A comparison of SPOT and Landsat-TM data for use in conducting inventories of forest resources

Abstract

SPOT multispectral (XS) and Landsat Thematic Mapper (TM) digital data were studied in an attempt to evaluate the use of this data in detailed assessments of forest conditions. Forest type, basal area, and age class information were collected from 256 sample sites within an intensively managed 80000acre experimental forest in North Carolina, U.S.A. A comparison of the SPOT and TM data with the sample site information showed that XS3, the near-infrared waveband, and TM bands 2, 3, 4, 5, and 7 were significantly correlated with basal area. Age class was not found to be significantly correlated with any of the three SPOT XS wavebands. TM bands 2, 3, 4, 5, and 7 were, however, shown to be significantly correlated with age class. Although significant, the correlation coefficients between the TM or SPOT waveband data and basal area or age class were low (<0.65).

Six forest cover types, and an additional water category, were selected as the basis of a land cover classification system for use with the TM and SPOT data. Verification of the classification of the seven cover types using the SPOT XS waveband data resulted in an estimated accuracy of 74.4 per cent. Classification accuracy was slightly reduced (70.8 per cent) when the TM wavebands corresponding to the SPOT XS bands were used as inputs to the classifier. When each of the six visible and reflective infrared TM wavebands were included in the classification process overall accuracy increased to 885 per cent.     

Multi-temporal and multi-source cartography of the glacial cover of Nevado Coropuna (Arequipa,Peru) between 1955 and 2003

This study reports on the glacial cover evolution of the Nevado Coropuna between 1955 and 2003, based on Peruvian topographic maps and satellite images taken from the Landsat 2 and 5 multispectral scanner (MSS), Landsat 5 Thematic Mapper (TM) and Landsat 7 (ETM+). The normalized difference snow index has been applied to these images to estimate the glacierized area of Coropuna. The satellite-based results show that the glacier area was 105 ± 16 km² in 1975 (Landsat 2 MSS), which then reduced to 96 ± 15 km² in 1985 (Landsat 5 MSS), 64 ± 8 km² in 1996 (Landsat 5 TM) and 56 ± 6 km² in 2003 (Landsat 5 TM). Altogether, between 1955 and 2003, Coropuna lost 66 km² of its glacial cover, which represents a mean retreat of 1.4 km² year^?1, that is, a loss of 54% in 48 years (11% loss per decade). The maximum rate of retreat occurred during the 1980s and 1990s, a phenomenon probably linked with the pluviometric deficit of El Niño events of 1983 and 1992.     

Remote sensing of savanna vegetation changes in Eastern Zambia 1972-1989

The use of the historical Landsat Multi-Spectral Scanner (MSS) archive to monitor changes in savanna vegetation between 1972 and 1989 in the South Luangwa National Park region, Eastern Zambia, was investigated. Land-cover types in the region were mapped and major changes in land cover from 1972 to 1989 were detected from MSS data. Woody canopy cover, which provides a quantitative measure of woodland structure, was estimated for woodland vegetation from MSS data using a linear relationship between woody canopy cover and red reflectance. The canopy cover changes estimated from MSS data agreed with those measured from multitemporal aerial photographs (r=0.94). Woody canopy cover changed significantly in the region from 1972 to 1989 and revealed strong spatial patterns of deforestation in Colophospermum mopane woodland on alluvial soils and vegetation regrowth of valley miombo vegetation and riverine woodland. This information on the spatial patterns of canopy cover change from 1972 to 1989 suggests certain criteria that any causative process must satisfy, and it provides a baseline for the National Park and Wildlife Services to manage the natural resources in the region. The canopy cover estimated from MSS data also provides an important input to biophysical and climatic process models for estimating the impact of vegetation structure on vegetation and climate processes.     

Landsat-comparable land cover maps using ASTER and SPOT images: a case study for large-area mapping programmes

The long-term record of global Landsat data is an important resource for studying Earth's system. Given the identified gaps in Landsat data and the undetermined future status of Landsat data availability, alternatives to Landsat imagery need to be tested in an operational environment. In this study, forest land cover and crown closure maps generated from Advanced Spaceborne Thermal Emission and Reflection Radiometer (ASTER) and System Pour 1'Observation de la Terre (SPOT) data were compared to Landsat-based map products currently in use by the grizzly bear habitat-mapping program. Overall accuracies greater than 85% were obtained for both ASTER- and SPOT-based land cover maps. The ASTER and SPOT classification accuracies were higher than that achieved by Landsat. Crown closure maps derived from ASTER and SPOT data show a small increase in accuracy when compared to the Landsat products. Overall, these results demonstrate that ASTER and SPOT could provide alternative data sources for producing maps in the event of a gap in the Landsat data.     

