Proton binding to humic acids from organic amendments and amended soils by the NICA-Donnan model

The acid-base properties of humic acids (HAs) are known to significantly affect the acid-base buffering capacity of soils, thus having a marked influence on the speciation of cations in the soil solid and liquid phases. Detailed information on the proton binding behavior of humic-like acids (HALs) from organic amendments and humic acids (HAs) from amended soils is, therefore, of intrinsic interest for the evaluation of the agronomic efficacy and environmental impact of soil amendment. In this work, the acid-base properties of HLAs isolated from sewage sludge (SS) and municipal solid waste compost (MSWC), and HAs isolated from soils amended with either SS or MSWC and the corresponding nonamended control soils were investigated by potentiometric titrations at various ionic strengths (0.01, 0.05, 0.1, and 0.3 M) over the pH range from 3.5 to 10.5. The nonideal competitive adsorption (NICA)-Donnan model that describes proton binding by two classes of binding sites with low and high proton affinity, i.e., carboxylic- and phenolic-type groups, was fit to titration data, and a set of fitting parameters was obtained for each HLA and HA sample. The NICA-Donnan model successfully described the shapes of the titration curves, and highlighted substantial differences in site density and proton-binding affinity between the HLAs and HAs examined. With respect to the nonamended control soil HAs, SS-HLA and MSWC-HLA were characterized by smaller carboxylic-type and phenolic-type group contents, larger affinities for proton binding by the carboxylic-type groups, and smaller affinities for proton binding by the phenolic-type groups. Amendment with SS and MSWC determined a number of modifications in soil HAs, including decrease of acidic functional group contents, slight increase of proton affinity of carboxylic-type groups, and slight decrease of the affinities for proton binding by phenolic-type groups. These effects were more evident in the HA fraction from the SS-amended soil than in the HA fraction from the MSWC-amended soil. Thus, both organic amendments examined can be a considered as a valuable source of organic matter for soil. However, MSWC appears to be an amendment of greater quality producing a smaller impact than SS on proton-binding behavior of soil HA.     

Binding of atrazine to humic substances from soil,peat and coal related to their structure

Partition coefficients for the binding affinities of atrazine to 16 different humic materials were determined by the ultrafiltration HPLC technique. Sources included humic acids (HA), fulvic acids (FA), and combined humic and fulvic fractions (HF) from soil, peat, and coal humic acid. Each of the humic materials was characterized by elemental composition, molecular weight, and composition of main structural fragments determined by 13C solution-state NMR. The magnitude of K(OC) values varied from 87 to 575 L/kg of C, demonstrating relatively low binding affinity of humic substances (HS) for atrazine. On the basis of the measured K(OC) values, the humic materials can be arranged in the following order: coal HA approximately = gray wooded soil HA > chernozemic soil HA and HF > sod-podzolic soil HA approximately = peat HF > sod-podzolic soil FA > peat dissolved organic matter. The magnitude of the K(OC) values correlated strongly with the percentage of aromatic carbon in HS samples (r = 0.91). The hydrophobic binding was hypothesized as the key interaction underlying the binding of atrazine to HS.     

Immobilizing humic acid in a sol-gel matrix: a new tool to study humic-contaminants sorption interactions

Humic substances originated from aquatic, soil, or sediment environments are mixtures of humic compounds with various characteristics. Sorption interactions with isolated, well defined humic fractions can be studied either in an aqueous phase ("dissolved humic substances"), or in a solid-phase, by coating mineral particles with the humic materials, or simply by working with humic acid particles (powder) at low pH to minimize dissolution. Each attitude, by definition, can be studied by different experimental techniques and has a different meaning for understanding natural environmental processes. In this study, a new tool for studying sorption interactions is presented. Sol-gel was used as an inert matrix to immobilize (entrap) various humic acids (HAs), and then used to study the interactions of several polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) with the entrapped HA. Linear and nonlinear sorption coefficients were highly correlated with contaminant hydrophobicity. Sorption of pyrene to immobilized HA was in the order of soil HA > Aldrich HA approximately = peat HA. It was concluded that the entrapped HAs retained their original properties in the gel matrix and were accessible to the external contaminant through the pore network. Additionally, binding coefficients of pyreneto dissolved humic substances and to dissolved organic matter (DOM) were determined from the reduction in pyrene sorption to immobilized HA in the presence of dissolved humic material or DOM in solution. Binding coefficients of pyrene were in the order of the following: dissolved Aldrich HA > dissolved peat fulvic acid (FA) > DOM derived from mature compost > DOM derived from fresh compost.     

