The influence of high temperature, type of muscle and electrical stimulation on the course of rigor, ageing and tenderness of beef muscles

The course of rigor mortis (rigor), ageing and tenderness has been evaluated for three beef muscles; M. biceps femoris (BF), M. semimembranosus (SM) and M. semitendinosus (ST), when entering rigor at constant temperatures of 15 and 37°C respectively, with and without electrical stimulation (ES/NS) (85 V, 14 Hz and 32 s). The course of post-mortem changes has been registered by isometric tension, by shortening of unrestrained muscle strips and by following the pH decline and the changes in metabolites, such as ATP and CP. Ageing at +4°C was recorded by measuring Warner-Bratzler (W-B) shear values 2, 8 and 15 days post mortem. On the last occasion, the sensory properties of the cooked meat were also evaluated. Maximum shortening and isometric tension were higher at 37°C as compared to 15°C, whereas ES did not reduce rigor shortening. A high correlation between maximum shortening and the ATP-level at the onset of the shortening rapid phase was found (r = 0·77(???)), which could explain the greater shortening obtained at 37°C compared to 15°C. Rigor shortening is an important phenomenon governing meat tenderness as tenderness is highly affected by rigor temperature but not by ES. This was the case for muscles SM and ST but not for BF muscle. Even though tenderness was measured after ageing (15 days post mortem), shortening during rigor seems to be more important for toughness when rigor mortis occurs at 37°C than any suggested tenderizing effect due to increased proteolysis in this temperature region.     

Effect of rigor temperature on muscle shortening and tenderisation of restrained and unrestrained beef m. longissimus thoracicus et lumborum

Pairs of muscularis longissimus thoracicus et lumborum (LTL) from young bulls were removed within 1h of slaughter. Small portions of the muscles were placed in a rigormeter to continously follow the isometric tension and isotonic shortening developed, at constant temperatures of 15, 20, 25, 30 and 35°C, as the muscle went into rigor. The bulk LTL was placed in water baths at the same temperature. One of the bulk pairs was tightly restrained by wrapping, to reduce muscle shortening, the other was unrestrained free to shorten. For the bulk samples, shear values were measured using a Warner-Bratzler instrument (1, 7 and 14 days post mortem), and sensory attributes were measured using a sensory panel (7 and 14 days post mortem). Minimum tension and shortening occurred at 15°C. The activation energy for the muscle shortening process was larger than for the isometric tension process. This indicates that the isometric tension data, collected during rigor, does not solely reflect muscle shortening. Thus, a counteracting process that decreases the tension response, most likely ageing is simultaneously detected. Meat that went into rigor at 15°C had least shortening and was always more tender than meat going into rigor at higher temperatures. For meat entering rigor at temperatures higher than 15°C, restraining of the muscle by wrapping, significantly (p<0.05) decreased the amount of muscle shortening and resulted in an improved meat tenderness (p<0.001). It was also observed that at rigor temperatures higher than 15°C the meat tenderness is affected negatively by a reduced ageing capacity. It therefore appears that muscle shortening and enzyme activity both affect tenderness and that both are highly affected by rigor temperature and have the greatest beneficial effect at a rigor temperature of 15°C.     

Calpains and calpastatin from cold-shortened bovine M. longissimus lumborum

Sections of beef longissimus lumborum from four animals were held after 1 hr post mortem at either 0 ° (cold-shortened) or at 15 °C (controls). After 24 hr, the levels of μ- and m-calpains were the same in both treatments and about 30% and 85% of their initial levels respectively. The level of calpastatin at 24 h was higher in cold-shortened (100%) than in controls (60% of its initial level). During subsequent storage at 4 °C, the activities of calpains and calpastatin decreased similarly in extracts from both cold-shortened and control muscles. The similar levels of μ-calpain during the first 24 hr post mortem but at the lower temperature suggest that there is less activity under cold-shortening conditions. This, combined with the increased calpastatin levels, would produce less proteolysis by the calpain system. Reduced proteolysis is therefore a factor which should be considered in an understanding of the mechanism of cold-shortening toughness.     

