Experimental investigation and economic analysis of surfactant (Span-20) in powder mixed electrical discharge machining (PMEDM) of AISI D2 hardened steel

Abstract

Powder mixed EDM (PMEDM) is recognized as an advanced and innovative technique with enhanced performance and limited drawbacks in comparison to conventional EDM method. This study investigates the effect of powder particle size, various powder concentrations (C_p), and surfactant concentrations (C_s) on the performance of EDM. Since the machining characteristics are highly dependent on the dielectric performances, significant attention has been directed to introduce Cr powder and Span-20 surfactant into the dielectric fluid to achieve higher productivity and enhanced surface integrity. The EDM machining was carried out on AISI D2 hardened steel through ´Plug & Plaý dielectric circulating system attached to the main machine in order to evaluate the machining performances (i.e. MRR, EWR, and R_a). Interestingly, machining performance was improved with combination of Cr powder mixed and span-20 surfactant. By comparing the performance of span-20 surfactant and micro-nano chromium, the result within selected parameters shows that the span-20 surfactant and nano-chromium is the better choice for the EDM of AISI D2 hardened steel. In the machinability studies, the EDM machining of AISI D2 hardened steel by using span-20 surfactant and nano-chromium has exhibited the excellent machining performances, which led to 45.08% MRR enhancement and 68.89% R_a enhancement comparing to micro-chromium powder and span-20 surfactant led to 35.28% MRR and 28.96% R_a. Furthermore, cost analysis revealed that the nano-Cr powder size was approximately 4 times more economical than micro-Cr powder in machining of AISI D2 hardened steel, although the price for 1?kg is quite expensive.     

Surface characterization and material migration during surface modification of die steels with silicon, graphite and tungsten powder in EDM process

The present study reports the results of an experimental work carried out to evaluate the improvement in machined surface properties of die steels machined using powder mixed electric discharge machining (PMEDM) process. Two surface responses, surface finish and microhardness were analyzed for changes when machined with Si, W and graphite powders mixed in dielectric fluid. The machined surfaces were subsequently analyzed using Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy (EDS) to study the element migration from powder, dielectric and the tool. The powder mixed with dielectric and its concentration, current and pulse on time were identified as the significant factors affecting surface finish. Brass electrode and tungsten powder resulted in good surface finish. Amongst the dielectrics used, kerosene provided a better cooling effect whereas EDM oil resulted in better surface finish. The microhardness of the machined surface was also affected by powder and its concentration, current, pulse on time and electrode material. W-Cu electrode and W powder resulted in a higher microhardness. The SEM and EDS analysis showed significant migration of material from the suspended powder, electrode and dielectric to the machined surface.     

Material removal rate and electrode wear ratio study on the powder mixed electrical discharge machining of cobalt-bonded tungsten carbide

In this article, a material removal rate (MRR) and electrode wear ratio (EWR) study on the powder mixed electrical discharge machining (PMEDM) of cobalt-bonded tungsten carbide (WC-Co) has been carried out. This type of cemented tungsten carbide was widely used as moulding material of metal forming, forging, squeeze casting, and high pressure die casting. In the PMEDM process, the aluminum powder particle suspended in the dielectric fluid disperses and makes the discharging energy dispersion uniform; it displays multiple discharging effects within a single input pulse. This study was made only for the finishing stages and has been carried out taking into account the four processing parameters: discharge current, pulse on time, grain size, and concentration of aluminum powder particle for the machinability evaluation of MRR and EWR. The response surface methodology (RSM) has been used to plan and analyze the experiments. The experimental plan adopts the face-centered central composite design (CCD). This study highlights the development of mathematical models for investigating the influence of processing parameters on performance characteristics.     