Quantitative evaluation of noncovalent interactions between glyphosate and dissolved humic substances by NMR spectroscopy

Interactions of glyphosate (N-phosphonomethylglycine) herbicide (GLY) with soluble fulvic acids (FAs) and humic acids (HAs) at pH 5.2 and 7 were studied by (1)H and (31)P NMR spectroscopy. Increasing concentrations of soluble humic matter determined broadening and chemical shift drifts of proton and phosphorus GLY signals, thereby indicating the occurrence of weak interactions between GLY and humic superstructures. Binding was larger for FAs and pH 5.2 than for HAs and pH 7, thus suggesting formation of hydrogen bonds between GLY carboxyl and phosphonate groups and protonated oxygen functions in humic matter. Changes in relaxation and correlation times of (1)H and (31)P signals and saturation transfer difference NMR experiments confirmed the noncovalent nature of GLY-humic interactions. Diffusion-ordered NMR spectra allowed calculation of the glyphosate fraction bound to humic superstructures and association constants (K(a)) and Gibbs free energies of transfer for GLY-humic complex formation at both pH values. These values showed that noncovalent interactions occurred most effectively with FAs and at pH 5.2. Our findings indicated that glyphosate may spontaneously and significantly bind to soluble humic matter by noncovalent interactions at slightly acidic pH and, thus, potentially pollute natural water bodies by moving through soil profiles in complexes with dissolved humus.     

Transport of humic and fulvic acids in relation to metal mobility in a copper-contaminated acid sandy soil

The transport of inorganic and organic pollutants in water and soil can be strongly influenced by the mobility of natural dissolved organic matter (DOM). In this paper, the transport of a humic acid (HA) and a fulvic acid (FA) in a copper-contaminated acid sandy soil was studied. The data showed that the transport behavior of HA differed from that of FA. The breakthrough curves (BTCs) of HA were characterized by a rapid relatively sharp front followed by a plateau at a lower HA concentration than in the influent solution. The increase of the Ca concentration decreased the HA concentration further. Compared to HA, the BTCs of FA were retarded and showed an extended tailing, approaching complete breakthrough. The increase of the Ca concentration decreased the FA concentration only temporarily. On the basis of our model calculation, the characterization of HA transport could be explained by the coagulation of HA largely upon the binding of Al. The increase of the Ca concentration resulted in further coagulation of HA because of the increased Ca adsorption, which occurred mainly in the Donnan phase. For FA, the adsorption to the soil matrix was more likely the process that controls its solubility and mobility. The mobility of Al and Cu in the soil column was closely related to the solubility and transport of the DOM in soil solution. The concentration of Ca in the effluent was lower than in the influent because Ca was retained in the soil due to the retardation of HA and FA and due to the compensation of the other cations released from the soil to the solution.     

Phenanthrene sorption to sequentially extracted soil humic acids and humins

Humic substances strongly influence the environmental fate of hydrophobic organic chemicals in soils and sediments. In this study, the sorption of phenanthrene by humic acids (HAs) and humins was examined. HAs were obtained from progressively extracting a soil, eight times with 0.1 M Na4P207 and two times with 0.1 M NaOH solution, and then the residue was separated into two humin fractions by their organic carbon contents. The chemical and structural heterogeneity of the HAs and humins were characterized by elemental analysis, ultraviolet-visible spectroscopy, diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy, and solid-state 13C NMR. There were significant chemical and structural differences among the HA fractions and humins; the later extracted HAs had relatively high aliphatic carbons content. All sorption data were fitted to a Freundlich equation, S = K(F)C(N), where S and C are the sorbed and solution-phase concentrations, respectively, and K(F) and N are constants. All of the phenanthrene sorptions were nonlinear, and the nonlinearity decreased with further extractions from 0.90 (first extracted HA) to 0.96 (ninth HA) and was the lowest (0.88) for the higher organic carbon content humin. Phenanthrene sorption coefficient by HAs significantly increased with progressive extractions, being the highest for the humins. For HAs isotherms, a positive trend was observed between the sorption coefficient and the aliphaticity, but a negative relation was shown between the nonlinearity and the aliphaticity and between the sorption capacity and polarity of HAs. Phenanthrene sorption was greatly affected by chemical structure and composition of humic substances, even from a same soil. In addition, polarity of humic substances seems to mainly regulate the magnitude of phenanthrene sorption rather than structure.     

