Analysis of the acidic proteome with negative electron-transfer dissociation mass spectrometry

We describe the first implementation of negative electron-transfer dissociation (NETD) on a hybrid ion trap-orbitrap mass spectrometer and its application to high-throughput sequencing of peptide anions. NETD, coupled with high pH separations, negative electrospray ionization (ESI), and an NETD compatible version of OMSSA, is part of a complete workflow that includes the formation, interrogation, and sequencing of peptide anions. Together these interlocking pieces facilitated the identification of more than 2000 unique peptides from Saccharomyces cerevisiae representing the most comprehensive analysis of peptide anions by tandem mass spectrometry to date. The same S. cerevisiae samples were interrogated using traditional, positive modes of peptide LC-MS/MS analysis (e.g., acidic LC separations, positive ESI, and collision activated dissociation), and the resulting peptide identifications of the different workflows were compared. Due to a decreased flux of peptide anions and a tendency to produce lowly charged precursors, the NETD-based LC-MS/MS workflow was not as sensitive as the positive mode methods. However, the use of NETD readily permits access to underrepresented acidic portions of the proteome by identifying peptides that tend to have lower pI values. As such, NETD improves sequence coverage, filling out the acidic portions of proteins that are often overlooked by the other methods.     

Effects of peptide hydrophobicity and charge state on molecular ion yields in plasma desorption mass spectrometry

Plasma desorption mass spectra were obtained for a series of peptides, grouped in four mass ranges having approximately 9, 20, 30, and 40 amino acid residues. Within each group, the individual peptides differed in hydrophobicity, charge state, and retention time, as measured on a reversed-phase HPLC column. Comparison of the molecular ion intensities in the positive ion mass spectra of peptides from each group showed a strong dependence upon hydrophobicity and no correlation with charge state. Plasma desorption mass spectra of mixtures of all the peptides within each mass range generally resulted in the desorption of a single residue and suppression of the ion signal from other components. In most cases, this could be correlated with hydrophobicity, as calculated from the Bull and Breese index; however, a better correlation existed when the results were compared with reversed-phase retention times. In general the spectra of mixtures were not influenced by charge state (except in the absence of hydrophobic peptides), as the same component in each peptide mixture produced the most abundant ions in both positive and negative ion spectra.     

Separation and detection of phosphorylated and nonphosphorylated peptides in liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry using monolithic columns and acidic or alkaline mobile phases

Efficient chromatographic separation is a prerequisite for the sensitive analysis of complex peptide mixtures using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. This is especially true for the analysis of mixtures of unmodified and posttranslationally modified peptides, for example, phosphorylated peptides in the presence of their unmodified analogues. Applying monolithic capillary columns based on poly(styrene/divinylbenzene), the influence of acidic eluents based on trifluoroacetic and heptafluorobutyric acid as well as an alkaline eluent based on triethylamine-acetic acid (pH 9.2) on the separation of synthetic phosphopeptides was evaluated. Heptafluorobutyric acid offered the longest retention times and highest selectivities and, hence, the most effective separation. Application of the alkaline eluent in conjunction with detection in negative ion mode electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, on the other hand, allowed the detection of phosphorylated peptides with significantly lower limits of detection, as compared to acidic eluents in combination with detection in positive ion mode. Pairs of phosphorylated and nonphosphorylated synthetic peptides, ranging from 7- to 16-mers, as well as phosphorylated peptides form a tryptic protein digest could be separated both at acidic and alkaline pH. Utilizing a 60 x 0.20-mm-i.d. capillary column, the limit of detection in negative ion detection mode for a 4-fold phosphorylated peptide in a beta-casein digest was 10 fmol. Together with the capability for fast separation of protein digests, monolithic columns, thus, facilitate the effective and sensitive analysis of this important posttranslational modification.     

Alkylating tryptic peptides to enhance electrospray ionization mass spectrometry analysis

A major limitation of mass spectrometry-based proteomics is inefficient and differential ionization during electrospray ionization (ESI). This leads to problems such as increased limits of detection and incomplete sequence coverage of proteins. Incomplete sequence coverage is especially problematic for analyses that require the detection and identification of specific peptides from a protein, such as the analysis of post-translational modifications. We describe here the development and use of aldehyde-based chemistry for the alkylation of peptide primary amines to increase peptide hydrophobicity, providing increased ionization efficiency and concomitant signal enhancement. When employed to modify the peptide products of protein tryptic digests, increased sequence coverage is obtained from combined modified and unmodified digests. To evaluate the utility of alkylation of peptides for selected reaction monitoring (SRM) assays, we alkylated a peptide from the protein Oct4, known to play a role in regulating stem cell differentiation. Increased chromatographic retention and ionization efficiency is observed for the alkylated Oct4 peptide compared to its unmodified form.     