Historical tropical successional forest cover mapped with Landsat MSS imagery

Maps of tropical successional forest cover of the 1970s and 1980s are needed for long-term modelling of tropical forest-cover change, carbon flux and habitat change. Landsat Multispectral Scanner System (MSS) imagery may provide a basis for such maps, but its capability in this respect is poorly unexplored if not discounted. This article examines how reliably single-date MSS imagery may distinguish tropical successional forest. Statistical and graphical analyses of 2043 MSS pixels of successional forest cover, pasture and mature forest cover of Central Panama indicate that successional forest may be accurately mapped, with a maximum-likelihood classification accuracy of 86–90%. Detectable successional cover is unlikely to be older than 10 years approximately. These findings indicate that MSS imagery may provide a new baseline for historical mapping and long-term modelling of tropical forest-cover change that, unlike that of Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) imagery used for this purpose, is amenable to fine-scale spatial analysis and reliable accuracy assessment.     

Land cover characterization and mapping of continental Southeast Asia using multi-resolution satellite sensor data

Land use/land cover change, particularly that of tropical deforestation and forest degradation, has been occurring at an unprecedented rate and scale in Southeast Asia. The rapid rate of economic development, demographics and poverty are believed to be the underlying forces responsible for the change. Accurate and up-to-date information to support the above statement is, however, not available. The available data, if any, are outdated and are not comparable for various technical reasons. Time series analysis of land cover change and the identification of the driving forces responsible for these changes are needed for the sustainable management of natural resources and also for projecting future land cover trajectories. We analysed the multi-temporal and multi-seasonal NOAA Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) satellite data of 1985/86 and 1992 to (1) prepare historical land cover maps and (2) to identify areas undergoing major land cover transformations (called ‘hot spots’). The identified ‘hot spot’ areas were investigated in detail using high-resolution satellite sensor data such as Landsat and SPOT supplemented by intensive field surveys. Shifting cultivation, intensification of agricultural activities and change of cropping patterns, and conversion of forest to agricultural land were found to be the principal reasons for land use/land cover change in the Oudomxay province of Lao PDR, the Mekong Delta of Vietnam and the Loei province of Thailand, respectively. Moreover, typical land use/land cover change patterns of the ‘hot spot’ areas were also examined. In addition, we developed an operational methodology for land use/land cover change analysis at the national level with the help of national remote sensing institutions.     

Land use/land cover changes in the coastal zone of Ban Don Bay,Thailand using Landsat 5 TM data

Land use/land cover of the Earth is changing dramatically because of human activities and natural disasters. Information about changes is useful for updating land use/land cover maps for planning and management of natural resources. Several methods for land use/land cover change detection using time series Landsat imagery data were employed and discussed. Landsat 5 TM colour composites of 1990, 1993, 1996 and 1999 were employed for locating training samples for supervised classification in the coastal areas of Ban Don Bay, Surat Thani, Thailand. This study illustrated an increasing trend of shrimp farms, forest/mangrove and urban areas with a decreasing trend of agricultural and wasteland areas. Land use changes from one category to others have been clearly represented by the NDVI composite images, which were found suitable for delineating the development of shrimp farms and land use changes in Ban Don Bay.     

The utility of multi-sensor data for mapping eroded lands

The availability of remote sensing data with improved spatial, spectral and radiometric resolution is now available to fully exploit their potential for a specific application subject to the relative merits and the limitations of each sensor's data. Presented here is a case study where Landsat MSS and TM; and SPOT MLA data for part of the Bijapur district, southern India, which were acquired on the same day, have been evaluated for mapping eroded lands. The approach involves the geometric registration of all three data to a common map grid using tie points and third order polynomial transform; and resampling the MSS and TM data to a 20m by 20 m pixel dimension and radiometric normalization. Thematic maps showing eroded lands were generated on a micro-VAXbased DIPIX system using a maximum likelihood classifier. Accuracy estimates were made for the thematic maps following stratified unaligned random sampling technique, and subsequently, computing overall accuracy and Kappa coefficient. Spectral separability and classification accuracy was maximum from SPOT-MLA data followed by a combination of Landsat MSS band 1, SPOT-MLA band 2 and Landsat TM band 4; Landsat TM, a combination of Landsat MSS, TM and SPOT MLA; and Landsat MSS data.     

