Effect of electrical stunning method and cardiac arrest on bleeding efficiency, residual blood and blood splash in lambs

Five hundred and fifty-nine Southdown-Romney cross lambs were used in a comparison of the efficiency of bleeding animals slaughtered by one of three different methods. The main comparison was between spear stuck lambs that had been electrically stunned by either head application or a head-back method. In addition, some unstunned lambs were slaughtered by the traditional New Zealand gash cutting method, no longer used by industry but known to produce well bled carcasses. There was no difference in blood obtained during a 120-s bleeding time between the unstunned and head stunned lambs. For the head-back stunned lambs little, if any, of the blood not collected at bleeding remained in the carcass after dressing despite the fact that these animals released only 46% of the weight of blood recorded from the head stunned lambs during the bleeding time. The head-back stunning method markedly decreased the incidence of carcass blood splash in comparison with the splash observed in lambs stunned by the head application method.     

A comparison of the effects of electrical, captive bolt or percussion stunning on the incidence of blood splash in lambs

Three-hundred-and-three lambs were divided into three equal groups. Half the lambs in each group were not weaned before slaughter and the weaned half were slaughtered a week later. Lambs in one group were head stunned electrically before slaughter; in the second group lambs were stunned with a captive bolt pistol and in the third group they were percussion stunned before slaughter. Carcasses, gall-bladders, hearts and duodenums were inspected for blood splash after slaughter. A few small haemorrhages were detected in 57% of the electrically stunned lambs, in 30% of the captive bolt stunned lambs and in only 16% of the percussion stunned animals. Although no splash of commercial significance was found in any carcass, 25% of the electrically stunned lambs had detectably splashed carcasses, whilst only 1% of percussion-stunned lambs had splashed carcasses with captive bolt stunned lambs being intermediate in carcass splash incidence. These results show that stunning method affects the incidence of blood splash.     

Effect of electrical stunning methods on petechial haemorrhages and on the blood pressure of lambs

Electrical stunning of lambs to render them unconscious and insensible to pain can result in blood splash (spots of blood in muscles) or speckle (petechial haemorrhages in fat or connective tissue overlying the muscle). Stunning through electrodes applied to the head causes mainly blood splash with some speckle, while currents applied head-to-back or head-to-foreleg can produce speckle without blood splash. To identify the causes of speckle, animal movement and blood pressure changes that occur during stunning were measured. Three different stunning methods were employed: head-only, head-to-back and head-to-foreleg. Head-only stunning, which does not stop the heart and produces a moderate amount of speckling, was accompanied by elevated arterial blood pressures up to 300 mm Hg, and venous pressures up to 100 mm Hg. The carcass became rigid on stunning but reflex kicking occurred when the hind legs were shackled. Head-to-back stunning, which stops the heart, produced a momentary arterial and venous blood pressure rise during the stun, as a result of thoracic pressure changes, followed by a decline in pressure to 40-50 mm Hg. The muscles became markedly rigid due to direct stimulation of the loin and spontaneous kicking was absent following current switch off, although spontaneous coughing persisted. Stillness associated with head-to-back stunning was accompanied by the highest incidence and severity of speckling, whereas head-to-foreleg stunning, which also stops the heart, resulted in less muscle contraction and was accompanied by the least incidence and severity of speckling. Kicking was also eliminated if sufficiently high currents were used. Stopping the heart with KCl before a head-to-back stun lowered arterial blood pressure to 20-30 mm Hg and markedly reduced speckle. Abolition of nervously mediated muscle movement with curare before stunning resulted in no observable speckle in head-only stunned lambs but, in the head-to-back stunned lambs, there was a low incidence of speckle in the loin as a result of the muscle being directly stimulated to contract. The results from this study are consistent with the view that speckle is a result of vigorous movements between muscles during stunning, causing a shearing and rupture of blood vessels in the fat and connective tissues, thus allowing the muscles to squeeze out blood. The incidence of speckle does not appear to be related to blood pressure during stunning.     