15N NMR investigation of the reduction and binding of TNT in an aerobic bench scale reactor simulating windrow composting

T15NT was added to a soil of low organic carbon content and composted for 20 days in an aerobic bench scale reactor. The finished whole compost and fulvic acid, humic acid, humin, and lignocellulose fractions extracted from the compost were analyzed by solid-state CP/MAS and DP/MAS 15N NMR. 15N NMR spectra provided direct spectroscopic evidence for reduction of TNT followed by covalent binding of the reduced metabolites to organic matter of the composted soil, with the majority of metabolite found in the lignocellulose fraction, by mass also the major fraction of the compost. In general, the types of bonds formed between soil organic matter and reduced TNT amines in controlled laboratory reactions were observed in the spectra of the whole compost and fractions, confirming that during composting TNT is reduced to amines that form covalent bonds with organic matter through aminohydroquinone, aminoquinone, heterocyclic, and imine linkages, among others. Concentrations of imine nitrogens in the compost spectra suggest that covalent binding by the diamines 2,4DANT and 2,6DANT is a significant process in the transformation of TNT into bound residues. Liquid-phase 15N NMR spectra of the fulvic acid and humin fractions provided possible evidence for involvement of phenoloxidase enzymes in covalent bond formation.     

Elucidating differences in the sorption properties of 10 humic and fulvic acids for polar and nonpolar organic chemicals

In this work we present a dataset of more than 1000 natural organic matter (NOM)/air partition coefficients covering polar and nonpolar organic compounds measured in 10 different humic and fulvic acids (HAs/FAs) from terrestrial and aquatic origins. Differences of more than 1 order of magnitude in the sorption coefficients of a given compound measured in HAs and FAs from different origins were found. The terrestrial HAs exhibited substantially higher sorption coefficients compared to aquatic HAs and FAs. The difference between any two types of NOM is mainly reflected by a constant shift in the partition coefficients that applies to all compounds in the same way. This indicates that it is the number of available sorption sites per mass of sorbent rather than the types of intermolecular interactions between the sorbate and the sorbent that governs the major differences between the sorption properties of various types of NOM. The experimental partition coefficients measured in all HAs and FAs were successfully described by polyparameter linear free energy relationships (pp-LFERs) that explicitly account for van der Waals as well as H-donor/acceptor interactions between the sorbate and the sorbent. These pp-LFER equations provide for the first time a tool that allows including the variability of the sorption properties of NOM in environmental fate models.     

Adsorption of humic substances on goethite: comparison between humic acids and fulvic acids

The adsorption of humic acids (HA) to goethite (at pH 3-11) and the proton co-adsorption (at pH 4.0, 5.5, and 7.0) were measured, and the results were compared to those of fulvic acids (FA). Compared to FA, the adsorption of HA is stronger and more ionic strength dependent. The adsorption of both HA and FA decreases with increasing pH. The relative change of the adsorption with pH is bigger for HA than for FA at relatively low pH. At relatively high pH, it is the opposite. Protons are released at pH 4.0 and co-adsorbed at pH 5.5 and 7.0 upon the adsorption of both HA and FA. The observed pH dependency of HA and FA adsorption is in agreement with the proton co-adsorption data. Model calculations show that the adsorbed FA particles are on average located in the Stern layer, whereas the adsorbed HA particles protrude beyond the Stern layer. The closer location to the surface of the adsorbed FA leads to stronger electrostatic interactions between the FA particles and the surface, which explains the larger amount of protons released at low pH and co-adsorbed at high pH with each mass unit of FA adsorbed than that with HA adsorbed. The model also revealsthatfor FA a mean-field (smeared-out) approximation is reasonable, but for HA a patchwise approach is more appropriate at relatively low loading.     