Historical and future land-cover changes in the Upper Ganges basin of India

The green revolution represents one of the greatest environmental changes in India over the last century. The Upper Ganges (UG) basin is experiencing rapid rates of change of land cover and irrigation practices. In this study, we investigated the historical rate of change and created future scenario projections by means of 30 m-resolution multi-temporal Landsat 5 Thematic Mapper and Landsat 7 Enhanced Thematic Mapper Plus data of the UG basin. Post-classification change analysis methods were applied to Landsat images in order to detect and quantify land-cover changes in the UG basin. Subsequently, Markov chain analysis was applied to project future scenarios of land-cover change. Fifteen different scenarios were generated based on historic land-cover change. These scenarios diverged in terms of future projections, highlighting the dynamic nature of the changes. This study has shown that between the years 1984 and 2010 the main land-cover change trends are conversion from shrubs to forest (+4.7%), urbanization (+5.8%), agricultural expansion (+1.3%), and loss of barren land (–9.5%). The land-cover change patterns in the UG basin were mapped and quantified, showing the capability of Landsat data in providing accurate land-cover maps. These results, in combination with those derived from the Markov model, provide the necessary evidence base to support regional land-use planning and develop future-proof water resource management strategies.     

Spatial pattern analysis for monitoring protected areas

The management of diverse biota within protected areas is affected by both land cover change within a protected area and habitat loss and fragmentation in the surrounding landscape. Satellite images provide a synoptic view of land cover patterns, but the use of such imagery requires careful consideration of sensor type, resolution, extent, and the metrics used to quantify ecologically significant change. We examined these factors for landscape monitoring applications in four small National Parks near Washington, DC: Antietam National Battlefield, Catoctin Mountain Park, Prince William Forest Park and Rock Creek Park. Using 4 m Ikonos, 10 m SPOT, 15 m pan-sharpened Landsat ETM+ and 30 m Landsat ETM+ imagery, the parks and surrounding areas were mapped to National Land Cover system classes. For each park, we examined four methods for defining map extent, including park administrative boundaries, two variable buffer widths, and watershed boundaries, and then analyzed patterns of forest habitat for the maps using a graph theoretic approach (critical dispersal threshold distance) and common landscape metrics (number of patches, percent forest, forest edge density, and forest area-weighted mean patch size). As expected, landscape metrics for maps derived at differing resolutions varied significantly, but map extent often yielded even larger differences. We found that for most applications, coarser scale data (e.g., 30 m Landsat) are adequate for characterizing landscape pattern, although ultimately data from multiple sensors may be appropriate or necessary based on different objectives of landscape monitoring (e.g., mapping single trees vs. forest stands) and the scale at which a resource of interest interacts with the larger landscape (e.g., birds vs. herptiles). Our results provide a strong caution regarding the practical issues associated with combining data sources from multiple satellite sensors for monitoring applications.     

Subpixel forest cover in central Africa from multisensor, multitemporal data

Seven Landsat Multispectral Scanner (MSS) scenes in central Africa were coregistered with 8 km resolution data from the 1987 AVHRR Pathfinder Land data set. Percent forest cover in each 8 km grid cell was derived from the classified MSS scenes. Linear relationships between percent forest cover and 30 multitemporal metrics derived from all AVHRR optical and thermal channels were determined. Correlations were strongest for the mean annual normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) and mean annual brightness temperature (AVHRR Channel 3) and weakest for those metrics, besides NDVI, based on near-infrared reflectances (AVHRR Channel 2). The relationships were used to estimate percent forest cover in various locations in the study area using multiple linear regression and regression trees. Overall, the multiple linear regression provided more accurate results. Predicted percent forest cover estimates were within 20% of the “actual” percent forest cover (derived from the MSS data) for approximately 90% of the grid cells. The RMS error for the prediction was 12% forest cover. RMS errors above 18% forest cover were obtained when using AVHRR data from a single month to derive predictive relationships. The results demonstrate that multitemporal data reflecting vegetation phenology can be used to estimate subpixel forest cover at coarse spatial resolutions.     