Application of TOPSIS to Taguchi method for multi-characteristic optimization of electrical discharge machining with titanium powder mixed into dielectric fluid

Mixing powder into dielectric fluid in electrical discharge machining (PMEDM) is a very interesting technological solution in current research. This method has the highest efficiency in simultaneously improving the productivity and quality of a machined surface. In this study, material removal rate (MRR), surface roughness (SR), and the micro-hardness of a machined surface (HV) in electrical discharge machining of die steels in dielectric fluid with mixed powder were optimized simultaneously using the Taguchi–TOPSIS method. The process parameters used in the study included workpiece materials (SKD61, SKD11, SKT4), electrode materials (copper, graphite), electrode polarity, pulse-on time, pulse-off time, current, and titanium powder concentration. Some interaction pairs among the process parameters were also used to evaluate the effect on the optimal results. The results showed that MRR and HV increased and SR decreased when Ti powder was mixed into the dielectric fluid in EDM. Factors such as powder concentration, electrode material, electrode polarity, and pulse-off time were found to be significant in the optimal indicator (C*) and the S/N ratio of C*. Powder concentration was also found to be the most significant factor; its contribution to C* was 50.90%, and S/N ratio of C* was 51.46%. The interactions of the powder concentration and certain process parameters for C* were found to be largest. The optimum quality characteristics were MRR?=?38.79 mm³/min, SR?=?2.71 μm, and HV?=?771 HV. The optimal parameters were verified by experiment, and its accuracy was good (max error ≈13.38%). The finished machined surface under optimum conditions was also analyzed. The machined surface quality under optimum conditions was good. In addition, the results of the study showed the TOPSIS limitations of TOPSIS in a multi-criteria optimization problem.     

Advantages of carbon nanotubes in electrical discharge machining

Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) have a small specific gravity and a straight-pin shape, which allow them to continuously float and to uniformly disperse throughout the entire dielectric-filled cavity with little agglomeration during electrical discharge machining (EDM). In the past, powder mixtures of silicon, aluminum, and chrome have been used in the EDM process. However, there are concerns about flushing the controlled gap between the electrode and the workpiece because of their heavy specific gravity and their associated non-uniform dispersion in the dielectric. In this study, the effect of adding CNT powders to the dielectric on the surface integrity and the machining efficiency of the workpiece were investigated. CNTs can avoid the agglomeration problem. The CNTs were fabricated by chemical vapor deposition and added to the dielectric at a concentration of 0.4?g/l. The average surface roughness of 0.09?μm was achieved within 1.2?h, and the material defects of the recast layer and the micro-cracks were considerably reduced. The adopted processing parameters were a negative electrode polarity, a discharge current of 1?A, a pulse duration of 2?μs, an open-circuit voltage of 280?V, and gap voltage of 70?V. This technology improved the surface finish by 70% and the machining time by 66%. The achievement is attributed to the nanoscale characteristics of the CNTs in the dielectrics. The surface force became large and was able to balance the gravity body force of the CNTs. Consequently, the electric arcs were well dispersed and more uniform across the electrode gap, thus significantly enhancing the performance of the electrical discharge. It is expected that carbon nanotubes will be used in many EDM applications.     

混粉准干式电火花加工介质击穿机理研究

混粉准干式电火花加工以气、液、固三相流作为工作介质,能够有效改善气中加工短路率高、加工效率低的问题。以纯净气体介质的击穿理论为基础,对三相流工作介质的击穿机理进行理论分析,阐明固、液分散相的作用机制。建立混粉准干式电火花加工的极间电场强度表达式,给出三相流中加工的放电间隙计算式,从理论上证明分散相的加入使得混粉准干式电火花加工的放电间隙较气中加工大,指出放电间隙增大是加工效率提高的一个重要原因。进行压缩空气中和三相流介质中的放电加工对比试验。测得两种加工介质中的放电间隙值,试验证实三相流工作介质具有放电间隙增大效果。测得放电电压波形,证实气体连续相中固、液分散相的加入能够降低短路率,提高加工稳定性。     

EDM混粉工作液国产化研究

利用国产铝粉作为混粉工作液的粉末添加剂,进行混粉电火花加工试验研究。结果表明,国产铝粉用于混粉电火花加工对于改善加工质量和提高加工效率都具有明显效果。     

A review on the use of dielectric fluids and their effects in electrical discharge machining characteristics

Electrical discharge machining (EDM) is one of the earliest non-traditional machining processes. EDM process is based on thermoelectric energy between the work piece and an electrode. In electrical discharge machining (EDM), a process utilizing the removal phenomenon of electrical discharge in dielectric, the working fluid plays an important role affecting the material removal rate and the properties of the machined surface. Choosing the right dielectric fluid is critical for successful operations. This paper presents a literature survey on the use of dielectric fluids and also their effects in electrical discharge machining characteristics.     