Effect of post-mortem temperature on beef tenderness

Beef adductor muscles were incubated for 4 h post mortem at 10°C and for 4 h and 6 h post mortem at 30°C, 37°C and 42°C. Half of the muscles were cooked just after incubation and the other half was first stored for two days at 4°C and then cooked. Meat kept for 4 h or 6 h at 42°C and for 6 h at 37°C and cooked at once had a significantly (p<0·05) lower shear force than meat kept for 4 h at 37°C, 4 h at 30°C, 6 h at 30°C or 4 h at 10°C. The respective significant differences were also found when the meat was cooked two days after incubation. Organoleptic evaluation showed that meat incubated for 6 h at 37°C or for 4 h at 42°C was not significantly more tender than other samples. However, meat kept for 6 h at 42°C was more tender (p<0·5) than the other samples. After two days of storage, meat incubated for 6 h at 37°C and for 6 h at 42° was more tender (p<0·05) than meat kept for 6 h at 30°C. It was concluded that high temperature conditioning at 37°C or higher for 6 h (4 h at 42°C) just after slaughter makes meat more tender than conventional cooling systems.     

Chilling pig carcasses: Effects on temperature, weight loss and ultimate meat quality

Effects of conventional (4°C, air velocity 0·5 m/s) and forced chilling at -5°C (120 min) or -30°C (30 min) with air velocities of 1, 2 or 4 m/s, followed by conventional chilling till 24 h post mortem on temperatures, meat quality and weight losses, were studied. Experiments were carried out in six batches of six slaughter pigs each (crossbred gilts, weighing 105-110 kg. The subcutaneous temperature decreased very rapidly to values below 0°C when 'ultra' rapid chilling (-30°C) at high air velocities (4 m/s was used. Immediately after rapid chilling, when the carcasses were railed into a conventional chiller, the subcutaneous temperature increased above the air temperature, after which the decline in temperature was continued. Temperature inside the biceps femoris muscle decreased from the start of chilling rather slowly according to an asymptotic curve until ultimate values of 4°C were reached. Theoretically calculated temperatures during slaughter and chilling were comparable with the measured values; indicating that a finite-element calculation method in combination with a cylindrical model for heat transport can be used to predict muscle temperatures for various chilling regimes. Losses in carcass weight, 24 h after conventional and forced chilling at -5°C, were about 2%. After 'ultra' rapid chilling (-30°C) the losses were reduced to 1·3% when air velocity was increased to 4 m/s. Meat quality of the longissimus lumborum muscle was not significantly affected by the various chilling regimes except for the variables related to tenderness. The Warner-Bratzler shear forces were higher (P < 0·05) together with shorter sarcomere lengths (P < 0·10) after 'ultra' rapid chilling at a high (4 m/s) air velocity, indicating an increased risk of cold shortening.     

The influence of elevated temperature conditioning on bison (Bison bison bison) meat quality

Elevated temperature conditioning (ETC: 10°C until 10 h post mortem) was effectively employed as a means of cooling bison carcasses in order to avoid the cold-induced meat quality defects that are a risk with conventional bison carcass chilling (0-2°C for 24 h). The ETC treatment maintained internal M. Longissimus lumborum and M. Semimembranosus temperature above 10°C within the first 10 h post mortem. The time/temperature combination did not result in significant evaporative loss, although loss of weight during carcass cooling can represent a practical economic loss. ETC accelerated post-mortem glycolysis and pH decline, and resulted in samples of lighter, more intense red colour than those conventionally chilled. Significant improvement in both initial tenderness and tenderization during ageing was realized with the use of ETC.     

Effect of pre-rigor stretch and various constant temperatures on the rate of post-mortem pH fall, rigor mortis and some quality traits of excised porcine biceps femoris muscle strips

Porcine biceps femoris strips of 10 cm original length were stretched by 50% and fixed within 1 hr post mortem then subjected to temperatures of 4 °, 15 ° or 36 °C until they attained their ultimate pH. Unrestrained control muscle strips, which were left to shorten freely, were similarly treated. Post-mortem metabolism (pH, R-value) and shortening were recorded; thereafter ultimate meat quality traits (pH, lightness, extraction and swelling of myofibrils) were determined. The rate of pH fall at 36 °C, as well as ATP breakdown at 36 and 4 °C, were significantly reduced by pre-rigor stretch. The relationship between R-value and pH indicated cold shortening at 4 °C. Myofibrils isolated from pre-rigor stretched muscle strips kept at 36 °C showed the most severe reduction of hydration capacity, while paleness remained below extreme values. However, pre-rigor stretched myofibrils - when stored at 4 °C - proved to be superior to shortened ones in their extractability and swelling.     