On the acid-base properties of humic acid in soil

Humic acid was isolated from three contrasting organic-rich soils and acid-base titrations performed over a range of ionic strengths. Results obtained were unlike most humic acid data sets; they showed a greater ionic strength dependency at low pH than at high pH. Forward- and back-titrations with the base and acid revealed hysteresis, particularly at low pH. Previous authors attributed this type of hysteresis to humic acid aggregates-created during the isolation procedure-being redissolved during titration as the pH increased and regarded the results as artificial. However, forward- and back-titrations with organic-rich soils also demonstrated a similar hysteretic behavior. These observations indicate (i) that titrations of humic acid in aggregated form (as opposed to the more usual dissolved form) are more representative of the acid-base properties of humic acid in soil and (ii) that the ionic strength dependency of proton binding in humic acid is related to its degree of aggregation. Thus, the current use of models based on data from dissolved humic substances to predictthe acid-base properties of humic acid in soil under environmental conditions may be flawed and could substantially overestimate their acid buffering capacity.     

Key role of the low molecular size fraction of soil humic acids for fluorescence and photoinductive activity

The IHSS soil humic acid (HA) standard and two HAs from soils of very different origin (Chernozem and Ranker) were fractionated by tandem size-exclusion chromatography-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. From each HA, three fractions with different molecular sizes (MSs) and electrophoretic mobilities were obtained and investigated for their fluorescence properties and abilityto photoinduce the transformation of 2,4,6-trimethylphenol and herbicide fenuron. Regardless of the source of the HA, the two high MS fractions were found to be very weakly fluorescent. They photoinduced the degradations of fenuron and 2,4,6-trimethylphenol less efficiently than the bulk HA (10-50-fold and 1.4-5.3-fold, respectively). In contrast, the low MS fraction was proved to be fluorescent and to photoinduce the transformation of probes as least as efficiently than the bulk HA. These results show that (i) most of fluorophores and a great part of photoinductive chromophores are located in the low MS fractions of soil HAs and (ii) this distribution of photochemically active constituents may be characteristic across broad soil types.     

Reduction of disinfection byproduct formation by molecular reconfiguration of the fulvic constituents of natural background organic matter

Experiments were performed to assess the effects of treating the fulvic acid fractions of background natural organic matter (NOM) by catalyst-induced oxidative coupling reactions. Changes in the molecular characteristics of the fulvic acids and related disinfection byproduct formation potentials of these important NOM constituents were investigated. The coupling reactions were induced by addition of horseradish peroxidase (HRP) and hydrogen peroxide to aqueous solutions of the fulvic acids (FAs) in semicontinuous flow reactors. Subsequent removal of organic matter by ultrafiltration was found to be markedly enhanced for FA solutions subjected to oxidative coupling treatment. Uniform formation condition tests further indicated that the disinfection byproducts formed upon chlorination of FAs treated via induced oxidative coupling were reduced significantly on a unit carbon basis relative to those formed upon chlorination of their untreated counterparts. Spectroscopic examinations revealed thatthe FA molecules were effectively reconfigured in the oxidative coupling reactions. Substantial conversion of aromatic hydroxyl groups into ether-bonded moieties is evident, and a loss of primary amine groups, probably through conversion into secondary or tertiary amines, was also observed. These conversions apparently result in cross-linking of the natural FA moieties to form stable species of larger sizes, thus rendering them more readily removable by ultrafiltration and less reactive with chlorine. The results of the study may be interpreted as indicating that catalytically induced oxidative coupling reactions of the type conducted in this work can be combined with ultrafiltration to provide an effective scheme for removal of disinfection byproduct precursors.     

