered in this study because structural applications of ferritic stainless steels generally incorporate such profiles. Three columns were tested: two square hollow sections (SHS) and a rectangular hollow section (RHS) of different length. Fire loading was applied under a constant concentrically compressive load. Identical column tests at room temperature are also reported.     

A new slenderness-based approach for the web crippling design of plain channel steel beams

In this paper, the web crippling strength of cold-formed steel plain channel beams subjected to concentrated loads is evaluated on the basis of numerical models and available test results. The design equations existing in current steel codes display many coefficients, have not theoretical background and overlook the slenderness concept, which is a trademark of safety checking rules related with other failure modes such as column flexural-torsional buckling, web shear buckling and plate buckling. The main objective is to show that such slenderness-based approach is possible for web crippling design. Firstly, some considerations about the web crippling of cold-formed steel beams are drawn and a brief review is made. Secondly, the equations for web crippling design available in current Eurocode 3 and AISI steel codes are described. Then, the numerical model is explained in detail. On the basis of numerical and experimental results, it is shown that an approach based on the slenderness concept leads to fairly good estimates of web crippling load. Finally, some conclusions are drawn.     

双翼缘荷载作用下腹板开洞冷弯型钢截面的腹板压屈(1):试验和有限元分析

进行了82个腹板压屈试验,其中20个试验为没有开洞腹板的槽形截面,62个为有开洞腹板的槽形截面。试验考虑了端部双翼缘受荷和内部双翼缘受荷2种工况。在有开洞腹板的试验中,洞口直接位于集中荷载处。集中荷载通过承重板施加;研究了不同支承长度的影响。另外,还考虑了翼缘与支撑固定和不固定2种工况。介绍了非线性弹塑性有限元模型,研究表明,在强度和失效模式下有限元模拟结果与试验结果均吻合较好。     

Web crippling behaviour of laterally restrained cold-formed steel re-entrant profiled deckings

Web crippling failure is often found to be critical in cold-formed steel profiled deckings during construction of composite slabs. Therefore, accurate prediction to the web crippling resistances of profiled deckings over internal supports under hogging moment is highly desirable. This paper presents an extensive experimental investigation into the structural behaviour of laterally restrained re-entrant profiled deckings under concentrated loads. A total of 104 web crippling tests on fully supported re-entrant profiled deckings with nominal yield strengths at 235 and 550 N/mm² are carried out to provide data for direct comparison with design resistances obtained from codified design rules. It should be noted that in the past, little attention has been paid to establish the lateral restraint condition of profiled deckings under concentrated loads in tests. Hence, local section distortion or ‘section spreading’ is often observed in tests but seldom dealt with rigorously during design development. In the present study, effective lateral restraints are provided to the test specimens in order to fully mobilize the web crippling resistances of the profiled deckings. It is found that the measured web crippling resistances are typically 20%–40% higher than those obtained from the codified design rules given in BS5950: Part 6, Eurocode 3: Part 1.3 and the North America Specification, depending on the steel grades and thicknesses, the load bearing lengths as well as the loading conditions.

In general, both BS5950 and Eurocode 3 give conservative web crippling resistances for re-entrant profiled deckings with both low and high strength steel under internal and end loading conditions. Moreover, the corresponding resistance factors determined according to a codified reliability analysis are considerably larger than the required values. Thus, the design rules are reliable and conservative, although they tend to be very conservative for profiled deckings under end loading condition. However, an examination on the design rules given in the NAS shows that only some of them are applicable to predict the web crippling resistances of low and high strength steel re-entrant profiled steel deckings. The design rule for IOF condition always gives both conservative and reliable resistances for both low and high strength steel profiled deckings, compared to the measured values. The design rule for EOF condition is also found to be both conservative and reliable for low strength steel profiled deckings only, but not for high strength steel profiled deckings. The design rules for ITF and ETF conditions are not applicable for both low and high strength steel profiled deckings according to the reliability analyses.

It is demonstrated that a set of new design rules specifically for re-entrant profiled deckings is needed for both improved efficiency and reliability. Moreover, the comprehensive set of test data is readily adopted to calibrate both finite element models and design expressions in subsequent studies.     