Initial chilling rate of pre-rigor beef muscles as an indicator of colour of thawed meat

The effect of three rigor temperatures and two muscles of different fibre composition on the colour of thawed meat were determined. Within 45 min post-mortem, m. semitendinosus (ST) and m. biceps femoris (BF) from unstimulated heifer sides were held at 0, 10 and 35°C until they entered rigor. The rate of pH fall was higher at 35°C than at 0 and 10°C; and the pH values were lower (first 12 h post mortem) in the ST than the BF. Hunter L*, a* and b* and the hue angle increased with increasing rigor temperature (P<0.001). The ST was lighter and yellower and had greater hue angle than the BF. Colour parameters were plotted against the rate of muscle cooling in the first hour post mortem and linear regression lines were fitted to the data and equations were derived that gave a good indication of the colour and colour stability of the muscles as meat.     

Rapid tenderisation of lamb M. longissimus with very fast chilling depends on rapidly achieving sub-zero temperatures

A study was undertaken to determine whether variations within the defined temperature-by-time profile for very fast chilling (VFC), might explain variations in tenderness found with VFC. Loins from 32 lambs were subjected to one of five cooling regimes; defined by the average temperature between the meat surface and centre reached at a specific time post mortem. These were: -0.3 °C at 22 h (Control), 2.6 °C at 1.5 h (Fast(supra-zero)), 0.7 °C at 5.5 h (Slow(supra-zero)), -1.6 °C at 1.5 h (Fast(sub-zero)) and -2.3 °C at 5.5 h (Slow(sub-zero)), respectively. Shear force values considered very tender by consumers (less than 50 N, MIRINZ tenderometer) were found 2 days post mortem in Fast(sub-zero) loins only. Both time and temperature at the end of the cooling period contributed to variations in shear force. To achieve low shear force, the loins needed to be cooled to less than 0 °C at 1.5 h post mortem.     

The influence of low temperature, type of muscle and electrical stimulation on the course of rigor mortis, ageing and tenderness of beef muscles

The course of rigor mortis, ageing and tenderness have been evaluated for two beef muscles, M. semimembranosus (SM) and M. longissimus dorsi (LD), when entering rigor at constant temperatures in the cold-shortening region (1, 4, 7 and 10°C). The influence of electrical stimulation (ES) was also examined. Post-mortem changes were registered by shortening and isometric tension and by following the decline of pH, ATP and creatine phosphate. The effect of ageing on tenderness was recorded by measuring shear-force (2, 8 and 15 days post mortem) and the sensory properties were assessed 15 days post mortem. It was found that shortening increased with decreasing temperature, resulting in decreased tenderness. Tenderness for LD, but not for SM, was improved by ES at 1 and 4°C, whereas ES did not give rise to any decrease in the degree of shortening during rigor mortis development. This suggests that ES influences tenderization more than it prevents cold-shortening. The samples with a pre-rigor mortis temperature of 1°C could not be tenderized, when stored up to 15 days, whereas this was the case for the muscles entering rigor mortis at the other higher temperatures. The results show that under the conditions used in this study, the course of rigor mortis is more important for the ultimate tenderness than the course of ageing.     

Effects of cryogenic chilling on beef carcass grade, shrinkage and palatability characteristics

Alternate right or left sides of 90 carcasses were randomly selected and chilled at -70°C for 5 h, held at +16°C for 4 h and held at 1°C for 15 h (rapid chill-RC). The remaining sides were chilled at -7°C for 24 h (conventional chill-CC). Physical measurements and USDA quality grade data were obtained at 24 h post mortem and palatability samples were collected at 3-5 days post mortem. RC sides had 0·9% less shrinkage (P < 0·05) at 24 h post mortem when compared to paired CC sides. Beef sides that were given the RC treatment had a darker, softer lean (P < 0·01) and received higher marbling scores (P < 0·01) at 24 h post mortem than did CC sides. Loin steaks from RC sides had longer sarcomeres, less shear resistance and higher sensory panel tenderness ratings. It may be possible to rapidly chill carcasses with less carcass shrinkage and with no detrimental effects on USDA quality grade or on beef palatability.     

Effects of stress and high voltage electrical stimulation on tenderness of lamb m. longissimus