Sorption of peat humic acids to multi-walled carbon nanotubes

Sorption of humic acids (HAs) from a peat soil by multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) was examined in this work. Sorption rate of HAs to MWCNTs was dominantly controlled by their diffusion from liquid-MWCNT boundary to MWCNT surfaces. Size exclusion chromatography analysis did not detect preferential sorption of HA fractions to MWCNTs at equilibrium, whereas the components with lower molecular weight in some HA fractions (e.g., HA1) would more preferentially be sorbed to MWCNTs at the initial sorption stage. Equilibrium sorption intensity of HAs by MWCNTs was dependent on their surface area and a sum of meso- and macropore volume. The surface area and sum of meso- and macroporosity-normalized sorption coefficient (K(d)) values of a given HA by MWCNTs increased with increasing outer diameter of MWCNTs, because MWCNTs with larger outer diameter were more strongly dispersed by HAs thereby making more sorption sites exposed for HA sorption. Van der Waals interaction between the alkyl components rather than the aromatic ones of HAs with MWCNTs was likely the key driving force for their sorption. This study highlights the sorption rate-controlling step of HAs from a same source to MWCNTs and the major factors affecting their sorption intensity at equilibrium.     

Molecular and quantitative analysis of metal ion binding to humic acids from sewage sludge and sludge-amended soils by fluorescence spectroscopy

Humic acids (HAs) isolated from sewage sludge (SS) and control and SS-amended soils were characterized by fluorescence spectroscopy. The main feature of fluorescence spectra was a broad band with the maximum centered at excitation/emission wavelengths that were much shorter for SS-HA (340/438 nm) than for any soil HA (440/510 nm). Titration with Cu(II), Zn(II), Cd(II), and Pb(II) ions decreased fluorescence intensities of HAs. Titration data were fitted to a single-site fluorescence quenching model, and metal ion complexing capacities of each HA sample and stability constants of metal ion-HA complexes were calculated. The binding capacities of HAs and strengths of metal ion-HA complexes followed the order Pb(II) > Cu(II) > Cd(II) > Zn(II). With respect to the control soil HA, SS-HA, which showed the smallest contents of acidic functional groups and the lowest humification degree, was characterized by much smaller binding capacities and stability constants. The binding capacities and affinities of SS-amended soil HA were intermediate between those of native soil HA and SS-HA but closer to the former, thus suggesting a partial incorporation of HA fractions of SS into native soil HAs. These effects are expected to have a great impact on the behavior of metals in SS-amended soils.     

Roles of acetone-conditioning and lipid in sorption of organic contaminants

Sorption of phenanthrene and 1-naphthol by a peat soil (PS) and its humic acid fractions (HAs) and humin (HM) was examined. Both phenanthrene and 1-naphthol consistently had decreased isotherm nonlinearity in the order PS > HA1 (first fraction) > HA7 (seventh fraction), due to decreased heterogeneity of soil organic matter (SOM). High isotherm nonlinearity of HM was attributed to the condensed structure of SOM in it. Acetone-conditioning increased sorption affinity and isotherm nonlinearity of HAs and HM for phenanthrene, and the conditioning effect was more pronounced at low solute concentrations. However, sorption of 1-naphthol by PS, HAs, and HM was insignificantly affected by acetone-conditioning, suggesting that 1-naphthol could have disparate distribution of sorbed sites from phenanthrene due to their structure and hydrophobicity difference. Lipid removal further increased sorption of phenanthrene and 1-naphthol by acetone-conditioned PS, HAs, and HM, due to increased accessibility of high-energy sites in SOM. Nonlinearity of phenanthrene and 1-naphthol also increased after lipid removal from the acetone-conditioned sorbents. In 1-naphthol- and phenanthrene-lipid competitive sorption systems, lipid had strong competition with phenanthrene, whereas 1-naphthol exhibited cooperative sorption with lipid on lipid-free PS, HAs, and HM, again showing the different sorption characteristics between phenanthrene and 1-naphthol.     