Probabilistic enrichment of phosphopeptides by their mass defect

The mass defect, that is, the difference between the nominal and actual monoisotopic masses, of a phosphorus in a phosphate group is greater than for most other atoms present in proteins. When the mass defects of tryptic peptides derived from the human proteome are plotted against their masses, phosphopeptides tend to fall off the regression line. By calculating the masses of all potential tryptic peptides from the human proteome, we show that regions of higher phosphorylation probability exist on such a plot. We developed a transformation function to estimate the mass defect of a peptide from its monoisotopic mass and empirically defined a simple formula for a user-selectable discriminant line that categorizes a peptide mass according to its probability of being phosphorylated. Our method performs similarly well on phosphopeptides derived from a database of experimentally validated phosphoproteins. The method is relatively insensitive to mass measurement error of up to 20 ppm. The approach can be used with a tandem mass spectrometer in real time to rapidly select and rank order the possible phosphopeptides from a mixture of unmodified peptides for subsequent phosphorylation site mapping and peptide sequence analysis.     

Selective sampling of phosphopeptides for detection by MALDI mass spectrometry

The analysis of phosphopeptides by mass spectrometry (MS) is one of the most challenging tasks in proteomics. This is due to the lower isoelectric point (pI) of phosphopeptides, which leads to inefficient sample ionization in MS, particularly when competing with other peptides. The problem is compounded by the typical low abundance of phosphopeptides in biological samples. We describe here a simple nonsorptive method to isolate phosphopeptides based on their pI. A voltage is applied to selectively migrate the phosphopeptides into a capillary, which are negatively charged at acidic pH. The selectively sampled fraction is directly deposited onto MALDI sample target in nanoliter volumes (7-35 nL) for highly sensitive MS detection. No significant sample loss is evident in this procedure; hence, the MS was able to detect the isolated phosphopeptides at trace quantity. In this case, attomole-level detection limit is achieved for synthetic phosphopeptides (nM concentration and nL volume), from a mixture containing other peptides at up to 1 million times higher in concentration. Selective sampling was also applied to the tryptic digest of beta- and alpha-caseins to reveal the multiple phosphorylated peptides at the low-femtomole level using MALDI MS. Knowledge of pI based on the rejection/injection of peptides was found to be useful in peak assignment. To confirm the sequence of the selectively sampled peptides, fraction collection was performed for offline ESI MS/MS analysis.     

Improving de novo sequencing of peptides using a charged tag and C-terminal digestion

An improved method for peptide de novo sequencing by MALDI mass spectrometry is presented. The method couples a charge derivatization reaction with C-terminal digestion to modify tryptic peptides. The charge derivatization attaches a fixed charge group onto the N-termini of peptides, and the enzymatic digestion after the derivatization step removes C-terminal basic amino acid residues such as arginine and lysine. The fragmentation of the modified peptide(s) under low-energy CID conditions (MALDI Q-TOF mass spectrometer) yields a simplified yet complete ion series of the peptide sequence. The validity of the method is demonstrated by the results from several model protein digests, where peptide sequences were correctly deduced either manually or through an automated sequencing program.     

Evaluating preparative isoelectric focusing of complex peptide mixtures for tandem mass spectrometry-based proteomics: a case study in profiling chromatin-enriched subcellular fractions in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We have evaluated the use of free-flow electrophoresis, an emerging separation method for preparative isoelectric focusing of complex peptide mixtures, as a tool for high-throughput tandem mass spectrometry-based proteomic analysis. In this study, we investigated the ability of free-flow electrophoresis to resolve and fractionate complex peptide mixtures and also the effectiveness of using peptide isoelectric point in conjunction with peptide match probability scoring in sequence database searching. As a model system for this study, we analyzed a chromatin-enriched fraction from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This mixture was fractionated using preparative isoelectric focusing by free-flow electrophoresis, followed by online capillary liquid chromatography electrospray tandem mass spectrometry and sequence database searching. Our results demonstrate that (1) FFE effectively resolves and fractionates complex peptide mixtures on the basis of peptide isoelectric point and (2) the introduction of peptide pI is effective in minimizing both false positive and false negative sequence matches in sequence database searching of tandem mass spectrometry data.     