This study was conducted to investigate the reported effect of pre-slaughter stress on meat tenderness independent from its effect on ultimate pH, and its interaction with electrical stimulation. From a group of 80 Coopworth lamb, 40 were stressed by subjecting the animals to a swim wash 3 h before slaughter and the use of dogs to assemble the animals to the access ramp of the abbatoir. Half of the carcasses of each group was electrically stimulated within 30 min post mortem. Temperature and pH decline of the longissimus was monitored and shear force of the cooked muscle was determined at 2 days post mortem and after 6 weeks vacuum storage at 1°C. To investigate an effect of stress independent of ultimate pH, 10 muscles with an ultimate pH below 5.8 were selected from each group for detailed analysis. This analysis consisted of determination of calpastatin activity and sarcomere length, and immunoblotting of μ-calpain and calpain substrates. The stress treatment led to an increase in the number of muscles with an ultimate pH above 5.8 (32.5 vs 15%), and muscles with an ultimate pH above 5.8 were significantly tougher than muscles with an ultimate pH below 5.8 at 2 days post mortem. Electrical stimulation improved tenderness at two days post mortem. This effect could be attributed to an effect on muscle contraction, but not on post mortem proteolysis of calpain substrates. A large variation in tenderness at 2 days post mortem was observed and this was not reduced by electrical stimulation. Six weeks of vacuum storage resulted in a 6 kgF drop in mean shear force and a uniformly tender product. Despite the fact that the stress treatment was similar to those in earlier studies, we failed to observe an effect of stress independent of ultimate pH on tenderness. The reason for this is unclear, but differences in the response to stress between breeds may be responsible. The results of the present study underscore the importance of minimizing pre-slaughter stress and adequate post mortem storage for meat quality.     

Influence of temperature on the rate of post-mortem metabolism and water-holding capacity of bovine neck muscles

Strips of forty bovine neck muscles were placed at temperatures in the range -1° to +30°C within 45 min of slaughter and stored for up to 24 h. Strips were taken at various times during storage and assayed for pH, 'R' value (degree of transformation of ATP to IMP) and ATP concentration. The water-holding capacity (WHC) of the intact muscle was compared with the WHC of a salted muscle homogenate prepared at each sampling time. The rate of pH fall post mortem was relatively low around +5°C and increased at lower or higher temperatures. ATP concentration showed a delay phase dependent on storage temperature and a subsequent rate of depletion which was also temperature dependent. The patterns of change in WHC of the muscle samples and the salted homogenates differed, the former showing a rapid fall to a fairly steady level shortly after initiation of storage, the latter showing no appreciable change until the onset of rigor. It is suggested that salting meat at any time prior to the onset of rigor will confer improved WHC and that the temperature of storage post mortem should be chosen to induce low rates of ATP turnover so as to prolong the feasible delay between slaughter and salting.     

Modelling post-mortem tenderisation-II: Enzyme changes during storage of electrically stimulated and non-stimulated beef

Levels of calpains I and II, cathepsins B and L and β-glucuronidase were determined in extracts of electrically stimulated and control beef M. Pectoralis profundus stored at temperatures between 0 and 30°C and varied to avoid muscle shortening. The level of lysosomal enzymes remained essentially unchanged throughout storage. The levels of calpain II were largely unaffected by the early treatments and decreased slightly throughout ageing. The level of calpain I, in both stimulated and control meats, was unaffected by temperature prior to the attainment of about pH 6·2 and thereafter the loss was accelerated at higher temperatures. In the extreme case studied, that of stimulated meat held at 15°C, 73% of the activity was lost in the first 24 h. After ageing, the level was about 11% of the initial when stored at 1°C and 25% when stored at 15°C. The exponential decay constants for the decrease in the levels of calpain I were 0·01 h(-1) at 1°C and 0·06 h(-1) at 15°C, and were the same as those for the previously determined rate of tenderisation. This suggested that the rate of proteolysis by calpain I was linked to the rate of tenderisation.     

Structural changes in endomysium and perimysium during post-mortem aging of chicken Semitendinosus muscle-Contribution of structural weakening of intramuscular connective tissue to meat tenderization

Post-mortem changes in endomysium and perimysium were investigated during aging of chicken semitendinosus muscle at 4°C. Although the shear-force value of raw meat decreased rapidly within 5 h post mortem and gradually thereafter, the solubility of collagen and the ratio of each chain of soluble collagen remained unchanged during 24 h post mortem. Light microscopic studies showed that structures of endomysium and perimysium disintegrated into several thin sheets within 12 h post mortem, and that many gaps opened in the cross-section of endomysium and perimysium. While endomysium and perimysium were not stained by periodic acid Schiff reagent in fresh muscle, they were markedly stained in muscle 12 h post mortem. These results provide direct evidence for the structural weakening of endomysium and perimysium during post-mortem aging of chicken. Therefore, we conclude that the structural weakening of the intramuscular connective tissue is closely related to tenderization of chicken.     