基于遥感的植被覆盖变化分区研究——以黄土高原马莲河流域为例

为了研究黄土高原1977~2010年近33 a的植被覆盖变化过程,以黄土高原典型植被区马莲河流域为例,将其划分为董志塬农业区、子午岭林业区和北部半农半牧区3个生态功能区进行研究。利用1977、1987、2000和2010年共4期陆地卫星影像,采用监督分类和非监督分类相结合的方法获得植被分类结果。利用转移矩阵分析植被覆盖的变化过程,并计算植被覆盖年度变化率。结果表明:1977~1987年董志塬农业区的植被恢复程度大于子午岭林业区,而北部半农半牧区除草原大面积恢复,其他植被均退化;1987~2000年是植被覆盖变化的一个转折点,各分区植被均以退化为主,董志塬农业区最为典型;2000~2010年各分区均以植被恢复为主,董志塬农业区和北部半农半牧区植被恢复相对较快。整个马莲河流域植被覆盖呈现出退化-恶化-恢复的变化趋势。     

Updating land cover classification using a rule‐based decision system

This paper proposes a land cover classification methodology in agricultural contexts that provides satisfactory results with a single satellite image per year acquired during the growing period. Our approach incorporates ancillary data such as cropping history (inter‐annual crop rotations), context (altitude, soil type) and structure (parcels size and shape) to compensate for the lack of radiometric data resulting from the use of a single image. The originality of the proposed method resides in the three successive steps used: S1: per‐pixel classification of a single SPOT XS image with a restricted number of land cover classes (RL) chosen to ensure good accuracy; S2: conversion of RLs into a per‐parcel classification system using ancillary parcel boundaries; and S3: parcel allocation using exhaustive land cover classes (EL) and its refinement through the application of decision rules. The method was tested on a 120?km² area (Sousson river basin, Gers, France) where exhaustive knowledge of land cover for two successive years allowed complete validation of our method. It allocated 87% of the parcels with a 75% accuracy rate according to the exhaustive list (EL). This is a satisfactory result obtained with one SPOT XS image in a small agricultural parcel context.     

Remote sensing techniques for mangrove mapping

Different approaches to the classification of remotely sensed data of mangroves are reviewed, and five different methodologies identified. Landsat TM, SPOT XS and CASI data of mangroves from the Turks and Caicos Islands, were classified using each method. All classifications of SPOT XS data failed to discriminate satisfactorily between mangrove and non-mangrove vegetation. Classification accuracy of CASI data was higher than Landsat TM for all methods, and more mangrove classes could be discriminated. Merging Landsat TM and SPOT XP data improved visual interpretation of images, but did not enhance discrimination of different mangrove categories. The most accurate combination of sensor and image processing method for mapping the mangroves of the eastern Caribbean islands is identified.     

Spectral separability of tropical forest cover classes

Abstract

Spectral separability analysis of various tropical forest cover classes as recorded on Landsat MSS data were carried out for two test areas of northeastern India. The results indicated that two density classes of forests and two edaphic forest types formed spectrally separable classes but some of the important physiognomic units could not be reliably separated using Landsat MSS data in a spectrally complex tropical forest environment.     

An analysis of deforestation patterns in the extractive reserves of Acre,Amazonia from satellite imagery: A landscape ecological approach

Classified multi-temporal Landsat satellite imagery for one of the extractive reserves in Acre, Amazonia was classified into forest and cleared forest patches. Three indices of landscape structure were applied to the classified satellite imagery to characterize the impact of social and economic processes on the development of the forest landscape. The Lacunarity Index was used to measure landscape homogeneity, the Korcak Patchiness Index to measure the distribution of patches according to their size and the Area-Perimeter Fractal Exponent to measure change in the shape of cleared forest patches. The changing shape, size and spatial frequency of patches in the forest landscape showed that major changes in the forest landscape occurred between 1975-1989. Pre-1975 the region was mainly exploited by family groups who formed an extractive economy based on natural resources. By 1985 the economy had changed, with larger more regular patches indicating a transformed economy based on a settled and well developed farming economy. The techniques are important for measuring the human impact on fragile tropical ecosystems.     