Aggregation and disaggregation of humic supramolecular assemblies by NMR diffusion ordered spectroscopy (DOSY-NMR)

Diffusion ordered nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (DOSY-NMR) was applied to a number of fulvic (FA) and humic (HA) acids of different origin. Spectral separation achieved by DOSY based on diffusion coefficients (D), and correlated to molecular sizes by calibration standards, showed that carbohydrates had the largest molecular size in FA, whereas alkyl or aromatic components were the most slowly diffusing moieties in HA. At increasing concentrations, these components had invariably lower D values in DOSY spectra for all humic samples,thereby indicating an aggregation into apparently larger associations, whose increased hydrodynamic radius was confirmed by viscosity measurements. When humic solutions were broughtfrom alkaline to acidic pH (3.6), components diffusivity detected by DOSY increased significantly, suggesting a decrease of aggregation and molecular size. A general comparison of HA and FA molecular sizes was achieved by multivariate statistical analysis. While a larger extent of aggregation and disaggregation was observed for HA than for FA, no aggregation was detected, under similar conditions, for a true macropolymeric standard. Such difference in diffusion between a polymeric molecule and humic samples, is in line with the supramolecular nature of humic matter. The possible formation of humic micelles was also investigated by both changes of diffusivity in DOSY spectra and shift of 1H NMR signals. Except for HA of peat and soil origin, revealing a self-assembling in micelle-like structures at the 4 mg mL(-1) concentration, no other humic sample showed evidence of critical micelle concentration (cmc) up to 20 mg mL(-1). These results indicated that DOSY-NMR spectroscopy is a useful technique to evaluate components of different molecular size in natural humic superstructures.     

Adsorption of Insecticidal Cry1Ab Protein to Humic Substances. 2. Influence of Humic and Fulvic Acid Charge and Polarity Characteristics

Assessing the fate and potential risks of transgenic Cry proteins in soils requires understanding of Cry protein adsorption to soil particles. The companion paper provided evidence that patch-controlled electrostatic attraction (PCEA) and the hydrophobic effect contributed to Cry1Ab protein adsorption to an apolar humic acid (HA). Here, we further assess the relative importance of these contributions by comparing Cry1Ab adsorption to seven humic substances varying in polarity and charge, at different solution pH and ionic strength, I. Cry1Ab adsorption to relatively apolar HAs at I = 50 mM exhibited rapid initial rates, was extensive, and was only partially reversible at pH 5-8, whereas adsorption to more polar fulvic acids was weak and reversible or absent at pH >6. The decrease in adsorption with increasing HS polarity at all tested pH strongly supports a large contribution from the hydrophobic effect to adsorption, particularly at I = 50 mM when PCEA was effectively screened. Using insect bioassays, we further show that Cry1Ab adsorbed to a selected HA retained full insecticidal activity. Our results highlight the need to consider adsorption to soil organic matter in models that assess the fate of Cry proteins in soils.     

Biodegradability of fractions of dissolved organic carbon leached from decomposing leaf litter

Dissolved organic matter leached from decomposing organic matter is important in the leaching of nutrients from the root zone of ecosystems, eluviation of metals, and transport of hydrophobic pollutants. The objective of this study was to compare microbial mineralization rates in intact soil cores of various fractions of water-soluble dissolved organic matter. Uniformly 14C-labeled Populus fremontii leaf litter that had decomposed for 1 year was extracted in water and this extract was fractionated into phenolic, humic acid, fulvic acid, hydrophilic acid, and hydrophilic neutral fractions. Fulvic acid comprised 42.1% of C in dissolved organic carbon (DOC) extracted from the litter. These fractions were added to intact cores of soil or sand, and respired 14CO2 was collected. The percentage of labeled substrate C mineralized in soil at the end of 1 year was, in order from least to greatest, hydrophilic acid (30.5), fulvic acid (33.8), humic acid (39.0), whole, unfractionated DOC (43.5), unseparated hydrophilic acid and neutral (44.7), phenolic (63.3), glucose (66.4), and hydrophilic neutral (70.2). In acid-washed nutrient-amended sand that was inoculated with soil microbes, mineralization rates of fulvic acid and glucose were lower. The fractionation appeared to separate the DOC into components with widely different rates of mineralization. Results also supported the ideas that the dissolved humic substance and hydrophilic acid fractions are inherently difficult for microbes to mineralize, and this property can contribute to movement of refractory C in soil and into aquatic ecosystems.