Effect of electrical stunning on meat and carcass quality in lambs

The effect on meat quality and the presence of haemorrhages were assessed in head-only electrically stunned and non-stunned lambs. Colour (L?, a?, b?), muscle ultimate pH (pHu), chilling losses and carcass weight at 45 min and 24 h were not significantly different between treatments. However, the amount of blood lost relative to live body weight and the killing-out were significantly higher (P<0.05) in electrically stunned lambs compared with non-stunned lambs. No carcasses with petechiae, ecchymosis, haematomas and bone fractures were found in either treatment. On the other hand, the incidence of hearts with petechiae was significantly (P<0.05) higher in electrically stunned lambs compared with lambs slaughtered without prior stunning. It is concluded that meat quality and the incidence of haemorrhages are unaffected by head-only electrical stunning for 3 s at a constant voltage of 250 V.     

Effects of normal, light/normal or double stunning on the incidence and severity of blood splash in lambs

One-hundred-and-twenty lambs were divided into three equal groups which were subjected to head electrical anaesthesia before bleeding. The normal group was stunned and bleeding was initiated within 5 to 8 s. The light/normal group was partially stunned and then treated as the normal group after a delay of 10s. The double stunned group was electrically anaesthetised, allowed to recover and then restunned and bleeding was initiated within 5 to 8 s. The light/normal and double stunning procedures increased the incidence and severity of carcass blood splash compared with normal stunning but the increase was less than that sometimes seen in normal mobs of head-stunned sheep and which occurs for unknown reasons.     

The effect of stunning method on the incidence of PSE meat and haemorrhages in pork carcasses

Two commercial pig abattoirs (A and B) equipped with a head-only and head-to-chest electrical stunning systems, and two (C and D) equipped with compact carbon dioxide (CO(2)) stunning systems, were visited during 3 days to evaluate the effects of the stunning system on meat quality and haemorrhages. Meat quality was evaluated by measuring muscle electrical conductivity (PQM) and colour (Minolta Chromameter) at 2 and 7 h post mortem (abattoirs A and C, and B and D, respectively). PQM and colour were measured in 2486 and 2321 loins respectively. Also ultimate pH (pHu) was measured in 2395 loins at 24 h post mortem. Haemorrhages were evaluated by recording the incidence of petechiae, ecchymosis and haematomas, bone fractures were also recorded. A total of 1980 shoulders, 3943 loins, and 5438 hams were inspected. In the abattoirs equipped with the electrical stunning systems, a higher (P<0.05) incidence of potentially PSE meat (PQM>6) was found compared with the abattoirs equipped with CO(2) stunning. Likewise, the loins from electrically stunned pigs were paler than those from CO(2) stunned pigs (P<0.05). Electrical stunning increased the incidence of petechiae in the loin and the ham (P<0.05). No shoulder, loin or ham with bone fractures was found in the abattoirs studied. Therefore, CO(2) stunning reduces the incidence of PSE meat and of petechiae on muscle fascia of loins and hams, compared with electrical stunning. However, petechiae are not of great importance because they can be removed from the affected commercial cuts.     

Electrical stunning by direct brain stimulation in pigs

The effects of electrical stunning of slaughter pigs by electrodes shot into the brain, on sensibility and on the incidence of haemorrhages in the shoulder postmortem, were studied.

To determine the efficiency of this method 37 slaughter pigs were equipped with EEG (electroencephalograph) and ECG (electrocardiograph) electrodes and stunned twice via the EEG electrodes. In the first experiment the pigs were stunned with 25 V and in the second with 25 V followed by a relaxation current. The day after slaughter the shoulders were scored for haemorrhages. Under more practical conditions three groups of 10 pigs each were electrically stunned via electrodes shot into the brain using 25, 50 or 75 V, followed by a relaxation current. The day after stunning the shoulders were scored for haemorrhages.

The pigs did not react to shooting electrodes frontally into the head. After stunning all animals showed a general epileptiform seizure. However, after the second stun the tonic and clonic muscle cramps were impaired. The heart rate increased significantly (P < 0·01) after stunning, and extra systolae and irregular heart rates were observed. In the shoulders of 27% of the carcasses no haemorrhages were found and in the remainder only minor haemorrhages were seen. Under practical conditions a voltage of 87(± 2) V and a current of 511(±20) mA seemed to be necessary for an effective stun. When lower voltages were applied fewer carcasses with shoulder haemorrhages were found.