Peptide sequencing and characterization of post-translational modifications by enhanced ion-charging and liquid chromatography electron-transfer dissociation tandem mass spectrometry

We have tested the effect of m-nitrobenzyl alcohol (m-NBA) as a method to increase the average charge state of protonated gas-phase molecular ions generated by ESI from tryptic peptides and phosphopeptides. Various concentrations of m-NBA were added to the mobile phases of a liquid chromatography system coupled to an ESI tandem mass spectrometer. Addition of just 0.1% m-NBA changed the average charge state for the identified tryptic BSA peptides from 2.2+ to 2.6+. As a result, the predominant charge states for BSA peptides were changed from 2+ to > or =3+. To evaluate the benefits of peptide charge enhancement, the ETD fragmentation efficiency and Mascot peptide score were compared for BSA peptides in charge states 2+ and 3+. In all cases but one, triply charged peptides fragmented more efficiently than the analogues 2+ peptide ions. On average, triply charged peptides received a 68% higher Mascot score (24 units) than doubly charged peptides. m-NBA also increased the average charge state of phosphopeptides by up to 0.5 charge unit. The ease of implementation and the analytical benefits of charge enhancement of tryptic peptides by addition of m-NBA to the LC solvents suggest the general application of this reagent in proteomic studies that employ ETD-MS/MS and related techniques.     

Pressurized electrochromatography coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry for analysis of peptides and proteins

Pressurized capillary electrochromatography (pCEC) was coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) using a coaxial sheath liquid interface. It was used for separation and analysis of peptides and proteins. The effects of organic modifier and applied voltage on separation were investigated, and the effects of pH value of the mobile phase and the concentration of the electrolyte on ESI-MS signal were investigated. The resolution and detection sensitivity with different separation methods (pCEC, capillary high-performance liquid chromatography) coupled on-line with mass spectrometry were compared for the separation of a peptide mixture. To evaluate the feasibility and reliability of the experimental setup of the system, tryptic digests of cytochrome c and modified protein as real samples were analyzed by using pCEC-ESI-MS.     

Electron-transfer ion/ion reactions of doubly protonated peptides: effect of elevated bath gas temperature

In this study, the electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) behavior of cations derived from 27 different peptides (22 of which are tryptic peptides) has been studied in a 3D quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer. Ion/ion reactions between peptide cations and nitrobenzene anions have been examined at both room temperature and in an elevated temperature bath gas environment to form ETD product ions. From the peptides studied, the ETD sequence coverage tends to be inversely related to peptide size. At room temperature, very high sequence coverage (approximately 100%) was observed for small peptides (< or =7 amino acids). For medium-sized peptides composed of 8-11 amino acids, the average sequence coverage was 46%. Larger peptides with 14 or more amino acids yielded an average sequence coverage of 23%. Elevated-temperature ETD provided increased sequence coverage over room-temperature experiments for the peptides of greater than 7 residues, giving an average of 67% for medium-sized peptides and 63% for larger peptides. Percent ETD, a measure of the extent of electron transfer, has also been calculated for the peptides and also shows an inverse relation with peptide size. Bath gas temperature does not have a consistent effect on percent ETD, however. For the tryptic peptides, fragmentation is localized at the ends of the peptides suggesting that the distribution of charge within the peptide may play an important role in determining fragmentation sites. A triply protonated peptide has also been studied and shows behavior similar to the doubly charged peptides. These preliminary results suggest that for a given charge state there is a maximum size for which high sequence coverage is obtained and that increasing the bath gas temperature can increase this maximum.     

Studies of histidine as a suitable isoelectric buffer for tryptic digestion and isoelectric trapping fractionation followed by capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry for proteomic analysis

The use of histidine as a protein digestion buffer followed by isoelectric trapping separations using "membrane separated wells for isoelectric focusing and trapping" (MSWIFT) and mass spectrometry (MS) analysis is described. Tryptic digestion of bovine serum albumin (BSA) performed in histidine buffered solutions yields similar amino acid sequence coverage values to those obtained using ammonium bicarbonate buffer. Time course studies suggest that histidine buffers provide faster migration of peptides from the loading compartment compared to digestions prepared in ammonium bicarbonate due to differences in conductivities of the two buffers. In addition, this sample preparation method and MSWIFT separations have been coupled with capillary electrophoresis (CE) and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) as an alternative separation approach for proteomic studies. Tryptic peptides of ribosomal proteins in histidine are fractionated using MSWIFT followed by CE-MALDI-MS, which further illustrates the ability to couple fractions from a pI based separation device to CE-MS. Specifically, two-dimensional CE-MS plots provide a direct correlation between the numbers of basic residues within the peptide sequence displayed in charge-state trend lines. Combining MSWIFT and CE-MS provides added information regarding peptide sequence, specifically pI and in-solution charge state. Post-translational modifications can also be identified using this method.     