Capability of SPOT XS data in producing detailed land cover maps at the urban-rural periphery

The capability of SPOT multi-spectral (XS) data in generating detailed land cover maps at the urban-rural fringe is critically evaluated using two images, one recorded in summer and another in winter. The factors affecting the mapping accuracy are also identified and assessed in this study. Covering an area of 90km2 in South Auckland, New Zealand, two subscenes of SPOT XS images were used to map 10 categories of land cover at level II of the Anderson scheme with an overall accuracy of 76.2 and 81.4 per cent from the winter and summer data, respectively. The higher accuracy achieved using the summer image is due to the higher distinctiveness of vegetative covers in summer. The main limiting factors are identified as the high heterogeneity of land-use patterns commonly found at the urban periphery, poor representativeness of training samples caused by the presence of the same land cover element across a diverse range of land cover classes, and varying conditions of vegetative covers.     

Using remote sensing to estimate the change of carbon storage: A case study in the estuary of Yellow River delta

Land cover change can exert a crucial effect on the terrestrial carbon cycle. To estimate changes in the carbon pools and carbon fluxes to the atmosphere, Landsat Thematic Mapper (TM) data of 1992 and 1996 were used to calculate the extent of different land cover types and their changes in the estuary area of the Yellow River delta. Image processing and the unsupervised classification allowed accurate land cover maps for 1992 and 1996 to be generated, by which the changes in the carbon pools were detected. Estimation of the carbon pools and the carbon fluxes to the atmosphere was carried out employing the results of Landsat image analysis and the published data on carbon stocks in vegetation and soil. By calculating the area changed between different types of vegetation and their different carbon stocks, the quantity of the terrestrial carbon cycle in the estuary area of the Yellow River delta was acquired. The results shows that the vegetation carbon storage was 11.43 2 10 11 g and soil carbon pool 7.24 2 10 12 g in 1992, and the vegetation carbon pool increased by 3.77 2 10 11 g during the 4 years from 1992 to 1996.     

Vegetation mapping of a tropical freshwater swamp in the Northern Territory,Australia: A comparison of aerial photography,Landsat TM and SPOT satellite imagery

The tropical wetland environments of northern Australia have ecological, social, cultural and economic values. Additionally, these areas are relatively pristine compared to the many other wetland environments in Australia, and around the world, that have been extensively altered by humans. However, as the remote northern coastline of Australia becomes more populated, environmental problems are beginning to emerge that highlight the need to manage the tropical wetland environments. Lack of information is currently considered to be a major factor restricting the effective management of many ecosystems and for the expansive wetlands of the Northern Territory, this is especially the case, as these areas are generally remote and inaccessible. Remote sensing is therefore an attractive technique for obtaining relevant information on variables such as land cover and vegetation status. In the current study, Landsat TM, SPOT (XS and PAN) and large-scale, true-colour aerial photography were evaluated for mapping the vegetation of a tropical freshwater swamp in Australia's Top End. Extensive ground truth data were obtained, using a helicopter survey method. Fourteen cover types were delineated from 1:15 000 air photos (enlarged to 1:5000 in an image processing system) using manual interpretation techniques, with 89% accuracy. This level of detail could not be extracted from any of the satellite image data sets, with only three broad land-cover types identified with accuracy above 80%. The Landsat TM and SPOT XS data provided similar results although superior accuracy was obtained from Landsat, where the additional spectral information appeared to compensate in part for the coarser spatial resolution. Two different classification algorithms produced similar results.     

An assessment of SPOT capability for cartographic applications in Indonesia

Abstract

An assessment of the operational cartographic capability of SPOT in Indonesia is presented from the points of view of (1) the size of the smallest distinguishable land cover units through computation of the percentages of pure pixels per unit and dominant unit per pixel and (2) planimetric accuracy. Generally speaking, units larger than 0.16 and 0.05ha can be distinguished with SPOT multispectral (XS) and panchromatic (P) data respectively. For full images, basic manipulations (bilinear transformation or shift, enlargement and rotation) of level-IB SPOT digital data and photographs provide standard deviation accuracies towards local Transverse Mercator (LTM) maps of 2 and 3 pixels, respectively. Due to the poor reliability of most LTM maps, SPOT should undoubtedly be used as a major cartographic data source in Indonesia.