混粉大面积电火花加工机理的分析

根据电火花加工原理和特点,分析了传统大面积电火花加工很难获得良好粗糙度的原因,同时探讨了混粉电火花加工改善大面积加工表面粗糙度的原因,并用实践验证了混粉电火花加工能改善加工表面粗糙度     

密封圈模具的电火花成形铣削

在研究分析电火花成形铣削的工艺方法、工艺特点及适用范围的基础上,提出将其与混粉工艺相结合,应用于密封圈模具的制造,可提高加工效率,获得镜面效果的高精度型腔,使电火花加工成为模具型腔的最终精加工。     

Development and application of new composite materials as EDM electrodes manufactured via selective laser sintering

The cost of a part manufactured by electrical dischargeEDM machining (EDM) is mainly determined by electrode cost. The production of electrodes by conventional machining processes is complex, time consuming, and can account for over 50 % of the total EDM process costs. The emerging additive manufacturing (AM) technologies provide the possibility of direct fabrication of EDM electrodes. Selective laser sintering (SLS) is an alternative AM technique because it has the possibility to directly produce functional components, reducing the tool-room lead time and total EDM costs. The main difficulty of manufacturing an EDM electrode using SLS is the selection of an appropriate material, once both processes require different material properties. The current work focused on the investigation of appropriate materials that fulfill EDM and SLS process demands. Three new metal-matrix materials composed of Mo–CuNi, TiB₂–CuNi, and ZrB₂–CuNi were developed and characterized. Electrodes under adequate SLS conditions were manufactured through a systematic methodology. EDM experiments using different discharge energies were carried out, and the performance evaluated in terms of material removal rate and volumetric relative wear. The results showed that the powder systems composed of Mo–CuNi, TiB₂–CuNi, and ZrB₂–CuNi revealed to be successfully processed by SLS, and the EDM experiments demonstrated that the new composite electrodes are promising materials. The work also suggests important topics for future research work on this field.     

混粉准干式电火花加工试验研究

提出一种混粉准干式电火花加工技术,其加工介质是气液固三相流混合物。试验结果表明,材料去除率与表面粗糙度随脉冲宽度、峰值电流及分层厚度的增大而增大,脉冲间隙作用则相反,提高空气压力既有助于提高材料去除率又可降低表面粗糙度,电极损耗随脉冲宽度增大而减小,当脉冲宽度较大时电极损耗接近于零,随峰值电流增大而增加。由于液滴、粉末的介入,气体介质的绝缘强度降低,放电间隙会增加,有利于电蚀产物的排除,可减少短路、电弧放电的发生率,加工稳定性得到提高,从而材料去除率得到提高;由于粉末会产生放电分散效果,电蚀凹坑深度减小,工件表面粗糙度降低。     

Sinking EDM in water-in-oil emulsion

In this paper, a new type of sinking electric discharge machining (EDM) dielectric–water-in-oil (W/O) emulsion is proposed, and the machining characteristics of W/O emulsion are investigated by comparing with that of kerosene. In the experiments, machining parameters such as the dielectric type, peak current, and pulse duration are changed to explore their effects on machining performance, including the material removal rate (MRR), relative electrode wear rate (REWR), and surface roughness. Experimental results revealed that W/O emulsion could be used as the dielectric fluid of sinking EDM and adopting long pulse duration and large peak current could lead to obtaining higher MRR than kerosene. Compared with kerosene, W/O emulsion is observed to cause lower carbon adhered to the electrode surface. Therefore, its REWR is higher. Statistics of the discharge waveform show that more stable discharge processes can be obtained by using W/O emulsion compared with kerosene. Furthermore, W/O emulsion is more economical and more environmentally friendly than kerosene, and it could be an alternative to kerosene in sinking EDM application.     