Separation of a set of peptide sequence isomers using differential ion mobility spectrometry

Protein identification in bottom-up proteomics requires disentangling isomers of proteolytic peptides, a major class of which are sequence inversions. Their separation using ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) has been limited to isomeric pairs. Here we demonstrate baseline separation of all seven 8-mer tryptic peptide isomers using differential IMS. Evaluation of peak capacity implies that even larger libraries should be resolved for heavier peptides with higher charge states.     

Proteomic analysis with integrated multiple dimensional liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry based on elution of ion exchange column using pH steps

A novel integrated multidimensional liquid chromatography (IMDL) method is demonstrated for the separation of peptide mixtures by two-dimensional HPLC coupled with ion trap mass spectrometry. The method uses an integrated column, containing both strong cation exchange and reversed-phase sections for two-dimensional liquid chromatography. The peptide mixture was fractionated by a pH step using a series of pH buffers, followed by reversed-phase chromatography. Since no salt was used during separation, the integrated multidimensional liquid chromatography can be directly connected to mass spectrometry for peptide analysis. The pH buffers were injected from an autosampler, and the entire process can be carried out on a one-dimensional liquid chromatography system. In a single analysis, the IMDL system, coupled with linear ion trap mass spectrometry, identified more than 2000 proteins in mouse liver. The peptides were eluted according to their pI distribution. The resolution of the pH fractionation is approximately 0.5 pH unit. The method has low overlapping across pH fractions, good resolution of peptide mixture, and good correlation of peptide pIs with pH steps. This method provides a technique for large-scale protein identification using existing one-dimensional HPLC systems.     

Quantitation and facilitated de novo sequencing of proteins by isotopic N-terminal labeling of peptides with a fragmentation-directing moiety

We describe a method for comparative quantitation and de novo peptide sequencing of proteins separated either by standard chromatographic methods or by one- and two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The approach is based on the use of an isotopically labeled reagent to quantitate (by mass spectrometry) the ratio of peptides from digests of a protein being expressed under different conditions. The method allows quantitation of the changes occurring in spots or bands that contain more than one protein and has a greater dynamic range than most staining methods. Since the reagent carries a fixed positive charge under acidic conditions and labels only the N-terminal of peptides, the interpretation of tandem mass spectra to obtain sequence information is greatly simplified. The sequences can easily be extracted for homology searches instead of using indirect mass spectral-based searches and are independent of posttranslational modifications.     

Enhanced ionization of phosphorylated peptides during MALDI TOF mass spectrometry

Although alpha-cyano-4-hydroxycinnamic acid functions as an excellent matrix for the analysis of most peptides using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight (MALDI TOF) mass spectrometry, the ionization of phosphorylated peptides is usually suppressed by nonphosphorylated peptides. As an alternative matrix, 2',4',6'-trihydroxyacetophenone (THAP) with diammonium citrate was found to overcome this problem for the MALDI TOF mass spectrometric analysis of proteolytic digests of phosphorylated proteins. Specifically, the abundances of phosphorylated peptides in tryptic digests of bovine beta-casein and protein kinase C (PKC)-treated mouse cardiac troponin I were enhanced more than 10-fold using THAP during positive ion MALDI TOF mass spectrometry. The protonated molecules of phosphorylated peptides were sufficiently abundant that postsource decay TOF mass spectrometry was used to confirm the number of phosphate groups in each peptide. Finally, tryptic digestion followed by analysis using MALDI TOF mass spectrometry with THAP as the matrix facilitated the identification of a unique phosphorylation site in PKC-treated troponin I.     