Immersion chilling of hot cut, vacuum packed pork primals

Hot-cutting and immersion chilling of pork was compared with a conventional air chilling process. The right sides of eight pig carcasses were cut into primals whilst hot, vacuum packed and chilled in sodium chloride brine at 0°C, whilst the left sides were chilled conventionally in air at 0°C and 1 m/s, before being similarly cut and vacuum packed. The primals from both treatments were then stored in air at 0°C for either 24h or 15 days post mortem. The immersion process achieved an average saving in weight loss of 1·9% after both storage periods, and took between 2·5 and 3·5 h less than the conventional process to reduce meat temperatures to 7°C. It did, however, produce significantly tougher meat after 24 h, although not after 15 days. Sensory evaluation of odour and appearance suggested a reduced shelf-life and a darker meat coloration for immersion chilled pork.     

Comparison of Dehiding versus Scalding and Singeing: Effect on Temperature, pH and Meat Quality in Pigs

The aim of this work was to investigate the temperature and pH changes taking place at the slaughter line and during the chilling process, and the subsequent effect on meat and eating quality in pig carcasses that had either been scalded and singed or dehided. Both processes were followed by fast chilling. 219 halothane-gene-free Duroc Sire and Landrace-Yorkshire pigs were delivered from three farms and slaughtered over 2 weeks at either a dehiding or a scalding singeing slaughterhouse. Temperature and pH were measured at intervals from exsanguination until 6 hours post mortem. Ultimate pH, internal reflection, drip loss and colour (Minolta) were measured the day after slaughter. Colour (JPCS scale) was evaluated after freezing and thawing, and eating quality was estimated on unaged and aged (4 days at 4°C) m. longissimus dorsi (LD), using a trained taste panel. At the slaughter line the dehided carcasses had an almost constant and lower temperature compared to the scalded and singed carcasses. During chilling there is a shift in temperature curves between treatments, where the scalded carcasses had the lowest muscle temperature in LD and m. biceps femoris (BF) from 2hr post mortem and throughout the measuring period. In spite of the shift in temperature, the dehided carcasses had the highest pH in LD and BF from exsanguination and throughout the measuring period. The rate of pH fall in LD and BF was slowest in the dehided carcasses from exsanguination until 3 and 2hr respectively, post mortem. Dehided carcasses showed a 40% lower drip loss, a darker meat colour and a lower internal reflection in LD and BF compared to scalded and singed carcasses, thus indicating less protein denaturation in dehided carcasses. Scalding and singeing, however, lead to increased tenderness compared to dehiding, and this difference persisted even after ageing for 4 days at 4°C. The differences in toughness may be caused by increased proteolysis by released lysosomal cathepsins.     

Post-mortem electrical stimulation and high temperature ageing of hot-deboned beef

The effects of electrical stimulation (80-100 V, 15 pps) of hot-deboned, bovine Longissimus dorsi muscles, followed by ageing at 30° or 40°Cfor 5, 7 or 10 h, on the solubility of sarcoplasmic and myofibrillar proteins, soluble non-protein nitrogen, and on the water-holding capacity, colour, tenderness and microbiological status of the meat, was assessed. Comparisons were made with the same traits measured on non-stimulated controls (average muscle temperature, 5°C), which were cold-deboned post rigor, and with hot-deboned, electrically stimulated muscles, subsequently held at 2°C. For each treatment and its corresponding control, six muscles each were studied. Such electrical stimulation produced a typical acceleration of pH fall post mortem and enhanced ageing changes at both 30°C and 40°C. It significantly increased tenderness over non-stimulated, cold-deboned controls. The higher temperature of ageing, however, was significantly associated with adverse colour development, loss of water-holding capacity and increased microbial growth. Electrical stimulation alone would not obviate the need for immediate refrigeration in hot-deboning operations with ambient temperatures of ～ 40°C.     

Effect of chilling applied to suckling lamb carcasses on hygienic, physicochemical and sensory meat quality

The effect of post mortem temperature treatment on suckling lamb carcass and meat quality was study. Conventional (2°C for 24h), ultra-rapid (-20°C for 3.5h, 2°C until 24h) and slow chillings (12°C for 7h, 2°C until 24h) were compared. Total viable counts (TVC), weight losses, and pH and temperature falls were recorded on carcasses. Meat colour, water holding capacity (WHC), Warner-Bratzler shear force, sarcomere length and sensory analysis were evaluated in M. longissimus. Ultra-rapid treatment reduced TVC and weight losses. The pH decline was faster in slow chilled carcasses than in faster chilled carcasses. No significant differences were found for colour and WHC. Slow treatment carcasses showed significantly lower shear force and higher sarcomere length. In the sensory analysis, tasters also rated the early post mortem slow-treated meat as more tender, less fibrous and chewy. Therefore, delay chilling in suckling lamb carcasses made it possible to obtain meat with better organoleptic characteristics, without affecting weight loss or hygienic quality.