水气联合电火花加工实验研究

将自来水和压缩空气作为电介质,使用实心成形电极对钢件进行电火花加工实验,探讨其加工机理。实验证明,空气与水的配合状况对电火花效果起着决定性作用;加工中可以获得较大的加工速度(材料蚀除速率)和较低的电极相对损耗,加工后工件表面粗糙度值一般较大;水气联合电火花加工适宜于高电流大脉宽加工。     

Assessing the effects of different dielectrics on environmentally conscious powder-mixed EDM of difficult-to-machine material (WC-Co)

Electrical discharge machining (EDM) is a well-known nontraditional manufacturing process to machine the difficult-to-machine (DTM) materials which have unique hardness properties. Researchers have successfully performed hybridization to improve this process by incorporating powders into the EDM process known as powder-mixed EDM process. This process drastically improves process efficiency by increasing material removal rate, micro-hardness, as well as reducing the tool wear rate and surface roughness. EDM also has some input parameters, including pulse-on time, dielectric levels and its type, current setting, flushing pressure, and so on, which have a significant effect on EDM performance. However, despite their positive influence, investigating the effects of these parameters on environmental conditions is necessary. Most studies demonstrate the use of kerosene oil as dielectric fluid. Nevertheless, in this work, the authors highlight the findings with respect to three different dielectric fluids, including kerosene oil, EDM oil, and distilled water using one-variable-at-a-time approach for machining as well as environmental aspects. The hazard and operability analysis is employed to identify the inherent safety factors associated with powder-mixed EDM of WC-Co.     

Assessment of PM-EDM cycle factors influence on machining responses and surface properties of biomaterials: A comprehensive review

Powder mixed-electro discharge machining (PM-EDM) is recently evolving machining technique which can simultaneously remove and modify the machined surface through thermo-electrical process. It is a modified form of EDM in which the conductive powder elements are added in the dielectric liquid to enhance machined surface characteristics and machining responses. The commonly used biomaterials such as 316L stainless steel, Ti-based alloy, Ni–Ti, Mg alloy, and Co–Mo–Cr alloy have excellent mechanical characteristics while the biofunction of these materials are not in satisfactory level. Due to higher hardness, brittleness, and heat resistant natures of the biomaterials, it is very challenging to machine them with conventional machining. Both the system efficiency and modified surface properties depend on the associated electrical and non-electrical factors of PM-EDM cycle. This review focuses on the influence of process factors such as current, pulse duration, tool-polarity, duty cycle, potential voltage, types of liquid, and added powder concentration on performance outputs including material removal and tool wear rate, coating thickness, coarseness, microhardness, coating adhesion bonding, biocompatibility, and resistant to corrosion. This study also discusses influence of various powders on machining and modified surface characteristics of biomaterials. The future research scopes and challenges of PM-EDM process are included in this study thoroughly.     

Comparative study of different dielectrics for micro-EDM performance during microhole machining of Ti-6Al-4V alloy