Improvement in peptide detection for proteomics analyses using NanoLC-MS and high-field asymmetry waveform ion mobility mass spectrometry

Sensitive and selective detection of multiply charged peptide ions from complex tryptic digests was achieved using high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) combined with nanoscale liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (nanoLC-FAIMS-MS). The combination of FAIMS provided a marked advantage over conventional nanoLC-MS experiments by reducing the extent of chemical noise associated with singly charged ions and enhancing the overall population of detectable tryptic peptides. Such advantages were evidenced by a 6-12-fold improvement in signal-to-noise ratio measurements for a wide range of multiply charged peptide ions. An increase of 20% in the number of detected peptides compared to conventional nanoelectrospray was achieved by transmitting ions of different mobilities at high electric field vs low field while simultaneously recording each ion population in separate mass spectrometry acquisition channels. This method provided excellent reproducibility across replicate nanoLC-FAIMS-MS runs with more than 90% of all detected peptide ions showing less than 30% variation in intensity. The application of this technique in the context of proteomics research is demonstrated for the identification of trace-level proteins showing differential expression in U937 monocyte cell extracts following incubation with phorbol ester.     

Miniaturized ultra high field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry combined with mass spectrometry for peptide analysis

Miniaturized ultra high field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (ultra-FAIMS) combined with mass spectrometry (MS) has been applied to the analysis of standard and tryptic peptides, derived from α-1-acid glycoprotein, using electrospray and nanoelectrospray ion sources. Singly and multiply charged peptide ions were separated in the gas phase using ultra-FAIMS and detected by ion trap and time-of-flight MS. The small compensation voltage (CV) window for the transmission of singly charged ions demonstrates the ability of ultra-FAIMS-MS to generate pseudo-peptide mass fingerprints that may be used to simplify spectra and identify proteins by database searching. Multiply charged ions required a higher CV for transmission, and ions with different amino acid sequences may be separated on the basis of their differential ion mobility. A partial separation of conformers was also observed for the doubly charged ion of bradykinin. Selection on the basis of charge state and differential mobility prior to tandem mass spectrometry facilitates peptide and protein identification by allowing precursor ions to be identified with greater selectivity, thus reducing spectral complexity and enhancing MS detection.     

High-efficiency capillary isoelectric focusing of peptides

Several approaches are presently being developed for global proteome characterization that are based upon the analysis of polypeptide mixtures resulting from digestion of (often complex) mixtures of proteins. Improved methods for peptide analysis are needed that provide for sample concentration, higher resolution separations, and direct compatibility with mass spectrometry. In this work, methods for the high-efficiency capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) separation of peptides have been developed that provide for simultaneous sample concentration and separation according to peptide isoelectric point. Under typical nondenaturing CIEF conditions, peptides are concentrated approximately 500-fold, and peptides present at < 1 ng/ microL were detectable using conventional UV detection. CIEF separations of peptides provided much faster measurements of isoelectric points compared with conventional isoelectric focusing in gels. Very small differences in peptide isoelectric points (deltapI approximately 0.01) could be resolved, High-efficiency CIEF separations for complex peptide mixtures from tryptic digestion of yeast cytosol fractions were obtained and showed significant improvement over those obtained using capillary zone electrophoresis and packed capillary reversed-phase liquid chromatography.     

Use of a single-quadrupole mass spectrometer for collision-induced dissociation studies of multiply charged peptide ions produced by electrospray ionization.

The feasibility of obtaining the collision-induced dissociation (CID) spectra of multiply charged peptide ions produced by electrospray ionization in a simple and inexpensive single-quadrupole mass spectrometer is demonstrated. Collisional activation was carried out in the high-pressure region between the capillary exit and the skimmer entrance to the mass analyzer. The CID of multiply charged peptide ions is very efficient, and the observed fragment ion intensities are typically 1-5% of the parent ion intensity prior to CID. About 70 pmol of the peptide is consumed in obtaining each CID spectrum. Spectra obtained by CID of multiply charged ions from bradykinin, angiotensin II, two peptides with features similar to tryptic peptides, and a synthetic analogue of a component of TGF-alpha containing two disulfide bonds are shown. The influence of the primary structure of the peptide on the observed fragmentation pathways is discussed. Although the present single-quadrupole configuration is simple and effective, the inability to choose a particular parent ion for collisional activation makes it less powerful than the triple-quadrupole configuration for mixtures of peptides and peptide samples that yield more than one charge state in the normal mass spectrum. However, it has the potential for inexpensively obtaining sequence information of proteins at high sensitivity by analyzing the pure tryptic peptides obtained by on-line or off-line chromatographic separation of tryptic digests.