It may be concluded from these experiments that 25 V (134 mA; 150 Hz) is sufficient for effective stunning of slaughter pigs when electrodes are in direct contact with the brain. But as the optimum position of the electrodes may not be reached under practical conditions a voltage of approximately 90 V (550 mA; 150 Hz) is recommended. After this stunning method only a few haemorrhages were observed in the shoulders.     

Recent concerns about stunning and slaughter

This review summarises information that is relevant to concerns that have recently been expressed about stunning and slaughter. It is known that captive bolt stunning can result in brain material passing to the lungs via the jugular veins. If future studies show that BSE prions pass beyond the lungs to the edible carcass, there will be a move away from captive bolt stunning in large cattle towards electrical stunning. Greater use of electrical stunning in large cattle will increase the importance of blood splash in the beef industry. The theoretical causes of blood splash are reviewed to improve our understanding of this problem. In some situations it can be due to excessive venous pressure causing rupture of a capillary bed some distance from the source of the pressure rise, but it is not known whether this applies to electrical stunning. Gas stunning is replacing electrical stunning for poultry because it can reduce blood spots, which is a similar condition to blood splash. Several gas stunning methods are now being used, but it is not clear which of these is the most humane. Anoxic stunning leads to carcass convulsions and this causes more carcass damage. In fish, recent developments in electrical stunning are showing promise in overcoming problems with carcass damage. It is recommended that rock lobsters should be chilled or frozen before butchery, to ensure a humane death.     

Comparison of CO(2) stunning with manual electrical stunning (50 Hz) of pigs on carcass and meat quality

The effects of carbon dioxide stunning on carcass and pork quality attributes were compared with the effects of manual electrical stunning using either head-only or head-to-brisket electrodes. A total of 30 Large White×Landrace boars (homozygous dominant for the halothane gene) were randomly allocated immediately prior to slaughter to one of three stunning treatments: carbon dioxide (90% CO(2)), head only (HO; 1.3 A for 4 s at a frequency of 50 Hz) or head to brisket (HBR; 1.3 A for 4 s at a frequency of 50 Hz) electrical stunning. The pH of the M. longissimus thoracis (LT) muscle measured at two sites [between the fifth and sixth thoracic vertebrae (Site 1) and the last thoracic rib (Site 2)] at 40 min post-slaughter was lower (P<0.001) in HBR stunned pigs compared with both CO(2) and HO stunned pigs. No differences in ultimate pH of the LT at either measurement site were found due to stunning method. However, a faster (P<0.05) relative rate of pH decline was found in the LT at Site 1 from HBR stunned pigs compared with CO(2) stunned pigs. No difference in the relative rate of muscle pH decline (P>0.05) between stunning methods was found in the LT muscle at Site 2. Pork from HBR stunned pigs was paler (P<0.05) and had a higher (P<0.001) percentage drip loss compared with pork from HO and CO(2) stunned pigs. LT muscles from HBR stunned pigs had lower (P<0.001) WB shear force values compared with pork from HO stunned pigs (6.57 vs. 8.12 kg, S.E.D. 0.49). Carcass quality was improved by CO(2) stunning, with less (P<0.05) ecchymosis-affected pork trimmed from shoulder primals compared with electrically stunned pigs. These results indicate that manual electrical stunning of pigs using HO tongs and CO(2) stunning reduced percentage drip loss, reduced muscle lightness and reduced the rate of muscle pH decline compared with pigs manually electrically stunned using HBR tongs.     