爆炸荷载作用下外贴FRP加固钢筋混凝土双向板试验研究

通过集团装药隔土爆炸荷载作用下4块外贴FRP条带加固钢筋混凝土双向板和1块普通板的对比试验,考察了裂缝的产生、开展过程及分布形状,分析了FRP加固板的荷载、位移、加速度、钢筋和混凝土以及FRP应变动力响应时程,研究了FRP加固板的抗爆破坏特征。研究结果表明：外贴FRP条带加固能有效延缓混凝土的开裂,限制裂缝的开展,改善钢筋混凝土板的抗爆性能;外贴FRP条带加固后,RC双向板的跨中位移响应、混凝土和钢筋应变响应明显降低,结构的抗爆炸冲击波能力得到明显提高;外贴FRP条带加固双向板在爆炸冲击荷载作用下的破坏形态有受弯破坏和弯曲屈服后的剪切破坏,外贴FRP条带在极限状态时发生了剥离及断裂破坏。图12表6参10     

利用砂浆填充FRP管对受压钢构件进行加固

介绍提高受压钢构件抗弯性能的加固方法,砂浆填充FRP管套在钢构件外侧,管端采用FRP织物包裹。对18个双向轴对称截面试件进行三轴压缩试验,得到试件的荷载-应变曲线和失效模式,证实其承载能力和延性得到了提高。对试件钢骨截面、长细比及端部包裹FRP织物层的影响进行了研究。结果表明,加固后,失效模式从由于整体屈曲引起的钢构件中部屈服转变为钢构件端部的局部损伤;因此,试件的承载能力提高了44%～215%,延性增加高达877%。细分模型用于加固构件的计算,由此计算出的承载能力与试验结果相符。     

Debonding of FRP in bending: Simplified model and experimental validation

Reinforced concrete members strengthened in bending by bonding of surface-mounted fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) may present several failure modes: failure of material (reinforcing steel, concrete and composite material) or failure of the interface between concrete-adhesive or adhesive-FRP. Nevertheless, experience gained from testing confirms that in most cases delamination prevails over the other possible rupture modes. Delamination in FRP strengthened sections is difficult to model because it involves multiple parameters such as FRP stiffness, adhesive material properties, presence of cracks in concrete, among others. A simplified model to predict strain of FRP at failure is presented in this paper. The experimental validation is presented as well. With this purpose carbon FRP and aramid strengthened specimens and large scale bridge models are considered. The types of bridge models tested include externally-prestressed segmental box-girder and monolithic RC continuous girders.Based on the results of the proposed model, an equation for the prediction of the ultimate force per unit width in the FRP to prevent FRP debonding is proposed. The equation has been experimentally checked with beams of small and large size, representative of real structures. In comparison to other available models, the equation is very simple to apply.     

Strengthening of RC beams in shear using GFRP inclined strips – An experimental study

Though there have been a number of studies on shear strengthening of RC beams using externally bonded fiber reinforced polymer sheets, the behaviour of FRP strengthened beams in shear is not fully understood. This is partly due to various reinforcement configurations of sheets that can be used for shear strengthening and partly due to different failure modes a strengthened beam undergoes at ultimate state. Furthermore, the experimental data bank for shear strengthening of concrete beams using FRP remains relatively sparse due to which the design algorithms for computing the shear contribution of FRP are not yet clear. The objective of this study is to clarify the role of glass fiber reinforced polymer inclined strips epoxy bonded to the beam web for shear strengthening of reinforced concrete beams. Included in the study are effectiveness in terms of width and spacing of inclined GFRP strips, spacing of internal steel stirrups, and longitudinal steel rebar section on shear capacity of the RC beam. The study also aims to understand the shear contribution of concrete, shear strength due to steel bars and steel stirrups and the additional shear capacity due to glass fiber reinforced polymer strips in a RC beam. And also to study the failure modes, shear strengthening effect on ultimate force and load deflection behaviour of RC beams bonded externally with GFRP inclined strips on the shear region of the beam.