In microelectrodischarge machining (micro-EDM), dielectric plays an important role during machining operation. The machining characteristics are greatly influenced by the nature of dielectric used during micro-EDM machining. Present paper addresses the issues of micro-EDM utilizing different types of dielectrics such as kerosene, deionized water, boron carbide (B₄C) powder suspended kerosene, and deionized water to explore the influence of these dielectrics on the performance criteria such as material removal rate (MRR), tool wear rate (TWR), overcut, diameteral variance at entry and exit hole and surface integrity during machining of titanium alloy (Ti-6Al-4V). The experimental results revealed that MRR and TWR are higher using deionized water than kerosene. Also, when suspended particles, i.e., boron carbide-mixed dielectrics are used, MRR is found to increase with deionized water, but TWR decreases with kerosene dielectric. Further analysis is carried out with the help of scanning electron microscope (SEM) micrographs, and it is found that the thickness of white layer is less on machined surface when deionized water is used as compared to kerosene. Also, a comparative study of machining time has been carried out for the four types of dielectrics at different machining parametric settings. Furthermore, the investigation on the machined surface integrity and wear on microtool tip have also been done in each type of the dielectrics with the help of SEM micrographs and optical photographs. Hence micro-EDM machining on Ti-6Al-4V work material with B₄C-mixed dielectrics is performed in the investigation and reported the performance criteria of the process. It can be concluded from the research investigation that there is a great influence of mixing of boron carbide additive in deionized water dielectrics for enhancing machining performance characteristics in micro-EDM during microhole generation on Ti-6Al-4V alloy.     

Study on the characteristics of plasma channel based on multi-spark pulse discharge machining effect

Plasma channel characteristics and energy distribution in electrical discharge machining (EDM) were mostly studied by analyzing the geometry parameters of craters caused by a single pulse discharge in previous studies. However, single pulse experiments cannot provide us insights into superposition, migration, abruption, interruption, and other phenomena of the plasma channel which have significant effects on EDM. Besides, EDM itself is a consecutive pulse discharge process. Thus, this paper focuses on the characteristics of plasma channel and the mechanism of material removal based on experimental data from multi-spark pulse discharge machining. The contrastive milling experiments of different parameters in multi-spark pulse discharge machining in high-speed dry EDM by using nickel-based superalloy as workpiece were conducted. The effects of peak current, dielectric type, breakdown voltage, air pressure, and electrode rotation speed on the crater number, crater distance, crater depth, and crater removal volume were studied. The plasma channel characteristics and material removal mechanism in continuous machining of high-speed dry EDM were revealed.     

Modeling and analysis of the effects of machining parameters on the performance characteristics in the EDM process of Al2O3+TiC mixed ceramic

Electric discharge machining (EDM) has achieved remarkable success in the manufacture of conductive ceramic materials for the modern metal industry. Mathematical models are proposed for the modeling and analysis of the effects of machining parameters on the performance characteristics in the EDM process of Al₂O₃+TiC mixed ceramic which are developed using the response surface methodology (RSM) to explain the influences of four machining parameters (the discharge current, pulse on time, duty factor and open discharge voltage) on the performance characteristics of the material removal rate (MRR), electrode wear ratio (EWR), and surface roughness (SR). The experiment plan adopts the centered central composite design (CCD). The separable influence of individual machining parameters and the interaction between these parameters are also investigated by using analysis of variance (ANOVA). This study highlights the development of mathematical models for investigating the influences of machining parameters on performance characteristics and the proposed mathematical models in this study have proven to fit and predict values of performance characteristics close to those readings recorded experimentally with a 95% confidence interval. Results show that the main two significant factors on the value of the material removal rate (MRR) are the discharge current and the duty factor. The discharge current and the pulse on time also have statistical significance on both the value of the electrode wear ratio (EWR) and the surface roughness (SR).     

An experimental investigation into the micro-electrodischarge machining behavior of p-type silicon

The present study aims to investigate the feasibility of micro-structuring in p-type silicon, using conventional die-sinking electrodischarge machining (EDM). The EDM behavior of the silicon material is studied in terms of the effect of major operating parameters on the performance characteristics during the micro-hole machining. In addition, microelectrodes are fabricated successfully on the conventional EDM machine for machining different micro-structures in silicon. Three different types of micro-structures??micro-hole, blind slots, and through slots??are fabricated in p-type silicon successfully by using optimum parameters setting. It has been observed that p-type silicon is machinable by EDM using both the polarities. Moreover, like other electrodischarge machinable materials, the selection of optimum operating parameters is very important for improved performance, as those parameters are found to influence the EDM performance of silicon significantly. Finally, it has been concluded that p-type silicon is machinable into different forms of micro-structures by understanding its electrodischarge machining behavior and by careful selection of optimum parameters.