The effect of different methods of electrical stunning of lambs on blood pressure and muscular activity

The effect on blood pressure and muscular activity of a 'head-only' and a 'head-to-body' method of electrical stunning was measured in groups of lambs. A two- to three-fold increase in arterial pressure followed 'head-only' stunning, along with moderate increases in venous pressure. By contrast, after 'head-to-body' stunning, arterial pressure decreased, but venous pressure increased to above 50 mm Hg. Electromyographic recordings showed there was a greater increase in the intensity of muscular activity following 'head-to-body' stunning compared with 'head-only' stunning and there was a direct correlation between the degree of muscular activity and the increase in venous pressure. It is argued that the resultant pressure changes in the microcirculatory bed are likely to be associated with the occurrence of haemorrhagic defects following stunning by electrical methods.     

Blood in the respiratory tract during slaughter with and without stunning in cattle

Bovine respiratory tracts were examined for blood following shechita without stunning, halal slaughter without stunning, and captive bolt stunning with sticking. In all three methods the cattle were in the upright (standing) position at the start of bleeding. Those that had not been stunned continued to breathe during the early part of bleeding whilst those that were stunned were not breathing. Nineteen percent of the shechita, 58% of the halal and 21% of the stunned plus stuck cattle had blood lining the inner aspect of the trachea. Thirty six percent, 69% and 31% had blood in the upper bronchi, respectively. Ten percent, 19% and 0% had fine bright red blood-tinged foam in the trachea, respectively. It was concluded that concerns about suffering from airway irritation by blood could apply in animals that are either not stunned before slaughter or do not lose consciousness rapidly whilst blood is present in the respiratory tract.     

致昏电压对兔肉品质的影响研究

采用100、75、65、55V和人工致昏(对照组)的宰杀方式,研究其对兔肉品质的影响,结果表明:不同致昏电压对兔肉pH值的影响差异不显著(p>0.05),只有75V致昏组与100V致昏组间宰后1h的背最长肌pH值差异显著(p<0.05);宰后1h,不同致昏电压对兔背最长肌的肉色亮度L*值、红度a*值、黄度b*值和后腿肉的L*值、a*值的影响差异不显著(p>0.05);宰后24h,75V致昏组的肌肉颜色鲜红,而人工致昏组和100V致昏组的肌肉颜色较苍白;100V致昏组的滴水损失最大,为3.738%,而75V致昏组的最小,为2.420%;蒸煮损失最大的为100V致昏组,最小的为55V致昏组,其次是75V组;肌肉嫩度最好的是75V致昏组,最差的是人工致昏组。     

Meat quality in suckling lambs: effect of pre-slaughter handling

Thirty-three suckling lambs of the Manchega breed were used to compare the effects of pre-slaughter handling (PSH) on initial meat quality and at 7 days post-mortem. Lambs were distributed into three groups: electrically stunned (ESL; n=15), stunned using CO(2) (GSL; n=10) and slaughtered without previous stunning (USL; n=8). Meat quality was evaluated by examining pH, colour (L*, a*, b* values), water holding capacity (WHC), cooking loss (CL), shear force (SF) and drip loss (DL). At 24 h post-mortem, the highest pH corresponded to the USL group (P<0.05) whereas the lowest pH decline (pH(0)-pH(24)) corresponded to the GSL group (P<0.05). Differences in pH among groups disappeared after 7 days post-mortem. In general, PSH did not affect values of WHC, CL and colour parameters. After 7 days post-mortem, there were significant differences between groups in DL, this being lowest (P<0.05) in stunned animals. GSL resulted in more tender meat (lower SF value) than ESL and USL (P<0.05). Moreover, there was no blood splash in any of the carcasses of the GSL group.     

The use of a high pressure waterjet combined with electroimmobilization for the stunning of slaughter pigs: Some aspects of meat quality

It is considered that waterjet stunning may be a humane stunning method to apply in slaughter facilities. An experiment was conducted in a slaughterhouse to examine the effects of waterjet stunning combined with electroimmobilization during exsanguination on the occurrence of haemorrhages in the muscles and on meat quality.Slaughter pigs (n = 31) were stunned by waterjet (3900 bar) in a V-type restrainer and immobilized electrically (40 V) during exsanguination. Control animals (n = 39) were stunned automatically and electrically (600 V) using the same restraint device.At 45 min post mortem the pH in the semimembranosus (SM) and longissimus dorsi (LD) muscles was significantly lower (p < 0·01), while rigor mortis and temperature in the SM and LD were significantly higher (p < 0·05 and p < 0·01, respectively) in the carcasses of pigs stunned with the waterjet as compared to control pigs. At 18 h post mortem the ultimate pH of the LD was lower (p < 0·05), while scatter (fibre optic probe) and filter paper test values of the LD were higher (p < 0·01) in carcasses of pigs stunned with the waterjet. Fewer haemorrhages were observed in the shoulders of pigs stunned with the waterjet.The results of this experiment suggest that waterjet stunning, when combined with electroimmobilization, may be a suitable method to stun pigs in a slaughterhouse. However, further studies are required to improve the meat quality.     

Rate of blood loss and timing of exsanguination on prevalence of ecchymosis in fallow deer (Dama dama)

Blood loss associated with four combinations of stunning and exsanguination methods was determined as part of studying prevalence of ecchymosis in slaughtered fallow deer (Dama dama). A fifth treatment simulated incomplete severance of the extended neck after captive bolt stunning. Predicted mean weights of blood collected from the five slaughter treatments, including electrical stunning followed by the thoracic stick method of exsanguination, captive bolt stunning followed by the thoracic stick, captive bolt stunning followed by the gash cut method of exsanguination, electrical stunning followed by the gash cut, and captive bolt stunning followed by incomplete severance of the extended neck, were 1458.7, 1072.7, 684.5, 463.7, and 228.5 g, respectively. The overall effect of exsanguination method was highly significant (p < 0.001) with the thoracic stick resulting in the greatest weight of blood collection in the 10 s period immediately after initiation. The overall effect of stunning method on blood loss was not significant, although there was a significant (p < 0.05) stunning method by exsanguination method interaction. Ecchymosis of varying severity occurred in some carcases from all treatment groups. Using the total loin and round ecchymosis scores, when little or no ecchymosis (grades 0 or 1) was compared with some ecchymosis (?grade 2) by logistic regression, castrated bucks were 9.8 times more likely (p = 0.002) and does 4.2 times more likely (p = 0.06) to have some ecchymosis than entire bucks. The results indicate that ecchymosis can be reduced in fallow deer carcases by thoracic stick exsanguination incorporated less than 10 s after stunning.     

The effect of electrical stunning and slaughter on the electroencephalogram of sheep and calves

To study the application of electroencephalography (EEG) for the assessment of insensibility during stunning and slaughter, recordings were made on sheep that were slaughtered by throat cutting, electrically stunned head-only and allowed to recover, electrically stunned head-only followed by throat cutting or electrically stunned head-to-back. The same experiments were repeated on calves (1–6 weeks old) except some calves were stunned and allowed to recover before final stunning and throat cutting.

After the throat cut, sheep became insensible (i.e. EEG < 10 μV) at 8–22 s but the calf EEG did not fall below 10 μV until 79 s after the cut. With head-only stunning/recovery, high-amplitude EEG waves (electroplectic fit) continued for 47 s (sheep) and 33 s (calves) post stun. A quiescent period followed, which then developed into a period of moderate-amplitude EEG signals, so that, at 50 s post stun, the EEG usually exceeded 50 μV and often had bursts of 150 μV activity. After head-only stunning/throat cutting, the electroplectic fit was shortened (39 s in sheep, 23 s in calves) and the EEG took at least 50 s to fall below 10 μV. With sheep stunned head-to-back, which stops the heart, and thus should cause immediate, permanent insensibility, the EEG took longer to fall below 10 μV (52 s) than after throat cutting. These results suggest that electrical stunning of sheep and calves causes a prolonged increase in the post-stun EEG amplitude. Therefore, during slaughter, stunned animals have larger amplitude EEG signals than unstunned animals, and EEG criteria developed for judging the sensibility of unstunned animals cannot be used for those that are electrically stunned.     

The histology of blood splash in lamb

Ecchymosis (blood splash), can occur in the carcasses of animals that have been stunned electrically or shot with a captive bolt. While blood splash presents no health hazard, it is likely to detract from the acceptable appearance of the meat. Based on light and electron microscopic studies, ecchymosis has been shown to be due to the localised discharge of blood from ruptured blood vessels into the surrounding muscle tissue. A small proportion of muscle fibres in a splashed region were distorted ( 5 %) with irregular zones of high shortening interspersed with zones of lesser shortening. Such ‘supercontracture’ and its associated blood splash was markedly reduced by neuromuscular blocking agents. It is proposed that through supercontracture of some fibres, a severe strain is placed on adjacent blood vessels, occasionally leading to their rupture and hence to haemorrhaging.     

Electrical stimulation during exsanguination: Effects on the prevalence of blood splash and on sensory quality characteristics in veal

Twenty-four veal calves were stunned with a captive bolt. Twelve calves were shackled by the left, the other twelve by the right hindleg. Approximately 1 min after sticking, six carcasses of each of these subgroups were stimulated electrically with equipment relying on a combined high (3000 V, 0·83 pulses s(-1), 1·5 ms duration) and low 35 V, 14 pulsess(-1)) voltage action. The remaining carcasses were left unharmed. At 24 h post-mortem hindquarters were boned to commercial primal cuts. Surrounding connective tissue and cut-up surfaces of primals as well as certain locations vulnerable for blood splash were further dissected. Neither electrical stimulation nor shackling by either of the hindlegs significantly affected the prevalence and severity of blood splash. Post-mortem factors promoting blood splash and possibly related to electrical stimulation and shackling are discussed. At 7 days post-mortem the sensory meat quality was assessed. In general, electrical stimulation did not significantly affect waterbinding and colour characteristics in longissimus (M. longissimus dorsi) and semimembranosus samples. Sarcomere lengths were similar in stimulated and control groups in longissimus but not in semimembranosus muscle. In both muscles shear force values were lower after electrical stimulation. In general, neither longissimus nor semimembranosus samples excised ipsilaterally from the shackled leg side exhibited differences in tenderness and sarcomere length. It is concluded that shackling by one leg or the other does not interfere with the tenderising effect of electrical stimulation.     

Effect of electrical stunning or sticking without stunning on the microstructure of zousoon, a Chinese semi-dry pork product

The microstructure of muscle fibers from pigs killed following electrical stunning was compared to that from pigs killed after tying-resting and sticking. Examination of the muscle fibers demonstrated that electrical stunning resulted in contracture bands that caused tearing and fragmentation of the myofibers/myofibrils. On the other hand, tying-resting and sticking was not accompanied by microstructural fragmentation of the muscle fibers. Results indicate that electrical stunning of hogs causes fragmentation and breakage of the muscle fibers so that the meat is not suitable for production of Zousoon-a semi-dry shredded Chinese pork product and other similar items prepared from prerigor pig muscle. Heating and drying intensify the deteachment of the myofibrils from the muscle fiber bundles, which is caused mainly by electrical stunning or stimulation and improper conditioning following slaughter. The combined effects of electrical stunning and heating-drying appear to be responsible for the fragmentation of the muscle fibers/myofibrils and contribute to the unsuitability of prerigor muscle from electrically stunned pigs for use in the production of Zousoon. Since sticking of pigs without stunning does not meet humane slaughter standards, alternative animal welfare slaughter procedures should be examined from the standpoint of their usefulness in producing Zousoon.     

Jugular blood flow in calves after head-only electrical stunning and throat-cutting

Jugular flow was measured after head-only electrical stunning and gash cutting in 12 calves less than a week old. Jugular flow was assumed to provide a crude measure of cerebral perfusion during exsanguination. In 10 animals the average amount of jugular blood collected within 1-2 min of throat-cutting was the equivalent of a total cerebral blood flow of 3·6 ml/min/100 g ± 1·4 SD or 4·8% of normal. In two animals the jugular flow was increased to 39% and 22% of normal cerebral flow. All animals had strong retrograde flow from the head ends of the cut carotid arteries. The dynamics of cerebral blood perfusion are discussed with reference to systemic arterial blood pressure and spontaneous cortical electrical activity, and some potentially fruitful areas of research on the humaneness of halal slaughter of cattle are proposed.